Skip to main content
Committee HearingJoint

Joint Budget Committee [Nov 13, 2026]

November 13, 2026 · Budget Committee · 38,197 words · 8 speakers · 391 segments

Jana Lockwitness

. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. LOCK OR LOCKY OR LOTS OF ECHO. ECHO, ECHO. ONE MOMENT. THAT IS ME. OK. MY APOLOGIES. NO PROBLEM. ALL RIGHT. GOOD MORNING.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

GOOD MORNING, COMMITTEE.

Jana Lockwitness

THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. MY NAME IS JANA LOCK. I'M THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PERSONAL AND ADMINISTRATION. AND JOINING ME HERE TODAY IS JESSICA GREEN, WHO IS THE STATEWIDE DEPUTY CHIEF HUMAN RESOURCES officer at the Department of Personnel Administration. We're pleased to be here today to present to you the 2027-28 Annual Compensation Report. So in this presentation, we'll give you a brief overview of the statutory requirements, classification structure, and survey process that guide the creation of the Annual Comp Report. And then we'll walk through a summary of the findings in the 27-28 report. So as noted, we'll start with the statutory requirements, The annual compensation report, as you know, is required by statute. The purpose of the annual comp report is to analyze the competitiveness of the state's compensation against the labor market and to make recommendations and estimate the cost for the upcoming fiscal year. Recommendations are subject to approval and funding by the governor and the general assembly, and approved changes will take effect on July 1, 2027. So this year's report assesses the competitiveness of base salary and the state's pay structure against the market. Every four years, the quadrennial report also addresses benefits, leave, and retirement against the market. So the next four-year report will be on October 1, 2029. Statute also outlines the state's total compensation philosophy, which is to provide innovative total compensation that meets or exceeds total compensation provided by public or private sector employers, and to ensure the recruitment, motivation, and retention of a qualified and competent workforce. So before I turn it over to Jessica, I just want to take a moment to review the relationship between the Partnership Act and agreement and compensation at the state and highlight some recent changes. In 2020, as you all know, the Partnerships for Quality Jobs and Services Act passed, requiring the state to bargain wages and economic issues with the certified employee union COENS. In 2024, legislation was passed to codify STEPPAY, and the STEPPAY program was implemented on July 1, 2024. This past year, in May, we signed an MOU to increase minimums for the classified pay plan and non-classified employees in the executive branch to a new minimum wage of $19.29 per hour and provided for certain related compression increases. The provisions of this MOU were effective on November 1 2026 and they are included in the November 1 budget request submission AND THEN ON AUGUST 18TH OF THIS YEAR WE SIGNED AN MOU FOR STEP PAY 2 THAT PROPOSED MODIFICATIONS TO THE STEP PAY PROGRAM, INCLUDING CALCULATING STEP PAY BASED ON THE TIME AND OCCUPATIONAL GROUP AND A NEW TOTAL STATE SERVICE AWARD. THE CURRENT PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT WAS SIGNED ON SEPTEMBER 23, 2024 AND IS EFFECTIVE THROUGH July 31st, 2027, and we'll start the negotiation process for the next agreement in January of 2027. So just a couple of notes for the purposes of this report. Please note that we use projected salary data based on the November 1 compensation changes so that we have the most up-to-date and accurate market comparison, and the recommendations in this presentation reflect the result of negotiations that are outlined in Article 31 of the Partnership Agreement, which governs wages. So I'll now turn it over to Ms. Green to walk us through the rest of the presentation and to go over the report's findings. Thank you.

Jessica Greenwitness

Thank you. Thank you and good morning. So at the state of Colorado, we use a classification system to create and organize our jobs. Within this classification system, we have seven occupational groups. An occupational group is a set of job classes that are alike enough to be treated similarly for purposes of promotion and pay relationship structures. Example occupational groups include administrative support services, enforcement and protective services, health care services. You will see our data broken down today by occupational group within the report and throughout our presentation. Within occupational groups, we have job series that identify a unique set of duties and responsibilities. Example job series include training specialists, nurses, criminal investigators. We have 184 job series in our classification system. And then finally, within our job series, we have job classes that reflect differing levels of complexity, scope, and decision-making. So within the training specialist job series, for example, we have training specialists 1, 2, 3, et cetera. We have 755 unique job classes in our classification system. The classification system forms the basis of our pay plan structure which establishes pay grades and pay ranges for each job class. Employees may not be paid below the minimum of the range or above the maximum of the range. When we need to make changes to the classification system we conduct a system maintenance study which is a structured review of part of the classification system. A system maintenance study may result in revising, ABOLISHING, CREATING, AND OR ADJUSTING PAY RANGES FOR ONE OR MULTIPLE JOB SERIES. THIS YEAR WE ARE PROPOSING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THREE SYSTEM MAINTENANCE STUDIES, TWO OF WHICH WOULD CREATE NEW JOB CLASSES AND ONE OR JOB SERIES, I'M SORRY, AND ONE OF WHICH WOULD MODIFY AN EXISTING JOB SERIES. MORE TO COME ON THIS LATER IN THE PRESENTATION. SO NOW THAT WE'VE LOOKED BRIEFLY AT STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS IN OUR CLASSIFICATION STRUCTURE HERE AT this state on this slide we will briefly overview the process to create the annual compensation report before going into an overview of the report itself so as a first step in order to create this report we identify a set of jobs within the classification system that we are going to use to compare with similar jobs in the labor market we call these benchmark jobs we then work with a third-party vendor to compare these benchmark jobs to the market in both base salary and pay range WE REQUIRE AN 80% MATCH OF THE DUTYS, RESPONSIBILITIES AND FUNCTIONS WITHIN A BENCHMARK JOB TO ITS MARKET COMPARATOR. FOR THE 27-28 ANNUAL COMPENSATION REPORT, WE USED 20 MARKET SURVEYS REFLECTING SALARY AND PAY RANGE DATA FOR HUNDREDS OF FOUR thousands of participating organizations. In order to be used, these surveys must be conducted by a reputable salary firm, must be surveyed on a continual basis, and must be less than two years old. We strive for a minimum of three comparable market data sources for each benchmark job, and we look at both public and private national and local market data. In totality, these requirements help us capture the labor market to the best of our ability given available data to compare our jobs against. Then we adjust and compare. So we collect market data about a year in advance. Once we have the survey data, we work with our vendor to age it forward to a common effective date, in this case July 1st of 2027. Then we compare our benchmark jobs to the labor market and identify recommendations. All of this goes into the development of the annual compensation report by October 1st to prepare for the governor's budget request on November 1st. Any approved changes will be implemented on July 1st of 2027. As I just mentioned, as part of the annual survey process, we identify a set of jobs within the classification system that we are going to use to compare against similar jobs in the market. We select benchmark jobs based on jobs that are a good representation of job series and levels across occupational groups, that are highly populated, that are found in most organizations, and or jobs that have recruitment and retention issues. Benchmark jobs are assessed and updated annually. So throughout this report and this presentation, you will see our market comparison for this year's benchmark jobs, which includes jobs that we have rotated in, as well as a comparison of core benchmark jobs, which are jobs we look at every year. We rotate benchmark jobs to ensure that all jobs are regularly reviewed, while maintaining a relatively steady set of core benchmark jobs to give us that year-over-year trend. For fiscal year 27-28, we identified 200 benchmark jobs. The full list of those jobs can be found at the end of the report. which leads us to an overview of the 2027-28 report. So at a high level, based on our analysis, the state is lagging the market in both base salary and structure. We consider anything above or below a 15% variance to be a misalignment with a market, while anything between 10% and 15% reflects a potential misalignment with a market. In both base salary and structure, our analysis indicates that we have a potential misalignment with the market that we need to continue to monitor for both base salary and salary structure. I will note that both base salary and salary structure are trending downwards. So the 12.4% base salary lag was 9.5% last year, and the 13.4% structural lag was an 8.2% lag last year. This increased lag can be attributed to a number of factors that we will get into on the next few slides But here I will highlight one of the biggest factors I think this group is well aware due to budgetary constraints last year We funded step pay but we had a 0% cost of living adjustment or COLA While the market increased salaries by 3.5% We also funded a 1% structural adjustment while the market was projected to increase salary structures 2-3% THE RECOMMENDATIONS ON THE RIGHT REFLECT WHAT WAS INCLUDED IN THE TOTAL COMPENSATION REQUEST FOR THIS YEAR WHICH INCLUDES STEPS 2.0, A 1.25% COLA, A 2% STRUCTURAL ADJUSTMENT, AND THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THREE SYSTEM MAINTENANCE STUDIES. AND WE SPEND THE REMAINDER OF THE PRESENTATION DIVING DEEPER INTO EACH OF THESE AREAS WE START BY TAKING A LOOK AT HOW AVERAGE BASE SALARY FOR EMPLOYEES AND BENCHMARK JOBS COMPARED TO THE MARKET FOR THIS MEASURE WE LOOK AT AVERAGE BASE SALARY FOR EMPLOYEES AND BENCHMARK JOBS AGAINST MARKET MEDIAN BASE SALARY. BASED ON OUR AVAILABLE DATA AND OUR ANALYSIS, THE STATE LAGS THE MARKET AND BASE SALARIES BY 12.4% COMPARED TO 9.5% LAST YEAR. as previously mentioned, any variance of plus or minus 15% reflects a misalignment, and anything between 10 and 15% is a potential misalignment that we should monitor. I'm sorry.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

I'm sure you said this. I might have just been having a stroke or something. The market is companies in Colorado or its similar state jobs across the country or can you just tell me what the market is that we're comparing?

Jessica Greenwitness

Absolutely, Madam Chair. It's a great question. So we use both national and local data in market surveys, and we work with our vendor to survey hundreds of thousands of participating organizations, which includes both public and private sector. And so our view of the labor market is pretty broad in this case.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Thanks.

Jessica Greenwitness

So as you will see, as with every year, market competitiveness varies by occupational group. So for example, average base salary for employees in enforcement and protective services is aligned with the labor market, while average salary for employees in professional services is misaligned and below the market. You also see some swings year over year. FOR EXAMPLE, LAST YEAR BASE SALARIES IN HEALTH CARE SERVICES WERE ABOVE THE MARKET, AND THIS YEAR, BASED ON OUR ANALYSIS OF AVAILABLE DATA, THEY ARE BELOW THE MARKET. SO WHAT CAUSES THESE SWINGS AND WHY ARE WE FALLING BEHIND? THERE ARE A FEW FACTORS THAT IMPACTED BASE SALARIES IN THE LAST YEAR. AS I MENTIONED, DUE TO BUDGETARY CONSTRAINTS, IN 26-27, THE STATE HAD A 0% COLA, WHILE THE MARKET SALARIES WERE PROJECTED TO INCREASE 3.5%. THE STATE DID FUND THE STEP PAY PROGRAM AND SEPALATELY FUNDED AN INCREASE TO THE MINIMUMS OF THE PAY PLAN TO 1929 PER HOUR AND CERTAIN COMPRESSION INCREASES. THESE TARGETED MECHANISMS PROVIDED BASE SALARY INCREASES FOR SOME EMPLOYEES, BUT THE MAJORITY OF EMPLOYEES DID NOT SEE A BASE SALARY INCREASE LAST YEAR, WHICH IMPACTED OUR MARKET POSITION. ADDITIONAL FACTORS THAT IMPACT OUR MARKET POSITION, SO OF COURSE THE MARKET MOVES, RIGHT? DID A HIGH, LOW IN EMPLOYMENT, COMPETITION FOR TALENT AND COST OF LABOR, WHICH IMPACTS OUR POSITION, EMPLOYEE POPULATION SHIFTS SUCH AS TURNOVER, LONGEVITY, AND JOB CHANGES. WE'LL LOOK AT SALARY DISTRIBUTION ON THE NEXT SLIDE, BUT IT'S WORTH NOTING HERE THAT SALARY RANGE DISTRIBUTION FOR EMPLOYEES DECREASE YEAR OVER YEAR, WHICH ALSO IMPACTS OUR MARKET POSITION WHEN IT COMES TO BASE SALARY. AND THEN, AS I NOTED, WE ROTATE OUR BENCHMARK JOBS, SO CHANGES TO BENCHMARK JOBS, SURVEY DATA AND MARKET MATCHES ALSO IMPACT OUR MARKET POSITION. SO BECAUSE OF THESE FACTORS, RATHER THAN REACTING TO ANY ONE YEAR, WE WANT TO LOOK AT YEAR-OVER-YEAR TRENDS. SO FOR EXAMPLE, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES SHOWS A DECLINING YEAR-OVER-YEAR LAG, WHILE HEALTH CARE SERVICES SHOW SOME CHANGES THAT WARRANT ADDITIONAL MONITORING. I BRIEFLY MENTIONED EMPLOYEE SALARY DISTRIBUTION, ALSO CALLED PAY RANGE PROGRESSION, SHOWS WHERE EMPLOYEES ARE LANDING IN THEIR PAY RANGE. IDEALLY WE WANT TO SEE THE MAJORITY OF EMPLOYEES CLUSTERED IN THOSE MIDDLE QUARTILES WITH NEWER EMPLOYEES IN QUARTIL 1 AND MORE TENURED EMPLOYEES IN QUARTIL 4. THE STEP PAY PROGRAM IS ONE OF THE PRIMARY MECHANISMS FOR ENSURING EMPLOYEES MOVE THROUGH THEIR RANGE PROVIDED THEY HAVE WORKED IN THE SAME JOB SERIES IN ADDITION TO THOSE COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENTS AS I MENTIONED AVERAGE RANGE PROGRESSION DECREASED FROM 36 IN JULY 2025 TO 33 IN NOVEMBER 2026 FLUCTUATIONS IN SALARY DISTRIBUTION OCCUR FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS. I THINK MOST RECENTLY CHANGES IN OUR SALARY STRUCTURE. SO LAST YEAR WE INCREASED SALARY STRUCTURE BY 1%, BUT HAD THAT 0% COLA, WHICH PUT DOWNWARD PRESSURE ON RANGE PROGRESSION. OTHER FACTORS THAT IMPACT RANGE PROGRESSION INCLUDE SALARY CHANGES FOR INDIVIDUAL EMPLOYEES AND CHANGES IN EMPLOYEE POPULATION SUCH AS TURNOVER. SO IF WE HAVE A HIGHLY TENURED EMPLOYEE WHO IS PAID HIGHER IN THE RANGE, THEY RETIRE, THEY'RE REPLACED BY AN EMPLOYEE WHO IS MAYBE NEWER AND PAID LOWER IN THE RANGE, THIS WOULD PUT DOWNWARD PRESSURE ON OUR OVERALL DISTRIBUTION. BASED ON THE MOST RECENT FISCAL YEAR 2024-25 WORKFORCE REPORT, THE AVERAGE EMPLOYEE TENURE AT THE STATE OF COLORADO HAS REMAINED STEADY AT OR AROUND NINE YEARS. HOWEVER, IN THAT SAME REPORT NOTED THAT 31% OF THE STATE EMPLOYEE POPULATION WAS ELIGIBLE TO RETIRE IN THE NEXT FIVE YEARS. AND WE MAY BE STARTING TO SEE SOME OF THAT IMPACT HERE IN ADDITION TO GENERALIZED TURNOVER. OKAY, SALARY RANGE MIDPOINT COMPARISON. So as a reminder, salary structure or the pay plan establishes pay ranges for each job class. For each benchmark, we look at the state's pay range midpoint against the average pay range midpoint in the market. For fiscal year 2027-28, you will see that based on our analysis, salary structure midpoints lagged the market by 13.4 percent compared to 8.2 percent last year. So we have a potential misalignment in this area, with a few occupational groups showing a definite misalignment with the market. As I mentioned, we adjusted our salary structure by 1% last year, which was less than the market that went up by 2 to 3%. Other factors that impact our market position, again, include market movements, those changes to benchmark jobs, some of those same factors that impact base salary. I will also note for this group that the change to the minimums that were implemented on November 1, 2026 did narrow the pay grades in our pay plan at the lower levels, which we will continue to monitor and make recommendations to restore in the future. The report also includes individual job classes with significant variance to market. This year, Tax Examiner and Data Management Job Series in particular had a significant variance below market. We've made some recommendations in this report for pay grade adjustments to these series, although they were not included in the total compensation request due to budget. This chart is an overview of the last four years of labor market comparisons and approved compensation changes. On the far right, you will see the recommendations for this year, which is to implement steps 2.0, a 1.25% cost of living adjustment, and a 2% structural adjustment. AND THESE RECOMMENDATIONS ARE IN LINE WITH THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT. WITH THOSE RECOMMENDATIONS IN MIND, EMPLOYERS...

