November 12, 2026 · Budget Committee · 26,719 words · 14 speakers · 274 segments
. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . . Thank you. Thank you.
Just remember, my microphone's always on. I know that. You should be careful with that. That bridge is going to say all sorts of stuff, wouldn't you? I need the microphone. Okay.
Thank you, Madam Chair.
Craig Harper, JBC staff. Pleased to be joined by Chief Economist Sabetsky because I think the light's on. Yep. It says it's on. I'll crowd it. Now it's on. I'd have to just eat the microphone, apparently. Okay, so Craig Harper, JBC staff, pleased to be joined by Chief Economist Szebetsky because I think we can assume that there going to be a number of questions throughout this presentation And best to have the source here on the revenue side because I think a lot of those questions are going to relate to revenues We're in a bit of an awkward situation, as you all know, with this document was complicated because I had to summarize the request in the context of the September forecast. and then as we'll talk about, the landscape shifted dramatically the day after we received the request.
So first of all, we're glad to have everyone back. Welcome, Representative Garcia, to the JBC hearing room. We're glad to have you all back, and we're glad to be back in your hearing room. Sorry for the cold and sorry for the dark. We have a light bulb issue that's flashing if all the lights are on. I, this is, it was, it was down last week and then it was back up again and now it appears to be down again. So apologies for any convenience to members or folks in the audience as well. This is an annual presentation that kicks off the committee's budget process for the fiscal year. And so you'll see the title of the document overview of the fiscal year 27-28 budget requests. I feel like this document really needs a lot of asterisks around it because everything is so different than it was literally the day that we received the request. But the goal of this document is to provide an overview of the budget request. And in a typical year, well, we'll just jump in. Let's turn to page two, since the table of contents is page one. If in a typical year, as we did this year, we get the budget request on November 1st under statute. This year we received a good chunk of requests on Friday, October 30th. That was from the independent electeds. the governor submitted the request for all of the agencies that are under the governor and OSPB on Monday, November 2nd. And the role of this document in a typical year, and I've incorporated that into the document for this year, is to take that request that we receive on November 1st, overlay it on both of the September forecasts, and both summarize the major points that are in the request. This document does tend to be general fund heavy. there's massive components of the request that are cash funds, federal funds, etc. that I don't give a lot of attention here because we need to keep this document manageable. But summarize the major points and themes of the request and then take that whole set of data and overlay it on the September forecasts and give you an indication of whether the request is in balance and if it is, how much extra you have, if it's not, how far short it is. That's the normal task in a typical year. This year is quite different because the voters passed five ballot measures the day after we received the request that directly impact the budget. And you can see all of those at the bottom of page three. Amendment 87 graduated income tax You all familiar with these but that one is that really the earthquake of the five as we look toward for you all purposes how much general fund is available and we get into the details in a bit of what color that general fund is. For the committee's purposes, you've always had, for as long as I've worked here and since Ref C was passed, you've had really two flavors of general fund. You've got the general fund that everyone thinks about. That's the general fund that's subject to TABOR, and that's what you use for any purpose in state government. You've always had general fund exempt since Ref C passed, which is an account within the general fund and I think is the model for how these were constructed. That one has three dedicated uses. This committee deals with that generally once a year as we get to the long bill when we have the last available forecast of how much general fund exempt there will be, and it goes to HICPF, K-12, and higher ed. The ballot measures this year, including 87, are going to create two new accounts within the general fund. So now you're going to have four colors or four flavors of general fund. You'll have the regular general fund that's subject to TABOR. You'll have the children's account. You'll have the Colorado Futures account. And then you still have general fund exempt. So all of these things are going to be general fund for the purposes of this document as it sits right now. I think Chief Sebecki and I and the governor's office will want to talk about how we collectively move towards presenting that going forward. I frankly couldn't make that scale of changes to the presentation in the time that I had and rework everything to try and show you all the different flavors of general fund. but Amendment 87 creates a new account that's the graduated income tax Proposition NN which returning members of the JBC are particularly familiar with that one probably new account within the general fund that one is different in that it's retaining money that the state already collects so Amendment 87 is actually collecting more money for the state NN is retaining money that the state was already collecting under current law instead of it going out as TABOR refunds, it's being retained, and it creates a new cap that I'll, if you have cap questions, I'll defer those to Chief Sobecki. Those two both make more general fund available for you. Proposition 132, increased penalties for fentanyl crimes, that one's just a straight cost. There's no new revenues there, but there are implementation costs in the Department of Corrections there based on caseload estimates for that one. Similarly for Proposition 133, penalties for human trafficking of a minor, that one's a much lower estimate of cost than fentanyl, but there are costs in Department of Corrections there. And lastly, Proposition 137, the sporting goods sales tax. That is general fund that you are currently collecting, but it's attempting to estimate how much of that general fund is attributable to the sales that are addressed in the measure, and then it's taking that kind of off the top. That is money that is currently general fund subject to TABOR, and it's taking that and siphoning it into a distribution under Proposition 137. So all five of these directly impact the budget. When we get to the back in the general fund overview, I'll point out kind of which lines they're appearing in. But again, we received the governor's request on Monday, November 2nd I was at that point preparing to come in here and tell you yet again that you were dealing with a billion shortfall The September forecasts were 1 Last year, I said it felt like Groundhog Day to talk about the $1 billion. This one was going to be even larger. By the time that the election was called, 387 in particular, this became a very different conversation that we're facing today. Okay. Just to put the numbers in magnitude, Amendment 87, and I'll ask Chief Sobetsky to correct me if I'm wrong here, but we've got some apples and oranges mixing inherently because the fiscal impact statements in the blue book were published before the September forecast. So they're actually drawing on data from the June forecast to the extent that they're using forecast data. then we're taking June forecast data that fed those fiscal analyses and incorporating that into the September forecast of revenues and then we're taking the November revenue, the November request and flopping it on top of those things. So we're definitely kind of mixing across data types here and I am looking forward to the December forecast when we can all be looking at the same information and it will all be drawing from the same source. But to put it in perspective, the fiscal impact statement for Amendment 87 for the first full year of collections, which will be fiscal year 27-28, you will get a half year of benefit in 26-27. It starts in tax year 27, but obviously the first half of tax year 27 is in fiscal year 26-27. So there's a half year of revenue in the current fiscal year. But in the first full year, you're looking at more than a 9% increase over the amount of general fund that was expected, gross general fund revenue in the September forecast. So this is a hefty increase in flexibility that you're getting out of these measures. Let's see. Okay, if we go to page four, I just want to note with a little bit of gratitude, or a lot of gratitude, given the change in circumstances and the effort to try and incorporate the effect of the ballot measures into the general fund overview, I've had to rely really heavily on both OSPB and Chief Sebecki to get these numbers as close to right as we could. but it's been a rapidly moving target. And as I note at the top of page four, everything that we're talking about today is going to change to some extent. The revenue estimates are going to change in December. We'll have, I would expect, new and at least slightly different estimates of the impact of each of these ballot measures, not necessarily the ones that are straight spending, but the income tax pieces. The impact of NN, the money you retain, fluctuates directly with the estimated TABOR surplus under what this committee has always dealt with as the TABOR surplus. So December 26 revenue forecasts are going to change the landscape potentially significantly. It will be a big difference from the September forecast because they now will have the ballot measures. We're going to continue to learn. I think it's been, at least for me, a very steep learning curve trying to get my hands around the interactions of these measures. Each one of them has complexities, but when you pass, particularly the three that have directly impact revenue, they interact in ways that were not Obviously not visible in the fiscal impact statements because just like a fiscal note for your bill, those are written specific to that and they don't address interactions with the other things that are on the ballot. I continue to learn more. I think that's true of the entire staff. And as an aside, I would recommend that someone on the committee or multiple members of the committee ask legal services for an analysis. not a formal opinion, but some legal advice or legal input on the interactions of these ballot measures, because they're thinking about it, and I know they have folks there that would add a lot of value. Okay. Senator Krikmeyer and then Rep. Brown.
So you're saying we should be asking for that legal advice or legal opinion right now, that we don't have it?
Again, it's not going to be a formal opinion because that takes a lot longer, and we don't have a specific legal question to ask. But I think for my purposes right now, you saying, yes, we would like to get that advice from legal services will suffice. I'll just consider that asked for, and they're also listening. Great. Well, then I think we should consider that we're asking. Yep. That's right. Okay. Can we get it by tomorrow? Okay, Rep Brown.
That was it. That was it.
Okay, we're asking. Anybody else? Rep Taggart.
Thank you. Will that legal opinion, Director Harper, you and I have talked about this, will that legal opinion also expand to the impact in particular 87 in relationship to the Chase Enterprise?
I don't think that that is included in the discussions that I've had with them to date, but I think that may be, that's a somewhat separate question, but I think they're obviously in a position to, they will be in a position to answer that. So I think consider that requested. So are you asking, can 87 money be used to backfill the Chase Enterprise?
Is that what you're asking? Yes.
And if there, I don't know if it's a yes, but I'd like to get an answer.
if there's a yes, and if there is a yes, is there a cap to that that would, that 10% that's been, that exists that can't go above a certain percentage before it puts the enterprise in jeopardy?
Okay, yeah, I mean, that would be worth knowing for sure. Rep Brown.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I would add the health insurance affordability enterprise at the same, the other sort of major enterprise in health care to that analysis as well.
Okay. Okay. Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. So the last piece that I think we can assume will change is you always receive budget amendments every year in January Last year you received one in April which was a first in my time here and I hoping we don repeat that But you always get some in January and particularly we would have expected potentially more than usual with a change in administration to begin with, but now you have a change in administration and a dramatic change in the fiscal situation since the November request was submitted. So I think nothing in this document is even close to static at this point. This document will stay what it is, but I think the request that you all are actually deciding on by the time you're working on the long bill is probably going to look at least reasonably different from the one that's in front of you. Hopefully those changes will be targeted to some specific places because we're not in a, it would be a real challenge for us to start this whole machine up again and do it over. But regardless, I think every piece of data that's in this document is likely to be different when we're talking in January than it is now. Thanks for that. So I guess I would suggest that we spend only time on things that might make a difference for us to understand now for what's to come and not spend time on the stuff that's going to change. And it is important that we understand it today because it's not going to be like that when we're actually having to act on it. I will try to take that lens as I move through the document. Thanks. Rep. Sirota. Senator. Senator Alex Sirota.
Thank you. I'm wondering, what does that look like then for all the presentations that we're about to get up until January? Director Harper.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Again, I am desperately hoping that the vast majority of those presentations you're not going to see sweeping changes because it doesn't make sense to come in. in my, well, I've never been elected anything, so why would I, who cares what I think makes sense? We care. I do. I'm not sure that it makes a lot of sense in January to come in and rewrite the request for every agency across state government, but as you'll see when we get in farther into the document, or I'll just note it here, the September, the November request from the governor kind of held is the term that they tend to use $15 million for the new administration's priorities. So the assumption was that I'd be remiss not to point out that there is not an amount held in that request for legislative priorities for the General Assembly. But there was $15 million for the new governor. So if we still lived in the world of the September forecast and this request stuck as it is, then barring other budget amendments to cut, the new governor would have been limited to an increase of $15 million of general fund. Of course, there could be cash funds. There could be any number of other types of requests. But I think that would have really constrained the number of requests that you were likely to get unless they had things they wanted to cut to free up the money. That's not the environment that we're in right now, so I'm expecting the number of budget amendments, or at least the magnitude, is going to be higher. But I'm really hoping that the vast majority of the content that you see from the JBC staff is still going to be relevant If we tweaking every line item in the budget for example through this then that going to introduce some new and unique challenges to an already challenging timing to get the figure setting and long bill process done. Okay. Okay. but if you have items I would say that as we're going through the staff presentations if you have items that whether they're cuts or increases that are just really not of interest to the committee then feel free I don't know that it well to move us along we don't need to spend a lot of time talking about stuff that for example if it was a reduction I think the governor had given guidance for a 4% operating reduction to the agencies under OSPB. That has resulted in a very large number of small reductions, but it's a large number of those requests. How much time you all want to spend talking about those is up to you on whether. So speed us along, but the hope is that our documents will remain relevant. To the chair's request to kind of focus on the things that have changed and what is less likely to change, I do want to level set just a little bit. Page four, section called September Forecast Context, Caseload and Medicaid Costs. This committee and the General Assembly as a whole has spent the last two years with a really heavy focus on caseload, particularly in Medicaid, and trying to get Medicaid growth reined in to the point that it's not at risk of consuming the entire budget. You saw, I think, compelling visuals this morning from the governor and Director Ferrandino, both looking forward in the distant future where you have that Medicaid block kind of crowding out everything but K-12 and higher ed and even K-12 and higher ed are shrinking and the near term version which if you don't trim Medicaid even in the context of 87 and NN passing within three years we find ourselves back in that same structural deficit if we don't manage as a state to get those Medicaid the growth rate of the Medicaid costs under control. Caseload has been a heavy topic, and you can see at the bottom of page four, I've got a table that shows what the November request assumed would be the caseload demands under current law and policy. So they were projecting a $918 million increase for HICPF. That is roughly 83% of the total caseload increase statewide as caseload was identified by the governor. So out of $1.1 billion of caseload estimate, $918 million of that was for HICPF and Medicaid. You can see they've got $125 million for school finance. That one is always a number that moves around a little bit based on the amount available in the state education fund. The other one here that I wanted to hire or that I wanted to highlight is the $43 million in corrections, because that's been the other heavy caseload discussion that this committee has been having for several years. I think they're continuing to anticipate growth in caseload. This number does not yet reflect. This was in the November 2nd submittal letter It does not yet reflect the impact of 132 and 133 Yeah I just going to say it also doesn reflect or does it this new prison that already anticipated. Like 43 million isn't enough for that. We heard last year it was 150 million. so just wondering what is why is this number here instead of this much bigger number because they did ask us to open up 500 new beds I don't know this was in the request but they also in the governor's document it says they want 500 more beds Madam Chair, members of the committee I will get back to you. I'll work with Mr. Brackey to try and get some reconciliation there. I don't have it off the top of my head.
Senator Kirkmeyer. Thank you, Madam Chair. And what about with regard to the competency? I think didn't we set aside $30 million on the competency deal and for additional beds and whatnot there?
