Skip to main content
Committee HearingAssembly

Assembly Communications And Conveyance Committee

July 1, 2026 · Communications And Conveyance · 10,974 words · 3 speakers · 74 segments

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Okay. The communications and conveyance committee is now called to order. My name is Tasha Burner. I serve as the chair of the committee. Joining me on the dais today are assembly members, Chris Rogers and assembly member Maggie Krell. We are awaiting. Oh, and we have our vice chair, Josh Hoover, just joined us. We are also joined by Emilio Perez, the chief consultant of the communications committee, and Elizabeth Delgado, the committee secretary, as well as Daniel Ballin, the Republican policy consultant. There are five items on today's agenda. We have one item on proposed consent calendar, item five, SB 985 Strickland. Before we begin our presentations, I would like to take care of some logistical housekeeping. As we proceed with the witnesses and public comment, I want to make sure everyone understands that the Assembly has rules to ensure that we maintain, order, and run an efficient and fair hearing. We apply these rules consistently to all people who participate in our proceedings, regardless of their viewpoints they express. We seek to protect the rights of all who participate in the legislative process so that we can have effective deliberation and decisions on the critical issues facing California. You can exit the hearing room once you're done testifying or return to your seat. Now let's cover the ground rules for appropriate conduct. The Assembly has experienced a number of disruptions to committee and floor proceedings in the last few years. in order to facilitate the goal of hearing as much from the public within the limits of our time, we will not permit conduct that disrupts, disturbs, or otherwise impedes the orderly conduct of legislative proceedings. We'll not accept the disruptive behavior or behavior that incites or threatens violence. The rules for today's hearing include no talking or loud noises from the audience. Public comment may be provided only at the designated time and place as permitted by the chair. Public comment must relate to the subject being discussed today. no engaging in conduct that disrupts, disturbs, or otherwise impedes the orderly conduct of this hearing. Please be aware that violations of these rules may subject you to removal or other enforcement actions. And lastly, a public announcement. As noticed in the daily file, the Utilities and Energy Committee is now meeting at 2 p.m. or upon adjournment of the Communications and Conveyance Committee in Capitol Room 126 Please note the time and room change Okay We, noticing the absent of the quorum, we'll operate as a subcommittee. We'll proceed to item one, SB 739, Ergen. Related to the California Clean Mile Standard and Incentive Program, Senator Errogean, you may open when ready. And each of your witnesses have two minutes. It goes by quickly, so I'll count down with my fingers, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, and then I will politely cut you off. Well, thank you very much, Madam Chair and members. It's my pleasure to present Senate Bill 739. This bill will update the Clean Miles Standard Incentive Program to ensure that the program is meeting its greenhouse emissions and electric vehicles, miles travel targets that transportation network companies in California need to comply with. I want to start by sincerely thanking the chair and the committee for working with my office and the bill's sponsors. I am accepting the committee's amendments. This bill would allow for the California Air Resources Board and the California Public Utilities Commission to adjust the current CMS targets so that they are reflecting the changing policy and economic landscape. As a strong climate supporter, it is unfortunate that the current federal government has been so hostile towards California's climate efforts. And the modest adjustments in my bill will allow for the clean mile standard to continue to be on a trajectory to grow the zero emissions market for TNC drivers. And I want to also acknowledge, and this will be, I think, touched upon by my witness testimony, the work that the TNC companies are already doing to make investments towards that ZEP transition. Without these changes, we'd be placing hundreds of thousands of California right-share drivers in a difficult position where they might lose platform access if they do not adopt zero-emission vehicles pursuant to the statutory targets. Many of these drivers are working a second or third job to help make ends meet. We have yet to provide assistance to these drivers to purchase ZEVs through the Driver Assistance Fund. And I know that's one of the amendments that the chair recommended. I very much appreciate the inclusion of that in the bill. Currently, the Clean Mile Standard is requiring TNCs and drivers to meet an electric vehicle miles travel target of 13% by 2025. And that target more than triples next year to 50%. 50%. The bill, as amended with the committee, would provide interim targets of 17% by 2027 and 19% by 2028 so that we can continue to make progress on these targets while state agencies work through adjustments. Finally, before I introduce this bill, one of the main points of feedback that I received was that the law as written did not provide state agencies with the flexibility needed to adjust targets. And in fact, I met with both staff and representatives of the California Air Resources Board and the California Public Utilities Commission to get a briefing on the implementation of the Clean Mile Standard. And CARB was very clear that they do not believe, under the current statute, that they have the legislative authorization to make adjustments to the targets after the first targets were established. As written, the law only allowed for either implementing the targets or delaying them. This bill will provide flexibility to both respective boards and agencies. With me to testify are the co-sponsors, John Finley representing Uber and Malcolm McFarland representing Lyft. And at the appropriate time, respectfully ask for an event. Sorry, my back to you all. Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Good afternoon, Chair and members. My name is Malcolm McFarland II here on behalf of LIFT in support of Senate Bill 739. LIFT would like to thank Chair Berner and this committee for the thoughtful engagement on this issue. California deserves a climate policy that works, and SB 739 updates the original 2018 Clean Mile Standard targets to reflect the realities of what's achievable today. To be clear, Lyft is committed to supporting California's climate goals and has demonstrated that commitment in action. We have met every EVMT target since the Clean Model Standard took effect, electrifying our platform at over twice the statewide adoption rate since 2023. We have invested over $64 million in driver bonuses, EV rentals, and in-app tools to make driving electric easier. Lyft remains committed to continuing those investments, which this bill appropriately directs the Commission to consider when evaluating any enforcement action. California's Clean Mile Standard targets were set using 2018 data before a global pandemic reshaped rideshare, before the federal EB tax credit was eliminated, and before $5 billion in charging infrastructure funding was halted. These are documented and structural barriers, and for many drivers, affordability and availability remain real challenges that fall disproportionately on low- and moderate-income drivers. Notably, the CPUC's own Unanticipated Barriers Report recommends pausing enforcement of targets it acknowledges are no longer achievable. SB 739 fills that gap and makes reasonable adjustments to the CMS program, supported by a two-year review process, and requires an annual EVMT increase to ensure continued progress toward electrification until new targets are adopted and implemented by the Board. Lith would also like to note our support of protecting TNCs that meet at least one of the annual EVMT or GHG targets from enforcement action beginning in 2029. Thank you.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Thank you. Next two minutes comes fast.

