Skip to main content
Committee HearingAssembly

Assembly Select Committee Growing And Retaining Creative Economy California

October 29, 2026 · Select Growing And Retaining Creative Economy California · 33,626 words · 11 speakers · 156 segments

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . Thank you. are about to begin. Good morning. Thank you. Thank you.

Chair Zaburchair

I need help with the technical features of this.

Chair Zuburrchair

Good morning. I want to welcome everyone to the inaugural hearing of this select committee, which Speaker Robert Revis recently created to explore opportunities to protect California's status as an iconic hub for global talent and to identify policy solutions to ensure that California is not only a place to start a business or a career in the creative economy, but the best place to grow one. With my district bringing home to thousands of highly skilled professionals in the creative industries including in Hollywood, West Hollywood, and Santa Monica, I'm grateful to Speaker Rivas for appointing me chair and grateful for my colleagues for joining us today on this committee. Before I share some opening comments, I'd like to introduce Maury McIntyre, President and CEO of the Television Academy to welcome you all to the historic Wolf Theater in the Television Academy Saban Media Center. Thank you for graciously hosting us today, Maury.

Maury McIntyrewitness

Thank you so much. Good morning, everyone. To Jaris Spur, members of the committee, all of our guests here, it is my pleasure to welcome you to the Wolf Theater here at the Sivan Media Center for the inaugural hearing of the Select Committee on Growing and Retaining the Creative Economy. The Television Academy represents nearly 30,000 television professionals across 31 peer groups, spanning every craft in our industry. Roughly two-thirds of our members, that's about 20,000 people, live and work right here in California. They are the writers and producers, costumers and camera operators, editors and makeup artists, and countless other professionals whose talent and ingenuity bring the stories we love to life They are what makes California the global capital of the television industry Keeping that industry strong keeping that industry a vibrant part of California and its economy depends upon the livelihoods they build and the communities that grow around their work. From the thousands of crew members on set to the hundreds of small businesses that support a local production, California's creative economy reaches far beyond the screen. And that's what makes today so consequential. By convening this committee, the assembly is recognizing the importance of the creative workforce and the shared responsibility to ensure California remains a place where creative talent can thrive, build careers, and shape the future of our industry. Chair Zabur, thank you for your leadership, and thank you to every member of the committee for your commitment to California's creative future in a rapidly changing landscape. And on behalf of the Television Academy and our members, welcome to all of you. We're proud to host this conversation, and we look forward to keeping California a place where the world's most compelling stories are created and shared. Thank you so much.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you. Thank you, Maury, and thank you again to the Television Academy for hosting this important conversation. And now we're bringing the Select Committee on Growing and Retaining the Creative Economy in California to order. California's creative industries are among our state's greatest economic strengths, supporting hundreds of thousands of jobs and generating billions of dollars in economic activity. The charter of this Select Committee is broad to include the creative economy, extending well beyond the film and television to include visual effects, post-production, live theater, advertising, and emerging entertainment and communications platforms. Our goal is to examine the challenges and opportunities facing all of these industries and identify ways to ensure they continue to thrive here in California. These industries support an extraordinary network of artists, performers, writers, technicians, craftspeople, and small businesses that have helped make California a global leader in creativity and innovation. But that leadership is not guaranteed. Indeed, other states and countries are investing aggressively to attract California productions, California businesses, and California's highly skilled workers. In future hearings, we'll focus on other parts of the creative economy. But today, we're beginning with one of its most important foundations, California's film and television industry. And we have an important foundation to build on. Over the past two years, the legislature and Governor Newsom have taken significant steps to strengthen California's competitiveness in the film and television industry. Last year, I worked closely with the governor, my legislative colleagues here, industry leaders, labor partners, to expand and modernize California's film and television tax credit program. Together we more than doubled the program's annual funding to $750 million, expanded eligibility, strengthened incentives to bring productions and good-paying jobs back to California, and enhanced diversity provisions in both the 3.0 and 4.0 programs to advance our ongoing commitment to building a more diverse and inclusive entertainment workforce. And we're already beginning to see that impact. In the first year of the expanded program, California awarded tax credits to 170 film and television projects, representing $6.6 billion in projected economic activity and nearly 35,000 projected cast and crew jobs across the state. But this year we faced another challenge when unintended consequences of the state corporate tax credit limitations threatened to undermine the program effectiveness I believed it was critical that we protect the integrity of a program that was already capped and fully allocated in the state budget We all together on this stage fought alongside others in the State Senate and many other stakeholders here today to advance SB 186, which Governor Newsom signed last month, to strengthen the program and provide greater certainty for productions and workers. I want to reiterate my thanks to Governor Newsom, Senate President Pro Tem Monique Lamone, and Speaker Rivas for their leadership in protecting this important investment. I also want to thank the Motion Picture Association, the Directors Guild of America, and importantly the Entertainment Union Coalition representing more than 167,000 entertainment industry workers for their tireless advocacy and commitment to keeping good-paying entertainment jobs here in California. And I want to recognize Colleen Bell and the California Film Commission for their leadership in administering the program and their continued work to support film and television production throughout our state. But while we've made important progress, we know that there's much, much more work that needs to be done. Specifically, we know California's film tax credit is not yet competitive with other states and countries that are luring our jobs away. And that's what today's hearing is about. Today's hearing will help us examine that work through three important discussions. Our first panel will focus on maintaining and growing California's iconic film and television industry. We'll hear from industry and labor leaders about the importance of film and television jobs, the challenges facing workers and productions, and what California must do to retain the extraordinary talent that makes this industry possible. Our second panel will examine California's film and television tax credit program specifically. We'll discuss how the expanded program is working, what additional steps are needed to strengthen its effectiveness and opportunities to support more of the industry, including post-production and the businesses and workers who depend on it. And our third panel will examine how California evaluates economic and budgetary impacts of the film and television tax credit program. This is an especially important discussion. We need to ensure that our budget process fairly and accurately assesses both the costs of the program as well as the tax revenues that are the direct result of the economic benefits of the program. That includes understanding the jobs supported, the economic activity generated, the tax revenue returned to the state, and the broader impact on our communities. Because when we lose productions, we don't just lose film and television jobs. We lose business for local restaurants, suppliers, countless small businesses, and we lose economic activity and tax revenue that helps support our schools, our healthcare, infrastructure, and other essential services. California's leadership in film and television is not guaranteed. We have to make investments and policy decisions necessary to maintain it. We have important questions to answer today. One, how do we ensure California remains competitive as other states and countries expand their incentives and investments to track film and television productions? Second, how do we protect and grow good-paying jobs for the workers and small businesses that form the backbone of California's entertainment industry? And third, what changes do we need to make to California's budget process to ensure we're fairly and accurately assessing both the costs and the economic benefits of the film and television tax credit program. These are the questions that I hope that will guide our discussion today and the committee's work as we move forward. We intend to introduce legislation next year to address the remaining impacts of the state's corporate tax credit program which threatened to undermine this program before we intervened with SB 186 and build on that work to further strengthen the program. WE ALSO LOOKING AT ADDITIONAL OPPORTUNITIES TO IMPROVE THE PROGRAM PARTICULARLY WHEN IT COMES TO SUPPORTING POST WHICH ASSEMBLY MEMBER SCHULTZ HAS BEEN THE LEADER AND THE ASSEMBLY AND WE CONTINUE FOCUSING ON HOW WE additional opportunities to improve the program particularly when it comes to supporting post which Assemblymember Schultz has been the leader in the Assembly and will continue focusing on how we integrate that into the program Assemblymember Schultz will be taking the lead on that effort, and I look forward to working with him to keep these jobs and businesses in our state. Assemblymembers Jessica Colosa and John Parabedian are both here. John is here already today. Represent incredibly important districts that are the home to significant film and television employment, including production facilities, sound stages, and the many workers and businesses that support the industry. So I want to thank you for being here today, Assemblymember Herbedian. We're also, also today, we have Assemblymember Mike Gibson, who is chair of the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee, whose expertise will be particularly valuable as we examine the tax credit program, and he has been such a leader in protecting this industry in the state. So thank you so much for being here. And, of course, I just introduced Assemblymember Nick Schultz, who has been such a leader on the post-production effort and will be working closely on how we integrate. We also hope to be joined later by Assemblymember Tina McKinner, who's worked to advance diversity and expand opportunities within the entertainment industry, and Assemblymember Pilar Schiavo. I see that we've been joined by Assemblymember Colosa. And Assemblymember Pilar Schiavo, who represents a district where the new sound stages and production facilities are creating opportunities for growth and employment. I'm grateful to all of my colleagues for being here today and for bringing your perspectives and expertise to this committee, and I look forward to working together as we move forward in the next legislative cycle. Our goal is not simply to preserve the industry that California built. It's to make sure that California continues to lead the industry into the future. While every member of this committee will have their own questions, I know that each of my colleagues shares my desire to see the film and tax credit program grow and strengthen. For those who wish to provide comment later on at the end of today's hearing, we will open the microphone for in-person public comment, and you'll be allowed to speak for a number of minutes, and we'll determine that depending on how many people want to speak. I want to thank everyone who's engaged with us so far and say that we look forward to continuing to learn from and with you as the Select Committee moves forward into 2027. With that, I'd like to welcome our panelists and audience to the forum and give members of our committee an opportunity to provide their own opening remarks. I'd like to go ahead and start on this with the chair of our tax and revenue committee, Mr. Gibson.

Mike Gipsonother

I want to say thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and thank you very much for allowing, first of all, Speaker Revis for allowing this committee to exist and thank the audience for being here. Again, my name is Mike Gibson. I chair the revenue taxation committee. And so, one, again, my purpose for being here is one, because I believe in this industry. We've done a lot of heavy lifting as a legislature, and also with my committee, the Revenue Taxation Committee. We are committed to making sure this industry thrive and grow. It is important for us to make sure that California continues to lead in this space. This industry provides not only the jobs, but also California is strengthened by this industry. The homes and the tours that we have taken individually as well as collectively, the stories we have heard are so important and so incredible because with each story, there are lives and there are families that are connected to those stories, and it is not lost on me taking the tours. and those are very important stories that I've heard. We don't want your families to go to different states or different other countries. all those stories and those lives to thrive and grow right here in California. And so the work that we've done in the legislature is important. There's so much work that we need to do and continue to do here in the legislature. The $2 billion here in the state of California, we want to make sure that that continues to stay here. The tax, the film tax credit that we passed here in the state legislature, We want to make sure that we continue to make sure that whatever one that we – the work that we do and the governor did a yeoman's job. And I want to commend our governor for, one, having the vision of the foresight because I believe without a vision the people perished. And this governor did the heavy lifting. He brought us all in. And I want to commend his work because it was important, but I think there's a lot of work to do. And I believe that with this hearing today, that you're going to share with us the real work that needs to be done in 2027 and beyond. And I want to hear what you have to say. And I'm here to be able to listen and take that work in my new role moving forward. And I'm looking forward to seeing and hearing what needs to be done. So thank you very much.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Assemblymember Gibson. I'd like to recognize Assemblymember Schultz.

Nick Schultzother

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I'll keep it brief, but I wanted to thank you, Mr. Chair, for your leadership and bringing us together on this issue and to everyone at this table who I think has done a lot of work already and plans to do more to keep this industry here. Of course, thanks in recognition to our speaker, our fearless leader, and to the governor and our Senate counterparts. I just wanted to express that what I hope we take away from today is a sense of urgency. I think that this committee's focus on the entertainment industry is not ideological, it's pragmatic. People aren't working in our communities. When I brought forward AB 2319, and Mr. Chair, you and I have talked a lot about it and can't thank you enough for your partnership on it, there was no time to wait. To put some context into it, we lost more than 1,800 post-production jobs just between 2012 and 2025. That's a 13.2% decline across the state of California. That's a crisis, and California did nothing, nothing for a very long time to keep people working and to keep those jobs here. When I talk about the urgency that we should act with, I don't, again, talk about it from an ideological point. I talk about the conversations I've had with MPEG Local 700 members that are looking for work and can't find it. And yet California, until very recently, both in the expansion last year and legislation this year, has done nothing to incentivize those jobs staying here. What that means in terms of a loss to the state of California is an estimated $1.63 billion in annual economic activity, annual economic activity, and more than $507 million in annual wage loss. The point that I'm trying to make is none of this is possible without your leadership, of course, Mr. Chair, all of our panelists who are here, everyone that we're going to hear from. But I hope that we all walk away fired up with a sense of urgency and an understanding that we need to accomplish much, much more in 2027. No cannot be an answer that we tolerate, and we have got to strive and dream bigger and do more at the state level. And I'll simply close with noting that our incentive structure alone may not solve the issue, but it's a critical component of our solution to keeping these jobs in our community. And, of course, we'll need to continue to find opportunities for federal partnership in forms of expanded incentives, and we need our local partners to do more to cut red tape and keep production rolling in Los Angeles Thank you very much Mr Chair Thank you very much And I like to recognize Assemblymember Herobedian Well thank you Mr Chair and thank you to Mr Schultz Can you tell

Chair Zuburrchair

he used to be a prosecutor? You would never guess that. I'm fired up. I'm fired up by that. Thank

John Harabedianother

you to the Television Academy for hosting us this gorgeous venue. But just briefly, Mr. Chair, thank you for everything that you've done. No one has worked harder on these issues than you. And behind the scenes, especially just how hard you've pushed to make some of these things a reality and to improve them. And us being here is really because of you. And Mr. Schultz, thank you for having us in your district. I could say the same thing about you and just all your advocacy and all your work. But this is such an important issue for not only our districts, but the whole state. And it's personal for a lot of us. Whenever we're back in the district, especially those of us who represent so many folks in this industry, the message is clear. We want to work here. We want to work and see our kids and our spouses and our partners at the same time. We don't want to be in Georgia. We don't want to be in Canada. We don't want to be overseas. And the more that you can help facilitate that, the better. We have the natural advantages here. We have the talent. We have the studios. We have the scenery. But that isn't enough anymore. And we need to actually put the dollars and the investment behind it. And that's where we come in. And I think that we have a collective buy-in to do that. And I think today is about learning how to most efficiently and effectively do that. And we're going to hear, I think, from the experts, some of whom I see when we're trying to pay for parking in our respective districts. And I'm looking forward to learning because I think all of us up here are trying to figure out in this arms race between the different states and, frankly, the different countries, where can we be better? Because California is always better we're smarter we have the tools here to do this it's just a matter of implementing and and getting it done so we can do that with the leaders up here and mr. chair thank you again and I look forward to the discussion thank you for

Chair Zuburrchair

being here thank you I'd like to recognize assemblymember Colosa

Jessica Calozaother

thank you so much chair hi everybody I just got close assembly member for District 52, I represent Northeast LA, spanning from East Hollywood, Los Feliz, Echo Park, Silver Lake, Highland Park, Cypress Park, Mount Washington, a lot of the incredible places where many of you film, and I also represent South Glendale and East LA. And so, one, first let me thank my seatmate, one of my favorite people in the assembly, Assemblymember Rick Chavez of Burr. This is, by the way, the nicest hearing I've ever been to. So you kind of leveled up our assembly select committee game here by having us at the academy. And so I thank you as well to all the staff, the consultants, and just everyone who is here today taking time to be with us to come up with solutions to what we know to be an existential crisis impacting the industry and the state. thanks as well to our speaker Rivas our budget chair Jesse Gabriel who both I know also care deeply about the industry for me this is really incredibly important to be here the district that I represent some of those neighborhoods that I talked about are the home to not just a lot of filming in LA, but also home to a lot of the workers. And so that is something that has been very clear to me from when I was elected in 2024 till now, when I'm in the neighborhoods, talking to my constituents talking to my neighbors that so many of them are still out of work Even with the film tax credit even with some of the things that we know we been doing to stay competitive, to make sure that Hollywood doesn't leave California, we know that we need to do more. And it's our workers, it is our electricians, our drivers, our set builders, our actors, our artists, It's our small businesses. It's our dry cleaners. It's our restaurants. Everyone is impacted by the greater creative economy and just the benefit that this has to everybody. And so I know I'm deeply committed to this in working with our unions, working with the industry, working with all the artists and actors who are here. Thank you for your advocacy. We are really looking forward to getting a head start for the next legislative session, thanks to our chair, and hopefully figuring out what more we can do in legislation to ensure that we keep Hollywood in California, we keep filming in California, and that we know that there's so much at stake. And so we know that sense of urgency. We see that sense of urgency. And I know that you have the commitment from so many people here and so many people who aren't here that we want to do more in 2027. So thank you again to my seatmate and our Mr. Chair for having us. So thank you so much.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you. Thank you. I want to thank all of my colleagues here. I think the folks that you see up here, both last year and the end of the session this year, I mean, we were on the phone, I think, every day really counting votes to make sure that we were getting the budget bill over the line. I just want to thank all of them because this has been a partnership of all of us and some others that are not here today. With that, I'd like to welcome and introduce our first panel on maintaining and growing the creative economy in California. First, we've got Mike Miller, who is the third international vice president for the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees, IATSE, and the department director for the motion picture and television production. We also have with us Gina Rodriguez, an actress, director, and producer, and the founder of I Can and I Will Productions. We've got Lindsey Dougherty, who has served as recording secretary, business agent, and lead organizer at Local 399, representing over 6,000 movie Teamsters in Hollywood. In Hollywood, she is currently the Teamsters at-large Vice President and Director of the Motion Picture Division. We also have Jason George, a renowned actor and who serves as co-chair of the National Government Affairs and Public Policy Committee and is a national board member with SAG-AFSTRA. And then of course we have Rebecca Rhine, who is the Associate National Executive Director Western Executive Director of the Directors Guild of America and additionally the President of the Entertainment Union Coalition which collectively represents over 167,000 members who live and work in California's entertainment industry. So I'd like to ask each of the panelists to limit your comments to about five minutes and I'd like to start with Mr. Miller.

