Skip to main content
Committee HearingSenate

PA Senate Health and Human Services — 2026-10-06

October 6, 2026 · HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES · 2,183 words · 7 speakers · 66 segments

Chair Brookschair

Good afternoon, everyone. I call to order this meeting of the Senate Health and Human Services Committee. David, will you please call the roll? Capiletti? Here. Collette? Here. Culver? Here. Ferry? Here. Haywood? Here. Hutchison? Here. Laughlin? Proxy? Schwenk? Here. Stefano? Here. Street. Ward Judy. Proxy. Ward Kim. Proxy. Brooks. Here. We have a quorum. The first bill on today's agenda is Senate Bill 865, sponsored by myself, which adds metatomidine to emergency department urine drug screening requirements and provides for awareness education. I will move to consider the bill. Is there a second? Seconded by Senator Hutchinson. This bill is similar to the bill signed into law in 2023 with xylazine as it emerged as a serious threat in the illicit drug supply. Metatomidine is now an ongoing and serious problem and this bill will help us identify its presence through emergency department screening and make sure Pennsylvanians understand the dangers of human use. Are there any questions or comments

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

on the bill? Senator Haywood. Thank you for introducing this legislation. It's clear to me this will strengthen our emergency department screening and the protocols so that we can hopefully protect patients from the consequences of these new drugs. This bill, amongst many others, advances our commitment to public awareness and ensuring communities have information they need to stay safe. Thank you for the legislation.

Chair Brookschair

Thank you, Senator. Any other comments or questions? Seeing none, hearing none, Dave, will you please call the roll?

Capiletti? Collette? Culver? Ferry? Haywood? Hutchinson? Laughlin? Proxy, aye. Stefano? Aye. Street? Aye. Ward Judy? Proxy, aye. Oh, sorry, Judy. Sorry. Ward Kim? Proxy, aye. Brooks? Here. Or, aye.

Chair Brookschair

Senate Bill 865 passes unanimously and is reported out of committee. The next bill on today's agenda is Senate Bill 1145, sponsored again by myself, which requires the Department of Health to verify whether health care facilities are complying with mandatory reporting requirements for suspected child sexual abuse or exploitation. Takes steps to file the report, if not, and provides for penalties for failure to file. As we all know, that human trafficking is unfortunately increasing. So that is one of the thoughts behind this legislation is to make sure that if minor children are coming in and being treated for things that they did not consent to, that those reports are done and hopefully we can track them. Any questions or comments on the bill?

The prior roll on Senate Bill 865, Senator Schwenk, your name was not recorded.

Yes. And aye.

Thank you very much.

Chair Brookschair

so again Senate Bill 865 passes unanimously is it budget time it just seems like it but so all right I will move to consider the bill is there a second seconded by Senator Stefano any questions or comments on the bill

thank you

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

So this legislation reinforces our shared responsibility to protect children by ensuring the health care facilities meet mandatory reporting requirements. We understand there are some concerns about Senate Bill 1145 and that the administration is working to resolve some of those concerns but I did want to note that I will certainly be a yes on the legislation.

Chair Brookschair

Thank you. Thank you, Senator Haywood. Any other comments or questions on the bill? David, will you please call the roll?

Capoletti. Colette. Aye. Culver. Aye. Ferry. Aye. Haywood. Aye. Hutchinson. Aye. Laughlin. Proxy, aye. Schwenk. Aye. Stefano. Aye. Street. Aye. Ward Judy. Aye. Ward Kim. Proxy, aye. Brooks. Aye. I'm sorry, 12 to 1. I'm taking your party.

Chair Brookschair

Senate Bill 1145 passes by a vote of 12 to 1 and is reported out of committee. The next bill on today's agenda is Senate Bill 1147, sponsored by Senator Masteryano, which provides medical assistance reimbursement to licensed EMS agencies for emergency services provided to patients who decline or do not require transportation. I will move the bill, seconded by Senator Hutchinson.

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

I am a co-sponsor of Senate Bill 1147, and I support ensuring that our EMS agencies are reimbursed for the care they provide, even when a patient ultimately does not need or declines transportation. EMS providers are a lifeline to our communities, and they most certainly are struggling, especially in rural areas. They spend time, resources, and effort going to calls whether or not the patient needs or wants to be transported, and I feel very strongly that they should be compensated for their time, labor, and costs. Are there any questions or comments on the bill?