From last year's budget? Yeah, well, in the 26-27 budget. Was there anything in the 27-28 budget with regard to that? Yes, but it's not a decision item, I think. We passed an amount for both years. I don't believe that they have an increase for competency built into these caseload estimates. I'll check with Ms. Pope on that one. But you can see the increase. What they're showing for human services as a caseload increase is only 6.1. Thank you.
that people that were permanently incompetent, and I thought we only touched on the first phase of that.
So, okay, my understanding or my recollection is that we passed two years of funding last year for 26-27 and for 27-28. Oh, okay.
But we can check.
on actually on both pieces of that. It was for beds, basically. It was for beds, yeah.
Yeah, so I guess we need to know where we're at.
Yeah, thank you. Ms. Pope confirms that there's no new money in here for competency. There's annualization of legislation, but there's not a caseload increase related to competency. If we jump to page 5, let's see, trying to apply the lens of not talking about stuff that is not as relevant anymore. I'll just note again that when you heard from Mr. Sebecki in September, the LCS forecast was, well, we ended up below the reserve based on the best available information, which I assume is still moving, but we ended up below the reserve requirement in 2015. 526. My estimate for that number is about 170 million below the reserve for 2526. In 2627, Mr. Sebetsky's modeling had us at using, well, had us at 375 million low. You all, I'm sure, recall the discussion that the Medicaid Commission had with Director Farandino on the preliminary Medicaid forecast. That was what drove the shortfall in the current years. At that time, and this came up this morning in the committee's discussions with the governor, I believe that at that time, the Department of Health Care Policy and Financing was projecting a need for about a $440 million increase in Medicaid at midyear. And that was the key driver pulling us at that time under Mr. Szebetsky's estimates, $375 million below the 13% requirement for the current year. As we'll talk about in a minute, that estimate for the total supplemental cost for this year has dropped a lot. It's down to about $140 million for total supplemental increase in appropriations in the current year. That would obviously shift these calculations quite a bit. And the other piece that's important is that you do have Amendment 87 benefit in the current year for revenue, as well as a Prop NN impact in the current year. so in September what you heard from Mr. Sevetsky based on their forecasting and the obligation data from JBC staff was pushing a $400 million shortfall below 13% in the current year and then the $1.6 billion shortfall below a 15% reserve for 27-28 that was the context for the November request and we get into some detail at the bottom of page 5 on that the November request, the governor's task under statute is to offer a balanced budget proposal based on estimates of the revenue available. In practice, that means that the governor is balancing to the September forecast from the Office of State Planning and Budgeting. And state planning and OSPB had a similar $1.6 billion shortfall in September. The task of the request was to close that gap. And I've listed the main tools that they used to close it here in part because I think as I know that the committee is undoubtedly hearing from stakeholders that would like to rethink reductions that you've made in the past, particularly to Medicaid, but probably elsewhere. And we'll undoubtedly be asking both the executive branch and your branch to be thinking to rethink some of the cuts that were proposed for next year. So I figured I'd walk through the big rocks that they offered in the November request, because I think those are likely to be topics of conversation either with stakeholders or with staff. Okay, just one second. Rep Taggart has a question.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Director Harper, given the fact that the September number was indicating a caseload increase of $440-plus million, dollars, and now that has come down in two months to $147 million. I know we get an awful lot of detail, but I'd like to know where that $300 million is coming from. Because I don want to see a surprise in December in the December forecast that the 443 or the 147 has gone back to 443 or somewhere close to that I just. It doesn't seem real. Something seems. It just doesn't seem real. What's happening? Somewhere Medicaid got cut. dropped by $300 million in a two-month period. It just doesn't seem right. Right?
Yep.
Rep Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. Yeah, I think understanding how what they may present to the Medicaid Commission next week reconciles with this, what Rep Taggart and Senator Kirkmeyer, in terms of sort of the administrative actions that they have taken to sort of rein in certain aspects of Medicaid spending, I think that's maybe an interesting part of this. Otherwise, they need to sort of demonstrate to us, like, how do they think that these projections are, like, what changed between September and now?
Director Harper. Okay, thank you. So under the November 2nd request piece, the handy thing about this particular scenario and the way that Mr. Svetsky presents scenario B is that we do actually know what was driving the shortfall in the September forecast. And I have assumptions that largely our staff provided to Chief Svetsky that were driving that shortfall. And then we have a frame of reference to compare what actually came in in the request. So for the current year, as we've talked about, what was presented to the Medicaid Commission was an estimate of about $440 million, 443, for Medicaid supplementals in the current year. Their placeholder for total supplementals, and that's where this gets a little bit complicated, is maybe they have cuts in other departments. I think you all should be able to get more information when you meet us with the Medicaid Commission next week. But they're coming in almost $300 million below that estimate from 443 to 147. They have proposals in this budget to increase, to make $33 million more general fund available in the current year. There's a table that we'll show in a couple of pages, but it's two requests interacting. There's an increase of $62.6 million that's a placeholder for stuff that we don't have detail on yet. and then there's a statewide decision item for severance tax funding that's actually going to reduce general fund available by about $29 million if it's approved. And that's based on solvency concerns for severance tax. But on net, you have a decrease in obligations of almost $300 million and an increase in general fund available of about $34 million in the current year. So that's not a small, combined, those two are not a small rock because anything you do in the current year that helps the general fund balance at the end of the year puts you in a better position for next year. For 27-28, their projections in this request or their assumptions in the request represent about a $610 million reduction to fiscal year 27-28 Medicaid obligations. When they presented to you all or to the Medicaid Commission in September, they were projecting that HICPF would increase, or scenario B was projecting that HICPF general fund obligations would go up by about 860 from to above the current appropriation The request is targeting an increase of about million So they're trying to trim that back by a lot. I do note the last sentence in that second from the bottom bullet on page 5. That decrease includes $330 million in cuts that haven't been identified yet. It's just a placeholder of future information to come. So we'll see what you all get when we get to January and what information you get as the Medicaid Commission. Last bullet there. Again, the $1.6 billion shortfall was relative to a 15% reserve requirement. That's because current law puts the reserve back at 15. The November request would drop that by about $350 million by putting it at 13.05. So under the request, it would go from 13 to 13.05. Probably surprising no one on the committee. I think you can expect a recommendation from our office to get that reserved to 15 or higher in 27-28. I think this will be a subsequent discussion and may feed into the conversation with Mr. Svetsky today. but my advice to you, my recommendation is and will remain to focus on getting the reserve up because we are going to be, as a state, we are going to be exposed to more volatility than we've had in a long time. We've had what our staff has informally referred to as the shadow reserve in any year that the state was above the Tabor cap because you had a ways that revenues could fall before it actually, and Chief Sovetsky talks about this at every revenue forecast to date. Maybe that will be a different conversation now. But that has been the first. Revenue could fall. If we were above the cap, revenue could fall before you had to do anything to balance. That is out of the window now. You've got, we're riding the income tax train wherever it goes. I mean, so we're going to be facing more volatility, and when you talk to experts about managing rainy day funds and reserves, the more volatility a state has, the higher the reserve recommendation tends to be. And I think, arguably, our revenues are not necessarily going to be more volatile, but you are going to feel it more often.
Rep Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. I, in that vein, I'm interested in sort of, given the restrictions of the ballot initiatives, you know, how we can use, whether we can use any of that new money to help to plus up our reserve or whether that needs to be some sort of complicated exchange with general funds or something along those lines. But I guess I would be interested in your recommendations and maybe based on legal advice from OLS, how we can use some of these newer sources of money to get that reserve up a little bit.
Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Brown, I'm going to lean heavily on legal services for that one. The rest of these changes from scenario.
Yes, Senator Kirkmeyer. I mean I appreciate that but the Amendment 87 was pretty clear on that it could be used for three things but it also a statutory provision So, I mean, I'm sure they're going to give us legal advice based on the law that was passed. It doesn't mean it can't be changed.
Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer, absolutely. I was taking the question as sort of as they were passed, but I think there's... probably room for interpretation of different mechanics, depending on whether it's... I think you have options, but I would be very hesitant to speculate on them right now on a live microphone. The rest of these changes are all on the smaller side. The last one that I'll... I'll point to the top two on page six. Capital construction request is coming in about $190 million, lower than scenario B assumed. Again, we provide those assumptions to Chief Sovetsky's team. As standard practice, our assumptions that we provide for scenario B assume that controlled maintenance will receive 1% of current replacement value as recommended by the state architect, and that's not what happened. So they're coming in less than, it's a reduction of about $190 million, And the main driver there is that there's $89 million requested for controlled maintenance level one, whereas scenario B had assumed about $280 million for controlled maintenance. $157.6 million decrease for SNAP relative to what we had assumed for scenario B. That's because the request is proposing to use cash funds rather than general fund. That'll be an ongoing discussion, I'm sure. and the request does include a legislative proposal to refer a ballot measure to allow the state to retain excess revenues collected under Proposition MM. I don't know how many times we're going to ask the voters as a state to retain money there, but it's in the request. $50 million less for school finance than we had assumed. We had assumed as a staff about $175 million.
I'm sorry, Rep Taggart has a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Director Harper, there's a statement in here that Human Services assumes that our air rate is lower. The only thing I have heard on our air rate is that we seem to be consistently right around 10%. So what do they know that they haven't shared with us? Because I don't know how they can come up with this. unless anybody else has heard, I haven't heard any numbers much less than 10%.
Well, I think I heard 9 point something, and that's enough to drop us, and that it was heading in that direction and that the 10% was an anomaly when we went over 10 and that they expect us to be below 10 going forward. but I have the same concern about budgeting to a more ambitious number than we've had, but I guess we'll see when we get there. Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Taggart, the language that I pulled here, it's not a direct quote, but the letter was clearly assuming that the error rate was going to come in lower than it has been, and that that was going to help between that and the HSMA It was those two things were going to help alleviate the need for the general fund. It says the most recent information that we as a staff have is that DHS says between October 2025 and May 2026, the error rate was 9.4. I'm going to do my best to dramatically pick up the pace along the lines of the lens that the chair asked for so bottom of page 6, I'll just hit the high notes, this or the key point in terms of the normal role of this document the table there, table 2, shows the status of the general fund reserve relative to, under the request under both forecasts, and you can see that it's actually falling less than 100 million short under both forecasts for both years. The request really isn't trying to balance 26-27, so that would be a supplemental discussion to the extent that that conversation needs to happen. It does have changes in 26-27, but they're really targeting balancing 27-28. The key driver and the reason that it's roughly 80 million short of the OSPB, under the OSPB forecast in 27-28. The biggest driver there goes to the independent agencies, specifically judicial is the big mover in this case because it's a very large FTE department with a lot of general fund. They asked for about $44 million more in decision items than the governor had assumed in his assumptions. I do want to give a shout-out here to a bill that the committee ran last year. you ran a bill requiring all agencies included and we did the same thing for our budget to provide a base budget estimate to OSPB in September so that they could account for annualizations. If you remember our conversation at this time last year, there was a huge annualization in judicial for the judge's bill that hadn't been accounted for in the request and the bill that you all ran really helped with that. It also helped with data entry on our side for our office's self-interest, but the annualizations were reflected in the request this year, regardless of the agency. But the decision items that judicial is asking for are not really, they're not under OSPB's purview. But it was a big improvement to have the base built in so that we didn't have that kind of disconnect. The next several pages give the detail on stuff that, frankly, we've already talked about. You can see Table 3 on page 7. That shows interim supplementals that the committee approved. Those came up earlier, but you have about $6.1 million of general fund that you've approved. This was all in September. For the current year, biggest piece there is in HICPF at 4.7. Table 4, these are changes specifically to 2627. Table 4 shows the proposed changes in general fund available for 26-27. You can see about 62 or 63 million dollars as a placeholder for transfers and reversions that will make more available. And you can see statewide R1, I think I had R2 in the previous paragraph. That was a mistake on my part. Reducing general fund available by about 29 million dollars. You all ran legislation last year that reworked the flow of severance tax money and it included some transfers from the operational fund to and from local affairs fund to the general fund for budget balancing purposes They have big solvency concerns with severance tax revenues So the proposal would eliminate an million transfer from the operational fund to the general fund in the current year because their data indicates that that money is needed to balance the operational fund in the current year. And then the second piece, the last bullet on page 7, you get into some complicated mechanics with the decarbonization tax credit administration fund that under current law is transferring a slew of money to the general fund in 26-27. The proposal would reduce that transfer to the general fund by $18 million and instead transfer $10 million to DOLA for the local government severance tax fund and $8 million to natural resources for the operational fund. You'll hear about both of these in the respective briefing documents, but that's the mechanics there. changes to general fund obligations. We're back to the $147 million for supplementals. And then there's a proposal to reduce a transfer to OEDIT for advanced industries by $7.5 million in the current year. That's an ongoing request that would scale the transfer for advanced industries back to $20 million in the current year and then grow it by inflation going forward. and under OSPB's forecast, that would save about $7.5 million in the current year and roughly $5 million in 2728. Then we get into the request for 2728 operating appropriations, and this gets a little bit confusing. I'm going to go as quickly as I can, but stop me if you have questions. Paragraph right under the header there. The request proposes $18.2 billion in general fund for operating appropriations for 27-28. That's a $720 million increase above the current year. That $18.2 billion, though, includes a bunch of placeholders for offsets that are not actually reflected in the detailed data that we had that we could enter into the database, which becomes important in just a second. It includes allocations that we don't know what line item they would hit and in some cases necessarily what department the request would hit. So that piece includes the impact of placeholders that you'll see throughout the general fund overview tables, but it's not going to reconcile to the table at the bottom of page 8, which is table 5. Table 5 excludes those placeholders and statewide requests that we didn't have the necessary information to enter into the database. And those excluded proposals reduce general fund by about $333 million. The big driver here is the HICPF cut that is not yet identified. But if you look at the table at the bottom of page 8, the way it's structured, just one sentence here, the way it's structured, you can see fiscal year 26-27 appropriation, second to last row, and the first row. That is the current appropriation for 26-27. and then each department here is showing you the requested increase or decrease for 27-28. The last row on page 8, you can see the HICPF request as it shows up in the detailed request, an increase of $300 million of total funds, but that's actually about $575 million of general fund. Then you have the placeholders that reduce it. But that's the way it plays out for every department. So you can see HICPF's, as it has for years, is leading the way in general fund increase. This is organized from largest to smallest general fund increase HICPF at 576 page 9 education at 125 corrections at 111 and then judicial at 98 and then you get a larger drop to human services at 55 and then it really drops off after that. The paragraphs below the table give some context for why those are going up that much. I don't think it'll surprise the committee. I don't want to dwell on them here. It's largely caseload. You've got caseload in HICPF, caseload in education in terms of school finance. And then you get into some departments that are heavily driven by compensation common policies, and it's the ones you would expect. It's very large FTE departments like judicial and human services and corrections.
