Skip to main content
Committee HearingAssembly

Assembly Judiciary Committee

June 23, 2026 · Judiciary · 30,834 words · 12 speakers · 93 segments

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Welcome to Assembly Judiciary Committee. In order for us to complete our agenda, allow everyone equal time, the rule for witness testimony, each side will be allowed two main witnesses each. Witnesses will have approximately two minutes to testify in support of or opposition to the bill. Additional witnesses should state only their names, organization, if any, and their position on the bill. We don't have quorum, but we will proceed as a subcommittee. Senator Umberg, whenever you're ready.

Senator Tom Umbergsenator

Well, thank you, Mr. Chair and member. I have a very simple bill before today, SB 46. I appreciate the help of Mr. Lideke in making sure that this bill is up to snuff. Senate Bill 46 amends the California Elections Code to ensure that the California Secretary of State has the legal authority to remove constitutionally ineligible candidates for president and vice president from California's primary and general election ballot. What it does in sum is make sure that somebody who's already served two terms as president of the United States may not appear on the California ballot if that same person wishes to serve a third term. That's it, Mr. Chair. Urge in our vote.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 46? Is there anyone here? Oh, all right. Well, a very dramatic, very, very dramatic approach.

Terry Brennanwitness

At least I didn't fall. Mr. Chairman, members, Terry Brennan on behalf of SEIU California, representing over 750,000 California voters who support protecting the Constitution and democracy. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 46 All right I bring it back to committee Any questions or comments

Senator John Lairdsenator

If this is in the Constitution, the Seventh Amendment or 20, why is this necessary?

Senator Tom Umbergsenator

That's a great question. And most of us who had fifth grade civics understand the import of that question. But there's at least one person in the United States, supported by others who believe that he can serve a third term. And so when the president says, I may seek a third term, and those around him encourage him to do so, I actually believe him. So thus the need for the bill.

Senator John Lairdsenator

And I don't believe him. Anyway, Senator, I respect what you're doing, but I don't think I can support it. But anyway, thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Well, thank you, Senator Murray. Yeah, and whether we believe him or not, I think this is another example of a piece of legislation that we wish we wouldn't have to do, but these are unusual times, and I think we're doing things that are out of the ordinary for that reason. And so I appreciate you for bringing this forward. Would you like to close?

Senator Tom Umbergsenator

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Leike, for your assistance and urge an I vote.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. We'll take that up when we get a chance. and hopefully we'll get more senators in here. Thank you. Thank you. Item six, SB 1078. See what happens when you get here at a relatively early time?

Senator John Lairdsenator

Yeah, that's right.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Making up for last week. Senator Laird, SB 1078, whenever you're ready.

Senator John Lairdsenator

Oh, yeah, hold on. There we go. Yeah, there we are. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I'm in three simultaneous Senate hearings, so I couldn't believe I was getting yanked out of one already. Senate Bill 1078 requires a copy of a court filing to be sent to the Director of Civil Rights Department. If the matter involves a violation of civil rights laws that fall under the Civil Rights Department, this ensures that the director of that department, the institutional centerpiece of California's broad anti-discrimination and hate policy is made aware of any alleged violation of any civil rights in the cases that may affect interpretation or enforcement of the state laws, the Civil Rights Department's, the state's primary civil rights enforcement agency. However, current law only requires this notice to be sent to the Attorney General. The bill has no registered opposition. I ask for an aye vote.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone here in support of SB 1078? Anyone here in opposition to SB 1078? We'll bring it back to our committee member. Any questions, comments? Okay. As you can see, we do not have quorum, so we can't take it up for a vote yet. But thank you for bringing this vote forward. Would you like to close?

Senator John Lairdsenator

At the appropriate time, I respectfully ask for an iPhone.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Thank you, sir. Thank you. All right. All right.

Senator John Lairdsenator

Senator are you ready for your Yeah I need my note Okay

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Okay. All right. So we have item four, SB 989, Senator Blakespear, whenever you're ready.

Senator Catherine Blakespearsenator

Okay, excellent. Thank you. I'm happy to be able to jump to the front of the queue.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you for calling.

Senator Catherine Blakespearsenator

That's what I tell folks.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

You get here early, you never know.

Senator Catherine Blakespearsenator

That's right.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Early bird gets the one.