John Finleywitness

All right. Thank you, Madam Chair and members. John Finley here on behalf of Uber and strong support of Bill 739. Uber is deeply committed to a zero emissions future. We've invested hundreds of millions of dollars in driver incentives, vehicle discounts, education initiatives, and charging partnerships. And it's working. Drivers on the Uber platform adopt EVs five times faster than the average motorist in the United States, Canada, and Europe. and nearly one in five miles on the Uber platform in the state of California is already all electric. But the current CMS framework is no longer technically or economically feasible. A perfect storm of high electricity costs, rising interest rates, elimination of federal tax credits, and ongoing constraints of EV supply and access to affordable public charging infrastructure led CPUC staff just last week to recommend a three-year pause on the CMS program. Forcing an unworkable standard on TNCs won't help accelerate EV adoption. It will simply risk the premature deactivation of thousands of low-income working Californians

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

who cannot yet afford or are otherwise unable to transition to electric vehicles right now. SB 739 provides a realistic and durable path forward. It provides CARB with the authority to recalibrate the CMS targets in light of existing market conditions and the most up-to-date data to increase the likelihood that these targets remain technically and economically achievable. CARB can then more regularly reevaluate and adjust those targets based on future market conditions and policies. It would also revoke enforcement of the original targets in light of new interim and future targets coming into enforcement under this bill. Despite significant challenges Uber is not backing away from this commitment This year alone we committed million to expanding fast charging globally and launched a nationwide Go Electric grant program offering a incentive for drivers who switch to EVs We are doing our part and we ask that California continue to do the same by passing a flexible framework that protects drivers while continuing climate progress. We thank Senator Araguin for bringing this issue forward and respectfully urge an aye vote on SB 739. Thank you. Perfect timing. Thank you to the proponents. We'll move to any additional witnesses in support. You may approach the mic with name, affiliation, and position only, please. Timothy Byrd, Jr. Timothy Byrd, Jr., on behalf of TechNet, in support. Thank you. Okay. Thank you to the witnesses in support. Moving on. Are there any primary witnesses in opposition? We had none registered, so please, if you first two people can come up to the desk. And we're going to pause right there because we have a quorum. Will the committee secretary please call the roll? This is to establish quorum. Berner? Here. Berner present. Hoover? Here. Hoover present. Bonta? Here. Colosa? Castillo? Krell? Here. Krell present. Lowenthal? Rogers? Here. Rogers present. Rubio? Here. Rubio present. Okay, we have a quorum. You now have four minutes. Good afternoon, chair and members. I'm Dr. Benjamin Liu, and I'm the cleaner advocacy manager for the American Lung Association. We are in respectful opposition to SB 739. I just wanted to highlight some, emphasize for the members that, according to the Lung Association's latest state-of-the-art report, over 80% of Californians still live in communities impacted by unhealthy levels of air pollution. Fuel combustion in the transportation sector is the primary source of smog-forming ozone pollution and a significant contributor to PM2.5 particles. This pollution leads to both acute and chronic health emergencies such as asthma, heart attacks and stroke, developmental harm, lung cancer, and premature death. These are costly and disruptive health emergencies that strain family budgets and contribute to the affordability crisis in the state. The Clean Mile Standard was designed to promote adoption of EVs among transportation network companies' drivers, and consequently, the goal is to try and limit this kind of air pollution. We appreciate the latest amendments in print and are committed to working with the author on further amendments to address our opposition. One thing in particular is that the current amendments in print prescribe decelerating targets for 2027-28, plus 4% electric vehicle miles traveled in 27, and then plus 2% to 28. We feel like this program should have accelerating targets. The program was designed to drive EV adoption over time as opposed to merely match or decelerate. And so we're committed to working with the author on further amendments, but for now we are in respectful opposition. Thank you. Thank you. Any additional witnesses in opposition that would like to state their name, affiliation, and position only, please? You may approach the mic. Good afternoon. Jacob Evans with Sierra, California in opposition. Thank you. Marquis King Mason, Natural Resource Defense Counsel. We appreciate the amendments but still in opposition Thank you Thank you Okay bringing it back to the committee Any questions comments from committee members Yes, Assemblymember Rubio. Thank you. I just wanted to chime in for a second. I understand the concerns. However, my concern has always been about the EV programs that we don't have enough resources to provide to those same people that we're trying to help. My parents are 80, 85 and 80, and I've been talking to them about an electric vehicle. And they're like, first of all, they think I'm crazy. You know, they don't see how not having any infrastructure, for example. So talking to my mom and she says, well, what is it going to take to, you know, have an EV vehicle? And when we start pricing it, it's unaffordable to them to change from gas to electric vehicles. And the bill I know references the fact that there is no infrastructure available. And so, you know, with that in mind, you know, it's unaffordable either way. And trying to push people into EVs when we don't have the infrastructure actually, I think, hurts them more. Plus, now they have a bad taste in their mouth about being pushed into electric vehicles when we don't have the proper infrastructure. So just wanted to point that out because you brought up the affordability issue. You know, unfortunately, everything's unaffordable right now. And trying to push people into, you know, EVs while there is no infrastructure, you know, hurts them even more. So I just wanted to make sure that I address that because I know that the Assembly or the Senator has been working hard, took a bunch of amendments to make sure that, you know, we got to a better place. And I appreciate the work that you've done and appreciate my chairwoman, you know, for bringing this up and trying to balance, you know, the affordability issue with, you know, the health issues, which I think we're all concerned about. But, you know, at the moment, if there's no infrastructure, then where do we go from here? And I think the incentives to, you know, be able to do that I think is what the goal is or the study to make sure that folks do have the opportunity eventually to convert to electric vehicles. Thank you. Assemblymember Rogers. Thank you so much. This is the second time in, I think, just like three days that I've had a chance to see this bill. I supported it in transportation. I'm going to support it today. I don't take backtracking on our climate goals lightly, but I do think the built-in flexibility that you're talking about is important when we make a commitment, but then the level of investment that we need to meet that commitment doesn't materialize, whether it's because our body doesn't approve the funding or, in this case, in particular, the federal government backtracking on commitments and failing to deliver when we're helping to fund the rest of the nation. We do have to take a serious look at who is impacted by not being flexible and whether or not it harms our overall goals of trying to get more people to accept climate solutions that they view as unattainable, unaffordable. And so for me, the built-in flexibility here helps us to keep folks saying that we are reasonable in these goals, that they're not just lofty for the sake of being lofty, but that we're going to match our commitment and our investment with what is attainable. It's not always going to be the case. I'm not always going to vote for these bills, but in this case I think that the author done a good job of trying to work with folks to do something reasonable So I happy to support Okay Do we have a motion I'd like to move the bill. Moved by Assembly Member Krell. Do we have a second? Second by Assembly Member Rubio. Any other further comments? Okay. Senator Errigan, would you like to close? Well, once again, thank you, Madam Chair and committee staff for your work with us on this bill. I want to thank the opposition. We've met with some of the opposition. We're committed to meet with all of them. We've reviewed their letters. We're happy to work