So, Director Harper, can we go back? I think Reps Arota had a question, which I have too. Thank you. I'm sorry to take us back. We were just sort of talking amongst ourselves about these questions around a reserve. And so I'm sorry if I missed that you said this or someone else asked this in a way, but we were talking about different reserves and what is the obligation of, you know, for example, you talked about multiple different flavors of general reserves. fund, but it's all general fund in terms of its tax revenue coming in, even if it's sectioned off into a different, I don't know, bucket. But my presumption would have been that those would be subject to whatever reserve amount, if it's 15% or 13%, you know, wherever we were to land, that those appropriations also would be, you'd count that in the same reserve bucket. But it came up separately that, you know, that Healthy School Meals has its own little reserve fund, that maybe there's a difference of opinion about what kind of a reserve it's supposed to be. But that aside, this was our question is. Does 87 cause us, does that, do we need a reserve of whatever percent on the money that comes in from 87?
Thank you, Madam Chair. Keep in mind that the reserve is calculated as a percentage of appropriations. So if you, and this is a discussion that Chief Sebecki and I have had, I think we apply the reserve requirement as a state to the current, the previously existing general fund exempt appropriations. It doesn't, the general fund exempt account doesn't have its own reserve, but the appropriations that come out of there are subject to the reserve. So if you appropriate a billion dollars out of the general fund exempt account, then 15% of that, if we have 15% reserve, needs to be held in the reserve. Whether you will want to get particularly complicated and have different accounts for reserves, I think, is a question. But especially given the scale of the Amendment 87 money, to not have a reserve on it sounds just remarkably risky. So I think anything you're appropriating out of there, I would recommend that you have a reserve requirement applied. If I may.
Yes, Senator Kirkmeyer. And what about with regard to the Tabor Emergency Reserve and Amendment 87 funds? Does the 3 that in Tabor for that emergency reserve you know where we put the buildings in and stuff Director Sebecki Thank you Madam Chair For the record Greg Sebecki Chief Economist with Legislative Council staff Senator Kirkmeyer the requirement in Tabor THE REQUIREMENT IN TABOR FOR AN EMERGENCY RESERVE IS 3 OF FISCAL YEAR SPENDING FISCAL YEAR SPENDING IS THE WORDS USED IN TABOR TO REFER TO WHAT I USUALLY CALL STATE REVENUE SUBJECT TO TABOR. THE 3% RESERVE REQUIREMENT WOULD NOT APPLY TO THAT SPENDING. or revenue. Because we were going to have to get some more buildings. Okay.
Director Harper. Okay. I think we've covered a lot here. There's some information here on statewide requests. If you go to page 11, we'll try and pick up the pace. There are a number of statewide requests that would result in $16.8 million of additional general fund available. This is table six at the top of the page. For general fund appropriations, you can see this is table seven. Top row there is a $15 million increase. That's the placeholder that they were holding for the governor-elect. Net reduction here of $340 million, and that's driven by the $330 million cut placeholder for HICPF and Medicaid. table 8 at the bottom of page 11 other legislative placeholders the submittal letter does include proposals for a number of specific pieces of legislation here totaling a need for 6.5 million dollars of general fund in 27 28 and here again I'll note because it this is a topic and often a question from both the JBC and its colleagues, that the request does not have a placeholder for bills prioritized by the General Assembly.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I don't think you need to answer this today, Director Harper, but in the attachment one of the governor's prepared by OSPB. What's got me concerned looking at Table 5 is the numbers are so dramatically different from the governor's proposed budget because in his, in the OSPB document, he's saying that general fund is 18.94 billion and he's using a basis of 2627 of 18.461 billion. And so he's coming up with a 2.6% increase where you're using 18.5 versus 17.461 at 6%. And so when I was going through it, it's just puzzling because the governor's is higher, but his basis for 26, 27 is much, It's almost a billion dollars higher. Don't have to answer it today, but at some point it'd be good if we are operating with the same overall numbers. And I realize in the case of the governors, he didn't put in the additional $44 million that judiciary has requested. But that would take his $18.9 almost to $19 billion. So I'm, the big thing that jumped off, one says a 2.6% increase and the other one says a 6%. Those are very different numbers. What's a billion among friends?
Director Harper. We don't have to do it today. I'll get back to you, Rep Tigard, because OSPB and I have gone back and forth enough times with my data that we're definitely on the same page, but I don't want to try and do it on the fly. No, no, don't do it on the fly. Page 12 has the other changes that you'll see pop up in the general fund overview tables below. So Table 9, changes to rebates and expenditures. They've got two pieces there. One, they're proposing to extend homestead portability. That would cost about $3 million. And then statewide R6 would repeal the business personal property tax exemption. That reduces 16.3. I'll note relative to our reserve conversation that rebates and expenditures are not subject to the reserve. Those are obligations that the reserve requirement doesn't apply to. Tabor refund slash proposition and end spending this was a big change from the last couple of years where you've received requests that were making significant enterprise proposals, the special purpose authority, etc using that mechanism to try and make more general fund available that wasn't in the request this year so you can see two that basically offset there, an update to the DUI surcharge and then a change in Division of Insurance in DORA. Changes to transfers from the general fund. You can see they're proposing, again, transfers that these are transfers from rather than to. You've got three here that offset each other, and you end up with net zero change. Lastly, statewide R11 is the proposed change to the general fund reserve in order to get it to balance under their request in the September forecast. They trimmed it back to 13.05, so that would be an increase from 13 in the current year to 13.05. Next year, again, I think you can count on a recommendation from me to either keep it at 15 and 2728 as it is under current law or consider going higher. Informational statewide requests, this was a difference from prior years, but you have two statewide requests that were submitted for informational purposes, is not really proposed as JBC bills, but for discussion. Statewide R-12 is the pinnacle conversation. You had that this morning with the governor privatizing it, but in this case, not balancing to it. You'll recall last year's request assumed that you would get several hundred million dollars, and that was built into the balancing. This year, that's not the case. They're just proposing to change it, and then they do specify what they would do with the money, but it isn't integral to balancing. Lastly
It is integral probably to the reserve Because that's what they say They want to add it to the reserve 200 million of it would go to the reserve
Director Harper They are proposing to add it to the reserve But it's not assumed in their balancing calculations For the reserve It's not in the 13.05 It would take that 13.05 And boost it Like 13 Under their math yeah And I don mean that I don mean that Which is where we at right now I don I didn I want to be clear I didn mean that pejoratively It it yeah it would take it to 13 or so somewhere in there But I think they didn and I appreciate this I didn mean their math comment pejoratively at all I appreciate that they didn They balanced the budget by reducing the reserve percentage, but they said if we could sell Pinnacle, though, then we could increase the reserve back up to approximately 14.
To something higher than 13.05. The last informational item, statewide R13, new funding for preschool and child care, proposes to refer two measures to the ballot,
but one to increase taxes on nicotine, cigarettes, and tobacco, and the other to increase gaming taxes and fully exempt gaming taxes from the TABOR limit. You'll hear about these in early childhood in the tobacco briefing shortly today and in the Department of Revenue. So the last few pages here, and I want to get to your questions because I'm already over the hour. Again, when I scheduled this, we wouldn't have been talking about anything to do with ballot mills, measures if they didn't pass. So I did not allot enough time for this presentation in the timeline that we're on. But the last several pages here are the general fund overview with the ballot measures. And the key point is really table 12 on page 13. If you take the September forecast as it was submitted with all of the assumptions in it, and I mean, there's significant assumptions in there. There's the $330 million cut to HICPF that is yet to be identified and frankly along the lines of the committee's discussion with the Medicaid Commission and with the governor this morning. It is unclear to me how reliable the estimates are for cuts to Medicaid to begin with because you took a lot of cuts. The General Assembly enacted a lot of cuts to Medicaid in the current year. How that has played out I can't speak to, but you passed the budget, it balanced based on the March forecast with a lot of cuts to Medicaid, and then by September you were told as the Medicaid Commission that they would need $440 million increase in general fund at the current year. So I feel like we're in a realm of uncertainty, particularly there because of HICPAF's over expenditure authority and the fact that it's an entitlement. So it gets a little squishy, but if you make all of the assumptions that are included in the governor's request, then, and overlay that with the new revenue estimates from September plus the ballot measures, then you would end 26-27 with about $450 million above the 13% reserve requirement in the current year, and $2.4 billion under the legislative council staff forecast, it's $2.3 to $2.4 billion above, depending on the forecast in 27-28. Note that I did use the governor's proposed 13.05 or it rounds to 13.1% reserve. So if you went to 15, then each of those numbers would drop by about $350 million in terms of the excess reserve. The rest of the tables are really the supplemental information that shows how we got there If you go through those we can talk through them But again I would suggest that we get to the questions for myself and Mr Sevetsky But in each place that a ballot measure impacted those tables, I tried to make it clear and have a separate line for the ballot measure. So Table 13, you can see Amendment 87 and Prop 137 both show up as impacting revenue. Amendment 87 pushes it up. Prop 137 pushes it down. In the obligations, you'll see Prop 132 pop up, Prop 133, and you see NN show up as the amount that's available under each forecast in each year. So you have the obligations under NN showing up in Table 14, along with the obligations for the two criminal justice measures. and that takes us to the end. You can see at the very last, line 22 on page 15 shows the amount that Prop NN is reducing the, or is retaining that would otherwise have been TABOR refund under the governor's request.
Rep Garcia. Thank you, Madam Chair. I can understand why we would see some estimated forecast for Prop 132, but I'm not entirely sure why we're even seeing a 0.2% for 133 if it's lifetime. Is this the assumption? Like, because we wouldn't see the impact to our state budget until years from now.
So why are we seeing this in next fiscal year? Director Harper. Let me double check the fiscal impact statement, but I think it showed a $200,000 impact. And this is to the millions. So each decimal point there is $100,000. I think it had a $200,000 impact in 2728, but I'll double check that.
I mean, it kind of makes, I think it also expanded the number of people or the behaviors that would land you in prison. Right.
So I think, and that would start to happen right away, presumably.
Mr. Zabetsky, Chief Zabetsky. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Representative Garcia, for the question. I actually do think that's in error in the document. Due respect to Director Harper, we had to incorporate a whole lot of information. There is an estimated $200,000 first year impact of Prop 133, but to Rep Garcia's point, that occurs when the sentences under Prop 133
are longer than they would have been under pre-Prop 133 law.
So in the fiscal impact statement, WE ESTIMATE THAT THAT FIRST OCCURS IN FY20-4142, AND THEREFORE OUTSIDE THE FORECAST PERIOD. WHICH, BY THE WAY, I SEE AT LEAST ONE CONFUSED FACE ON THE COMMITTEE. I'LL SAY THAT'S KIND OF TYPICAL FOR THESE MEASURES THAT INCREASE MANDATORY MINIMUMS, WHERE UNDER PRIOR LAW TO PROP 133, WE WOULD HAVE ASSUMED INCARCERATION AND STATE EXPENDITURES FOR THAT INDIVIDUAL BEING IN A STATE CORRECTIONAL FACILITY.
the fiscal impact from that measure arises when that person remains in a facility when they otherwise would have been released. Not to beat a dead horse but are there some additional costs because these are crimes that have the penalty of life without the possibility of parole and so they are more costly to prosecute
Chief Sebecki. Thank you, Madam Chair. That is not assumed in our fiscal impact statement, which doesn't mean that it's all of these fiscal impact statements are going to be a little bit incomplete.
Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. This was just a case of me going through and always reading year one as the budget year. Okay. So just a straight error on my part. I missed it by 15 or 16 years, something like that. Okay.
Senator Kirkmeyer. Thank you, Madam Chair. So where does the homestead exemption show up in here? Like is it under expenditures and obligations someplace? or? It's going to show up in different places depending on the year. Well, no, it's not because
it's not, it's in rebates and expenditures. So line 14 on page 15, Homestead is in that number.
In that 533 million number? Am I looking at something wrong there? Yeah, that's 2627. In the 508 number,
It will show up in there under rebates and expenditures.
Chief Zabetsky. Madam Chair, yes. Senator Kirkmeier, the rebates and expenditures are items that are included in the appropriations despite not actually being amounts for which the General Assembly can constrain spending through appropriations. So Homestead is an obligation. we are required to spend the amount that counties lose in revenue as a result of homestead that gets reimbursed to them. I know that you're familiar with that just edifying for newer members of the committee that that amount of money is always included in rebates and expenditures. And both for FY 2627, when we did not have a prior year TABOR refund obligation, even before the ballot measures, We were anticipating the requirement that we fully fund the Homestead exemption from the General Fund. You all appropriated that and balanced to that in the long bill for FY2627. Going forward for FY2728 and beyond, we are now using retained revenue under Prop NN to pay for Homestead so long as there is sufficient revenue retained under Prop NN to pay for Homestead. If there is insufficient revenue retained under Prop NN, then we pay for homestead from the general fund. That's similar to what would have happened if not for Prop NN, because we had been using TABOR refunds to pay for homestead exemption reimbursements in a TABOR surplus environment and in a non-surplus environment had been using general fund to pay for homestead. So it's not a significant change from pre-NN law.
Rep Taggart. Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you, Chief Sebesky. What's got me concerned, though, is Table 14 that you folks worked on, which calls out the elements of NN, does not call out the senior and veterans' homestead exemption. And so I don't know if that number is net of the exemption or not, but it would be good, at least for me, if we always had the senior exemption in there so that we know that that's the first. That's the first. Yeah. And then I have a second question on that.