Representative Garciaassemblymember

HOLD ON. REF GARCIA. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. FOR THE SAKE OF THE NEWBIE, CAN YOU JUST EXPLAIN THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT AND WHAT THE STRUCTURAL ADJUSTMENT WOULD BE?

Jessica Greenwitness

YES.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

WHAT IS THE STRUCTURAL ADJUSTMENT?

Jessica Greenwitness

ABSOLUTELY, MADAM CHAIR, REPRESENTATIVE GARCIA, ABSOLUTELY. SO OUR PAY PLAN STRUCTURE IS PAY RANGES FOR EACH JOB CLASS. So it sets a minimum and a maximum. And every year we make recommendations to keep that pay plan or pay structure in line and competitive with the market So we might move the entire pay structure Last year it was up 1 for all of our jobs again to keep that competitive and in line with the market When we talk about cost of living adjustment, that's an individual employee salary. So one is our actual pay plan structure, and one is changes to individual employees.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Rep Garcia. Thanks. So theoretically, if you have somebody that's at the bottom end of the structure, and you give them a cost of living adjustment of 1.25. So you would first do the structure adjustment, and then you would do the cost of living, or you would do the cost of living first, and then the adjustment.

Jessica Greenwitness

Ms. Green. Madam Chair, thank you, Representative Garcia. Great question. So we adjust the structure, we apply the COLA, and then if any employees are still below that structural increase, we will bring them up. So, for example, if we had a 1% structural adjustment last year but a 0% COLA, you still might have seen some employees come up to make at least the minimum because that's our requirement. They can't make below the minimum. So we still had some employees who received a small increase based on that structural adjustment change because the minimums of the pay plan went up. In addition to the cost of living. We didn't have a COLA last year, but if we had had a COLA, usually that would cover, in some cases, that would usually cover the structural adjustment.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So an example, sorry, can I? You can dialogue. Thanks. So basically, if you have somebody that's at the very end, like the bottom tier of one of your classes, and you give them a 1.25 cost of living adjustment, but it doesn't get them to the 2% structural increase, you would then give them an additional bump just to get to the minimum of the 2%.

Jessica Greenwitness

That's right. And I will note this is also true for steps. So if they're below their step or the minimum, they will be brought up to at least that minimum or their step.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Senator Kirkmeyer. Welcome. Thank you. As I was here. There you go. You stated earlier that you're doing the comparisons between national and state. Is it possible that we just have a comparison with the state employers and state industries?

Jessica Greenwitness

Ms. Green. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer. We don't have that handy, so in our statute it requires us to look at both public and private, national and local data. I don't have a breakdown handy, but I can absolutely look into it for you of just like state comparisons.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yeah. Yep. Thanks. Okay. Okay.

Jessica Greenwitness

And so actually, finally, as we continue to look at recommendations, so this year, as I noted, we are recommending the implementation of three system maintenance study. As a reminder, a system maintenance study is a structured review of part of the state's classification system that may result in revising, abolishing, creating, or adjusting pay ranges for one or multiple class series. So forensic psychologist and product manager, those would be two new job series, while port of entry is expanding the current job series to provide more career progression and differentiation between those levels. And that actually brings us to the end of our overview of the annual compensation report. SO ANY ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS?

Representative Garciaassemblymember

OKAY. ANYBODY HAVE ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS? THE REP. TAGGER. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. QUESTION FOR EITHER. WHEN WE START COMPARING OURSELVES TO PRIVATE, ARE WE CERTAIN WE'RE LOOKING AT BASE SALARIES OR ARE WE LOOKING AT TOTAL COMPENSATION, WHICH INCLUDES POTENTIALLY INCENTIVES AND BONUSES?

Jessica Greenwitness

Green. Madam Chair, Representative Taggart, great question. We are looking at base salaries. Every four years in the quadrennial report, which was our most recent one was last year, we do compare also against incentives and benefits leave retirement. But for this year, we are comparing base salaries against base salaries.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Any other questions? Okay. That was quick. While I have you guys here, though, somebody told me that you're responsible for the heat in this building. We're cold.

Jessica Greenwitness

Madam Chair, thank you. Yes, Director Harper and I were talking about that before the committee hearing, so we will take a look at that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Thank you. We were cold all last year, too, just FYI. Senator Kirkmeyer. Thank you, Madam Chair. AND WHILE WE HAVE YOU HERE AS WELL, I WAS TALKING TO A COUPLE OF OUR STAFF MEMBERS YESTERDAY OR THE DAY BEFORE. IT MUST HAVE BEEN YESTERDAY. AND THE DOOR, THERE'S A DOOR THAT'S LOCKED, COMPLETELY LOCKED, AND THEY'RE ALL THE WAY BACK IN BY THAT KITCHEN OVER ON THE FAR SIDE. I MEAN, I'M JUST WONDERING HOW THEY WOULD GET OUT SHOULD SOMETHING HAPPEN TO THEIR ENTRYWAY. AND THEN THERE'S ALSO APPARENTLY SOMEBODY'S OFFICE, JOHN CATLET'S OFFICE, HAS SOME WATER ISSUES WHERE IT LEAKS THROUGH. MAYBE WE COULD TAKE CARE OF THOSE, TOO. THANKS.

Jessica Greenwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Jana Lockwitness

Ms. Locke. Noted. We also heard about the light bulb, so we have our maintenance list here.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. And we were told that there was only one person in the entire state who could change that light bulb. That might have been a little bit of an exaggeration, but yeah.

Jana Lockwitness

Madam Chair, we'll look into that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Aren't you guys glad you came?

Jessica Greenwitness

Definitely.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you for your time this morning.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Okay, so next up we have MPRAC and they're not here, is that right? Okay. Yes, we did speed work. I wonder if there's a way for us to bring up somebody from the afternoon. Okay, let's check. We'll just be sitting here in a very brief recess. I think we can try to get reptile out. What do they mean? I've heard told my family I'm traveling to the morning. If you change your mind, let's see what we can do. You could. We all want to do it. Okay, so don't. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . . Thank you. I'm sorry. THE JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE IS BACK. MS. CURRY, YOU'RE GOING TO PRESENT DORA, AND THAT IS TAB 3. GREAT. ALL RIGHT. READY, SET, GO. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.

Michelle Curryother

MICHELLE CURRY, JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE STAFF. I WILL BE PRESENTING THE BUDGET BRIEFING FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF REGULATORY AGENCIES FOR YOU today. We'll kind of jump right in. Page two of the document has information about the recent appropriations. And then moving forward, you'll see the department's share of statewide general fund is minuscule, very, very small, 0.02%. The only division within the department of regulatory agencies that gets any general fund is for the civil rights division. There is an amount of general fund that is also in the executive director's office, but that's related to indirect costs associated with that division only. Otherwise, the other divisions in the department on page four, you'll see all of those divisions are cash funded. Basically, the cost of regulating those

Representative Garciaassemblymember

different entities pays for itself. So, question. Senator Kirkmeyer. So, in looking at the cash FUNDS ON PAGE FIVE. WE DON'T HAVE ANY GENERAL FUND MONEY IN THOSE CASH FUNDS.

Michelle Curryother

MS. CURRY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU, SENATOR KIRKMAYER. THAT'S CORRECT. THE ONLY CAVEAT WITH THAT WOULD BE THE DIVISION OF INSURANCE CASH FUND IS THE ONE THAT'S KIND OF TRICKY. AND THERE'S A DESCRIPTION OF THAT ON PAGE SIX. TECHNICALLY, THAT'S NOT GENERAL FUND, BUT IT DOES DIVERT PREMIUM TAX, INSURANCE PREMIUM TAX REVENUE INTO THAT CASH FUND. SO ANY REDUCTIONS IN APPROPRIATIONS TO THE DIVISION OF INSURANCE INSURANCE DOES RESULT IN MORE GENERAL FUND REVENUE, SIMPLY BECAUSE THOSE APPROPRIATIONS, IT'S TAX REVENUE THAT WOULD BE CREDIT TO THE GENERAL FUND OTHERWISE.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

OKAY.

Michelle Curryother

PAGE 7 GENERAL FACTORS DRIVING THE BUDGET THERE ARE A HANDLEPT OF THINGS THAT CAUSE THE CASH FUND REVENUE TO CHANGE IN THIS DEPARTMENT LEGAL SERVICES IS A BIG ONE BECAUSE IT HOUSES MOST OF THE REGULATORY PROGRAMS There are a handful of things that cause the cash fund revenue to change in this department Legal services is a big one because it houses most of the regulatory programming in the state There are legal services necessary for things like rulemaking potentially, but more often so any kind of complaint settlement or things like that might have to go through legal services. There is a request slightly related to this that we'll talk about momentarily. Otherwise, it's licensing and examinations. The more folks who are regulated by the department, the more revenue that they receive and the more costs that they have. And then I added one more factor driving the budget on page 8 about the health insurance affordability enterprise. This is not on budget because it is the enterprise. However, in the last couple of years, the last two sessions, one of which was a special session, there was general fund revenue that was put into that enterprise in order to kind of keep it afloat. You all will look forward to in January there will be a presentation from the Division of Insurance specifically about cost containment strategies, what can be done at the state level in order to contain premium costs while reducing the amount of revenue that needs to go in there. And so I have an issue brief that will kind of lay the landscape for that and be able to allow me to collect some questions that I can pass on to the division so that they can answer your questions during that presentation. On page 10 is the summary of Dora's requests. Dora has three requests this year, which is more than usual. The first couple are both requests for increased spending authority, and I'll talk a little bit more in depth to that. And then the third is a general fund reduction in line with some of the executive goal to reduce general fund in each department by 4%. The R1 I do have a full brief on, but just shortly to summarize, that's the one that's related to legal services in some ways. It's a request for increased spending authority, a total of $450,000 from the Division of Professions and Occupations Cash Fund, which includes a reallocation of $483,000 from the operating expenses line. We put a total of $930,600 into the personal services line, and that's related to efforts to decrease the amount of legal services that they need. But again, there's a longer issue brief to kind of discuss that goal. There are two related to the Public Utilities Commission. and their increased costs. Again, this is a request for increased spending authority for a total of $497,161 from the fixed utility fund, and that would support 2.5 FTE. The reasoning for that request is related to pretty big increases in the rate filings from the public utilities that are regulated by the PUC, specifically around wildfire mitigation and then resource adequacy issues. And so the department explains that basically when the commission is dealing with all these rate filings, they both will take testimony from experts in different areas. They will also have staff that conducts research. And because of the increased level of rate filings and the complexity of them THE PUC WANTS TO ENSURE THAT THEY actually giving the due diligence to make sure that the rate requests are reasonable for what is happening So the first aspect of this is the wildfire risk proceedings. This is directly related to the increased fire risk in the state alongside the Marshall Fire and the fallout with that with XL Energy. So an example of the increased filings for them is that, and I'm on page 11, in July of 2020, they filed a wire fire mitigation proposal that cost XL $500 million. That went fine. In 25-27 period, that had ballooned to $1.8 billion that they wanted to invest in wildfire mitigation. those filings can result in rate increases because it's just increased money that they'll be spending on those and so the PUC's job is to just ensure to decide whether or not that is worth the amount the other factor is power resource adequacy so this is kind of a compounding couple of things there are a couple of different power sources in the state the Comanche 3 that's the the largest coal power plant, and then a couple of wind farms that have produced either completely come offline as with Comanche 3 or are producing lower than expected levels of energy. And so that combined with the oncoming data centers coming online, a lot of the utilities are concerned that they're going to have constraints in the amount of power that they are able to output and are asking for rate filings that are more complicated dealing with those kinds of issues. So the specific FTE, 0.5 would be a professional engineer. This engineer would support with the wildfire mitigation planning, including the cost of undergrounding power lines, the viability of rebuilding and hardening transition poles and things like that. And then how could those utilities kind of isolate the impact of the public safety power shutoffs that have been happening? There are ways to make it so fewer users are impacted by that, but that costs money for the utility to implement those things. And so the engineer would kind of serve as an expert to be able to understand how that would work. Another full FTE would be a financial analyst to work as a commission advisor. They would also be in the work of analyzing those rate filings, making sure that what they are asking for is commensurate with their actual need, AND SUPPORT THEM IN MAKING THESE DECISIONS. AGAIN, THESE FILINGS ARE JUST MUCH LARGER AND TAKING A LOT MORE TIME TO LOOK AT, SO THEY'RE ASKING FOR AN EXTRA STAFF MEMBER TO HELP WITH THAT ANALYSIS JUST TO MAKE SURE THE PROCEEDINGS AREN'T TAKING TOO LONG. AND THEN FINALLY, THEY ARE ASKING FOR A SENIOR ECONOMIST. THIS IS A, THEY IDENTIFIED THIS AS TWO HALFTIME SENIOR ECONOMISTS THAT COULD LOOK AT ANALYSIS BASED ON COST ALLOCATION FOR RESOURCE ADECUACY as well as provide a cost-benefit analysis for whether those power shutoffs are actually serving the purpose that they are hoping for them to.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Rep Taggart. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm puzzled by the senior economist because I could understand it if it was a financial analyst as it starts up. but the definition or the detail that below this is not an economist Economists look to summarize what happening from an economic standpoint and project that to the future This is very much a financial analyst, so I just worry about that term, senior economist, because I think you put it into that category, you all of a sudden have raised the compensation level. I'm only going by one sentence, but that's not an economist. Rep Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think to maybe piggyback off of what Rep Taggart was saying, I'm really interested in this proposal. I think that making sure that our utilities are mitigating for wildfire impacts is really important. I also want to make sure that those costs don't disproportionately get passed on to our consumers and our rate payers. And I would love to know a little bit more about how this, I assume that these FTE requests fit within their sort of existing regulatory regime by which they review these things. And so I'd like to know a little bit more about how the PUC evaluates the appropriateness of these particular rate requests and whether the mitigation should be happening, whether they should invest in these things, what the impact it is to rate payers, and then I would like to know a little bit more about how these additional impact, or these particular positions and what they're asking for sort of will augment those requests. Is it just that they're getting a large volume of the same requests, or is it that it will actually allow them to better analyze the requests that they are given?

Michelle Curryother

MS. CURRY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU, REPRESENTATIVE BROWN AND REPRESENTATIVE TAGGER. I'LL MAKE SURE THAT THOSE QUESTIONS WILL BE PART OF THEIR HEARING PRESENTATION, I'M SURE. THERE WILL BE LOTS OF THEM. THE FINAL PIECE OF THIS REQUEST IS FOR $75,000 FOR CONSULTING SERVICES, FOR A WILDFIRE CONSULTANT. THAT'S LOOKING MORE AT THAT WILDFIRE MITIGATION KIND OF WORK THAT SOME OF THE UTILITIES ARE DOING. I did ask to the department, I was like, well, is this contracting with people already at the state? Like, there's lots of people at the state. I think that's something that they're in consideration with in figuring out who are the right people. It sounds like they have previously spoken to, like, the Wildfire Resiliency Code Board, but I will also mention that they could be using DNR for some of that kind of work as well, but that would still result in a cost because those contracts would still be paying for them.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay, Rep Brown and then Senator Kirkmeyer. Just to follow up in that, with the consultant as well, I'd like to know what the consultant specifically is going to provide. Are they talking about best practices in wildfire hardening for utilities? Are they, you know, what is it that the consultant will be providing to the PUC? Senator Kirkmeyer. Yeah, I think they need to talk to the state forester. And we already paid for him, so I don't know why we would have to pay for it again. THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO BE DOING. OKAY.

Michelle Curryother

MS. CURRY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. THE LAST THING I WOULD NOTE ABOUT THIS REQUEST JUST IS THAT CURRENTLY, AS REP. BRANDE PUTTING OUT, THIS IS ALL WITHIN CURRENT APPROPRIATIONS THAT THEY COULD FUND ALL THIS. HOWEVER, BECAUSE OF THE WAY THAT FEES CYCLE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF REGULAR CHAIR AGENCY, The fees are always going to be matching or the revenue is always going to be matching what the appropriation need is. And so down the road, this could result in an increase of revenue to the department just by nature of it having new employees coming online, that kind of thing. The departments are three then.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Question. Rep Taggart. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think this is a repeat question from Senator Kirkmeyer last year. This is another department that you've already pointed out that has significant cash funds. Could we get a common question that if there's incoming revenue above X number of dollars, let's say $20 million, that we get a summary of what the fund balance is effective on a particular date? Because we end up asking this question over and over again, and I just think it should get to some kind of standard operating procedures that they provide that information.

