Skip to main content
Committee HearingAssembly

11-9-26 Assembly Public Hearing on Automatic License Plate Reader Systems - Nov 09, 2026

November 9, 2026 · Assembly Public Hearing on Automatic License Plate Reader Systems · 31,526 words · 14 speakers · 341 segments

Chair Neely Rosickchair

Thank you for joining us. I'm Assemblymember Neely Rosick. I chair the Consumer Protection Committee in the State Assembly. There you go. Now it finally works. So I would like to thank today's co-chairs of the public hearing, Assemblymember John McDonald, the chair of the Assembly Committee on Governmental Operations, and McGee Solage, the chair of the Assembly's Committee on Local Governments. we're examining an important topic this morning I'd also like to thank the members who are attending today's hearing I know more will join us along the way and in no particular order Patrick Carroll, Amarita Torres, Dana Levinberg Steve Raga Tommy Chavoni, Jonathan Jacobson and I'll have my ranker do the Republicans if possible Thank you to my committee staff, Sky Matthews and Allie Dewar, and thank you to all of the witnesses who will be joining us today to present testimony. We also have testimony that was submitted from various sources, including FLOC, DFLOC, Motorola Solutions, Chamber of Progress, NCMEC, NISAC, and Reinvent Albany, among others. All of today's testimonies by today's witnesses and those submitted will be posted on the assembly webpage at a later time. That's what I've always done as chair of the Consumer Protection Committee in an effort to be transparent about everyone's testimony. So over the past several years, we've seen a significant expansion of the use of ALPRs, Automatic License Plate Reader Systems. These systems use cameras and software to capture and record license plate information from passing vehicles, often logging the date, time, and location of each scan. They are increasingly utilized by law enforcement agencies, local governments, and private businesses for a range of public safety, commercial, and operational purposes. There are legitimate benefits to this technology. ALPRs can help law enforcement locate stolen vehicles, assist in investigations, and find missing persons. Businesses and municipalities, we know, use these systems for security and operational purposes. But as the technology becomes more widespread, we also need to take a closer look at how it operates, what information is being collected, who has access to it, how long it is retained, and with whom it is shared. And to be clear to my dear colleagues, today's hearing is focused on ALPRs, not on traffic safety enforcement cameras, such as red light cameras or speed cameras. I know those also have their issues, but those offer a different and specific purpose of making our streets safer and only activate when the violation occurs and not to necessarily identify cars or vehicles. So the systems that we're discussing today can collect information about virtually every vehicle that passes a camera, and that means the movement of ordinary New Yorkers, people commuting to work, dropping their children off at school, visiting a doctor, attending religious services, or simply going about their daily lives may be recorded and stored. So that raises fundamental questions about consumer privacy, data security, individual rights, and the appropriate limits on the use of this technology. So the question before us today is not simply whether ALPR technology works or whether it can improve public safety although I sure that be part of the discussion It is whether the safeguards governing its use have kept pace with the technology itself And in New York, we currently lack universal minimum standards governing the collection, retention, and use sharing of information through these systems. And what is clear is that we probably should have one. We probably should not leave the protection of New Yorkers' information entirely to the discretion of individual agencies or private companies. And so that's what I'm concerned about as the chair of consumer protection. I'm interested in understanding the consumer implications of the technology and the responsibilities of the companies that provide it. We need transparency about how vendors collect and store information, their data sharing practices, their contractual obligations, and basically who can access that information that they maintain. We have lots of legislative bills in front of this committee, including one sponsored by myself, a 8779 that restricts the use of ALPR information when it comes to reproductive health. especially as it is used to cross jurisdictional lines. There are other bills. I know Assemblymember Pollan has a bill, A563, and Assemblymember Hunter has a bill, A10808A. To be clear, today's hearing is not about a particular bill or piece of legislation, although witnesses feel free to opine on any of them, but rather on the important questions raised by these bills. So each of them deserves careful consideration. That's what we're trying to do here. Today's hearing gives us an opportunity to consider this broad spectrum of bills. And with that, I will turn it over to today's co-chair, Assemblymember McDonald.

Assemblymember, Chair of Assembly Committee on Governmental Operations John McDonaldassemblymember

Thank you, Chair Rosick, and thanks to all who are participating today, whether in person or through live stream. and also thanks to all who have submitted their written testimony. ALPRs have been around for a period of time, but as the chair indicated, its growth has been explosive over the past several years. And it's an interesting topic. From my perspective, obviously, they do play an important role in public safety. And at the same token, I've heard from many individuals their concerns about their privacy. And by the way, this issue is bipartisan. Actually, I would probably go to say it's nonpartisan. This is something where we need to look at, and I will be the first to tip in the city of Troy, which I represent. This past year, the Troy City Council took the lead on trying to address this issue. And I have to admit, as one who works and listened to the council and their concerns, I myself learned an awful lot in the process. they've arrived at a conclusion of what they're going to do locally, which is something that should be shared at the appropriate time with many other municipalities. And that's why we're having this hearing, to hear what works, to really dive in deeper, to really understand the concerns. Obviously, concerns about retention of data, access to that data, and how that data, if it's going to be shared, who it's shared with, is important. And admittedly there are communities already who made their point that they just don want to have anything to do with that Listen as a former mayor I respect local home rule control But at the same token, I think we all benefit by having a more rotund discussion. So with that, I turn it back to our chair. Thank you.

