September 30, 2026 · Finance Committee · 8,556 words · 11 speakers · 90 segments
The House Finance Committee will come to order. Will the clerk please call the roll? Chair Stewart? Here. Vice Chair DeVilla? Here. Ranking Member Sweeney? Here. Representatives Abdullahi? Here. Rep. Abrams? Here. Baker? Here. Byrd? Here. Rep. Calendar is excused. Glassburn? Here. Grimm? Here. Hall? Here. Hoops? Here. Jerrolds, John, here. Johnson, here. Manning, Piclantonio, here. Plummer, here. Ritter, here. Robinson, present. Gromer, here. Santucci, here. Schmidt, here. Sims, here. Thomas, here. Troy, White, here. Williams? Here. Willis? Here. And Young? Here. We have a quorum present, so we'll proceed as a full committee. The first order of business is to approve the minutes from the previous committee meeting. Without objection, the minutes will be approved. Hearing no objection, the minutes are approved and are a part of the record. I want to thank everybody for making time to come back, and a little unexpectedly, here at the end of September. So appreciate all the members for being here and being prompt. A bit of housekeeping, as we always try to do. House Bill 1019 has not yet formally been referred to the committee, and so we are hearing the bill informally. And with that in mind, before we get started, happy to recognize Ranking Member Sweeney for a comment.
Thank you, Chair, and good morning to the committee members and everyone watching the Ohio Chamber in the audience. and I appreciate the chair allowing me to make some comments because I felt it was important and my caucus felt it was important to acknowledge what it means with the decision of purposely having an informal hearing. An informal hearing means that the actual bill that we all know is going to be attempted to be voted on later means that the bill before us will actually not be the bill. It will also, in the House, we will have no ability to hear from the public and hear concerns about how this bill could be better or maybe possible concerns with how it's currently constructed as what happened yesterday. Additionally, and I do appreciate the chair sharing that, the bill that is likely to be voted on later today is likely to change because of some of the issues that the public brought up. And so by that nature, by definition of the bill that we'll be hearing today, is not actually the most up-to-date. And most notably, what this does is ensure that not one member of the House of Representatives will have any ability to amend, make any changements, to meet any more improvements to meet the crisis of affordability in this state. And oftentimes, if anyone's watched committee, it is a normal process for people to offer amendments. Most of the time they get tabled, and that's the reality of having two parties. We have two different views on how to do things. but this is different than that typical notion. What we're doing this year is barring anyone from having the ability to even offer. And I would suggest that the reason that is the reality of what we're facing today is because the amendments that Democrats want to offer are popular. They're not just what our caucus wants. It's what the majority of people want, and many of these ideas are supported by people on both sides of the aisle. And so as we are about to go into testimony, our call is to continue to urge the public and for the House to do its duty to have input on a bill that is going to spend $726 million of your taxpayer dollars in an attempt to get it back to you. And so we urge the continuation of having more thorough discussion for amendments that meet the relief of finding ways to make this gas tax holiday more effective, but also meeting the other needs that are left unaddressed and purposely left so that we have no ability to structurally make those moments. And with that, I appreciate the chair for giving me that time to make that and hope that we can have a thorough discussion, not just about how we can make this bill better, but how we can do better and do more for the people of Ohio.
I thank you, Ranking Member Sweeney. Just a brief reply. We've had a substantial amount of discussion and testimony yesterday in the Senate. The effort we're talking about today has been drafted in conjunction with our friends in the other chamber, and so the product that we are likely to vote on today has been vetted in that chamber as well. I would also say I received three amendments relating to this bill, and at the risk of disappointing anybody, they all would have been ruled not germane remotely to the bill. There's an amendment about data centers, an amendment about the war in Iran, and an amendment about the Cleveland Browns. None of those have anything to do with a gas tax suspension for the benefit of Ohioans. So at the risk of denying some folks some theater today, we're ready to talk about the bill. So I now call up House Bill 1019 for its first hearing. I call up Representatives Andrea White and Jim Thomas to provide sponsor testimony. Welcome, representatives. You are free to proceed whenever you'd like.