Michelle Curryother

AND I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE THRESHOLD SHOULD BE. I WOULD LEAN ON MY COLLEAGUE HERE TO USUALLY ASK THAT QUESTION. THE 20 IS TOO HIGH. TOO HIGH. OKAY.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

DO WE WANT TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION RIGHT NOW OR SENATOR KIRKMAYER? YEAH, I'D PROBABLY MAKE IT MORE LIKE AT FIVE. IF YOU'RE LOOKING AT THEIR CASH FUNDS, IT WOULD BE GOOD TO KNOW WHAT THEY'RE SPENDING, WHERE IT'S AT AND WHAT THEIR BALANCE IS.

Michelle Curryother

ALL RIGHT. MS. CURRY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. CHAIR. AND I WILL NOTE THAT WE DO RECEIVE A REPORT IF ANY OF THE REVENUE IS OVER THE 17.5, I THINK, THAT RESERVE REQUIREMENT. BUT ALSO I WILL DIRECT THAT TO MR. RICKMAN WHO IS COORDINATING OUR COMMON QUESTIONS FOR BALANCE.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

YOU SAID $5 MILLION REVENUE? YOU WOULD BE INTERESTED IN THE BALANCE? YEAH.

Michelle Curryother

GREAT. AWESOME. ALL RIGHT. SO THEN THE R3 REQUEST. Again, as related for the budget balancing purposes, this is a reduction in general funds totaling 4%

Jana Lockwitness

of the general fund impact of the department. And so they're requesting a decrease of $97,954 general fund from the Colorado Civil Rights Division, and then $567,312 from the Division of Insurance Cash Fund. CASH FUND. ON PAGE 12, THIS HAS BEEN THE BUDGET BALANCING OPTION FOR THE LAST THREE YEARS THAT THE DEPARTMENT HAS GIVEN BECAUSE IT'S WHERE THE GENERAL FUND LIES. AND SO I HAVE A CHART ON PAGE 12 SPECIFICALLY CONSIDERING THE COLORADO CIVIL RIGHTS DIVISION. THE RECOMMENDED OR THE REQUESTED REDUCTION WOULD BRING THEIR TOTAL APPROPRIATION FOR 27-28 line with their appropriation in 2425 and that's not accounting for any kind of inflation or anything like that it would just be at the same number level so i just wanted to bring back to the attention that that's a continued thing rep garcia thank you i guess i'm curious the justification between the requests for it increasing for the last two years and now thinking NOW WE CAN GO BACK TO DECREASING. MS. CURRY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. SOME OF THE INCREASING THAT HAPPENING IS RELATED TO THE TOTAL COMPENSATION SO ANY OF THE INCREASE LIKE TECHNICALLY THIS DEPARTMENT IS ACTUALLY REQUESTING AN INCREASE OF 12 OF GENERAL FUND BUT THAT RELATED TO THE TOTAL COMPENSATION SO ANY OF THE INCREASE LIKE TECHNICALLY THIS DEPARTMENT IS ACTUALLY REQUESTING AN INCREASE OF 12 OF GENERAL FUND BUT THAT RELATED TO TOTAL COMPENSATION SO WHEN IT'S INCREASING, IT'S BECAUSE OF COMPENSATION. YOU'LL SEE BETWEEN 25, 26, AND 26, 27, IT STAYED FLAT. THAT'S RELATED TO THAT AS WELL. SO THERE'S THE BASE REDUCTION AND and then like the increase that happens with the other common policy pieces. Yeah. Yeah, sorry. Red Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. I would love to know what this half a million dollars in the personal services line of DOI, that seems fairly significant. Is that, are they planning on not filling some vacant positions? How are they planning to absorb that? And I would say the same with the Civil Rights Division. Like, what is it about the workload of the Civil Rights Division that allows them to think that they can absorb this, especially in the current sort of environment that we have federally and otherwise? Ms. Curry. Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you, Representative Brown. In the request, the direct quote is that they'll cover it through natural attrition associated with filling positions, having vacancies, managing retirements, and ensuring contract expenses within available resources. When I spoke to the department about it, they basically said that there will be vacancies, things will happen, they'll just only be able to hire within their personal services line, and so that's the plan, and that the request is a result of what the executive, like, directive to be able to make these reductions as opposed to, like, actual amount that they would, don't need in the department. So it's sort of vacancy savings or, yeah, they're just not going to fill some positions and then less work may get done or whatever else. I guess I don't understand. I would love for the department, especially both of these divisions, to sort of explain sort of what's the risks of these particular. I think I understand why they're coming at us, right, which is that the departments by OSPB were given a 4% requirement to reduce general fund. I'd just love to know why or how they – what isn't going to get done because of it. Okay. Ms. Curry. Thank you, Madam Chair. And Representative Brown, I will make sure that that's on the hearing questions. I will also note, and I missed this piece, that the Division of Insurance, part of that reduction, so about half of that reduction, they are proposing a piece of legislation that would recover some of that amount. So the proposed legislation would require health insurance carriers to cover the cost of any contractors used during the rate review process for individual and small group insurance coverage. So currently, under current law, property and casualty insurance providers do already cover that cost. Just health insurance providers were left out of that. And many states do charge, like if there is an unseen cost of a contractor that's needed to kind of understand what is happening in the rate filing, many states do allow their divisions of insurance to bill for that. This would just give them the option to bill for it if they thought that it was going to lead to them exceeding their personal services lines. AND TYPICALLY ANNUALLY THAT'S $115,000 TO $250,000 THAT THE DEPARTMENT IS PAYING FOR THOSE. SO THAT'S WHAT THE LEGISLATION WOULD SAY FOR THAT. AND THAT TO WOULD BE SPREAD ACROSS HOW MANY INSURERS IT JUST SOUNDS LIKE SUCH A SMALL AMOUNT OF MONEY IT A LOT OF INSURANCE IT WOULD BE LIKE 150 to 200 would be spread across how many insurers It just sounds like such a small amount of money It a lot of insurance It would be like 700 or something like that Okay. I mean, just. Yeah. Okay. Moving right along. They should go find someplace else to reduce the money. Exactly. Thank you, Madam Chair. The rest of what's listed here in the overview is the common policies, including prior year actions. I'll note that typically we, in the DOOR presentation, talk about new legislation and new regulatory bills and things. In the last few years, there has been very little change in the regulation landscape. Lots of sunset reviews, obviously, but otherwise there hasn't been a lot of new regulation coming online, and so that's not really a big impact this year at least. Page 14 has the last executive proposal that is part of the Department of Regulatory Agencies. It's our favorite conversation about Pinnacle. This year I did not include a full briefing, but there is, I think for Rep. Garcia, if you're interested in two years' worth of research, it is all part of last year's budget briefing, including the valuations and things like that. Lots of detail here. But just to summarize the proposal this year, they're not requesting that the JBC vote on it at all, but the assumption from OSPB would be that it could have between $200 million and $400 million of revenue, and they recommend that that revenue would be used as $200 million towards the general fund reserve, which would increase from the proposal that has it set at a certain amount. I want to say it increases it to 14% by their projection. And then $100 million to the state education fund, and $100 million to the CCAP program. Some more fantasy money. It looks like McCluskey's bill from last year should not get introduced. Just saying. Okay. I DON'T THINK WE NEED TO SPEND A LOT OF TIME ON THAT ONE. MOVING RIGHT ALONG. IT LOOKS LIKE TAKE YOUR BILL THAT DIDN'T REALLY GET INTRODUCED LAST YEAR. HEY, I WAS ON THAT BILL, TOO. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. PAGE 15 IS MY FIRST FULL ISSUE. THIS IS RELATED TO THE R1 REQUEST, WHICH WE GLOSSED OVER A BIT. THE R1 REQUEST IS TO FUND EXPEDITED SETTLEMENT AND EXPERT SERVICES. The department is requesting an increase in spending authority for the personal services line item in the division of professions and occupations to cover the cost of expedited settlement and expert services. The total would be an increase of $450,000 from the division of professions and occupations cash fund. the personal services line would increase by $930,600 and part of that would be offset by a reduction of $483,600 from the operating expenses line. This request is actually originating from a budget decision made in my first year as your analyst for DORA. During the 25-26 budget year, there was a mechanism within DORA to try to reduce the amount of revenue THAT THE ENTIRE DEPARTMENT WAS BRINGING IN. IN EFFECT, WHAT IT WAS, WAS REDUCING THE APPROPRIATIONS KIND OF ACROSS THE BOARD IN THE DEPARTMENT. FOR THE MOST PART, IT BROUGHT THEIR APPROPRIATIONS IN LINE WITH THEIR ACTUAL SPENDING. WHEN I ANALYZED THAT REQUEST OR THAT RECOMMENDATION IT WAS RELATED TO LOOKING AT REVERSIONS IN EACH OF THEIR LINES AND THEN REDUCING APPROPRIATIONS BY When I analyzed that recommendation it was related to looking at reversions in each of their lines and then reducing appropriations by some percentage of their reversions with the idea that over the course of the next three years, that would reduce the amount of revenue that was coming in because the revenue matches the amount of the appropriation. This specifically in DPO was one of the larger reductions that happened, And the way that you all went about that is through my recommendation was to combine lines that were related to personal services and operating expenses to give them a little more flexibility on how to spend those. What it resulted in for the Division of Professions and Occupations is that the Office of Expedited Settlement got included in the personal services line. and then what used to be called hearings pursuant to complaints, which is where they contract with expert services in order to talk them through some of the regulation and the complaints that are happening, and I'll talk more about that. That got incorporated into their operating expenses line. That was an error on my part that I didn't understand where that line actually needed to be personal services. So that's why the operating expenses line is much larger than it needs to be at this point. And so both of those costs are coming from personal services at this point. So the Office of Expedited Settlement, what they do and what happens with the Division of Professions and Occupations is that a complaint will be filed against an individual who is regulated by the department. And the Office of Expedited Settlement are folks who kind of look at that complaint, provide some filing for a type of settlement and come up with a, they assist whatever board is managing that individual to come up with a settlement of some kind of disciplinary action. They do the paperwork of that and they file that with the respondent. The respondent has the option to accept that. If they accept it, cool. Legal services is not really called in to do those things because it's a kind of an in-house thing. Imagine somebody's mad they got a bad haircut. they can have some disciplinary action on the barber because they actually didn't have a good license. So they might make them go through some training or something like that. The argument that the department gives is that this office contains the costs of legal services by being able to do more of those settlements. However, what can happen in a lot of those conversations is that eventually the respondent says, no, I don't actually want to go through with the settlement. and then the whole package has to be passed along to legal services. The key there is that then the Department of Law is completely redoing the entire case anyway. And so they are also, the legal services cost there, if it is not settled, is the same as it would have been otherwise. And so this office was brought on, I think the first time it had its own dedicated line was in 2009, 2010, but they began doing the work in the fiscal year 04 or 05. And so if you'll see on page 16, that's a graph of the legal services costs between that time. In general, it seems as though legal services costs stayed relatively flat-ish, I guess you could say, maybe related to the costs of the common policy set by the Department of Law. BUT BETWEEN 22, 23 AND 24, 25, THOSE COSTS WERE INCREASING EVEN WITH THAT LINE AND WITH THAT OFFICE DOING THEIR FUNCTION. NOW, IT COULD BE THAT THEY JUST NEEDED MORE PEOPLE IN THAT OFFICE. WHO'S TO TELL? AND THEN THE OTHER THING THAT COULD contribute to the cost would be the fees that are being paid. But on the bottom graph there shows the actual number of hours. So the number of hours really does align. It's not just an increase in cost for an individual hour or something like that. So I think it's a question as to whether or not having more folks dedicated to this work would make more sense. The reality is it's still within the department's responsibility to do it. It's still within their purview to do it with what they have. It's just that competing, the money is not being spent on this necessarily because they're all grouped into the same personal services line at this point. Rep. Garcia. Thank you. Excuse me. I think just a couple of questions that come to mind for this request is, are we seeing an increase in complaints being filed, or are we seeing an increase in time that it takes to do the complaint? AND THEN I GUESS THE OTHER QUESTION IS, HOW LONG DOES IT TAKE ONCE A COMPLAINT IS FILED FOR DORA IN ITS CURRENT CAPACITY TO ADDRESS IT? MS. CURRY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU, REPRESENTATIVELY. THOSE ARE GREAT QUESTIONS I WILL PUT ONTO THE HEARING DOCUMENT. I DO KNOW THAT ONE OF THE BIG PUSHES IS THAT IT IS TAKING LONGER AND LONGER FOR THE COMPLAINTS TO BE CONSIDERED. And so that's the rationale between adding more staff, because they're asking for two staff members for this as well. Rep. Garcia. Thank you. And I guess in addition to that, if that's the justification and explanation of why it's taking longer and longer. Okay. Rep. Taggart. Thank you, Madam Chair, for the hearing. And I'd appreciate if they, Ms. Curry, if they'd answer the question. their theory is this is going to reduce legal services. It didn't. And to date, the data doesn't prove that out. And so now they're asking to put more dollars into it. What do they know from this that truly is going to reduce legal services? Because they're adding another $17,000 for legal services. So I really question their theory or their assumption in this, particular case. Getting things done quicker and more efficiently, I wouldn't argue with that at all. But making the assumption that it's lowering legal costs, the data doesn't support it. Rev. Garcia. Thank you. And I really appreciate that, Representative Taggart, because it leads me to question also, what is the current conversion rate from a complaint into a lawsuit? So how HOW MANY ALREADY DO THAT? AND I ALSO WONDER AROUND THAT, IF THEY ARE TRACKING WHICH PERSON THAT DOES THE INITIAL INVESTIGATION FOR A COMPLAINT, WHAT IS THEIR RATE OF SETTLEMENT VERSUS HOW MANY IT GOES INTO, HOW MUCH IT GOES INTO A LAWSUIT? BECAUSE I THINK THAT ALSO IS A QUALITY CONTROL QUESTION. OKAY. MS. CURRY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. AND THANK YOU, RAP GARCIA. I have some of those questions. I will also clarify, it's not necessarily a lawsuit that's happening. It just becomes more of a legal hearing kind of setting. But it is once it gets kicked over to a legal process, because these aren't actually lawyers who are doing these settlements. It's just like filing paperwork and that kind of thing. Once it gets kicked over that is what causes the legal services time to climb But I will make sure that the questions about the time and that kind of thing the efficiency pieces of it On page 17 is kind of the second part of the request which is the expert service purchase orders This is much more related to time and the time it's taking to settle complaints than it is to the cost from the Department of Law. So expert service purchase orders, those are used to bring in an expert when the complexity of a complaint is kind of beyond the scope of what the board that's regulating the entity is. So this most often happens in, like, health care professions. So DORA does work on regulating, for example, nurses. if there's some kind of very specific complaint and they're trying to figure out, like, is this actually go against, you know, the typical practices or the expected procedures that should be happening, they might ask an expert to provide testimony in order to say that, you know, like, in this profession, this is how things should be done. These purchase orders are charged on an hourly basis. the rate is usually somewhere between $60 per hour is the base rate but can get up to $125 per hour they will set up an agreement with the expert based on what they think it's going to cost at first and then that expert may file do a whole series of things whether it's observing the person at work whether it's you know just studying the case itself or if it does move over to a full hearing process provide expert testimony in that to kind of show their side from the actual job category that's there. These have the, they have had to reduce the time that it takes to do some of these. So if you'll look at the chart there, they have the ESPOs that have been issued, like in 24-25, you can see they issued $529,000 worth of purchase orders. However, they only actually paid $340,000. Some of that is because they just pushed out the cost into the following fiscal year because they knew they didn't have it within their appropriation amount to be able to pay for it. And so this seems like a reasonable reason that things are taking a long time. And again, like the way that I made the recommendation, I misunderstood where that cost was coming from. and so he's reasonable to make sure that that's there. The last thing that I'll note on page 18. Sorry, Rep Taggart has a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Again, the data doesn't support their statements, and I understand it going into the next year, but there isn't a single year on this chart that the dollars paid out were more than the PO issued. So I don't understand their statement. You know, the only one that could potentially be problematic is 26, 27, which we don't know as of yet. But in most cases, you know, the POs have been between $100,000 DOLLARS AND $200,000 A YEAR MORE THAN WHAT THEY PAID. SO I DON'T UNDERSTAND THEIR ARGUMENT. SO IT JUST DOESN'T MAKE DATA NEEDS TO SUPPORT WHAT THEY ARE ARGUING. WE ALL NODDING OKAY THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND THANK YOU REPRESENTATIVE TAGGERT I think my understanding is that they are anticipating higher costs just in case But I understand that it could just be that they're overestimating on those things. I'm not entirely sure. Rep. Garcia. I think going back to the chart on page 17, and you mentioned that a lot of the overage or like the amount paid is less than the amount issued because they push it over to the next year. But then they keep, it looks like then what they're doing is they keep pushing it over and over and over again. So are there people who have ESPOs from 2023, for example, that have yet to be paid? Ms. Curry. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Rep. Garcia. I think I misspoke. So some of it is being pushed out. Some of it is that they didn't actually need the number of hours that they were contracted for. So they're only paying out for the actual hours used, but they're anticipating, like, if you were to have to go to testify, it would take an extra 15 hours, perhaps, so they would reserve that in the purchase order, and then if they didn't use those hours, they would not pay that out. So that's part of the difference as well. Okay. Thank you, Madam Chair. So the last thing I would say on page 18, and this is I think the biggest push that I have on this is that the argument was that there just is not enough money in the personal services line to do this work on the table there it shows that they they have had reversions in their personal services lines not huge reversions necessarily but like as that's showing is that in those personal services lines they have reverted the reverted funds when OES and the hearings pursuant to complaint existed and then in our most recent information, they have also reverted about $135,000 from their personal services line for 25-26. So I think one of the pieces of this is that perhaps just resplitting out those lines would force them to use the money on the thing that they're being appropriated for, which seems reasonable to me as opposed to giving more personal services and then perhaps they're not going to spend it on the thing that they're asking it for right now. So I think I anticipate that I may recommend that that Office of Ex-Bite-Eyed Settlement should go back into its own line if that's something that you all and that they feel is like an important piece to be funding in order to make sure that the work is happening. Okay. I mean, am I looking at this right, this chart on page 18 that somebody recorded that they reverted $3? Is that what that says? Yes. Okay. I think I found a place where they could save some money. Okay, moving right along. Thank you, Madam Chair. Page 19 is the start of the meatiest issue that I have for you all. This is an issue brief related to the health insurance affordability enterprise. We're back here again, aren't we? I think we might continue to be back here. So there's kind of a broad overview of this enterprise. Representative McCarthy, I did a similar issue brief last year that had a little bit more background information. So if you're interested in more information, I can make sure that you can see that issue brief as well. This attempt was to try to be a little bit more nuanced about what's happening right now, look at historically how has the enterprise been funded and what is the landscape moving forward AND IN PARTICULAR AS I SAID TO KIND OF COLLECT QUESTIONS FOR THE DIVISION OF INSURANCE BECAUSE THEY WILL BE HAVING A BIGGER PRESENTATION ON THIS IN JANUARY PER RECENT LEGISLATION SENATE BILL 26-178 REQUIRED THAT PRESENTATION FROM THEM. SO, BROADLY SPEAKING, IN THE SUMMARY, THE HEALTH INSURANCE AFFORDABILITY ENTERPRISE IS CHARGED WITH REDUCING THE COST OF INDIVIDUAL HEALTH INSURANCE POLICIES on the Connect for Health Colorado, which is our affordable care marketplace. The mechanisms that happen through this enterprise are completely focused on that group of people. It is not a vast percentage of folks in Colorado, but it is enough that it has a pretty big role on the market as a whole is that population there. So many different... The enterprise initiated as just a reinsurance program back in 2019. The goal of it was the bill that authorized that reinsurance program allowed the state to apply for a 1332 waiver to the federal government. That 1332 waiver basically provided a mechanism by which the state could draw down federal dollars by saving the federal government money on insurance premiums, insurance premium tax credits. So it was intended at that time to invest just enough state money to bring down as much federal money as possible. And it ended up working very well, brought down a lot of federal money. and therefore the reinsurance program got expanded into the health insurance affordability enterprise to incorporate more programs that would continue to bring down premium costs. There are many states across the country. I want to say it's 13 states that have similar 1332 waivers, and they have various different mechanisms in order to invest the state funds that kind of are required to begin the process of drawing down that federal money. AND SO IN THE SUMMARY IT KIND OF GOES OVER WHAT ARE SOME OF THOSE MECHANISMS AND WE CAN TALK ABOUT THOSE MORE IN DEPTH. PAGE 20 AND THROUGH THAT KIND OF REALLY OUTLINES WHAT WAS IN EACH PIECE OF LEGISLATION IN TERMS OF HOW TO FUND THINGS. I THINK AS YOU ALL ARE CERTAINLY FAMILIAR WITH, THE LAST TWO SESSIONS INCLUDING THE 2025 EXTRAORDINARY SESSION, The 2026 session included what I would call certainly one-time Band-Aid funding options to kind of hobble through as the amount of federal money decreased pretty significantly during that time. Currently, the health insurance affordability enterprise receives, again, that federal funding, and then from the state it receives a health insurance affordability fee that comes from insurance providers. That fee is currently set at 1.15% of premiums for non-profit carriers and 2.1% for for-profit carriers. That fee had come up quite a few times in the last two sessions as a potential way to receive revenue. I listen back to a lot of testimony, and those fees were set in order to try to mirror the long back ago hit tax. And that was the federal tax that was used to sure up the ACA to begin with. The way that they calculated that at the federal level was they figured out the amount of money they needed and then proportionally allocated that to the different insurance companies. There has been conversation about why in our state do we have a different rate for for-profit or non-profit. It turns out that there was a kind of loophole in that tax credit, so that if you were a non-profit carrier, you could discount 50% of your premium tax revenue. So that's why there's a difference between those two percentages. In the original piece of legislation, that 2019 bill that started the reinsurance program, that fee was set to be 2.2% across the board for all insurance providers if that HIT tax was repealed. So during the original reinsurance program, the HIT tax was in place. They knew, they thought it could end in two years. So in that legislation, it was going to automatically start when that was at 2.2% across the board. So the current level that we're at is actually less than it would have if that legislation had just continued versus the legislation in 2020 that added the full enterprise and added extra programming. I'm going to skip through some of this, and I want to really talk about some of the charts that are on here. On page 22, Representative Taggart, you gave me a really good goal for this year, and I really wanted to show exactly what premium tax revenue means and how the health insurance affordability enterprise is what creates that tax rate that comes down from the federal pass-through dollars that we get. So at the top of that page is kind of the visual representation of how this is all supposed to work and continues to work. The Affordable Care Act set an expected household contribution for individuals and families. The original Affordable Care Act considered families who made 400% or less than the federal poverty line, and so that is set there. Then the Affordable Care Act created these benchmark premiums. They said this is how much it costs to get it. That is what you'll see at the top of the bars is like that would be what the federal cost would be. So anybody earning less than 400% of the federal poverty line would receive a premium tax credit that is equal to the gap between their expected contribution and the actual cost of that premium. With a 1332 waiver, Colorado said and successfully did put lower cost premiums on their marketplace. Because the premium is lower cost, the premium tax credit still exists up to that cost, right? So if I'm a family, I'm only expected to pay $100. The Colorado marketplace has my premium at $150. I'm still getting that $50 tax credit. However, at the federal level, they would have been paying them $200 maybe because it was a $200 premium. That amount is what gets passed through as federal funding to the state in order to continue to reduce the costs on the marketplace. I think that interaction is really significant because as the cost of health insurance is less expensive in Colorado, the amount of money that the federal government gives us to make it less expensive increases. When the enhanced premium tax credits, what those enhanced premium tax credits did was expand that expected household contribution to all income levels. So now, all income levels, I think it was limited at 8.5% of their income. So if the cost of a premium was going to be more than 8.5% of my income for the year, I would also receive a premium tax credit because it capped the cost of insurance across the board That by necessity by virtue brought in many many many more folks receiving those tax credits brought in many more dollars that the state of Colorado was saving the federal government from having to pay back, and that is how the federal amount increased so quickly beyond what was expected when they first started the reinsurance program. The chart at the bottom of page 22 kind of shows that relationship between the federal drawdown and the state investment into the program. So the bars show you the federal pass-through dollars each year with it peaking in 2024. You'll notice that 2024 was also when there was the lowest amount of state investment. Part of that had to do with that 2020 legislation that brought in lots more programming that was able to bring on more people onto insurance, which was then able to draw down, bring down the cost of the premiums on the marketplace. And then that federal amount was the amount that was used to be able to fund those programs. You'll notice in 25 and 26, then there's that drastic increase in state funding. Those are those one-time fundings that were different from what was already going into the program. And also the expiration of the premium tax credit, which is where you see the drop in federal dollars, which is anticipated to continue based on the fact that as people fall off of insurance, fewer people buy insurance, premiums get more expensive, fewer people buy insurance. This is a fully optional kind of marketplace for people to be able to choose whether or not they're going to buy.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay, so I just want to ask, well, first of all, are there questions? Brett Brown.