Senator Catherine Blakespearsenator

I'm pleased to author SB 989, which is sponsored by the California Professional Firefighters. This bill would expand access to CareCourt and help more Californians with schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders receive the care they need. CareCourt was created to provide a structured, coordinated pathway to treatment for individuals with severe mental illness who are too often cycling through emergency rooms, jail, and repeated law enforcement encounters. While early implementation shows promise, barriers in the current petition process are preventing the program from reaching many of the individuals it was designed to serve. Through June 30, 2024, there were 557 petitions filed to care courts statewide. Of those, 217 were dismissed, and only 100 individuals, just 18 percent, ultimately developed treatment and housing plans. That's a very small number, 18 percent.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Today, first responders are often the first point of conduct for individuals in crisis, but under current law, they must navigate a complex court filing process, obtain sensitive medical records, and appear in court to initiate a care petition. As a result, many individuals who would benefit from care court are never connected to the program. SB 989 creates a more practical and effective pathway by allowing first responders to request that county behavioral health agencies review and file care petitions on their behalf. Counties are required to assess these requests within 30 business days and determine whether to file a petition when eligibility criteria are met or are likely to be met. Finally, the bill directs the Department of Health Care Services to develop a standardized referral form to provide guidance to first responders and to establish data reporting requirements to improve transparency and program performance. This approach reduces administrative barriers, better aligns responsibilities with expertise, and ensures that individuals in crisis are connected to care and not lost in the system. SB 989 builds on the promise of care court by making it more accessible, more accountable, and more effective. With me today in support to testify, I have Megan Subers on behalf of the California Professional Firefighters Association. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair and member Megan Subers on behalf of the California Professional Firefighters and pleased to be the sponsor of SB 989. CPF and our local affiliates have been leading and evolving the local response framework to improve patient care and outcomes for individuals who are experiencing mental health crisis. We've worked with this legislature to expand programs like community paramedicine and mobile mental health units, and our members are committed to this work. What I hear again and again is that they are too often running 911 calls on individuals who they know may not get the deeper level of treatment that they need, and they will likely have to respond to that individual again soon. We see care as another tool for firefighters and and first responders who have had repeated interactions with someone to try to connect them to the services that they need through this process if they are eligible. I've been fortunate enough to sit on the Care Act Advisory Working Group at HHS with one of my local presidents from the city of San Jose And through that work we learned a lot about implementation across the state We have good examples of cities and counties working with their fire departments in Alameda City Alameda County San Diego, integrating them into Care Act implementation. But we have other examples across the state where there is a little bit of a disconnect. The process of filing a petition as the first responder can be complicated. There is in-depth medical history information that's required as part of the petition. So what is proposed under this bill, we think is an additional tool to give the first responder an option to collect what information they do have about that individual, the repeated interactions that they've had, and give that information to the county so that the county can follow up and do the investigation and determine if that individual is eligible. We know there are concerns from organizations and individuals about the underlying process of care, and we respect and understand those concerns. I think we view this bill as not an expansion of anyone who can already do a petition or an expansion of who would be eligible. But if what was working prior to care was actually working, we wouldn't be in a situation where we're trying to, you know, make sure that care is a helpful tool. So for those reasons, we ask for your support today. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 989? Good morning. June Dudas, San Diego family member and representing the California chapter of the National Shattering Silence Coalition. My cousin's no-fault brain disease was obvious to everyone who encounters him, but getting him into treatment remained incredibly difficult. He suffered unnecessary neurological damage as he cycled through homelessness and prison. Please give first responders a simpler path to connect people with care court and an earlier path to treatment. Thank you. Thank you. We'll treat that as our second witness. Good morning, Chair and members. Moira Topp on behalf of San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria in support. Thank you. Is there anyone else? Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 989? . Chair and member Samuel Jan with Disability Rights California. We are here in opposition to SB 989. We are sympathetic to first responders about wanting to help people they see on the streets over and over again. We're also sympathetic to family members who have and have lost loved ones struggling with severe mental illness. This bill would create a streamlined referral process for CARE Court. CARE Court is already law, but we don't believe that deepening our investment in this program is the solution. We know what services work. We have decades of research showing that people need stable housing and low-barrier intensive services in the community. As California's designated protection and advocacy system, our organization litigates against county behavioral health departments across the state. We've had to prove in court what's wrong with the system and negotiate with counties to reprioritize services due to the imbalance between the extreme need and available resources. What wrong is people in crisis are being placed on three wait lists because we don have enough outpatient care People are being discharged from psychiatric hospitals onto the streets because we don have enough housing Last year this committee found that CareCourt costs $713,000 per participant per year, and that just pays for a court process. CareCourt doesn't pay for services. How many outpatient visits would that cover? We could buy participants a new house, probably a condo, a box from the beach, every year. People don't need court-ordered services with the threat of conservatorship if they don't comply. They just need reasonable access to timely services, which many aren't getting. This bill deepens our investment into a program that's rotten at its core and pulling money from the services that do work. We ask for your opposition. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in opposition to SB 989? Danny Therickel, on behalf of Mental Health America of California in opposition. Thank you. Apologies. I'm actually in late support. Leah Barrows on behalf of California Hospital Association. Thank you. Thank you. All right. We'll bring it back to our committee member. Yes, please. Thank you, Senator, for another. Another good bill that you're trying to, to the gentleman's comments, the care court is what, only two or three years old and it's still working through its growing pains and figuring out ways to meet the needs of those who best need it. I think this is a good bill. I support it. I'd like to co-author it with you because it's going to take one step at a time. I don't think it conflicts with the witnesses' organizations. They're doing their good work on the streets and helping people. I think if we come at this in our communities to help people through the court system, through the services that your organizations provide, it's mainly to help people and get them into protected housing. And if their situation on the street involves activity that needs to enter the court system, there needs to be a pathway into the court system. If not, that's where your organizations do good work. So I don't know. And hearing these other bills we've talked about last week, they're not mutually exclusive. Everybody has a role to play. And once this patient individual becomes part of the criminal justice system, let's find the best way to help them. And I think this information from from the fire first responders, I think that's useful. I didn't realize that I wouldn't have thought about it, but that could be an important component to making those decisions in court. So thank you. I support it. I will co-author it whenever we do that. Thank you. Thank you, Senator, for bringing this forward as famously or infamously being a care court skeptic. You know, I don't want that to be mistaken for wanting it to fail. I do have the general concerns, as was raised by opposition. But that being said, on this particular bill, I do believe that firefighters in particular are very well situated to make determinations because they are sometimes responding to the same individual 5, 6, 7, 10, 12 times for medical calls that oftentimes are mental health related. And I trust their judgment. I have a little bit more concern with law enforcement in the category of first responders. because of different incentives as to why you may want someone off the street, as well as the trauma that law enforcement might cause with some individuals that are on the street versus firefighters. That being said, I think helping to facilitate some process for first responders to better at least get their referral over to the county is something that I think that we can say. Well, again, you mentioned collecting data. We'll see what the fruits of that are once or if they're given that opportunity to have a more streamlined approach. Again, the caution is simply the burden on the county to have to kind of have folks, to some extent, jump the line or at least have more care of court referrals to process more quickly. And so I'm sure we'll hear from our counties as to the cost burdens of that. Appropriations can deal with that in terms of those issues. But as Summer Dixon said, this is still a work in progress. And I think there's still a lot to be learned about how we can better facilitate care courts in a way that actually get people the help they need. If we don't have a quorum, we can't take a vote. But would you like to close? Yes, thank you. I appreciate the comments from both of the Assembly members who are here. And thank you to the chair for your deep thought and work on care court and these issues. I want to take a little bit of exception to the suggestion that CARE Court is rotten at its core, because I do think that one of the things that the opposition who's here today, and in general, the opposition to CARE Court, is concerned about the mental health services being provided through jails, basically through a criminal justice approach, is really what we're trying to get away from. And having taken the time to go and actually witness multiple hours of care court and operation, what I saw was that there's very much a group therapy aspect to what care court is doing. So there are many people who are helping one person who has a lot of needs. And the reality is that the responsibility for people with severe mental health problems really does devolve to the counties. And we hear this from so many family members who come and speak here at committee, but also talk to me directly about the fact that they are begging for more help for their family members and trying to find a system that allows for an entrance point so that the counties can actually be helping the people who are most severely in need of help. You know, counties have a lot of responsibilities, but I would argue that this is the tip of the spear in terms of the priorities that counties should be focusing on. And what we see is that there are a lot of different programs that are funded. And are they the ones that deal with the most severe people who need the most help, who family members are begging for help? And our first responders are seeing the same person dozens and dozens of times. And I think the worst thing is when the fire department comes to try to help somebody having a mental health crisis. And when that doesn't work out. It's a dead end. There's no future place for that person to go. Then they end up with a law enforcement violation. And the next thing you know, it's the sheriff. And the next thing you know, they're arrested. And then they are involved in the carceral system, which is the whole thing we were trying to avoid. So recognizing that having a mental health-related intervention and having the county involved is really the right path for people and for families and also for our system to be functioning in a healthy way that also respects the opposition's concerns, respects people's rights, but provides help that is currently not being provided. I think it clear it very clear that we continue to have a major problem And when you look at just the care court numbers of having only 18 percent developing a treatment and housing plan in the state, you see that we're really not at all meeting the need. So, you know, recognizing where are the barriers and why is this such a slow and difficult start to having care court operate, this is a bill that will really help streamline and create the opportunity for a path to be a little bit wider for people who desperately need that help. So with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you. And we'll take that up as soon as we can. Thank you. Thank you. All right, up next, Senator Gonzalez, file item 5, SB 998, and also file item 8, SB 1146, after that. Yeah, I can take those both up. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members. All right. Hi. All right, so good morning, Mr. Chair and member. I'm here to present, member, Senate Bill 998, which defines the roles and responsibilities of five discrimination prevention coordinators housed in the newly created Office of Civil Rights at the Government Operations Agency, GovOps. Last year, the chairs of the API, Black, and LGBTQ caucuses, as well as myself, the chair of the Latino caucus, authored and the legislature passed SB48, establishing four discrimination prevention coordinators. SB 998 fulfills our commitment to follow-up legislation. Specifically, the bill clarifies coordinator roles, adds a new coordinator focused on disability discrimination prevention, and creates four deputy coordinators on anti-Black, anti-Asian American, Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander discrimination, anti-Latino discrimination, and anti-Native American discrimination. And each coordinator will work with the local educational agencies upon request to ensure administrators are equipped to proactively identify and address incidents involving discrimination based on the protected characteristics. A school's culture and climate shape everything in 998 strengthens that foundation by equipping educators with restorative justice practices, cultural competency, training, and providing tailored student services. With me to testify in support is Beth Graves Meyerhoff, Senior Attorney from the Public Council. I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you. Good morning, Chair and members. My name is Beth Graves Meyerhoff, and I'm a Senior Attorney with Public Council, a nonprofit public interest law firm dedicated to advancing civil rights and racial, gender, and economic justice. Our education equity team serves many students of color, students with disability, and gender-expansive youth experiencing racial, gender, or disability discrimination in school. Our office has seen an exponential increase in the number of students seeking services after experiencing discrimination, often intersectional, leading to a devastating effect on a student's ability to thrive in school. The law prohibits discrimination. Nevertheless, discrimination in school happens. The California Department of Education's uniform complaint procedures process saw an upward trajectory in recent years of complaints based on protective status. In 2025, well over half of the education equity complaints filed with CDE spanned two or more protected categories. SB 998 recognizes that students often fall into more than one protected class and ensures the coordinators for race, gender, LGBTQ+, and disability create the intersectional framework our students desperately need. Federal rollback significantly impacted Office for Civil Rights capacity. In 2025 OCR received a record number of civil rights complaints yet dismissed upwards of 90 of individual discrimination complaints This bill is filling a vacuum by Preventing discrimination ensuring that schools have guidance and staff to provide clear direction on how to identify and address discrimination on the school campus Every student has the right to feel safe and be seen on a school campus Senate bill 998 will help schools provide a place for students to learn and grow free from discrimination and harassment harassment. On behalf of Public Counsel and Disability Rights California, who is also in support, I respectfully ask for your support today. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 998? Diana Vu on behalf of the Association of California School Administrators in support. Thank you. Samuel Jan with Disability Rights California in support. Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 998? All right, we'll bring it back to committee. Any questions or comments? Okay. Well, thank you, Senator, for bringing this bill forward and kind of further creating some guidelines as to how some of the legislation in years past will be executed. I know it's pretty complicated, and I think some of that guidance is going to be important. Would you like to close? I respectfully ask for an aye vote on behalf of our diversity caucuses. Thank you. Thank you so much. All right. And then up next, item 8, SB 1146. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for taking this up. And members now. I'm here to present Senate Bill 1146, which will protect Californians from deceptive AI-generated health advertisements. As we know, the rapid advancement of AI and generative AI has made it increasingly difficult to distinguish between real and fake content. SB 1146 will address the issue by requiring advertisements for health products or services that include a digital replica or synthetic performer depicted as a health care provider to clearly disclose that the content was AI generated. It's a critical step forward in ensuring that there is integrity and a trusted medical information that is out there for the public. Testifying in support, I have George Sorries from the California Medical Association. I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you. Good morning, Chair and members. George Sorries with the California Medical Association. We're the proud sponsor of SB 1146 by Senator Gonzalez. Whether it's a good practice or not, patients increasingly rely on online videos and advertisements for health information. Unfortunately, some artificial intelligence programs now allow bad actors to create convincing deepfake physicians to promote products and services that are ineffective, misleading, and even harmful. This bill provides a common-sense safeguard by requiring clear disclosure when AI-generated or digitally altered physicians are used in advertisement, and by establishing meaningful enforcement mechanisms, including giving physicians a tailored pathway to legally defend themselves when their image is used without their consent. This bill protects patients, preserves trust in physician-patient relationship, and helps ensure Californians know when health information is coming from a real clinician and when it's not. We respectfully ask for your aye vote at the appropriate time. Thank you. I'm happy to answer questions. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SP 1146? Great, John. Janet Chase on behalf of the University of California in support. Thank you. Hello, Kelly Macmillan on behalf of the American Academy of Pediatrics, California in support. Thank you. Good morning, Lawrence Gaden with the California Dental Association in support. Thank you. Good morning, Chair Allison Ramey on behalf of Kaiser Permanente in support. Thank you. All right. Is there anyone here in opposition? Oh, I'm Maura. Chancellor Mellie, AFSCME California in support. Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 1146 All right Bring it back to committee Any questions or comments Yeah sure Hey, Senator, I think your bill is a good bill. My question is about the private right of action. Have you thought about that? Why? Is there any other way to work around that? Well, at this time, you know, we do think that individual doctors need to find some reprieve to be able to, you know, ensure that their name and likeness is not replicated. And, you know, that they're also not. But does it have to go through a private? I mean, couldn't it go through a local prosecution? Right now, I mean, you want to add, but right now we just have the private right of action. We're certainly up for discussion, but, you know, that's what we've been working on only. I mean, just to make sure that, you know, people are not being faked out. But please, George. Thank you. I appreciate the question. So in general, you know, the bill, we included this because we thought that it was the best way to give a physician a way to legally defend themselves, as the senator said. But we found that in California and in other states, when a physician has had their images without their consent, that courts don't necessarily always take it serious because the laws have not necessarily been updated to account for AI-generated technology. So it was something that we thought was very narrow and it's only for the individual physician. So it couldn't become a larger situation to where folks like action or something. Correct. It cannot become that. Okay. Well, thank you for clarification. Thank you. Thank you for bringing this forward. Would you like to close? I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you. We'll get to it as soon as we can. Thank you so much. Up next file item 10 SB 1164. Senator Cervantes. Whenever you're ready. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members, for the opportunity to present Senate Bill 1164 today. Before I begin, I want to refer the committee to the Campaign Legal Center support letter and state publicly that I concur with the interpretation of Senate Bill 1164. Colleagues, as we know, democracy in America is under attack by this federal administration and his conservative allies in Congress and in the Supreme Court of the United States. Under the stewardship of Chief Justice Roberts, conservatives on the court have steadily been chipping away at the Federal Voting Rights Act of 1965. This has culminated in the court's shameful recent decision in Louisiana v. Calais, which Governor Newsom rightfully called the implementation of Jim Crow 2.0. This means that many of the safeguards against vote dilution, voter suppression, and voter discrimination that have been protected for Californians for generations are effectively no longer in place. While we have the California Voting Rights Act of 2001, in law, the CVRA only protects against discriminatory at-large election systems. We cannot stand idle by and watch the Chief Justice and the Supreme Court dismantle our democracy piece by piece. This is why we have Senate Bill 1164, which is part of the California Voting Rights Act of 2026, which comes into play. This bill will codify many of the provisions of the Federal Voting Rights Act as it existed before the Cal-A decision into state law. This will ensure that no matter what the Supreme Court does, California voters will continue to have safeguards against vote dilution, voter suppression, and other forms of voter discrimination. The bill also provides the California Attorney General and individual voters with more tools to enforce voting rights laws. We cannot allow... California to continue to be imperiled by the chaos emanating from D.C. Here in the Golden State, we will continue to protect democracy, even in the face of federal government that sabotages voting rights and continues its descent into authoritarianism. I do want to note that it is not our intent of the California Voting Rights Act of 2026 to conflict with federal law, including Supreme Court jurisprudence. Our mission is to protect voting rights in California and the space between the actions that the 14th Amendment permits of the states and what the 15th Amendment authorizes Congress to do. To that end, we will continue working to ensure that the provisions of the California Voting Rights Act of 2026 are in a strong position to survive future judicial scrutiny. I also want to say that my team and I have been in discussion with a wide variety of stakeholders, many of whom reached out really at the last minute before the bill reached the assembly. And so I am committed to working with the sponsors and those stakeholders to address concerns should this bill continue to move forward. And I did share that with some members of this committee that I had a similar issue in my own city of Norco. And so I certainly understand the city's perspective and what we need to do and what I will continue to do in future committees. I do have with me today to testify in support the California Democracy Partnership, Hector Viagra, Vice President of the Policy Advocacy Community, well, MALDEF, just say MALDEF for short here, and Kristen Neemers, the Policy and Campaign Manager with the California Black Power Network. Thank you. Whenever you're ready, will everyone start? Good morning, Chair and committee members. I'm Kristen Nimmer's Policy and Campaigns Manager with the California Black Power Network. We are one of the sponsors of SB 1164, and we represent a statewide coalition of over 49 Black-led and Black-empowering grassroots organizations. Formerly known as the Black Census and Redistricting Hub, our coalition actually began with an intentional focus on democracy. We led work to engage hard-to-reach black residents during the 2020 census, and we led a statewide campaign to engage black communities in the state redistricting process and support our network in engaging in local redistricting to uplift communities of interest. For over a decade, our member organizations have been engaging voters year-round to provide public education on voting. Through this work, we've seen firsthand the challenges that black voters face to achieve true political power and representation. We have also been called to support and advocate on behalf of communities facing disenfranchisement and voter suppression. These things are not confined to the past. There are a few examples of recent intentional acts to suppress black votes and political power. In 2022, leaked records captured L.A. City Council members making racist remarks in a discussion about how to redraw district lines to maintain power at the expense of historically black communities. In 2018, a court found that Latino voters faced similar dilution attempts under Kern County's supervisorial map. We've also seen increased efforts to restrict access to the ballot as election deniers take hold of some local governments. Last year, we joined an amicus brief challenging the attempt in Huntington Beach to enact a new voter ID law based on unfounded claims of fraud. We highlighted the burdens voter ID requirements placed on black voters and other communities. and although successful, the outcome of that case turned on a narrow legal theory that is not always available in cases like these. These examples confirm that we still face threats of discriminatory redistricting and efforts to pass laws that suppress voter participation. SB 1164 provides important safeguards against current threats to voters of color by strengthening California Voting Rights Act to cover district systems adding a pre program to prevent repeat violations And I stop there Thank you. Thank you. Good morning, Mr. Chair, members. My name is Hector Viagra. I'm vice president for policy advocacy at MALDEF, and I'm here in proud support of SB 1164, a key part of the Civil Rights Act of 2026 package. California has long recognized that the right to vote is not simply the formal right to cast a ballot. It's the right to participate equally and meaningfully in the political process. Nearly 25 years ago, California led the country by passing the nation's first state voting rights act. MALDEF was proud to be the principal sponsor of that law, which has been enormously important in addressing at-large election systems that prevent Latino and other protected class voters from electing candidates of their choice. California can and must lead again by enacting SB 1164. Federal voting rights law is no longer a reliable protector of equal political opportunity. For decades, Section 2 of the Federal Voting Rights Act recognized that minority voters can be denied equal participation when district maps or election systems dilute their voting strength. But recent Supreme Court decisions, including Louisiana v. Calais, have made those claims far more difficult to prove and remedy under federal law. That leaves voters of color vulnerable to discriminatory barriers to equal participation, especially at the local level where there's less scrutiny. SB 1164 addresses that problem by, one, expanding the CVRA's protection against vote dilution beyond at large elections to district elections, to prohibiting voter suppression and discriminatory barriers to the ballot. Three, requiring pre-approval of certain voting changes by local governments with the recent history of discrimination. And four, directing courts to protect voting access and equal political opportunity. The public understands the need for states to step up and protect the promise of democracy. Two-thirds of California voters support expanding the CBRA. For all these reasons, Maldeff proudly and respectfully urges an aye vote. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1164? Good morning, Mr. Chair, members, G.S. O'Malley with AFSCME California in strong support. Thank you. Carlos Lopez with the California School Employees Association in support. Thank you. Dora Rose, League of Women Voters of California, sponsor and support. Also, I have the proxies of some other sponsors, Asian Law Caucus, UCLA Voting Rights Project, PANA, the Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans, NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund, Power California Action. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning, Chair and members. Symphony Barbie on behalf of the ACLU California Action, we're our co-sponsor. Thank you. Good morning. Daniel Conway on behalf of Common Cause, another proud co-sponsor. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning. Sydney Fong on behalf of Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders for Civic Empowerment, API Force, proud co-sponsor and support. Thank you. Thank you. Scott Rafferty. I've represented LULAC and the Doris Wirt Foundation and others in 10 lawsuits. I support with legislative findings to protect the law and to avoid protracted litigation. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning, Chair and members. Ruth Sosa on behalf of PowerCA Action in support. Thank you. Good morning. Panarea Abdus on behalf of the California Community Foundation in support. Thank you. Benjamin Henderson with the Western Center on Law and Poverty in support Thank you Tiffany Whiten with SEIU California co in support Thank you Thank you Sarah Brennan with the Vitamin Group on behalf of the Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans, PANA, and NextGen California in strong support. Thank you. Thank you. Sarah Phlox, California Federation of Labor Unions in support. Thank you. Hi, Jeanette Zanipatine on behalf of the Coalition for Immigrant Rights. Thank you. Thank you. Dr. Pereira on behalf of the Inland Coalition for American Justice in support. Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 1164? If we can clear the chair for the gentleman. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning, Chair and members. Johnny Pena on behalf of the League of California Cities here today and respectfully oppose. Unless amended to the bill and apologies for getting our position in late on here. And I just want to start by saying we do appreciate the already productive discussions that we've had on this bill. So thank you to the author and to the sponsors of the bill. And I'll start by saying that we recognize and appreciate the intent of this bill. I think our cities share the goal of protecting voting rights and ensure equitable access to democratic process. However, SB 1164 makes a significant policy shift, and I think our concern is kind of how that expansion is done. The bill in its current form, in our opinion, clearly does not define voter dilution or suppression or certain triggers in the bill, like material disparity. and without certain clarifications, I think it'll make it harder for our cities to come into compliance with the law. At the same time, the bill does not provide a meaningful opportunity to cure alleged violations. Notice provisions can be bypassed, timeline conflicts with required public processes, and our cities may even need a court approval too. As talked about, go forward with that. Other important point of this, our concerns are that as our cities that are already in compliance with the CVRA by adopting district-based elections do lose those meaningful safe harbor protections and can be pulled back into repeat. litigation even before that next census cycle starts. Our concern, I think, is for our cities that have gone from at-large to districts could be sued again and again, kind of having to change from district to district and again having to redistrict once the census is updated. And with that, we're respectfully opposed unless amended at the time, but again, look forward to productive discussions. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in opposition to SB 1164? All right, bring it back to committee. Any questions or comments? Assemblymember Harabidi. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the author. I enjoyed our conversation. Obviously, a very important bill, and I appreciate the witnesses on both sides. I think that I agree with the staff analysis and both sides I mean frankly I think most of this is really And I think that this bill is trying to do great things I have concerns and questions on a few different things that we discussed including the remedy how we're defining the harm. And I just appreciate that you're going to continue to work on these issues. I completely trust you to get this right. And with that understanding, I will be supporting this out of committee, and I look forward to the amended bill before it comes to the floor. So thank you for responding to what's going on in this country. It's really sad to see what the Supreme Court and what our federal government has done to the Voting Rights Act at the federal level. And I think California does need to step up to make sure that everyone is protected. And hopefully this bill does everything we can. Obviously, as the staff report noted, this bill isn't going to solve what federal law has become and what the Supreme Court has done on the federal level, unfortunately. But I think that hopefully on the state level and on the margins, it will be protecting a lot of communities that otherwise wouldn't have protection. So thank you again and happy to support the bill with the ongoing amendments. Thank you. Yeah, I also want to thank you for bringing this forward. I think the Supreme Court decision demands a response from California, and I think this is a good one. And I know you'll continue to work. The recommendations to pass this to Elections Committee, where I think that they have certainly expertise that can help to further guide the author and all the stakeholders. Would you like to close? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for the comments from my colleague. Yes, my commitment is to continue to work with the sponsors and the stakeholders to address the issues that have been raised and to work to manifest those into a solution that's workable for future amendments. So we'll be taken. I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you. We'll take it up when we can. Do we have an author? Not yet. All right. Good luck. Thank you. Thank you. And if they both come in at the same time. Thank you. yeah Thank you. Thank you. How many have we done? Which ones have we done? One, four, five, six, eight, eight. Eight and ten. Yep. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. All right. We have an author. Senator Jones, come on up. Thank you, sir. Item number 16, SB 1256. Senator Jones, when you're ready, please proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Vice Chair, third Vice Chair to the fourth. Nice to see you. Thank you for accommodating our presentation. Members, I'm going to be presenting SB 1256. It's a measure to prevent lawsuit abuse, nimbyism, and needless delays in the building of a much-needed new homes for the residents of San Diego County. I want to thank the chair and the committee staff for their work on the bill, and we will be accepting the committee's amendments to address the concerns of the chair and the opposition. Harmony Grove Village South is a planned development of about 500 new homes in San Diego County San Diego County has identified a need for an additional 100 new homes by 2029 So this is a small dip into that need Litigation abuse like seen with Harmony Grove Village South is one of the main reasons that that goal will almost certainly not be reached, and as you know, around the state as well. This development has been twice approved by the Board of Supervisors and the Planning Commission. It has a project of labor agreement with the local laborers union, Local 89, and the plans for the subdivision are fire safe and certified by local fire authorities. This project has been tied up in litigation since 2018 and has been updated to address CEQA concerns and is completely shovel ready. However, the opponents of the project have continued to put the County of San Diego and the developers of the project through a litigation spin cycle over the same claims on issues that were already litigated in the previous filings. Litigation that never ends on issues that have already been addressed by the court is nothing more than a tool to stop construction at any cost. That is why this measure is needed, because without it, the litigation will keep coming, and these much-needed homes will remain a dream and not a reality, and we want to bring these homes to fruition. Today with me, I have Matt Henderson, counsel for the developer of the project, to speak in support and answer if you have any technical questions. We'd be happy to do that as well. Thank you. Thank you, Senator Jones. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. My name is Matthew Henderson, and I do represent RCS Harmony Partners and Harmony Grove Village South. I'm here this morning to advocate for my clients' much-needed housing project in San Diego County and to be candid to, you know, hopefully talk myself out of a job in this particular case. That project is exactly the kind of housing development that California needs and should be encouraging. The project has 453 units, including affordable housing with a renewable energy component, and it is sited close to jobs and services. It also has the support of local union, as Senator Jones mentioned. The project was first submitted to the county in 2015, more than a decade ago. And as is often the case for these kinds of projects, it was subject to extensive environmental review, including traffic, fire safety, etc. The county approved the project in 2018. As is often the case, it was subject to litigation, in which my client almost completely prevailed, but they only have to win once. We have to win. We have to bat 1,000 in those cases. And so after it was sent back to the county, there was yet more analysis and the county approved the project again in 2025. So you had two completely different boards of supervisors reviewing the same project and deciding this is what the county of San Diego needs. Despite that 2025 re-approval, the project today continues to face further litigation and delay. It has been more than a decade and we're still not even close to breaking ground. And these kinds of delays and all the uncertainty they entail, the problems that you have with financing, with tariffs, with construction costs, these are the kinds of delays that kill projects. And at some point, we need to ask, when is enough government review enough and when do we allow housing to actually be built? It is litigation like this, precisely like this, that helps explain California's housing crisis. This bill is not about eliminating environmental protection. It's not about eliminating or limiting public participation. It about providing certitude and finality to the process for a project that has been thoroughly reviewed and lawfully approved So we respectfully ask for your aye vote Thank you very much Any other individuals or organizations in support of the bill? Come forward now. State your name, organization, and your position. Good morning, Chair and members. James Thorewactor with the California State Council of Labor is also here on behalf of Labor's Local 89 based out of San Diego in strong support. Thank you. Thank you. Any main witnesses in opposition on the bill? Please come forward. Thank you, Chair and members of the committee for the opportunity to speak in opposition to SB 1256 on behalf of our community and our town council. I moved to Harmony Grove area, one of the most fire-prone communities in San Diego County about 14 years ago. quickly learned what it means to live in a fire-prone community. I served on Volunteer Fire Department Board, our Fire Safe Council, our Town Council, and became really real to me a few years later when the Cocos Fire burned thousands of acres and thrashed our community, destroying 40-plus homes on the same dead-end road this project is being proposed. I have seen firsthand how limited our evacuation infrastructure is. Our community is actually a very pro-housing community. In fact, we worked with the county and two other housing developers to improve projects, strengthen fire safety measures, and add evacuation routes. ultimately earning broad support. Both projects, Harmony Grove Village and Valiano, are being built today with our backing and our testimony in favor of those projects at the Board of Supervisors. So we're not housing anti-housing people. Excuse me, my thing just canceled. Sorry about that. And while you're finding your place, your name and affiliation, I'm sorry. My name is J.P. Thabers, and I'm on the Elf of Forest Harmony Grove Town Council. This project is different. It is proposed on a dead-end road in a bowl canyon surrounded by thousands of acres of open space where that same Cocos Fire destroyed homes a decade ago. In good faith, we asked for additional evacuation improvements and safety measures. We were ignored. When the county approved the project anyway, our community did what all citizens are supposed to do. We held fund runs, fundraisers, attended hearings, and pursued legal process. More than a dozen independent fire scientists, PhDs, fire professionals, and evacuation modeling experts identified serious concerns, including a very likely evacuation entrapment scenario due to the limited narrow country roads. This is not a case about opposing housing. It's about whether the court or the county properly followed its own local and state fire safety requirements when approving a newly submitted recently, for the second time, in a very high fire hazard area. We believe the county got it wrong. We may ultimately win or lose, but we deserve the opportunity to present our evidence in court. We don't believe that an out-of-state billionaire should be given a chance to override our fire safety concerns. We strongly ask you to reconsider this because this is not just a Harmony Grove issue. It's an unincorporated community issue that we're all facing, and we really appreciate your support. Thank you. Thank you. Any other parties in opposition to the bill? Please come forward now. Say it's your name, organization, and position. Good morning. Marissa Rodriguez with the Planning and Conservation League in respectful opposition. Good morning. Natalie Brown on behalf of Resource Renewal Institute, the California Coastal Protection Network, Endangered Habitats League, and the Center for Biological Diversity, also voicing opposition. Thank you. Thank you. I'll bring it back to committee. Any questions, comments from committee members? Seeing none, Senator Jones, would you like to respond and Sure. Yeah, I'll just be brief. And I want to point out, you know, one thing that's very important in this issue that Matthew pointed to is that two different boards of supervisors in the county of San Diego. have approved this project, one that was a Republican majority and one that most recently the Democrat majority. So this is obviously a nonpartisan issue in San Diego County. So I appreciate that perspective. And I want to speak personally to the comments regarding the fire prone and fire issues there. I've represented this area since 2010 when I got elected to the city council, or to the State Assembly, but before that, 2002, since I was on the Santee City Council. I've been elected through both the 03 fires and the 07 fires that impacted my district and my area. So I'm very sensitive to that. This project has been approved by CAL FIRE and the local Rancho Bernardo fire officials. KB Homes just most recently opened a new housing development in my district in Escondido. It is recognized as one of the most fire-safe new communities in the country with a bunch of fanfare and press. The California Commissioner of Insurance, Ricardo Lara, came and visited at the grand opening. So the new construction policies are going to lead to this being one of the most fire-safe communities as well. And with that, I ask for your aye vote. Thank you. And we will take that up as soon as we have a quorum. Oh, thank you. All right. I appreciate that. And I do see that we have another senator here to present, Senator Reyes, which would be item number two, SB 873. Senator, welcome. Good to see you. Whenever you're ready, you can begin. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee members, for the opportunity to present SB 873, an important step forward to ensure all Californians can have access to our justice system without fear. One of the core responsibilities of government is to protect people, not to inflict terror on them. SB 873 will protect the legal process for all in California by preventing the indiscriminate arrests by ICE agents in and around the grounds of a courthouse. Recently, there have been numerous reports of immigration-related arrests happening in and around courthouses in California. Earlier this year, witnesses at the Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse located in my district witnessed several arrests of individuals coming out of the courthouse. This was done without explanation and with very little detail after the fact, significantly impacting our community. Despite this limited information, one thing is clear. This has a chilling effect on the willingness of individuals to participate in our legal process. Discouraging people from coming to court makes our community less safe. Several states have taken similar action as we are proposing here, including New York, Illinois, and Washington, who have all enacted legislation to protect the sanctity of courthouses from ICE arrests. California fully intends to protect the rights of our residents to participate in judicial proceedings. When we talk about the indiscriminate arrests we do not intend to stop a judicial warrant to be executed by an ICE agent or anyone else Here to testify on behalf of this bill are Andrea Garcia, public defender with the San Bernardino County Public Defender's Office, and Jacqueline Ruby, legal observer with the Inland Coalition for Justice's Rapid Response Network. Good morning. My name is Andrea Garcia, and I'm a deputy public defender, speaking on behalf of the California Public Defenders Association. I am asking you to vote aye on SB 873 because it protects the fair administration of justice in our state courts. This is a justice system issue. Every case, civil, family, probate, juvenile traffic is affected when the public believes the courthouse is a trap. These civil arrests are unbridled and widespread across California. We have collected reports from deputy public defenders, community members, and families of persons subject to civil courthouse arrests. These civil arrests occur on a weekly, sometimes daily basis. Immigration agents are civil administrative officers who do not carry judicial warrants, unlike our deputized criminal law enforcement officers. They surround persons in the parking lot, in the streets, on the sidewalks, and in and around the courthouses. These civil arrests are not surgical. One man was detained in a parking lot while simply searching for a son. I personally witnessed a monolingual Spanish-speaking woman surrounded in a desolate alley only a block from the San Bernardino Courthouse, my courthouse. The Department of Homeland Security's internal memo shows that fewer than 14% of people arrested by ICE nationwide were charged or convicted of a crime. These civil arrests chill due process. When people fear arrest at the courthouse, they stop coming. Witnesses don't show victims of domestic violence and wage theft refuse to seek relief. Children who need court services don't have rides because of the fear instilled in their caregivers. Defendants miss mandatory appearances and face new charges. The courthouse stops functioning as a courthouse. California law already prohibits civil immigration arrests inside courthouse buildings. SB 873 closes the loophole. It extends the protection to parking lots, sidewalks, and the 1,000-foot perimeter where ICE is currently operating freely. SB 873 gives courthouse staff authority and a legal framework. The bill requires that agents present a valid judicial warrant signed by a judge and clearly identify themselves to court personnel before any arrest. This means our clerks, security staff, and public defenders are no longer guessing who these masked agents are or whether their paperwork is legitimate. This is not obstruction. This is due process in action. This is a public safety issue. All the bill asks is this. If you want to make an arrest near a courthouse, get a judicial warrant. This is a reasonable constitutional standard. The courthouse must be a place where everyone, regardless of their legal status or their family members' legal status, can safely exercise their rights. Please vote aye on SB 873. Thank you. Please proceed Hi good morning Chair cholera and committee members My name is Jacqueline Anton I am a professor at a Cal State University here and I am also a trained legal observer from Rancho Cucamonga As Senator Ella Reyes said, Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse has been hit hard by immigration agents. In exactly 290 days between June 2025 and April 2026, 60 people were abducted by federal law enforcement agencies at the Rancho Cucamonga Superior Courthouse alone. That does not include the surrounding streets. It does not include unwitnessed abductions. It does not include abductions at other locations in the city. That is solely the numbers for the abductions that had taken place at the Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse in a little under nine months. Since the beginning of this current administration, I have personally witnessed 40 of the 60 abductions at the Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse and countless others on the streets of San Bernardino, Pomona, Fontana, Rialto, and you name it. I've personally witnessed how disruptive and violent these operations are and how negatively they impact the system. I will take you through an average day at the Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse in the last nine months. Beginning as early as 7 a.m., you could expect to see a plainclothes ICE scout agent standing outside of the public defender's office or the district attorney's office waiting as attorneys were calling their clients' names so that they could alert agents who are outside in anywhere from 10 to 15 vehicles, which means you have 15-plus agents who are waiting to take people from inside and outside the courthouse, including outside parking lots that are already over 2,000 feet away. It gives them a great bird-eye view into our courthouse parking lots. During this, they drive recklessly through our courthouse parking lot, refuse to identify themselves, and demand compliance from people who don't know why they're being stopped or who they're being stopped by. They use the excessive force to arrest people and racially profile people while also threatening the safety of bystanders and court attendees in their vehicles and by person. One day stands out in particular for its heedlessness and devastation. On February 19th, 2026, there were six abductions in one day at the Rancho Cucamonga courthouse alone. There were 15 unmarked vehicles in the parking lots of the courthouse and surrounding parking lots. I witnessed masked agents violently tear a mother from her car as her children were screaming for her. I watched two men completely unrelated to the incident run in fear because masked men unidentified were chasing them. They were then profiled based on their fear, their skin color, and the language they were speaking, and they were detained. In person, ICE agents referred to them as collateral. Both of those men are still in attention at Atalanto. One is going through medical crises at which he is not receiving any attention for. And this has become a regular practice at courthouses all throughout the Inland Empire in San Bernardino, Montana, Pomona, Rancho especially, and elsewhere. Law enforcement and the state courthouse or use the state courthouses to stalk them, eavesdrop in court proceedings, and make shows of force that only serve to deter people and scare them away. Allowing indiscriminate civil arrests at our state courthouses prohibits everyone's ability to engage in due process, not just immigrant communities, but all communities. This is not only affecting our ability to engage in due process it is also tearing families apart causing unnecessary trauma and sometimes ending in death Following abductions families are hit with inaccessible legal systems egregious legal fees and for-profit detention centers that don't care about their loved ones. SB 873 is an important first step in protecting our judicial system for everyone and especially for Californians. For these reasons, I respectfully request your your aye votes and thank you for your time. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 873? Hector Pereira on behalf of the Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice, power co-sponsor of the bill in support. Brian Augusta on behalf of the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, one of the co-sponsors, also the National Housing Law Project, Public Interest Law Project, and Housing and Economic Rights Advocates in support. Thank you. Sam and Jan with Disability Rights California strong support. Thank you. Becca Kramer, I've been asked to register support for Oakland privacy. Thank you. Sandra Barrero on behalf of SEIU California, proud co-sponsor and support. Tracy Kenny on behalf of the Judicial Council in support of Senate Bill 873, ask your aye vote. Rebecca Marcus on behalf of the California Public Defenders Association, proud co-sponsor and support. Thank you. Eric Paredes with the California Faculty Association in support. Thank you. Thank you. Marcus Ejo with the County of Los Angeles in support. Thank you. Thank you. Benjamin Henderson with the Western Center on Law and Poverty, who is also a co-sponsor in support. Thank you. On behalf of the Coalition for Human Immigrant Rights, also in support. Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 873? Okay, we'll bring it back. Oh, yes. Go ahead. On behalf of the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department in opposition. Thank you. Thank you. All right, we'll bring it back to committee. Any questions or comments? Thank you, Senator, for bringing this forward. I think it's an incredibly important piece of legislation. I would like to be at it as a co-author. Would you like to close? We'd be honored to have you as a co-author. Thank you. In closing, our Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, Patricia Guerrero, in the state of the judiciary, stated, Making courthouses a focus of immigration enforcement hinders rather than helps the administration of justice. I cannot agree more with our Chief Justice. And with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you. We will take that up as soon as we can. Okay. Thank you. That's okay. I don't mind that on the record. Thank you. Thank you, members. We have item 14, SB 1267, whenever you're ready. So, thank you. Residents belonging to homeowner associations and condominium complexes find it often particularly difficult making the switch to electric vehicles. because unlike with single-family homeowners or HOA owners that have a dedicated, personally-owned garage, folks in this set of circumstances have to use common area spaces to park. And then most people charge at home, they then have to install the needed infrastructure to charge their vehicles in these common area spaces. So we know that the biggest barrier to large-scale market proliferation of EVs is accessibility to charging stations. As someone who has some electric vehicles in my family, I know this well. So we know we have to do more to ensure that prospective EV drivers living in HOAs that have these common area spaces for parking are accommodated. So last year, I authored a bill, SB 770, which removed a requirement for HOA residents to name an association as an additional insured on their homeowner's policy. Many consumers were struggling to find insurers that would allow them to add an endorsement for the HOA. And you remember this discussion last year. Now, our friends who represent the HOAs raised concerns at the time, as you may recall, assembly member, about liability for damage or injury that might be caused by a charger. I made a commitment at the time that if this were to move through, we would figure out a path that would provide some protection for the association. So this bill is me fulfilling that promise. And it seeks to require the installer of an EV charging station to indemnify the association during the installation of the charger and make the homeowner liable for any costs arising from the use of a privately owned charger. You know, listen, there's not been any shown, as we discussed last year, risk of significant risk or injury. But I understand the lack of certainty in the law then and now that is worrying to HOAs and, you know, can make it more difficult for HOAs to obtain adequate insurance in an increasingly unaffordable broad-based insurance market, especially for HOAs. And so it's with that spirit we come today, and I respectfully ask for your aye vote on SB 1267. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, Louis Brown here today on behalf of the Community Associations Institute. The senator is a man of his word, and we have addressed some of the issues that we were discussing at the end of session last year, and we support the bill and ask for an aye vote. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1267? Is there anyone in opposition to SB 1267? I'm bringing it back to committee. Any questions or comments? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to briefly thank both of you. I do think that it's rare when And an author actually follows through on addressing. We hear a lot about how if a bill gets done, I promise to follow up with additional work and additional bills. And oftentimes that's, you know, that falls by the wayside. And it's great because we had a lot of discussions, the three of us and members here and in insurance about going forward, trying to make sure that everyone was comfortable. So it's just great that both of you followed through and appreciate the Senator for doing that. So happy to support at the right time Thank you Thank you I also want to thank you Senator Actually about a month ago I have a charger in my home but it a single family residence It started smoking. I know it was, it was, it was, it was medical or? I don't know. I do think there might've been some user error involved, But the bottom line was, you know, we had to shut the power off, get an electrician to come and fix it. If I did live in a condo complex townhouse under the office of an HOA, it would be, I think, unreasonable for me to expect the HOA to be liable for that. And so I think that this is one more step, not only a follow-up to legislation, but one more step in helping to facilitate the growth of the infrastructure of EVs, which is really the next phase of our kind of EV involvement in this state. So I thank you for bringing this bill forward. Would you like to close? Yeah, no, this is a good issue that reminds me that insurance undergirds so much of our economy and so many aspects of life, including our transition to a less carbon intensive future. But appreciate the work of everyone. Appreciate Mr. Brown and ask for an eye vote. Thank you. When we get warm, we'll get right on top of that. Thank you. Thank you. While we're waiting for senators, and the senators, if they do show up, we can pretty much get everything but one item done by noon. Last week, we had to go into the afternoon because senators didn't show up, and we had over a half hour we were waiting for authors. It seems to be happening again today so I really urge our Senate authors to get here so we can take care of their business as quickly as possible And we will be returning in the afternoon regardless for one item on for special order of business at 1 p That's SB 623 Umberg. And we'll be in room 447 this afternoon. But I just urge our Senate colleagues to get here as soon as possible and we can get you on your way. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Senator Cortese, item 16, SB 1425, whenever you're ready. Good morning, Chair. Good morning. and members, I'm pleased to present SB 1425. Before I begin, I want to thank the Chief Counsel and Chair for their work on this, and I'll be accepting the amendments as outlined on page six. Thank you. California is building the nation's first 220-mile-per-hour fully electrified high-speed rail system, as I think we all know. There going to be massive development potential along that corridor measured at approximately 400 miles while the state is charged with managing the land it lacks legal authority to regulate encroachments that may delay the building operation and maintenance of the project SB 1425 simply enables the authority to do what most local governments and agencies are equipped to do to adopt regulations to establish an encroachment permit program within the projects right of way. A codified permit process will bridge the gap between local property owners, businesses, and public entities to bolster the surrounding communities and support expansion along the corridor. With us today, we have Keith Dunn with State Building and Construction Trades Council. I'm at an appropriate time. I'd respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members. Keith Dunn, State Building and Construction Trades Council. I'd like to thank the Senator for bringing forward this measure. As he's mentioned, This provides the authority for the high-speed rail authority to manage encroachment permits. We've spent a lot of time talking about some of the concerns and issues that surround this project. I spent a better part of the last decade and a half trying to improve them. I would tell you that this bill goes a long way to make sure that we're avoiding some of the delays that drive costs. So, again, this is a measure that's been borne out of experience in the ground with the valley and some of the utilities that interact in that space. So I hope that you can support this measure that's going to provide the opportunity to do things better, to learn from some of the past issues that we've encountered and improve upon the delivery of this very important construction project. So with that, I'd like to ask for your support. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1425? Mr. Chair, members, Sarah Phlox, California Federation of Labor Unions in support. Thank you. Chairman, members, James Thorewactor with the California State Council of Labor is in strong support. Thanks. Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 1425? Good morning, Mr. Chair, members, Brian White here on behalf of Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, largest public utility in the nation. We have our own rights of ways and enforcement issues that we deal with at a local level. We have a lot of interactions with various agencies, Department of Water Resources and Coutrans. We're just worried about, notwithstanding the enforcement provisions, we're worried about the ability to go in and do emergency work and maintenance and repairs along our rights of ways. So we just need to have a better process of dealing with that without having to get an encroachment permit to go in and protect our public rights of ways. So we're working with the author trying to fix that, and hopefully we can get that done in the next committee. So thank you. Thank you.