Mike Millerwitness

Thank you very much and I appreciate the requirement to put my comments in writing because it's the only way you'll keep me to five minutes on this issue. I do want to take the opportunity, Mr. Chairman, to thank you, not only for your leadership today, but for your past and your ongoing leadership. And to all the members of the committee, very much appreciate your advocacy. And I hope that what we can provide today is additional information to support the insightful comments that each of you made in your opening remarks And I do feel a little bit like I preaching to the choir which I think is a good thing because the more folks that understand our industry, the more important it is. And in your introduction of me, you stated my position. And in that position, I think it's important to note that I also have responsibility for contracts and motion picture production across the United States. And that gives me an interesting and really appropriate perspective on the situation that our IA members face here in California. The majority of IATSC members who work in film and television production live in California. And in California, we represent 52,000 people throughout California who work in all different craft-specific locals. And there is no more important issue to these constituents and their families than their ability to work and live here in California. We've seen a downward spiral of opportunity that began as a trickle and in the last few years has become a deluge. What makes our industry so tempting for others is not just its high visibility, not just its great revenue generation, not just the amazing middle-class union jobs with health care and pensions that it provides, but it's also a highly mobile industry. It's one where legislation can be passed on one day, a handful of plane tickets can be bought the next day, and an equivalent of a mid-size manufacturing company or corporation or plant can be moved overnight out of California with just that handful of plane tickets. And that handful of plane tickets isn't going to the below-the-line folks that I represent. That handful of plane tickets, they're not taking members out of California the last few years the way they did in the heyday of California production, where you went on location to do a particular portion of your production and you took your California crew with you. That doesn't exist anymore. And many of these other jurisdictions that have created these incentives programs are designed around that. And those incentive programs are designed to take California jobs, transfer them to other countries and jurisdictions, and aggressively prevent California technicians and artists from traveling with them because they don't qualify for those incentives in those states. We appreciate the efforts, Mr. Chair, and all the members of this committee to approve the California Film and Television jobs in 2025, and we were really proud to work with you towards passage on this important issue. And as all of you know well, we still, our incentive program still lags behind other states and more importantly other countries. In the fight to gain and retain film and television production, the results are real and the results are devastating. Just last week it was reported that New York City is poised to take the film capital away from Los Angeles, California. Just today, the LA Times has an article about the effectiveness of the incentive in Ireland, who has now exceeded $632 million in production a year. It's important to note that for our members, California has more than five times the number of film industry workers workers than New York has. And when you take Broadway out of the entertainment component, it's five to ten times the number of film workers in Los Angeles that we have have in New York, but yet they are poised to have the same level of production as California does. So in addition to having the most money, it's also important that it be recognized on a pro-rata basis because their industry is 20% of the size of the California industry, yet they have incentive programs that are, I hesitate to use the word better because I do, But I think it's important to note that proportion in scale is every bit as important as final dollar amount. So they have $800 million in New York and we have $750 million in California. Those are nowhere near equivalent because our industry is five times the size. One of the best and most accurate data points on what's happening comes through our motion picture industry pension and health plans. These are the health and pension plans that were created decades ago through collective bargaining that covers health care and retirement benefits for IATSE, the Teamsters, the Basic Crafts, LIUNA, and thousands of others in our industry. In our industry, due to the freelance nature of the work, a family's health coverage is directly tied to the hours that they work under contracts where they live or on location. And that data shows us very clearly what employment looks like. And what it shows is that at 2022, we had 123 million hours of employment contributed to those plans. And in 2024, 2025, rather, we had 79 million hours of employment contributed to those plans. 45 million hours of employment have disappeared on an annualized basis since 2022. A job loss of this magnitude in a typical manufacturing environment would mean the closing of multiple plants. In film and television production, there's no difference. The result's the same. It's just less visible because of the freelance nature. Nobody's putting a closed sign on the door on the outside of that plant. It's just those productions that are no longer existing or happening here. Obviously, this level of job loss and loss of health care coverage and pensions is devastating to people that have spent their lives building the skills and knowledge who made a commitment to working and living in California and now have fewer prospects and little less or no income. It's also devastating for their families who face a loss of health insurance and benefit coverage. And that's a problem for the state because instead of becoming contributors to the California economy, these workers are forced to become dependent on the state's safety net. So it's a double hit to the state. There are also more long-term devastating impacts that are very real, if not immediately visible. The middle class jobs with benefits, a highly unionized industry. If this ecosystem is dismantled, if the workers in our industry are forced to leave it, if small businesses have to shut their doors, then these jobs and the infrastructure that have been Californians for a hundred years will not easily be replaced. When these entertainment industry jobs, and I might add, represent what policymakers know, what those of you on this panel know, are one of the backbones of our strong economy in California are gone, then the state and local governments are going to be very hard pressed to fill that gap. When all the small businesses that support our industry are shuttered, bringing them back will be hard if not impossible When sound stages are empty then as OneTrade article said this week they become places to hold parties not part of a thriving economy Another article this morning in the L Times talked about the closing of child care centers in Los Angeles and the loss of child care due to the downturn of the entertainment industry in California. Those types of residual effects are not always apparent, but it's meaningful. When child care in California now exceeds $4,000 a month, it becomes a significant drain on the economy. And when those opportunities dry up for people to provide health care, how do they support their families if they don't have to rely on the state safety net, which becomes an additional drain? Finally, there are long-term repercussions of an industry shutting its doors to young people who have the talent and desire to work in film and television. Our industry has jobs for people at all levels of education. and for many different types of skill sets. In the past, IATSE and all of the other unions involved have put resources into creating programs that would help people jump over the real and the perceived barriers to entry in our industry. But today in California, this is not a place to build a career as so many generations before us have been able to do. It's not a place of opportunity for young people. It's not a place of opportunity for people of color. And quite bluntly, if there are no jobs, there can be no effective training programs because there are no opportunities. And training folks and people for jobs that don't exist is not only unfair, it's just wrong. We have to provide training to folks to expand the diversity of our industry, and the only way we can do that is if those folks we train have opportunities to work in this industry. In 2025, the Entertainment Union Coalition used the slogan that if our industry thrives, California thrives, and that's true. But the reverse is equally true. So even with my prepared remarks, I know I went over my time. I look forward and our organization looks forward to working with each and every one of you. Chair, again, thank you for your staunch support of our industry. we will create a program that is competitive and stops the outflow of these important middle-class jobs. And that's a program that includes all appropriate expenses and removes the cap and continues to hold California and our workforce back. Thank you for your leadership. Thank you for your time and appreciate the opportunity to address the committee today.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Mr. Merrill. I really, really appreciate that. Thank you. We're going to go ahead and go through all the panelists first, and then we'll have opportunities for the members of the committee to ask questions at the end. So I'd like to recognize next, Gina Rodriguez.

Gina Rodriguezwitness

Hi. Hi, everyone. Good morning. Thank you, Chair Zuburr and the members of the committee for having me today, and thank you, Mr. Chair, for your leadership on the California Film and Television Jobs Act. You know, I have a script also, because I too will go over time, but you rocked that, Michael. I didn't realize how, with the magnitude of this panel till now, which has shook me a little bit, to be honest with you. I grew up in a household where my father was a teamster, local 714 in Chicago. And I would go with him to picket lines. He represented union workers in the factory and I watched my father fight for people jobs and he was my hero and he was like awesome to me And And my dad would be really proud right now That so funny It so strange I guess I'm not here as somebody who runs a union. I'm here as a person that is affected by this. And when I was shooting my movie, so hi, I'm Gina Rodriguez. I'm a director, producer. I just wrapped my first feature, my directorial debut, House of Guerrero. Yes, very exciting. A boxing drama about my family, and it was set in El Centro here in the Imperial Valley. And California was integral to this story, and we were able to shoot it here because of the tax credit. So thank you so much. and we were awarded nearly 4.5 million through the California Film and Television Tax Credit Program as one of 28 films that were selected last December. And, you know, I think when I was on the movie set, my father the first day, he said, Gina, look around, look at how many people you employed. And I was too wrapped up in, like, you know, breastfeeding my child and doing my first film and running a set of 150 crew to stop and really understand what that meant until like right now, quite literally. Because I heard stories on set. Now I definitely can't even go through this script. But I heard stories on set that shook me in a way that were so different than what I felt 15 years ago before I was a mother. before I was a mother it was so exciting to go to New York to shoot a movie or Atlanta or Toronto or you know London that was like such a thrilling experience when it was just me and then I my mother got GBS three years ago and she dropped down paralyzed and she lived with me and I had to take care of her and I had to take care of myself and I had to take care of my children and I had to take care of my household, which means I had to work, but I had to stay. I had to stay here in California or else who would take care of my mother 24-7 and help her walk to the bathroom and help her eat every day? And who was going to take care of my kids if mom was gone? And so working in California was imperative. And everything changed. No longer was it about this thrilling experience of being an actor, but this person that had responsibilities and had created a family in this beautiful state and had wanted to continue to make the art that brought me joy and took care of my family and got us health insurance and covered the caregiving that my mother needed. But I couldn't leave. And I didn't realize how scary it was going to be for me to be limited in the opportunities that existed here. in the form of work that I do. And at that moment, it was all about me and my family. And there I was on this set a few years later, and it was all about the people that were making my art possible and the families they had to go home to and the families they had to take care of and the elderly that they were caregiving for and the children that they were able to go home to every night or the pets or their bed or their just familiar space. And they got to do it because of this tax incentive And they got to do it because we were able to make a movie here And it just shaking me right now because I knew it all felt like something until I sat here and listened to all of you and then listened to Mike and his awesome statistics and scary statistics. But now I look at my script and all the things that I thought about, which was, yes, we shot 26 days. We employed more than 150 cast and crew members. We did over 400 background performers. These are people that are getting a paycheck. These are people that are able to pay for their bills and contribute to their health care and help the people around them. And every one of those people took home a paycheck.

Maury McIntyrewitness

And our production also spent money with the equipment houses and the caterers and the local businesses and the food trucks that we ordered every week to be special for our crew. and how important it was to those small businesses. And it just continues to spiral into something magical, like the fact that our majority of our cast was Latino and a large majority of our crew identified as Latino, and most of them were California natives or longtime California industry professionals, and they told me again and again how much they loved that we were able to work here in their home state. And, you know, filming demands long and grueling hours, but our crew said many times what a blessing it was to go home at the end of the day to their families and their kids and their pets and their loved ones and their beds. And, you know, that does include me and being able to go home to my children. And, you know, Latinos make up nearly 40% of Californians, yet we remain unrepresented in the industry and on screen. But when productions stay here, our communities get these jobs. And that is what I've been praying for since I got into this industry was to help my community and the community at large. And I'm able to do them both because of your incredible work. And I'm able to make art here because of this incredible work that you're doing. And it matters to us. And I realize I'm just like, I'm just an us. I'm just one of them that benefits from your hard work. But I am a real story. And I realize that I am a privileged story. There are so many more that are, I mean, far more that aren't in the position that I've been blessed to have that need our support and need the jobs. So the 2025 expansion is working. Our nearly $4.5 million credit brought about $12.7 million in spending into California. My film is just one of 170 projects the expanded program supported in the first year, and every one of them has a story like ours. And I respectfully urge you to protect this program and keep it strong to continue to support independent productions and to keep production in Los Angeles and across California. And every production that stays in California means real jobs for real families. And my father would be so proud. And I'm postpartum, so that's why I'm crying. But more so because that's what he used to do. Yeah. So it's cool. We should do this for everybody here. I didn't know it was going to go in this direction. So some say that Hollywood is dying, and I respectfully disagree. Hollywood isn't just a place on the map. It's the crews, the artists, the families who make this work. And as long as California keeps investing in us, Hollywood will never die. Okay. I'm done crying. I'm done talking. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Gina. And I had the opportunity of being out on your set, and I saw all of the workers and you know thank you for having many of us out on your set while you were filming here in Los Angeles yes next I'd like to introduce Lindsey

Mike Gipsonother

Dougherty who as the recording secretary business agent and lead organizer at local 399 and also the at-large vice president and director of the motion picture division of the Teamsters thank you and thank you Gina for keeping it real because you are representation of why we're here on behalf of all of our members and industry workers good morning and thank you for the opportunity to speak. I will keep to my five minutes. I will not have any f-bombs, but if I don't do it, it's going to be Jason. Now, my name is Lindsay Doherty. As Rick Sabur already mentioned, I'm the Principal Officer of Teamsters Local 399 here in North Hollywood. Also, International Vice President at large for the International Brotherhood of Teamsters and the Director of the Motion Picture and Theatrical Trade Division for the Teamsters, representing all Teamster members throughout this country. For the past several years, the Teamsters, alongside other entertainment unions and guilds, have worked alongside the Motion Picture Association, Hollywood Special Ambassador John Voight and his team, as well as independent producers, film commissioners, vendors, and industry stakeholders to advance a federal film and television production tax incentive. Our shared goal is to bring production back to the United States, protect American jobs, and ensure our industry can compete in an increasingly global marketplace. I want to begin by recognizing the California legislature for the steps it has already taken to strengthen California's film and television tax incentive program. We appreciate that investment and the recognition that production is essential to California's economy and workforce. Today's conversation is not about overlooking that progress. It is about building on it and ensuring California remains competitive as the industry continues to change. And you may have all heard on September 24th this last month, bipartisan legislation known as the Motion Picture Television and Entertainment Revitalization Act was introduced into Congress. As proposed, it would establish a 20% federal tax credit for qualifying production expenditures and compensations with requirements for domestic filming. The federal credit could be combined with existing state incentives, so it's stackable on our California State program here. An industry commission economic analysis projects that a federal incentive could generate substantial economic activity and support additional American jobs. It's projected that over a nine-year period the motion picture television and entertainment revitalization act it's a mouthful would add two hundred and forty nine point one billion dollars in total economic activity a hundred and thirty three billion dollars in wages and a hundred and forty three thousand five hundred American jobs. It's important to note that this legislation has not been passed into law and we have some difficult challenges ahead of us for the next few months to accomplish this, it would undoubtedly be historic for our industry and for our country. But California must understand something fundamental. Bringing production back to the United States is not the same as bringing production back to California. A federal incentive would help address the competition between the United States and other countries. A federal incentive would not eliminate competition between states. It would not require a studio to film in California. Producers would continue to compare costs and incentives in California, New Jersey New York Georgia and other competing jurisdictions If another state offers a more attractive overall financial package that state may capture the jobs the vendor contracts and economic activity generated by a federal incentive Even if the production's creative leadership or corporate headquarters are based here in California, productions will still compare total costs, available incentives, workforce, infrastructure, locations, and certainty of funding when choosing where to film. We have already seen this to be the case without an existing federal incentive. Now, ProdPro's recent state of production report, which I know some of you have heard, illustrates this challenge. California's committed production spending declined 15% in 2025 to approximately $5.51 billion, while New Jersey's increased 96% that same year. And Mike has already touched on this, but just yesterday, Deadline Hollywood reported with the headline that said, NYC production boom sees permits and spending surge. Sound stages max out. We are bursting at the seams. And we know this is not the case for California, and this is the reality that we live in today. Even without a federal incentive, it's projected that New York will soon surpass California in production spend. The report also estimates the effective incentive for a hypothetical $100 million project. Under its modeled assumptions, California's effective incentive rate is approximately 28 percent, compared with 30 percent in Georgia. Under New Jersey's program, 40 percent effective rate. The report further found that approximately 70 percent of surveyed studio executives place productions in the lowest cost viable location. California cannot expect extraordinary workforce, locations, infrastructure, and creative community to overcome every financial disadvantage. We have an opportunity to protect and rebuild an industry that supports, thank you Jason, to support skilled workers, small businesses, local communities, and an essential part of California's economy. We should not assume that the work will automatically return simply because federal policy changes. That is why California must continue to take action at the state level as well as continue to build upon the competitive nature of our state jobs program. We should be preparing now for the possibility of a federal incentive, not waiting until it takes effect and then discovering that other states are better positioned to capture the resulting production activity. California should strengthen its own program, evaluate its funding cap and eligibility rules, and make sure the incentive is structure to attract projects that create real work for California residents, businesses, and workers. And we should continue to measure our success by results which include jobs, wages, crew days, vendor spending, and production activity that would otherwise have gone elsewhere. A federal incentive could help grow the production industry nationally. A competitive California incentive is what can help ensure California workers share in that growth and keep our state the film capital of the world. California should not simply hope to benefit from the next chapter of the film and television industry. We must invest in our program and put ourselves in a position to lead it. In a position to fucking lead it. Sorry, I did it. Members of the legislature, my apologies, but I had to, we recognize the work that you have already done and we appreciate your commitment to this industry. We are asking you to build on that foundation as the competitive landscape continues to quickly evolve day to day I urge you to support a stronger more competitive California film and television tax incentive one that protects our workforce attracts new investment and helps ensure that California remains a place where productions are made and working families can build lasting careers. Our members and all workers helped build this industry and they deserve the opportunity to continue building their futures here in California. Thank you very much.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Lindsey. Now I'd like to recognize Jason George.