on any amendments that would address concerns. But towards the goal of trying to provide that flexibility, that's something that Rogers talked about. And I take the issue of clean air very seriously. I represent Oakland and Richmond, which are two, some of the first AB 617 communities in California. We've had significant air quality issues. And that's why the Clean Mile Standard was created, because of the large number of TNC trips that are happening on our roads, making sure that we make that transition. I strongly support that goal, but we have to recognize a change in the political and economic reality, sadly, and make sure that we are moving forward with the implementation of this program in a way that works for the drivers and for the state of California, respectfully as for an item. Thank you, Senator Erdogan, for bringing this bill forward. Your bill does enjoy a due pass as amended recommendation, and thank you for cooperation with the committee amendments. The amendments will prohibit the CPUC from finding a TNC in violation of the targets and goals if they meet one of the two most recent annual targets or goals, which would apply to the updated targets and goals. We have to find better words for targets and goals because it gets very confusing when you read the bill. It's like targets and goals, and then there's yearly targets and goals, and then there's actual GHG, VMT targets and goals, lots of targets and goals. I think what was important in this bill was balancing ambitious targets and goals that are also attainable targets and goals. And we've done that. I grew up in the Inland Empire. We had third-degree smog alerts every single day as a child. I still have problems running. And that's, you know, many, many, too many decades later. Um, and additionally, the thing that we also took, you took as an amendment in this bill is we know that our drivers need assistance with gaining access to EVs. And so the amendments would require that the CPC commence issuing support from the driver's assistance program, which they've been collecting for years, starting January 1st, 2027. Because if you look at how the bill is designed, we do a pause. We have a slow ramp up. I wouldn't say it's a ramp down. It's a ramp up. Maybe not at the angle we want, but it's still an angle. And in that time, you guys have two and a half years of getting the drivers or two years to get the driver's assistance fund before really needing to get ramping up. And that is ambitious and attainable. And that's what this bill balances. So that we have a motion by Krell, seconded by Rubio. The motion on SB 739 by Senator Erdogan is due, passed, as amended, and re-referred to the Committee on Appropriations. Will the committee secretary please call the roll? Berner. Aye. Berner, aye. Hoover. Bonta. Colosa. Aye. Colosa, aye. Castillo. Krell. Aye. Krell, aye. Lowenthal. Rogers. Aye. Rogers, aye. Rubio. Aye. Rubio, aye. If that bell is out, we'll leave the row open so that other members can add on their votes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Next, we're hearing, I see is Senator Grove here. Did I see Senator Grove? Yep. Next, we're hearing SB 1190 by Senator Grove relating to transport escort services. That's exciting. I didn't think we were going to get that in this committee, but it's exciting. Senator Grove, you may open when you, you may open. And you have one primary witness, I understand. You will have four minutes. I'll count down the last five seconds. It goes fast. I do, Madam Chair. Thank you. Yes, I hate that title that's in statute. I'm choosing to call it the Safe Passage for Youth Act, but the other title is what's in statute, which had to be used to come to this committee. And so just to be funny and stress my chief of staff out, when she Googled it to try to get the explanation, it sent an alert to the computer that you're no longer allowed to the site. so we should definitely look at changing that title and statute so i'm here today to present sb 1190 i thank the chair this is the safe patches for youth act before i get started i want to accept the committee amendments and thank the chair as well as the committee staff for their hard work on this bill i also want to thank the bill's sponsor paris hilton and all the survivors associated with 11 11 media impact for their tireless engagement over the last several years and their bravery of sharing their own personal trauma in order to advance protections for vulnerable youth. As some of you may know, Paris Hilton was ripped from her bed in the middle of the night by strangers and transported across state lines. This bill is a direct response to the trauma that she experienced, as well as the experiences of many others' youth in our state. When a parent arranges for out-of-state residential placement facilities, those residential placement facilities often recommend the transport escort service. These companies often hire security-type individuals to show up in the dead of night, awaken startled children, strip them from their phones, and transport them across state lines. We're seeing a trend of minors being subjected to physical restraints, blindfolds, abuse, and severe emotional distress, and this is completely unacceptable. SB 1190 establishes the Safe Passage for Youth Act to directly dismantle these abusive practices and ensure that this industry is properly regulated. SB 1190 achieves this by requiring transport companies to secure charter party carrier permits through the CPUC and mandates that all staff be trust line background checked. Furthermore, it strictly bans the use of blindfolds, hoods, or unauthorized physical restraints and institutes a 9 p.m. to a 6 a.m. transport curfew, meaning you can't rip kids out of their bed anymore, and it empowers the AG to go after bad actors. If children are to be transported at all, they should be provided with a regulated safe passage that protects their dignity, respect, and health. Here with me today to testify in support of, on behalf of this sponsor, is Amanda Simmons, an attorney who represents youth victims of institutional abuse and is a survivor of the troubled teen industry herself. Good afternoon, chair and members. My name is Amanda Simmons. I'm a special education and school injury attorney, and I come to this issue with extensive experience surrounding institutional child abuse, both as an attorney and as someone with lived experience. I am here in strong support of SB 1190. I would also like to relay the powerful testimony of a fellow troubled teen industry survivor and advocate Alex Gaeta She has testified in Senate committee hearings but couldn be here today She has asked me to read her story for the record. I would like to thank her for her bravery in sharing her experience. Her story is just one of countless children, many of whom disproportionately come from the state of California. These are Alex's powerful words. On June 23rd, 2019 in Menlo Park, I was awoken before dawn by two strangers standing over my bed. They said they had been hired by my parents to take me somewhere, but wouldn't say where. They told me not to resist or it would be worse for me later. I was 14 and terrified. I wasn't dressed. I asked them to leave the room so that I could get dressed. They refused, saying I was a flight risk, and they watched me. I begged to say goodbye to my dog. They said no. Each of them grabbed one of my wrists and a shoulder. I have a connective tissue disorder, and they held me so hard that my joints partially dislocated. They marched me to a car, then to the airport, where they showed paperwork saying my parents had signed over temporary legal guardianship to them. When I asked to use the bathroom, the female transporter followed me into the stall. I was a child with no history of dangerous behavior. I had straight A's. None of this mattered. It has been almost seven years and I still have nightmares. I can't sleep in my childhood bedroom because it's too triggering. Nothing can undo what has happened to me. But today, you have the chance to make sure fewer stories like mine happen. Thank you. This bill matters because private youth transport services have operated in California without real guardrails for far too long. For decades, children have described being taken from their homes in the middle of the night by strangers. As the brave survivor testimony just described so powerfully, youth are being handcuffed, zip-tied, blindfolded, and otherwise forced into transport. These are not isolated stories. They are a pattern. And this trauma does not end when the transport does. Many survivors carry it for years, nightmares, PTSD, anxiety, and a deep mistrust that follows them well into adulthood. Parents and families are often harmed, too. Many families never fully understand the force, fear, and coercion that may be used on their children until long after, by which point the damage is done, including serious and lasting harm to the relationship between parent and child. The bottom line is simple. If a private company is going to transport