Chair Brookschair

Senator Haywood.

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

Thank you again for this legislation. This supports our frontline responders and enhances the sustainability of emergency medical services across our communities, particularly communities that are in such high need. I'll be in favor of this legislation as well. Any other comments or questions?

Chair Brookschair

David, will you please call the roll? Capoletti.

Aye. Collette. Aye. Culver. Aye. Ferry. Aye.

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

Haywood.

Haywoodother

Aye.

Hutchinson.

Hutchinsonother

Aye.

Laughlin.

Hutchinsonother

Proxy, aye.

Schwenk.

Schwenkother

Aye.

Stefano.

Stefanoother

Aye.

Street.

Streetother

Aye.

Ward Judy.

Streetother

Aye.

Ward Kim.

Streetother

Proxy, aye.

Brooks.

Brooksother

Aye.

Chair Brookschair

Senate Bill 1147 passes unanimously and is reported out of committee. The next bill on today's agenda is Senate Bill 1196, sponsored by Senator Tartaglione, which prohibits Medicaid and commercial insurers from imposing less favorable coverage on non-opioid pain medications than are offered for opioid medications. Is there a motion to consider the bill? Moved by Senator Haywood, seconded by Senator Schwenk. I would like to recognize Senator Tartaglian.

Senator Tartagliansenator

Thank you very much for being here. Thank you, Chairman Brooks, Chairman Haywood, and members of the Health and Human Services Committee, and thank you for your consideration of Senate Bill 1196. The purpose of this legislation is simple. If you are in pain and require treatment to manage this pain, you should be able to avoid using opioids if you wish. Yes, opioids are an essential and life-saving tool in the toolkit of pain management. There is no disputing that. That's why this legislation does not change or reduce the ability for medical professionals to prescribe opioids for pain treatment. However, it is also no secret that opioids are addictive and their overprescription can lead to accidental cases of opioid use disorder with disastrous and fatal consequences. There should never be a scenario where a doctor is recommending against opioids and the patient doesn't want them either, but for insurance costs purposes the patient has to try and fail an opioid first before accessing a non drug In turn, Senate Bill 1196 would eliminate this scenario and also generally allows for equal access to non-opioid alternatives for both Medicaid and the commercial insurance market. On the Medicaid side, this bill will prohibit DHS from disadvantaging non-opioid medications through the use of preferred or non-preferred drug designations or imposing tighter utilization controls. On the commercial side, the bill does the same while also requiring parity between opioids and non-opioids in coverage criteria and cost-sharing. Signing Senate Bill 1196 into law would also be timely as earlier this year, the USDA issued its first promising non-opioid pain management drug in decades called Duranex. Finally, it is my understanding that the department may be opposed to this legislation at this time. In response, I want to stress my willingness to work with them and other stakeholders through any concerns for the remainder of this session or in the future. It is important to offer non-opioid alternatives for pain management and to ensure Pennsylvania isn't lagging behind in granting access to these drugs, but there are issues with our approach. I am open to discussion. For now, I urge an affirmative vote. Thank you.

Chair Brookschair

Any questions or comments on the bill? Senator Haywood.

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

Thank you so much for this legislation to remove barriers that prevent patients from accessing non-opioid treatments. This is an important pathway for recovery. As a longtime lawyer for Gardenzia, I'm very familiar with some non-opioid treatments that do work. Making sure that there's parity and coverage and covering these procedures is a significant step forward. Thank you for this legislation.

Chair Brookschair

Thank you, Senator Haywood. Senator Hutchinson?

Hutchinsonother

Thank you. Sorry, I don't know the answer to this, but maybe, I don't know if Senator Tyrone can answer it, or staff, maybe. Would this cover medical marijuana?

Senator Tartagliansenator

I am not sure. I don't believe it does, but I could be wrong. I probably should have figured that question out before this meeting. I'm sorry.

Chair Brookschair

All right. Senator Hutchinson, we don't think it will, but we will look into it. And when it comes to the floor, we will ensure that your question is answered.

Hutchinsonother

Thank you. I appreciate that.

Chair Brookschair

Senator Street.

Senator Streetsenator

Yeah. There are other things that would prevent medical marijuana from being paid out of any insurance disbursement funds, whether they be Medicaid or private insurance currently, so nothing in this legislation would impact that.