Michelle Curryother

Thank you. And thank you, Ms. Curry, for this presentation. I appreciate it. I know you've got a little bit more yet to do, but I think when, you know, your chart on page 22 at the bottom really indicates sort of the problem that we've been facing, which is the because of the expiration of the enhanced premium tax credits, the federal the federal APTC pass through has been declining. the programs were built on sort of Biden era tax credits. And so we've been increasing our investment. You know, we're facing that again for plan year 2028, which we will have to plan, which we will have to solve in 2027. And I'd love to know a little bit more about what the department thinks, what the division thinks will be necessary in terms of sustaining the programs at current levels. and to run some scenarios. What does it look like if we put no more money in, right? If all of our one-time money goes away from 2026 and 2027, what does that look like in terms of the eligibility levels, the premium wrap, the reinsurance program in particular, and how will that impact people's premiums across the state? So I think those are some of the basic fundamental questions.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. We are at 1030, which is when we had scheduled to hear from the MPRAC committee, and I think they're here. And so, how much more of this were you planning to go through with us? Should we have you come back, or should we just, can we wrap up in a short amount of time?

Jana Lockwitness

THANK YOU, MANA CHAIR. I THINK IT'S REALLY UP TO YOU. THERE'S A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF INFORMATION THAT COULD BE A CONVERSATION OR IT COULD JUST BE READ AND SO THAT YOU WOULD KNOW THE ONLY OTHER THING I WAS GOING TO TOUCH ON THERE A COUPLE OF INFORMATIONAL BRIEFS IN HERE THAT I don necessarily think need to be touched on but the only other thing I was going to touch on outside of this was some of the RFI information that we got particularly about the PDAB. I know that's an interesting thing for this.

Michelle Curryother

I have one more question.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yep, Rep Brown.

Michelle Curryother

Thank you. I have one more question, Ms. Curry, which is I know for the last two years this enterprise has sort of fallen out of enterprise status because we've been putting general fund into it. I'd just be interested in, I don't quite understand the mechanics of that, and I would love to maybe that's less for you, but I'd love to know a little bit more about how that has impacted either refunds or the TABOR limit or just some of the TABOR impacts of that. Because especially with NN now and with A7, understanding how these enterprises that may or may not be within enterprise status anymore MIGHT AFFECT ALL OF THAT IS I THINK ANOTHER PART OF THE MOVING PIECES THAT WE NEED TO DEAL WITH.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

MS. CURRY.

Jana Lockwitness

THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. AND THANK YOU, REPRESENTATIVE BROWN. I DO KNOW THAT THE ENTERPRISE STATUS FOR THE HIAE WAS ONLY IMPACTED FOR 25-26. BOTH OF THE PROVISION, LIKE ALL OF THE GENERAL FUND THAT WENT INTO THE PROGRAM WAS IN THAT SAME FISCAL YEAR, EVEN THOUGH IT HAPPENED DURING TWO DIFFERENT POINTS IN TIME. and so currently, like theoretically this year, it would still be, it would go back to being under enterprise status where the revenue wouldn't impact the TABOR limit. So any impact has already been incorporated into 25-26.

Michelle Curryother

Before the end of the year.

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah, so the tax credits that we sold for the 26 plan year and then the revenue bonds that we sold for the 27 plan year, that all impacts 25-26.

Michelle Curryother

Yes.

Jana Lockwitness

Okay, thank you.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay, so Senator Kirkmeyer.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

I think this was a great presentation. I'm sure that the Division of Insurance is going to look at your mechanism to reduce premium costs because my question for them is going to be with regard to 26-187, how are they fulfilling all the requirements that came from that bill because they're supposed to be looking at increasing premiums, not on the general population but on the population that's getting served by this enterprise. AND THEN SO I'M GOOD WITH THAT. SO I'M SURE WE'RE GOING TO HEAR MORE DURING THEIR PRESENTATION. AND WE MIGHT HAVE MORE QUESTIONS AFTER THAT. BUT I THINK THIS WAS GREAT. THANKS. I THINK I'M GOOD. I MEAN, THE SUNSET AND SUNRISE STUFF, I THINK WE KNOW. OKAY. BUT ALL RIGHT. AND YOU WERE GOING TO TALK ABOUT PDAB. IS THAT WHAT YOU SAID?

Jana Lockwitness

THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I JUST WANTED TO POINT OUT THAT THAT INFORMATION IS THERE IN THE RFI. I KNOW FREQUENTLY YOU'LL HAVE ASKED ME HOW MUCH THEY'RE SPENDING ON THINGS AND THEY REPORTED THAT AND IT'S ALL there in the RFI section.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. I'll just ask, how much are they spending on PDAB? Because I didn't look ahead.

Jana Lockwitness

Currently, Madam Chair, their personal services expenditures is $543,483. And the total cost of the litigation that they've spent so far is about $1.2 million. And we'll get an update on, there's a lawsuit happening. Will we get an

Representative Garciaassemblymember

update on that at some point? I can ask the department to address that. Okay, that'd be great.

Michelle Curryother

Rep. Brown. Is that personal services? Is that all from, and the litigation, is that all

Representative Garciaassemblymember

DOI cash fund? Okay, thank you. Okay, thank you very much. Thank you, Madam Chair, and I would just

Jana Lockwitness

say if there are other questions that you want to make sure that the Division of Insurance does address, please do send those along to me and I'll make sure that they get all of that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

All right.

Michelle Curryother

Thanks. Thanks.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you.

Michelle Curryother

It did for just that period of time before the end of the year. What year was the special session, in 25? But they knew it was going to impact the enterprise. It wasn't like a surprise. They were okay with that. That was, but it went out for a brief time and it's back in as an enterprise.

Jana Lockwitness

.

Michelle Curryother

They can. They can. As an enterprise, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And the Division of Insurance may have a different understanding of and press that as a . Thanks. Thank you.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Mr. Goldstein. Is it Steinerstein? Steve. Welcome.

Thank you. It's not a suggestion that they get. Let's get ready.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yes. Okay, we're ready.

Okay. Good morning. I'm the chair of M-PRAC. Excited to be here today to share with you our work from the past year. Early background for those who haven't met, I was just a medical background at MDMPH, No longer practice. I'm the co-founder and CEO of the Soror Autism Center. We're a network of integrated autism therapy clinics across Colorado. And I've been on Hintracht for three years, first as a member, then as vice chair last year, and then chair this year. We're going to go for today's 2-4-1

Representative Garciaassemblymember

to just briefly remind you of our process in the M-BRAC and how we would be providing rates across the state. Excuse me. Can you just get a little closer to the microphone?

We have people online, and they said they can't really hear you. Is that better? Yeah. Emily, is that better? I think that's the problem. There we go. Testing, testing, one, two, three. Okay, that sounds a little bit better.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

She'll let us know. Better.

Okay, great. Thank you. So, again, my goal today is to share two things. One, just a brief re-review of what the MPRAC is, how our process works, just to re-ground JBC members in the work that we do, and then we'll get into the specific recommendations for next fiscal year. So in terms of the MPRAC and what the MPRAC is for There's really three key components of the MPRAC Review, listen, and recommend So review We review a wide range of data that is provided by HICPUF And by their outside vendor, CBIZ Optimist We look at rates across thousands of different codes And then ask for additional analyses as well Based off of committee recommendations Listen WE TAKE PUBLIC COMMENTS. SO WE HAVE QUARTERLY PUBLIC MEETINGS. WE TAKE COMMENTS FROM PROVIDERS, FROM MEMBERS, FROM OTHER STAKEHOLDERS ACROSS THE COMMITTEE OR ACROSS THE STATE. AND THEN WE RECOMMEND. that quantitative and qualitative data, and we use that to make a recommendation for what the services under review should be paid for in the state of Colorado. Really on the bottom left of this slide, our job is to help understand what rates need to be to retain providers in the state of Colorado and sustain access to quality care for members. That is really the core of the MPRAC as written in the statute, and then it is really for the department and for the JBC to answer what can the state afford.

Rick Taggartother

This has been a tension, I believe, in previous MPRAC presentations. We have tried to push a little bit further to the right-hand side of this, and you'll see that in just a moment as I get to some of our ideal versus pragmatic recommendations, where we did this year try to be a little bit more budget conscious, but really at the core, we're trying to answer how do we sustain access to quality care for members.