Terry Brennanwitness

Good morning, Kiarra Ross on behalf of the city of Burbank of Burbank Water and Power. We would echo the comments of LADWP. We've had conversations with the author and we'll continue. Thank you much.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you.

Terry Brennanwitness

Good morning, Mr. Chair and members. Rod Brewer for Southern California Edison, also one of the posts.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. All right, bring it back to the committee. Any questions or comments? Assembly members of Brewer.

Terry Brennanwitness

Thank you for bringing the bill. I'll be supporting it today. I actually do think, though, that some of the comments from the utilities related to rights away and doing those in a more systematic way, similar to what's been done in other kinds of bills that are similar, are valid points. And I'm hoping that you'll continue working with them to try to refine that as the bill moves forward. Yes, absolutely. May I respond?

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Yes, please.

Terry Brennanwitness

Thank you, Assemblymember. We've been working, among other things, I think we've solved the issue of making sure existing or pre-existing agreements, which some of the larger utilities have, directly with high-speed rail, basically dealing with what we normally do. deal with a code section just by contractual agreement that give them presumably what they want, the rights they want. That doesn't foreclose still having an encroachment permit program is sort of a fundamental building block beneath all of that. But issues of where they have pre-existing easements, underground work, underground pipelines, et cetera. We assume that they have easements. Some of them probably go back decades and decades, which allow them, just like Pacific Gas and Electric, or I know we have Southern California utility here, but they don't ask permission. They just go into their easement and do their work because that's what the easement says they can do. But we're going to keep working to make sure we don't inadvertently create an encroachment permit program that forces them where they already have a right to come in, you know, to take another step. There's no intention of doing that. Thank you. Yeah, I think the thing that makes the electric utilities and other utilities a little bit different is because they're so extensive. So, I mean, it's not like one property owner that you actually have to deal with. It's, you know, they've got easements all over the place. They have them in my backyard. So I just think it needs more attention to really deal with the details of some of the concerns that they have to allow them to continue doing what they need to do to serve the public. So thank you for agreeing to work with them. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions or comments? Yeah, and if this past this committee is going to the Utilities Committee, and I think that's an appropriate committee to deal with some of these more technical issues, it doesn't sound like opposition is principally opposed, but they obviously have their concerns of the work that they need to do, especially when it's urgent work. But on a larger scale, we already know that delays have really hindered the High Sea Rail project and whatever we can do to help speed it along. And I think this is definitely a bill that can help us do that. It's critically important.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Would you like to close?

Terry Brennanwitness

Thank you, Chair. And thank you for this. Again, this committee's hard look at it and the amendments that we're taking. and we'll certainly, you know, through each committee, we've, you know, taken the process very seriously. And I think, you know, probably everybody says this, at least in my committee when they come through, but we're very, very close in reality to just, you know, buttoning up these issues and it's everyone's intention to do it, including mine. So with that, I respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

We'll get to a vote when we get a quorum, which is we're very close. Thank you. Thank you Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Can we establish a matter of secretary, if you can establish quorum, please? For quorum, cholera, Macedo, Barakahan, Brian, Connolly, Dixon, hair beating, Pacheco, Pappen? Here. Sanchez? Stephanie? Here. Elizabeth Burr? Here. Can I have a motion on the consent calendar? So moved. Second. The consent calendar includes SB 997 Caballero, SB 1088, Black Sphere, SB 1192 Rubio as amended to appropriations, SB 1316 Smaller Cuevas to appropriations and SB 1405 Smaller Cuevas to Appropriations Kalra Aye Kalra aye Macedo Barakahan Brian Connolly Dixon Harabian Aye. Harabian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Papin? Aye. Papin, aye. Sanchez? Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir? Aye. Zabir, aye. The consent calendar is on call. All right. Let's keep it moving. Can we get a motion on file item one? So moved. I'll second. Motion is due pass to Elections Committee. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barcahan, Bryan, Connolly, Dixon, Harabedian? Aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Papin? Aye. Papin, aye. Sanchez? Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir? Aye. Zabir, aye. That's on call. The motion on item two. The motions do pass to preparations cholera. I call her I'm a Cito Barcahan Brian Connelly Dixon hair beating. Hair beating I check out the check out I happen happen I Sanchez Stephanie. Stephanie I Zipper I said on call. We have a motion item for SB 99 Blake Spear. Blake Spear. Second. Motion is due pass to appropriations. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barcahan, Brian, Connolly, Dixon, Herabedian? Aye. Herabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Pappin? Aye. Pappin, aye. Sanchez, Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir? Aye. Zabir, aye. Okay, place that on call. Do we have a motion on item 5, SB998, Gonzalez? So moved. Second. Second. Motion is due pass to appropriations. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Bargahan, Brian Connolly, Dixon, Harabedian? Aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pappen? Aye. Pappen, aye. Sanchez, Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zuber? Place it on call. Zuber, aye. Is there a motion on item six, SB 1078, Laird? Second. Second. Motion is due pass to appropriations. Kalra? Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barrakehan, Brian, Connolly, Dixon, Harabedian? Aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Pappin? Aye. Pappin, aye. Sanchez? Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir? Aye. Zabir, aye. Place it on call. Is there a motion on item 8, SB 1146, Gonzales? So moved. Second. Motion is due pass to appropriations. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barrakehan, Brian, Connolly, Dixon, Harabedian? Aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Papin, aye. Papin, aye. Sanchez, Stephanie, aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir, aye. Place it on call. Surround motion on item 10, SB 1164, Cervantes. Motion is due pass to Elections Committee. Kalra, aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barcahan, Brian Connolly, Dixon, Harabedian, aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco, aye. Pacheco, aye. Papin, aye. Pacheco, aye. Sanchez, Stephanie, aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir? Aye. Zabir, aye. That's on call. Okay, we'll place it on call. Is there a motion on item 13, SB201256, Jones? Aye. So moved. Motion is due pass as amended to local government. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barcahan, Brian, Connolly, Dixon, Herbedian? Aye. Herbedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Pappan? Aye. Pappan, aye. Sanchez, Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir? That's on call. Okay, I said on call item 14 SB 1267 Allen Motion is do pass Cara I call right I miss it Oh Barcahan Brian Connelly Connelly I Dixon hair beating hair beating I but check oh check oh I happen happen I Sanchez Stephanie Stephanie eyes the burr Zuber, aye. That's our bill out. All right. We have a motion on item 16, SB 1425, Cortese. Motion is due pass as amended to Utilities and Energy Committee. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Aceto, Barra-Khan, Brian, Connelly? Aye. Connelly, aye. Dixon, Herbedian? Aye. Herbedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Pappin? Aye. Papin, aye. Sanchez, Stephanie, aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir, aye. Okay, that bill is out. If we can do add-ons for the consent calendar. Macedo, Barrakehan, Brian, Conley, aye. Conley, aye. Dixon, Sanchez, Sanchez. Okay, the consent calendar is out. If we can do add-ons for item 1, SB 46, Umberg. SB 46, Macedo Barcahan, Brian Connelly. Aye. Connelly, aye. Dixon Sanchez. That bill is out. Two add-ons for item two, SB 873, Reyes. Macedo Barcahan, Brian Connelly. Aye. Connelly, aye. Dixon Sanchez. That bill is out. Add-ons for item four, SB 989, Blake Spear. Macedo Barcahan, Brian Connelly. Aye. Connelly, aye. Dixon Sanchez. Those out add-ons for item 5 SB 998 Gonzalez Macedo Barakahan Brian Connelly Connelly I Dixon Sanchez Those out add-on item 6 SB 1078 Laird Macedo Barakahan Brian Connelly Connelly I Dixon Sanchez That bill is out add-ons item 8 SB 1146 Gonzalez Macedo Barakahan Brian Connelly Connelly I Dixon Sanchez Those out add-ons item 10 SB 1164 Cervantes Masito Baracahan Brian Conley Conley I Dixon Sanchez That bill is out Move the call on item 13 SB 1256 Jones Masito Baracahan Brian Conley Conley Conley I Dixon This is Jones SB 1256 Dixon, aye. Sanchez. That bill is out. Okay. All right. We have with us Senator Durazo. Item 9, SB 1160.

Good morning. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members. During my time at the legislature, I've been really focused on protecting tenants. In my district alone, there are over 70% renters. The cost of housing rises and more Californians are rent burdened on the verge of eviction or actually getting evicted and becoming homeless This bill seeks to increase transparency and better understand the housing instability and homelessness across our state by gathering eviction court data at the zip code level. Specifically, this bill requires that Judicial Council of California assess which counties have the feasibility to report eviction data by zip code. It also allows counties with 100 or fewer zip codes for their data to be kept at the countywide level, which is where they currently report. Other counties that are not in that carve-out would report at a zip code level. Lastly, the Judicial Council will then have the aggregated data and will post it on their website. Year after year in the legislature, we continue to hear of the growing crisis. Just last year, data showed 13% of low-income households, 800,000 renters, report facing evictions. With the data this bill collects, policymakers, legal service providers, and local governments can identify patterns in eviction filings and outcomes like default between zip codes, track local, statewide, and statewide progress preventing. Why zip codes? I'll give you an example. The specific State Housed LA is an innovative homelessness prevention initiative. It functions as a right to counsel program. During implementation, advocates encountered two major challenges, a high volume of eviction cases relative to the limited number of attorneys handling eviction defense and low public awareness of tenants' rights and services. So to address these issues, the program partnered with community-based organizations, conducted outreach, education, workshops, and canvassing. The advocates soon identified more barriers, which were concentrated near downtown Los Angeles. Given these capacity constraints, advocates adopted a phased implementation strategy using priority zip codes Because eviction filing data were unavailable, they relied on proxy indicators such as homelessness counts and census data. Zip codes were prioritized based on the severity of housing instability and the estimated demand for community services. This approach helped inform residents about eviction process, available assistance, and how to respond to eviction notices. I know that Judicial Council continues to have some concerns, but I remain committed to continuing the discussion to find a solution on the concerns. Today, we have the opportunity to hear from our two co-sponsors, Kyle Nelson, Director of Policy and Advocacy with Strategic Actions for a Just Economy, and Benjamin Henderson, Housing Policy Advocate for the Western Center on Law and Poverty. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you.

Kyle Nelsonwitness

Good morning, Chair and committee members. My name is Kyle Nelson, and I'm Director of Policy and Advocacy at Strategic Actions for a Just Economy. We're a co-sponsor of SB 1160 because we strongly believe that having zip code level data on eviction filings and outcomes is worth the investment. Not only is it worth the investment, it will positively impact how we make policy decisions to end homelessness in California. 75 organizations from across the state agree with this assessment And in their support for the bill they shared how essential eviction data can be to the day work of preventing homelessness in an increasingly unstable economy. Currently, eviction data is available at the county level. And since 2016, I've collected this data by submitting public records requests to the Judicial Council. In Los Angeles, this data helped elected officials craft emergency tenant protections during the COVID-19 pandemic, and it's been vital to implementing Stay Housed LA, the city and county's right to counsel program. But this data can only tell as part of the story. For our homelessness prevention policies to work, we also need to know where eviction outcomes are happening. For example, we know that over half of tenants in Kern County default, where they lose their cases before their first court date. With zip code level data, however, tenant advocates could focus outreach efforts on areas with the highest default rates, increasing the likelihood that tenants respond to landlords' lawsuits in time. This is especially important in a county that is larger than the state of New Jersey, with a lot of evictions and few tenant advocates. Implementing SB 1160 will not come without costs, but if California hopes to curb homelessness, then we must enact data-driven policies that allow advocates to focus their efforts on the places where tenants need support the most. I respectfully ask for your aye vote and thank you for your consideration. Thank you.

Benjamin Hendersonwitness

Good morning chair and members. My name is Benjamin Henderson. I am a policy advocate with the Western Center on Law and Poverty. For tenants an eviction filing can mean losing affordable housing, disrupting a child's education, and even experiencing homelessness. Yet despite the life-changing consequences of eviction, California still lacks consistent statewide data to understand how many unlawful detainers are filed, how these cases are resolved, and which communities are most impacted by evictions. Today, legal advocates and local governments need eviction data to identify communities experiencing the highest rate of displacement and to target resources where they are needed most. They look at eviction cases, look at where eviction cases are being filed, how many cases end in default judgment because tenants are unable to respond, and other factors. The Western Center on Law and Poverty holds monthly eviction defense calls where we discuss this information with our legal service partners. The problem is that this data is not collected or reported consistently across California. Some counties make this information available, but most do not, making it difficult to understand statewide trends or evaluate whether our policies are effectively keeping people housed. SB 1160 addresses this gap by creating a standardized statewide reporting system for unlawful detainer cases by collecting information on filings, defaults, stipulated judgments, dismissals, and other case outcomes by zip code. This bill would give California the transparency and information needed to improve eviction prevention efforts and better serve people at the risk of losing their homes. We respectfully ask for a yes vote. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1160?

Brian Augustawitness

Good morning, Chair and members. Brian Augusta on behalf of the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation California Coalition for Rural Housing the Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board and Housing California in support Thank you Good morning.

Marky Cedrowitness

Marky Cedro with the County of Los Angeles in support. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 1160?

Morgan-Larry Zabowitness

Good morning, Chair and members. Morgan-Larry Zabo, Legislative Advocate with the Judicial Council today here in respectful opposition to 1160. We appreciate the work Senator Dorazzo and her office have put into the latest amendments, especially the needed delayed implementation timeline. However, we remain in opposition based on the significant workload and fiscal impact the bill will have on the courts and the council. The main crux of the impact remains with the requirement to provide the data by zip code. This is not a field that exists in nearly all court case management systems today. As these systems are designed to ensure cases are tracked through the judicial system, it is not an easy fix to add a new field to each of the individual systems and create a statewide extraction system for the information to regularly flow up to the council for the aggregation and information that needs to be reported by the bill. This new requirement will require significant resources and divert court staff from helping court users to focus on data collection for use outside of the court system. We look forward to continuing the conversation with Senator Durazo and her office. Thank you and happy to take any questions. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Is there anyone else here in opposition to SB 1160? Bring it back to the committee. Any questions or comments? Assemblymember Pacheco?

Pachecoother

Thank you. I just had a question for judicial council. Is there a way to get this bill to a better place so that this bill can continue going forward? I know there were some amendments that were already taken, but I do also have a concern about our course in different judicial council forms. Is there a way to go to neutral?

Morgan-Larry Zabowitness

There's not a cheap way to go to neutral, I'll put it that way. It's really going to take an update to all the different systems. LA is currently doing this with the help of Stanford researchers. So they have a lot of people helping them do this currently. And one of our first suggestions was maybe we do a pilot program specifically to LA where they do have this data. We have all the other data elements that do get reported annually. It's really this zip code factor that they're hinging the bill on every year that we just simply don't have an ability to easily implement into all of our systems. There are 58 different systems. Every system is different. We'd have to work with multiple vendors at the council and the court level. The bill amendments do reference our gypsum system, which is an outdated system that we're slowly starting to move away from. So it's a separate system that needs to be created at our level and then at every individual court level. So short answer is no. And I'm just curious to the author, and I commend you for always advocating on behalf of tenants.

Pachecoother

I'm curious if there's a way, and I'm not saying to make a commitment right now, but is there a way to maybe go down the route of maybe doing this as a pilot program, maybe only for L.A. County, so that way this wouldn't be an impact for Judicial Council?

Well, L.A. County pretty much does it now. So a pilot project isn't going to help in that case. What we were looking at is the time that it would take. One is that the judicial council would decide which of the counties have the feasibility to do it.

Terry Brennanwitness

So it's not just saying everybody right now, right? So the judicial council decides which counties have the feasibility to do that. We gave them extra time to do it. We can talk about more. And then that there are counties with 100 or fewer zip codes. So capacity, feasibility, we're trying to address that. We're not just saying you're off on your own. We've also suggested that as technology, as they upgrade the technology, each county has some more, some less, but they all rely on some level of technology that has that technology. They make changes in the technology that they would include this. We did this with the paid family leave information that we asked when we got passed through a law, is that as the technology was upgraded, they added these data points. So those are the ways in which we've suggested to move forward. We'll continue to take any suggestions along those lines. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

And I'm curious, does this, what the senator just mentioned, do those amendments help to alleviate some of the concerns? It seems like it does.