Chief Zabetsky. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Representative Taggart. I hear what you're saying. I think we could show it that way, and we can do that that way going forward if that's going to be clearer for the committee. So that line three in Table 14 that says Prop NN spending, I think an earlier version of this document had that labeled as spending from the children's account. The way that NN works is it says, first, take the amount of money that is required to be used for homestead and use it for homestead. And then if there's any amount remaining after fully funding homestead exemption reimbursements, then put the rest in the children's account, which is effectively the amount that you see on line three here, and use it for the positive factor, line four, other education programs, line five, other programs for children, line six. I think in this version of table 14, that amount gets shown instead in the rebates and expenditures amount, as we talked about. Just to clarify for the committee what you're looking at in both forecast scenarios, under the OSPB forecast for both FY27-28 and actually FY28-29, WHICH I KNOW ISN'T SHOWN HERE, OSPB ANTICIPATES BASED ON ITS CURRENT FORECAST THAT REVENUE RETAINED UNDER NN WILL NOT BE SUFFICIENT TO FULLY FUND HOMESTEAD BECAUSE THEIR REVENUE EXPECTATIONS ARE LOWER THAN LCS'S. AND SO THEY'RE ANTICIPATING THAT HOMESTEAD EXEMPTION REIMBURSEMENTS WILL BE PAID FOR THROUGH A COMBINATION OF BOTH THE NN RETENTION AND UNDERLYING GENERAL FUND. LCS anticipates that you can fully fund Homestead out of the NN retention, and that the NN retention is not enough to fully fund the positive factor. The way that that works is NN limits the amount of the positive factor to that retention. So it's not as if you have a general fund obligation to fund the rest of the positive factor. The amount that goes out through the positive factor is capped at the NN retention amount. but it does mean that if session started tomorrow and we didn't have the December forecast and we were writing fiscal notes for legislation anything that changes revenue subject to Tabor under the LCS forecast which is what we would use for fiscal notes has a dollar for dollar change on the amount of the positive factor so we would say this bill over here that's changing a fee in DORA by two million dollars is either increasing or decreasing POSITIVE FACTOR DISTRIBUTIONS TO SCHOOL DISTRICTS BY $2 MILLION. THAT'S SOMETHING NEW THAT YOU WILL SEE IN FISCAL NOTES THIS SESSION. OKAY.
SENATOR KIRKMIR. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. SO IF WE WERE TO USE UNDER THE OTHER EDUCATION PROGRAMS THE $306 MILLION AND PUT THAT INTO CATEGORICALS, THEN THE NEXT YEAR WOULD WE HAVE TO TO INCREASE THAT AMOUNT BY INFLATION? CHIEF SABETSKY.
THANKS, MADAM CHAIR. I MAY END UP RELYING ON DIRECTOR HARPER FOR PART OF THIS QUESTION AS WELL. I BELIEVE THAT THE OTHER EDUCATION PROGRAMS AMOUNT IS AN AMOUNT IN PROP NN THAT DOESN'T HAVE THE SAME SPECIFICITY ATTACHED TO IT AS THE POSITIVE FACTOR AMOUNT. I THINK THAT IF YOU CHOSE TO PUT IT INTO CATEGORICALS, YOU WOULD NOT NECESSARILY INCLUDE A MAINTENANCE OF
EFFORT REQUIREMENT THAT WOULDN DERIVE FROM AMENDMENT 23 BECAUSE AMENDMENT 23 DOESN LOOK AT CATEGORICALS when it determining its inflationary adjustments nor does Prop NN create its own maintenance of effort requirement over time
really for anything because, again, all of its spending is just a function of the amount retained. So I think the answer to your question is no, but looking for Director Harper for a second opinion, perhaps. Director Harper.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer, now it's my chance to disagree with Chief Sobetsky. Usually it's my mistakes. But I think state money that goes into categoricals carries an inflationary requirement under Amendment 23, and I don't think it matters what source it comes from. So when the General Assembly has elected to increase, often for special education, special education funding higher than would be required under Amendment 23, that's base building. And I strongly, we can, I mean, this could be a, I suppose that there could be legal questions here. but my read of Amendment 23 is that the state money that goes into the categoricals is base building for the subsequent inflationary increases. So yes.
Regardless of where it comes from. That's always been my interpretation, but we're adding more fund sources that this. Amendment 23 clearly wasn't contemplating the children's account of the general fund because it didn't exist. So, I mean, I suppose there could be questions. It's still general fund, though. Yep. Chief Sebecki. General fund in the categoricals is base building for Amendment 23 purposes. Chief Sebecki has. I just want to echo that in addition to Director Harper correcting me, so did my own school finance team. So they are on the same page with him. Glad we got that straight. They beat me to it. Okay. Rep Taggart.
Thank you, Madam Chair. what concerns me for our budgeting purposes for 27-28 are these two numbers on both other education programs and then going down to other programs for children because those amount to over $700 million. And if $700 million goes per NN out for those programs for 26-27 and then we as a budget committee say zero for this upcoming budget season, we're going to have people screaming at us. I mean, just literally screaming at us. Director Harper, that'll be fun.
Director Harper.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Taggart, I think you're alluding to two concerns or two risks that I think are in place with the way that NN could play out. And for part of this, I'm going to defer to Chief Sebecki on the timing. But there's two components here. One is back to my kind of volatility discussion. The NN spending is going to be volatile, the amount of money that's available under that measure. if you look at we swing between it's been tempered some with the tax credits in place but over the course of several years we can swing between a billion dollars of TABOR refund and zero and so I think there's some real risk depending on the programs that those are going into that you have a volatile source that user the recipients are likely to use the money for ongoing purposes and that always risky Like this is if the NN money goes away and they it gone into an ongoing purpose then you going to have to backfill that with general fund from another source So there so there real risk there The other one that I want to point to is the 2627 piece, as I've thought through this in the, in greater detail in the last seven days. The committee heard from Mr. Sabetzky in September that the Tabor refund amount really couldn't be reconciled for 25-26. We were below the cap, but we really couldn't verify, and the Office of the State Auditor wasn't able to reconcile and confirm the numbers, the TABOR surplus amount, the final amount for the year, is not known in the fiscal year. It's not known at the end of the fiscal year. This year, we still don't know the final disposition of the TABOR number, but it's always September at the earliest. And so I will express my concern if you all were to fully appropriate the NN amounts that are shown here up to the, and I appreciate the catch. I think Chief Sabetsky and I can figure out a way to manage the homestead piece and make it clearer in the documents. But if you all were to appropriate the $107 million for the positive factor and $306 million for other education programs and $413 million in the current year for other programs for children, based on, for example, and you'll have more up-to-date data before you would make these decisions, but let's say you decided to appropriate that $800 million based on the September LCS forecast as a supplemental for the current year. It does worry me that we could find out in September of 2027 that that number was imaginary, and the money would have gone out the door in the current year, and we wouldn't know until potentially halfway through the next fiscal year that the money wasn't real. So I think there's real risk with how this could play out. But if there's further questions on timing, I would defer to the chief.
Okay, Rep Brown.
Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you, Director Harper, for that. And I guess maybe this is less of a question, more of a comment. It seems like there are some significant risks that you have outlined for us, some significant uncertainty about what the amount of money will be available related to Prop NN in particular. And so, you know, I think I would encourage us to think about ways that we can implement Prop NN in a way that is in keeping with what the voters passed, but also is safe so that we don't end up spending money that we don't have.
Senator Kirkmeyer.
So a couple of things. So the first thing is, would it be good to get the state controller in here? Because I'd like to know what the heck they're doing and why they can't get it figured out. I mean, and confidence is one thing, but now we are a couple more months along. And, you know, we need to know. Everybody needs to know. Do they anticipate they going to be able to give us a number by the December forecast or are we just going to have to wait until next year That my first question Do we have any idea at all Chief Zubetsky So I OR ARE WE JUST GOING TO HAVE TO WAIT UNTIL NEXT YEAR THAT MY FIRST QUESTION DO WE HAVE ANY IDEA AT ALL CHIEF ZYBETSKY SO TO GO BACK THROUGH THE CALENDAR
BECAUSE I THINK IT'S HELPFUL TO CONSIDER THIS IN THE CONTEXT OF THIS QUESTION, WHICH I AGREE WITH THE SENTIMENT OF, WE HAD THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED ON JUNE 30TH. UNDER LAW, UNDER STATE LAW, THE CONTROLLER IS REQUIRED TO REPORT BY SEPTEMBER 1ST on the amount by which revenue exceeded or fell short of the referendum CCAP for FY 2526. They issued that report. The auditor is supposed to complete an audit of that report by September 15th. That audit essentially said it cannot conclude that the books were correct. And in fact, there was a major issue that the auditor identified and the controller had to issue a revised certification for on September 8th that changed the certified amount by $72.8 million, so a large amount of money. At this point, that auditing process is complete. The auditor reported on their findings to the legislative audit committee. There is no downstream action to be taken until the annual comprehensive financial report is released. That usually happens in December or January. It usually does not happen before the December forecast. FOR THE PURPOSES OF MY TEAM'S WORK IN PREPARING THE DECEMBER FORECAST, I'M VERY CONFIDENT THAT REVENUE DID IN FACT FALL SHORT OF THE REF RENOM C-CAP IN FY2526. THE PRECISE AMOUNT BY WHICH IT FELL SHORT OF THE REF C-CAP ENDS UP BEING FAIRLY IMMATERIAL FOR OUR CURRENT FORECASTING PROCESS. But I think Director Harper is right to emphasize that in future years, this kind of a delay will make it even more difficult for you all to make any sort of true ups to the amount that was appropriated for the positive factor and other elements of Prop NN. Because one, you won't know the amount that is actually being retained under Prop NN during the fiscal year for which NN requires spending. and two, the process in place doesn't deliver that number to the state until September after the fiscal year has ended and three, the process in place currently isn't being kept up with in a way that actually guarantees that that amount even is delivered in September. So there's, I think, a procedural question for the legislature in implementing this requirement as to whether it makes sense for those appropriation amounts for the fiscal year in which the retention occurs to exactly equal the amount retained in that year, or if there's some kind of a post hoc true-up process to make sure that the will of the voters is met and the money does in fact make its way to schools. And that would require some legislative changes to do the post-true-up kind of thing that we're talking about here? Chief Sebesky.
Thank you, Madam Chair. My understanding of Prop NN is that it says here is the amount that is put in the children's account. It's equal to the amount that was over the RFC cap, less the amount that went out to Homestead. And then the requirements for spending from the children's account are a function of what it calculates the positive factor requirement to be. And then depending on how much is left over after the positive factor, potentially some more amounts that need to go through K-12 and otherwise programs that support children to succeed in schools.
I SHOULD PROBABLY REVIEW THE TEXT OF THE MEASURE ONE MORE TIME, AND DIRECTOR HARPER SHOULD CORRECT ME IF HE THINKS DIFFERENTLY, BUT I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY ALLOWANCE FOR THE FACT THAT THE NUMBER IS NOT KNOWN AT THE TIME WHEN THE APPROPRIATIONS ARE SUPPOSED TO BE MADE AND DISTRIBUTED, BECAUSE WE WON'T
know the actual amount of the retention until after the end of the fiscal year. And so I think that that's a very difficult legal requirement for you all as budget writers to comply with. If you wanted to change the process, then that I think would require a statutory correction.
Well, maybe we should get some legal advice with regard to that as well.
Totally.
Hopefully, well, maybe they all need to understand that it's going to be reimbursed after the fact. I don't know. But we can't appropriate funds that we don't know how many funds we have to appropriate.
Chief Sebecki. I'm nodding enthusiastically, Madam Chair.
Okay.
And so my other question, though, is this.
Director Harper had a comment.
Oh, no. Please. No.
Were you going to comment on that?
Because I have a little bit different question.
Madam Chair, Senator Kirkmeyer, just as an aside, what I was confirming with Chief Sobetsky is if you look far enough back, the state paid TABOR refunds in the year that the revenue was collected, and there was probably a reason that you changed it.
Yeah. It was the same dynamic in that you don't know how much you have. Way after the fact.
In this case, I mean, if in terms of a true up, that works if it's along the lines of what we as a state and you all as the committee currently do with the general fund exempt, where you make this sort of, in the case of general fund exempt in the three departments that receive it, you all receive a supplemental recommendation from me every year and it gets attached to the long bill to swap money back and forth between those two columns. As long as there's general fund available to support that, it works. But again, this is a volatile enough potential revenue source that I think, one, it's not hard for me to picture a scenario where whatever forecast you all make the appropriation on for the current year. So let's say based on March, you appropriate this money. You appropriate the $826 million reflected in Table 14 in the current year. We get through the end of the year, and there's been maybe there was a pandemic. I mean, any number of things that cause a big drop in the revenue, the money has gone out the door, and it's not entirely clear to me that there's going to be revenue available to swap back and forth and true up the next year. So I think there's real risk here, both from Representative Taggart's initial question, which I took to mean, okay, so right now there's 800 million, next year there's 200. People put that into ongoing uses, again, assuming these numbers are accurate which their forecasts of course they're not going to be precisely accurate i think there's real risk of stakeholders not necessarily putting that into one-time uses because it's it's going to be a significant flow of money especially as the positive factor grows in k-12 i mean it's called nn calls out uses that are not It's not one time in nature. It's not capital construction. It's not uses that are going to, you can really turn it on and turn it off if you're the school district. Once you increase teacher pay and reduce class size, whiplashing in and out of that is going to be a challenge And so the volatility exposure I think is a concern here It possible that Amendment 87 helps enough with the overall revenue situation that some of that's mitigated, but again, the planning for that volatility is going to be, I would say, incredibly important for this committee and the General Assembly as a whole.
Senator Kirkmeyer.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So my other question is this. But we could take, like, for example, either the 306 or even the 413 for other children's programs, and, for example, we were using other education programs, $306 million. We could actually refinance some of those grant programs that are funded out of the SEF that are not subject to inflation, and we could then shore up, to some degree, the state education fund, because we know that in the next few years we have some issues there, correct? because those grant programs that we do out of there are not subject to inflation, of the inflation requirement in Amendment 23.
Director Harper.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer, I think you might bump into some supplement-not-supplant challenge.
Some what?
The supplement-not-supplant requirement, if you replace the existing funding.
I thought the supplement was based on the total program,
the parts of the education funding that requires the Amendment 23 inflationary increase.
My mind was in Amendment 87 space.