Chair Brookschair

Thank you, Senator Street. Does that answer your question, Senator Hutchins?

Hutchinsother

Senator, I want to thank you for this legislation. It most certainly is common sense. I think on a daily or weekly basis, I think we read articles of folks that have become addicted because of an injury or opioid use, you know, that was prescribed to them. So it just seems like common sense that we would do this in a step forward to combat the opioid epidemic. And I want to thank you for the legislation.

Senator Tartagliansenator

Absolutely.

Chair Brookschair

David, will you please call the roll?

Brooksother

Capoletti. Hi. Colette Aye Culver Aye Ferry Proxy Aye Haywood Aye Hutchinson Aye Laughlin Proxy Aye Schwenk Aye Stefano Aye Street Aye Ward Judy Aye Ward Kim Proxy aye

Chair Brookschair

Brooks? Aye. Senate Bill 1196 passes unanimously and is reported out of committee. Congratulations. Thank you for your work on this.

Senator Tartagliansenator

Absolutely.

Chair Brookschair

The final bill on today's agenda is Senate Bill 1424, sponsored by Senator Capaletti, which adds Gaucher disease to Pennsylvania's newborn child screening program.

Senator Capilanisenator

I will move the bill.

Chair Brookschair

Is there a second? Seconded by Senator Haywood. Senator Capaletti, would you like to speak on your bill?

Senator Capilanisenator

Thank you so much, Chair Brooks and Chair Haywood, and the entire committee for your interest in Senate Bill 1424. As you mentioned, this legislation is essential in ensuring that newborns across the Commonwealth are adequately screened for Gaucher disease. For those who don't know, Gaucher disease is a rare genetic disorder wherein a person is missing a critical enzyme that breaks down fatty substances or lipids in your body. And without that enzyme, the lipids or fatty substances, they'll build up in certain areas of your body, resulting in an enlarged spleen and enlarged liver, anemia, or even bone fractures, among many other debilitating symptoms. Gaucher disease can also increase a person's risk of Parkinson's disease, various forms of cancer, and gynecological or obstetric issues. And while there is no cure for Gaucher disease yet, we know that early detection is vital to an early diagnosis and prompt access to treatment that can improve someone's quality of life as the disease progresses. When I gave birth to my two daughters, my husband and I wanted to ensure that we did everything we could to set our girls up to live a safe, healthy life. I know I'm not the only parent who feels this way. In fact, I believe every parent in this Commonwealth deserves to have the peace of mind when it comes to their child's well-being. And Senate Bill 1424 will help deliver that by adding Gaucher disease to the list of Pennsylvania's new board screening panel. It's a simple common sense measure to alleviate some symptoms of this lifelong disease poses. So I want to thank Chairwoman Brooks and Chairman Haywood for prioritizing this legislation that will support our constituents' health and well-being from birth and onward. I ask for an affirmative vote for my colleagues. Thank you.

Chair Brookschair

Thank you, Senator Capilani. Thank you for the legislation. Senator Haywood?

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

Thank you so much. This is a very important step toward expanding newborn screening. We know that this legislation will underscore our fundamental commitment to giving every child the best possible start in life.

Chair Brookschair

Thank you, Senator Capaletti. I do want to let the members of the committee know that with the information that we have, it is an approximate cost of less than a dollar for this test. that the test can be performed with the blood draw that's already taken with other screenings and that no other new equipment would be required. And early detection is important for the quality of life for the child. So, Senator Capaletti, thank you for introducing the legislation. Are there any other questions or comments on the bill? Seeing none, hearing none, David, will you please call the roll?

Brooksother

Capoletti? Aye. Collette? Aye. Culver? Aye. Ferry? Proxy, aye. Hutchison? Aye. Laughlin? Proxy, aye. Schwenk? Aye. Stefano? Aye. Street? Aye. Ward Judy? Aye. Ward Kim? Proxy, aye. Brooks? Aye.

Chair Brookschair

Would you call Senator Haywood?

Senator Arthur Haywoodsenator

Senator Haywood.

Chair Brookschair

Senate Bill 1424 passes unanimously and is reported out of committee. That concludes today's agenda. Having no other business before the committee, the committee stands in recess. Until the call of the chair, I would like to thank the members on this busy day.

Source: PA Senate Health and Human Services — 2026-10-06 · October 6, 2026 · Gavelin.ai