Terry Brennanwitness

It doesn't, just because that's not the way our systems are set up to be updated. So all the different vendors have current projects ongoing that this can't just easily be added into. And we need project managers at our level to be able to make sure everything gets implemented across the board. and the two years really LA is the only county that would be able to court in county that would be able to do this so it really is an update that needs to go out to all 57 other courts and currently with these latest amendments there is an exception for courts with 100 or fewer annual filings over the last five years however the bill still requires all 58 courts to report to the council it's just when the council then posts the results we would exclude those so So it's just it needs a lot of updates to be able to make this work.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Well, I'm hoping that there will be further conversations held. I will be voting for your bill today so that you can continue having those conversations. But I'll reserve my vote for when it gets on the floor. But hoping that it gets to a better place. But again, thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Assemblymember Zabur. I want to thank the author for bringing the bill. You know, data collection is something that's really important. And when I was at Equality California, we actually had a series of bills that were trying to collect data on sexual orientation and gender identity. And we were doing it in pieces because you always sort of – and they're valid concerns, but you always have the concerns about how much it's costing to update your systems, how much it's costing to update your forms. And the way you deal with it is the way you're dealing with it now, which is that you try to look at, okay, when is the system going to be updated on its own anyway? So you're already bearing those costs. When are you going to print the forms anyway? So when you print the forms the next time you add it at that point and so those are the ways that you typically deal with Issues of data collection when you're trying to collect more data It sounds like you're very focused on those kinds of things to reduce the cost of our court for our judicial council in our courts And so with that I'd be supporting the bill I think these are the kinds of things that always happen on data collection bills and so You know I just want to thank the author for continuing to work on these issues and I'll be supporting it all today. Thank you All right Any other questions or comments Okay I also want to thank the author Look you know this is we talking about adding one more field of information to information that already exists The courts already have it These are unlawful detainers They have the zip code of these residents You know, we talk a lot about the housing crisis, and I think so much focuses on new construction and being able to have homeownership. The number one crisis, not just now, but has been for many, many years, is rents too high. evictions. Families are struggling to survive. And it's not just in LA County. It's in all 58 counties now. Having the data to be able to be nimble enough to respond is critically important. Although I understand the concerns of the Judicial Council, I think having from today's data at least two and a half years to add one more field. Every year, court forms are updated every single year. Adding one more field and adding one more field, particularly electronically, just to enter into a computer. I get it's going to take some work, but I think, again, in balance, having that information is critically important for us to deal with the number one crisis that our residents face, which is the cost of housing. So with that, would you like to close? I ask for your aye vote. Thank you all very much for your comments. Is there a second? I'll second it. Motion is due pass to appropriations. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barra-Kahan, Brian, Connolly? Aye. Connolly, aye. Dixon? Herbedian? Aye. Herbedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Papin, Sanchez, Stephanie, Zabur? Okay, we'll place that on call. Thank you. Thank you, members. Thank you. So we still have five bills left. Unfortunately, we've had very, very long delays without having senators here to present. So we're definitely going to go to the afternoon on some of those bills, unfortunately. For the second week in a row, for lack of having Senate authors, we're going to the afternoon on bills that we really shouldn't have to. So I implore senators, not just today, but next week, please show up present. We are all ready for your presentations. It's unfortunate that we're going to be further delayed today when I know folks have very busy agendas in the afternoon as well. It's unacceptable. We'll go ahead and do some add-ons right now, and we'll start with the consent calendar. For consent, Macedo. Aye. Macedo, aye. Barcahan, Brian, Dixon. Aye. Dixon, aye. Sanchez. Item 1, SC 46, Umberg. Macedo? No. Macedo, no. Barcahan, Brian, Dixon? No. Dixon, no. Sanchez. Add-on for item 2, SB 873, Reyes. Macedo? No. Macedo, no. Barcahan, Brian, Dixon? No. Dixon, no. Sanchez. Add for item 4 SB 989 Blakespeare Macedo Aye Macedo aye Barrakehan Brian Dixon No Dixon no Which one we're doing? Blake Spear? Yes. Dixon, aye. Aye. Sanchez? Item add-ons for item 5, SB 998, Gonzalez. Macedo? No. Macedo, no. Barrakehan, Brian, Dixon? No. Dixon, no. Sanchez. Add-ons for item 6, SB 1078, Laird. Macedo? No. Macedo, no. Barrakehan, Brian, Dixon? No. Dixon, no. Sanchez. Item 8, 1146, Gonzalez, add-ons. Macedo? Aye. Macedo, aye. Barrakehan, Brian, Dixon? Aye. Dixon, aye. Sanchez. Move the call on item 9, SB 1160, Durazo. Macedo? No. Macedo, no. Barrakehan, Brian, Papin, Sanchez, Stephanie Zuber. I'll place that back on call. Add-ons for item 10, SB 1164, Cervantes. Macedo. Macedo, no. Bauer-Cahan, Brian, Dixon. Dixon, no. Sanchez. Add-ons for item 13, SB 1256, Jones. Macedo. Aye. Macedo, aye. Bauer-Cahan, Brian, Sanchez. Item 14, SB 1267, Allen, add-ons. Macedo. I'm not voting. Actually, aye. Macedo, aye. Barcahan Brian Dixon Dixon I Sanchez add on so item 16 SP 1425 Cortese Macedo Macedo no Barcahan Brian Dixon Dixon no Sanchez Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. If we don't have a Senator here in five minutes, we're going to recess for the afternoon. People have work to do. All right, here we go. Good. Do you save the rest of the Senators? Item 11. Item 11, SB 1194, Senator Caballero. Whenever you're ready.

Good morning, Mr. Chair and members. Thank you for the opportunity to present SB 1194. This bill will codify the Immigration Legal Fellowship project, which has proven to be a successful model to expand access immigration legal services in some of the most underserved regions of the state. The fellowship began as a pilot project in 2019 in response to the federal administration as it pursued repressive immigration enforcement, creating fear and confusion for many immigrant families and children across California. While access to immigration counsel and legal services has been limited, the environment created under the federal administration magnified the severity of the issue and demonstrated the clear need for trusted legal services and community-based support to assist individuals navigating the complex immigration processes. The fellowship was designed to increase the number of qualified immigration attorneys who could defend California residents. The first fellowship cohort was deployed in 2021, and the program has not only created a sustainable immigration attorney pipeline to areas hardest hit by the federal administration's raids, but has also strengthened trust in public institution and ensured individuals receive accurate legal representation during some of the most critical moments of their lives. The fellowship has provided legal representation services to nearly 2,500 individuals across 39 counties. Local organizations who have hosted fellows have gained the requisite experience required in order to be eligible to apply for state legal services funding and are in a better position to leverage philanthropic support. The One California funds that we put into operation went to communities that already had established legal services, legal immigration services. So the value of this fellowship was that it created a pipeline to be able to send resources so people could see an attorney. In my region of the state, both when I was in the Assembly and now in the Senate, we had no operating entities. And so what would happen is people would come in and do a know your legal rights series. But knowing your legal rights series doesn't mean you know how to defend yourself in court. And so these attorneys have been critically important. So with that, SB 1194 builds on a successful model. And with me to testify today is Jackie Gonzalez, co-executive director of immigrant defense advocacy. Thank you.

Kyle Nelsonwitness

Good morning, Chair and members. One of the most pressing questions before our state over the last year is how best to navigate the uncertainty and harm caused by federal immigration policies. And while the intensity has certainly increased, these problems and challenges are not new. I would go so far as to say they transcend federal administration policies under both administrations. Seven years ago, under the first Trump administration, I stood before this legislature and pitched this fellowship. It is near and dear to my heart as a former practicing deportation defense attorney. I still remember how far people would travel from other parts of the state to talk to me. Five hours, three hours, and they did that to make sure that the advice that they were getting was reputable, honest, and they would have a fair assessment of their case. For some of those people, they were lucky enough to obtain pro bono representation. As you have seen over the last year, immigrants remain vulnerable to arbitrary arrests, inhumane detention. And all of this without due process. Immigration law is one of the most complex areas of the law In fact lawyers joke that after tax law it one of the most complicated areas Even I refuse to give legal advice to anyone no longer practicing because the law changes every day. The need, as the senator mentioned, is especially urgent in rural and underserved parts of our state. Seven years ago, when we advocated for this fellowship, we provided data to this legislature that showed that the highest rates of enforcement in this state were exactly in the Central Coast and the Central Valley. This was not by mistake. It is by design. We need durable capacity, trained providers, and a pipeline of expertise to these areas that have been historically left behind. That's what this fellowship has begun to do. Today, when an individual or family needs representation or there is an unexpected raid in a community, we are far better prepared than we were seven years ago. These are the kinds of investments that the state should be making, not just to stabilize individuals, but families and entire economies. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1194?

Benjamin Hendersonwitness

Good morning, chair and members. My name is Abraham Bedoy. I'm the California Policy and Government Affairs Manager with the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, proud support of SB 1194. We are also participants in the current iteration of the fellowship program. There's so much I could say, but I'm actually a native to the Central Valley. I currently live in Stanislaus County, Modesto, California, and I could tell you firsthand how transformative the fellowship has been to provide legal services to regions like my own, and we'll continue to hopefully do so through this program. So strong support, and let's make sure more legal services come to the community. Thank you.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. We'll treat that as a second witness. Jeanette Sanyfati on behalf of the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights, or CHIRLA, in strong support. Thank you. Zineit Yaya on behalf of ACLU CalAction, and strong support. Thank you. Diego Zamaio, Policy Intermittal Mesa Verde Group, on behalf of Central American Research Center, Caracin, strong support. Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 1194? Back to committee, any questions or comments? We have a motion, is there a second? A motion and a second. I want to thank you, Senator, for bringing this forward. I think those that choose to do these legal fellows that choose this work are truly angels in our legal system. And it also provides them of a pathway towards a very fulfilling career in using their law degree to really bring voice to those that are all too often voiceless. I'd like to close.

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I agree with you 100%. Having legal services in the community is transformational. It gives me a place to be able to send individuals that come in with some really serious issues and who have lived in this country for 25 years, have worked with citizen children, and I don't even try to give legal advice on it because it is so complicated. So I respectfully ask for your aye vote.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you, and I also would like to be on it as a co-author, if that's okay.

Yes.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Motions do pass to appropriations. Caller. Aye. Caller, aye. Macedo. No. Macedo, no. Barakahan. Brian. Connelly? Aye. Connelly, aye. Dixon? Dixon, no. Harabedian? Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Papin, Sanchez, Stephanie, Zabur. Okay, I'll place that on call. Thank you. Thank you very much. All right, item 3, SB 957, Senator Perez.

Brian Augustawitness

Thank you seeks their personal information through an administrative subpoena. This bill also ensures that users have 30 days to respond or challenge the subpoena, requires companies to disclose what information was shared, and establishes reporting requirements to the attorney general. Social media has become a critical tool for Californians to engage in activism, political expression, and information sharing. This is especially true now. Discussions around politics and government have been particularly prominent as communities across the state are responding to increased federal immigration enforcement. Community leaders and residents have organized to share updates about immigration enforcement activity, using social media platforms to track ICE presence, share alerts with their neighbors, and hold federal agencies accountable. Despite the federal and state constitutional right to freedom of speech, administrative subpoenas are being increasingly used by DHS to obtain information about individuals who operate accounts that post about or criticize ICE. These administrative subpoenas do not require judicial approval or probable cause, yet they can be used to obtain sensitive personal information like names, addresses, and phone numbers. We've already seen cases where individuals were targeted simply for expressing criticism of the federal government. For example, a New York Times article cites that in recent months, Google, Meta, Discord, and Reddit have received multiple subpoenas from DHS requesting identifying details of anonymous accounts that have spoken out against ICE or track the location of ICE agents. In another example, a man in Philadelphia was subpoenaed after sending an email to DHS criticizing their treatment of an asylum seeker. DHS agents and local police showed up to his home to interrogate him. The subpoena was challenged in federal court as a violation of the First Amendment, and the court ruled that subpoenas cannot be used to intimidate individuals who criticize federal agencies. While some social media companies have willingly provided notice to individuals, others have shared information without ever letting the user know their data was requested. The lack of transparency in these instances undermines trust, exposes individuals to potential retaliation, and discourages people from speaking out publicly. People should not be intimidated into silence out of fear that their personal information may be secretly shared to the federal government without their knowledge. SB 957 would protect user privacy and free speech by ensuring that Californians are notified and given a fair opportunity to challenge a subpoena before their information is disclosed. This bill is sponsored by the California Legislative LGBTQ Caucus and is supported by the ACLU California Action, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, Oakland Privacy, Public Council, and others. Today with me to provide testimony in support of this bill is Becca Kramer with Kaiser Advocacy on behalf of the Electronic Frontier Foundation Thank you Hello Becca Kramer with the Electronic Frontier Foundation in strong support

Marky Cedrowitness

In the past year, the Trump administration has consistently targeted people engaged in free speech. For example, ICE has issued administrative subpoenas to tech companies to unmask users tracking ICE activity, people who have criticized the government, and even those who have attended a protest. These ICE subpoenas are unlawful and the government knows it. Nearly every time a user has challenged one of these subpoenas in court in the past few months, ICE has withdrawn them. SB 957 offers very basic consumer protections. It requires social media companies to do two things that they should already be doing. First, companies must give their users prior notice of a subpoena. In order to challenge a lawless subpoena, users must first know about them. Many companies already promise to give this notice, but they don't always follow through. EFF's lawyers currently represent a Ph.D. student whose data was turned over to ICE because Google didn't give him the notice that he was promised. Second, SB957 requires companies to make sure that ICE subpoenas do not exceed the agency's authority and are not overly broad. Companies say that they already do this. For example, when EFF asked 10 tech companies to do more to protect their users from these subpoenas, one company replied, quote, We carefully review all legal process to ensure facial validity and legal sufficiency, and we will object when appropriate. While this statement is a good start, a mere promise from a tech company is no longer enough. We need enforceable laws, which is why EFF strongly supports SB 957.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 957?

Morgan-Larry Zabowitness

Hello again, Zenit Yaya on behalf of ACLU CalAction and Oakland Privacy in support.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 957?

Robert Boykinother

Good morning, Chair and members. My name is Robert Boykin with TechNet. Here today in respectful opposition to SB957, unless it is amended. To be clear from the start, our member companies understand the authors' intent behind this bill. Therefore, we are proposing targeted amendments to minimize conflicts with federal and state laws, set clear notice standards, and define workable obligations for assessing subpoena validity. First, link the duty to notify the company's confirmation that the subpoena is valid and that it plans to disclose information so notice is required only after an actual decision is made, not beforehand. As currently written, the bill might suggest that notice is needed before the company even decides whether the subpoena is valid or whether or not it will disclose anything. The obligation should only arise once the company confirms the subpoena validity and its intent to disclose. An allowance for court-ordered nondisclosure so the notice duties don't apply when a company is legally barred from disclosing a request. Let a court of competent jurisdictions set a different response window and replace it to fix 30 days when circumstance is warranted. Second, our amendments do remove, sorry, submitted amendments do remove Section 1509. However, we are open to a conversation around a clear exclusion so that when a company has a good faith belief that disclosure is needed to prevent imminent harm, it can act without the 30-day notice. Companies are most concerned with the addition of Section 1509 because most administrative subpoenas we received from DHS under that section involve child exploitation cases. And a 30-day tip-off in those cases puts a child at greater risk. Third, align the bill with California's existing Cal ECPA framework rather than establishing a separate parallel regimen that applies only to certain companies. The bill authorizes enforcement by both AG and private individuals, but does not clearly define the scope of liability or the standards for compliance. This creates the uncertainty for regulated entities and increases litigation risk, particularly when companies must make complex legal determinations of adequate guidance. And fourth, give companies a single workable validity standard rather than ones they must apply under threat of liability. The bill asks companies to evaluate three separate undefined standards, procedurally improper, irrelevant or immaterial, and two indefinite or abroad with no statutory guidance and liability for getting it wrong. We ask to remove those three and keep the clearest, most administratable one, whether the request was related to lawful authorized purpose. We included the specific statutory language in our letter for each of these, and we're committed to working with the author of this committee and the stakeholders moving forward to address these concerns. Thank you for your time today.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone else here in opposition to SB 957? Bring it back to the committee. Any questions or comments? Assemblymember Pacheco? Thank you. To the author, it seems like some amendments were already taken to address some of the concerns.

Brian Augustawitness

So I'm hoping more conversations can be held.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

It seems like the opposition is an opposed unless amended. So there's a pathway of perfecting this bill. Just wondering, you've had conversations with the opposition, right?

Brian Augustawitness

Yeah, so the opposition approached my office last minute. And so we reached out very early on to see if they had any feedback. And so there have been conversations with my staff. My staff actually proposed a solution. I want to be very clear. Section 1509 of the Tariff Act of 1930 is a customs enforcement statute that was specifically designed for investigating duty payments on imported goods to catch smugglers. So I understand what he's raising around the child exploitation cases, but this goes beyond that. So we provided a solution. We didn't receive feedback in terms of what we were suggesting. And so I'm happy to have those discussions, but we need to continue talking.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

And thank you. Thank you for that. I am, of course, supporting your bill today, but I would like to see more conversations had. And I'll reserve my vote when it gets to the floor, but I'm sure I will be supporting it as well because I'm sure you will get to a good place. So thank you again for bringing this bill forward. Thank you. Do we have a motion? The motion is there a second a motion in a second. Thank you senator as well for bringing this forward Would you like to close?

