November 10, 2026 · Assembly Public Hearing on Concession Pricing Fairness · 12,543 words · 8 speakers · 93 segments
All right. Good morning. Oh, the mic is on. So good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us. I'm Assemblywoman Nealey Rosick, Chair of the Consumer Protection Committee in the State Assembly. I want to thank the members who are attending today's hearing. We have from the majority Assemblywoman Torres and Assemblymember Patrick Carroll. To my left is Assemblymember Brian Miller, Assemblymember Derso, and Assemblymember Jensen. I want to say thank you to my committee staff, Michael Sullivan, Sky Matthews, and Allison Dewar, and thank you to all of our witnesses who will be joining us today to present testimony. We also have submitted testimony from the New York Thruway Authority, Delaware North, and apple green New York travel plazas. We will be posting all of the testimony that you'll hear from today and the ones that have been submitted on the consumer webpage at a later date for the sake of transparency and everyone having the information. Today we are examining an issue that almost every New Yorker has experienced and one that increasingly affects families, visitors, and everyday consumers. the cost of food and beverages at publicly funded venues and facilities. Whether you're taking your kids to a sporting event, spending the afternoon at a state park or a beach, traveling through an airport, or stopping at a rest stop, the experience of purchasing food and drinks has become increasingly expensive. And for many consumers, these aren't optional purchases in the traditional sense. At many venues, outside food and beverages are restricted or prohibited altogether. Two years ago, the Consumer Protection Committee actually passed legislation to allow for reusable water bottles at certain venues, and so that's just one step, tiny step, in trying to bring some balance there. That means families who want a snack for their kids or something to eat during a long event really have no realistic alternative but to purchase from the venue's concession operator. A bottle of water that costs a fraction of the price outside a stadium can suddenly cost several times as much inside. A family attending a game or spending the day at a facility can find themselves paying a significant premium simply because of where they happen to be. And, you know, that's widely reported. The Buffalo News did a big story at the start of Bill's season about how much it would cost a family of four, and that was hundreds if not thousands of dollars. So we have to ask ourselves, at what point does convenience become an exploitation of a captive consumer? And that brings us to one central concept, which we will examine today, called street pricing. Street pricing is the idea that consumers should be able to purchase everyday goods and refreshments at prices reasonably comparable to what they would pay outside the venue. Rather than imposing substantial markups simply because the consumer has limited alternatives, venues and concession operators should consider pricing practices that reflect fairness, transparency, and today's buzzword, affordability. Of course, we recognize that operating concessions come with real costs. Vendors have staffing expenses labor costs supply chains rent equipment and other operational considerations We also recognize that concession agreements and business models vary significantly across venues including in New York City where it really expensive to operate Our goal today is not to dismiss those realities or suggest that every venue must operate under an identical model. We want to better understand how prices are determined, what drives up the markups, and whether there are reasonable standards or best practices across the industry that can protect consumers without undermining the viability of concession operations. And that means looking at more than just a sticker price. It means examining whether prices are clearly disclosed, whether consumers have meaningful alternatives, and what kind of oversight mechanisms are in place to ensure fair practices. So today we're going to hear from some stakeholders across the industry and from those who advocate on behalf of consumers. Honestly, I wish that more of the stadiums and actual venues chose to be represented here today. Many of them declined to comment or declined our invitation, but I hope that they are still watching. Ultimately, consumers should not have to choose between participating in a family outing, enjoying a public space, or staying within their budget. Fair pricing, transparency, and consumer choice should not be luxuries. They should be part of the experience New Yorkers can expect when they visit our public facilities or a game. So thank you again to all the witnesses. Thank you to my colleagues who are here. I look forward to a productive discussion. A bit of housekeeping. We only have two panels today, so it should go fairly quickly. The first panel, each panelist will have five minutes to present, and then the chair and the ranker will each have five minutes of questions, and then everyone else will have three minutes. Okay? With that, I'll just turn it over really quickly to my chair, Mr. Miller.
Well, thank you for having this hearing today. This has been an issue throughout New York State, the country, all over the place. You know, the consumer is getting gouged at, you know, a lot of the venues or a lot of the, let's say, closed markets that are out there. and we're looking forward to having some testimony on this. Thank you.
Great. Okay, with that, our first panelist is Mr. D'Angelo. He's the Chief Deputy Attorney General for Economic Justice from the Office of the New York State Attorney General. Take it away.