Nick Schultzother

What she said. Listen, thank you all for having us here today. This is, we passed the, we moved the number to 750 million and everybody cheered and very quickly other states surpassed us within days because they know what we, you're the choir. You know what we've been screaming to your peers up in Sacramento. There's money, there's jobs. This is how you keep the industry and it feeds people's lives. It feeds families. It helps them get health insurance. Some of you had the opportunity to come to my set. We did a tour of my set. I shoot a show called Grey's Anatomy. Some of you came. Thank you for coming down. And And you saw the hundreds of jobs that are created, incredibly diverse, when you just create the opportunity. We have something between 300 to 400, depending on where we are in the season, people working on the show. That's just this show. And that's of every walk of life you can think of. The 65-year-old white guy, the 25-year-old woman of color, the 30-year-old Asian, on and on and on. It's all of America on my set, and I love it. it's become a unicorn in town because people are shooting out of Los Angeles, people are shooting out of the country. The unique thing also about that tour, I think, was when you came, top executives from both within the primary producing company, but also the major studio, the head of business affairs, the head of legal affairs came down because they all recognize how important this is. This isn't just the people on the ground floor. This is at all levels of the industry want the business to be here in Los Angeles because they recognize the synergies that come from that. When a showrunner can actually walk in and actually meet the writers, when most of your writers' room have never personally met the actors that work on the show, that's a recipe for your show not going the distance. When you have to look at what the set that your designers have worked hours on, And when you look at it on Zoom, so you don't really see the proportions, you don't really see the colors, what it's going to look like on TV because you're looking at it from the camera from your phone, that's a recipe for disaster. So the tour was a good time, and we had a good time. But the funny part was that was on the Grey's Anatomy set. I had just finished shooting the spinoff show of Grey's called Station 19. and to be perfectly honest, my family, and I consider them my family from that show, haven't worked in the two and a half years since that show finished. People with 20 and 30 years experience as craftspeople are driving Uber Eats, are scrambling, are losing health insurance, are trying to figure out, do I make the move? I'm having these conversations with friends. Do I make the move to other states where I think there might be more opportunity? I told the story before in these rooms where I went to shoot a talk show in Georgia. This is years ago. And first off we never heard of a talk show shooting in Georgia That was a new thing for me but we went and did the talk show in Georgia And as I talking to the producer and they explained to me how the segment going to go I getting mic up and I eventually lock eyes with the guy mic me up and realize it was my buddy who had shot a sitcom with me seven years before. I was like, what are you doing here? He said, I had to go where the work is. Now that was over a dozen years ago. It's only gotten worse. And so people follow the work. I have two kids who are going into film school, and I'll be perfectly honest, for the first time in my entire career, I prided myself on being the dad who would just support whatever his kids' dreams are, and I am. But it scares the hell out of me. Because, I mean, let's forget about AI for one thing. I've always thought, well, you know, you've got a free place to stay when you come back to work in the industry. That right there gives you a leg up in the industry. I don't know that they're coming back here to work in the film industry at this point. That's a conversation that they and their 18-year-old peers who are going to film school are having right now. I know personally of – look, I'm a fan of not only raising – forget about maintaining and keeping. We need to raise the amount and, if possible, uncap because we will reap the benefits more than any other state will. because the heads of studios are not moving anytime soon. They like the sun. If we can keep it here, then we'll be good to go. But I personally know of a show that wanted to shoot in California, that took pains to shoot in California, that pushed their start date when they didn't get the initial lottery because they really wanted to shoot in California. Do you realize how much trouble that is to press your studio to shift the start date of a production because they really wanted to shoot in California, but we ran out of money. The incentive ran out of money, so now that show will not be shooting in California. Producers want to. You just have to give them the opportunity. I just remind everybody that ecosystems break down, and when they do, they don't grow back. The Sahara Desert was once lush, green wildlife, and once it dies, it doesn't come back. We can't just maintain. we have to increase.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Jason. I'd like to recognize Rebecca Ryan with the Entertainment Union Coalition.

Nick Schultzother

I just got to say, there were periods of time when Rebecca's been my work sister. I think we've been on the phone almost every day, so I just want to thank you. It's been just a pleasure to work with you. Rebecca. Absolutely. Thank you.

John Harabedianother

As everyone knows, my name's Rebecca Ryan. And first of all, I want to thank Assembly members, Burr and the committee members today for their long-standing and continued commitment to the 100-year relationship between California and the motion picture industry that provides thousands of middle-class jobs. But as others have highlighted, the past does not guarantee the future. Complacency is not our friend in this fight. There is no coming back once the ecosystem of our industry is weakened beyond repair. I'm going to be very direct today, and I hope you will recognize my candor is born of urgency. I have represented workers in this industry for over 30 years, and at this moment, we are at a tipping point. A recent EY study commissioned by the unions shows that over the past 25 years, America's share of global production for the 25 highest budgeted films dropped by 54%. For the same time period, TV production suffered a 32% decrease in domestic market share as U.S. spending on TV production migrated abroad. Work on the highest budgeted films has decreased from 74% in 2000 to 31% in 2025, a precipitous drop in 25 years. That reduction in U.S. production has been especially devastating for California, as the state now has only 38% of domestic production, the 38% of domestic production that remains. The irony is that people and governments around the world see the entertainment industry as an economic engine that creates good paying jobs and they have made building a skilled workforce and necessary infrastructure a priority. Yet in our home state, it is sometimes an uphill effort to get policy makers to recognize the cultural, economic and historical importance of this industry. We should be proud that California's production incentive is and always has been the most accountable and transparent tax credit program. The projects with the most jobs are given priority, and tax credits are not awarded until a production delivers the promised job. No other tax credit program is structured in this way, and the law reflects our state's priorities and values. That said, it is also the most complex, and that complexity has hurt us as we compete both within the U.S. and the rest of the world. AB 1138 has had a positive impact. The incentive is responsible for slightly over 40% of all permits for scripted production in L.A. during the last quarter. The incentive is propping up L.A.'s industry, but there are many more productions that wanted to stay but could not because of the cap on funding. And the limited funding is further exacerbated by the statutory requirement to allocate money for recurring productions. All of this serves to reduce the amount available for new productions. We appreciate that this hearing is the beginning of an effort to deal with this, and those of us who work in this industry believe this is what it will take to bring it back. First, while the program now has a competitive base percentage, it remains difficult to use. We must find a path to maintaining our values that also makes the program easier to navigate. Second, we should avoid segmenting the various elements of production with multiple approaches and programs. Not only does that risk retaining only a portion of our industry, but it weakens the infrastructure necessary for larger productions to return. The California Film and Television Jobs Program was always envisioned as covering the entire scope of production and all the jobs that entails. Third, there is an important role neighborhoods, cities, and counties must play in not just welcoming but facilitating production. We know this is difficult at a time when local government budgets are strained, but if the revenue generated by production leaves and workers disappear, it hurts those municipalities. Fourth, and most critically, the current California program is fundamentally inadequate because of what it cannot do. serve all eligible participants The California Film Commission consistently turns productions away because the money runs out long before the demand does Many of these challenges would go away if that basic problem was solved California will never be competitive with a capped program when many states and most countries are uncapped. We recognize this is a tall order. California has many challenges, and we're not blind to the problems. But losing the jobs, businesses, tax revenue, and tourism this industry provides will do nothing but damage the state. We want our industry to be part of the solution. As we've always said, the bottom line is that when our industry thrives, California thrives. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you all. We're running a little bit behind, but we've got about 15 minutes for questions from members of the panel. I've got to step out for a minute. So I'd like to ask Assemblymember Schultz if he'll preside for just a minute, and then I'll be right back. So I'm going to hand this over to you.

Jessica Calozaother

Sure thing, Mr. Chair. Okay. All right. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Colleagues, would anyone like to begin? All right. Mr. Gibson.

Mike Millerwitness

Thank you very much. First of all, I want to say to all of you, I've taken two pages of notes, but I won't go through them all. I want to say your story, especially to Ms. Rodriguez. Thank you very much for giving us your authentic, transparent emotions. It's not lost on me sharing your story, especially. How's your mother? She's working at the game, so we're going to go back and do this. Well, good. Thank you very much. It's those kinds of stories, especially with the committee, that really brings it home in a real authentic way. So I really appreciate each one of your stories. I know Mr. Miller, you talked about removing the cap, and each of you talked, what does removing the cap looks like? So if someone can talk about what does that look like for us, because for us as lawmakers and members of the legislature, right, we have to deal with a structural budget deficit. we have to try to imagine what our state looks like in terms of budgeting, health care, HR1, which is what this fool is doing to us in Washington, D.C., because it's really fucked up what he's doing in a number of different ways with health care. And we have to balance all of that. So what does removing the cap looks like for us moving forward? So if you can answer that question.

Mike Gipsonother

Okay. I mean, I think the answer is it means that we have to understand how much this industry brings to the state. We have to do very detailed analysis about all of the value that comes in in tax revenue. There's a we've been in discussions about a very robust study to really be able to articulate clearly and with data that every for every dollar the state spends, it has more value coming back into the state. But removing the cap is difficult. Priorities are always competing with each other. And what we're saying is if we make this a priority, it's value added to the state. And that has to happen by allowing us to fully compete. And when 14 productions, 14 television series, were unable to get the incentive in the last round because there was no money left, What that did was send all of those earnings all of those jobs all of that tax revenue all of that money into small businesses other places So I understand the challenge is significant for

Mike Millerwitness

all of you. I recognize that. We should look at where other places do it and how they do it and I think it happens. So I'm just curious, have anyone done a study what other states who have removed caps how they have done it because I'm sure they are managing and trying to do the same exact thing. What is those other states? Their problems are the same as our problems. They're trying to, but we're the fourth largest economy. So as those states are managing their own budgets, how are they doing it so we can look at how they're doing it, so we can look at how to do some comparison and contrast, and how to manage our state to see what they're doing. Am I making sense? You are.

Mike Gipsonother

But I think we have, I think it's very important, Member Gibson, to level set here. Because so many of the other jurisdictions that have created tax incentive started with a production base of zero or near zero. So everything was additive to them. And we can look at the state of Georgia as a prime example. The state of Georgia prior to their domestic tax incentive had about 250 IATSE members in total in the state of Georgia. They currently have a film and television workforce of IATSE members alone of over 10,000, right? It works. In California, the effect of the cap is in the overwhelming majority of cases, if you get an incentive and it works, you will stay in California. If you don't get an incentive and you don't have access, you will leave. So I challenge to a degree the impact on the state budget because it presumes that those companies that don't qualify for the incentive program will stay. And the reality of it is they will not. And we have almost created an incentive for companies to leave. I'll give you three examples of shows that I suspect every one of you are intimately aware of. They're big cultural shows recently. America's Got Talent, American Idol, and The Masked Singer. Those are massive productions that employ hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of technicians. They're not scripted series, right? but they have an impact on so much of the workforce in the same way. Those shows were not eligible to access the California tax incentive because they were existing shows in California. We can argue the merits and why we pushed. What we did is create an incentive for them to leave. All three of those shows have left California, two are in Georgia, and one is in New Jersey. That has been a net impact of IATSE jobs of probably close to 900 jobs per season. So those shows didn't stay because, well, California hit the cap, so we're going to stay anyway and pay. If we don't provide an incentive for them to stay, they will leave. And when they leave the payroll tax the property tax the sales tax the value of real estate the economic driver the folks literally going to the gas station the dry cleaners and the grocery stores goes away because either they not working and they don need those things or they looking for another industry or to move completely out of state So I think when we look at the cost to California, we have to make sure that we are not presuming everything will stay if they can't access the program. And that's what we talk in terms of California's budget will lose. that would be true if every production stayed regardless of whether or not they got the incentive. That isn't what has happened. That's why we've seen, if that were true, we would not have seen the significant 45 million hour a year comparing 2025 to 2022 that we saw. Because it would have been, oh, well, the cap isn't there, we're going to stay. That money isn't there, and they will leave. So I think we have to look at the inverse. What is the benefit of production staying in California? And if those 900 jobs on those three jobs I articulated, you can figure out what that means. These are 900 jobs at between $50 and $100 plus an hour with $25 an hour in benefits and a health system that keeps people off the dole.

Chair Zuburrchair

It keeps folks, those are 900 people that are probably exhausted their California unemployment benefits. That's a drain on the state. Those are 900 jobs that are not paying California state income tax. If they're moving or they have to sell their homes, they're not paying property tax. They're not paying sales tax because they don't have the income to spend money in the state. So I think we have to be very cognizant of how we look at this. And I think we need to look at it from what does a production in California bring to the state as opposed to what does a cap cost? because it's a false economy because it doesn't cost anything. If they weren't going to be here anyway, 100% of nothing is still nothing. Do we have anyone else that has a question? Somebody over Colosa?

Mike Gipsonother

Thank you so much, Chair. Thank you to all the panelists for your insights and for sharing your stories. It's really incredibly important, And I know that, yes, it probably feels like you're speaking and preaching to the choir a little bit based off of who's here. But I know Assembly members of BRRRR also has this live streamed. So there's a lot of people who are also listening and watching to everything that we're talking about in hopes that hopefully it provides a little bit more stability into the industry, knowing that you have a coalition of people in this room who are working to tackle these issues. One of the things that I have seen and wanted to echo, I'm also the chair of the Asia Select Committee on Trade and Investment. I've met with a lot of countries from across Asia, a lot of productions across Asia and Hollywood, and our production is a consistent topic because it's true. They are trying to take our production. I've also spent a lot of time with other legislators from across the country this past year. And let me tell you, they talk about California all the time. They talk about how to take away our competitiveness, how to take away our jobs, how to take away our industry, how to take away our edge. And so that was a wake-up call, definitely. this past year to hear these words come out of other legislators mouths, that this is an active effort. And so I just wanted to emphasize that for folks, because I think for me, looking ahead to 2027, I would love to hear, you know, from the panel, your experience when productions do choose another state or country, if you can just maybe share a little bit more about what other factors contribute to that decision. Is it purely about the tax incentive, or is there more that we can be doing? I know that's something that's on our radar that we're working to tackle and obviously make more competitive, but how do we leverage the things that are here in California, like our workforce that is a lot harder to steal and to build in other places, other states, and other countries. So if you can elaborate a little bit more on that, I would appreciate it. We're running a little bit short of time. Is there someone that... I'll just take a... Great.

Maury McIntyrewitness

We all know the number one driving force of why productions go where they go is incentive-based. So there's other reasons. It's creative, but it's very limited in that respect. The other incentive programs out there, Georgia, New York, New Jersey, I know we've already mentioned uncapping the incentive program here. Georgia has uncapped. So does New Jersey. New York has $800 million, but they borrow from the future, which is why they have more productions now. And one thing I think should be pointed out, all of those programs include Above the Line, which ours does not. That's another disadvantage for us to be competitive. Mike already touched on the unscripted programs like the reality television series or game shows that have left elsewhere. I know we modernized the program just last year, but there's still more work to be done on that front as well. And I think even Rebecca already touched on the difficulties of applying for the credit itself. Because it's not uncapped, that is why there's difficulty for productions to even look at California. So they're not, California's not number one in terms of budgeting. I think it's now four or five, and that's where we have fallen. And now next year with the federal incentive, it's projected that we would be more in line with being the third most budgeted. But at the end of the day, we're still not leading in that front either. And that's because of the actual program itself, not just the funding. But both are two key components that we need to look at when we're talking about modernizing or changing the program for 2027. Thank you.

Nick Schultzother

Just underscoring something she just said, streamlining the process so that you can plan well in advance. The reality is right now everybody has to wait until they – we know when we want to shoot, but we're going to wait to see if we get the tax incentive. And that's a problem because the number one thing in business, you know, if you know you're – you can have a bad year. You just need to know you're going to have a bad year. Knowing what to expect, knowing when you'll have a firm answer so you can actually pull the trigger early on is a massive problem for producers right now that they have to wait. And then there are several takes on it. But if it were uncapped, you would know that you could, you might even be able to gamble, as I was talking about the productions that I'm aware of. You might wait for a later shot at the lottery if you knew that there was still money there. But we run out of money so early. So the scheduling piece, you've got to streamline the process better for producers. Similar to like what, you know, making it easier to get permits in town. That's a low-hanging fruit thing that actually made a lot of difference for a lot of independent producers They like oh I actually can shoot in this town because I not just jumping out of a car and running out on the street and shooting It easy to actually be legal while you shooting on the street Those things, streamlining the process of producers also makes a difference, but really that scheduling piece is one of the big things I think of.

John Harabedianother

I just want to add one thing. I got a call from a producer the other day, and they're doing a show that is set in Big Sur in Australia. So as beautiful as California is, and I'm a California native, it is all about the money. And, you know, one of the benefits of our program is that we have these job standards, but if we uncapped it, you could have the standards in place and then just basically not have to go through the application process.

Chair Zuburrchair

So, Gina, would this be the last response?