Brian Augustawitness

Respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Motions do pass to appropriations cholera. I call right I Macedo Macedo no back a hand Brian Connelly Connelly I Dixon Dixon no hair median Pacheco Pacheco I happen Sanchez Stephanie's the burr the burr All right, I'll place that on call. Thank you. And we have item 7, SB 1103 as well. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members. I appreciate the work and effort of this committee staff in working with my office to work through amendments to address opposition reflected on pages 6 and 10 of the analysis. The amendments will do the following. Extend the amount of time that retailers have to submit documentation to the AG after being subpoenaed from 72 hours to 14 calendar days. Incorporate a sunset date for January 1 2030 SB 1103 the Repair Act requires large home improvement retailers doing business in California to publicly report immigration enforcement activity occurring on their premises and to provide the Attorney General with copies of any documentation gathered in the normal course of business within 14 calendar days of receipt of an administrative subpoena. This bill will also require retailers to publicly disclose their policies on employee interactions with immigration authorities and whether they directly or indirectly share surveillance data with federal immigration agencies. Every morning across California, day laborers gather in the parking lots of large home improvement retailers, which have long served as informal hiring sites for workers seeking jobs from homeowners and contractors in need of labor. Recently, we have witnessed these same locations increasingly become targets for immigration enforcement activity. Authorities carrying out these raids have utilized deceptive and legally questionable tactics during raids, including showing up masked, driving unmarked vehicles, utilizing military-style equipment, and otherwise racially profiling a predominantly Latino workforce. These dangerous practices have spread fear, chaos, and harm among workers, shoppers, and surrounding communities. Individuals who are simply seeking honest work and otherwise abiding by the law are being kidnapped in broad daylight. In many cases, they are seriously injured, and in some instances, they have lost their lives. This is an issue that has deeply impacted my district. In 2025, Carlos Roberto Montoya Valdez was seeking work in the parking lot of a Home Depot in Monrovia when an immigration enforcement raid occurred. He was chased and fled onto a nearby freeway where he was struck by a vehicle and later died from his injuries. Despite lives lost and communities terrorized, there has been no accountability taken for the actions that continue to occur on the premises of these companies. Even when there have been efforts to enforce basic constitutional protections, these orders have been ignored with little consequence. In April of this year, a federal judge of the Eastern District of California ruled that agents again violated a court order by continuing to detain individuals without reasonable suspicion of any law violations, relying instead on generalized assumptions about day laborers. We cannot allow these assaults to take more lives and continue to spread fear in our communities. As these actions have continued, there is little to no information available for the appropriate parties to pursue legal action against the aggressive and borderline delinquent behavior directed at largely innocent people. This includes information about when these enforcement actions occur, how they are conducted, or whether surveillance data collected on these premises is being shared with federal agencies. That lack of transparency creates fear, spreads misinformation, and undermines public safety for workers, businesses, and communities across the state, especially as efforts to curb these attacks have stalled. SB 1103 is a transparency and accountability measure to address that gap. Now, I want to note that my office has engaged in ongoing conversations with stakeholders and opposition. We are open to working collaboratively to address concerns. We've also accepted several amendments as well. Joining me to provide testimony today in support of this bill is Salvador Sarmiento staff attorney and campaign director for the National Day Labor Organizing Network or Endalon and Mr Pedro Giovanni Rossell, a volunteer from a local Adopt-A-Corner group in Pasadena. Thank you. Good morning. My name is Giovanni Rossell. I'm here with Endalon and as a member of Grupo Alto Defensa Pasadena, my local rapid response network. I volunteer at the Home Depot in Pasadena alongside countless members of the community. The work that volunteers do at Home Depot is centered around keeping the day laborers and our other neighbors safe from the ongoing unconstitutional immigration raids. This work entails canvassing large retailers that have been the hotspots for these raids to get information about whether or not people were taken, who was taken, and how many people were taken. The aim of these raids is ultimately to instill a sense of fear and chaos in our community. Since the first wave of raids, there has been a growing anxiety that day laborers, customers, and volunteers feel related to retailers like Home Depot. Present with us today is a family who tragically lost their home in the Eaton Fire. As they go through the process of trying to rebuild their home and restore the sense of home that they once had, they're confronted with the fear of going to Home Depot and other retailers in order to buy material, tools, and hire laborers. Jose and Maria's story are indicative of the compounding impacts that Home Depot's uncooperative inaction have. To close, I'm part of a group of neighbors that's been showing up for our other neighbors. We're volunteers and we're doing what we can. Day laborers are doing what they can, and we need these companies to do better, and we're calling on this body to act in order to make that happen. Thank you. Thank you. In the mic? Yes. Sorry. Sorry, you get the back. Sorry, you get the front. So my name is Salvador Sarmiento, staff attorney and national campaign legislative director for the National Day Labor Organizing Network. I'm going to make two points and I'll be brief. First, it's important to clarify that this didn't come out of the blue. This is very much a response to what we've been seeing for a year and a half. We've all been appalled by the arrests, the abuses. It's not just the rhetoric, but the directives of the fanatical Stephen Miller, etc. About six months ago, our legal team with the facilitation of the mayor of Los Angeles, Bass, met with vice presidents of Home Depot and members of the general counsel to ask minimal information to show good faith about where raids have, if they could confirm where some of the raids had happened. Their response was that they could not confirm that raids have taken place on their stores. So this is very much a response to the inaction of some of these major stores. Like our friend from Pasadena said, folks are doing what they can. The cities are doing what they can. Volunteers, neighbors are doing what they can. We need Home Depot to do better. As the Senator mentioned, we've tried to be very flexible because we need these stores to do something, right? Everybody's doing the best we can in this crazy time that we live. We need these stores to do something. And we think this legislation is something modest. It's something concrete. And given the moment that we're in, it's something that will move the ball forward. Given the moment we're in, again, what we're asking for is very, very specific and modest. We're asking for these stores to share with the community what it is that they already know. And we've tried to be flexible. We've provided a lot of clarifications, amendments in Senate Judiciary where we're amending, again, but for this committee to make clear that there no additional duties for the employees They don need to interact with federal enforcement This is already information that these stores already have We just asking them to share it with the public with the community. So I think it's a question of public safety and trust in the community. These are our local home-informed stores. Thank you so much. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1103? Hi, committee. My name is Fatima Garcia. I'm here with the Sembrando Semillas Day Labor Workers Center here in Sacramento and we are in full support and we hope that you support us today. Thank you. Hi. Hi, good morning. My name is Maria Rivera. I am here to support the law. Thank you. Hello, my name is Jose Rivera. I'm from Altadena and I'm here to support the bill. Thank you. Hi, my name is Ricardo Milo. I support Pasadena. I support this bill. Thank you. Hello, my name is Jose Madera, director of the Pasadena Community Job Center, also part of the DINA Rise Up Coalition, and I support this bill. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Chair, members, Sarah Flux, California Federation of Labor Unions, in support. Thank you. Zinit Yaya, on behalf of ACLU CalAction, in support. Thank you. Jeanette Sanipatine on behalf of the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights, or CHIRLA, in strong support. Thank you. Negoza Mayor, intern with Mesa Verde Group, here on behalf of CARESEN and Inclusive Action for the City, in support. Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB1103? Good afternoon, I think. I think it's just noon right now. Ryan Elaine, on behalf of the California Retailers Association and respectful opposition to SB 1103. I want to mention my colleague with the chamber would be here today as well, but he's sick, so he's giving a me too in his absence. First, I'd like to recognize the profound negative impact that immigration enforcement activities have had on employees, customers, and our communities. And I got to say the example given by the senator regarding Carlos Roberto Montoya Valdez is absolutely gut-wrenching. And my sympathy goes out to all those impacted. CRA opposes SB 1103 for a few reasons. First, principally, we oppose statewide public policy effectively directed at two companies. We believe this bill places two retailers in the middle of state and federal government fights to surveil the federal government's activities and maintain a daily log on their websites of immigration enforcement. We appreciate the committee's analysis recommending that the online daily log be removed from the retailer's website and moved under the AG's authority and website. Additionally, we appreciate the amendments to place the sunset on this bill and extend the time to comply with the administrative subpoena from 72 hours to 14 days. Um, we further believe it will be difficult for retailers to determine when an immigration enforcement activity occurs as they're often dressed in plain clothes. Uh, also the definition of premises is expansive to include the adjacent walkways, uh, not on the retailer's property. This causes compliance issues outside the retailer's control. Uh, we appreciate the Senator and the committee's work, uh, on this to get this bill, uh, moving in more positive direction, but, um, the California retailers association must remain in opposition. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in opposition to SB 1103? Good afternoon. Mr. Chair, members, Skyler Wanaka on behalf of the California Business Properties Association in respectful opposition. Thank you. I'm bringing it back to committee. Any questions or comments? My advice, Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank you for bringing this forward, and I'm so sorry for everything that you guys have experienced. I do share some of the concerns of retailers that I'm hoping you can clarify for me. So as it stands right now, there has to be a link on the retailer's website. But I mean, this being California law, these are national retailers. So are you expecting this to be on their national website? Because there's not like a California-specific one or, you know, my Tulare Home Depot doesn't have its own website. This bill is California-specific, so it would apply only to Home Depots that are located here in the state, so nowhere across the nation. But it would have to be on the national company's website. Yes. I mean, the goal would be basically to indicate whether or not a raid has occurred at a Home Depot and the location of that Home Depot. And so that's part of the discussion that we've been having. And I think part of what the sponsors really want to see here is transparency with that data. So when these activities are occurring on the premises of a Home Depot or another location, that that information is being made public. It's really critical, especially as folks search for their family members. But, yes, that is how we would envision this operating and that it would be, for example, the Home Depot in Tulare, that it would list that Home Depot in Tulare, and it would say whether or not a raid has occurred in that location. And I don't know if my sponsors want to speak at all, too. Well, I mean, I would just think that maybe a California-specific website that people can reference would be more appropriate for something like this to put where they are happening. I just struggle with a California-specific immigration policy affecting a national homepage. And then to add on to that, how long do they have to keep it on this website? When can they bring that down? Because I know there's a sunset, but I don't believe the sunset applies to these postings. Or are they supposed to leave them on until 2030? I think the sunset applies to the entire bill. So it would sunset, I believe we said it is a 20, 20, 29. So that's when that information would come down. So, and, you know, while I can appreciate this concern, and if I was a member of Congress, we would be doing this federally and I'd be introducing legislation. And, you know, our stores here operating in California have to navigate our different laws that we have here in the state versus other states all the time. So I think that there's a way that we could figure that out. And I know the retailers are we have different laws across various states. So but the link would stay up then until 2029. So if something happened tomorrow at Tulare Home Depot, God, please know. But then it would have to stay all the way until 2029 under this current bill is what you're saying. I think one of the things that I think we've been really, really open with the opposition and the Senate has gone more so than out of her way to we're really open. And so if there's really if there's, you know, where we took amendments and Senate Judiciary, we're taking amendments here because if there's, you know, right now everything will sunset at the sunset date. But, you know, if there's concrete, specific ways that we can make it better, we are more than willing. Our position is like, we need these stores to do something. Just sharing what information they have would be a big game changer for the neighborhoods around these stores. And so if there was concrete specific ways that we can make it better for example if that impractical that something super specific And for example we trying to address some of the things that were brought up for this committee The next committee hearing is privacy, right? And so that I was, you know, that there's a lot of questions related to the website that we know are going to come up for privacy. And that's, you know, that's a really specific one that could as well. Well, I'm vice chair of privacy as well. So I guess we can discuss it there a little bit more. But from the retailer's point of view, I mean, is it even feasible to put it on a national website? I mean, leaving that kind of information up. I did go to Home Depot's website, and I see that they do have a tab about immigration-related questions and answering the questions about the parking lots and things like that. But from the retailer's perspective, I mean, is there a way to make this better, I guess? Yeah, and I appreciate the question and kind of appreciate the goal of what this bill is intending for. I think a lot of the websites, when you go to the retailer's websites, it'll have the national page and then the individual store for products. And so I think our members are kind of trying to see where would we put that in the store or the page for the products. And then how is that going to be, kind of like figuring that out. That's why I think we appreciate the recommendation of putting it, moving that kind of towards the AG side. because he already collects that data, collects that information, and having it in his realm as like one single space. Based on the data that would be given via an administrative subpoena to them, I think that would probably be – we would recognize that as a better place for that to be. Okay. Well, I look forward to that ongoing conversation. And then my next question is you had mentioned, you know, sometimes these people are in plain clothes, so it's kind of hard to decipher. And when the bill says to report immigration enforcement activity, but that kind of depends on knowing which agency is involved in the purpose of the enforcement action. So for an employee, I think it's a very difficult thing to decide or to verify who they are. So, like, in this, I mean, the question goes to the retailer specifically. If this goes in as implemented, would you guys expect employees to go and approach these maybe, maybe not law enforcement officers? Yeah, that's a concern that our members have said to us in the definition of immigration enforcement activity and what that means. in order to comply with the administrative subpoena, should it say, let us know what immigration enforcement activities happen, for us to confirm that, it's going to be hard for us to do it via video surveillance. We might not know if it's an undercover operation from a state agency. It could be a sting operation or some other thing. Just on the video alone, and I know there were strides made to protect employees in this space, but just still how it is in order to comply with it and not give the wrong information, because if we give information that may not be an immigration enforcement activity, that could cause unnecessary fear in the community as well. So that's something in order to verify it, they're saying that we may have to have employees see and go look to see who is actually providing this raid. And I do just want to mention, I know that that was a concern raised early on by the opposition. I've sat down and I've had conversations directly with Home Depot as well. I want to make very clear there is no desire, no way, shape, or form that I would want for employees of big box stores to be having interactions with whether it's ICE, DHS, CBP. You know, that is not at all something that we're seeking in this bill. This is about the data that they collecting through flock camera systems that have been installed at many of these locations in order to address shoplifting and to also use video evidence when they are able to verify that there is immigration enforcement activity happening I recognize and we talked about this as well, that it is hard to discern in some cases whether or not something is immigration enforcement activity or not. And so there is going to be some discretion that they're going to have to exercise in determining whether or not to share that information. And I think the sponsors recognize that as well. There's just a desire here to create some transparency with what is happening at these locations and for us to begin collecting data. But we've tried to make very clear in addition through the amendments that we do not want employees having those types of interactions at all. Yeah, I totally agree with that. I just, from an employee safety standpoint, and even from, you know, making sure they feel comfortable in the workplace, trying to figure out how we can avoid that interaction completely for employees. And then my final concern was also with the premises issue that you had mentioned of, you know, including parking lots, public walkways, and things like that, that I just don't think it's the employee's responsibility to be, you know, sidewalk monitors or parking lot monitors. And at the end of the day, I also on the Home Depot website, it does explain it being a public area. So is there, you know, I'd love to hear from you guys what your solution would be as far as how you can achieve what the senator is wanting to do, but also understanding those are public areas and not sending out people into unsafe areas like parking lots or public sidewalks. Yeah, I think the premises definition, as mentioned, the adjacent sidewalks and the parking lots, and I think a part of it, interpreting it as where does the parking lot, and if it's a big shopping center or a big mall, how far does that extend? I know my folks, some of the folks that have talked to, like the property owners as well that own these, they're kind of like, well, those aren't your cameras that are over there. They might be on the other side of a parking lot. I think there could possibly be ways to narrow it down to specifically, I got to actually talk to my members on that because that's just something they look at like, we don't really quite know how to comply. But I know they're having conversations, we're having conversations with the senator to see how that can be workable. And maybe like setting a radius from the front door or something like that? Because a lot of these are in large shopping centers that how do you hold somebody accountable if they don't have access to the cameras and things like that? Do you have any solutions to that? Yeah. I mean, the data we're referring to in my bill is data that is owned by these big box stores. So it's through their cameras. We're not seeking for them to tap into any other cameras or devices that are outside of their ownership. In addition to that, and I think all of us have seen this now because we've seen so many of these rates occur either online or on television and seen videos of them. Most of them do occur in public parking lots. Parking lots are considered public spaces. That's why immigration enforcement rates happen there. That's why they have the legal right to do so. But for many of these parking lots, there are cameras installed for loss prevention. There is a flock data cameras that are installed to collect in case somebody steals an item, they try to get away. And so that's information that we're trying to tap into. Okay. I think that there's workable things to make this bill better. I can't support today, but I do appreciate you all being here today. And to the people in the audience that came, thank you for being here as well. Senator Zabert. So first, I want to thank you for bringing the bill. It has righteous goals, obviously. I remember I remember at one point, you know, when all of this ICE enforcement activity was happening in my district it was happening almost every week in the you know at the Home Depot in my district almost every week I will tell you though that also at that time we were getting a lot of co-op my district staff was out there we were getting a lot of cooperation from the store management they were giving us information they were cooperating with us they didn't like this happening in the in their parking lots I mean they you know they're sort of being put out of crosshairs and so I think the you know I'm still gonna support the bill today because obviously I know that the goals are good, but I really would encourage you to continue working with the retailers. I met with both Home Depots and Lowe's on this issue a number of months back, and I think a lot of what they were concerned about was two things. One is having to comply in ways where they just didn't have the ability to do it without putting their own employees in harm's way, going out and what's happening in these, as you all know. I mean, you know, I, you know, the reason why you're bringing this is righteous. I mean, you had like thugs that are coming into these parking lots. It's often you don't even know who they are. They're coming in in vans with vests without any uniforms, with guns, putting people in vans. And the last thing that the retailer wants is to have to go send their employees out there and figure out what, you know, what's happening. So, I ask you to continue working with the retailers to really try to deal with these sort of implementation issues. I'm making sure and I know you don't really want to put employees in harm's way, but making sure that it's very clear that what is being reported is what they have access to. That it's their own cameras, that it's not, you know, outside the boundaries of the store dealing with the shared parking lot issues. And then I also think the I went through after I met with the with the retailers, I went to actually went on to one of the websites and I was trying. It's a national website. So I was trying to figure out how you actually report these daily logs and how they would even do that in some kind of timely way. So I do think that's a real issue. I do think that potentially providing that information to the attorney general and having the attorney general put that on a website is probably a better approach. So I'd ask you to consider doing that. You know, I think ultimately, you know, we do want, and I guess the last issue is about sort of the targeting of two entities. Um, the reality is ice agents are on these parking lots more than they are other piece. So I think we can't ignore that fact, but they're also doing this to other things too. I mean, we were having raids in car washes in my district. So, um, you know, I, I would sort of think carefully about the scope of the bill as well. Um, and, um, you know, just want to thank all of you and, and, and the retailers for trying to come to a place where we're providing good information. I think that ultimately what we want to do is make sure that as much information as it can be provided is being given to the attorney general and potentially DAs. We also want to know when things are happening on parking lots that are not ICE enforcement. If people are coming in on a parking lot that's not ICE enforcement, obviously that's something that, you know, the public needs to know, you know. So anyway, I'm supporting the bill today. Just wanna thank you and encourage you to continue working with the opponents of the bill, because I do think some of the issues they're raising are legitimate ones. Senator Dixon. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just listening to the discussion about this, I would like to think we could look at the root cause The people who ICE is going, interacting with, and you talk about the day laborers, so you represent day laborers. I mean, they're not going to be working for Lowe's or Home Depot, correct? They're looking for people driving by to give them a job, or what is the purpose of them aggregating, congregating on public or private? Some parking lots are private and privately owned. And so can they avoid putting themselves at risk? Or if you're representing them, I just see your organization is the National Day Laborers Organizing Network. Great. Providing leadership to people. They're looking for jobs. I think that's important. But to be on private property or public rights of way and putting themselves at risk, as well as employees of these retailers, to me, is unwise. And then the people, I mean, the real targets, these retailers are being targeted to do this additional compliance proposal when they're not even hiring these people. It's their customers, perhaps, who are hiring these people who are congregating on street corners, who are looking for lower-wage people to work, sadly. I mean, that's really the target. That's the root cause that somebody is driving that demand for those workers. If you have a place where you're organized, that's where people should congregate and not put themselves at risk. I think it's bad for the employees of the retailers. It's bad for the day laborers themselves that they're setting themselves up as easy targets. Don't be in a major retailer and find ways that you could find opportunities maybe to help them get a work permit. Ultimately, you're organized. Help them get a work permit. Help them go through a process so they don't put themselves at risk. But to put the burden because they're there, help them be successful in getting work that's perhaps through a work permit. I mean, that's a complicated, long process. I get that. But why put the burden on the retailers when people are looking for work? And maybe there's a way to help go through a process that keeps them safe. Employees safe, private property safe, and the people who are looking for work safe. And I don't even know if they are illegal or undocumented. Maybe they're just workers and they have work permits. So help them be safe. That's, I guess, my position on the bill. Thank you. Thank you. Can I? Yeah, very, very quickly. Yeah, I appreciate the earnest question. I mean, that question goes back, as long as there's been home improvement stores and contractors and homeowners that go to home improvement stores, there's been day laborers. There's plaques in New York and West Massachusetts of the Jewish day labor centers, the Italian day laborers, right? As long as there's folks on that end, the low income end of our economy, It's an ecosystem of contractors. The day laborers themselves are also Home Depot customers. They wouldn't be going. Folks don't go to Home Depot because it's their first choice of job searches. They're going because there's a market there. And a lot of homeowners, they themselves are customers of Home Depot. And also a lot of homeowners, contractors that are Home Depot's huge customer base, also a huge segment of the construction industry is subsidized by day laborers across the country as well. But what you're pointing to is real. There a solution there somewhere long term complicated but I appreciate what you trying to do Any other questions or comments I will just say a couple things One is it not asking any of these retailers to do anything more than what they do in the ordinary course of business If you don have a camera in a certain area you don have to have patrols walking around to see what's going on. So let's make it very clear that this is just asking if you happen to have that information, provide it. And look, we have rapid response networks that are up of volunteers that are very basically trained that can identify very quickly if someone is ICE or not. They post up. If there's concerns in the community, it's literally online within an hour, oh, that wasn't ICE. That was a retail theft response or that was a drug operation. These are highly sophisticated stores that have highly sophisticated surveillance protocols to respond to retail theft. I worked at Orchard's Buy Hardware back in the 1980s. Everything is is meticulously recorded, everything is documented by managers, any law enforcement that shows up for any reason to suggest that somehow like, oh, yeah, we're just going to not pay attention to what's happening on our property or in front of our premises is just not what's happening in reality. These stores have very sophisticated protocols on how they record things and how they document things. So to suggest that somehow there's law enforcement activity of any kind on their premises and they have no idea about it is just not reality. What this bill is asking is if you have that information, hand that over. If you have it on your cameras, hand it over, not if someone across the street has it. It's quite simple in that sense. And I get the idea of putting on the AG site, but the reality is not everyone's going to go to the AG site. Like, you know, when you go to your Home Depot or Lowe's site, as I just did a moment ago, it tells you the closest location. They know which ones are in California. And I get this. Some of the immigrant enforcement organizations may know to go to the AG site, but not everyone that is curious or wants to know if there's activity at that particular Home Depot or Lowe's is going to know to do that. That's why the most accessible and common sense place is for these to be on the websites of those particular stores or corporations. And they know that they're highly sophisticated. They'll be able to put a link or some information based upon what store you're looking up because it's closest to you. that's where you're going to pick up your product or go to to buy something is something that absolutely can be done. And I would just end by saying that you can't have it both ways. For many, many, many years, all of us have had the experience of going to these stores, and we've spent many billions of dollars over many, many years at these very profitable stores going there. And we all know that there are day laborers there. These stores have had no problem with that because ultimately it's an amenity that they're offering. They may not be their employees, but the fact that people know that not only can you get your hardware products from these stores, but you can also get someone that's a day laborer there. They've never charged them for loitering or trespassing. Why? Because it's an attraction for people coming, not only looking for supplies, but looking for workers to help get their jobs done. So let's be very clear that that's the reason why there are day laborers at these sites, and to distinguish from, and I agree there are issues of car washing the places, is that this is a place that specifically attracts folks to be hired by third parties. And they have highly sophisticated surveillance systems for anti-theft that are already in place where they're going to capture a lot of information that is being asked for through this bill. So I would just ask that these retailers understand that you can't have it both ways. You can ask our immigrant community some of which were undocumented to offer an amenity to your customers and then turn a blind eye when they being targeted harassed and arrested by the federal government I would like to be at it as a co-author. Would you like to close? Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I really appreciate your comments and everything you just shared. I don't think I could have said it better myself. And I just also want to thank the assembly members, Assemblymember Macedo Dixon and Chavez Zipper for their questions and their comments, too. We are facing an unusual moment in this country and in this moment in history. And it's requiring us to think creatively about how we respond and make sure that we're not just keeping our immigrant community safe, but that we're keeping members of the public safe. And these questions about data, about transparency, about how our information is being used are all very real. And so that is what we are working to address with this bill. And we will continue to work with the opposition and respectfully ask your aye vote. Thank you, Senator. And for the record, the amendments being accepted are the 14 days to respond to the subpoena and the sunset. Those are the only amendments that we're asking that are being accepted today. And we do need a motion. I'll second. Motion is due pass as amended. Motion is due pass as amended to privacy and consumer protection. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo? No. Macedo, no. Barak-Hahan, Brian, Connolly? Aye. Connolly, aye. Dixon? No. Dixon, no. Harabedian, Pacheco? Not voting. Papin, Sanchez, Stephanie, Zabur. All right. We'll place that on call. And we'll return. We'll adjourn until 1.30 p.m. Room 447. We have a special item of business, and we have one other bill that we'd have two other bills to hear. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. All right, we're going to reconvene, you know, semi judiciary committee. And we have an item, a special order of business for SB 623, Umberg and Papen. And we do have chair Umberg here with us. And it looks like we have witnesses here with us as well. So whenever you're ready, you may begin, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair and member. I'm here to present SB 623, which is authored by myself and Assembly member Papin. First, due to the hard and good work of the various stakeholders, they reached a compromise, which is a fair compromise, a compromise that creates a system that's safe, fair, accountable by protecting patients from unnecessary treatment or getting overcharged, ensuring access to medical care and legal representation, and strengthens rideshare safety measures. Just to briefly summarize what the compromise does, what the bill does, it provides that for accidents occurring after January 1, 2027, if a plaintiff receives treatment from a lien-based medical provider, the plaintiff generally cannot recover more than 70, more than the 70th percentile as shown in the Fair Health database, that particular service in that geographic area. Charges above this amount cannot be collected. The court, however, can approve a higher amount if the plaintiff approves by clear and convincing evidence that the treatment was exceptionally rare or highly specialized, and there's no comparable provider or service available. Requires standardized itemization of all lien-based medical bills. The lien-based care provider sells their lien to a third party. The maximum amount the third party can recover is the consideration paid by the third party to the lien-based provider for the assignment. Makes it unlawful for an attorney representing a person under a contingency fee agreement to refer the client to a health care provider in which an attorney or family member has a direct ownership interest. Makes it unlawful for an attorney to receive kickback or a fee split for referring a client to a lien-based provider or provide bonuses or other remuneration for referring a client to a lien-based provider. Prohibits attorneys from charging an additional contingency fee, administrative fee, management fee, or other fee based on reducing or resolving a client's medical lien. Also, provides for several reforms in the rideshare industry in order to protect passengers and create greater accountability. It requires an initial background check before activating a rideshare driver and annual background checks thereafter. It adds additional crimes like violating a restraining order and child abuse to a list of crimes that disqualifies a potential rideshare driver. And also, importantly, expressly allows women drivers to request women passengers and women passengers to request women drivers only. With me here to testify are several witnesses, Ms. Ramona Prieto, as well as Captain Doug Seltzer, formerly of the 82nd Airborne, now coincidentally President of the California Association of Consumer Attorneys. Thank you. Thank you. expands background checks and requires annuals re-screening for drivers. Second, when someone is injured in a crash, they often require emergency or specialized care. Providers often treat these patients without requiring payment upfront recovering later from any settlement or judgment That is called medical lien That access to care matters especially for people who can pay out of pocket At times however those lien bills come in far above the ordinary cost of the same care, and it's the injured person who pays. The fact those bills are now being sold on a secondary market makes the problem worse. Private equity and hedge funds buy them at a steep discount and turn around and collect the full inflated amount. That's money flowing to Wall Street investors, not patients. SB 623 stops that. It anchors lean recovery to fair health and independent nationally trusted database of what providers charge. This bill caps recovery at 70th percentile, a ceiling that sits high enough so these vulnerable patients keep their access to care. And no patient can ever be held personally liable for amounts above what is allowed in court. We appreciate the opportunity to bring this bill forward on an expedited basis. Respectfully ask your support, and we wouldn't be here without my fellow here, Leanne Tratton. Thank you. Thank you. Let me add to my testimony. I may have misspoken. Scott Jalowick is the primary witness with support from Ms. Ramona Prieto and also for technical support, Ms. Leanne Tratton. Thank you. Thank you. Yes. Thank you for that clarification and thank you everybody for your time this afternoon. I realize this has come together rather quickly and we are very grateful to have the opportunity to talk today. My name is Ramona Prieto and I lead the public policy team at Uber and I am joined by my colleague Scott Jalwick who leads complex litigation for the company. And I'm here today in support of SB 623. Namely, it addresses a problem that has grown increasingly common in the medical lien space. While medical liens can help facilitate treatment following an accident, the current system can also produce charges that bear little relationship to what is typically billed for the same care. When that happens, injured people ultimately bear the cost of a system that lacks consistent standards and transparency. SB 623 establishes an objective benchmark for lien-based medical charges using Fair Health, a nationally recognized and independent database that reflects what providers actually charge for similar services. The bill creates a clear and predictable standard while preserving flexibility for extraordinary circumstances. The bill further addresses the growing practice of selling and financing medical liens by tying recoverable amounts to the actual economics of the transaction and requiring disclosure of lien transfers. SB 623 helps ensure that financial arrangements are transparent and that more of an injured person's recovery remains with them. In addition, SB 623 contains important ethics provisions that prohibit conflicts of interest and undisclosed financial relationships in connection with lien-based treatment. Finally, the bill includes meaningful safety investments for drivers and riders. It deepens background checks and provides clear statutory authorization for women, riders, and drivers, as mentioned earlier by Senator Umberg. This balance reform measures focused on transparency, consumer protection, accountability, and safety. It establishes CLEAR's rules, protects injured Californians from inflated charges, and brings greater confidence to a system that affects thousands of Californians every year. For those reasons, we respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you for the time. Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 623? Good afternoon Andrea lunch on behalf of the California Chamber of Commerce and support. Thank you Thank you Mr Chair and members Annalie Augustine with the Civil Justice Association of California Please to support and hope this is a first step in broader reform too Thank you Thank you Mr Chair and members Stuart Thompson on behalf of the California Medical Association We officially neutral on this bill but we are supportive of this bill moving through the process We believe it a fair compromise and want to thank all the stakeholders for involving us in these negotiations Thank you Thank you Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 623? Okay. We'll bring it back to committee. Any questions or comments? Assemblymember Pacheco? I just want to commend and I want to thank both sides for reaching this compromise. This is amazing. I think now we can stop seeing all the commercials on both sides. I think we're all going to be happy about that. But congratulations. And this is so amazing that I would love to be added as a co-author. So thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? I also want to thank you, Senator Umberg. And I also want to add my thanks to all the parties, particularly the Consumer Trainings California and Uber for coming together. I agree that over the last several weeks, it's gotten kind of depressing. I think that's the intention of the ads to some extent. But the reality is that even more seriously, this piece of legislation does some really important things in terms of consumer protection, patient care, access to justice, and putting parameters in terms of guardrails against unethical practices by lawyers. all noble and necessary, I think, to ensure that we're not curtailing the ability for those that are genuinely injured and harmed to have their day in court, but also, more importantly, to be able to get healed, to be able to recover appropriately what they should. And the added, I think, really important aspects of not just background checks, but But women drivers and passenger preferences, I think, is a critical aspect of this. I know that it's something that in different forms has been offered in different ways. But I think to ensure that there's, first of all, the companies are free from liability. But more significantly, again, it's about the customer experience. And we want to make sure that everyone, especially given how ubiquitous these rideshare companies are now, that people feel comfortable using them. And I think that's always been the goal of the companies. But I think with this legislation, I think it adds that extra element for women to truly feel safe and to have that preference if they so choose to have it, both the driver and the passenger. So, you know, I think that this is something that we're all very grateful for, ensuring that, again, not just making sure the stuff's on the ballot. That's, of course, certainly not a bonus, but more importantly, what's before us is a very good compromise that actually accomplishes really important objectives that both sides wanted to see get done. And so incredibly grateful to all the work that's been put into it. Many, many hours. I want to express my gratitude to Manuela Boucher de la Cadenia and Nicholas Lidke from our team here on the committee. I know they spent many hours, especially this past weekend, on this, updating me and making sure the analysis was done. And that's during a couple of the busiest weeks we already have. And so that added on to all the work that all of you and your staffs have done Chair Umberg And so we have a lot of people to thank for this including the folks that are here at the table And I would, yeah, please, Senator Papin. Sorry to go out of order, Mr. Chair. I appreciate the opportunity to be heard. I just want to comment about the process rather than the intricacies of the bill. and I am a firm believer that compromise is what really constitutes good government. And so I'm very grateful that the parties hammered this out. All of the public will benefit from compromises like this. And then I'm going to make a second comment, and that is, you know, we have representative government for a reason, and some of these issues do not lend themselves to the ballot. So the fact that we have two less ballot initiatives that might have been very complex and perhaps not particularly clear to the public. I mean, I trust the public, but these can be very complex things. I'm very grateful that we are able to present this at the legislative level and hopefully get it signed by the governor and make things easier for all parties and for the public at large. So it's an honor to be involved in the process as well. So thank you all for the yeoman's effort you put into a compromise that really moves government forward. Any other question or comment? The last thing I wanted to mention is that I think that even if you look at the data and you look at kind of rider experiences, driver experiences, I think that the far majority of experiences are safe. They provide a service. And so I don't think the need for this legislation is critical because we want to make sure that every ride is safe and everyone feels safe, but also that if there are accidents which happen, that we make sure that people are made whole to the greatest extent possible. However, I do believe that most of the folks that are driving do so safely, do so in a way that is respectful. And I think this will just add to that. And for that, I'm grateful. Would you like to close? Well, thank you, Mr. Chair. And thank you for giving me any sort of credit for this. I am in politics, so I take credit for everything I possibly can. I did a press release this morning taking credit for the sun coming up. I'll take credit for it going down there. Well, there you go. But really, I'm just honored to be associated with this effort, that I'm just a rider on the bus. But the group here and those behind me formed an incredible coalition. I've not seen this kind of a coalition since everybody opposed my Grim Free Challenge bill. So kudos to all those who are engaged, involved, and I echo the comments of Assemblymember Ruppapin that this is the way government should work. With that urge, and I vote. Thank you. Do we have a motion? We have a motion and a second. Motion is do pass. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo, Barakahan, Ryan, Connolly? Connolly, aye. Dixon, Harabedian? Aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Papin? Aye. Papin, aye. Sanchez? Aye. Sanchez, aye. Stephanie, Zuber? That bill's on call. Good luck. We'll see you guys. Can you guys spend the night? Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Although we're going fast. I mean, we're going really fast in San Francisco. We may be done by 4 o'clock. So yes. We may see you earlier than you think. Thank you. We now only have two items that are from this morning. I'll plan to adjourn at 2.15 if we don't have an author here. Let's do some add-ons. Yeah, I think there's quite a few folks that might need to add on. So we'll start with consent calendar. Consent, Barra Cahan, Brian, Sanchez. Sanchez, aye. Item 1, SB 46, Umberg. Barra Cahan, Brian, Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Item add-ons for item 2, SB 873, Reyes. Barra Cahan, Brian, Sanchez. Sanchez, no. We'll move the call on item SB 957, Perez, as item three. Barra Cahan, Brian, Herbedian. Aye. Herbedian, aye. Pappin. Aye. Pappin, aye. Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Stephanie. Okay, we'll place that back on call. Item four, add-on SB 989, Blake Spear. Barra Cahan, Brian, Sanchez. Aye. Sanchez, aye. Add-ons for item 5, SB 998, Gonzalez. Barra Cahan, Bryan, Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Item 6, SB 1078, Laird, add-ons. Barra Cahan, Bryan, Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Item 7, SB 1103, Perez, move the call. Barra Cahan, Bryan, Parabedian. Aye. Parabedian, aye. Pappen. Aye. Pappen, aye. Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Stephanie, Zuber. We'll place that back on call. Add-ons for SB 1146, Gonzalez, item 8. Barrakehan, Brian, Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Move the call on item 9, SB 1160, Durazo. Barrakehan, Brian, Tappan. Aye. Tappan, aye. Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Stephanie, Zabur. Place that back on call. Add-ons for item 10, SB 1164, Cervantes. Barrakehan, Brian, Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Item 11, SB 1195, Caballero, move the call. SB 1194, Caballero. Barcahan, Brian, Herbedian. Aye. Herbedian, aye. Pappin. Aye. Pappin, aye. Sanchez. No. Sanchez, no. Stephanie, Zabur. Place that back on call. Item add-ons for item 13, SB 1256, Jones. Barcahan, Brian, Sanchez. Aye. Sanchez, aye. Add-ons for item 14, SB 1267, Allen. Mary Cahan, Brian, Sanchez. Aye. Sanchez, aye. Add-ons for item 16, SB 1425, Cortese. Mary Cahan, Brian, Sanchez. No. Sanchez, no. Okay. We're all caught up. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Okay, we have item 15 SB 1323, Senator Rubio. I'll move the bill. I will streamline it. Whenever you're ready. Thank you so much. Well, first of all, thank you for that. And I just want to begin by saying that I will be accepting the committee's clarifying amendments. SVE 1323 is a patient protection and dignity measure that strengthens existing law for individuals receiving medical care while in immigration custody A lot of our patients that go into hospitals don't have a way of notifying their families. They don't know where they're at. And so this simply just says, let's take care of our human beings. And I always like to say, it's not only immigrant communities because so many U.S. citizens have been hurt. One was shot, was in a hospital for two, three days, couldn't notify their parents. So again, this is for everyone, protection for everyone, where they can notify their parents, their loved ones, if they're hurt, and they're in detention centers. And so if I may turn it over to my witnesses. Thank you. I'll keep it brief to Jeanette Sanifatin, Director of Policy and Advocacy for the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights. I just want to hear to say that we're in strong support of this measure. We actually had a client that was at UCLA Harbor Medical Center who was in ICE detention at a hospital. And essentially what the center just mentioned is absolutely correct. Their family was not able to locate the individual. We had to go in with basically 12 to 15 people one day to try to have access to the patient with his immigration attorneys, with a minister, as well as union members. and what the hospital did was pretty terrible. In addition to not releasing information about the person who was the patient, once they did allow the family to have access to the patient, they subsequently took away the family's visitation rights. And so we want to make sure that individuals that are in these situations, that we do have uniform policies throughout the state. And so for those reasons, we urge your support today. Thank you. Good afternoon, committee. Hector Pereira on behalf of the Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice, proud sponsor of the bill. This bill is really about basic human dignity and the rights that are afforded to any person who is hospitalized, but for some reason not to civil immigrant detainees. We work extensively with folks that are detained at the Adelanto Ice Processing Center, which is in our region in San Bernardino County. And there have been so many countless stories that we hear from people who are injured when they're detained. So they haven't even been sent to a detention center yet. But because of the violence of this administration, they're injured because they've been beaten. They've been trampled to the ground. So they have to be hospitalized right after an arrest. People who are sent to detention centers where medical conditions are among the most negligent. And this is well documented that medical attention and medical care, both for physical and mental health in these detention centers are abhorrent. And folks die in these detention centers. last year was the deadliest year for folks that are being held in private detention centers since the creation of the Department of Homeland Security. So these are the conditions that folks are being subjected to. And then when they're hospitalized, finally, because their conditions have become life-threatening and these private detention centers have stopped ignoring them, they're completely cut off from access to their family members and to their lawyers. We had a case in which a detainee from Adelanto was hospitalized. They were not allowed a phone call to let their family know that they were hospitalized. And when they finally were allowed one after pleading and pleading for days, the ICE agent told them, if you even hint at where you're being hospitalized right now, we will completely cut you off from any other phone calls. But he couldn't even tell his family member where he was. He just had to tell them he was hospitalized. Another Adelanto detainee that passed away last year, the family was only called a couple hours before that detainee passed away to say, your loved one is in their final moments come say goodbye Those are the conditions that are existing right now in the state of California and we cannot accept this in this state so I respectfully ask for your aye vote Thank you Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1323 Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 1323? Okay, we do have a motion already. Any questions or comments? We already have a motion. Thank you, Senator, for bringing this bill again. Another example of a bill that we will hope we wouldn't have to do, but at this moment in time, I think our community desperately needs it. Would you like to close? Just real quickly, I'll leave you with this story. A young lady was taken, shot several times since she was bleeding out in a hospital. Again, they wouldn't let her call her family. She was moved into the detention center. The detention center denied her entry because she was dying. She had to be hospitalized again somewhere else and again was denied a phone call. And just wanted to share she was a U.S. citizen and her family didn't know where she was at. So with that, I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you. Thank you. Motions do pass to appropriations. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo? Barakahan? Aye. Barakahan, aye. Bryan? Connelly? Aye. Connelly, aye. Dixon? Dixon, no. Harabedian? Aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Pappin? Aye. Pappin, aye. Sanchez. Sanchez, no. Stephanie? Stephanie, aye. Zabir. Okay, the bill is out. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. Our last bill is item 12, SB 1247, Padilla. Senator Padilla? We have a motion and a second. Yay. You want me to present? I mean, I'll take the vote. One of a couple, one of a couple.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members. Pleased to present SB 1247, which gives the children whose images, particularly while they were juveniles, were provided in content monetized online, the ability to delete the content from which they were a minor, allowing them to take control back of their image, and particularly during some of the most important developmental stages of their life. You might remember two years ago I introduced SB 764, which created financial protections for child influencers in line with the Cougan Act of nearly more than a century ago. The bill, now law, is a key step in adopting laws that adapt to the modern economy. Today, as we know, children of vloggers provide click-worthy content, which is often monetized to the benefit of their parents. This bill gives children who were monetized online the ability to delete content from when they were a minor and take back control of that element of their lives going forward. Children of family influencers may not have a choice in participating in videos during this stage of their lives, which are often available for public consumption. And more child influencers are now speaking up about the difficulties of growing up in the public light, with some experiencing stalking and threats due to this public presence. A New York Times investigation also found many of these children posted online drew audiences of adults seeking explicit content, and parents continued posting their child because more followers means more lucrative branding deals. An example is Alison Stoner, a champion of the bill and former child actress, actually, experienced stalking and identity theft as a performer and states that these sorts of threats are the norm. And with the rise in AI tools, these images are now used often for sexual exploitation of minors. Similar legislation to this has been proposed and passed in other states, such as Utah, where Sherry Franke, daughter of Ruby Franke, a family blogger who was convicted of child abuse championed a similar bill after her and her siblings grew up with their lives documented online. This bill, again, would give them control of their image when they turn 18, requiring platforms to make available a user-friendly platform for them to request the deletion. This bill has had broad bipartisan support, has had no no votes, and I would respectfully ask for an aye vote.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone else here in support of SB 1247? Hold on one moment. Let's get the microphone on. Thank you. Thank you.