Good morning, everybody. Good morning, Chair Rosick and committee members. My name is Chris D'Angelo, and I am the Chief Deputy Attorney General for Economic Justice at the New York State Attorney General's Office. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today on this very important topic. We are in an affordability crisis, and we know that consumers across the state are being gouged for everything from basic necessities to specialty items and experiences that involve entertainment. Attorney General James in our office is deeply concerned by reports of profiteering in state theaters, and other places where consumers do not have ready alternatives to in-house sellers. Like you, we have read with concern about things like FIFA's policy banning outside water bottles at World Cup games in a transparent attempt to force consumers to purchase extremely expensive stadium water reversed only after fierce public backlash. Also, the Saratoga Performing Arts Center or SPAC which bans outside lawn chairs during outdoor Live Nation concerts instead requiring rental of those lawn chairs via Live Nation for each a policy that has been maintained despite a jury having found Live Nation to be an illegal monopoly based on a lawsuit brought by the New York Attorney General and 33 other state attorney generals. Price inflation at Major League Baseball has gotten outrageous, where an average fan who spent $5 on a beer and a hot dog in 1985, $15 in today's money, now spends as much as $20 on a single beer. When a consumer is at an entertainment venue, such as an arena or a sports stadium, the venue decides who will sell the food inside the venue and also decides whether the venue will allow outside food to be brought in. Although there may be competition for the right to sell inside that venue, those decisions are made by the venues with their own bottom line and not the consumer's best interest as the key consideration. And once inside the venue, the consumer is captive. If the venue does not permit outside food, the consumer must purchase from a venue's concessionaires if they want something to eat or drink while at the event. The impact on families is particularly significant. We are long past the day where kid-sized meals at ballparks were charged at kid-sized prices. Given the venue's control over the consumer's choices, is it any surprise that prices are suddenly double or triple what they would have been when consumers have easy access to goods sold by competitors or are able to bring in their own food or drink? The existing enforcement tools are not targeted to these harms. The Donnelly Act, the state's antitrust statute, applies to anti-competitive conduct, but whether it can address concession pricing would turn on specific facts and anti-competitive conduct not applicable to these general facts here. Likewise, whether or not consumer protection laws like the Fair Business Practice Act would apply would depend on the specific facts and circumstances of each case and not apply to specific pricing decisions within a particular venue. But we think there are several common sense policy prescriptions to address the most egregious price increases. First, we encourage the legislature to require that stadiums and other entertainment venues allow consumers to bring in their own food and non-alcoholic beverages. Where venues do not have chairs, they should be allowed to bring their own chairs. Directly allowing competition from outside the venue to compete with in-venue options is a straightforward way to increase consumers' options, including low-priced outside venue options, while respecting the venue's ability to provide unique offerings. It is also an important public health measure in this era of extreme temperatures and climate change to ensure that there are minimal impediments to spectators receiving proper hydration. We also recognize that venues need the ability to impose reasonable restrictions on things brought from outside, in part to ensure they comply with liquor license conditions, but many venues have already managed to strike a reasonable balance between these concerns and allowing consumers to bring in their own materials. If these venues can allow consumers to bring their own food and drink already while addressing legitimate safety and compliance concerns, there is no legitimate reason why all major venues and stadiums should not allow consumers to do the same. Venues should not be allowed to artificially restrict competition for food and drink for no reason other than pumping up their profits. Second and more importantly the legislature could build on the work of the Port Authority in bills like the one that been proposed by Chair Rosick The Port Authority currently has a restriction on airport concessions that is tied to street prices Now, they allow a certain amount of a surcharge on top of that. I think we would like to see that surcharge be much more limited than the one that the Port Authority currently allows for. But in the way the Port Authority structure is set up today, if an airport seller has the same kind of store in New York or the New Jersey area outside of the airport, think a Starbucks, then the price that they charge at the airport has to be the same price that they charge outside. Second, if the airport seller only operates in the airport, their prices are pegged to the average price regularly charged in the metro area by similar retailers for the same or similar area. This is similar to how price gouging works in abnormal market conditions and is measured under New York state law already. There are obviously edge cases in these rules, and so the Port Authority does allow some cushion for prices that are higher than the standards set out above. Such a cushion may be warranted, but any state law should keep any margin extremely limited. The Port Authority's rules are built on state law already. The state should now return the favor and build on these Port Authority rules for a statewide law that says very simply that whatever you charge inside one of these captive consumer spaces needs to be what you charge outside. In setting out these examples, I've used the word price a lot. Obviously, it would not be okay for vendors to subject to these laws we propose to get around them by setting the price at one level and then adding hidden fees or surcharges at the register. The Port Authority, for example, allows certain surcharges to be added on top of the threshold amount that they allow above the street price. we would recommend that any state law does not allow for such surcharges. We also believe that it's high time for New York to adopt a comprehensive, loophole-free, no-hidden-fees law for the entire state. We believe the New York City DCWP rules in this area that were recently adopted are a great model to build on statewide. In crafting any policy in this area, it is most helpful for us as enforcers and for venues as regulated parties to have clear objective criteria against which to compare a business's compliance. And for that, we also recommend that there be reasonably sized penalties to ensure that violating the law is not just the cost of doing business. I thank the committee and Chair Rosick for providing the opportunity to share input on this important topic. Our office will continue to aggressively protect New Yorkers, whether they are at a ballgame or at a concert or anywhere in the state. Thank you.