Jessica Calozaother

Yeah, just to what you had asked earlier, Mr. Gibson, about has somebody else done the procedure of uncapping? What did that look like? And that felt way above my mathematical brain, especially as a mom right now. But I do look at life very much so in the realm of motherhood and parenthood. And one thing that I think my parents did that has totally changed the trajectory of me and my siblings was we came from a very low-income family, quite literally economically challenged in Chicago, in the hood of Chicago. And my parents said, I'm going to invest in the three of you. And they had no money to invest in us. But like New York City, they borrowed from the future. And they put myself in NYU, my sister in Harvard, my other sister in the University of Medicine in Chicago. My eldest sister runs one of the biggest private equity firms. My middle sister is a doctor. And I get to stand here and do what I love every day. Because they invested in those that they loved and they believed in. And it worked. And it worked because the three of us are more successful than we ever could have imagined from our childhood. And nobody can ever believe that the three of us have done it, but they borrowed from the future. They didn't have it. They believed in us. So I think that's what you guys should do with us. Maybe we don't have it, but believe in us because we're going to show you how economically strong we are and how much we should be trusted with these opportunities when you give them to us. So, yeah, just give them to us. Watch. Like me and my sisters, watch what we'll make what happened.

Chair Zuburrchair

Okay, we're going to go with one last question for Assemblymember Schultz, and then we're going to move to the next panel.

Mike Millerwitness

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the panelists. Very informative. I love so much of what I heard from uncapping the program to looking at some of the other regulatory impediments. I guess my question is for Ms. Ryan. In your testimony, what I thought I heard, and I just wanted to make sure, give you a chance to elaborate, it sounds like what you were saying was the better approach is to have a more holistic view of production as opposed to segmenting different parts of it. Is that accurate?

John Harabedianother

I think that's right. I think our intent always was to have an incentive that kept all of production in California from soup to nuts. And, you know, obviously there are different approaches to doing that, and we should talk about them. But we don't want to become sort of the capital of X or Y. We want to be the capital of these films, of this industry. And when you want to bring big-budget films back, you have to have a program that can encompass something of that size and scope.

Mike Millerwitness

Yeah, I really appreciate your comments, and I agree with you. I think that that intent has yet to be realized, but it's something we're all moving towards. And I agree. I think we should have a program that incentivizes and looks at pre-production, production, post-production, and everything in between, because we can have a program that picks winners and losers as respectfully it has been So we have to do better Totally totally agree I sure do Rest in power Dolores Huerta

Chair Zuburrchair

So I want to thank the members of the first panel. Thank you for taking time out of your busy days to be with us today. Please, very appreciative. And we're going to have some additional, I know that we have members of the dais have additional questions about the film tax credit. We're going to have some additional opportunities for them to ask those questions with the next panel. So I'd like to invite up panel number two. Thank you, everyone.

Chair Zaburchair

Thank you. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

on the panel entitled Protecting and Growing Jobs Through the California's Film and Television Tax Credit Program. Join me in welcoming Carrie Wood Eidertson, who's Executive Director of Government Affairs and Public Policy with the Screen Actors Guild, American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, otherwise known as SAGASTRA. Alex Aguilar, Business Manager and Secretary-Treasurer with Labor's Local 724, representing utility workers in the motion picture industry. Welcome, Alex. Betsy Beers, the acclaimed Shonda Land executive producer and creative partner. Welcome, Betsy. Mariel Abanza, president of the California Post Alliance and executive vice president of business development. Welcome. And finally, Arlen Valdivia, vice president of state government affairs with the Motion Pictures Association, an organization representing studios including Disney, Netflix, Paramount, Prime, Amazon, MGM, Sony, Universal, and Warner Brothers. Welcome, Arlen. So I'd now like to start with Carrie.

Gina Rodriguezwitness

Thank you so much. Good afternoon. Carrie Wood, SAG-AFTRA. We represent approximately 160,000 members nationwide, the majority of which reside right here in California. Thank you to Assemblymembers of Burr for inviting our union to be involved in today's discussions. We all know how valuable the film and TV industry is to California economy, and we know how devastating it's been for the labor force. our businesses and our infrastructure in recent years. I first want to just say that the incentive program is working. I think so much of this has already been said, but the projects are getting made here, and that's great. But unfortunately, the rate of that increase is not what it could be. With some adjustments, we can make our state more competitive than anywhere in the world In particular California needs to make itself an attractive place to shoot episodic TV and streaming shows That where workers can build sustainable long employment and where local businesses can enjoy reliable revenue from those shows, their cast and their crews who spend their money locally. One big thing I think we need to do to the program is include above-the-line costs. That's wages for actors, directors, and writers in our tax credit program. And this could have a profound impact on the success of the program. In New York, above the line expenses are included. Episodic spending grew a whopping 108% during the most recent quarter. California pales in comparison. We saw episodic spending increase by only 8% in that same quarter. I also think we have to do a lot of education around this topic. I think we can start by avoiding using the terms above and below the line, frankly. Those are confusing to people. Those are accounting terms, and there really is no line. It means cast and crew, really. Most of our SAG-AFTRA members are considered above the line, whether they have one or two lines or they're at the top of the call sheet, which is very few. When you look at the whole picture, this is not a very daunting thing to do. Most of our members don't work the entire productions like the crew does. So by and large, it could greatly benefit the returns of the program to the state. California is currently the only U.S. state that does not include these costs as qualified expenses in the program, and we need to correct that, never mind foreign countries, which all do. The next thing I will say that I know has been said is uncapping the incentive would be a huge boon to the program. I just want to give an example of Georgia they recently nabbed an upcoming Superman sequel which is a Warner Brothers production and then a daytime drama Beyond the Gates hundreds of jobs and 400 episodes over the past three years so in closing I think as it's been said California has the best creative workforce in the world the best locations, the best vendors we should do whatever it takes to keep our residents employed and our industry thriving, and I think those two critical changes could really make that happen. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Carrie. Thanks. I'd like to recognize Alex Aguilar. Welcome, Alex.

Alex Aguilarwitness

Thank you. Thank you. Well, you guys know me, Alex Aguilar. I appreciate you guys having this. This is very important to all of us sitting here today, and so I have some remarks I want to read and a couple of comments. so good morning assembly members of BRRRR members of the committee thank you for the opportunity to discuss protecting and growing film and television jobs here in California I'm Alex Aguilar business manager secretary treasurer of Liuna local 724 better known as the Hollywood labors because we don't really do a lot of the construction stuff that the rest of our Liuna brothers and sisters do. We represent approximately 1,800 members in production, studio operations, and Universal Studios Hollywood. I also serve as the vice chair and the incoming chair of Film LA, which is going to be exciting with all the hearings we're having lately. Our members are the first on a production and the last to leave. From preparing the shops where sets are built to maintaining studio facilities, and supporting daily operations. We help keep productions running smoothly from beginning to end. For me, this industry is personal. I'm a second-generation laborer who joined Local 724 in 1996, straight out of high school. Following in my father's footsteps, later in his career, my dad unfortunately had to leave. He left to Georgia because my father worked on all the Marvel shows, all the movies that Marvel did, relocated to Georgia. And so this one is particular, you know, it's a little, it's hard talking about it sometimes because my kids really grew up without their grandfather and their grandma for many, many years. To this day, my parents relocated to Georgia. They're there now full time. We keep trying to tell them to come back, but I think they don't want to hang out with the kids anymore. But listen, I wanted to crack a joke there, but it's serious. This goes beyond the programmatical changes that we made. You guys know me. I always speak from the heart, man, and the members are the ones that suffer the most. the communities, the businesses, the families. I mean, our industry is well known for, you know, divorce. And it's because many of us had to relocate or leave for months at a time. And I'll give you a little example of my own personal story. When my daughter was born, she was born on a Friday. Friday. I left Sunday for six months on a movie. And, I mean, I was crying, man. You know, listening to Gina, I was like, you know, she got me going because it's true. I'm not the only person that's experienced that. There's many of us that have done that. And that's the unfortunate part of when these productions started leaving is that not only businesses suffered, but families, children, you know, it's rough. It's rough. So I'm going to continue with my remarks real quick. So when productions leaves, our members lose more than paychecks. They also lose work hours and the employer contributions that support health care and retirement. These challenges extend beyond our union. Whether you're a laborer, a teamster, a prop maker, or a production assistant, we all depend on productions choosing California. That is why this tax credit program really matters. I want to thank the legislature, the governor, our industry partners, my union brothers and sisters, for working so hard to increase the annual funding from $330 to $750 million. Broader eligibility, improved refundability, and the new post-production incentive are also meaningful steps forward. Together, these changes give California a stronger foundation to compete for work. But we're not even close. now we need to build on that progress with long-term stability. Productions are planned years ahead, and studios make decisions about where to invest for the long haul. Extending, for me, one of these things that I think is very important, which I'm not sure if it's been mentioned, but extending the program beyond the five years would give producers greater certainty and more confidence to keep investing here. Other states have already recognized the value of stability, and some, you know, New York, what do they do, Kerry? Ten years, right? I think their program is extended through 30, I don't know. It's a ten-year program. Let's just say that. Ours is a five-year, and that really truly makes a big difference. I sat down with a producer, Ross Fanger, who became my friend because he reached out to me because he wanted to know what the heck going on Alex with productions why is it that we can get this right Now obviously I explained to him that there was a lot more to it right Budget restrictions people have to agree But one thing he told me that stuck in my mind was that he's been doing movies all over the country, all over the world, really. And he's like, but we all want to film in LA. We want to be in California. And so it's, it's unfortunately, it was beyond his, you know, decision making process that he couldn't just say, let's stay in LA and, uh, and do that. But, um, anyway, with, um, with that and, you know, for our members, success means productions actually filming here, more Californians working, families earning wages, maintaining benefits. It means shows returning season after season because steady work is what allows people to build lasting careers. We each bring a different perspective to the panel, but we share a common goal. A strong California production industry, I look forward to working together to build on what we've accomplished, bring more work home, and do everything we can do to keep Hollywood in Hollywood. Thank you. Thank you, Alex. Appreciate it.

Chair Zuburrchair

Now I'd like to recognize Betsy Beers.

Betsy Beerswitness

Hi. Hi. Good morning. Thanks for that. And it's lovely to meet all of you. I've never done this before, so I'm really excited to be here. You know, my name is Betsy Beers. I'm the creative partner at Shondaland and have been the producing partner of Shonda Rhimes for over 20 years, which means before there was a Shondaland, there was just the two of us sitting in a room, basically. During the period of time, we've made, I believe, 13 series, the majority of which we filmed right here in Southern California. So I'm here today to talk about the subject, about which I feel passionately, which is the California tax credits and how those tax credits are determined. For background, when we started filming the first season of Grey's Anatomy in 2004, it didn't occur to us or anybody else at ABC to go somewhere else. The crew, the infrastructure, the facilities were unparalleled in the world. We created the world of Seattle Grace here. From that point on, as more states and locations started to provide better incentives, Shonda and I continued to fight to film locally. Private practice we set in L.A., so we didn't move it. Scandal, we figured out a way to double L.A. for Washington seamlessly. And how to get away with murder doubled for Philadelphia. Over this period of time, we developed a deep bench of the best below-the-line talent around. We followed up with The Catch, For the People, and Station 19, all filming here. And finally, a few years ago, we built the entire White House, and I mean really the entire White House, on our lot in L.A. for Netflix, which we were able to achieve thanks to that credit that the state provided. So recently when our great partners at ABC applied for the new tax credits this past summer for our new Grey's Anatomy spinoff set in West Texas, we assumed there are a long history of loyalty to the state, fighting to stay here when there were no credits to be had, and the fact the odds were, as they had been with every single show that Shonda has created or co-created, there would be at least six seasons for a wonderful crew and staff to keep working and to sleep in their beds at night. It was also crucial since the co-creator and showrunner is also running Grays, and the geographical proximity was key to her ability to doing the job. How wrong we were We were denied credit due to the fact we were not providing enough jobs for the state to consider us an asset None of our past history or track record were taken into consideration. Undaunted, our wonderful partners at ABC agreed that it would make more sense for us to apply again in the fall. In order to do that, we had to postpone prep, locking down stage base, losing below the line talent, et cetera, et cetera, but we We all deemed it necessary and were working on ways to legitimately build up the number of employees. And then we were told, regardless of earlier messaging, there would be no chance to apply if you were a new show. Returning? Sure. Not a new show. We lost personnel, we lost a lot of time, and we lost money trying to find a way to stay where we have always been. Now we are filming in Albuquerque, where they have been wonderful to work with, but we want to be here. We've always been here. And look, there's an irony here too. I personally fought for the tax credits when I went up to Sacramento and screened the residents and talked about to all those people what did it mean to stay in my home state. With Jason George, I hosted you and a number of people on the set of Grace Anatomy so they could see how the longest running primetime medical show has been able to lift up and promote from within. The woman who is now running Grey's Anatomy and is going to be the co-creator of our spinoff was a runner. She was an assistant runner season two, and she's now running the show. For another example, my ex-assistant has worked through the years and is running Bridgerton. That's the way you continue to increase talent. And more ironically, a few years ago, I was awarded the California Golden State Award for keeping jobs in L.A. I don't even know what to say about that. I'm here to say please, please look at metrics and factors when deciding who gets credit, and please increase what's available. If it all boils down to numbers, all you are going to have is movies coming in and out of here, and the advantages we have discovered with long-running shows will be gone. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Betsy. Thank you. I'd like to recognize Mariela Bauza.

Mike Gipsonother

Hi, how are you? Thank you so much for allowing us to be here. I'm Mariela Bauza. I am the president of the California Post Alliance and executive vice president of business development at Signature Post. And I am here to represent the thousands of post-production professionals who have finally a seat at the table. So this is a very new opportunity for the post-production community. It is the first time that California has recognized post-production on its own. And this is a bit of a homecoming for me, as you know, or for us, because on September 18th, in this very theater, Governor Newsom signed AB 2319 into law, establishing California's first ever stand-alone post-production tax incentive. And that moment would not have been possible without the leadership of Assemblymember Zabur and paving the way for Assemblymember Nick Schultz who I call our knight in legislative armor because he took on post at a time that was incredibly difficult It was a year with an outgoing administration the second year of a session And so it is my hope that by launching the California Post Alliance, which became the sponsor of the bill, we can advocate, educate, and build community. And I'm here to answer the question of why do we need a standalone post-production tax incentive. Well, historically, regardless of where principal photography took place, California was always the premier destination for post-production. But unfortunately, with aggressive tax incentives offered by other territories, both domestic and international, that is no longer the case. The post-production workforce is so vast, we're about 12,000 post-professionals. And that number is probably underrepresented because there hasn't been historical data tracking our impact. And because our concentration of talent and the infrastructure is still the largest of anywhere in the world, we need not only the local productions, but we need those out-of-state and international productions to come back to California to be able to sustain such a vast community. For example, the biggest challenge that we had as we set out on our legislative journey was to really educate people on what post-production was. Because our work is not as visible as production, you don't see the trucks, you don't see the actors on the screen, we're felt, we're not seen. Our struggles were also invisible. So we were able to illustrate and educate everyone that, for example, production is six weeks to 10 weeks, whereas post-production is 24 to 48 weeks. These are long, stable jobs that are an economic driver that have not been at the forefront of this conversation. So I'm incredibly grateful to each of you for giving us that momentum. And while we did accomplish something historical, we did fall short by 1-0. Our budget request was of $100 million, and we did receive $10 million. And that is a testament to all the legislators that recognized the urgency that Assemblymember Schultz addressed earlier in his opening statements. And just for perspective and to address something that Assemblymember Gibson asked, when you're asking for something that is unprecedented, for example, an uncapped or above the line, you have to look to other states or to other countries that have done it to get those facts, those metrics that Betsy alluded to. And when you think that a state as vast and as big as California only got $10 million, but one of the metrics that we shared through our journey is that New York, in the fourth quarter of 2024, awarded 18 projects to tax incentive. And that was an $11 million investment that generated $57 million of spend before a single dollar was paid out. And it gave the state a revenue of $46 million. That is one quarter in one state that is so much smaller than California. Imagine what we can do if we multiply that for our state. And, you know, as a testament that these... tax incentives work, my facility was the biggest project that we worked on this year that generated the most revenue for my business was a film called Sponsor by Apple, which was awarded the tax incentive. And that was only one project. So if we expand the program, if we make it easy for studios to choose California as their destination, we can multiply that number for companies like mine. Thank you so much. The last thing that I will say that I want to leave you with, one of the biggest lessons that I learned through this journey is that when you have government, when you have industry, when you have labor, and when you have coalitions aligned and working together for one common goal, we are unstoppable. So thank you so much for giving us the platform to launch this advocacy efforts.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Mariel. I'd now like to recognize Arlen Valdivia, Vice President of State Government Affairs with the Motion Pictures Association.