Kyle Nelsonwitness

Cheryl Westmont with Mothers Against Media Addiction for Overall California.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you.

Benjamin Hendersonwitness

Mamta Bhandari from Common Sense Media in support of the bill.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Is there anyone here in opposition to SB 1247? Okay, bring it back to committee. We do have a motion. Assemblymember Dixon?

Brian Augustawitness

Yep. Hello, Senator. I think I have supported many of these bills, and I want to support your bill. Thank you for bringing it forward. I'm concerned about the private right of action. Do you have a specific reason why you're including that?

That accrues to the—Mr. Chairman, if I might. Assemblymember, thank you for the question. As you might note, there was a distinction noted even in your analysis, but the language in the bill goes to providing that private right of action to seek damages from actually the creator, but not the platform.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Oh, okay. All right. Thank you. You're welcome. Assemblymember Bower-Cahan.

Marky Cedrowitness

I want to thank the author for his work on this. I mean, this amongst many other bills that protect children. But for those that have not read the New York Times reporting on this issue, it is hard to read, frankly. Parents are abusing their children by putting them online, and they are selling sexual images, clothing, undergarments to pedophiles, frankly, through online influencing. And the investigative reporting by the New York Times where they did an undercover, they went online and posed as children and saw what happened is frankly astonishing and upsetting and should never happen to a child. And so your ability to give children once they're old enough to understand and seek the ability to take these images offline is one piece of healing that we can hopefully give them. It won't take the trauma away, but it's really, really critically important. And this is a really important issue for us to be focusing on. And frankly, I wish we could do even more than this. And hopefully our law enforcement agents are. But I just want to thank you for this and would love to be. We are seeing it in privacy. I believe this is going to privacy next.

No, it's not. It went to privacy. I think we saw first.

Marky Cedrowitness

So I would love to be out as a co-author if you'll have me.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Any other questions or comments? I also want to thank you, Senator.

Morgan-Larry Zabowitness

Clearly, Assemblymember Bauer-Cahan mentioned some of the extreme cases, but along the spectrum, it's about having ownership over what's out there in the world about you. Even if you're just a more private person than your parents are and you're 18, 19, you don't want them out there. I think that whole spectrum of egregious conduct from parents to just, you know what, I just don't want it out there. And I'm 18 now. I have the right to make that decision and everything in between. And I think for those reasons I think this is a common sense bill that gives ownership where it should be to the person themselves And so with that would you like to close Thank you for your comments and encouragement Mr Chairman and also to members of the committee

I think it is important, as you point out, to remember the spectrum, right? We have egregious conduct at the one end that's just outright intentional, even criminal exploitation based on the content. But also we're learning a lot more today about the fact that minors, particularly at critical points in their life development, their emotional and psychological development, to have it exposed at such scale can often be detrimental to the health and well-being of that development and cause a lot of other issues down the road. And so I appreciate it and would respectfully ask for an aye vote.

Assemblymember We'veassemblymember

Thank you. Motions do pass. Kalra? Aye. Kalra, aye. Macedo? Barra-Kahan? Aye. Barra-Kahan, aye. Brian? Connelly? Aye. Connelly, aye. Dixon? Aye. Dixon, aye. Harabedian? Aye. Harabedian, aye. Pacheco? Aye. Pacheco, aye. Pappin? Aye. Pepin, aye. Sanchez? Aye. Sanchez, aye. Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir? Okay, that bill is out. Thank you all. All right, so thank you. We're done with the business. Now let's just do any final add-ons. Okay. Almost done, everybody. Almost done. If we can just keep it down just for a second so folks can hear our secretary as she goes through the add-ons. Consent calendar. On consent, Bauer-Cahan? Aye. Bauer-Cahan, aye. Brian? Aye. Brian, aye. No. All right. Item one, SB 46, Umberg. Bauer-Cahan? Pay attention now. Item one, let's go. Bauer-Cahan, aye. Brian? Aye. Brian, aye. All right. Item two, SB 873, Reyes. Barra-Cahan. Aye. Barra-Cahan, aye. Brian. Aye. Brian, aye. Item three, SB 957, Perez. We're lifting the call. We're lifting the call. Barra-Cahan. Barra-Cahan, aye. Brian. Aye. Brian, aye. Stephanie. Aye. Stephanie, aye. That bill is out. Add-ons for item four, SB 989, Blake Spear. Barra-Cahan. Barra-Cahan, aye. Brian. Aye. Okay. Item 5, add-ons for SB 998, Gonzalez. Barra-Cahan. Aye. Barra-Cahan, aye. Bryan. Aye. Bryan, aye. Item 6, add-ons for SB 1078, Laird. Barra-Cahan. Aye. Barra-Cahan, aye. Bryan. Aye. Bryan, aye. Lift the call on item 7, SB 1103, Perez. Barra-Cahan. Aye. Bryan. Aye. Bryan, aye. Stephanie. Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir. Okay. I'll place that back on call. Add-on, so item 8, SB 1146, Gonzalez. Barra-Cahan. Aye. Barra-Cahan, aye. Brian. Aye. Brian, aye. Lift the call on item 9, SB 1160, Durazo. Barra-Cahan. Aye. Barra-Cahan, aye. Brian. Aye. Brian, aye. Stephanie. Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir. The bill is out. Add-ons to item 10, SB 1164, Cervantes. Barra-Cahan. Barra-Cahan, aye. Bryan. Aye. Bryan, aye. Lift the call on item 11, SB 1194, Caballero. Barra-Cahan. Aye. Barra-Cahan, aye. Bryan. Aye. Bryan, aye. Stephanie. Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zabir. The bill is out Add for item 12 SB 1247 Padilla Macedo Aye Macedo aye Brian Aye Brian aye Zabir Item 13, add-ons for SB 1256, Jones. Bauer-Cahan. Aye. Bauer-Cahan, aye. Brian. Aye. Brian, aye. Add-ons for item 14, SB 1267, Allen. Bauer-Cahan. Aye. Bauer-Cahan, aye. Brian? Aye. Brian, aye. Item 15, add-ons for SB 1323, Rubio. Macedo? No. Macedo, no. Brian? Aye. Brian, aye. Zuber? Item 16, add-ons for SB 1425, Cortese. Barcahan? Aye. Barcahan, aye. Brian? Aye. Brian, aye. Lift the call on item 22, SB 623, Umberg. Macedo? Aye. Macedo, aye. Bauer-Cahan? Bauer-Cahan, aye. Brian? Brian, aye. Dixon? Aye. Dixon, aye. Stephanie? Aye. Stephanie, aye. Zuber? Okay, that bill is out. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Okay, we're going to lift the call on SB 1103 Perez. Zabur? Aye. Zabur? Aye. Item 9 is SB 1160, Durazo. Zabur? Aye. Zabur, aye. Item 11 is SB 1194, Caballero. Zabur? Aye. Zabur, aye. Item 12 is SB 1247 Padilla Zabur Zabir aye Item 15 is SB 1323 Rubio Zabir Item 15 Aye. Zabir, aye. And the last one is SB 623 Umberg. That's item 22. Zabir. Zabir, aye. And with that, SB 1103 is out and we are adjourned. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

Source: Assembly Judiciary Committee · June 23, 2026 · Gavelin.ai