I'm back on NN. 87 is a different situation. We just need to make sure everybody understands there's not a whole bunch of money for everybody to go spend on a bunch of ongoing projects anywhere. I'm talking about NN. If we were to use those funds to refinance things in education that are not subject to the inflationary mandate in Amendment 23, we could do that. And that would free up some funding in the state education fund that maybe we could start building that fund back up instead of having to worry that it's not going to have enough money in it in the next couple of years.
That's just a question I have.
Director Harper.
I think we could. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Senator Kirkmeyer, I think you're probably on to an option there.
Okay.
Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. We're already a half hour over my estimated time. I do think you have some wiggle room in this afternoon's activities, but Chief Sabetsky and I are here for you all's questions, So if I don't have anything else that I was planning to present.
Okay. Other questions?
Senator Kirkmeyer. Thank you. So is there any other legal advice we need to be trying to get from our, attempting to get from OLLS that either one of you can think of? Did we cover it fairly well?
Chief Zabetsky.
This may already be incorporated in the request that you made of OLS at the beginning of this part of the meeting. I think getting an opinion on whether Amendment 87 revenue can be reserved or must all be spent in the year when it is collected seems pretty important to me. That would be great.
Okay.
Did you hear that, OLS?
I'm sure Executive Director.
Okay. I think, thank you very much. Appreciate your time and all the work you put in to figure this out and we will stay flexible as new information becomes available
Thanks.
Okay, Mr. Rickman's up. Woo-hoo. Aren't we having? See how much fun this is? It's so much fun. I said yesterday we'd be having fun today. Okay. Mr. Rickman, take it away.
Sam Rickman, JBC staff, here to talk to you all about hearings and common questions. This hopefully shouldn't take too long, but just as a refresher, for hearings, the whole staff will come up and give their briefing presentations about every agency. you all will ask the staff a bunch of questions. The staff might not know the answers to those questions or the department might be able to speak to them better. And so then we'll say, okay, we'll add that to the hearing agenda. Then we as the staff go back to our desks and we send out an agenda to the departments where they will prepare responses to the questions for their hearing, which is usually about a week or two after the briefing. The general purpose of the hearing is for you all to be able to ask the questions you want of the department, but it's also for the departments to be able to speak to their budget requests. But ultimately you all decide what the purpose of the hearing is. So if you want us to rethink it, that's totally fine. And I'm happy to do that, but that's what we have for now.
Okay, so I mean, I do think that's worth us talking about because if they're gonna spend a lot of time on a budget request that isn't actually gonna materialize and I don't know how we'll know what that is. I think it's safe to say the one coming from the treasurer's office isn't going to materialize. I mean, I'm just wondering if the treasurer-elect went to the current treasurer and said, hey, go ask for some more FTE for me so I don't have to because Kirkmeyer will beat me up over it. No comment. I hope he's listening. I mean, I think the first hearings, maybe some of those, like, just because we now find ourselves in a different budget situation doesn't mean we shouldn't still be cutting things that aren't important or aren't doing what they're supposed to do. So maybe we just carry on in the way that we have. But I just feel like the request is going to look pretty different by the time we finalize it.
Rep Taggart. Thank you, Madam Chair. I would just make one comment on your example of the question from last year. I agree with you that that question is no longer appropriate. but there is a question that is appropriate, and that is tell us you have followed this direction and report on the fact that you followed this direction because I'm getting indication that there are departments that completely ignored this. And so I want to know that they followed it.
Mr. Rickman. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just to clarify what do you mean you intend for them to follow exactly Because the way I read it the question is providing information about how much they spend on local media versus national media If I recall correctly, the conversation was last year.
What are you hoping to get from the department? Yeah. Oh, I'm sorry. It was the footnote.
The footnote, no, that was a part that supported this.
The footnote indicated that their advertising needed to be spent locally. I don't know if it was 100%. I can't remember. But it...
I don't think it was that specific.
I think it was significant. I don't know what the wording of that footnote was, but I just want to make sure that they're doing it.
So I would appreciate a common question that takes the footnote into account. MR. RICKMAN. SO THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. SO WHAT YOU'RE SAYING IS DEPARTMENTS ARE REQUIRED TO BE SPENDING 100% OF THEIR
I DON'T THINK IT SAYS 100%. I THINK YOU'VE GOT TO LOOK AT THE FOOTNOTE BEFORE YOU CAN CRAFT THE QUESTION.
BUT A FOLLOW-UP, ANSWERING YOUR QUESTION, HAVE YOU FOLLOWED THIS FOOTNOTE? IF SO, TELL US ABOUT IT.
Okay, so the way I understand it, I'll go back and look at the footnote and then maybe come back at some point in the near future and just clarify and make sure that we're asking the department what you want them to respond to. It might not look exactly like this. It'll probably be smaller, but is that?
Okay, let's see.
Rep. Sirona. I'm fairly sure it was Mr. Dermody that helped draft the footnote for Mr. Rickman's purposes of, okay, or Director Harper can find the exact language, but I think Mr. Dermody helped craft that, so, or put it in there.
And then Rep. Brown had a question.
Sorry, so just so I understand, I think what we're moving towards is that we would replace this common question with something like what Rep Taggart was saying, which is how are you basically complying with the language of the footnote? Is that everyone's understanding?
Okay, great. Okay.
Yes, Senator Kuchmeier. Just for discussion purposes, the comment about how things are going to change pretty dramatically probably with, one, the new administration, but even after we see the December forecast and we start getting some answers back on 87 and NN and 132 and 133 and 137, I'm wondering if maybe we don't want to change around the schedule a little bit. There are some things like the capital, you know, the CDC stuff, that maybe we could get that information ahead. I mean, because it's not only the value of time for the staff, but even the value of time here. I mean, if we're going to listen to a briefing that we're just going to have to have a new briefing because things have changed so much. I don't know. I'm just asking. So maybe like we hear about capital or maybe we go through all that marijuana stuff, you know, dollar amounts and stuff because that's not really going to change and how we're going to, you know, are there things there we want to make changes to? You know, that stuff that takes us 10 hours.
Well, actually, I think we spent like three days on marijuana. Sorry.
You know, dollar amounts and where they go and how much there isn't going to be kind of thing. And I mean, maybe we try and knock some of those things out instead of going back and forth and just going to have to have more briefings and hearings.
Director Harper. I don't know. It's just a thought. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Like higher education, the formula there and stuff, that's changing around. Maybe those types of things we could hear that aren't being impacted by 87NN and the others.
Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer, fortunately in this vein, you have the marijuana presentation today. It's up right after this one, so that one is addressed. I think my recommendation to the committee is that we can look at some changes to the calendar, but the way that the calendar really forces us to work is briefings and hearings now, figure setting. So there's generally not hearings after you receive the budget amendments. There's comebacks based on the decisions that you make. But we really can't, I can't picture a world where we could put the briefings for, A, we don't know which departments are going to change. So I don't know which ones we would hold. The biggest departments that you tend to worry about, DHS is different. It's sort of spread over a longer period because of the magnitude and the number of presentations there. But if you think about HICPF, corrections, higher ed, they all come late anyway because of the workload required on the staff side and to kind of get the documents of that magnitude done. If we waited until we knew how things were going to change, I don't think there's any way that we could do a briefing and hearing process because particularly with the transition administration, I know in one prior transition the budget amendments came in at the very end of January and we really can't start up the briefing cycle after that I think the only option that we have that would make it possible for you all to kind of get through this process assuming that we're not going to have briefings and figure settings as the exact same presentation is briefings now now if you want to de-emphasize the amount of time that we spend talking about departments, I think that's absolutely an option, and you all can control that. We could also look at scaling back and trimming down the calendar, but I think we're... I really don't see a way that we could do briefings and hearings after we find out the changes because we won't know how anything's going to change until January. I would be... Based on this morning, it sounds like probably the current governor is absolutely planning on budget amendments on January 2nd, and then the governor-elect will submit some at some later point in the year. But our timing is always tight to get the long bill done as we do it now. So scaling back presentations now might make sense if you think that's not time well spent. But I don't see a way we can do briefings after that.
Rep. Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. Director Harper, regarding the Governor-elect and his budget amendments, I have assumed that those would come sort of at the end of January or something along those lines. Do we set that date? Do they set that date? Is it some sort of negotiation between us? When will we know sort of when his changes will be with us?
Thank you Madam Chair Representative Brown we we in it interesting because I been talking with staff from the current administration and none of us have any authority to set that So I think you all would be in a position to discuss with the governor team I can tell you what statute says, which is supplementals come in on the 2nd, with some exceptions that you all are aware of. DOC comes in on the 8th or 9th. HICPF comes in later. K-12 school finance comes in January 15th. Budget amendments, the way that the statute reads is budget amendments also come in on the 15th, unless there's information that was not reasonably foreseeable before then. And looking back at the last couple of transitions, Governor Polis actually got his budget amendments in on the 15th, from what Director Ferrandino and I were able to track down, as did, at that point, new Attorney General Weiser. Governor Hickenlooper, when he came in, I think the request came on the 30th. So I think the interpretation during time of transition has been the new governor's thoughts on priorities as information that wasn't reasonably foreseeable because it also specifically says that the agencies are requesting it based on information that wasn't reasonably foreseeable. If you read that statute as the agency making the request, then they don't have access to the governor's – the governor is not actually driving that until he's sworn in.
Rep. Garcia. Thank you, Madam Chair. Can you just reference what the statute is?
Director Harper. Give me just a minute. I'll let Mr. Rickman take the stage here, and I'll find it. Okay, I mean, I'll just say, I had suggested yesterday, somewhat inartfully, like I'm looking ahead at these write-ups for what we're supposed to be looking at today, marijuana, which is complicated and big, and then tobacco. And I was suggesting that maybe we ask the staff or help the staff to skinny up what they're working on because a lot of it is not going to be important for our conversation right now since we don't really know where we're going to be when we start actually doing figure setting. I don't know how that lands for them or what it is I'm even asking, but it just seems like we're going to spend an inordinate amount of time talking about stuff that isn't going to matter.
Or it's going to change. Yeah. Or it's going to change. Rep. Sirota. I don't particularly disagree with that, except that I guess to, I think I said this earlier, or maybe you did, that there are going to be things that we probably should keep cutting. And even if our financial outlook has changed, maybe we should do those things anyway. So to be sure there will be, but there will be things that we would disagree with that Governor Polis put forward, whether he were staying or going, that, you know, they would tell us about, and then we would say, well, we're not going to do that. I don't. Yeah, but like the marijuana thing is so, you know, integrated with all these other things, and maybe other programs that are funded through the marijuana cash tax fund we don want to cut but we would ordinarily but maybe this year we won want to That's all. I don't know exactly how we fix it. Maybe we just forge ahead and see how it goes. And then if we say, well, okay, this isn't going to be relevant, then Rep Taggart. Thank you, Madam Chair. and Mr. Reckman, we're taking away from your conversation. I'd like to pick up on the skinning up of the documents. Folks, I've said this before, but I run out of hours in the day to read the size of these documents that we're getting, and this has been a problem. and my whole time on the GBC, I find, because I can't read after we leave here at night. I know some folks do, but I can't. My eyes are tired. So I find myself getting up at 3 o'clock in the morning to read, and I need every day at least three to four hours of solid reading. And I don't want to slight the work Director Harper, the church team, does, But, you know, I'm in a situation today that I didn't get through the tobacco. And that always makes me anxious when I haven't gotten through all the reading. And the marijuana alone was a 40-page, it was a 40-plus page document. And I respect what you're saying, Senator Amabile, but I would say I would like to find a way. to get these thinner because it is just so hard to get. There's only 24 hours in the day, and I only sleep five hours, and I still have a hard time getting through everything. Rep. Garcia. Thank you, Madam Chair. This is more of a question around, like, the authority of this committee because I'm thinking if it's possible for us, not necessarily in this transition period because we're already in the middle of it, but is there some way that what we can do is have a JBC bill that would grant any future transition, any new governor-elect the authority of drafting a budget before they're sworn in? because I mean I think about like Senator-elect Sirota here is able to sit here before she's sworn in and so is there a way that we could for future is there a way that we could actually create a space where we're not in this position and we're giving more authority to the governor-elect to start the process sooner?
That sounds like a great idea, but I, we might be eight, might be eight years from now that we.
Yeah, I understand. I'm saying it just, you know, if we're, we're complaining about a problem right now, and I tend to solutionize.
Okay, fair.
Senator Kirkmeyer. I would say that it's probably not allowed because there's a sitting governor who has the authority over the executive branch. So I mean if they a governor and they already been elected you know like so when Governor Polis was going into his second term sure they get to do all that There is no transition But during a transition the governor does not have any authority over the executive branch So I don know how he would propose a budget Who is he going to direct to do that Well, I guess that's what I'm saying. Is that something we could figure out how to change? But who would he direct to do that? He doesn't have direct authority over them. For example, in this case, governor-elect Weiser does not have any authority over any of the staff in the executive branch. So he can't direct them to. I mean, we can't supersede the current governor's authority. And I'm not necessarily saying that it's the governor, current governor is not allowed to do and create his own budget. I'm just wondering, is there some other way, or if we, like, move session. Transition year session starts in February.
Yeah, you can't do that either.
That's constitutional, I think.
Okay.
Yeah.
Yeah, I think this is a good conversation for us to have, but maybe not right.
Well, we can keep having it.
No, we don't have to.
No, it's fine.
Okay, we could get...
It's not urgent.
Okay, yeah. So we could ask for some legal advice on that. Sometime in the next eight years. But I kind of like to go back to Rep Taggart's question, because this is the same thing we talked about yesterday. is there a way to save staff some energy and time, and then also for us to have less information or have it be more condensed into bullet points or something. I don't know. I don't want to put more work. I would like for it to be less work. So that's just something for us to think about, and I don't think we're going to decide that today either. So are there more questions for do you have more stuff to add Mr. Rickman?
Madam Chair I'll just say that I think this what you guys the the problems you talk you're talking about now are problems we've all been thinking about and wondering about as staff like I've gone through the mental gymnastics of how much do I focus on this request how many questions do I ask of the department related to this request and anticipating that it's probably going to change So I think the whole staff is listening, hopefully, and I hope they're thinking about what we're saying and maybe we can have more internal meetings about how to change the documents so that they're not focusing on aspects that are likely to change. But yeah.