Assemblymember, Chair of Assembly Committee on Local Governments McGee Solageassemblymember

Good morning, everyone. Thank you to my colleagues for being here and also thank the co-chairs for helping us facilitate this wonderful hearing. I appreciate that. So today we're going to be looking at technology that most New Yorkers drive past every day without noticing, the automatic license plate reader. And these cameras sit on poles, overpasses, and patrol cars. They record every license plate that passes along with the time, location, and often the make and model of the car. So let's be clear. This hearing is not whether law enforcement should have modern tools. ALPRs have helped find stolen cars, locate missing children, and solve serious crimes. And we'll hear all about that today, and we should. But New Yorkers still have, we, New York, still have no law that governs how these systems are used. How long the data is kept, how someone could search, why they could search, or what they share that information to. And increasingly, we see information being shared to private vendors. We have to give clarity to local governments on how to operate. And when there's no rules, we see problems. In one New York county, there was an audit of more than 4,000 authorized searches by a single investigator. Researchers have also documented that New York police were searching plate readers on behalf of federal immigration agents after our state made it clear that local cops should not do the work of ICE. officers across this country have used these systems to track former partners and create havoc in their lives New Yorkers deserve both safety and privacy and we could do that we could do both that means clear lines on how to use the technology sensible retention periods real audits and accountability when the rules are broken I look forward to hearing from law enforcement prosecutors the Attorney General's Office, advocates, community members on this insight, and I look forward to having a robust conversation. I thank again all my colleagues.

Chair Neely Rosickchair

There we go. I'll turn it over to Member Durso, who is serving as ranker for today's hearing.

Michael Dursoother

Thank you, Assemblymember Rosick. Again, Assemblymember Michael Durso. So I'm joined here today by Assemblyman Matt Simpson, Assemblyman Brian Miller, Assemblyman Daniel Norber, Assemblyman AJ, why am I blanking, AJ? VPAN, I don't know what happened there. And Ari Brown from the Consumer Affairs Committee's Government Operations and Local Governments Committees. Looking forward to the testimony of everybody who's come here today and looking forward to seeing what the concerns are from each and every individual group and if the positives outweigh the negatives of such technology. So we look forward to hearing from everybody today. Thank you.

Chair Neely Rosickchair

Thank you. Member Beepin.

Assemblymember AJ Bepanassemblymember

Thank you, Chair Rosick. As Mr. Dersa said, my name is Assemblyman AJ. Okay. It's good to be here with all of you. This has definitely been a nonpartisan topic, as Chair McDonald said. I heard from folks from both sides of the aisle that share their concerns about the technology but also our law enforcement partners that have done great work with this technology as well So I joined here by Assemblymembers Norbert and Simpson from the Government Operations Committee, and we look forward to diving deeper, and I want to thank the panelists that are here for your insight and expertise. Thank you.

Chair Neely Rosickchair

Assemblymember Brown.

Ari Brownother

Thank you. I'm joined. I'm the ranker on local governments. I'm joined today by my member, AJ Bepan, I remembered your name this time, and Assemblymember Matt Simpson from the local governments committee. Let me make something very clear. I strongly support law enforcement. Our police officers have an extraordinarily difficult job, and I believe we should give them the tools they need to protect our communities and certainly catch criminals. However, there's a fundamental difference between using technology to investigate criminal activity and using technology to monitor the movements of millions of law-abiding citizens. Automated license plate readers, or ALPRs, you know, they raise some very serious constitutional questions. Who has access to this information? How long is it stored? Who determines what constitutes a legitimate search? What prevents someone from using this technology for personal, political, or otherwise improper purposes? I want our police officers catching criminals, not our government creating a permanent record of the movement of innocent citizens. We can support law enforcement and defend our constitutional freedoms. At the same time, in fact, we have an obligation to do both. That's why we're here today, and I look forward to hearing from all of our panelists. Thank you.

Chair Neely Rosickchair

Thank you so much, our fellow colleagues. Okay, so our first panel is Tyler Nims from the AG's office. Tyler, before you begin, let me just clarify for everyone. Each panelist, each witness will get five minutes to testify, and then each chair will get five minutes of questions. Members, please tell your respective chairs if you have questions. You will each get three minutes to ask questions. If there is a need to pause proceedings for any reason, one of the chairs will announce that. Also, feel free not to take all of your minutes. All right, with that, Tyler Nims from the Chief of the Law Enforcement Misconduct Investigative Office of the New York State Attorney General's Office.

This page shows part of the transcript. The full transcript is available on request.

Source: 11-9-26 Assembly Public Hearing on Automatic License Plate Reader Systems - Nov 09, 2026 · November 9, 2026 · Gavelin.ai