In terms of the process on slide four, we run this process in an annual cycle So services, if you recall, are on a three-year rolling basis. We can also do a small amount of out-of-cycle reviews. And then there are quarterly meetings. We set a benchmark early in the year. We have multiple public meetings to take public comment and review stakeholder concerns around rates. And then that leads to a recommendation and a review of the recommendation in the middle of the year, which eventually leads to the report being written by the department at the beginning of November and then this meeting today. There's really three things that feed our recommendations, which I alluded to on the previous slide. So the first is this rate comparison. So the department does all the rate benchmarking work. They collaborate with an outside vendor, CBIZ Optimist, for the vast, vast majority of services. And again, we're going code by code, service by service. It's thousands of codes to look at how Colorado compares relative to the benchmark. Second is access to care. There's a wide array of access to care data around panel sizes, around provider acceptance, and so on and so forth, to ensure that members can actually receive care based off of the rates that Colorado pays. And then finally, public comment. We take both written and verbal comment. There were hundreds of comments this year. The department has also done a nice job of doing additional provider work groups outside of the meeting series shown at the top of this slide to really make sure that provider feedback, member feedback, stakeholder feedback is heard in that process. On the next slide, just a reminder on how we benchmark. So the first thing that we ask is, does a service have a valid Medicare rate? Medicare rates we tend to think of as very robust. They're very rigorously built. They're regularly updated. And if a service has a Medicare benchmark, we want to use that as the benchmark. And there's a long history in Colorado of benchmarking services to 80 to 100% of Medicare. And so if it has Medicare, we're automatically going to the left-hand side of this slide and trying to ensure that services are within this 80 to 100% range, and that was 12 of the categories this year. Not all services have a Medicare benchmark. In that setting, we are then typically benchmarking to other states' Medicaid plans. So there's a state selection process, which is driven by the department and their outside vendor, which the MPRAC also makes recommendations for, where we choose seven to ten different states to be the benchmark for a given code, and that was ten of the subcategories this year. We do occasionally look at...

Rick Taggartother

We have a question. Rip Taggart. Thank you. And I guess my concern is last year, the department came to us and actually put in place bringing down the benchmark to 80 percent So there no longer this 80 to 100 percent range And I hope that was taken. I'm not sure that I, well, I didn't agree with it. I made a fuss out of it. But having said that, they moved ahead and reduced it. Any rate that was above 80 percent, they brought down to 80 percent. So that range, to my knowledge, doesn't exist anymore.

I'm pretty sure it was 85.

Rick Taggartother

Wasn't it 85?

It was 85.

Rick Taggartother

All right.

Yeah, we're at 85%.

Rick Taggartother

You're right.

Right.

Rick Taggartother

But it's no longer a range anymore. So I don't know how that impacted you folks.

We'll get into that, I think, as we get to the recommendations that will come to life. All right. There was a lot of feedback from the public this year on codes that were benchmarked to 85%. So there is a lot of frustration that I know you all heard and we heard as well around codes that were above 85% that were brought down to 85%. And I think there's validity to the criticism. If you think about a Medicare rate, it is designed to be basically at cost for a relatively efficient provider. Not like the world's most efficient provider, but like a reasonably efficient provider. It's set at cost. So if you are benchmarking to 85% of that, that can be like pretty close. And then there's a lot of variability within there. Like I think 100% for every service is not experienced the same. And so there was a lot of feedback around the 85%. We, and we do sometimes use the 85% when I get to the recommendations in just a moment, but I do think it is a healthy tension that is still in place in Colorado around, we are still looking at 80 to 100% in the committee. That's a big range. And where within 80 to 100% do we as a state want to land? Where certainly you don't want to be over 100%, but the lower and lower you get within that band, the more and more you threaten access to care and provider sustainability. I hope that answers your question. The only thing I'll mention on slide five is we do occasionally use commercial rates. So there is either TRICARE or the all-payer claims database in Colorado that will, from time to time, we will use, but that's fairly rare that we will bring that in just because we try and be consistent across services. Okay, so on slide six, this year we did bring a new approach to the MPRAC of this ideal recommendation versus pragmatic recommendation. So actually this year, we now have two recommendations for every service. This is based off of the feedback that we heard from the JBC last year of there were, I think, I forget the number last year, but, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars of rate increases potentially when the budget was being cut, as you know very well. And so we now have two recommendations. So the ideal recommendation is meant to be the same way we would have reviewed services in the past. So this is, again, looking at the rate comparisons, looking at access to care, and really not having any budget filter whatsoever. Just if we didn't even consider the budget, what would we recommend? That's the ideal recommendation. Then the pragmatic recommendation is taking a more kind of cost-conscious and cost-thoughtful approach. So we're still doing the same process, just in our discussions and our recommendations. We're trying to say if it's another tight year where we might be in a deficit, How do we be really, really thoughtful and really elevate the things that we think are most important? And that's the pragmatic recommendation. So there are two recommendations. There are more recommendations but we really just trying to be thoughtful and respond to the feedback that we heard from this committee last year around you know the scarcity of resources available in the state and making sure that we yeah that we hear that feedback. Moving on to the next slide on slide seven. So this is the feedback that we heard from Colorado this cycle. So the yellow bars are written feedback, the blue bars are verbal feedback, the top four services here received 77% of all comments. I think the top five received about 90% of all comments. So it's very, very focused on these top four or five services of anesthesia, NEMT, the nurse home visitor program, pediatric behavioral therapy, and dental. The concerns vary by service, and I'll share them briefly in the top five. I think anesthesia, Reptagrit, to your point, is where we heard the most around the 85%, percent where we are within the target range but it's at 85 percent and this is a substantial reduction from where their rates used to be and providers are hurting from that and that's really what the volume of the feedback in anesthesia was. In NEMT I assume that you all have also heard feedback from the NEMT community. I haven't heard a word. From who? What?

Rick Taggartother

Yes. I don't need to belabor the full history here, but basically rates were likely set too high. They were set at an ambulance rate for an ambulatory rate, so rates were set too high.

Providers came in. There's concerns around fraud, and I know the JBC and others responded with cuts to the services, and so there's very, very substantial cuts here, and you hear that in the public comment. This is probably, it's the number two for number of comments. I'd say it's by far the number one in the tone and direness of the comments around providers are really, really struggling. I just really want to emphasize that. Now, the benchmarking data that we look at that I'll get to in just a moment does show that we do believe that the rate is comparable to what other state Medicaid plans pay. but there is a lot of concern from the NAMT provider community around the magnitude of rate cuts that that community has experienced. The Nurse Home Visitor Program is a program to help prenatal mothers have a successful prenatal period and postnatal period. It's a program that I think the committee overall feels is a very clinically important service, and there's some details that we'll get into around how they get paid and being paid in like a full kind of per member, per visit payment that's important. Pediatric behavioral therapy, I know this myself. I am one of the services that SOAR offers is pediatric behavioral therapy. This is another area that has been cut a good amount in the last couple years through the executive order last year, and so there are many comments around that. And then same thing on the dental side, where those were also received some targeted cuts.

Rick Taggartother

I want to just ask a question, because the way this is presented, it looks like these are the most, because you got the most comments, that these are the most important things for us to look at. But I'm just wondering about all of the people who use services that don't have lobbyists, lobbyists that don't have the ability to rally the troops to write in and to show up and all of that. And so I just wonder, like, what are we to make of this, that anesthesia was the top thing that got complained about or pediatric behavioral health Because we know that like we all got lobbied like crazy on crazy on that So I wonder if you could put this in the class I feel like my job as committee chair is to share with you the feedback that I hear from providers in the community and that's what this slide is saying.

We are not trying to say that because anesthesia is number one, that we therefore are increasing anesthesia rates by some amount. It is one input into our process that also considers other factors. And so if you look at our recommendations, we actually don't recommend any change in anesthesia rates. And so in many ways, I actually see the process working. And we are not saying that really of these top five in our pragmatic recommendation, really it's only the nurse home visitor program where we do recommend a rate increase, and it's fairly small from a total dollars perspective. And so, again, I feel like my job is to be transparent to you around what we're hearing in the community, not necessarily to say people complain, therefore the rate should go up. It's one input into many, which includes the benchmarking, which includes all the access to care data. Like the question we're trying to answer is can a member access quality care at the rates that Colorado Medicaid pays? And that is ultimately what we are using to make recommendations on rates, not necessarily how many people commented. I hope that makes sense. Okay. I just, I guess I wasn't saying that you were doing something wrong.

Rick Taggartother

I'm just, how much weight do we give this in terms of if we're trying to make sure that the people of Colorado are well cared for?

Jana Lockwitness

That was the only comment I was making, but thank you for that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Rep. Garcia.

Jessica Greenwitness

Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. I guess along the lines of that, I'm curious also if we could actually, I know what you are sharing here, but could we maybe even get the comments? I would like to see what is being commented, like if it's a form that people are just hitting click submit, or if they are actual like lived experiences where people are saying this is what this is going to do to my, like I see one comment on maternity, which we all know is really suffering, that would have generally warranted probably more than anesthesia would have received. So I'm just curious if we can actually see what those comments are.

Jana Lockwitness

Yes, the department has a drive of every single comment, and all members have access to that. We read every single comment. You should ask the department for access to that folder. They have it. I was looking at it last night to prepare for this meeting. You should look at it. And I would say it's a mix. There are some services that have a template letter that is minorly adjusted and does drive up the volume of comments. There are other services where there isn't, and there's a lot of stakeholder feedback and everywhere in between. I don't have that on this slide, but I'm sure the department would be happy to share those comments with you, Rep Garcia, so you can see yourself.

Jessica Greenwitness

Okay, thanks.

Jana Lockwitness

They're nodding back there. Okay, great. Okay, so the next slide, slide eight, I think is probably the most important kind of analytical slide that we will go through. So this is on the left, the Medicare benchmark services, and on the right, the Medicaid benchmark services. So starting on the left, the Medicare benchmark services, again, the committee is still looking at this target of 80 to 100 percent. That's the shaded band. And, you know, basically almost every code is within that target range. The one service on the top left, behavioral health, mental health, this is a small amount of fee-for-service codes that are not covered by the raise is below that. AND SO IN OUR PRAGMATIC RECOMMENDATION, THAT'S WHERE WE RECOMMEND BRINGING THIS FROM 78% up to 80% to be within the band. Then on the right-hand side is the Medicaid benchmark services. Again, this is where we target 100% of a benchmark selection of about 7 to 10 other Medicaid states. And you can see a wide variety of services here. And really the nurse home visitor program in the first row, and then the prenatal plus are two programs that are in the pragmatic recommendations. recommended for a bump where they are below what we would consider sustainable. Okay, so on the next slide is the summary of our pragmatic versus ideal recommendations. I think this slide in combination with the prior slide is helpful. So the pragmatic recommendations, that's a total fund cost of $5.1 million, and then the ideal is $100.4 in total funds. So on the pragmatic side, it is basically taking up that, this behavioral health, mental health, up to 80% of the benchmark. It's bringing the nurse home visitor program up to 80% of Medicaid. And then there's very, very, there's small adjustments in NEMT, DIDD, dental, dental and ASCs, not large changes, is like kind of small tweaking of some outlier codes. And then that is offset by reductions in some of the surgical services down to 85%. So some of the surgical services on slide eight are at, you know, 88%, 90%. And so there's a couple million dollars of savings of bringing those surgical codes down to 85% like other codes received. And so that nets to $5.1 million. That's the pragmatic recommendation is probably if there is almost nothing in the budget, like those are really the areas that we're recommending that the state focus on. Then on the ideal side, it includes obviously everything in the pragmatic, and then it does focus on additional services that are below our historic benchmark. So state dental and PBT are both below 100%. PBT sits at 92%. Dental sits at 97%. We typically think of sustainable as 100% of a Medicaid benchmark. And so the ideal recommendation brings those up to 100%. Those are larger dollars, even though the percentage is smaller, just simply because the basis of spend in PBT and dental is substantially higher. And then there's also a recommendation for NEMT to bring up some low outlier codes up to 100%. 100%. So the core codes and honestly the codes that you all have probably received the most public comment on are actually sit above 100% of a state Medicaid benchmark, but there are some outlier codes that are below 100%. And so bringing all of those below 100% of the benchmark up to 100% of the benchmark is $21 million. So that is where the majority of the cost comes from. There's a service-by-service breakdown on slide 27 and 28 that gets into, there's a little bit more than that, but that's where the vast majority of the cost comes from. Any questions on that before I keep going No Okay Policy recommendations So we do offer policy recommendations based off of stakeholder feedback So the first is on anesthesia which is to explore why anesthesia services were disproportionately affected You know again we did not feel comfortable recommending an increase in anesthesia rates when every other service that is Medicare benchmarked has been set to 85%. We did not see any data to suggest that anesthesia should be any different than the dozens of other services who are also set at 85%. However, there was a large volume and pretty strong tenor of feedback around the unsustainability of anesthesia rates in the state of Colorado from providers and from the community. And so either a further rate study or other detailed rate analyses to ensure that we feel completely sound in the recommendation of where rates are set for anesthesia in Colorado. Dental on the state dental plan. This was one of the more controversial policy recommendations in the committee to remove the annual benefit cap. It was four to three. I am one of the four, but there were people on both sides. Really, the idea being that caps don't actually save money because if people who have dental, people who miss out on dental preventative care end up having issues with their teeth, which can then get more costly. I still remember being a resident and seeing a member in the state of Colorado who was in the ICU for an infection that started in their mouth. And so if you cap services, you're basically preventing the care that can help reduce that long-term, very expensive care. But again, this was a very, you know, a very contentious discussion in the committee. Maternity nurse home visitor program to evaluate and consider adopting a per member per month rate. So there are multiple different services that go into this, and there's a lot of chart documentation and code coverage issues that the community spoke of. And so there is a proxy for this in other states to basically shift to a per-member, per-month rate that we think is a reasonable step to take. Pediatric behavioral therapy to explore cost-effective approaches to some of the caregiver...

Jessica Greenwitness

I have a question about that. I don't understand what a per member per month rate, I don't know what that means.

Jana Lockwitness

Yes.

Jessica Greenwitness

In this context.

Jana Lockwitness

Yes.

Jessica Greenwitness

Yes.

Jana Lockwitness

Basically, imagine a nurse going to a member's home or meeting with a member while that member is pregnant, and they do a wide variety of both medical and care coordination services and social-based services. So they're doing a lot of different CPT codes, not all of which are well reimbursed or well covered under the state because the state has certain rules around which providers can use those codes. So instead, given the breadth of services that those nurses offer, instead of doing like a code by code approach, shift to a per member per month. You get $400 for all the services that you, the nurse, provide to serve that member. And there are examples of this in other states which are in the report, which we're happy to share more.

Jessica Greenwitness

Okay, and what's the net impact of that in terms of dollars?

Jana Lockwitness

It is a complex question to answer. The base modeling that the department did on the Nurse Home Family Visitor Program was about to million in moving the current codes up to the benchmark either to 80 or 100 and you basically could set a bundle that is set at that same price There's a lot of sub-detail in this service where there are tobacco settlement funds that cover some of the cost of this. Some of those tobacco settlement funds, I believe, are short. They're drawing down, I believe, from a reserve to help fund it. So there's a lot of complexity. but basically I think there's two distinct things. One is the rate sustainability, which we do recommend a four to $5 million increase to ensure that the codes are sustainable for the program. That's kind of one piece. And then a second is I think you could have a, if we did that, there could be a cost neutral approach to a per member per month rate, basically bundle all of those codes into a single month. So there's not any additional costs added to a per member per month. It's just a administratively more simple way to administer the program. And then again, there's a lot of other details around the intersection with other funding sources that are important to take it on.

Jessica Greenwitness

Okay. And just to be clear, these are the rates that the provider organization gets.

Jana Lockwitness

They're not the rates that the actual nurse who goes into the home gets.

Jessica Greenwitness

Correct.

Jana Lockwitness

It is the provider organization that basically pays for the nurse to go in and do the services. So they might still pay that person who's doing the work. However they pay them, they don't necessarily change that. They just change how they get reimbursed through HIPPF. They're nodding.

Jessica Greenwitness

Yes.

Jana Lockwitness

With the asterisks of every provider is organized different, and so there are some solo practitioners who might be paid directly from the state. There are other providers who are in an entity, and then the entity is the one who gets paid, and then that entity pays the nurse at the end of the day. So there's more than one way that it happens.

Jessica Greenwitness

Okay. I mean, I would just want to understand how that might impact the actual person who's going into somebody's home and providing services.

Jana Lockwitness

But, okay, thanks.

Jessica Greenwitness

Makes sense.