Nick Schultzother

Good afternoon, Chairman Zabur and members of the select committee. For those of you that don't know me, I'm Arlen Valdivia, Vice President of State Government Affairs at the Motion Picture Association. On behalf of the MPA and its member companies, thank you for the opportunity to participate in this important discussion. First, let me start off by thanking you. the members of this committee, as well as the legislature, and Governor Newsom, for your continued support of this iconic industry. As the historic home of the entertainment industry, California has world-class crews, unmatched creative talent, and incredible locations. But in recent years, California has faced what the Los Angeles Times recently called a production crisis, with tens of thousands of entertainment jobs lost, and dozens of businesses that service the industry downsizing or closing. You all know the significant impact of this production crisis. has had on California workers and businesses because many of them are your constituents. And California has responded with meaningful improvements to its film and television tax credit program, particularly through the changes enacted in 2025 and 2026. These changes are demonstrating that a stronger incentive can bring production back to the state. We saw in the first application window of the 4.0 program, where the CFC saw an 82% jump in applications, and in the first year of the program approved 170 projects which collectively reflect 6.6 billion in direct production spending in California. That progress is encouraging. But the program as currently structured is still not competitive or predictable enough to fully address the significant losses of film and television production to other regions. We've all seen the various articles about California losing its competitive edge to other countries and states, most notably New York. The principal limitation of the program is uncertainty, which I think folks have addressed on this panel. The program is capped, specifically a front-end cap, which means that the Film Commission has to create mechanisms to allocate available credits through designated application windows. And because more productions are applying than available tax credits, there is a ranking process to prioritize which productions get into the program. And this means that the Film Commission is turning away productions because the program is oversubscribed and producers do not have the certainty that they'll be able to apply for and receive the credit even when they meet the qualifying criteria. We just heard Betsy's story, which sort of highlights that. Additionally, California is the only major production hub that does not offer to some degree above the line as a qualified expenditure. The program specifically excludes above the line, which includes writers, actors, directors, and producers' compensation from eligible expenses. This means that a large percentage of production total budget is automatically disqualified from getting an incentive and ultimately diminishes the value of the credit This in addition to the discounts of the refundable credits on the cap of the overall usage of corporate income tax credits annually further dilute the value of the credits. As a result, the studios are not budgeting to get a 35% tax credit. The value of the credit, once it's monetized, ends up being much lower, by at least 10%. This significantly contributes to the state's struggle against its competitors both nationally and globally. As you've heard in the previous panel, as you've heard from my colleagues on this panel, that while meaningful change has been made, there needs to be more to be done to make California competitive. I look forward to our continued work with Assemblymembers of BRRR, the members of this committee, the administration, to ensure that California can build on the progress already made, straighten the program's economic impact, and provide producers with the certainty they need to choose California. Thank you for your time.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Arlen. Appreciate that. Okay, we have about 15 minutes for questions. I'd actually like to give, welcome Assemblymember Schiavo, who just walked in the door, and give her just a couple minutes to make some introductory comments if you'd like to do that now. Or would you like to wait for a few minutes and get settled? Okay, great. Okay. Thank you.

John Harabedianother

I want to thank the chair, first of all. Thank you so much for including me in this conversation. This is a really important issue in my community. For those of you who don't know me, I represent the 40th Assembly District, which includes Santa Clarita, which we like to call Hollywood North. And I was listening to the panel on the way in. I was listening as I was traveling here from Sacramento today. And it was especially painful to hear you speak, Betsy, because I know there were conversations with studios in Santa Clarita and in my community. Yeah. The microphone. What also broke our hearts, just as an anecdote I didn't include, was one of the things we were intending, we were looking for places that look like West Texas, and there's a tiny little town a lot of people have used as a Western town, which is dead now because of ICE and because of the farming crisis. And our idea was to take that over, start to hire locals, and revigorate that area. So not only were we having to disappoint Santa Clarita and the wonderful stages there, but this weird part of me felt like we were letting down this part of California we could have helped. That's just smicing on a kind of crappy cake, sorry. Right, I know. It's incredibly heartbreaking, and I have to give credit to the chair because I know there are a lot of conversations exactly as you all were going through this and trying to make decisions and figure out where things stood that we were pushing at the end of session to improve upon the tax credit. And the chair was working all the time, willing to have 10 p.m. Zooms with people, studios in my community to talk about how we could make sure that it's something that was workable for folks. So I'm really here today to hear from all of you because I think that there's so much more that we can and must do. We cannot give up on this industry in L.A. I've talked to riders in my community who are driving Uber, and it is heartbreaking. It's really heartbreaking. And so you know this is a lot of workers This is a lot of families I heard you talk about leaving your baby after just days This is my kids' good friends' family who has had to go to Alaska and all over the country to do this work. And so we know that this is an industry we cannot give up on. And I will say also that I have heard directly from people within the industry that there are some studios that don't even try to pencil out California. And I see nodding heads. And so as we struggle as a legislature to protect this industry and fight for this industry, we need the industry to fight for it too. and I think that it is critical that California has always looked at and LA has always looked at if we are going to be stepping up with taxpayer dollars to support people in our community and we know that at the end of the day these dollars come back triple, five times is it that we see that investment come back to us so it's one of the smartest investments I think the state can make but everybody has to be trying to solve this problem and it cannot be something that is put upon the state to solve if the industry is not going to try to be a part of the solution as well and I am grateful that you and Shonda Rhimes have worked so hard to stay here in California and in Los Angeles and I know so many people have done that because it's their home and because we have incredible talent. And I look forward to what we're going to be able to do in this coming year to make sure that we can make more gains to ensure that this work stays here. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you. I'd like to recognize Assemblymember Gibson. Do you have some questions?

Jessica Calozaother

Yeah. Thank you very much. I want to apologize in advance. I won't be able to stay for the next panel, not all of it anyway. But this is a running theme, and I want to throw out a question to this panel, and that is eligibility. I know that Betsy talked about in her comments that the state didn't consider about eligibility. And then you talked about you guys had to wait, and then you were told that we ran out of money, and then I'm also hearing the previous panel that around the eligibility and the rules needs to be changed. Am I making sense to you?

Maury McIntyrewitness

Yeah, I mean, I can't speak to the earlier panel, obviously. No, no, right. But I think that what I was speaking to, and by the way, I'm just going to qualify myself and say I'm not a line producer. I was not the person in the trenches. I was the person kind of next to the person in the trenches. That's fine. So if I must speak at all, I apologize to my cohorts and anybody around. But what my understanding was that we were told when we were denied the credit first go-around this summer that it was based on the fact of the number of jobs that we would be creating for people working. So the only shows that actually, from my understanding, got credit for new business were ones that were hiring the most people. And we were encouraged when we came back ABC with us as well to figure out what is the largest number we can to hire which also obviously includes how many episodes are you producing? So can we produce more episodes? What are the other kinds of people that you can hire? I think the major point of what I'm saying is that I find it incredibly limiting that the only thing you look at with each application is the number of people. Because when you look at us, we have long running shows. We have an incredibly good track record. I'm only speaking for us. I'm sure there are many other shows. But what it does is it puts a bias on in and out businesses. Because mainly that money is being spent on world creating, on world building. So if you have a show about a space center, you know, you're going to have a lot more people working on that show than you might have on a medical show. But if that medical show goes on for six years plus, Grey's Anatomy is now its 22nd year. I lost count because I'm too old at this point. But you figure that the smallest number would be a six-year commitment. And I know from our point of view that we continue to grow the number of people that we work with. It's also where are you shooting in the local businesses that still have loyal connections with you. So our big thing initially was what are the standards under which you are judging our qualifications for getting tax credit? And the response we got was the only thing we are using is the number of jobs you have written, you have actually applied to show us. So I think we probably need to look at that, those criterias.

Jessica Calozaother

Yes.

Maury McIntyrewitness

Because those criteria could be so rigid that we're pushing some of that industry out and not considering some of that work and some of that production in California. Yeah, I think questions need to be asked at the very least. My understanding, as I said, this is second or third hand. So, you know, I feel like I'm probably, I may be getting something wrong, but I was there for most of it. And my understanding was if it is really just about counting, you have to understand what is the future of your counting. Right. And for a company like ours to think that so will be this number of episodes and out and we're not a good investment for California didn't make any sense to us. And we knew several other people in the same category, all of whom were told know what it's all about. Now, to me, what that means is you start to create jobs where you start to try to figure out ways of making more jobs. So somebody said, well, are you really, really counting absolutely everybody that you might be working? And it became sort of silly because we all know sort of how many people, but it's does the caterer have a caterer's assistant? You know, that's where you start to get into. And I think that's what was the thing for us that seemed crazy. And for others who have had either a track record, have a plan of attack, conversations had to be had. And I think things had to be evaluated in a different way. Because there's subtleties to this. And as I said, what you will do, because of the speculation on series as opposed to films, is you will eliminate series from your list of things that can get approved because there's always an if with a series. Like sometimes we're picked up for two seasons. There's usually not an if for us. But for a lot of my friends on shows, there are ifs. And so you sort of have to not only be believing in the present, but you're investing in the future. And I think this past season was all about the present and not about the future, and that's, to me, the future of California and all of us staying here.

Chair Zuburrchair

Mr. Chairman, I think she could. Yeah, I wanted to, because Arlen was first and then Mariel, but let's go in that order.

Nick Schultzother

I was going to say what Betsy is saying is highlighting sort of the issue with a capped program Because the program is capped, you have to limit how many people get the available tax credit. So you have to create – this is why we have allocation windows. Not everybody who's ready to get a tax credit can apply when they want to. They have to wait for those allocation periods that the Film Commission puts out. I believe it's about four plus a year, and they will be based on whether you're doing TV or film. And then once you get in, as Betsy noted, then you are ranked with others in your same group, and those are based on the jobs ratio. And so if you uncap the program, a lot of these barriers to entry go away because you're not rationing out $750 million because there's much more demand than there is tax credits.

Chair Zuburrchair

Mariel, did you want to add something?

Mike Gipsonother

Yes. Just to add to that, that is what I meant by we need to make it easy for decision makers to pick California. So we need to make our tax incentive reliable, something that they can count on and plan for. And when there's limited resources, it's uncapped, it doesn't allow for that. And so therefore, you know, that's why we're third or fourth or fifth in that conversation and not number one where we should be. One last thing and sort of to underscore Betsy's points, you know, the productions are not getting it because they're missing a percentage of a fraction. It isn't by leaps and bounds. So I think that's sort of what we're getting to is we're not talking about these ginormous numbers. It's small percentages that are making the difference between a production getting in and a production not or going to New Mexico.

Nick Schultzother

I was going to say, you know, part of the, from having worked on the standards for 4.0, when you have a capped program, the goal of the program is really to try to keep jobs on spending in the state. So that is what's written into the law. And I don't think we actually have probably done enough to look at issues related to longevity of the production, whether or not there's long-term commitments to the state. I mean, there's some other things that we could be doing in addition to just looking at sort of just really rough, you know, job standards.

Chair Zuburrchair

So, Alex.

Jessica Calozaother

Thank you. You know, to Betsy's point and everybody else, originally this program, when it first started, it was a lottery system. And, you know, we had issues with that. And I'm not making excuses. The point I'm trying to make is that I completely understand her point into wanting to have her production here. I mean, it's here for 22 years, 23 years. I was telling her we had a member who's been there his entire career when he joined our union. But there's so many things that we can work on. And look, Uncapped is obviously the goal for all of us, right? Whether that's possible or not, we don't know. But there's definitely things that we can do. This has always been a bill about jobs. How many jobs can you create? And I never really heard anybody say what you said, Betsy, that to Arlen's point, the fraction is so small. But, you know, there's so much work to do. And I think what I wanted to highlight is that we were slowly making it better. You know hopefully we can speed that up because we desperately needed But you know the ratio about jobs has always been a push because without that I mean we have some of your colleagues that won't ever vote for this and approve it unless we put a jobs ratio on it. So, you know, we're fighting a battle that is it's hard. It's hard because all these meetings we have and, you know, we just say, well, you know, and Graves has been here, and they are going to employ 100 people, and Fallout has 300 people. You know, it's hard to figure out where can we actually make the changes that will enable a show like Graves Anatomy to be here and continue on, or new shows like Graves Anatomy that they produce, I should say. So anyway, that's what I wanted to point out, that it was a lottery system, which was a mess at first, and now it's slowly getting better. But we definitely have a lot of work to do.

Chair Zuburrchair

Anyone else? I think Nick, did you have some questions?

Mike Millerwitness

Just for the sake of time, and I want to leave time for my colleagues over here if they have any questions. I did have one thing. We've talked about uncapping the program, which I think, Alex, you put it really well. That is really what we should strive for. That would solve a lot of the structural problems. Short of that, I think that more money for the program and some of these changes to the criteria make sense. We've also talked across both panels now about above-the-line costs and how and whether those should be counted. The one thing that you had said that I just wanted to follow up and maybe get a temperature check from the panel was the sunset. So California's program sunsets in 2030. I believe New York's 2036. I could be mistaken. I think Georgia may be the only jurisdiction that eliminated their sunset entirely. Yeah, I'm just wondering, I mean, do you think that that should also be part of the conversation the legislature has? Whoever from the panel would like to respond.

Jessica Calozaother

Well, you know, that's definitely a big thing because speaking to producers and creators who I've sat down with, that's a big issue for them because, you know, let's just take Betsy and Shonda. By the way, I worked on a couple of your shows, which were great. But they need that stability. Listen, someone like them who put out amazing content and its longevity, if the program's two years into its sunset, they may be like, well, why are we going to go there? Because then we run the risk of, you know, what if it goes away? I mean, and let's face it, look, I'm always a straight shooter. And, you know, we have a lot of new folks and some of your colleagues. And some of them don't understand the importance of these jobs and the families and what it does to California, the economy, the businesses, dry cleaning, donut shops. Right? I can go on and on. And so when they don't see that, they don't think long view. And so to take that away or at least extend it to like 10 years, I believe that's something that would also be in our favor to bring more productions here because that's something that I've heard from them directly. It's something they consider. They need stability to know this program is not going to go away.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Alex.

Gina Rodriguezwitness

I have one question and I think this goes a little bit to some of the comments that some of you ever made I know that when I was speaking to a lot of folks that were making decisions about keeping things in California versus not in California you know some of the reasons why they were not actually putting California on the piece of paper was because our effective tax rate was so low before the 4.0 program went through. I mean, when you actually had a 20 percent credit against 35, 40, and 45 and even 50 percent credits, it was sort of of like, well, why do the calculation when I know that it's not going to even come close to penciling out? I just wanted to actually ask Arlen and anyone else who wants to weigh in. My sense is that we've done some, that you've done some work looking at the effective rate of California's program now after the various bills that we've passed. And, you know, the 4.0 program, we raised the rate to 35%, which didn't include above the line. I know we want to move away from that terminology, but it didn't include above the line. The reason why we did that was we were trying to get to something that was close to a 30% effective rate compared to those states that had above the line, like Georgia, which was more at 30%. So we figured the 35% credit, because of the above the line, was close to a 30% effective rate. Now, I know that we've done some calculations with what we've done in response to the last session, and I understand that the effective rate is back down into the 20s. Can you talk a little bit about that?

Nick Schultzother

That's my understanding as well. One, thank you so much for you and your colleagues' work on SB 186. Before that, I think we were looking at a 17% effective rate. But, yeah, looking at the changes that were made, I think we're now hovering at, I would say, 10% less, so about 20-ish. We can give you the chart. afterwards, but I don't have the exact number, but I want to say about 20%. So the two ways we could deal with that is either by changing the effective rate, but also exempting the film and tax credit from the $5 million cap. So that's part of the issue. The monetization piece is the other piece that creates certainty, right? A longer program with the sunset, ensuring that there's more eligibility, including above the line, but the back end also matters, right? We want to make sure that when you're getting a tax credit that you can utilize it for the tax rate that you budgeted for.

Gina Rodriguezwitness

Merrill, did you want to add something, and then we're going to move on.

Mike Gipsonother

I would love to, yeah, both on the sunset and how competitive our rebate is or the percentage. So on the sunset, as an example, I'm currently bidding a film, an Amazon animated film, that is scheduled for 2028, right? if we have a sunset on the program, between now and then, the conversation could change. Right now, they can see a number, and then they can compare it to somewhere where they can count on it. And then as it relates to the rebates, I would like to highlight and just say thank you so much because our post-only tax incentive is now one of the most competitive in the world. and we were able to, or Assemblymember Schultz was able to secure the world's largest uplift for the scoring world, 15%. So that's unprecedented. And so therefore, the question that we need to ask ourselves is, why not us? If other territories are doing it, yes, we have to come up with the economic, the job impact reports and all of that. But really, the question is simple. Why not California?

Chair Zuburrchair

Anyone else? Okay. I'd like to thank you all for being here today. The next panel I think we going to be probing into the issue of why not us So but I want to thank you all for being here today and taking time out of your busy schedule so thank you very much Okay, we're going to call up our final panel. Welcome. So our final panel of the day is about evaluating the budget impacts of the California Film and Television Tax Credit Program. One of the challenges that we face in the legislature is that this tax credit program is scored by Department of Finance and is scored as a cost to the state budget, which of course means that we are making decisions about how we spend California public resources and whether or not this program is worthy of those expenditures. So I think one of the issues related to whether or not we can increase the size of the cap or take the cap off has a lot to do with how our Department of Finance and how we score these programs in the state budget, and that's what this panel is about today. So I'd like to welcome Stephen Chung, who's President and CEO of the Los Angeles Economic Development Corporation. I'd like to note that with him today is Shannon Sedgwick, Vice President of Research. She'll be able to assist with fielding any questions during the Q&A portion. Also today we have Rowan Isaacs, an economist with the Legislative Analyst Office whose program areas of expertise include economic development and the film and television industry. Welcome Rowan. Also we have with us today Matt Horton, a fellow advisor with the Milken Institute and previous director of the California Center at the Milken Institute. Welcome. As well as Cassandra Hazeltine, I hope I pronounced that right, president of FLIX, the film liaisons in California statewide, and the film commissioner with the Humboldt Del Norte Film Commission. So welcome today. I'd like to start with Stephen.