children for pay, there must be basic safety standards, clear boundaries, and real accountability. SB 1190 begins to provide that. It requires transport services to use trustline-registered staff, get a state permit, train their staff on de-escalation and child abuse reporting, and obtain parental consent. And it bans some of the worst practices that have caused the most harm, blindfolds, hoods, and middle-of-the-night pickups. This bill is about dignity, safety, and accountability. It is an important step towards finally putting safeguards around an industry that has operated in the shadows for far too long. On behalf of Alex, myself, 1111 Media, and other survivor advocates across the state and beyond, we thank you for your consideration, and we respectfully urge your yes vote on SB 1190. Thank you. Thank you to the proponents. We'll move on to any additional witnesses in support. You may approach the mic with name, affiliation, and position only, please. Hi good afternoon Chantel Johnson representing Youth Law Center and also Disability Rights California today in strong support Thank you Okay moving on Are there any primary witnesses in opposition Anybody who wants to come to the mic and just say name, position, and affiliation only? Okay, with that, moving back to the committee. Any questions? Assemblymember Krell. I just want to thank Senator Grove for your tireless efforts for child safety and for bringing this bill. I would love to be added as a co-author, if you'll have me, and also thank you to the sponsors for your work on this and for sharing today and everything you've done to get this bill to this place. Thank you. Did you make it? I'll move the bill. Move by Crow, second by Castile. Any other comments from committee members? Okay, Senator Grove, would you like to close? Thank you, Madam Chair, and absolutely I'd love to add my good friend and colleague who is on that same battle fight to protect youth and women in our state as a co-author. This TCP permit is just a requirement that is governing any person who engages in these transport. It requires insurance, workers' comp, corporate officers. They just can't be fly-by-night organizations anymore. They just go snatch kids out of their bed in the middle of the night and especially make brutal things happen to them that should never have happened to a child. And, again, I don't fault the parents. I think that they are trying to figure out what's best for their kid, and they arrange services with these out-of-state organizations, and they're like, hey, we'll take care of the transport and everything. And they have to sign all these documents that say they won't interfere, they won't stop, they won't engage. and by the time this all happens, it's too late and it takes a while for these kids to actually recover. I want to thank the sponsor again, Paris Hilton, and our incredible husband, Carter, who has been advocating on his wife's behalf as well, side by side from the national level as well to protect all children, but specifically those here in California. Respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you, Senator Groh, for bringing this bill forward. Your bill does enjoy a do pass as amended recommendation with the committee amendments, and I commend you for taking on this thorny issue. Thank you for working productively with my staff to get the technical aspects correct. We have a motion by Krell, a second by Castillo. The motion on SB 1190 by Cinder Grove is do pass as amended and re-referred to the committee on appropriations. Will the secretary please call the roll? Berner. Aye. Berner, aye. Hoover. Bonta. Caloza. Caloza, aye. Castillo. Aye. Castillo, aye. Krell. Aye. Krell, aye. Lowenthal. Aye. Lowenthal, aye. Rogers. Aye. Rogers, aye. Rubio. Aye. Rubio, aye. Thank you, members. Thank you, Madam Chair. Members, SB 1190 is out. We'll leave the row open so other members can add on their votes. Next, we're hearing SB 1191 by Senator Ochoa Bowe relating to communications universal service programs. Senator, you may open, and I think you have two witnesses. You each have two minutes. I'll count down. It goes by fast. Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the committee. Senate Bill 1191 extends the sunset date for the California High Cost Fund A and B programs by sorry that okay Okay. This is better. Yep. Okay. Good afternoon, Madam Chair and members of the committee. Senate bill 1191 extends the census date for the California High Cost Fund A and B programs by five years to January 1, 2033. These two universal programs are essential in ensuring that residents in rural and high-cost areas of the state have access to affordable, basic telephone service through reliable networks. Due to the high cost of serving areas with sparse populations, tough terrain, and extreme weather, the high-cost fund programs continue to be necessary for rural communities. California has a long-standing commitment to affordable universal service, and these programs have been a key part of that effort since they were first established in statute in 1987 and reauthorized multiple times by the legislature. Joining me today is Eric Votel with VARCOM and Pam Loomis, legislative analysts with the California's independent telecommunication companies. Good afternoon, Madam Chair and members of the committee. My name is Eric Votel. I'm the chairman and CEO and principal owner of VARCOM. We are a communications a telephone company in rural California, and I'm also a member of CalCom. I'm here in strong support of SB 1191. At its core, this bill is about one thing, making sure that every Californian, no matter where they live, can access essential telecommunications services. VARCOM, my company, serves rural communities where geographic and economic to make telephone service a challenge to provide. VARCOM serves rural communities in Tulare and Tehama counties where geography and economics are challenged. 100% of the children in the town of Ducor, where we serve, are on free lunch. The average median household income in Ducor, California, is $73,635 per year in comparison to the average statewide median household income of $99,000. VARCOM serves the working poor, the farm workers who put food on everybody's table and keeps our agricultural economy moving. In my Kennedy Meadows Exchange, which is at 7,000 feet in the Sierra Nevadas, there is no commercial power and we are the only connection for communications to that community for essential 911 services. My last exchange, Rancho Tehama, which is in Tehama County, is even worse economically than Ducor, where the average median household income is $53,606 a year. The poverty rate in Rancho Tehama is at 27%. The California High Cost Fundae makes it possible for us to provide access to telecommunication services at rates that are affordable and comparable to urban. I support this and hope that you will continue to make telecommunications affordable for Californians. Thank you. Pam, you have two minutes. Good afternoon, Madam Chair and members. My name is Pam Loomis, and I'm the legislative advocate for a coalition of nine small telephone companies. that receive financial support from the California High Cost Fund A, and we are in support of SB 1191. Building on Mr. Votas' testimony, the A Fund provides vital support for the operation and maintenance of telecommunications networks, networks that are necessary to provide cell phone and Internet service in our remote communities, networks that support Cal Fire's operations at our local fairgrounds, and networks used by law enforcement and counties to send reverse 911 alerts to our rural residents. Those are just to name a few of the critical services our networks enable in rural California. We are deeply committed to our rural communities we live in and serve and cannot do it without the ongoing support of the legislature through the high cost fund programs. We are grateful to Senator Ochoa Bogue for carrying SB 1191 and respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you to the proponents. We'll move on to any additional witnesses and support. You may approach the microphone with name, affiliation and position only, please. Okay, don't fight for the microphone. I saw that. Good afternoon. Tracy Ryan, Royal County Representative of California in support. Yolanda Benson, U.S. Telecom, the Broadband Association in strong support. David Nelson on behalf of California Communications Association in strong support. Thank you. Do we have any primary witnesses in opposition? Anybody who wants to come to the mic and just say me too and opposition seeing none turning to the committee. Do we have any questions, comments, assembly member? I want to thank the member for, I want to thank the Senator for bringing this bill and the sponsors for meeting with me about it. I think it's a great program. Happy to move the bill. Motion by Krells second by Rogers. Any other questions, comments from the committee with that Senator, you may close. Thank you very much for your support. SB 1191 extends our state's long-standing policy