Jana Lockwitness

Pediatric behavioral therapy, there are two codes that are not covered by the state, which are caregiver training codes. And so our recommendation was to explore cost-effective approaches to covering those codes. And then on NEMT, basically funding a more detailed rate study. There were a lot of rate analytics that went into this recommendation. We looked at every single code. We benchmarked them to other states. But again, the direness of the feedback that we hear in the provider community around the sustainability of NEMT rates is really what drives this recommendation here to just make sure that we're not missing something around the rate sustainability for NEMT providers.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Question. Senator Kirkhmeier.

Michelle Curryother

Thank you. So specifically, but on any of these, but specifically the pediatric behavioral health therapy, is there any, I mean, with regard to your policy recommendation, was there any discussion around the venture capitalists that have entered into the pediatric paper therapy field? And like how do you work around that or how do we make sure that they don't get to scam the system? So, you know, the covering the caretaker, caregiver training codes looks to me like it might be a place that would be pretty easy to scam their system on. and drive up costs, because we're having a big, huge issue with that, as you know, probably, since with the autism stuff. I mean, it's been going on now for a couple of years. Mr. Goldstein.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Madam Chair.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Or doctor, I guess I should have said. Senator Kirkmeyer, I appreciate the comments. The discussion around cost sustainability in the PBT program and ABA program definitely came up, and we had some earlier versions of modeling these codes. It is challenging to model these codes Ultimately at the end of the day what these codes are trying to do is to train the mom, dad, or caregiver to support their child better at home, which should reduce the spending on the core services themselves, i.e. ABA therapy. And so there's an argument to be made that these could actually reduce costs by supporting moms, dads, and caregivers to better support their child at home and need less services and better translate the therapy that a child is receiving into the home setting. What I think would happen actually is you would give them more information on how to go figure out how to bill for more codes and bill for more dollars for things that they're probably already doing or could get someplace else. So that's a concern to me. My other question is with the NEMT,

Michelle Curryother

is you say you have cost analysis, 50 state benchmark or other. Was there any discussion with regard in your policy recommendations, though, just within this state, the difference between urban, suburban, and rural? And how do we address that? Because that's the question that keeps coming up. We have, especially on the western slope, in the southern part of our state, in those poor counties in the southern part of our state, and on the eastern plains, you know, long distances that travel has to be done, less facilities that they can take people to because we have rural hospitals that are closing or shutting off certain services. So how do, was there any discussion there about maybe looking at a policy or looking at the fee in a way that looks at rural, suburban, urban instead of just, you know, across the state? Dr. Goldstein. Madam Chair, Senator Kirkmeyer, it did come up.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

NEMT is an off cycle review for us. So this is actually the full cycle will occur again next year. So NEMT will be back next year. And that is an area that we were discussing, studying in next year's cycle. And there is public comment on that that I will echo. As the rates go down, you need more basically like density to be able to make it as an NEMT provider. and that's easier to do in urban areas relative to rural areas. And there are several public comments from rural stakeholders who are, well, there's comments from all stakeholders, I want to be clear, but there are additional comments from rural stakeholders around how the rates in particular do not work in a rural environment because of the lack of density relative to urban providers. And so I think it is a good suggestion for the department to evaluate further.

Michelle Curryother

Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

On my last slide here is on the MPRAC, what we do, and our thoughts on how to improve. we believe that this is a valuable process on the left hand slide you have seven independent members we are unpaid we give our time to help review and steer the department to ensure that rates are sustainable we're public so again we have quarterly meetings open to the public we we take public comment very seriously we're very data driven we look at our benchmarks access metrics. We're not just trying to do whatever people tell us to do. We're trying to use a really data-driven, informed approach to ensure that we're thoughtful stewards of state resources. And then finally, we're one organized channel. We are a way for the department, for the JBC, for the state channel all provider feedback into an ongoing predictable cycle that allows for services to be reviewed and re-reviewed over and over. On the right are some ideas for improvement that our committee has. So the first is to better codify in the statute how budget considerations should be handled. They're really in the statute isn't good, the MPRAC statute itself, good information on how the state budget should be brought into the MPRAC decision-making process. We've tried to do this on our own in the ideal versus pragmatic recommendations that we've shared today, but I think there's an opportunity to better codify in statute of what do you all want from the committee as it relates to the budget? Do you want us to be budget-independent? Do you want us to be deeply budget-dependent? Do you want us to do both? I think that can be better clarified in the statute. Second is just continuing to fund...

Michelle Curryother

Senator Kirkmeyer. So I appreciate what you're trying to help out with, but quite frankly, that's our job here at the Joint Budget Committee. We're supposed to get the information. I do like, however, though, what you did with the presentation of, you know, ideal. You know, if we had all the money in the world, this is what we think it should be. But we all know that we don't have all the money in the world, even in other years. Yes.

Jana Lockwitness

Right?

Michelle Curryother

So I like your pragmatic approach. So I think what you did here is good for us. I think that was a good change. Okay. Because like last year, I think it was, I don't know, it was like hundreds of millions of dollars. And it's like, that's just never going to happen. So I think taking a pragmatic approach is a good way to go.

Jana Lockwitness

Okay. I appreciate hearing that feedback. I did not want to come here this year and recommend $500 million of provider rate increases when I know you all have a lot of, I believe you all have a lot of work to do this year. And so our thought is that more information is helpful. And that's what we're trying to do with the pragmatic. So I appreciate the feedback.

Thank you. I agree with the input that Senator Kirkmeyer just gave you. I'm reticent given the fact that you've already taken the two different methodologies and done them well. I guess I don't feel like we need to codify them. If it's working for us and you get nods from all of us, I would just as soon go ahead without legislation because we have too much legislation to begin with, and I don't really want to add more if it's working.

Jana Lockwitness

Okay, well, I would say that's still maybe an open question about whether we think it's working or not. So, but I agree with you. I mean, so the legislation question is. That is above my pay grade, and we'll let you all decide. Ultimately, you know, we serve at your pleasure. We want to be helpful to the state budget process when you have tough decisions. And if we hear nothing, we will continue with the ideal and pragmatic approach. If you have a different idea or recommendation on how it can be done, we're happy to collaborate. at the end of the day, we want it to be a helpful process to JVC members.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Thank you. Okay. Moving right along.

Jana Lockwitness

Okay. I think that's the only other thing I will mention on the right hand side is just really making sure that we fund access measurement. I know that there may be additional cuts coming and measuring access is I think the most important thing if I were in your shoes to understand how many providers do we have How long does it take to drive to a provider Can I find a provider within 30 minutes of where I live? And that does require resources. And I already hear the HICPF team talking about reducing the amount of access measures. And I get that. And I would just encourage you all to really make sure that we don't trim too much in that area because that is the data that helps us all together make good decisions on which services need more funding. And if you don't have that access data, it becomes a very hard question to answer. All right, that is the presentation. There is several additional details in the appendix around additional services, stakeholder outreach that we did, But yeah, any other questions that I can answer?

Representative Garciaassemblymember

I don't see any.

Jana Lockwitness

I don't see any questions online.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Senator Kirkmeyer.

Michelle Curryother

I don't have a question. I just want to make a comment. Thank you for the presentation. It was very well done, very concise, and put together very well. Appreciate it.

Jana Lockwitness

Great. Thank you. And I do appreciate some of the changes that you have put in here. Actually, quite a few of them, but especially the ideal and pragmatic. From my perspective, I think that's a good way of approaching it. Great. Thank you.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yeah, thank you. All right. Thank you. I appreciate everybody's time on the committee.

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah, it's a lot of work. All the volunteers and, yeah.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

All right, okay. Next up. I'm taking a two-minute break. All right, should we, we are a little bit ahead of schedule, so should we take a five-minute break? And we'll have Mr. Kurtz start at 1120. which will still be 10 minutes ahead of schedule. Plus, we've got a whole other thing in. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Madam Chair, as you just heard, the Medicaid provider rate review advisory committee or MPRAC reviews all of the department's rates on a three-year schedule. The statute says that the budget committee or the MPRAC may direct the department to review a rate outside of the three-year schedule. So if you're hearing a lot of concerns or complaints about a particular rate, you could direct the department to say, don't wait two years to do that rate, do it this year, please. The statute also allows the department to exempt rates from the rate review process. If the rate meets criteria, the primary one that gets used here is if it's periodically adjusted or reviewed already through some other state or federal law or regulation. Quite a few of the department's services are exempted from the MPRAC process already, but you can ask the department to review an exempted process. And there's this process in the statute that allows you to do that. If you want to do that, you have to submit the recommendation to the department by december 1st that's why we're having this meeting today to give you that opportunity before that statutory deadline if that's something that you want to do usually i do not recommend any changes the department puts a lot of effort into trying to coordinate these reviews with both their administrative schedule the stakeholders but but also releases of, for example, outside information, like there's a periodic survey of dental rates that comes out that they want to align their review with when that analysis comes out. This particular year, I am recommending that you ask the department to make a change to the schedule. And the reason is that nursing facility rates used to be on a statutory formula that they got adjusted every year based on that formula. And a few years ago, the budget committee sponsored a bill to end that. Well, it wasn't a budget committee bill, but it had a lot of budget committee members on it. To end that process. And now the nursing facilities are not going to get automatic statutory adjustments to their rates unless the General Assembly appropriates funding through the annual budget process. So given that change in the dynamic, I think that it's worth having the nursing facility rates reviewed by the MPRAC for their adequacy so you have some data to base your decisions on.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay.

Rick Taggartother

Rep Brown. Just for a procedural question, do you need a motion or you just need sort of a general like, Yep, that sounds good today.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Given the structure in the statute, I think probably a motion is best, and then we would send a letter to the department. Given the status of the committee, you may want to wait to vote a different day. Sure. Well, I think, oh, because we don't know, we're not all sworn in yet. Correct.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Senator Kirkmeyer.

Michelle Curryother

Okay, that's fine. We can wait. So if you think that is a motion you might want to make, we can schedule time for you to make that motion. Yeah, we have four.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

You can do it.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

We only have one senator, though. What are you guys afraid of? Well, is it an enemy here? Yeah, actually, Emily. Yeah, let's just do it. Okay, go ahead.

Michelle Curryother

I move staff recommendation on Medicaid on the MPRAC schedule.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Is there any objection? Seeing none, we will do the staff recommendation. That's it. Okay, thank you. All right. And Mr. Rickman is here to talk about ag. And that is tab four. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Madam Chair.

Michelle Curryother

Sam Rickman, JBC staff. Okay today we going to talk about the Department of Agriculture and the document I prepared which goes over their request and then a couple issue briefs which are reminders of things that you all talked about last year and that I think might come up again this year. So let's get right into the document on page two. There's just an overview of the department. There's nine divisions. I'll just go through them real quick one by one. Commissioner's office is the central division in the department which provides all those central administrative services. The conservation services division brings together a few programs that are related to sustainable agriculture and resource stewardship which also includes the Colorado Conservation Board. Animal welfare is enforcing Colorado's animal welfare laws and humane treatment of animals. The animal health division is livestock disease prevention and those related services. A lot of regulatory parts of that department. The inspection and consumer services division ensures or does regulatory inspections to ensure agricultural products are safe, fair, and transparent. Then three more brands division has I think the oldest program in the state of Colorado. It goes back to I think if I remember correctly before Colorado was even officially a state they had the brands division Yeah, so kind of interesting there The State Fair authority does the State Fair the markets division does marketing of Colorado agricultural products and finally the plant industry division regulates the production sale and distribution of plants

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Rep Brown You know how much this committee loves the insectary. Does that sit in the Department of Agriculture? Where does that sit?

Michelle Curryother

Yes.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Michelle Curryother

That does sit in the Department of Agriculture. I'm not entirely sure, actually, which division it sits in. Yeah, I'm not sure about that. I do have an issue brief later about the pine beetle thing that everyone approved last year.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Yeah, we did last year.

Michelle Curryother

Yeah, so we'll talk a little bit more about that. but there is also an RFI. Everyone, I'll say...

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

No, no, I agree.

Michelle Curryother

Okay, some of us.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Some people love it. Some of us love it. Some people are... I was going to say, I just want to say, for the record, I still have my specimens from the insectary that they sent us last year prominently displayed in my office. So, there you go.

Michelle Curryother

Probably, yeah.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

I don't know.

Michelle Curryother

Okay, moving right along. Okay, so moving right along to page number four. So Director Harper confirmed that it's conservation services division is where the insectary is.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

There you go. Yeah. I mean, an insect definitely isn't a plant.

Michelle Curryother

Okay, so on page four, you can see that this department makes up a very small percentage of the statewide general fund. It's mostly cash funded in this department, but they do have about 25% general fund.

I have a question. Is the Department of Ag going to get any of this 137 money? Is there any bucket that gives money to the conservation part of Department of Ag Thank you Madam Chair That a great question I think maybe we can add that to the hearing agenda I don know the answer

Michelle Curryother

I'm not sure if the department knows the answer either, but I think that's a good question. Yeah, there is some conservation stuff. I'm on page five now. The Commissioner's Office makes up the highest percentage of general fund, and then every division except for the brands division also has a little bit of general fund. And then you'll see the total funds by division where the commissioner's office also makes up the majority and then the rest are relatively even. Moving on to page number six, this is some cash fund detail in the department. I did, while preparing this document, group some of the cash funds together. since they have so many. I tried to sort of group them together by what sorts of programs they have and what their fees come from. So these aren't individual cash funds is my point. Again, the state fair cash fund is the biggest one in the department, and there is a request this year related to the state fair, and that's the one I usually flag, and also the AMF. We have an issue brief about the AMF that just sort of updates you all about the decisions that have been made IN THE STATUS OF THAT FUND.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

YEAH.

Michelle Curryother

SORRY, REP BROWN.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

MR. RICKMAN, LAST YEAR WE ASKED YOU WHERE WE SHOULD MOVE THE STATE FAIR FROM PUBLO. DID YOU COME UP WITH AN ANSWER TO THAT IN THE LAST YEAR? I THINK IT'S COMING TO BOLDER, ACTUALLY. YEAH, BOLDER COUNTY. WE'VE GOT A BIG FAIR GROUND. I'm like looking at all the members and trying to say a place that none of you are from. If I were you, I would go with wealth.

Rick Taggartother

Hey, there's a strong Adams County argument here, but I'll give it to you.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Okay.

Michelle Curryother

Now we're on page seven with the general factors. As I said before, there's not too much general fund in this department. Most of the general fund in this department goes to pay for staff and other administrative services, common policies. You can see that FTE has grown quite a bit from 2018-2019, and for the most part, that's driving the general fund growth in this department. I'll just note that there are a few small programs that receive some general funds, like grant programs here and there. but for the most part it's going to be for personal services and common policies in this department. Moving on to page 8 now, like I said, they have a bunch of cash funds. Now in this chart you see here on page 8, these are the actual largest cash funds in this department. Again, the State Fair Authority is the largest one. I think that AMF is the other one that's always noteworthy just because of how they use that fund. And then all the regulatory divisions like the brand inspection, plant health inspection and consumer services, these are all fee-based and are used to fund those programs that they have within those divisions. Okay, I'm moving forward, unless there are questions, to page number nine, which is the summary of the request. They have three decision items this year in the department. THEIR OVERALL BUDGET IS GROWING BY 3 WITH THE 7 GROWTH IN general fund Yeah so unless anyone has questions about that I jump into the decisions themselves The first one is decision R1 is a reduction in the conservation services division. The majority of this is made up of a 450 general fund reduction to the Noxious Weed Management Program, which is a statewide grant program that they give to private citizens and local nonprofits, I think, to help combat noxious weeds. I talked to the department about this. They said they think they'll be able to make up some of that lost general fund with federal grants, although they note that that is uncertain. And so the risk of this is that there will be less direct support provided to pay for noxious weed management in the state. I'm sorry. I was distracted. Rep Taggart.

Rick Taggartother

Madam Chair, I just want to go on the record. I am totally against this. The noxious weed problem alongside of the Colorado River that does run through Mesa County, by the way, it's the biggest. But be that as it may, the amount of water that is consumed by noxious weeds along river banks is serious. And with us not continuing to knock that down tamarisk in particular, it's just not a good idea. And it surprises me that they put this as a request.

Lorena Garciaother

Rep. Garcia. Thank you. How much is currently going to the noxious weed program? and is this a testament? Like, are they claiming that they just need less because they're doing so good, or is this just a whole, like, we're just being told to cut everywhere?