Mike Gipsonother

Thank you so much, Chairman Zipper, and the committee members for having us to be able to testify. Again, my name is Stephen Chung. I'm the CEO for the Los Angeles County Economic Development Corporation, and we're a nonprofit organization focused on inclusive economic growth for the Los Angeles region. and we're also able to do an economic impact report on the film and television tax credit 2.0 and the lead author is Shannon Sedgwick. That's why she's here to answer any questions you might have. For over a century, California has been the heart of the global entertainment industry and behind that industry is a network of workers across skilled spectrum and businesses of all sizes that depend on the production staying here in California. And the California film and television tax credit program as an investment in retaining that workforce and the economic activity it supports. The recent employment losses demonstrate What is at stake? Bureau of Labor Statistics data shows that California motion picture and video production industry average approximately 136,000 private payroll jobs in 2022. By 2025, that number has fallen to about 86,400 jobs. That is a net decline of nearly 50,000 jobs, or more than one-third. Employment was also about 20% below its pre-pandemic level. I want to put that in context. 50,000 people is a lot of people. That's the population of the entire West Sacramento region. These figures reflect several overlapping changes, including pandemic disruption, the dual Hollywood strikes, changes in commissioning, and competition in production as well. They are not all to be described as losses to other jurisdictions, but they demonstrate the scale of that contraction affecting California workers. The industry continued to make substantial contribution to our state economy. The Bureau of Economic Analysis estimates that motion picture and sound recording industries contributed approximately $58 billion to California's GDP in 2025. That is direct value added. before considering supply chain effects. BEA's category includes sound recording and is broader than just production employment figures. I just decided. California introduced a production tax credit in 2009 with $100 million annually. The program expanded to $330 million in 2015 and $750 million to 2025. The current program generally provides 35% of qualified spending with higher support for relocating series first California season. Recent legislation also created a standalone post-production credit. California must consider the effective cost of production, the certainty of receiving an award, and the time it takes to use the credit. Our competitors, as has been stated in the previous panel, use different tools. Georgia offers 20% base credit with a possible 10-point promotion uplift. British Columbia's basic production services credit is 36% of eligible local labor. The United Kingdom's standard expenditure credit is taxable and applied to different spending base. Headline percentages alone do not tell us which location has the lowest effective costs. The LADC Institute for Applied Economics has studied the program over time. These historic studies provide context and have estimated positive outcome for state and local fiscal return under their assumptions. Our 2014 study reported that approximately $19 in economic output per credit dollar. The 2022 study reported about $24.40, including suppliers and household spending. The published combined state and local fiscal return were one for each dollar is $1.11 in return and $1.07 return in 2022 with that study in 2022. State revenue support services across California, while local revenues benefit the jurisdiction that received them. The 2.0 program with analysis, which was the last release, estimated about $22 billion in total economic activities and $7.7 billion in labor income across productions study. The 4.0 program now expanded program is generating new commitments. CFC's first year of the expanded program included 170 projects, projecting $6.6 billion in direct California spending. The October award round added another 35 film project about billion Film LA reports released in October 21 showed that the local on location filming remained down nearly 5% in the third quarter but projects receiving safe credits accounted for about 40% of the script filming nearly twice their share a year earlier. They show encouraging participation alongside continued weaknesses rather than a complete recovery. Economic benefits reach beyond studios and beyond Los Angeles. Production supports drivers, carpenters, customers, technical workers, union covered work provides negotiated compensation and pension and health contributions as well. The industry purchase equipment, catering, lodging, and professional services through a supply chain. And activities occur statewide, not just in Los Angeles County but our 2022 study identified out out of zone filming in 24 counties across California. October's new award projected more than 450 filming days outside of Los Angeles zone and state revenue associated with activity support services throughout California. We therefore support a sustaining competitive credit with measuring its results, California wages, paid work hours, direct purchases and those made through supply chain across our counties and the state and local fiscal returns reported. Retaining production protects an established economic base and livelihoods connected to it. And before I close, I just want to say that a lot of times when people look at LADC, they think of us as a think tank with our research institute. But in fact, we're a do tank. We take the information and we do something with it. A lot of folks don't know that we have a business assistance program. And during the 2022 to 2024, when we lost all those jobs, our team actually fielded a lot of calls from businesses. One business called us, and as a sole provider in the entertainment industry, he lost his job and he didn't know what to do. And he was contemplating suicide because of that. That's the direct impact. So the cost is not just monetary and it's not just numbers, it's human lives. Thank you so much for your work to support this.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Steven. Next, Rowan Isaacs with the LAO.

Nick Schultzother

Thank you, Chair Sabur. Thank you, members of the committee. Rowan Isaacs from the LAO. I'm just going to make a few quick introductory points, and actually to something that Chezzebue had sort of alluded to. I think when we talk about the budget impact of the program, there are many different things you could be meaning when you say that, right? And so the first is just the gross fiscal cost and how much revenue is the state foregoing or paying out in refunds as a result of the program. But there's also, secondly, maybe the net fiscal cost, which is when we account for the fact that this additional production that we're incentivizing produces tax revenue, what is the net fiscal cost of the program after accounting for that. The final or third way you could think about it is think about the net fiscal impact, but relative to alternative uses of the money that the state could have used those funds for, especially given the requirements that are in place for a balanced budget. And that third distinction is particularly tricky to measure, just because there are all these indirect effects when we spend on film production and TV production. It has all these cascading effects on other industries and in the local area. But these alternative uses for money, for state resources, also have multiplier effects. And so it's not always clear relative to each other which use of the money would have the highest benefit to the state. One qualification, though, to all of that, even when we're thinking about these different measures, is that government programs aren required to make a profit in order to be a good use of state money Making a net fiscal return a positive net fiscal return is not necessary nor sufficient for being a viable or a good use of the state's money. So just to point that out as well. In terms of what available evidence tells us currently, we do find in the existing literature and what's out there is that fundamentally tax credits do increasingly and definitely incentivize productions to switch locations and do influence that decision greatly. Although there is still a case where we have to think about the number of productions that would have produced in the state regardless. And so that's a big question mark, and that's something that people try to estimate, and it's not always easy to do. Across various studies that have been done over the years, our office had previously assessed the film tax credit and had given a pretty broad range of possible estimates of roughly one quarter to three quarters of productions that may have filmed in the state anyway regardless of getting a tax credit or not. And obviously these effects are likely to change over time. Some studies also try to put these sort of effects into gross or net fiscal returns. The broader literature suggests that typically about 20 to 50 cents per dollar given to film tax credits is brought back in terms of increased revenues. Although Although I would say that when we think of California, California's film tax credit is designed in a way that is likely to increase the net fiscal return of the program compared to states like Georgia, for example, or other international countries. California has a competitive program. It has a jobs ratio. It tends to prioritize productions and applicants that would provide more jobs and more spending per dollar of credit given. At the same time, there are trade-offs with things like generosity. We recently increased the generosity of the program. A higher credit can mean fewer supported projects overall because each project takes up a larger piece of the pie. But we might be able to potentially attract stronger applicants if our credit is more generous. So there are a lot of ambiguities and uncertainties about which way different aspects of the program contribute. But California does have what we view as a better setup, more competitive process than a lot of other programs. And then just very quickly, finally, there have been some recent changes to the film tax credit outside of just the increasing of the size of the program, which sort of magnifies the effects of the program. I think the addition and expansion of refundability, the increasing of the generosity of the credit, things like that, are going to accelerate the cost to the state. and may mean, like I just mentioned before, could go either way, but there's maybe a possibility that we can, the more generous our credit is, the fewer productions we can fund in total. But I'll stop there, and thank you very much for your time.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Ron. Appreciate that. Next, I'd like to recognize Matt Horton.

John Harabedianother

Thanks, Chairman Zuber, and to the committee for your time. It's an honor to be here. As you mentioned at the stop, I used to work with my colleagues at the California Center with the Milken Institute. And in that capacity, we did a lot of studies on California's innovation-based economy and tools and strategies that can enhance and bolster that with entertainment sector being very entrenched in that analysis And so the last study we did on this topic was right in advance of the pandemic recovery So when the state foregoes a dollar of revenue through a tax credit, I think it's good to remember that the activity it hopes to buy arrives in three primary layers. And understanding how we score those layers in terms of the budget, I think is really important in terms of how you navigate this policy decision moving forward, especially around the cap. So like the first layer being the direct, you know, in terms of film and TV, you know, that those direct effects are wages, stage rental equipment, location fees. Indirect are more associated with catering, lumber, set materials, transportation, post-production. And VFX and insurance, and especially, as a side note, in the time of increasing uncertainty around AI and harboring post-production, I think, is really vital. And then induced. So those induced effects really speak to more of the spillover, the housing, the retail, the restaurants, the health care, the education. And those are larger, especially in terms of those induced effects when we're talking about jobs that pay a higher wage. And our study, we found back, and I think the Otis College report of 26 kind of underscores this. Creative economy wages pay more than 2.5 times the California average. Higher jobs carry a larger induced footprint than larger personal income tax footprint. And I think our – and it's been said a lot through this hearing that, you know, our core advantage here is the ecosystem. And that ecosystem, that local supply chain value capture, is really embodied in the indirect effects. And those only accrue in state if suppliers are in state. California's depth in both research and production supply chains is our inherent advantage, just like it was in Detroit before it wasn't. And every production that leaves erodes it, and that erosion compounds because of vendors, as you've heard, follow the work. So I think taking into account how those three layers interact with timing, mobility, our induced share, those spillover effects, really boil down to this key notion of certainty certainty and how the tax credit kind of works to provide that certainty or if it is capping. And I'm sorry, I didn't see that. Perfect. I'll finish up here. So I think the primary takeaway, and I'll take some questions later if you have any on the cap and maybe the benefits of or maybe the inhibitor nature of the cap. But tax credits do not create economic activity. Ecosystems do. A credit earns its cost when it keeps mobile high-wage work inside an ecosystem that is already deep enough to capture the supply chain and household spending that follows. So for film and television, Um, you know, the question for the budget is not whether the gross multiplier is X, it's whether the state will give the program enough certainty for the indirect and induced layers to compound and enough rigor in evaluation to prove that they did. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Next we have Cassandra Hazeltine, President of Flix. Welcome.

Jessica Calozaother

Thank you. Thank you, Chairs Ver and members of the committee. As you said, I'm Cassandra Hesseltine, Film Commissioner for Humboldt and Del Norte counties, as well as president of Flix. And for 16 years, I've been the boots on the ground, helping productions work in our communities and seeing where the dollars go. Across different versions of the California's film tax credit program, we've hosted participating productions including Swiss Army Man with Daniel Radcliffe, Bird Box with Sandra Bullock, which held Netflix's film viewing hours record for nearly three years. The sky is everywhere during the pandemic, and one battle after another, which resulted in my office receiving the Outstanding Film Commission International Award for 2026 from the Location Managers Guild International. Those are just some of the examples of this program bringing work and spending to our region. When a production comes to rural California, it brings outside dollars. It hires people, books rooms, rents locations, and buys supplies. One battle after another reported more than $2.1 million in spending in Eureka, including nearly half a million dollars in local wages, more than 900 jobs, and over 90 vendors. And it came in January. In rural California, off-season productions fills hotel rooms, brings customers to restaurants when they need business most, and the timing makes those dollars especially valuable. The spending extends beyond production purchases. A visiting crew can mean 200 to 300 people going out for dinner every night, shopping and exploring on their days off. Those meals, shopping trips and activities are additional sales for our local businesses. Local workers and businesses also spend their earnings circulating money throughout our economy. Statewide, the Motion Picture Association reports that 4,500 jobs and 700 vendors for one battle after another was spending reaching from Eureka to Sacramento to Los Angeles, San Diego, as well as four other communities throughout the state. But keeping the opportunity here took a filmmaker committed to California. Paul Thomas Anderson, one of our leading directors, used his influence to keep this production here, with the tax credit helping make the choice possible. We should not have to depend on a director of his stature fighting for California. We need an incentive strong enough that choosing California makes financial sense from the beginning. As it was noted earlier, last week, Film L.A. reported that the tax credit project now accounts for 40% of scripted and on-location filming in Los Angeles, nearly double last year's share, with incentivized productions more than doubling their shoot days compared to the same period last year. And what should be remembered in addition to that statistic is what was said by one of the producers whose show is now able to shoot here. Los Angeles is the big leagues, and after more than a decade away, I have forgotten what I was missing. From the cast and crew to the caterers everyone here brings their A Honestly moving here elevates everything Elle Wood Reed showrunner and executive producer of the hit CBS drama Tracker which moved production from British Columbia to Los Angeles for its fourth season. The earliest documented motion picture filmed in Los Angeles dates December 31, 1897. For nearly 130 years, California has cultivated world-class film crews whose expertise cannot simply be recreated overnight. We cannot afford to let producers like Elwood Reed forget what California has to offer because other states and countries have made it more financially attractive to film elsewhere. Another important factor is economic benefits continue long after their release through film tourism. One battle after another, an Academy Award winner for Best Picture is now bringing visitors to Eureka to find the payphone at our local grocery store. The interest has generated its own coverage. SFGate wrote about the payphone and people coming to see it. The New York Times published a driving tour of the movie's California locations throughout. And those vendors spend money on hotels, restaurants, transportation, shopping. Our Redwood Coast Museum of Cinema and map of the movies gives them more reasons to explore and stay. And we know that this can continue for decades. Return of the Jedi filmed in both Humboldt and Del Norte counties more than 44 years ago. Visitors still come to experience the Redwood landscapes where the speeder chase happened and the Ewoks lived. That interest led us to create the Forest Moon Festival, now approaching its fifth year as Star Wars celebrates its 50th anniversary in 2027. People come from across the country. One father and son stayed an entire week paying for accommodations, meals, transportation, and activities because a movie filmed here four decades ago. Expedia's 2026 research reports that 81% of Gen Z and millennial travelers planned getaways based on places they've seen on screen. We see that becoming actual visits and spending. There's also a quality of life benefit we cannot put a dollar amount on. During the one battle after another, a resident approached me and I thought I was getting a parking complaint. But instead, they thanked me because they had been struggling with winter depression and when they found out Leonardo DiCaprio was around the corner, it changed winter for them. At the Forest Moon Festival, a child asked, did you bring Disneyland to us? For families who cannot afford that trip, we brought an extraordinary experience to their hometown. I've watched our region struggle through changes in timber and cannabis. I see empty storefronts and beloved restaurants closing, and keeping economic opportunity here matters. Please consider the full reach of the investment, production spending, dollars circulating locally, tourism continuing for decades, and quality of life. California's identity and its tourism appeal as the home of filmmaking depends on continuing to make films here. From where I stand boots on the ground this industry is worth keeping and worth fighting for Thank you Thank you Cassandra Okay Really interesting panel Let me start with Assemblymember

Mike Millerwitness

Herbedian who I know had some questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to each of you for that testimony. Extremely helpful. I think that everything that everyone said was right and helpful, but I'm still, I think, searching for an answer to the simple question for this panel, which is, does the tax credit pay for itself and, more importantly, bring in much more than what we put out? And unfortunately, I don't know if any of the five of you or four of you actually answered that question. So I'm going to go to Rowan Isaacs, the LAO analyst. Does the tax credit 4.0, as we've structured it, pay for itself or bring in more? And I'm going to put the value of the industry aside and each of these jobs and the human lives. I think that we can very much justify what we're doing here by all of those intangible things. But if we want to just take that off the table and say, is this dollar spent bringing in more than we're spending? and what's the answer to that? Thank you, Assemblymember.

Nick Schultzother

The best answer I can give is that, well, so far, just to clarify, Program 4.0 is new enough that we can't really observe the data and the outcomes from those programs, so it might be a bit premature. On Program 4.0 specifically, we do have a required report that we'll be publishing in spring of 2028 that might be able to speak to that more. But based on the available evidence we do have, we would say that it probably doesn't pay for itself in terms of net fiscal return to the state, although it probably has a better return than many other state film tax credits. And I sort of mentioned that sort of range of estimates from other places of 20 to 50 cents on the dollar. Those are estimates from places like Georgia and New York. It's likely, it's probably reasonable to think that California's structure and the competitiveness and the way it's set up is more favorable for fiscal return. So it might be better than those states, but we think it's unlikely and relies on maybe overly optimistic assumptions to assume that it breaks even or makes a net fiscal gain for the state.

Mike Millerwitness

Got it. And is that – so – and I did write that down, which it seems low, but 20 to even 50 cents of a return. Is that because of the assumption that, to your point, a fourth or maybe three-quarters of the projects you are estimating would be here anyway? Is that why it's so low, or are there other things in your assumptions? That is one reason.

Nick Schultzother

Actually, one of the things that helps California somewhat also is its cap. You know, like in the U.K. or in Georgia, it is uncapped. And what that means is, you know, with California's process, we have a competitively ranked application system. and so the projects that get awarded a film tax credit by at least some metric are giving us a better bang for our buck in terms of job creation and spending. In places like Georgia or the United Kingdom, for example, it's more of an entitlement, essentially. It's not a competitive system to the same extent, and so you might get productions that are awarded a tax credit that aren't as competitive in terms of the amount of economic benefit they bring to that jurisdiction, but they still get the tax credit anyway. So on average maybe the bang for the buck of productions they get awarded a tax credit In California we might expect to be higher So that why the 20 to 50 cents the summarizing of fiscal estimates from other states we think that would be a lower bound for what we would think for California. But some of the other estimates that maybe describe the state as getting a net fiscal return from the film tax credit, we think are reliant on overly optimistic assumptions. And so we think it's – while I can't tell you for sure, and it's an unsatisfactory answer, somewhere in between those two is maybe a reasonable starting point.