of supporting the availability of affordable basic telephone service to California's rural communities. I respectfully ask for an aye vote. Thank you, Senator Ochoa Boe, for bringing this bill forward. Your bill does enjoy a due pass recommendation. As you know, I'm a strong advocate for telecommunications and our small telecommunications companies. If you've gone out on a tour and seen their facilities, you see what hard work they do for our communities, and without them, so many people would be disconnected. So we have a motion by Krell, second by Rogers. The motion on SB 1191 by Senator Chobo is due passed and re-referred to the Committee on Appropriations. Will the secretary please call the roll? Berner. Aye. Berner. Aye. Hoover. Bonta. Caloza. Caloza. Aye. Castillo. Aye. Castillo. Aye. Krell. Krell. Aye. Lowenthal. Aye. Lowenthal. Aye. Rogers. Aye. Rogers. Aye. Rubio. Aye. Rubio. Aye. Thank you very much. That's out. We'll leave the bill open for other members to add on. So we could let do consent Do we have a motion on the consent calendar Second Okay Motion by Rubio Second by Krell Rogers Krell Rogers Rogers? Secretary, please call the roll. Okay. This is item 5, SB 985 Strickland, 911 Emergency System. The motion is due, pass, and be referred to the Committee on Appropriations. Secretary, please call the roll. Berner? Aye. Berner? Berner, aye. Hoover? Bonta? Caloza? Aye. Caloza, aye. Castillo? Aye. Castillo, aye. Krell? Aye. Krell, aye. Lowenthal? Aye. Lowenthal, aye. Rogers? Aye. Rogers, aye. Rubio? I can send us out. We'll leave the roll open for other members to add on. And with that, I see that we have Senator Cortese here. We're going to be hearing SB 1246 by Senator Cortese relating to autonomous vehicles. Senator Cortese, you may approach the bench or the table, the desk. You may open when ready. And I think you have two witnesses here. One witness. One witness. Two. We have two witnesses. Two witnesses. You each get two minutes. It goes by fast. I'll count down with my fingers on the last five seconds. Senator, you may start when I'm ready. Very experienced witnesses. Members and Chair, I'm here to present SB 1246. Appreciate the opportunity. Appreciate the committee's analysis. Reports of AVs running red lights, obstructing traffic, and driving through active law enforcement activities have grown nationwide as the fleets have grown. In December, a citywide power outage in San Francisco caused 1,500 Waymo stoppages at blocked intersections and impeded first responders in dangerous weather conditions. Many of us remember that news. Emergency personnel were left on hold for 53 minutes as remote operations were overwhelmed. When remote operations are delayed, it falls on public sector workers. Our firefighters, law enforcement, and traffic officials step in despite the strain it puts on our public resources. SB 1246 sets standards to provide immediate coordinated response to AV incidents. Under SB 1246, AV companies must provide local jurisdictions with the location and status of their vehicles when system-wide failures occur. It also requires remote drivers to be based in the United States and have U.S. driver's license. Most importantly, SB 1246 ensures public workers are not treated as default road assistance. The bill requires AV companies to send a trained autonomous vehicle worker to the scene of an AV accident or obstruction. The DMV, with stakeholder input, will set appropriate guidelines for response times during regular operations. But if there's an emergency and an AV interferes with the first responder operations for more than 30 minutes, manufacturers are going to face penalties under the bill. Finally, SB 1246 protects first responders by ensuring that all AVs can be manually or remotely disabled upon their request. We've held frequent meetings with opposition, numerous might be a better description, and taken amendments to address their concerns. I'm confident the bill is moving in a positive direction, and as such, I would respectfully ask for your aye vote. With us here today, as the two witnesses, Matt Leger with our sponsor, SEIU California, and Megan Subers with the California Professional Firefighters. Thank you. You have two minutes. Good afternoon. Matt Lugier with SEIU California, the proud sponsor of SB 1246 And I appreciate our author for carrying this bill and the chair for for hearing and your work of your committee staff as well We proud to sponsor this effort because we want to ensure that public employees are not acting as roadside assistance for these companies, particularly as they expand and get deployed further. From our perspective, what we've seen is that the technology, while is still new and working through the implementation roadblocks, We don't want the public to be suffering when there's glitches on the streets and want there to be some responsibility of the companies to step forward, handle these issues with their local incident technicians as proposed in the bill, so that every day police, fire and parking officials are not stepping in and saying, hey, this car needs to move when it's just not moving and blocking traffic and disrupting the public. We think that having the local technicians there to respond to the emergency or accident involving property damage or injury is a basic step to ensure that these companies are bearing that responsibility and responding appropriately. Also, I would just highlight the need that the bill is proposing to make sure that the U.S. drivers, people doing driving tasks are based in the United States, which is critically important given the latency time between the U.S. and other countries. And that delay, particularly as things start to move at high speeds of the freeway and others, are not causing additional issues. So this technology has the potential to be incredibly disruptive, as we saw in San Francisco and numerous other instances when it glitches. If there is an issue, we think that there should be some common sense safety requirements and staffing requirements. And we think this bill takes an important step forward. For those reasons, we respectfully ask for your aye vote. Thank you. Thank you. Two minutes. Thank you, Madam Chair and members. Megan Subbers on behalf of the California Professional Firefighters, and we're pleased to be in support of the bill today. I'd like to thank the author for continuing his work on these policies to improve AV safety on our streets. As you've likely heard me and my members say, there have been several incidents involving AV operators across the state. And one of the things that they always tell me is that we need clear protocols that we know how to interact with these vehicles if it's during an emergency. We've had examples of them entering into live fire incidents, running over fire hoses, blocking entrance and exit out of fire stations. And so we think this bill is a step in that direction. The issue that our members always say is that if we can't disable the vehicle, they're also concerned that it may move. They're not sure if it's off. They don't know if it's going to continue to interfere with the people on the street there or with their operations. But I understand that this bill will not require that we have access to the vehicle or be able to move the vehicle ourselves necessarily. But we do think the steps that require the company to do so themselves immediately is an important step. And those are the reasons that we're in support today. along with setting up guidelines for response times for those local incident technicians and creating a fine structure if an AV does interfere with emergency operations. And so for those reasons, we are in support. Thank you to the proponents. We'll move on to witnesses in support. You may approach the mic with name, affiliation, and position only, please. Good afternoon, Madam Chair and members. Connor Gussman on behalf of Teamsters California and the Amalgamated Transit Union in support. Madam Chair, members, Sarah Flox, California Federation of Labor Unions, in support. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Cody Boyles, on behalf of the California Association Highway Patrolman. Thank you. Chair and members, Jonathan Feldman with the California Police Chiefs Association. Apologize our updated letter wasn in time to be reflected in the committee analysis but we remain in support Thank the author for his work Sean Flanagan on behalf of the Dawn Project in support Christopher Sanchez on behalf of the Consumer Federation of California in support Caroline Tessa, California School Employees Association in support. Madam Chair and members, Louie Costa with Smart Transportation Division, Safety and Legislative Board in support. motion by Lowenthal second by Rogers. Okay. With that, we have, uh, we have primary witnesses in opposition. We have Sarah. You get four minutes. Oh, well I won't need that long. Thank you. Thank you for that too. You do have four minutes. Am I on? Okay. You're on. You're gonna have to hold the mic as if you're like doing a podcast. Oh, that's exciting. Madam Chair and members, Sarah Boot on behalf of the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association with an opposed unless amended position. We appreciate the committee's thoughtful analysis and we appreciate the author and the sponsors and their willingness to work with us on this bill, accept amendments, and to consider our remaining concerns. I'm going to briefly highlight them here. So first, while the recent amendments to manual override provisions are an improvement, the bill still moves California into regulating vehicle design and performance, an area governed by federal standards. That national framework ensures manufacturers design vehicles to one uniform set of safety requirements, while states retain authority over the rules of the road and vehicle operations. Second, we continue to oppose allowing local governments to enforce compliance with the manufacturer's DMV permit. Those determinations are best made by the DMV, which has the necessary expertise. California's AV framework is built on uniform statewide oversight and allowing individual jurisdictions to impose penalties based on an alleged permit violation could undermine that consistency. Third, if an AV cannot be moved remotely, the bill requires an immediate dispatch of a local incident technician. The problem is that term is defined to mean either an employee of the AV company, which is fine, or a tow truck company with at least 50 employees. Because a lot of tow truck companies do not have that many employees, the bill could actually prevent companies from dispatching the closest available tow truck. Fourth, the bill requires AV companies to notify emergency dispatch of any fleet-wide emergency. We understand that intent, but the definition is overly broad. It includes any event that merely affects multiple AVs, which could be two or three AVs. And that could also be the case even when emergency dispatch isn't needed, which could lead to unnecessary notifications, and that could burden limited emergency dispatch resources. Finally, the bill imposes a penalty if a disabled AV cannot be removed within 30 minutes during an emergency. We understand that. We accept that. But we think the bill should account for circumstances beyond an AV company's control. So if the company immediately dispatches assistance, but then they can't access the vehicle in 30 minutes because of road closures or severe traffic congestion or other emergency conditions, they shouldn't be subject to a penalty in those instances. So with that, we look forward to continuing these discussions on the bill and respectfully request a no vote for today. And thank you for your time. Thank you. Any additional witnesses in opposition that would wish to state their name, affiliation and position only, please? You may approach the mic. Elizabeth Esquivel, California Manufacturers and Technology Association, also recognizing the recent amendments that the author had taken. We have moved our position from opposed to opposed unless amended for the reasons that were already provided. Thank you. Camille Wagner with KP Public Affairs representing Waymo. Also appreciate the work with the author, opposed unless amended for The reason stated, look forward to continuing the conversation. Thanks. Good afternoon. Lizzie Guansona here on behalf of Tesla, still reviewing the latest amendments, but at this time, opposed. Thank you. Good afternoon. John Kendrick from Cal Chamber, opposed unless amended. Thank you. Good afternoon, Chair. Brenda Contreras on behalf of Bay Area Council and Chamber of Progress in respectful opposition. Jack Giannis with Slogans Jensen on behalf of the Consumer Technology Association. We'll line our comments with the via. Thank you. Thank you to all the witnesses. Bringing it back to the committee, are there any members who would like to speak on the bill? Assemblymember Rubio. Just a couple questions about addressing the permits issued by the DMV versus the local governments. How is that going to work? That's one question. And then the issue about the flexibility about arrival. I'm from L.A. Like everything's 40 minutes away, even if it's four miles. and I know that that might be a factor. And I know San Jose, for example, is kind of the same way as San Francisco and pretty soon Sacramento is getting congested. So is there any flexibility for that, which is out of their control? So again, the primary one is the permits being issued by the DMV versus local entities and then the flexibility about how long it takes to arrive. Thank you, Samuel Rubio. So unfortunately, my opinion is unfortunate, we don't have local control of commercial ABs at this time. DMV has occupied that space. And with the exception of a bill that was done by Assemblymember Ting, you may recall, which took a step forward. I think he presented the bill often when he was here as taking a first step forward. We tried to build on that, but there's a limit to what we can do in terms of allowing the locals to do what they usually do with other motor vehicles, come in and enforce, establish congestion management areas, establish taxi stands and things like that. Those kinds of things are not allowed yet under state law. So we're just I think we're deferring to state law to the extent that we have to and then trying to do what we can within that framework. That said, your other question with regard to the 30 minutes, I want to be very, very clear. It's 30 minutes if the AV is interfering with first responder activities. It's not like they get fined if they're not there in 30 minutes. There's nobody else there yet. This isn't something that somebody's running a timer on. The question is the first responders are there. There's a collision. Could be somebody trapped inside the AV itself. We're trying to protect those passengers as well. First responders are trying to work around that situation. and obviously unlike a vehicle that we would drive, humans would drive, there's just nobody there to cooperate with what's going on. We find that to be a problem. At one earlier stage in this bill, we thought it was a much cleaner and more elegant solution to just say that emergency dispatch needs to be notified immediately. The AV technology allows that. Right now they're communicating with their own home offices, their own headquarters, their own remote drivers, their own remote assistance. That all happens real time, just like it would if you have an OnStar system in a Chevy. And we thought hey why don we do away with all this response stuff with human beings and just do it that way But that was negotiated out of the bill you know by mutual agreement with the opposition So we are where we are and we think we found spot. We're going to keep working on that. No, no, I just want to, I haven't, I didn't see it specifically articulated that way. That's why I was asking if, you know, because I completely understand what you're saying and I agree with that. But, you know, it's just that definition. If it's explicitly in there, maybe we can, you know, at least because you understand. I mean, and I completely understand that it's the star system, I think, is a perfect example that immediately notifies. So I could see if it's interfering with with, you know, emergency services. But the the definition, I guess, is what I'm looking for, just to be more specific. Appreciate that. It should be clear enough in the bill right now, given the amendments, but we'll be happy to get that to you afterwards. And we're happy to keep working with the opposition. This is literally one of those areas where there's been give and take for the last couple of months. Because it keeps evolving on a day-to-day basis. So I think those are my only questions. So thank you for that. And thank you for being willing to work with the opposition on those particular issues. Thank you. Thank you. We will continue to do so. Vice Chair Hoover. Thank you, Madam Chair. All right. So, Senator, you know, obviously the opposition raised quite a few concerns. I guess I just wanted to know, first off, like, if you're willing as we move forward, I know we're getting pretty late in the process here, to consider any of those potential amendments. It seems like something that could obviously help the bill move forward, but also help address some of the opposition's concerns. So I just wanted to see what your thoughts were on this. Yeah, what has been good about working with opposition and with the association on this, and you're an author, we sometimes run into oppose the last amendment or just oppose, and the amendments never come. And we don't really get the industry help in trying to hit the sweet spot, land where we need to land. We have had an ongoing back-and-forth negotiation that will continue almost by necessity on this right up to the end. And, of course, my hope that we're successful. Okay. So I think my other question is sort of related to a bill authored by a former member of the Assembly, Assemblymember Filting. those regulations, specifically referring to AB 1777, just went into effect