No. Good morning, everybody. Chair Stewart, Vice Chair Davila, Ranking Member Sweeney, and members of the House Finance Committee, I want to thank you all for coming back today to work fervently on House Bill 1019, a bill that, if you're anything like me, have been hearing from your constituents all summer about, please, how do you spell relief, and please do it now. So basically what we are here today to talk about is a bill that will give immediate relief for Ohioans through a temporary 90-day suspension of Ohio's motor vehicle gas and diesel fuel taxes. while at the same time ensuring, let's be clear about that, ensuring that our local and our state road funds will not be impacted because we're taking $725 million in surplus and putting it back into the hands of Ohioans through putting this in the gas tax fund, Ohio Highway Fund, and then letting Ohioans see that relief at the pump. So the complex ways, Jim's going to tell you all the detail. He's the attorney. But when representatives Ty Matthews and Adam Bird first brought up this idea, and I want to give them full due credit, because this idea has come up from both parties last week, Amy Acton, Vivek Ramaswamy. But Ty Matthews and Adam Bird both introduced this bill in May. And I signed on immediately because not that I thought the bill was perfect and that we needed to make sure the roads weren't affected, but I wanted us to begin the conversation and that's why I signed on. But I will tell you, now that we have fiscal year 26 firmly in the rearview mirror and new projections are coming out for fiscal year 27 and we have money in the surplus, money in the general fund, it's time to take action. As I've been walking in my district this summer, in the neighborhoods meeting with people, knocking on literally thousands of doors, I ask people, what is it that I can do for you as your state representative? What are the issues you care about? And the most consistent answer I get is, can you help me lower my food and gas prices? And I will tell you, I had several people tell me this yesterday. It's happening, it's frequent, and we're all hearing it. And I tell them something like, I wish we had more control at the state level. You know, there's a lot we can't control, like the price of oil, which is impacted not only by supply and demand, but also about decisions and geopolitical factors here and around the world. But I tell them what we can do as legislators is something that I've been pushing with my colleagues for, and that is to temporarily suspend Ohio's gas and diesel taxes so Ohioans can have relief. The response has been overwhelming. A year ago today, the price of gas averaged $2.87 a gallon. Yesterday, it was $4.32, down from a week ago, the last time I filled up. Last year, diesel was $3.67 a gallon. Yesterday, it was $6.73. And I will tell you, the price of diesel kind of pushed the tipping point for us to do something, because we all know gas has been expensive. We keep waiting and hoping it's going down. But not only gas, but diesel fuels the prices of every single thing we consume. The pain is real, and that's why we need to act now on what we can control, which is our state taxes, and move today to temporarily suspend the state's 38.5 cent per gallon gas tax, 47 cent per gallon diesel tax for 90 days, and to do so with an emergency clause so Ohioans will feel that immediate relief. Cents on the dollar add up as drivers and truckers fill up. And cumulatively, Ohioans are going to experience $725 million in tax relief over the next 90 days. House Bill 1019 accomplishes three things. Brings immediate relief for Ohioans now at a time of sustained high prices by returning their tax dollars to them at the pump. It uses surplus, higher-than-expected revenue to cover the costs so our local and state roads are maintained and none of that work is interrupted, and it provides clear transparency and accountability to ensure that consumers are the ones putting the tax break in their pockets. As I mentioned, the rise in fuel price impacts not only consumers at the pump, but affects every single industry that's fueled by diesel. Our farmers, our schools, our trucking logistics industries, our airline sectors, our manufacturers, and our businesses. Increased diesel shows up in the price of groceries, building materials, your Amazon delivery prices, and virtually every aspect of the supply chain. So acting now is going to bring a ripple effect down the road on future pricing. It's a win for all Ohioans. It's an initiative in line with some of the broader things we've been working on the last two years, which is cutting the state income tax to a flat rate, bringing over $4 billion in property tax relief over the next three years, including $350 million that people on the homestead exemption will see in their tax bills as a credit in January, and expanding access to things like publicly funded child care and preschool and renewing the state sales tax holiday. I'm going to turn it over right now to Representative Thomas to give you the finer points of this bill. Thank you.