Michelle Curryother

Mr. Wickman. I can't remember the exact number. I know that they're retaining, I think they're retaining 15,000 in this program for the other purposes of the program. So, statutorily, this program is required to provide educational and in-kind services, which they say they're going to continue to do. And then I think the statute says, and financial support, depending on available funding. This is a budget reduction option. They're not saying that this program isn't successful. They're just saying that, well, the governor's office has told every department to force some cuts, and this is the one they came up with. I think they put this one forward because they feel like they can get some federal funds, and they've secured federal funds in recent years. But I did have these same questions for them, and they said that while they think they can continue to get federal funds, it's obviously uncertain what they'll be able to secure.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Should we add something to the hearing agenda to have the department speak to this?

Michelle Curryother

Yes.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Senator Kirkmar. And while they're speaking to this, I'd like to know if they've actually worked with CSU Extension Office to see what kind of programs they have over there that maybe we could complement and maybe not do as much of a cut. Because it is essential in our state with the agriculture industry that we have being like, I think it's our third largest economy. that the extensive irrigation systems that we have and water systems that we have, that noxious weeds are cut down. And the suburban infringement in agricultural areas is causing a weed problem, quite frankly. And I don't mean marijuana weed. It could be that problem too. I guess I'd be curious to know what exactly they are doing to address the noxious weed problem. are they spraying? Are they deploying goats? That's what Boulder County does. Yes. We're having a big lawsuit right now about that and that's why I'm kind of curious. No, not about the goats. About the spraying. So I'm just curious what exactly these grants are going for and how effective it is. I mean, maybe it needs more money or less money. I don't know, but just curious.

Michelle Curryother

If you talk to the weed management boards, they would tell you that it isn't enough money to kill all the weeds in the state. So, I mean, the counties are required. There's statutory provisions. Counties are required to do a lot.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Moving right along. Moving right along.

Michelle Curryother

And I'll just add that there is another reduction in here that's just a program, and the commissioner's office has concluded. and so that's what makes up the difference between the $450,000 that I mentioned and the final number of $522,000. Okay, the R2 request is to increase the appropriation from the PACFA fund, which is the Pet Animal Care and Facility Fund. There was a bill run last year. I think it's 1181. that was a sunset bill to continue this program for eight more years. And this request is for additional cash fund spending authority from that fund. Through that sunset bill, they were granted authority to raise feed, like pet animal care fee, the fees that supply that fund. They were granted authority to raise those fees to be aligned with inflation. And so this would allow them to spend some of those dollars or increase their appropriation if they do decide to ultimately raise those fees.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Senator Kirkmeyer. Thanks. I just don't see it. Where is the pet animal cash fund? What is it called? The pet and something? Pet animal care and facility fund? Where is that?

Michelle Curryother

On their list of cash funds detail.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Are you missing it?

Michelle Curryother

Mr. Rickman. Thank you, Senator Kirkmeyer, for the question. So when I prepared this table on page six that I think you're referring to, they have so many cash funds in this department that they wouldn't all fit in this table. So what I did was group some of them together. I think the pet animal care and facility cash fund is within that animal industry related one. and I can tell you from my memory that they're appropriated about $900,000 or so from this cash fund. Does that make sense?

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

So this list of cash funds isn't, I realize now that this is a little misleading,

Michelle Curryother

it's not individual cash funds. Some of them are individual, some of them are a few different ones combined just so they can all fit in the table. You know we could put them on the other side of the page We could go on your front and back pages just saying But anyways well it would be

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

It would be. That's not hippie stuff. I'm an environmentalist, man. But anyways, well, I would just like to know what it is and how much they're actually spending and are they going to have to increase the fee?

Michelle Curryother

Mr. Rickman. And what are they going to do? I can add this to the hearing agenda. I've asked similar questions to the department. It probably makes sense to have them tell you in the hearing, but what they're going to do is, so they're appropriated, or in the long bill there's 11 FTE for this program. They currently only have 10 FTE because they use that additional appropriation to pay for the software that they use, which they said they can't afford the 11 FTE and the software. So what this request is doing is they're going to, it increases the appropriation to 12 FTE, and they're actually going to hire two FTE because they have one vacant position right now. And relative to whether they need to raise the fees or not, I asked them if they would raise the fees regardless of this request, and they said they might because there's increasing legal fees associated with this program. So they might have to raise those fees either way. but so that's the response I've gotten from similar questions I've asked but I

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

can still add this to the hearing agenda as well yeah okay I can you just I don't recall what this thing even does like are these people's pets or whose pets are these and why is the state involved in caring for people's pets thank you madam

Michelle Curryother

chair so this is like when you want to open a pet business like a grooming service or a dog walking business or something, you get PACFA certified. And so then they have these, their FTEs basically go around and, you know, will check on these facilities and make sure they're up to the regulatory standards and then they'll certify them. So you'll see if you go to like, I don't know, whatever your local pet groomer, you might see that they're PACFA certified. That's what this is and that's where that fee revenue comes from.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Okay, and we don't regulate them the way we regulate, like, I don't know, all kinds of other things?

Michelle Curryother

We set up this whole separate thing just for pets? Madam Chair, that's like a lot of what this department does. They have these kind of very niche programs that are regulating sort of very specific things.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Yeah.

Michelle Curryother

Okay.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Like insects. Yes.

Michelle Curryother

So the fees are paid by the licensee in this particular case?

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

It's like you get licensed by the PACFA, whatever, and then, okay.

Michelle Curryother

And is that an enterprise or is that? No, it's not an enterprise. It's got general fund impact. I mean, it's not a lot of money, but it's just.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

We'll just need more information. We're going to want to talk about pets. We want to spend a couple of hours on this. Pets, bugs, and animal welfare. We spent four hours on animal welfare division before. That might have been last year. Maybe last year it was only two. The year before it was like four or five. Okay.

Michelle Curryother

Moving right along.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay.

Michelle Curryother

State Fair Spending Authority.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yeah.

Michelle Curryother

So they want $500,000. So there are three requests of spending authority, and they say that it will go towards physical security equipment, facility maintenance, and increased entertainment offerings, AND THAT IS IN PRIORITY ORDER FROM WHAT THE DEPARTMENT TOLD ME AND THEY SAY THAT THIS WILL NOT AFFECT THE RESERVE BALANCE IN THE STATE FAIR FUND BECAUSE THEY HAD INCREASING REVENUES WELL WE HAVE TO ASK THE NEW EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR IF THINKS THAT A PRIORITY TELL HIM TO COME PREPARED FOR A GRILLING OKAY, MOVING ALONG. THE REST OF THE REQUESTS ARE JUST COMMON POLICY RELATED. THE LARGEST IS IN HEALTH LIFE AND DENTAL. That's because last year when you all approved to replace some general fund in this department with AMF, it came from that health life and dental line. So that's why you see such a huge amount in that health life and dental. There is an issue with how this was implemented that I'll talk about just in a few moments when I talk about the AMF. But, yeah.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Moving right along to page number 12.

Michelle Curryother

I tried to make the two issue briefs things that were relevant, whether or not the request changes. So I just wanted to give you all an update on the AMF. So I presented last year to you about this fund, the revenue sources, what the status of the fund is. The balance is growing. The revenue is growing. and so I kind of felt like it would be a good fund to use for general fund cuts and so this is kind of just checking back in on that. So just a quick background, their revenue comes from the UPTF which is the unclaimed property tourism promotion trust fund. The balance in that fund has been growing and it comes from the interest from that fund so that balance has been growing and interest rates have remained high which has led to revenue. Increased revenue, and the department uses this fund. They have a line item that is in their commissioner's office that is AMF, where they can use it on, and basically what they deem is necessary. And another way they use this fund is through a process called revenue transfers, where at the beginning of the year, they'll transfer money from the revenue that goes into this fund to various funds around the department to either prop up a program that is, the revenue is falling or the fund balance is falling. So they have authority to do that. As you can see on page number 13, despite how they use the fund, the balance has been growing significantly. And so I recommended that you all use this for general fund balancing last year, and it appears that the fund balance is still growing. So if it comes to it, this may be another option for general fund reductions as well. And then...

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Hold on one sec.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Rep Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Rickman, can you remind me what ends up in the UPTF? Is it stocks? Is that right? Unclaimed stocks?

Michelle Curryother

Okay. It's... Mr. Rickman, yeah. Thank you, Madam Chair. No, you're good. Yes, it's securities that were sold will go into that fund, and then also tangible property that's sold, like a house or, yeah, stuff like that. And then just one further update. So like I said, the reduction went into the health life and dental line just for procedural things, but then they did not put this into their budget request. So what is going to happen is I will initiate a staff initiated change, which will reduce general fund in the OIT line by 457 and replace it with AMF So the amount of general fund you see in the request is actually a bit higher than it should be And we talk more about that during figure setting

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Okay.

Michelle Curryother

One last thing to talk about is the mountain pine beetle. So they have implemented this project to control the increased damage that the state is seeing from mountain pine beetles. the insectary is doing kind of a biocontrol response to see if they can basically take predatory beetles from the field bring them back into the lab and breed them and then release them back this is kind of a pilot project where they have I think 10 test sites each one's a half an acre and they've been testing what the species are there and then they've gotten that predatory beetle brought it back to the insectary and based on the RFI that they submitted they did successfully rear an initial cohort of the natural enemies the reason I wanted to bring this forward to you is because it looks like there's a a placeholder in the governor's budget request for mountain pine beetle related things and so if you'll recall last December he initiated a mountain pine beetle task force. They've been meeting regularly and they have recommendations. I went back and looked at their recommendations from their most recent meeting, which was November 2nd. And one of those is to, I think, quote, aggressively pursue. Oh, yeah, aggressive. I'm on page 16 now. Quote, aggressively pursue opportunities to advance or use relevant research or capacity to impede pine beetle spread, including research and scaling production of natural predators conducted by the Colorado State Insectory. So the reason I'm bringing this before you is I think if there is going to be an upcoming legislation request or a budget request in the new year, I think this is a good opportunity to bring the folks in from the Insectory and talk to you all about what they're doing, how successful it's been, how much it will cost to do this at scale. Do they believe it can be done at scale. I think this would be just good for you all's information if you do need to ultimately make more decisions about this. I have asked some of these questions to them, and they've provided good responses, but I think they're scientists. I'm not a scientist. It might be easier for them to just come in and talk to you all. Only if they bring thunder.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Thunder. What's Thunder?

Michelle Curryother

Oh, the... That's what they're colloquially calling the beetle. Oh. That's the beetle that's going to kill the other beetles. The enemy species. The enemy species.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

I mean, what could... Are they going to bring us t-shirts? Like, should we wear the pine beetle t-shirt? What could go wrong? Yeah. Do they have, like, little pins that look like pine beetles? I just want to know.

Rick Taggartother

Rep Taggart. They do all need six of those.

Michelle Curryother

JUST A SUGGESTION TO HOLD DOWN COSTS, TO DO THIS BY WAY OF A ZOOM AS COMPARED TO ASKING THE SCIENTISTS TO COME OVER HERE FROM PALISADE. THAT GETS TO BE EXPENSIVE.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

OKAY.

Michelle Curryother

MR. RICKMAN. THANK YOU, MANAGER. AND I HAD THAT SAME THOUGHT AND I SAID THAT TO THE DEPARTMENT ALREADY, THAT IT'S TOTALLY FINE FOR THEM TO DO IT ON ZOOM. I HAVE SOME SAMPLE QUESTIONS AS WELL. but I think we can just add to the hearing agenda

Jana Lockwitness

to have them come and talk to you all. And that's all I have for you today. There is information in their RF I didn't feel the need to include that in this document, but there's more information about the, oh, and I do have a cuts issue as well. Two of the cuts I've identified are continuing to make cuts from the AMF and then also to further reduce the Conservation Division grants that you all produced a little bit last year. And, yeah, that's all I have for you, unless there's further questions.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

You are right on time. Good job. You're early. We're getting done early. Yeah, we're crazy. We've gone crazy today. And the door I was talking about earlier with DOPA is in Sam and Brendan's office. Okay, we don't want you to die in a fire, so we're going to get that fixed. Thank you, committee. We like you. Well, after this presentation, we've decided you can live. There you go. But we might release some fundabeatles into your office. Okay. I think that's it then. We're in recess until 1.30. Okay, great. Woo-hoo. I think you can just leave it there. I don't care. I'm flexible. I'm Gumby. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. who is going to give us a briefing on the Department of Local Affairs.

Michelle Curryother

Ms. Ewell. Thank you, Madam Chair. Andrea Ewell, JBC staff. This is the briefing for the Department of Local Affairs. Since this is one of your first real department briefings of the year, I will walk through all the elements in these documents, but I will do it quickly. So. You can skip over that part.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Which part?

Michelle Curryother

Okay, well, every document starts with an overview. For DOLA, we have four divisions, the Executive Director's Office, Division of Property Taxation, Division of Housing, and Division of Local Government. On the bottom there, you have recent appropriations. As you can see, for DOLA, we had two years in a row of general fund decreases, and that was due to some pretty significant budget balancing work that occurred in this committee. There's a slight increase requested for next year, and we will be covering the reasons why. Page three, graphic overview of every department. DOLA is 0.3% general fund, so very small share of the whole state, and then within the department, general fund makes up about 11% of their total funding. On page four, I found my first typo of the day, which is I switched housing and local government on the top graph. Housing is the largest share of general fund at 66%, followed by local government at 20.5. And then the bottom chart is the distribution of total funds by the division, and that one was correct. On page five, you will see this table in everyone's documents. This is all of the cash fund appropriations in this department with an explanation of what the cash fund does and a note about whether it's continuously appropriated and whether it's TABOR-exempt. As you can see for DOLA, the top five or six cash funds are all continuously appropriated. These are all sources we tend to talk about a lot in here, mostly Prop 123 and the severance and federal mineral lease dollars. They also have a big informational appropriation from the lottery proceeds to the conservation trust fund. And this department does have a lot of cash funds. Moving on to page six, you will see general factors driving the budget for every department. For DOLA a lot of their changes in their budget have been related to the creation of new grant programs So the first table there was ongoing grant programs that exist in DOLA and we have eliminated some of those or they're just now being cut down a little bit or cut down to zero, as you can see. There are still a few remaining, and we're gonna talk about a couple of them today. In the middle there is one-time funded programs, especially in 2024, there were a lot of one-time programs set up, and that's a big issue that we're going to talk about today. At the bottom of page six onto page seven is the Prop 123 funding, and those funds are mostly continuously appropriated to DOLA, but a couple of years ago, Ms. Bickle and I started including them as an informational cash appropriation just so we can better keep track and talk about the funds. And as you can see there on the graph on page seven, the first year was a half of a year of revenue, but ever since then it's been pretty stable but increasing slightly each year. And then DOLA also has a significant portion of federal funds. It's about 22% of the budget. Those mostly don't require state matching, so we don't really talk about their federal funds a lot, and they're only occasionally adjusted. But I don't think they're very volatile except possibly the federal housing vouchers.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So I have just a quick question. So these federal funds, we haven't seen a big impact from the federal government.

Michelle Curryother

They haven't.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

These have not been targeted for reductions, but you said except for the housing vouchers. And could you just talk about that a little bit? I mean, is that a tiny thing or is that?

Michelle Curryother

Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think the housing vouchers, formerly known as Section 8, those are the biggest informational ones shown. I know they have fluctuated, and I think there were some impacts from the federal government. That would probably be a good hearing question if you want to add that, because I haven't really been, like, we haven't followed that as a committee very much. And then they have some more stable federal grants like the community development block grants and community services block grants, and those I think have been pretty stable.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So we'll put that on the agenda.