OK. All right. Thank you. And we have Mr. Catlin is waiting in the wings, so to speak. Thank you, Mr. Rickman.
Hello.
We're back. Don't look so happy.
Mr. Catlett. Thank you, Madam Chair. John Catlett, JBC staff here with a policy review of marijuana tax policy. Welcome back, everyone. Congratulations, Senator Sirota. Welcome to the committee, Representative Garcia. Representative Taggart heard. So just for some context on the marijuana document, I acknowledge it is quite substantial and allow out of it is historical information that has always been included in there. And so I have I've followed suit, but you are heard and I will definitely look at trimming this down, especially the background information, which I will not talk about today, because I think the relevant conversation is where we are and where are we going in the future. So I know you guys have had a long day, so I will get to it again. I'm going to move past the early part of this document and go straight to page four. And on page four, you have a chart that kind of tells a story, and I think few graphics tell a story quite this vivid. Essentially, you have an entire product lifecycle playing out over the last 11 years. So the industry was introduced in 14-15. You have very rapid growth until 2021, and then seemingly overnight, it matures and immediately goes into decline. And for the last five years, we've seen a decline in overall marijuana tax revenue by about 50%, 48.1%. That has implications for everything that is funded by a marijuana tax cash fund. As you know, we've spent the last few years discussing ways to balance the MTCF. I will point out a couple things on this table. You will notice excise tax have fallen even more dramatically than the overall fund. So excise tax reached a peak in 2021 of about $121 million, and they've fallen by almost 65% to $39 million. And so all of that funding goes to the BEST program, and this is notably the lowest this fund balance has been, or actually the revenue has been since the introduction of marijuana. Fiscal year 2014-2015 was the last time revenues approached these levels. I have a question. Is NN money and 87 money, can they go to best? Yes. I'm seeing nods. Thanks. Rep Garcia. Thanks. 87 could if that's a direction that is chosen. NN is a little bit more prescriptive on teacher pay and a couple other things. And so I'm not sure. Only portions of it. There's some parts of NN that could potentially go to Western. I would think building schools is a children's type program. So the children's fund? I don't know. Okay. Just throwing it out there in case. We've paid for best out of SEF, too. Yeah. Okay. Sorry. Thank you, Madam Chair. Moving ahead to page five, very briefly I'll highlight where this tax revenue goes once it's received. So the 2.9% sales tax is applied to medical marijuana and also to retail purchases at dispensaries. And both of those revenue streams go 100% to the marijuana tax cash fund. And then moving to the far right, as we just discussed, the 15% excise tax, which is the maximum allowed by law, that goes to the best program. And then the retail marijuana special sales tax, that's changed over the last two sessions. Two years ago, that was reduced by about 6.5%. And then last year it was eliminated. So currently 100% of that funding goes through the general fund is passed through. And then you can see under House Bill 1409 last year balancing bill the proportions about 73 go to the marijuana tax cash fund 11 to the state public school fund 14 is retaining the general fund and then two years ago to address the challenges of the MED, 1.5% is directed to the marijuana cash fund. Moving ahead, I'll just note the graph at the bottom of the page six. This kind of illustrates the challenges facing the industry. You have an average market rate, which is how most excise tax is calculated, and it's based on the average transaction within a product category listed above, the largest being retail, BUD. But that has fallen from $1876 to $601. So you have a dramatic fall in the average market rate, which has passed through and reflected in the pronounced dropped in the excise tax. I'm going to go ahead and move ahead to the marijuana revenue outlook and talk about what we see in the two forecasts. And I'll pause there. Are there any questions about what we quickly covered so far? Okay. So the marijuana revenue outlook, we're seeing a pretty pronounced shift in our revenue expectations. When you look at this graph, what you see is a prolonged decline followed by some level of stabilization with really no indication of a meaningful recovery. And when we looked at this graph in years past, what you saw was, particularly by one forecast, a very V-shaped recovery where we had reached bottom and then often double-digit growth rates. both forecasts now have begun to converge which is actually in terms of balancing in March purposes anyway that will make the job of balancing a little bit easier and that there aren't significant discrepancies between the two forecasts that the committee has to reconcile. It is notable that you can see that the blue dots obviously represent actuals and then the gray the gray circles represent the March OSPB forecast, and that was the forecast selected for balancing. And what you see is a significant 10% revision over the last six months in revenue expectations. So it was revised downward by about $20 million, and in the out year it was revised downward by 11.5%. But essentially what you have is a shift in what we've seen in recent years, and now the OSPB forecast is more conservative in its outlook than what we're seeing from LCS. So a pronounced shift in expectations moving forward. Additionally, you have a convergence of the two forecasts that we just talked about. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Kandler, what's happening in the forecast? What are they seeing that this has bottomed and will stay relatively flat and then start to increase? Because that curve has continued to come down, what are they seeing that causes them to believe it's going to start to go in the other direction? Mr. Catlin. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Taggart, that's a fair question. I have not consulted with the forecasters this year. I have done so in years past and for various reasons I did not reach out this year But what in years past they saw was a significant growth as you see This year it bottomed But if you would like I can reach out to the two agencies and inquire about what they seeing, because it is particularly on the OSPB side of market shift, as we talked about in future expectations. Um, I'm sure the only reason I ask and it's not aimed at you whatsoever is they've been off significantly every year that I've sat on this committee and my, my concern is I want to believe their forecasts now. Um, and I don't know if I can. Mr. Catlin. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Taggart, fair point. I will reach out to both forecast agencies and get some direction on that. And I am in alignment with your view. I can read a trend line, and right now that trend line shows no sign of any turn. You know, I think it's generally good to have an optimistic perspective in life, but I'm not sure when forecasting. I'm not sure that's the best approach. We're the election year. That's all we got to say. Are they smoking marijuana over there in that department? Sorry. You don't have to answer that. Thank you, Madam Chair. Please don't. So if there are no other questions on the graph, I'll go ahead and turn over to page 10. This is a very granular level of revenue growth projections. For our purposes today, we don't need to talk through either of those, just big picture. As we've talked about, there has been a reversal in the outlook. Again, LCS, the more conservative forecast, OSPB, and the compound annual growth rate they're seeing is actually, I mean, they're both relatively flat. OSPB is projecting a 1.3% decline over the next two years, and LCS is relatively flat. they're seeing 10 basis points of growth. So adjusted for inflation, they're both negative. Moving ahead, I think the tables on page 11 are a little bit more relevant to our discussion. These are the revenue distributions. So you have a breakout of where marijuana revenue is allocated, and the first and largest source is to the marijuana tax cash fund. And you can see under LCS projections, revenue growing from about $127.7 million to $135.1 million. So they're projecting growth of about 3% there. And I think it's important to note that overall growth is projected to be basically flat. The growth in the MTCF is entirely due to statutory changes enacted over the past two years and the change in how the special sales tax is allocated entirely to the state. And that also follows suit when you look at the OSPB forecast. Again, the more conservative forecast, they are showing growth in MTCF at 70 basis points. Again, more than the overall growth projection, our decline of about 1.3%. And then for balancing purposes, this table has been very relevant at the bottom. Still quite relevant, but less so than years past. So on table six at the bottom, you can see the variance between the two forecasts. 25, 26, those are preliminary actuals. If you look at the forecast you can see in the last row LCS exceeds OSPB by about million And in the budget year that we going to be looking at the difference is about million Also really relevant to any excess balance above the 15% statutory reserve is that legislation passed last year that will be swept over to the state public school fund. So any remaining balance won't carry over to the next year. That being said, we haven't had a balance in excess of the reserve in some years. So it will be interesting to see how this year trends. Okay. Senator Sirota. I'm going to go for it. You can call me whatever you like. So I'm sure I'm getting ahead of myself here, But I just want to say that from the outset that this is something that I want us to look at and focus on when we get to the Department of Revenue. But the funding is from here. When you look at clearly both of these forecasts are looking at the marijuana cash fund being challenged here as well as the MTCF. MTCF, we always have issues there. And because I think in some years we have allocated funding from, and maybe I can't remember if it's ongoing or if we've just done it on an incidental basis, money from the MTCF, going to support what's happening with MED. there have been articles that we have, I think, all been reading during the interim about product on the market that is flagged to be unsafe. People are developing health problems, and that product is staying on the shelves, and nothing is seemingly happening. and my understanding is because MED doesn't have the infrastructure necessary to do the testing and support for safety for this industry that seems necessary and that I understand other states to have. And I think that is a really significant problem and one that I hope we and the next administration can work to rectify as we look at how we allocate these funds to ensure that there's actually, you know, safety and enforcement capacity at the department that is supposed to be regulating this industry. Rep Taggart. Can I follow up on that? Because I've had a couple of conversations with the Department about this and the division. They are using very old technology for tracking the plants. and there is far superior technology that's out there right now that we've introduced to them that they refuse to look at, which just floors me. I agree with you. We need to get MED to do what they're supposed to do, which is to enforce the rules and make sure that they're ensuring the public safety. I would say I'm not sure it's so much of a funding problem as it is a culture problem. And well, the culture and the technology are related. And I think there's been more of an emphasis on growing the industry than there has been on protecting the public from the industry. I would like to see that shift. So, Mr. Catlett. Thank you, Madam Chair. A couple of things I'll note. I have not heard that about the technology at MED. In fact, they received $2.9 million for an IT seed to sale in fiscal year 25-26. So I will reach out to the department to get additional information on that. But there was an IT capital investment for the seed-to-sale tracking investment. And I will have them also address that at the hearing. Yeah, that's good. I mean, I think there's also, like, it seems like some of the regulations are overburdensome and kind of, you know, not very useful. And then some of the stuff that we would expect is getting regulated and checked on and inspected isn't. So I just think there's an overhaul that maybe needs to happen in that department. Mr. Catlett. Moving on. Moving on to page 12, I'm doing my best to bring us back on schedule here. We are moving into the Marijuana Tax Cash Fund. Again, as we've talked about, or at least touched on, three funds. I will touch on the status of the Marijuana Cash Fund in the Department of Revenue briefing. There is some updated information that the department reported from their RFI. The medical marijuana program, which is funded by Feeds for Medical Marijuana, kind of beyond the scope of what we're going to talk about more moving forward. But MTCF is kind of the primary focus in the document from here out. I will note on page 11, there was a shift in the Tabor Emergency Reserve. Legislation shifted $40 million out of it. And so now the table of emergency reserve is set at $60 million for fiscal year 25, 6, and 7. And then the statutory purposes on page 13 and 14. And on page 15, you can see the departmental appropriations over the last fiscal year. Here, as you can see at the graph on page 15, $55.5 million to the Department of Human Services, which accounts for the overwhelming majority, about 42% of appropriations, followed by the Department of Education and Public Health and Environment. So in aggregate, the largest three departments account for about three quarters of all appropriations from the Marijuana Tax Cash Fund. And a detailed breakout of each department is found in the appendix. On page 16, it's just a breakout. I want to just ask another question, which isn't exactly about this, but it is kind of. So we have some money going to education. We have some money going to early childhood. Like if we were to not fund those things out of the marijuana cash tax fund, would we be supplanting if we used 87 and nn funds to pay for those things instead or like is there a way for us to pull this out of this particular mechanism without endangering that rep taggart Thank you Madam Chair I would think so long as you let take the example of early childhood that million So long as 87 came up with million wouldn that suffice Because it picks up the million dollars that was here before and added another million. I have no idea. I just throw that out there. Is that possible? or does it have to come from the source that it's been coming from? Well, that might be another. I think it's probably supplanting personally, but you just have to find other places. Okay. Or if we were to not fund it here, if we were to just say we're not funding that anymore and then start that funding up again at a later date. Sure, but wasn't the marijuana tax put in place to fund education? Well, we could. I'm just saying. Well, look at all the things we're funding, so I don't know. I was supposed to fund Best, but that was. We're supposed to fund Best, but that was. Best was just the. Like, you know, $2.2 million in agriculture. I mean, I mean. Just the excise. Everybody likes those programs, but. Rep Garcia. I would just say I think your argument, Rep Taggart, if you were to meet it and then add is one to consider, but I don't believe that that was the intention of being clear of having it to supplement and not supplant. But NN doesn't have a supplant in it, so it could come from NN funds. I thought they did. I thought they did. 87 does, but not NN. Well, NN is a two, it's the supplement supplant year over year. So it's not necessarily where it goes, right? So it's 250 million, but then you can't replace that 250 million with the next one. You have to do 500 million. You have to do 750. So I think that's the supplement component of NN. Okay, moving right along. Sorry to distract us with that again. Thank you, Madam Chair. If there are no questions, I will move on to page 17, which are national marijuana industry trends and policy developments. I will note, based on the discussion that the committee just had, and I guess a bit of a spoiler alert, we'll get there eventually, but the committee doesn't need to take any action to keep the fund in balance. I know that's a significant departure from prior years.
Obviously, the committee has the prerogative to rebalance your priorities with the executive request. But unlike years past where balancing actions were necessary to keep the funds solvent, that based on the current forecast is not the case. So on page 17, we examine some trends. Senator Kirkmeyer.
Just sitting here thinking about the supplant supplement question. Is that general funds? Does that include cash funds as well?
I mean, I think that may be something that the legal staff needs to give some direction on.
Okay.
So some direction on how cash funds and other Just asking I don know They didn outline like where it was like general like it intended to supplement not to plan current funding. But they did encompassing all
I don't know.
Could be an interpretation there.
Okay, sorry.