today, I believe. And so, you know, I guess I feel like this bill is a little premature. I think that, you know, that bill got quite a bit of bipartisan support, I think was, that's a bill I even supported, despite, you know, having some initial concerns with it. Why is it that we shouldn't let, those regulations sort of run their course and see how those improve the public safety response process before we sort of jump into or put another layer on top of that. There's some things that the Ting Bill didn't address that we're talking about today, which seem very, very much to be necessities. The immobilization issue wasn't complete. I mean, this bill actually says that you can have two types of vehicles at least those that have steering wheels and those that don We just expanded on 1777 a little bit I mean it really only took it took a step It took two, geofencing and the right of first responders to intervene. I'll let the witnesses respond because obviously we have somebody here representing first responders. I think they could give a better response as to how we're trying to sort of graduate up from that bill a little bit, especially on behalf of first responders. Thank you. And thank you for the question. I think you're correct. Most of that bill goes into effect today. It's been a year and a half since that bill was passed. And I think in that year and a half, we've recognized some deficiencies. We were not in support of the previous bill. We were actually asking for more to be included in that bill. And so for a few reasons, one the author just mentioned, which is the way the first responder interaction is, I guess, discussed in that bill, is that if the vehicle has a manual override system, then the first responders will get trained on how to do it. And in the last year and a half, we've learned a lot more about a lot of the, I think, path going forward for the AV companies. And most of them, we've been told, don't have manual override systems or steering wheels, like you've heard. So we think that that bill will still address the AVs that have that system. But the bill SB 1246 will address both. So the vehicles who don't have a way or a mechanism for first responders to actually interact with the vehicle directly themselves, this will address those other, capture those other instances, if that makes sense. Okay. So I think I would just, I'll just end on some comments here. You know, I, we recently had an informational hearing on this topic in the Assembly Transportation Committee. I would say that the testimony there conflicted quite a bit with sort of what I'm hearing here. We actually had police and fire personnel from San Francisco to testifying that companies are working very well with public safety officials, that there's obviously always learning things that we're learning and processes, but that things are definitely improving based on not just the bills that we've passed, but the DMV regulations based on just better practices being established. And so I personally don't see the necessity of this legislation. I also continue to remain concerned with some of your previous legislation, such as SB 915, that sort of, I think, goes after the industry more directly. and just overall concerned about putting these things into statute. I think the current system that we have right now is working very well. It's very flexible. We have CHP and DMV managing regulations and adjusting those regulations as time goes on and as technology improves and as technology changes. I mean, as you know, I know there's companies in California that were born in California that are operating in California that have technologies that don't have a steering wheel, They don't have some of the things that are sort of in this legislation. And I worry that by putting something like this in statute, we're actually limiting what we can do in California from a technological perspective. I think you know I would just close by asking the opposition you know is there more that do you think can be done with this legislation that you know in terms of amendments that would make this more workable And if so are you willing to continue working with the author as we move forward Yeah, yes. We have sent over recently. There was a lot of amendments taken in the previous committee and kind of had the dust settle from there and have everybody review the changes. and what emerged from that is a bill that's improved much since then. And then what I laid out today are basically five main issues that we still want to address. And the author's office is actually meeting and the sponsors are meeting with us on Thursday to talk about that. And we just gave them the language a couple of days ago. Okay. Yeah. Thank you for that. I think just in closing, I think I would greatly appreciate, you know, those changes being considered. I think until that point, I will be voting no today. but I appreciate you bringing the bill forward. Thank you. Any other comments from committee? Okay. That with that, Senator, you may close. Thank you again, very much. Um, I do believe longterm, this is going to be an iterative process. Um, not just with this bill today. And I, I think the Tings, uh, bill basically was, um, you know, the first, advancement of any kind in terms of beginning to deal with commercial AVs as motor vehicles in terms of their interaction with first responders and other motorists, pedestrians, bicyclists, and others like we've been doing ever since Henry Ford established the first assembly line. And to the credit of the automobile industry, and as you know, Chair of Transportation on the Senate side, and yes, we had an informational hearing, and yes, this bill is very, very consistent with what we heard there. The automobile industry, the traditional automobile industry up to this point has done a tremendous job of cooperating with federal regulation and state regulation. They have a culture of give and take. And look, we're introducing something that's out in the public, that's out on the roads, and we're going to have to figure it out. That's how we got curves and gutters and streetlights, stop signs and stoplights, WL lines, broken lines, motor vehicle tests. And there is going to have to be this, this dance that we do for lack of a better way to put it, you know, to, to ultimately get to the place of just the right balance of embracing this innovation and making sure that there's public safety all the way around. So with that and in that spirit, I would, I would respectfully ask for your, I vote. Thank you, Senator, for bringing this forward. I think it's really important that the opposition has moved from opposed to opposed unless amended. It's encouraging when you say Thursday, I assume you mean tomorrow, so that those last five things could be addressed as it moves out of that. I trust the senator to continue working on these final remaining issues. You want to have appropriate emergency response times. You want to be able to move these vehicles out of the way, keep our community safe. You also want it to be feasible. ambitious and feasible. It's the theme of today's C&C hearing. And with that, we have a motion by Lowenthal, second by Rogers. The motion on SB 1246 by Senator Cortese is due pass and may refer to the Committee on Appropriations. Will the secretary please call the roll? Berner? Aye. Berner, aye. Hoover, no. Bonta, Colosa, aye. Castillo, not voting. Krell, aye. Lowenthal, aye. Rogers, aye. Rubio, aye. Rubio, aye. Aye. The bill is out. Are we holding it open? Oh, yeah. We're holding it open for absent members. Thank you so much. Members, that concludes the bill of presentations for the day. Can the secretary please check and see if there's still items on call? This is for SB 739. Hoover? Aye. Hoover, aye. Castillo? SB 739? Aye. Castillo, aye. Lowenthal? Aye. Lowenthal, aye. This is for the consent item SB 985. Hoover? Aye. Hoover, aye. This is for SB 1190. Hoover? Aye. Hoover, aye. This is for SB 1191. John Hoover? Aye. Hoover, aye. Yeah. We're at a presence. I have no idea. But I can hang for a minute. Yeah, you can hang for a minute. Yeah. And it was going to have a concert talk. She said, you want to go to the . I mean, I can wait for a few minutes. Yeah, well. Because I'm in privacy next door, so I'll just. I have to go down. If you're there for that hearing. Can I have a recess? And then when I'm done voting, back up here. Do it. She's presenting right now. She's presenting. You should go to recess. You could go to recess. What's the better plan? Recess and we wait for her to add on? Let me see what she does. Yeah. Let me follow her. I want to get down. Yeah, because like privacy and ed are going to be going for a while. So I'm not in a victory. So that's not the problem. Every case is . But it's fine. Other people can do that. OK, she's going to have to talk to the chair.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Sure.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Okay.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Okay, so then could you like close a roll?