Thank you, Representative White, and good morning. As Rep. White indicated, House Bill 1019 creates a 90-day tax state holiday on gasoline, 38.5 cents per gallon for gas, 47 cents per gallon as the tax on diesel. The bill includes an emergency clause to ensure the relief can be provided as soon as possible. The 90-day period referred to as the temporary reduction period begins at 12.01 a.m. on the third day following the effective date of the bill and ends at 11.59 p.m. on the 93rd day after the effective date. The very slight delay before implementation will allow suppliers and retailers to update their systems to reflect the tax suspension. we recognize that motor fuel tax is paid before the fuel actually reaches the retailer the retailer being the gas stations and that fuel will have already been purchased by the retailers before this reduction period begins and that will be purchased at the higher cost hb 1019 thus includes a mechanism that will help ensure prices at our retail establishments reflect the state gas tax suspension promptly. Retailers will immediately apply to the tax department for an inventory credit based on the amount and value of that gas they purchased. They will notify the department of how many gallons of each fuel they are in possession of at that time for which the standard tax rates have already been collected. The tax department will then send a payment equal to those taxes paid on those gallons. This will occur on or before February 1, 2027. This process will then reverse itself at the end of the reduction period. The retailer will notify the tax department of how many gallons they possess for which the reduced rate was applied and then remit an amount equal to those gallons multiplied by the difference between the standard rate and the holiday rate Revenues from this tax will be deposited into the Highway Operating Fund. This bill includes several measures to prevent price gouging and ensure Ohioans receive the full benefit of this suspension for the next 90 days. The bill requires retailers to provide the full benefit of the tax suspension on to customers during the reduction period. It also equips the tax commissioner and our Attorney General with appropriate tools to ensure compliance and accountability. Violations of these protections would be considered an infringement on the state's existing Consumer Sales Practice Act and may be pursued by the Attorney General. Finally, HB 1019 ensures an uninterrupted, consistent flow of dollars into the Highway Operating Fund. This bill appropriates $725 million in GRF to supplement the foregone motor fuel revenues that will not be conveyed to the state during this period. The GRF will be distributed per statutory requirements in the same manner as motor fuel revenue. This includes the distributions which have already been mentioned to the Department of Transportation and also to our local governments. The bill fully maintains the same distribution and recipients for highway operating funds for both state and local entities. The only distinction is that a portion of the funds will now have originated from the GRF rather than from the motor fuel tax receipts. All existing discounts and processes will continue without interruption through provision of these GRF dollars. The bill does not make any additional appropriations from other funds nor does it divert existing GRF that was previously appropriated for another dedicated purpose. In summary, this bill will provide much-needed relief to Ohioans for motor fuel purchases, ensures that funds for roadway maintenance and construction across the state remain unaffected, and creates accountability and transparency mechanisms to ensure that consumers receive the savings. Chair Stewart, Vice Chair Davila, members of the committee, thank you for your time. And Representative White and I are happy to answer any questions.
Thank you, Representative, for your testimony. First question will come from Vice Chair Davila.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you both for coming in today. So a question that has come from some of my constituents and one that occurs to me as well, and Representative Thomas referred to this to some extent, but I'd like maybe some additional commentary on it. how can we be sure that this will actually be enforced at the local level by retailers? And part of the reason I ask that is we've been through a process here recently with some degree of frustration on enforcement of Medicaid and the types of things that we put in place to try to get fraud, waste, and abuse under control. We've done our part as a legislature. We are going to do our part as a legislature today on this matter as well. How can we be sure that on the executive branch side, whether it's through the Attorney General or other elements, that this law will actually be enforced so that consumers at the local level see the type of relief that this bill is designed to provide.
Vice Chair Davila, thank you for the question. I think we have two approaches here. I think we have the carrot and the stick. We have the market forces. When the retailers get the credits, and they're required by this law to bring the price down. The market forces are, as we all know, if there's one gas station that has a lower price compared to a gas station on the joining property perhaps that has a higher price, people go to the lower gas station. And then when you sell more, then you make more profit. So that is the carrot. And the stick is the aforementioned, what we've added, allowing the Attorney General to pursue violations as infringements of the Consumer Sales Practice Act, as well as the tax commissioner may consider violations in all licensing determinations. So we feel that's the stick, and we feel like the retailers are going to comply. Great. Thank you.
Follow-up?
I did want to add, if it's okay, Chair Stewart and Vice Chair Davila. So, you know, certainly yesterday the testimony by interested parties and others was helpful to show how rapidly the gas prices change, sometimes within a day, several times. But the mechanisms for looking at the inventory before and looking at the inventory after this takes place and the reporting structures, which I think there's been good input from the interested parties and we'll see the final product. but I think there's good mechanisms in place to help show what's being bought, prices paid, and things like that that will help us see clarity. And I do believe this has been an industry that has stood by Ohioans for decades, if not hundreds of years. We can count on reliability and trustworthiness, but we also have the trust but verify.
This page shows part of the transcript. The full transcript is available on request.