Thanks so much. So I'll start with a few questions. You've mentioned the Fair Business Act, which we did a few years ago as well through the committee. You've mentioned antitrust laws. But why kind of talk us through how these situations are not price gouging? You've got, especially, it's one thing at a venue, but I'm thinking of the case where you're on the throughway and you're a captive audience to whatever's in that one building for the next 40 miles. You are a captive consumer in that situation. So how is that situation not price gouging? Or what is the interplay between the current price gouging laws that are on the books and situations like this.
Yeah, I mean, so price gouging ordinarily is a very limited concept, and it's a limited concept in New York state law, which applies to abnormal disruptions. And those abnormal disruptions are defined in the statute as things like extreme weather events or war or some other market event that isn't the type of just an ordinary ballgame or just being in a particular venue that exists in the world on any given day. And so the price gouging law, as it's been designed, is designed for those extreme, unusual events, not for something that happens in the ordinary course of day-to-day business. What we have is just an industry where there's a market failure and competition isn't working because the only place where there's competition is for the right to sell at the venue. And there, the venue is only making that decision on the basis of their own best interest. And because they have monopoly power, right, they are the monopolists. They are the only ones that control that particular venue and that particular market. They are able to make decisions that raise prices to whatever the highest price is that a consumer would be willing to pay. But unfortunately, competition laws also are not a great fit for this either because there's nothing inherently illegal. New York law and federal law does not make it illegal to be a monopolist or to charge monopoly prices. What it makes it illegal to do is to obtain that monopoly by doing something to thwart competition elsewhere. And so you're allowed to be a monopolist in the United States and in New York. You just can't become a monopolist or maintain that monopoly by doing something that harms another competitor. So those laws don't really fit here either. But that doesn't take away from the fact that we have a market failure because when you show up at this monopolist venue, you can't vote with your feet in the way that you would if you were walking down Main Street. and you can say, well, that coffee shop is charging me $5 for a cup of coffee and that one's willing to charge me $3 for a cup of coffee and I don't think that the $5 cup of coffee is worth the – there's no quality benefit, so I'm going to choose the $3 cup of coffee and every consumer can make that decision for themselves. But when you have a venue here where you can't vote with your feet and choose a different vendor, you lose that price competition that exists in the ordinary world.
Okay. And then I'm going to let maybe my colleagues talk about the hidden fees portion, the junk fees portion of it, but is there current things that your office does if someone brings a complaint about these situations? I mean, I guess in the case of the $15 launchers, is there enforcement that's currently happening within your office? What does that picture look like?
Well, I would say on the topic of the $15 launch here, as you know, we have litigated a case to try to break up Live Nation's monopoly because not only is each individual venue a monopolist, but Live Nation is a monopolist because they own 70% of the arenas, the concert arenas in this country and we're hoping that the you know we we've won on liability and we hope and expect that the judge will on remedies break up live nation's illegal monopoly though you know we've had some mixed success in getting that kind of a remedy in these cases so so we do have some enforcement that we can do in under particular facts and circumstances but the laws that we have on the books today are not well suited to address the problem of a particular venue that has vendors that are charging excessive prices in a situation that doesn't otherwise trigger the price gouging laws.
Got it. But there's no effort to maybe look at the actual contracts that the Thruway Authority signed with X vendor or is there any oversight in terms of that side of things?
We're not in the position to review each individual contract. I think if we had reports that vendors were operating outside of the restrictions that the Port Authority does place on them, that would be something we would want to take a look at more closely. So if the surcharges, which, again, we view as too high already, if the surcharges and excess pricing that the Port Authority allows are also still being exceeded, if there are reports of that, I think we would want to take a close look at it. We have not received those types of complaints, but we would welcome them for sure.
This page shows part of the transcript. The full transcript is available on request.