Mr. Catlett.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So on page 17, a high-level overview. What you're seeing in terms of national markets, they are showing signs of mature and contraction. So Colorado is not alone in what they're experiencing in these dying decline in revenues. There are some developments at the federal level regarding rescheduling of marijuana. As you may know, medical marijuana has been rescheduled. Recreational is still unclear. And finally, we're seeing dramatic decline in retail prices, as well as significant drops in business licenses, which are an indicator of the status of the industry broadly, but also will impact the marijuana cash fund, as we've just talked about. It continues to face struggles. Moving ahead to national marijuana sales trends, you can see the map on page 18. There has been some stagnation in new states entering the market. No new states enacted legislation to legalize the market. In fact, Idaho was a bit of a contrarian. They increased penalties for possession of marijuana. And then Minnesota, they had already passed legislation, but they established a retail market. On page 19, this chart kind of gives a broad look at some of the larger states and the status of their industry. So what you can see here is, again, the decline in sales is not unique to Colorado. Seven of ten of these markets are experiencing decline, led by Illinois, which has about a 15% year-over-year decline in their sales. The markets that are experiencing growth, unsurprisingly, are the newer markets. So states that came online in 22 and 23, namely Michigan, Missouri, and New Jersey, they are showing growth. But again, they're in the early stages of marijuana. In terms of federal policy, and I will note that if you're looking at a test of how sales are relative to other states, Colorado has the fourth highest sales per capita of any of the states listed. So despite their challenges, they are not lagging significantly behind anyone in sales per capita. Moving on to the federal tax treatment, again, medical marijuana is rescheduled. Recreational marijuana, that has been tabled. A federal judge issued a pause on proceedings, so it is uncertain. But primarily, the biggest lift to the industry would be Section 280E of the IRS code would not apply, which would allow them to deduct normal operating business expenses. So marijuana operators, because of the punitive nature of 280E, often experience substantially higher federal income tax liabilities. Whitney estimated they can approach 70% or more for some operators. So it's a very significant change. One thing I will note though is if rescheduling does proceed it very unclear how that will impact It will definitely have a positive role on operators but whether that plays through into state taxes is very unclear Moving on to federal regulation of intoxicating hemp So this is a big subject we've talked about for the last few years. Madam Chair, how are we on time? It's 3.55. What would you like me to do here?
Well, we still have the briefing for the tobacco revenue that's supposed to start of four, and of course we did cut into your time already. It's five of four. How much detail do you all want on this presentation right now? Because I think that if people are interested in this, they can read it. I mean, I don't know. I just need to know about the solvency of the fund. Okay. It sounds like the fund is solvent, at least that's the projection. So I don't know. Does the committee, well, we could skip ahead to page 24. Let's do that. Mr. Catlett.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So in summary, for fiscal year 26-27, our current year, you can see the forecast, again, reflects a shift in expectations. For the first time in years, the fund balance is projected to end above the statutory reserve requirement. And then again, challenges to the industry are ongoing, and historically we've seen significant downward revisions between the September and March forecast. Moving on to page 25, so this is the current status of the MTCF under both the OSPB and LCS forecast. So you can see the beginning balance is about, I'll walk briefly through this chart. So you can see the beginning balance is about $74.4 million. Revenue under the OSPB forecast for the current fiscal year is projected to be about $128.4 million. The state Tabor Emergency Reserve is $60 million. So when you sum those top numbers up, you come up with the available balance of about $142.8 million. Total appropriations for the current fiscal year are found in the appendix, about $123.5 million. So that plus the transfer to various criminal justice programs gives you total obligations of about $124.2 million. When you subtract the total available balance with obligations, you have an ending balance right now of about $18.7 million projected under the OSBB forecast. Your 15% statutory reserve is 15% of your appropriations for the year, which comes out to about $18.5 million. The difference between the ending balance and the statutory reserve, under OSPB's projections, you have about $150,000 above the statutory reserve, which under legislation enacted last year would be transferred to the state public school fund.
Okay, so I guess I have the total after the emergency reserve, is that the Tabor emergency reserve that we're talking about? Yes, okay. And the ending balance excluding the emergency reserve is this 18 million. And I guess I'm trying to get out the liquidity. liquidity of that reserve. Is this the same reserve that we were going to pay for the prison out of last year? Or is this a different reserve?
That was the emergency Tabor Reserve, but that's the same. We're putting money into the Tabor emergency
reserve. The cash is 60. Because last year I thought we had $150 million of liquidity in the... Maybe I'm mixing things up. Last year we had $100 million of marijuana reserve in the Tabor emergency reserve.
Yeah, okay. Not the 15%, 13% reserve.
Right.
No, the Tabor emergency reserve.
So now we only. We reduced that by 40 million.
Okay.
Well, we didn't. It happened in a bill, but it got reduced. We put another building in the Tabor emergency reserve. Okay, to make up for it. And so we now have $60 million over in a reserve that, my understanding, basically came from or was around the same time as COVID, and we parked some money over there. So this reserve that we have over here is just on these marijuana dollars, right? Mr. Katniss.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kroegmeyer, correct. So previously there was $100 million that was held there. House Bill 1409 last year reduced that by $40 million and replaced the $40 million with a building, the annexed building. So that is the $100 million. That's what made it whole. Currently, there are $60 million of funds in the marijuana tax cash funds set aside for the table reserve. So last year, you saw $100 million there. It was reduced via that legislation to $60 million.
Okay. And that's liquid, this $60 million?
It is cash. It's cash.
Got it. Thanks.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So moving ahead to page 26, the proposed reductions and amended funding requests. If you recall from last year, we had well over a dozen of these. This year, it's been greatly scaled back. proposed reductions that the governor is proposing. In higher education, the request includes eliminating the $2 million appropriation within the Department of Higher Ed for the School of Public Health regulation of marijuana concentrates. And the only other proposed reduction that the governor's request has is a $500,000 reduction to the $1 million appropriation to the Peace offer Stanigan Training Board. So those are the two reductions that the governor has proposed, and he additionally has two new funding requests, and these are basically restorations of funding that were previously cut as balancing actions. So the first is in higher education. The governor is requesting a three-quarter million dollar appropriation to the Institute of cannabis research in Pueblo again to restore that appropriation previously reduced and then the last change is to the Department of Transportation a restoration of half a million dollars to the impaired driving campaign to do what so madam chair on the following page 27 you can see so this is under the OSPB forecast I won walk through through all the lines but basically as we saw previously current fiscal year under OSPB about And then under the governor request with the reductions you see as well as restorations the balance is projected to end in surplus of about million above the statutory reserve requirement So for fiscal year 27-28, there is $6.1 million. If these projections hold, that would be transferred to the state public school fund. Again, in a shift from what we've seen in previous forecasts, this is more conservative. So under the LCS, the outlook is better. In the current year, we finish $5.3 million above it. And in the budget year, we're working on about $11.7 million. Thank you, Madam Chair. That is all I have.
Thank you.
And I have the great honor of rounding out your first day back. So I know it's been a long day, so I'll try to be judicious with your time. But I'm Kelly Shen, JBC staff, and I'm here today to talk about tobacco revenue and an overview of three TABOR-exempt tobacco revenue sources. So if you flip to just page one of the table of contents, you'll see I have a brief summary at the very beginning and then a lot of detail about a master settlement agreement and then two taxes. And then there are actually two budget requests. One is informational related to tobacco taxes that I'll talk at a high level about. If you turn then to page two, this is the summary of the three revenue streams that are in this document. The first is the Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement, which is a 1998 legal settlement between tobacco manufacturers and states that sued manufacturers. Amendment 35 is a constitutional amendment that created tobacco and cigarette taxes. And then Proposition EE, the most recent, is the tobacco, cigarette, and nicotine product tax. So I just posed sort of three big questions to sort of center the conversation around tobacco revenue. One is how large are these revenue streams? Proposition EE is the newest and largest tobacco revenue source that we are going to discuss today. It generates over $250 million in annual revenue and is projected to remain relatively steady under the legislative council staff forecast. but I'll talk in a little bit that the OSPP forecast is a little bit different than what they're projecting. The EE money is increasing because more people are using these products.
Is that correct?
Madam Chair, I think a lot of it, you can see the spikes are sort of, it'll spike and then level off and spike, and there's a schedule of tax increases, and a lot of that increase is corresponding to a tax increase.
Okay, so not use. Rep Sirota.
Sorry, just a quick question. Are we reaching now? Have we now hit the last increase for nicotine products, or there's one more? Okay, this year.
July 1 2027 is the last increase So you see it sort of that projected increase revenue starting in 27 28 is because of that July 1 tax increase I think in contrast, the other two revenue sources you'll see are significantly smaller than Prop E and are projected to continue declining. A lot of that is related to sort of declining cigarette sales in the state and then nationwide.
God, we hate that, right? Just kidding.
The next big question is sort of where is this money going and what does the revenue fund? Most of it goes to the Department of Early Childhood. I think the graph on page three is most illustrative of this. You can see that most revenue goes to early childhood for the universal preschool program, and then some also goes to the Department for the Nurse Home Visitor Program. Followed by that is the Department of Health Care Policy and Financing. Some money is going towards Medicaid expansion and then primary care in underserved areas. And then the third sort of largest chunk is the Department of Public Health and Environment, which receives money for tobacco education related programs and then a whole variety of prevention, early detection and treatment. And a lot of this money is sort of being distributed as grants.
Rep Garcia.
Thank you. Do you know if any of the public health and environment dollars go to the Health Equity Commission?
Ms. Shen.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Yes, some of the money goes to the health disparity grant program.
Okay.
And then finally, in terms of just thinking about what is within the realm of adjustment in these couple revenue sources, of the revenue sources discussed, the distribution for the master settlement agreement is the most flexible since it's only dictated in statute, which you all could amend if you so choose. The distributions for Amendment 35 and Prop EE have some items outlined in statute, but ballot language and sort of constitutional language make that a lot more complicated if they are to be changed. So the next page is the master settlement agreement. I'm happy to go into as much or as little detail as you would like. I know it's late. So first is just an overview of how the master settlement agreement is calculated. So you can see in the middle of page four, the graph is basically just showing the payment since the beginning of the master settlement agreement. And you can see that there's sort of a downward revenue trend. Colorado sees 1.4% of the annual payment. And then factors that influence the payment that we get include inflation rates, cigarette consumption, and then how much money cigarette manufacturers are making.
And is that meant to go on indefinitely, or is there an end date to it?
Thank you, Madam Chair. To my knowledge, it's sort of in perpetuity, I mean, until someone engages in more litigation or this, yeah, settlement unfolds. So next is where the MSA money specifically goes. This is dictated in statute. There's a table on page 5 that outlines sort of actual funding that these programs have received, the estimate for this current fiscal year, and then the forecast for the next fiscal year. I think the big picture here is that the annual money going to these programs is declining. And again, most is going to the Department of Early Childhood and then Department of Healthcare Policy and Financing. There is, so these percentages are all outlined in statute, but there's also sort of more general language in statute in terms of what these funds should be used for So this is at the bottom of page five The overall state policies is funds used to dedicate to improving the health of the citizens of Colorado including tobacco use prevention, education and cessation programs, and related health programs, as well as different local public health, tobacco related research and health programs, and then programs to improve childhood literacy. On page six is sort of the actuals of how much money different programs are allocated and used. So you see items in the table in orange are programs that are spending more money than they have received in 2526. And then items in the gray-blue color are programs that have not spent everything that they received in 2526. So you can see that about half the programs are that orange color. So, and this is sort of a newer trend where they started spending more than they receive, and likely that's due to fund balances that some of these programs have, and that they're now spending it down is how they're paying for that. In the five years sort of prior to 25, 26, since sort of the pandemic, there's been a little steady increase in sort of the MSA payment every year. So programs have had a little bit more money, and I think some programs have built a little bit of a fund balance as a result. But, you know, the sort of MSA revenue looking forward does not anticipate revenues returning to those higher levels and it's sort of a continued downward projection. I will say your staff has been within the individual departments and briefings has looked at these programs for budget balancing.
Rep Taggart, sorry.
It's over there waving at me and I'm not seeing it.
Thank you.
I just lighthearted.
I THINK WE SHOULD BLAME THIS ON SECRETARY-ELECT BRIDGES. I THINK WE SHOULD, TOO. WHY NOT? OK. NOTE MADE. YOU'VE SENT THE MESSAGE.
I THINK CENTERING BACK TO THE BOTTOM OF PAGE SIX, I WANTED TO TALK ABOUT PROGRAMS THAT AREN'T SPENDING THEIR FULL ALLOCATION, your JVC staff and other departments have sort of initiated items where we're either taking some of the fund balance that they've built up and contributing that towards the general fund or doing different refinances where some programs, specifically within the Department of Personnel, Law, and then Human Services are contributing towards general fund offsets and have in the past. This brings me to two budget reduction options that we can, I mean, this, I think, was written in the context before a lot of the election results had come out. So option one would be, you know, adjusting the MSA fund distribution. This could provide general fund relief. There are certain programs where you could sort of just refinance the amount of MSA money that's going towards them and then reduce the amount of general fund that they're getting. But at the same time, that would come with a trade-off of potentially reducing money that's going towards programs that are only funded by the MSA. So that's one option that would require legislation since the percentages are all in statute. The second option is just something that's interesting to know about, tobacco master settlement agreement revenue, and I'm not recommending this option because it sort of creates this short-term budget relief in exchange for long-term, at a long-term cost, but it has been utilized previously. The accelerated payment is basically a loan that the past General Assembly took out against the future General Assembly, so you all, which allowed them to spend more in the current year with the promise of paying them, paying it back in the future year. So you're unfortunately just now in the position of having to pay it back. It hasn't been an issue in the past, but if you turn to page 8, I have a graph that compares the annual payment that you all are receiving, and then theoretically that would offset the gray line at the bottom, which is the size of the loan or accelerated payment. I think, you know, like obviously it will become an issue if these two lines cross, and currently the MSA forecast is projected to decline and has been declining at a rate faster than what we're paying it down. So, you know, at some point, I think, in the next five-ish years, it'll be a point of conversation to have about how quickly we are paying down the sort of accelerated payment and what MSA revenue continues to look like, but I think that sort of depends on what MSA revenue looks like in the coming few years and maybe some additional money would have to go towards that.
All right.
I'm sorry.
So we took an accelerated payment in the past,
and now the payment that we're having to make is getting more and more equal to the money that we receive? Yeah.
So we won't have anything left to spend at some point?
Thank you, Madam Chair. I found this idea pretty confusing myself. But basically, so when the MSA was set up, we get the payment every April, and that's the way it's been. And in the past, we get the payment in April and then fund programs in the following year, fiscal year, so starting in July. But then due to sort of budget balancing needs, we... We just did it. We changed the order. We changed the order, so it funds programs immediately. So basically, programs will spend all year, and then they just hope that in April we get enough money to cover all the expenses for the year. Okay.
We're going for a long time. It's good to have hope.
So, Madam Chair, yeah, not, I think, an issue for this year, but in the near future, or if there were to be additional funds available.