Mike Millerwitness

Mr. Chair, do you mind if Stephen and Matt answer that question as well? Thank you. Appreciate that.

Mike Gipsonother

So based on the 2.0 analysis, what we found is that for every dollar that the tax credit put in, you get $1.07 back for state and local. So when you look at it, is it directly to the state of California? But if you also include local because then you don't have to actually allocate the funding from the state for other resources to the state, it's a combined. So from that perspective, in our opinion, yes, you do make the money back. Regarding whether if you don't get the tax credit, whether they're going to produce here anyways, possibly. But the data also show that for half of the applicants that didn't get the credit, they actually filmed outside of the state of California. And in those productions, about 78 productions altogether, they spent about $3.9 billion direct spend outside of the state of California. that if you look at the same calculation that we use, that's about a $7.7 billion output for the entire region, which can result in about $354 million in additional state and local that we didn't get here because of that. So is it a direct answer? It's hard to, because the calculation is not there, but what we do know is that for every dollar you put in, you get a $1.7 sets back for the state and local.

Mike Millerwitness

Matt, could we get a mic to Matt Horton?

John Harabedianother

I think a bit more esoteric point is, and Rowan can correct me if I'm wrong, I only play an economist on TV. I think the disconnect here on the value of the credit breaks down at the scoring, what I was trying to say about the direct, indirect, and induced. So, like, the job, like, our static budget scoring in terms of the hit to the general fund doesn't necessarily capture that local uptick and the value that's created from the economic activity. So, and I mean, and that's not a negative thing.

Chair Zuburrchair

I mean, it's designed to tell you guys, you know, what the state's position is in terms of the revenues and funds available. But it's not designed to – and the credit is not designed, especially in its later years, to tell you what the economic activity is actually doing. So there's a bit of a disconnect from how we did more dynamic scoring in the 90s versus how we do scoring today. Yep. No, helpful. All three of those answers are helpful for different reasons, and I just think it brings to light that the way in which we're looking at the return I think needs to be, especially for 4.0, really what we're focused on because when we go back to Sacramento and all of us can attest to this, it becomes a regional fight. it becomes a, and it shouldn't be, because of the testimony that we just heard, it also becomes a best use of a dollar fight. And I think that analysis and all of that, All the analysis that you are all doing really hopefully at some point can be more standardized and more objective so that we can just make the case without having to tug on the human heartstrings. That's super important. But when we're going into tough budget times, I just think that the numbers are really going to convince our colleagues that don't necessarily live in L.A. And so I appreciate it, Mr. Chair. And I think what we just talked about there is really important going forward. Thank you.

Maury McIntyrewitness

May I say something about that?

Chair Zuburrchair

Yes, of course.

Maury McIntyrewitness

You had asked about whether productions would have stayed anyways if they got the tax credit. Are they the ones that are going to stay anyways? Up north, we get productions all the time that want to come, and they come, scout, look, then find out they don't get the tax credit and have left. So statistically, I don't think it could be possible that the ones that happen to get it are the ones that are going to stay anyway and only the ones that don't get it leave. I think they stay because they got it. They got the tax credit. Or there's someone like PTA and has that power. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Assemblymember. I have a couple questions. Did you have some? Do you want to go, Dan? Okay, let me go. So I have a couple questions. So the first is, are we scoring these kinds of tax credit programs, both the film tax credit, maybe the R&D program as well, are we scoring them differently than the way other states score? Do other states use sort of more dynamic scoring of these programs? I think I had a conversation with Stephen earlier today, and we've got a bit of a disconnect in terms of the amount of – we clearly are scoring the cost side. And then I think there's, for me, there's a question of how much are we scoring and how much is it appropriate for us to score the dollars that sort of come back in from, you know, the employees that are employed, the businesses that are paying taxes. And then there's sort of more induced costs beyond that, which are, you know, the impacts that we have to our tourism industry and a whole host of other things that are sort of multipliers of that. So the question I sort of have is, to me, most states have uncapped programs, and they're smaller states than California. So why is it that they feel the comfort of doing that? Do they have dynamic scoring when they're evaluating their budgets, or are they just making a bigger investment, I guess, in terms of what they're doing and just knowing that the economic and the other benefits are harder to quantify and they're making those assumptions. So maybe I'll start with Matt and love to Hepro and others' perspectives.

Mike Gipsonother

Well, I think that's a great question, which is my roundabout way of saying I'm not quite sure in terms of how, like, New York. I don't know how New York has justified their uncapped amount. I know that there's other tricks in that municipal finance toolbox that other states use. I think there's an equity fund that they use in the U.K. where they're putting public dollars into production that has a public return that kind of recycles and revolves the fund. So, I mean, there's different methods and strategies that I think in that toolbox that are deployed. But I would have to do a much broader comparative analysis on those finances to speak more authoritatively on it.

Chair Zuburrchair

Eben, can you and Ranyu, go ahead.

Nick Schultzother

So obviously we can really speak for the Department of Finance themselves I mean they tend to use more static scoring in a lot of tax expenditure report and other products they put out Informally I don want to speak for other places but I think informally, I think Congressional Budget Office in DC does some dynamic scoring. I think I've seen there are probably some examples of doing dynamic scoring, but obviously you're having to make a lot of assumptions, and you're having to create models that could be quite wrong. And so it just increases the uncertainty and the risk around your forecast being inaccurate, I guess.

Chair Zuburrchair

Is there a way, though, of doing dynamic scoring where you actually have enough of a level of conservatism that you know that you're protecting the state budget but actually reflecting more the value of these programs to our economy and our workers and the taxes that result in that?

Nick Schultzother

I mean, a lot of analysis might come up with a lower and an upper bound, you know, reasonable range of what the number could be and it could be one option is to use the lower bound like use the more conservative estimate I mean that might lead to being overly optimistic you know in some cases which has its own cost right you know not not funding programs because you're being too conservative also has an opportunity cost associated with it but that's something that could be done theoretically yeah I mean with many of the decisions we're making around the budget we don't have certainty in terms of what it's what it's going to cost us right I mean we have some amount I mean when we're making decisions around health policy we're making projections that are uncertain to a certain extent and we use our best our best data and judgment to try to judge what that's gonna the impact is going to have on the budget but just sort of seems to me that we could move towards dynamic scoring and do it in a way that's conservative enough that we know that we're protecting the state's budget, but at the same time scoring these kinds of economic development programs in a way that more fully represents the impact, the positive impacts that it's having to the state budget. I don't know if you'd want to comment or Matt or anyone else.

Chair Zuburrchair

There's a bit of disparity there too, I think to your point in terms of the state's revenue versus local and county. So, I mean, that also seems like the, you know, the rollercoaster of state revenues, you know, when times are good, times are good, and when times are bad. So it's getting off of that roller coaster, I think, is a much broader, you know, policy discussion. Anyone else want to comment to Steven or Cassandra?

John Harabedianother

In terms of the range that you mentioned, Shannon and team actually was, we were hired by LA28 to do an economic impact report on the impact of the Olympic Games. And what the team did is actually did a high range and low range using two different methods so that you can actually see what the scope. So from that economic impact report, for example, we reported that the total economic impact for the Olympic Games could be on the very low end, $20.5 billion, and the upper range of $40.6 billion. Yes, it's a range, but at least you know what the calculation is going in. So to Rowan's point, perhaps that might be giving that parameter that would give the state a bit more comfort knowing what the parameters are.

Jessica Calozaother

I just want to make a comment about the difference that exists too with the allocation of the credit versus the redemption. So if you're kind of wondering what the other jurisdictions that have uncapped, it's because when they're awarded the credit, it's not redeemed until years later. And we have that same situation here in California. So if you're looking on on an annual basis about the redemption of the credit, then typically you see it much lower than the caps that we have Sorry just very quickly to broadly agree but also note that the refundability provisions have been made a lot more readily available, and so I think that's going to nudge the total, the long-term cost of the program much closer to the headline number.

Chair Zuburrchair

Alar, did you have any questions?

Mike Millerwitness

Could you repeat what you just said or say it more slowly? I didn't catch that.

Jessica Calozaother

My apologies. So like was mentioned, often a tax credit is awarded to a production company, but they might have to wait until they complete production and then in the past until they had tax liability to utilize the credit. But what's happened in the last few years is we introduced refundability for the film tax credit and then made it apply to more awardees and so when you in some cases shorten the period in which you can get the credit refunded so in that case you are essentially accelerating the schedule in which you get the benefit of the credit so we're paying with refundability you can immediately elect to have the credit paid out to you and so it sort of moves up in time when the credit is being paid out by the state essentially or the fiscal cost to the state.

Chair Zuburrchair

Okay, and so the cost of the credit and the benefit that the company is getting is happening at the same time as it's the cost of the state. Not always at the exact same time, but more immediate than before. Okay.

Jessica Calozaother

I think previously we had cases where production companies would get big credit awards, but maybe they had other credits or maybe they had other deductions and they didn't have enough tax liability to use their credits, and so they sort of just carry them forward. But obviously the credits lose value, economically speaking, over time, and they become less valuable. And so with refundability, you can just immediately, if you don't have tax liability, you just immediately elect to be refunded for those tax credits.

Chair Zuburrchair

Okay. I mean, on the topic of kind of how we're scoring this, This is a hot topic on the budget committee in Sacramento on a number of issues. I sit on the budget health subcommittee, and it's a conversation we have a lot around if we're doing these health investments that are ensuring that people are getting preventative care, for example, instead of going into the ER and getting your medicine or getting treatment, which is much, much more costly. Why is that not kind of captured in the cost of, in the scoring that's done by LAO or Department of Finance? And we make that point every year and it doesn't change. And I think that this is another example of why thinking more about dynamic scoring is so important. because in conversations that I've had with studios in my district, they're talking to some of their employees about selling their homes or losing their homes because they're not working anymore. The kind of economic impact that this will make if the industry fails in Los Angeles is hard to imagine it really hard to imagine what that looks like And so thinking about how we do that I think is a critical part of the conversation that we have to incorporate. And I wanted to go back to you, Mr. Horton. You mentioned you could talk a little bit more about the cap and how it inhibits. I mean, I understand the point that's being made that, you know, that you have to kind of find a balance, right, and not just willy-nilly give out a bunch of tax credits to things that are probably not, you know, going to be successful or create a big, you know, economic benefit or, you know, et cetera, et cetera. so you know so finding that that sweet spot I think is always the complicated part of legislative work but wanted to hear more on your thoughts around the cap

Mike Gipsonother

well I mean I think essentially and it's been said in this room today I mean the program that was just extended I mean we can see that the program works but it's also the program is constrained and there's a top on its growth. So the cap is limiting its growth and preventing some of those indirect and induced effects that we talked about earlier. So without inducing more broader activity from the top down, we're limiting some of the local uptake and how that spreads out through our communities and our ecosystems. And this isn't in L.A. And the longer that cap or the more stringent that cap, I think the more erosion you'll see from those ecosystems. And it kind of plays out from the stories that we've heard today. So I think it's all in the – how we bake the – in the ingredients. It's like if we're designing the cap, then in that design, we're designing some kind of limitations around the effectiveness of the program.

Chair Zuburrchair

And are you – I don't know if you'd say, but are you a believer of just scrap the cap? Or you think some kind of cap is like a reasonable safeguard that needs to be somewhere?

Mike Gipsonother

I think there's got to be some, as you said at the opening of your comments, we're not advocating for some kind of fiscal mismanagement here. But there's, from a dynamic scoring standpoint, to see how other states have been able to find that balance for other regions so that they can support their critical industries or priority sectors, that their ecosystems have been decades building out, that that seems to be a point of further analysis. Like, why did the state abandon more dynamic scoring in the 90s? I don't know. But I mean, figure that out.

Chair Zuburrchair

And you've mentioned that a couple times. Can you talk about the dynamic scoring of the 90s that you speak of?

Mike Gipsonother

I was not in the legislature then. Well, sadly, it's just a footnote here in my talking points. But, you know, to get to the root of that and maybe some legislative pressures at the time. I mean, I was in high school in the 90s, so we've got to figure out. But I'm also curious now, and I would love to see a bit about what the autopsy of that would look like. Sadly, I don't know right now.

Chair Zuburrchair

I don't know if anyone else wanted to jump in on this conversation about CAPS.

Nick Schultzother

Just to come back more generally to dynamic scoring, I think dynamic scoring is hard, I think people will tell you. And I think your example of providing preventative care, maybe providing preventative care to someone who doesn't have access otherwise has induced ancillary benefits. But tracking those benefits down the road, that might lead to them doing better in school, which then leads to them getting a better job in the future. It's really hard to maybe always track all of these. And so rather than like a blanket, you know, dynamic scoring everything, you know, there are some, there are definitely policies that might be more suited to dynamic scoring where we have better information, where we have lots of economic literature to pull on. And so it's really more of a case-by-case basis. But in general, dynamic scoring is difficult and subject to a lot of uncertainty.

Chair Zuburrchair

Okay. Yeah. Okay. I had a couple questions for Mr. Chung as well. Maybe you can add on to this. Yeah, do you want to add on to this, respond to somebody?

Gina Rodriguezwitness

So just, as you were mentioning about the preventive care aspect, right, perhaps the way to look at it is that we're looking at 50,000 jobs less than before. Is that not worth California to do something about? So maybe we can look at what those jobs were before, how much they paid, and what we've lost in that process. Second, as we're looking in the future is previously we had the studio space, we have the cast and crew members, we were unrivaled. Right now, Georgia, other location have the sound stages. They now have the crew. They now have the infrastructure. And speaking of which, we should also invest into studio infrastructure here to make us more competitive as well. But this is about investing in the future economy. For LADC, we don't do just entertainment. entertainment, we've been pushing to do more infrastructure development in aerospace, defensive space, space commercialization for the entire state, bioscience and so on and so forth. The way to look at it, I would say, is also, yes, we need to do more study on how the rest of the states are calculating how they're getting their investments back. But if Georgia, Illinois, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, Louisiana, New York, British Columbia, Quebec, Australia, Ireland all have tax incentives? Yes, we should look at it. But I don't think we're the smartest people in the world. We are smart, but the thing is there's a reason why they're creating these tax incentives as well. So those are the preventive aspects is to look at the symptoms and how the rest of the world is treating this, why they're investing in this particular sector. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

I just had a couple quick questions and then we'll wrap up. So the $.07 that was projected for the 2.0 program in terms of tax revenues that come back to the state and local, state and local together, right? Can you just describe for me some of the things that are not included in that? So I'm assuming that because it's hard to quantify some of these things, that you actually have not included a lot of the tax revenues that come from some of the indirect and some of the induced economic activity. Can you just cover what is not included in the $1.07?

John Harabedianother

Since Shannon, you wrote that you want to tackle this first? So we are looking at the fiscal return on the supply chain and estimation and of household expenditures from employees of the direct industry and the supply chain activity What we aren looking at is federal fiscal return So we looking at specifically federal fiscal return We excluded that deliberately so that we can focus on your city level, your county level, and your state level fiscal return. So that includes supply chain as well.

Chair Zuburrchair

So in terms of supply chain, when you talk about supply chain, And does that include all the small business expenditures that come directly from what the productions are spending?

John Harabedianother

Right. So those would be all your contracted vendors.

Chair Zuburrchair

Okay. So the taxes they're paying, so would it then include the taxes that the employees of the small businesses are paying?

John Harabedianother

Yes.

Chair Zuburrchair

Okay. And would it include the expenditures that relate to impacts on the tourism industry?

John Harabedianother

No.

Chair Zuburrchair

Okay. Would it – I assume that when the budget is being evaluated, it's not including, for example, expenditures related to either job loss or social safety net programs.

Jessica Calozaother

and I'll let Mr. Rowan answer that if he can.

Chair Zuburrchair

But I'm assuming that we're not basically talking about when we're losing jobs, we're not evaluating the costs related to employment, unemployment compensation or the loss to Medi-Cal coverage, all of those kinds of impacts that relate to, that are connected to job losses. And I'm assuming that's not part of the $1.07.

John Harabedianother

No, that's not. Our analysis looks specifically at those productions that receive the credit. So it's only looking at the ripple effect of that spending, and it's not taking into account any kind of the counter effects of the decline in the industry is actually experiencing. It also doesn't capture the full impact of the industry here in the state. We are only looking at those productions that are receiving the credit. So what we aren't looking at in terms of a fiscal return is the rest of the activity that takes place in the industry that don't receive the credit. So if you did incorporate that element, you'd be capturing a much larger fiscal return associated with the industry. There's only a subset.

Chair Zuburrchair

And by that, what you're talking about is the X billions of dollars related to all of the productions that went to Georgia or Canada. Is that right? that we're not counting the loss related to that?

John Harabedianother

Not the loss. The activity that is taking place here without credits. We don't factor that into quantifying that whole size of the industry and its economic impact.

Chair Zuburrchair

So when Stephen mentioned the contribution to GDP, that was industry-wide. This is how much it's contributing to our economy. This is the proportion of our economy here in the state. When we're looking at this ROI from the program, it's only specific to the program and not taking into effect the net changes or negative effects that are happening industry-wide. Got it. Thank you. Mr. Ronda, I don't know if you want to add anything.

Jessica Calozaother

Just a couple of things. Obviously, we have a respectful, maybe, difference in opinion. And like I mentioned in my initial comments, there are all these indirect and knock-on effects of providing incentives and a fiscal boost to a particular industry. But because of the way the state allocates its money that would also be the case with other uses of money And so an analysis would have to balance those two and have to take into account the opportunity cost of not funding something else. And then just very quickly, I know you sort of briefly mentioned scoring and things like that. I know we can't really speak to the Department of Finance. It's not here. We don't really want to speak for them. But yeah, they are not trying to consider all these induced and dynamic effects when they're doing their scoring. It's static.