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

No, I don't… Okay because my chair is also willing to recess and come back or we can hold the roll over But if you wouldn't like it, she's still presenting. And she may not want to walk over.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Okay.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Okay.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you Thank you

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

We're going to recess the C&C committee and give time for Assemblymember Bonta to finish up presenting and when she's on her way back over we'll reconvene.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

All right.

John Finleywitness

Thank you so much.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

I appreciate it.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Okay, resuming the communications and conveyance hearing. Secretary, please call the roll. This is for SB 739. Bonta?

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Aye.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Bonta, aye. SB 739, Errigine, that bill is out, 8 to 0. Sorry that bill correction that bill is out 9 to 0 This is for our consent calendar SB 985 Strickland Bonta?

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Aye.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Bonta, aye. Consent calendar, SB 985 Strickland. That bill is out 9-0. This is for SB 1190 Grove. Bonta? Aye. Bonta, aye. SB 1190 Grove. That bill is out. Nine to zero. This is for SB 1191 Ochoa Bo. Bonta? Aye. Bonta, aye. SB 1191, Echobo. That bill is out, 9-0. This is for SB 1246, Cortese.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Bonta, aye.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Bonta, aye. SB 1246 Cortese, that bill is out. 7 to 1.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

And that concludes this year's...

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Oh.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

When I'm done.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

We now lifted the call.

Tasha Boerner Horvathother

Hold on. Members, that concludes the work of the Assembly Committee on Communications and Conveyances today.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

And hopefully for this session, we are adjourned. Woo-hoo.

John Finleywitness

Thank you.

Malcolm McFarland IIwitness

Thank you.

Source: Assembly Communications And Conveyance Committee · July 1, 2026 · Gavelin.ai