Okay.
That's something of concern, I think, as your tobacco analyst. If there are no questions about the MSA, we'll go on to just taxes.
Any questions? Nope. Nope.
Go ahead. Okay. Okay, so two taxes, and I'll go through them at a fairly high level. First is Amendment 35. This is the older tax from 2004. It's a tax on cigarettes and tobacco products. You can see the graph at the bottom of page 9 is sort of showing the revenue projections. Basically, that Amendment 35 revenue continues declining, again, largely due to those reduced cigarette sales. It's partially offset by Proposition EE money. Some of that is around $11 million of that every year is going towards programs that get this A35 revenue. So it's slowing down the decline, but there is a general downward trend that you can see on this page. This money funds programs in the Department of Health Care Policy and Financing, public health and environment, and then revenue. So if you turn to page 10, you can see the distribution of where this money is going. Almost half of it's going towards the healthcare expansion fund, which includes Medicaid expansion efforts And then the primary care fund within the Department of Healthcare Policy Financing So that's the two largest buckets And the next group is sort of public health and environment prevention programs And a lot of grant programs in that department is what it's going towards That's A35 And then Proposition EE and II This was a ballot measure initiated through the 2020 session and then approved by voters in November 2020 and it raised taxes on cigarettes other tobacco products and then also created a tax on nicotine products. And then Proposition I just allowed this greater than expected revenue to be kept and sort of retained by the state. You can see there's that tax sort of schedule that we were discussing earlier, that July 1 is the final tax increase that we'll see next year, and sort of in the forecast you can see there are increases that align with those tax increases. On the next page, we have a visual outline of Proposition EE revenue. And I think I just mentioned this is sort of comparing the LCS and the OSPB September forecasts. The LCS forecast is sort of projecting this slow, steady increase and then a sharper increase where we have the tax increase. But then the OSPB forecast is projecting a slight decline due to some reclassification of some nicotine pouches that reduces their tax rate. And it decreased their forecast by $10 million compared to the June 2026 forecast. So you can see that gray line is coming down a little and then again coming back up, which is in line with the scheduled tax increase within Proposition EE. I will say that cigarette taxes make up the largest portion of Proposition EE revenue like just over half but nicotine revenue is 42% so also a fairly large portion and I think in the forecast moving forward that proportion is kind of changing where revenue from cigarette taxes is projected to continue coming down whereas a lot of Prop EE revenue that's continued to increase is coming from nicotine taxes in nicotine products. Okay.
Can we ask a question? Yes.
Senator Kirkmeyer. So do we know what the effects were of Denver's flavor ban that started in January 2026? How much did that decrease the fund?
Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Senator Kirkmeyer. I don't have the exact number of how much it impacted. Certainly we can follow up with The Economist, but I do know that it was mentioned in their forecast documents THAT EFFECT WAS FACTORED IN, BUT I DON'T HAVE THE EXACT NUMBER OF HOW THAT CHANGED THE FORECAST.
AND HAVE WE HEARD OF ANY OTHER MUNICIPALITIES THAT ARE THINKING ABOUT ENACTING A FLAVOR BAN?
MS. CHEN. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I'M NOT AWARE, BUT MAYBE SOMEONE HERE HAS HEARD MORE THAN I HAVE.
WELL, I THINK IT'S POSSIBLE THAT IT MIGHT COME BACK AS A STATE EFFORT. Well, that will impact the ENII funding distributions, right? I'm not saying I'm doing it, but one has, I've heard tell. You're not vaping? I don't do vaping, no. I don't either. You know, this session might trigger something. Okay. I always figured you'd for gummies, personally. That is more likely, actually. Okay, sorry.
Okay, sorry.
If they put it in an Oreo cookie, she's doomed. It has to be. You have gluten-free ones. Free Oreo. I'm sorry. If they put it in gluten-free Oreo cookies, which there are gluten-free Oreo cookies.
There are. Yes.
Senator Motley has brought them to the floor.
Yes, I have. I will bring you all some.
Okay. You can taste the difference. OK, Miss Shen, sorry about that. We went really off.
You are fine, Madam Chair. However yeah people would like to consume nicotine There a lot of new products out there We in a frozen state That why Yeah it is so cold in here We have got to get a handle on this It cold and dark
We're working on both.
It's cold, it's gray, and it's going to last the rest of your book.
Oh my God. It's cold and it's gray and it's what?
It's going to last the rest of your book.
Ow. Okay. All right. Rep. Serona went really dark there. All right. Let's move on to shifting proposition EE transfers. Yeah. Sounds great, manager. I don't know if these are any brighter. But we can move on to some budget requests. And, yeah, maybe that's a light way to end your first day. Not sure. The first is statewide R7. I think a lot more of this will be discussed during the Department for Public Health and Environments briefing. But it's basically a stat, the request is a statutory change to increase the Prop E distribution to the general fund by 5 million and then reduce the distribution going to the Tobacco Ed Programs Fund by 5 million. It's proposed just as a one-time change. The Tobacco Ed Programs Fund is used by CDPHE for grants to local public health agencies and community-based organizations, just with the goal of reducing tobacco use and exposure to smoke. The fund currently receives a $20 million annual distribution from Prop EE due to budget balancing measures. So this current year, half of the annual distribution is already going to be transferred to the Department of Early Childhood to offset general fund there. This was a budget balancing measure last year, and so this is already going to sort of reduce and change available funding for grantees. That's the downside. The slightly, I guess, lighter side is that the fund is scheduled to receive a $10 million increase in their distribution in 27-28, so that their total distribution would be 30 million. That's under Prop EE as is, and then this request would bring that down to 25 million. So that's the first statewide request. The second one is informational, we have found out, and it's sort of submitted as an item for your awareness and not for a vote. So I think you're welcome to dig in as much or as little as you'd like, but I have written up some considerations for the tobacco tax portion of it. And then a lot more information will be discussed during the Department of Early Childhood's briefing since that's where this money is going. but I have just a couple questions for you all to consider in terms of raising tobacco, nicotine, cigarette taxes. The proposal is two ballot measures, as Director Harpin mentioned earlier in his overview, that would provide additional revenue for childcare and preschool programs by one, increasing those sort of cigarette, nicotine, tobacco taxes, and then two, increasing and exempting gaming taxes from Tabor. The tobacco tax is projected to raise 48.7 million in the first year and then there's a similar like tax increased tiered structure over three years. So in its final year on the top of page 13, it's projected to raise $135 million annually. Most of the revenue, so over 70%, is projected to come from cigarette taxes. You can see in that first table at the top of page 13, that's the proposed tax phase-in every year with the final step beginning July 2030. The proposed tax increase would bring Colorado's total cigarette tax, the excess tax, to a little over a pack This is a 55 increase compared to the current schedule under Prop EE And then tobacco and nicotine taxes would increase to 80 It should be 80 Sorry, it says 60 in the document, which is a 29% increase above current law.
Do we have any idea how that compares to other places, other states?
Thank you, Madam Chair.
I have that at the bottom of this page.
We'll get to it in just a second. Actually, we can talk about it right now. So in terms of the background, Compared to the rest of the country, Colorado has a rate of adult smokers that's below the national median. But then when we're talking about taxes, at the time of some of the data that I pulled, which is a little older, so 2024 is some of the cigarette tax data, the tax rates were a little bit below average, but they're already scheduled to increase sort of above what the average was at that time. And then nicotine and other tobacco products, it's kind of hard to compare across the country since people tax them so differently. But in general, compared to states that have a similar tax structure to us, we're looking at above average. With the proposed tax increases, we still wouldn't be the highest in the nation, but we would be significantly above sort of the average rates. If you turn to page 14, there's a map of basically the darker areas have higher excise taxes on cigarette packs, and then the lighter areas have lower taxes, and you can see Colorado's kind of right in the middle. The state is a little bit old, but I think it does factor in, it does give you a sense of generally where we are. Again, at the bottom, there's a little bit of comparison for tobacco and other nicotine products, so we're kind of looking at, again, right in the middle, about 34 states have a tax on e-cigarettes, and then at least 19 tax sort of alternative tobacco and nicotine products. The highest ad valorem e-cigarette tax, so that would be similar to our structure, is 95% of the wholesale price. That's in Minnesota, and the lowest is 7%. So there's like a really wide range. With the passage of Prop EE, our nicotine tax would be 62% in current law, as is the proposal would bring it to 80%.
Rep Garcia. Thank you. I don't know. I imagine that, for example, the tax rate in Minnesota is also more of an incentive to get people just to not do it versus revenue development, right?
So revenue generating. Would you like guess?
Ms. Hien. Maybe, if you could, if you have an idea. Thank you, Madam Chair. I don't know what the incentive of that is if it was intended to reduce usage as opposed to raise revenue but those are the two main reasons why people tend to run and pass tobacco and nicotine and these other sort of sin taxes especially since I think demand for some of these products tends to be pretty inelastic in the short term so if you change the price you'll tend to continue to generate revenue for some of these products. It's not true for all of these products, but I think the trends are changing for sort of vapes and other nicotine products. But for cigarettes, historically, that's sort of where the research has landed. That charging more doesn't reduce use. Or that it does. Charging. Sorry. No, go ahead, please. I'm Madam Chair. So charging is effective for reducing usage depending on the group of people. that we're talking about, and I think it varies a lot depending on the type of person, whether it's age or race or socioeconomic. There's a lot of different factors that impact it. And in general, it also depends on the product that's used. So whether it's cigarettes or e-cigarettes or sort of newer nicotine pouches, that changes, I think, how effective the tax is in the short versus medium versus long term. So I guess the answer is it varies. but yes, in some studies it is effective among certain populations and more so than others for reducing the amount of people who are using a specific product. Okay.
All right, moving right along. Yeah. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think the one caveat with this discussion about taxes is that a lot of localities also impose taxes on these products, So this is just the state excise taxes. It isn't talking about other taxes on top of that, and then also sales taxes that are imposed on top of that. So the actual price that people are paying is likely more than the amounts in these figures. And then finally, just on page 15 and 16, are just questions for your consideration that are fairly broad if the General Assembly decides to move forward with this proposal in some fashion. And it's just some information about, you know, is this proposal an appropriate use of tobacco and nicotine tax revenue? Some other states also use it to fund early childhood programs. Who will be impacted by this tax increase? There's some information about sort of who tends to smoke cigarettes or vape or how that varies by age, how that varies by socioeconomic status, and then how sort of people respond to tax increases also depends on those factors. And then the last page is sort of we talked about your sort of potential intended effects of increasing tax rates, but, you know, what might be unintended effects. There seems to be, you know, some sort of substitutions between all these different products now that have nicotine within them. And then also the fourth one is just digging more into the forecasted revenue and what are all the assumptions and risks that the governor's office has put forward in their, you know, estimate of well over $100 million. Like, what is that based on? They have some information, but there's a lot of risk to it too. And you don't have the, because the ballot measure also would change the gaming tax, but somebody else is going to talk to us about that. Okay. Thanks, Madam Chair. All right. Any other questions for Ms. Shin? Okay. Are we done? I think we're done. Yeah. Yes, Madam Chair. That's all I have for you today. All right. Thank you very much. That was great. All righty. We're done. Director Harper, are we done? Can we get out of the freezer here? Thank you, Madam Chair. Sorry about the temperature. We've been working on it for days. There's finally some level of heat coming out of those radiators, which is progress.
In this room?
Yep. If you put your hand on it, it's actually warmer than the air, which it wasn't earlier. So that's progress. And the lighting should be better by the time you're meeting next week. The issue is if we turn all the lights on we have a bulb back here that flashes in a very annoying fashion and changing those appears there one person in the state that can do it or something I here we are There's something about the JBC being in the dark though. I see all the jokes coming now. No number of JBC analysts can change that light bulb. But we'll kick off tomorrow at 9 o'clock with a presentation from the Executive Director of DPA on the annual total compensation report. So we'll be back in here for the full day tomorrow. Tomorrow you've got the DPA presentation. Then you'll have the MPRAC presenting. Then you'll get a little bit of a discussion with Mr. Kurtz on the MPRAC. And then tomorrow afternoon we will kick off with the normal departmental presentations. so we'll start to get into the flow tomorrow and again the whole staff is listening to you all's sort of interest in, I like the verb skinnying skinnying these documents a bit, where we struggle with there is one person's extraneous information is another person's useful information and another sort of common challenge with this with tailoring things for this committee is we always have a range of experience on the committee. So historic information that some members have seen some number of times. We have a new member this year that has seen it if she's read those documents in the past. So anyway, it's a balance that we are all interested in solving and we appreciate your interest in the workload concerns for staff. And we also are not interested in wasting your time. So as we go through these presentations, if you all have feedback on that, that's probably a more concrete way to do it. Thank you, Madam Chair.
And I know I'm the only person that has to deal with this. But Fridays, if there's any chance that we can finish early in the afternoons, it's the difference between me being able to go home or not. Five o'clock just eliminates my ability to go home. We all want to leave early on Friday. I think there's consensus. So there's a way.
What time is the best for you to be able to leave by? Like 3? Are you trying to get home before dark?
No, no. Just not to get caught in the Denver traffic.
Director Harper. Thank you, Madam Chair. As I was building the calendar, it was more constrained this year, and I wasn't able to build as many in. normally in the years that I've looked at since I've been director and before that just for reference in a normal year you would have met eight sometimes nine days before Thanksgiving this year we were only able to get four with Thursday Friday this week Thursday Friday next week and that sort of stacked up the calendar in a in a challenging way oh are you guys having a Is that your fault A joint retreat No So it just the Senate Dems
Oh. That ended two days, yeah. Just two days. Next week, too.
I've tried to moderate the Fridays in particular, and this year the calendar was just a particularly challenging one.
Just zoom in. It's hard to zoom in when you're driving over passes because you lose.
Yeah, but you just listen. I mean, if you live at 3, 3.30, you get out of here in fairly decent time.
It's not like you aren't going to hear of the briefing in a hearing.
Yeah, and then figure setting.
Yeah, true, true.
So, or the hearings will.
Yeah.
Because it will be different people. All righty. Here we go. All of these. Oh, my goodness. Let's get out of here. It's freezing.
Yeah. I know. I'm going to go turn my seats on and my steering wheel.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you Thank you. Thank you. .