Chair Zuburrchair

Well, thank you. I want to thank everyone on the panel today for coming. I'm going to now thank you very much. We're going to actually allow members here to make some closing comments. I don't know if you'd like to start. Do you want to go first? Yeah. We'll recognize Assemblymember Schultz first.

Alex Aguilarwitness

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I'll be brief. Really appreciate everyone coming down today, and I'm going to stick around for public comment, too. I just wanted to say for the last panel, I didn't ask any questions. I really appreciated the testimony, but the only observation I wanted to make is I just think there's some things like you know when you see it. For example, I know that when people in my district are working, the economic benefits are tenfold, and I really don't need an analyst to tell me that. No disrespect to anyone. It's just like I know it because I see it. Same way we could talk about the child and dependent care tax credit, and you could try to quantify how that might help our economy when parents can actually – you can have two incomes and both people can go to work. Hard to quantify the exact amount of that economic impact, but I know it's there. And so I think that that's what I would really say is I think the dynamic scoring, all the things that you talked about, Mr. Chair, I fully support. But it's a false narrative to suggest that this program is anything but a net positive to our communities and to California at large. And I think we just have to combat that misinformation that might exist. And the only other thing I'll just close with is there was so much good stuff discussed today, Very promising, the possibility of a federal tax credit that could be stackable with the California credit. But I really just wanted to thank you again, Mr. Chair, and our speaker for both your leadership and say that we really can't rest on our laurels. Program version 4.0 was a substantial improvement over the status quo, but we have to be talking, in my humble opinion, about lifting the cap. We have to be talking about extending or perhaps even eliminating the sunset altogether, really taking a hard look at above the line like all that has to be on the table and yes you know to one of the earlier panels I think that when you talk about even though there was some great work done in post-production and there's a boatload more to do there there's so many things we didn't talk about today a lot of folks in my district are being employed shooting commercials we're not incentivizing nearly enough of that game shows are leaving the state of California and I really do agree with miss Ryan's comments at the beginning why should we be picking and choosing why should there be winners and losers. Let's incentivize all of it to stay. So I look forward to working with all of you to do that. Really appreciate all the expertise and the passion that was here today. And let's get it done in 2027. Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Assemblymember Schiavo.

Betsy Beerswitness

You know, I'm so grateful to hear from everyone today and to have this conversation. I think We've seen, and to my colleague, Assemblymember Schultz's comment, we see it in our community. We know if people are working or not. And one studio that I spoke to has half the number of people they had working for them just a couple years ago. and you know the kind of impact in our community again you know the story that was was discussed earlier about the Grey Anatomy spinoff that could have been years of work for people in my community Years. Years of work. Oh, my gosh. It's just really, really painful to think about. Missing out on those opportunities for our community when they're really needed right now. People are struggling. And this is not only a critical industry for workers in our community and the creative economy and the creative identity of our community. It's our history. It's tied to Los Angeles in so many different ways. And it is why people come here. It is why people visit here and go to different locations. My kid and I just took a vacation last summer, and we specifically went to some locations where things were filmed. And that is how we chose places to go. And it truly is, you know, something that we have to figure out. And I think we have to have these hard conversations of how are we going to figure out a value attached to this? What do we want to do around the cap and the sunset? How do we make this more reliable and something that people can depend on and plan for? Because when you're planning something that could be running years out, you can't be thinking about if something's going to be there for you in a year or two that you need to make it work. so you know I think the folks who came here today and there's a number of us from this area very ready to roll up our sleeves and make sure that we find the right balance for this and that this is an investment that our state continues to make and look forward to working in partnership that also you know people choose not to quote gray's anatomy but choose us choose us here in LA and California and make sure that make sure that we can you know be successful together so I'm looking forward to this work and what we can do in 2027 thank you

Chair Zuburrchair

so I want to thank all of the panelists today for sharing their expertise and perspectives and obviously to my colleagues here you know the folks that are up here today have really been in this fight to make sure that we're preserving and improving the environment in which the film and television tax credit, the film and television industry contributes to the state of California and our workers. I also want to thank the Television Academy for graciously hosting us and again Speaker Rivas and I also want to thank Governor Newsom and the Senate President Pro Tem, Lamone for their leadership and commitment to strengthening our film and television industry. Um, you know, today's discussion reinforces why this committee's work is so important. California's leadership in film and television is an extraordinary asset, but maintaining that leadership will require continued investment, innovation, and a willingness to confront the challenges that it's facing this industry. We've heard about the importance of the film and television industry to our state's economy, the pressures facing workers and businesses, and the opportunities we have to strengthen this program's competitiveness. And while we've made significant progress through the expansion of the film and television tax credit last year and the passage of SB 186, we know that our work is far from finished. We need to think beyond a single bill or tax credit and develop a comprehensive strategy to ensure that California remains the best place in the world to create, produce, and innovate. As we look towards the next legislative session, we intend together to continue working to address the remaining impacts of the corporate tax credit cap and identify additional opportunities to strengthen the film and television tax credit program. We need to evaluate the things that are eligible. You know, there are many kinds of programs that are not even part of the program now, and we're losing them to other states. We need to reevaluate above the line. There are many those expenditures. We obviously have to do that in a thoughtful way, so it's not picking up executive compensation. But we need to make sure that the actors and actresses and others that are above the line that are dependent on this program, that we actually are doing this in a way that's competitive with other states. We need to think about raising or eliminating the cap. We need to continue figuring out how we strengthen post-production under Assemblymember Schultz's leadership. And we need to focus on how we score this program to make sure that what we all know is actually reflected in our budgetary decisions. So with that, I look forward to working with our colleagues, the governors of the new administration, our labor partners, and creative professionals to turn the ideas discussed today into meaningful action. California built its leadership in film and television through generations of extraordinary talent, hard work, and innovation. Our responsibility now is to ensure that the next generation has the same opportunities right here in California. So I want to thank everyone who participated today. I look forward to continuing this important work. Now we are going to turn to public comment. I'm going to ask people that want to, can we get everyone to line up over here along this wall that would like to say something? And then depending on how many people are here, we'll determine how much time we can allocate. I want to note that this hearing has been live streamed and will be archived for viewing purposes on the California Assembly website. The agenda and supplemental materials for the hearing are available on that website. And you can also submit written testimony to staff following the hearing. and please go ahead and just contact my staff in the Capitol. Let's see if we can get everyone just to line up on the stairs here who wants to make a comment. Great. I think we've got some folks coming from this side, so let me just wait a minute just to get a sense. Okay, that's it. Okay, let's go ahead and comment. We'll give everyone one minute.

Mike Gipsonother

My name is Brian Rawlson. I'm a film composer here in Los Angeles and an independent film producer. We talk about the downstream effects, the cost effectiveness of these rebates. There's also an effect of just the affordability of California. It's impacting union contracts. They are high because they reflect the cost of living here. living here and the cost of doing business here. Food prices go up, our catering costs go up. Gas prices go up. For whatever those reasons are, transportation prices go up. Generators costs go up. Like, everything goes up. So it's not just what the rebates can do to offset that, but it also every other legislation we do that increases costs to the affordability of California chips away at making this a place that we can do films I had a line producer do out a budget of the film that they really want to shoot in California and it going to cost between and million And they like, you know, if we go do this in Mexico, if we do it in New Mexico, we can do this for about five to six. And so those are the things that we have to deal with. And the last thing I'll leave you with is I really, as we look at job services, we're seeing our ways to calculate these dynamic qualification figures, how many jobs. Don't forget about the independent films and the independent productions. They're going to have smaller crews by the nature of their smaller budgets. But these films that are in that $5 to $10 million range, these are not the studio Marvel films that we're talking about. And they're going to have smaller crews. They're probably going to lose out on a lot of these things that look at a job services ratio to qualify because they're going to have a much smaller crew. But those are the filmmakers of tomorrow and the future people that are going to – if we get them used to working here and loving working here, when they get to do the next Marvel Avengers movie, they will want to come back here and do it because that's what they've learned is where you make films. So if there's a way that we can incentivize or even if we're going to baby step to an uncap thing, uncap below a certain budget level so these independent productions that are going to take a small amount anyway by the nature of their budgets can just freely be incentivized to also work here.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you. Could you, for the record, just state your name and the city that you live in?

Mike Gipsonother

Sure. Brian Ralston, R-A-L-S-T-O-N, and Los Angeles, California.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you very much. Next, Naiman, where you live, and then your comment.

Nick Schultzother

Hi. My name is Michael Elton. I live in Los Angeles. I prepared a little statement here. I'll try to get through it as quickly as I can. So I thought it was going to be a fly on the wall. So Mr. Chair, members of the committee, first I want to express my appreciation for the significant steps you've already taken to strengthen California's creative industries, particularly with the expansion of the film and television tax credit and the passage of AB 2319. These are important accomplishments, and I encourage you to build upon them by reiterating your closing remarks and emphasizing a more comprehensive strategy for California's entire creative economy. While I recognize the scope of today's agenda, like Assemblymember Schultz said in his closing remarks, the creative economy extends beyond film and television to music, animation, gaming, advertising, design, digital media, performing arts and the thousands and thousands of small businesses and skilled professionals supporting these industries. I also share your sentiment when I say that the urgency is real. Mr. Matt Horton earlier spoke a bit on the Otis Report of 26, and according to that same report, California lost approximately 114,000 creative economy jobs between 2022 and 2025. So the testimonies of the panels today could speak much better on the tax incentive programs than I ever could. So I want to just conclude here by just encouraging to look beyond tax incentives like reducing the cost of businesses, the cost of doing business in California, reducing production overhead with exploring streamlining permitting standardizing fees, eliminating duplicative charges, provide affordable parking and base camps for us and sorry, and and skilled per shoot, and just reducing the cost of production. I would also encourage to strengthen education and technical training and workforce development. There's already a foundation through the film commission's career pathways training program and New York City main to New York post program which offers another model combining technical education with job placement and career support I would also encourage supporting small creative businesses I point to the LA County Entertainment Business Interruption Fund which provided $4 million to 363 small businesses. And finally, two things that I think also need to emphasize are fundamental forces changing the industry, which is corporate consolidation and generative artificial intelligence. The Attorney General's recent proposed Paramount Warner Brothers settlement, which included a 47.5 million dollar workforce fund, demonstrates the importance of examining consolidation's impact on workers, competition, and creative output. And while the Otis report said that AI wasn't a job loss, but wasn't the primary cause of employment loss, employment loss, it's still impacting creative work and raising serious questions about intellectual property, compensation, and future employment. So I just urge the committee to explore some of these examples and consider a coordinated statewide creative economy strategy with measurable goals. Thank you. Thank you so much.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you. Could you leave your contact information? My staff is right over here. Yeah, sure. Thank you. Appreciate it. So we can follow up. Next.

John Harabedianother

Good afternoon. Thanks for having me on this, Mr. Zabor, Mr. Shultz, Mr. Salvo. Sorry if I got your name wrong. My name is Dijon Ellis. I live in Valley Glen. I'm the business manager at IATSC Local 80, representing Grips, Craft Service, and Medics. The person before me mentioned the creative economy. Our industry helps drive the creative economy. Our industry helps drive tourism. I think it's important that we look at the entire ecosystem. our last panel with the analysts. It's all about dollar in, dollar out. I get that for the LAO. But if we can look at the ecosystem as a whole. And also, Assemblymember, she brought it up. We're asking, what about shows that actually stayed? What's the impact? And also, the contraction of the industry, what's the impact? How has it hurt us? I think also will help support for your colleagues up north as well to support this program. I think if we look at the entire ecosystem and what film and television, and that's everything, commercials, post, animation, what that does to drive this economy in the whole state, I think it's important for your colleagues to know and for the public to recognize that the ecosystem of film and television, of production, how much it actually helps the entire state. Thank you for your time.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you very much. Next name and city.

Jessica Calozaother

Chair in members, Alex Torres. For the purposes of hearing, I hear on behalf of predominantly two clients, the Chula Vista Entertainment Company and the Out of Zone Coalition. Chula Vista Entertainment Company is developing an independent production hub in the San Diego region. You heard about the importance of workforce development here, developing that talent pipeline. It was mentioned a little bit about the importance of the ecosystem. Without roots, that ecosystem could never truly thrive. And so developing out-of-zone pipelines like the Chula Vista project is really critical to keeping that talent here and developing those up-and-coming artists and reducing those barriers to entry into the industry. The company also co-founded the Out-of-Zone Coalition. Our more than 40 members include creative professionals, arts organizations, and independent producers focused on geographic equity, workforce development, a lot of the discussion points you just heard. The recent conversations about consolidation, competition, and workforce pathways I think offers an opportunity to get everybody in a room. The statewide creative strategy is a great idea for you and how we get all stakeholders together to identify how we make this program work I think plus one on a lot of different points made on multiple panels here today As an aside lastly on behalf of the National Independent Venue Association of California representing over 650 independent music venues and festival promoters, we love the conversation, the comprehensive creative economy conversation. Plus one, they drive a lot of our largest California independent music festivals. So look forward to all the conversations to come on to create a strategy. Thank you. Thank you for being here. If you could leave your contact

Chair Zuburrchair

information with my staff, I'd appreciate it. Next.

Mike Millerwitness

Hi. Hi. Nice to see you. My name is Karen Baker-Landers. I'm a vice president of the California Post Alliance and one of the sponsors of AB 2319, the post-production bill. And I just want to thank you all for being here. This is so important. One of the things I wanted to talk about today was the negative narrative about California and changing that because we can get the tax incentives, but there is honestly such a machine out there trying to keep California down. And I've said this before. If they know if we get it right that it's game on for California, we will get the work back. the talents here it's a creative mentality that we have here it's a creative culture and to maintain that is so important and I don't know how to go about changing the negative narrative but it's so important because I have producers I'm a supervising sound designer I have producers and directors asking me about these incentives asking me about the post incentive when is it going to happen they're in the queue. They're waiting to do their films here. They don't want to go away. But the other thing I wanted to say was I'm speaking at the American Film Institute tonight, students, and I want to be able to tell them there's an industry here. They come from all over to go to this institute. And I want to be able to say we're fighting for you and that'll stay here because we need those voices in this state. And that was pretty much it. And thank you both, But thank you especially to Assemblymember Schultz for standing by us and fighting so hard.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you for being here today. Next, nice to see you.

Gina Rodriguezwitness

Nice to see you as well. Good afternoon. My name is Malachi Simmons. I'm a resident of Los Angeles. I'm the vice president of IATSC Local 728, as well as the Los Angeles County Federation of Labor. This tax incentive is a jobs bill. It's point blank. And it's not just a jobs bill. It's a careers bill. The Los Angeles County Federation of Labor believes that union jobs are a pathway out of poverty and homelessness. So this is a pathway for, I want to talk about the social impact and a pathway for members. From the IA's perspective, we've had a relationship with Hollywood CPR, our pathway program, for over 20 years. The DGA and WGA has a similar program of lifting people from underrepresented communities and giving them pathways into the industry. Six years ago, we incorporated that into our contract where we have internships within every department on the set. That was then strengthened by this tax incentive with the uplifts of encouraging productions to include interns on their sets. I think this is a reflection of the legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King that also felt that union jobs were a pathway out of poverty, the work of Sister Dolores Huerta as well. So once they get in the process, of this, they need jobs to continue to stay in it. A recent graduate from Hollywood CPR spoke about how he was on a continuous pathway of fast food job, after fast food job, after fast food job. And these programs, for the first time, provided him with the respect and dignity of being able to support his family and seeing a future where he felt seen as an individual. So I want to thank you for the work that you all have done, done, and I hope to continue this conversation so we can strengthen this program for future careers and people to come. Thank you.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you so much.

Alex Aguilarwitness

Good afternoon, everybody. Good afternoon, Mr. Chair and Assembly members. My name is Steve Kang, President of the Board of Public Works and Chief Film Liaison for the City of Los Angeles and Mayor Karen Bass. We appreciate the legislature's expansion of the state television tax credit to $750 million. But as you heard from many of us today, there is much more work to do. We strongly support an uncapped state tax credit system, including Above the Line, and expanding eligibility to include reoccurring reality and competition television shows. We must remain competitive, not only attracting new productions, but also in retaining existing productions, protecting good paying union jobs, and supporting local businesses. We look forward to our partnership and making sure that Los Angeles and California remains the entertainment capital of the world. Thank you very much.

Chair Zuburrchair

Thank you. Thank you, Mayor Bass, for all of her support. With that, I'd like to thank everyone who participated today. I want to thank, in particular, Sheila McFarland, who is my legislative director sitting to my right She has been working night and day over the last month on this I also want to thank our assembly sergeants who came in today to make sure that we are well served, as well as folks from the assembly communications staff. So thank you very much. I want to thank the staffs of all of my colleagues and my staff in particular. I think they're all here today, and the staffs of all of my colleagues. So with that, thank you for all your participation. I want to thank those in the audience for coming and having such interest in this important topic. And with that, the hearing of the Assembly Select Committee on Growing and Retaining the Creative Economy is adjourned. Thank you. Thank you.

Source: Assembly Select Committee Growing And Retaining Creative Economy California · October 29, 2026 · Gavelin.ai