Michelle Curryother

So page 8, summary of the request. DOLA has nine requests. Eight of them require legislation. A lot of them show up as zero. because they're either just statutory changes or transfers. So I will walk you through each one. There's only one request that costs substantive money, which is R1. So you can see R1, there's more than just the cost shown in the table, and there's an issue on that. So I'll skip over that one for now, and I'll walk through each of these. And all we have for these today is this summary. so if you have additional questions about them, I can maybe answer on the mic, or we can start adding to the hearing agenda. So R2 is related to a loan repayment. So basically, their building regulation fund, which is what does all the permitting and plan review for manufactured housing, that fund was having some solvency issues, even though they did raise fees for that fund the last two Julys. They raised the fees, but they were still having solvency issues. So they had borrowed money from the, they had borrowed $400,000 From this fund in the controller's office called the Cash Fund Solvency Fund, that was created by the JBC several years ago to kind of help the controller make loans to help agencies with cash flows in certain funds. So that loan has to be paid back within three years. And so basically what DOLA is asking is they identified about $350,000 that was sitting around in a defunct cash fund. Sitting around. which was called the Housing Assistance for Persons Transitioning from the Criminal or Juvenile Justice System Cash Fund. And that was created back in 2017, and initially that fund was receiving unspent community corrections appropriations that would go in a fund and then be appropriated later, and it was very confusing. And the JBC ran HB 2012-62 to say, instead of doing that, let's just appropriate money for this purpose. which we have been doing. We've been appropriating $500,000 for housing assistance for these specific types of people who are transitioning from the criminal justice institutions. So apparently, but we're just now noticing, there was $350,000 left in that fund because it was never repealed or swept. And I did ask, the controller is now issuing a report on they're supposed to be finding inactive cash funds, but apparently there was some kind of like transaction or administrative like transaction out of there that caused it to like show up as active instead of inactive. So the controller didn't notice it sooner either. So anyway, they have found $350,000 unused and instead of sending it to the general fund, they would like to send it to the building regulation fund. if they do not send it to the building regulation fund to subsidize that loan repayment, then the building regulation fund will be in the negative at some point during fiscal year 28-29. And they already have raised fees twice. So that is the proposal with R2. And it would take legislation to, first of all, make the transfer. And also, I do think it would be, as long as we're doing it, like probably good to repeal that cash fund from statute. Okay.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

But, I mean, do they not need it in the assistance to released mentally ill offenders? Because like a lot of those people have no place to live. And I don't know whether that's a funding problem or what. But before we transfer it off to something else, I'd like to understand if it's needed in the place where it was originally designed to go.

Michelle Curryother

Thank you, Madam Chair. That's a good question. The appropriation for that purpose in DOLA has been $500,000 general fund a year. And I believe there's another $500,000 reappropriated from the Department of Corrections for this housing support. but as we know for pretty much every type of housing voucher they have, there's always more demand than funding available. So I can put that on their hearing agenda. But also in general, at any point the department could request more funding in that line item, and they never have, but we've never asked them about it explicitly before.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So are we talking about R1?

Michelle Curryother

No, we're on R2.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

WE'RE GOING BACK TO R1, THOUGH. YOU HAVEN'T MISSED IT YET. OKAY. THANK YOU I WAIT THEN I WON ASK A QUESTION I WAIT TO HEAR ABOUT IT Okay We on R3 now Okay Yes moving on to R3 So this is they are requesting money for the 2030 census

Michelle Curryother

What they have requested is a little over $1 million spread out over four years. They have requested this through the creation of a new continuously appropriated cash fund with general fund transfers in statute. I will be up front. I'm not a fan of that system because we're trying to have fewer continuously appropriated cash funds, not more. So I haven't, you know, I'm not disputing the need for funding, but I think they need to figure out how to get an annual appropriation and correctly meter that over four years. Senator Kirkmeyer.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Well, I would agree with that 100% because it's about transparency for us and to be able to see what's going on. But don't we get money from the feds with regard to the census? I thought they did.

Michelle Curryother

Ms. Yule. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer, it's, there is, I'm not sure that they directly give us money, but they give, they will give support to states. But most states are doing a lot of work, like, in partnership with the feds for every census. So basically it's like people from the demographer's office are already kind of starting up having to do certain things to prepare for the census. And then most states do end up adding, like, temporary staff during the census years to help work on it. So for the 2020 census, DOLA had a decision item for fiscal year 1920. They hired one term limited employee, and that person is, I think, the point person with the feds, and then they help with outreach and support. And in addition to that, for the 2020 census, the General Assembly created a grant program that gave DOLA $6.1 million and one and a half FTE to basically give out funds to all of the local communities to also advertise the census. there was also after that the bill that created the grant program directed them to do a strategic action plan for the 2030 census so there's actually quite a lot of information in there and the recommendations in that report were that dola should start earlier on the ramp up efforts and this time around the this money would mostly it's going towards two fte instead of one And they also, I think the report basically said that it would be better to have more centralized planning coming out of DOLA than to give a lot more money out to locals because then the efforts aren't as well coordinated and you could have like overlapping or underwhelming efforts like if it's not as well planned. so right now all of the information in the action plan is what they've come up with to ask for this money to hire these two employees and hire them sooner and keep them a little longer on both ends than they did last time you know and DOLA has said like they you know they are not asking for a grant program this time around yet like I don't know if anyone in the general assembly will want to do that but like not knowing that aspect they feel that it very important at a minimum to have like those two term limited employees in the state demographers office for the census Because in absent that any work on the census is pulling regular full employees substantially away from their regular job and the demography office isn that big

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

What would be their regular job in the demography office if it isn't to do this?

Michelle Curryother

That's actually what part of the thing they're supposed to be doing.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

So I think we actually should find out from them what they've done as far as talking with the feds, as far as what the feds are going to give the states to help carry out their responsibility of getting the census count done. You know, that's the federal government. So they should be figuring out how to pay us to help them get their job done, not us figuring it out. And I'm glad to hear they're not asking for the grant program because, again, that should go back to local communities. I know cities and counties were able to put in funds in their local areas to help get the count done, but it was a person that was working for the federal government that came and was organizing, for example, up in Weld County, So we had like Weld County and a meeting with our 31 municipalities and them to start getting it organized. Because it behooves the cities and the counties to get that done. It also behooves Department of Local Affairs. But can't they use money out of like their CSBG or their CDBG dollars to help fund people to go out and do census stuff? I bet they could figure out maybe they should learn how to be creative. because I bet they could figure out how to use those dollars that they get to them. They've got their emergency shelter grant funds as well that they could use to go after it. Okay.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So those are some questions. I mean, I'm looking at this, and I'm thinking this is just the beginning. They're going to ask for actually the whole amount that they had last time, and they're just starting with this to get things, the ball rolling. So it would be good to understand exactly who's doing what. And there's a return, presumably, on this investment. If we do a better job of counting all the people, then we get more federal dollars somehow. CSBG and CDBG and ESG. So maybe if we could understand what that is.

Rep. Tiger. Thank you, Madam Chair. And I appreciate you already talked about the continuously appropriated. I just find that in relationship to very exact numbers a bit puzzling.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

If you're going to be that exact for a given year, why would you need, I don't know, it just seems a little odd to me. Okay. All right.

Thank you.

Michelle Curryother

Madam Chair, Rep. Taggart, the exactness of the numbers does have to do with the fact that it's mostly employee costs they use like a template to calculate it exactly but I agree if they're able to calculate it so exactly we should be able to annually appropriate it one year at a time there is also a note here they said on average based on our population the federal funds we get each color addon is bringing in two thousand three hundred dollars in federal funding per year and they did the math that if if we count 45 extra people and that's kind of valid for 10 years of the census, that the request would pay for itself. But I know that the department does have a lot more information that they would, I think, be happy to share and explain as the basis for this request. So we'll put everything you asked on the hearing agenda.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. All right. Moving on.

Rick Taggartother

Oh Rep Brown Thank you Madam Chair CONTINUOUSLY APPROPRIATED WE DON GENERALLY like that Please can you ask them to please justify why the heck they

Michelle Curryother

I mean, there are continuously appropriated funds. We generally don't like it, but they're going to need a pretty strong case in order for us to think about that. If you can ask them to justify that, that'd be great.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Our fourth. I just wanted to be clear. I'm not even thinking about continuously appropriated. I mean, that's a no-go for me. Okay.

Michelle Curryother

Ms. Yule, our four. Thank you, Madam. And I basically already told them that, too, because I was not convinced either. Long bill reorganization, this has several components. I'll just walk through them really quick. So they want several things. The first that I think is going to warrant more discussion is they want to combine the line items for Fort Lyon and Ridgeview into one so they have flexibility because their justification is that they're providing very similar service. They're structured similarly. If they underspend in one, they should be able to move money between them. In my experience looking back at Fort Lyon, they seem very good at spending pretty much exactly what's appropriated every year, and they've never had a supplemental request to operate Fort Lyon. Ridgeview is obviously newer, and it just is now fully open, so it's unclear how close the expenditures are coming into the operating costs there. And Fort Lyon is funded by the General Fund. Ridgeview is funded by their Affordable Housing Support Fund from Prop 123, which was the JBC's doing. That fund could also be used for Fort Lyon if it needed to. Also, there are some pretty big capital issues with Fort Lyon that you're going to hear about during the capital briefing, like basically questioning if its existence is even viable because of some of the capital problems. So, yeah, this one, you know, I think we'll need to investigate this one more before figure setting.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. I agree, and also just, you know, for the department to respond to at some point, I have also heard that there are problems with the two different entities that are running Sage Ridge and some effort maybe to do it differently, and so I don't know that this is the year to combine those things. I think we want to be able to look at them separately. And they do have slightly different things that they do. Anyway, I want to understand what the operational challenges have been. Would you like me to put that on the hearing agenda?

Michelle Curryother

Yeah.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

The second thing they're asking for here is kind of redoing the lines

Michelle Curryother

in which they reflect appropriations for the affordable housing grants and loans and low-income rental subsidies, which I think probably makes sense. There are some footnotes in the long bill kind of about how they – the appropriations and the expenditures maybe aren't super well aligned, and these are pretty confusing programs, so I think looking at which line items, which costs are in is warranted, and that doesn't take legislation, so I'll revisit that at figure setting. THE THIRD BULLET POINT WOULD TAKE LEGISLATION. SO THEY ARE WANTING TO REVISIT APPROPRIATING THE ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS RELATED TO PROP 123 AND THE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT GRANT FUND. THAT WAS SOMETHING ME AND MS. BICKLE WENT THROUGH WITH THE two sessions ago, and it was the reason we started appropriating these costs was because we felt we needed more oversight kind of on the breakdown of funds for Prop 123, and because we did, we also added Ridgeview as an expenditure that is annually appropriated, whereas the bulk of Prop 123 is still continuously appropriated. so there were some reasons we did that but the department does raise valid issues that the appropriated costs are based on a forecast so to the extent it's changing a lot that causes problems and the appropriated cap can be different than the statutory cap the statutory cap for Prop 123 is 3% and those are valid arguments and it was extremely difficult to figure this all out for the long bill But on the flip side to that is, do we necessarily think they need to be spending more on administrative costs every time there's a fluctuation in their funds? So this is something I'm going to be looking at more in depth for figure setting. They would also like to rearrange and restructure the subdivisions within division of local government to better reflect the operations, which I think is probably a good idea because, to be honest, the subdivision layout has never made a lot of sense to me for DOLA, and they've had a lot of programs added in over the years. So we're going to kind of look at redoing some of that within division of local government, which would purely just be for long-bill organization to better match, like, their core reports and stuff in the long-bill to how they actually operate.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

What exactly are those restructures of subdivisions? Ms. Ewell.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Senator Kirkmeyer, there's a different subdivision with the federal,

Jana Lockwitness

like the block grants and some of the programs too, like the firefighter stuff, the death and disability stuff, but then field services is the big subdivision where we've just kind of dumped most new line items. So there's like just the layout and where we've been placing them is probably not optimal. That's what they want to revisit. There's a subdivision called community and local government services, and then also local.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So you'll just work on that with them?

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah. And then the last thing is that they would like in the long bill to, I think, identify. It turns out there's two expenditures happening out of their severance and federal mineral lease money that personally I didn't know about, but apparently these have been around for a long time. there's $66,000 going to the Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Management and $326,000 going to the Division of Hazardous Waste Materials and Waste Management in CDPHE. I'm not sure the history of those or what the money's for or if it's still necessary, so I'll look into that also with those analysts and if we do still need to be spending that money, I think showing it as some kind of reappropriation or appropriation with a reappropriation will help us keep track of it better.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So that probably makes sense. I'd like to know what it's for.

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah. I can have them address that at the hearing if you want.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

That would be great. Rep. Brown.

Jana Lockwitness

Ms. Yule, thank you.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Can you tell, why is it not reflected in the long bill? Ms. Yule.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you Madam Chair Mr Vice Chair I believe that it reflected as reappropriations in those two agencies but in DOLA the expenditures out of those funds are continuously appropriated So I think the allowable use was put into statute somewhere a long time ago by a bill that just basically probably said, like, these agencies can spend, like, this money from DOLA's funds for this item, but because it's continuously appropriated the way it was structured, I think just never reflected it leaving DOLA. I'm wondering if for the public health, I'm sorry, Madam Chair.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Senator Kirkmeyer. Thank you. I'm wondering, though, if for the health department, if that's the till mining, the issue with the till, the mill, you know, over on.

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

It's on your side of the mountain. Sorry.

Jana Lockwitness

No, but I think we used to have to fund that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

No, I'm just saying.

Jana Lockwitness

I think that's what that's for. Just my guess.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

But I'd like to know.

Jana Lockwitness

We'll find out.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yeah.

Jana Lockwitness

Because the 65,000 might be a holdover from when OEM was at DOLA. Anyway.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

R5. R5. This one is related to a cash fund in the Division of Property Taxation, the Board of Assessment Appeals, that hears property valuation appeals. And what they are asking for is basically permanent one-year roll forward authority, and their justification is that because of the every-other-year reassessment cycle that the expenditures from this fund are going up and down every year. with the number of appeals. I think, so in this line item, there's about $850,000 appropriated each year, and about 70% of that is from the general fund, but what they're asking for would be more flexibility, basically, for the cash component. A couple, I think two sessions ago, when Ms. Bickle was working on this with me, they had a request related to this where they had more money than they needed in that cash fund and hired an extra person that I think they had been contracting work out, so they hired another staff person, which was approved by the JBC. But I think I will be discussing more with them whether roll forward is truly necessary because it is very hard to track. It becomes harder to track cash fund expenditures when there's roll forward. And putting it in statute takes a bill. The alternative would be a permanent footnote, basically saying every year when they get an appropriation, they can spend that for two years. But I would also still like to explore with them whether I know it's a pain for departments to adjust cash fund asks up and down every year. But if it's really going up and down every year, could it be a technical adjustment to that cash fund expenditure every year? Because we know it's going to keep going up and down. So there are some options there I'd like to explore.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Rep Garcia. Thank you, Madam Chair. do you have an idea of how much of what's appropriated every year is actually spent every year? Ms. Yule.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Garcia, they're saying that they're spending it all, basically, and that sometimes the cash appropriation is not enough, and I think they've been allowed a little bit of over-expenditure authority under the controller because the controller can approve like small amounts of cash over So yeah they saying but so they saying yeah the appropriation you know isn enough and it too volatile but also we could give them a higher cash appropriation with a buffer So, but, and they spend all the general fund, I think, every year.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

And I think there might also be a question of, could we lower the general fund appropriation and have them spend more cash if they have more cash. Good question to ask them. We'll look into all of that for figure setting. On page 10, R6 is related to the Disaster Resilience and Rebuilding Program. So this program was created in Senate Bill 22206 with a one-time $15 million transfer into a continuously appropriated cash fund. And this was primarily related to helping victims of the Marshall Fire. So over several years, they paid a lot of that out to help with low-interest loans and rebuilding and mitigation measures. And they had basically awarded most of the money out. And then some money did come back in. Apparently some reimbursements from the CDBG disaster recovery grants flowed through the fund and also some interest, and there's some loan repayment money that comes back in, but not very much. But there is a $3.9 million balance in there right now. And basically what they're asking for is a permanent exemption from the 16.5% cash fund reserve requirement, because if by statute, if a cash fund carries a reserve of more than 16.5% compared to their expenditures, if they do that three years in a row, they get in trouble with the state controller, and the state controller can restrict their funds and say you have to be on a plan to spend down your balance. And what Dole is saying here is they purposely want to have this balance because they think that they're going to want to spend it for the Aspen Acres fires and potentially the floods that just happened in southwest Colorado. And there is, for the statute, around the 16.5% limit, there is a long list of funds that are exempt from that, and there are several disaster-related funds already on that list. So they're basically saying we would like this cash fund on the list. if we don't do that, the alternative is they could end up on that controller's naughty list and have to get on a plan to spend the money down, which they're saying they're accruing it on purpose, or we would just have to do a cash fund waiver over and over and over again. So I think this is probably a valid ask.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay, so I have a question, though, because I don't know. I don't remember which bill I was on. I think I might have had something to do with this. but I thought it had a limited time frame. You were on it with Fenberg? Yeah, that's what I thought. I thought it had some limited amount of time that it was for, but that might have been a different bill, but it looked back to a disaster that happened. I think it included the East Troublesome Fire folks and then the Marshall Fire people, but it wasn't meant to go on forever. but I might be misremembering that.

Jana Lockwitness

Madam Chair my understanding is that it had a date specifying four disasters that happened after I think it was like 2018 or something but I don believe there was like an end date to the fund in statute so it is kind of ongoing and they do also have related general funded staff in the Colorado resiliency office that kind of help administer this okay I just it seems like a little bit weird to

Representative Garciaassemblymember

to just have this $3.9 million sitting out there with no exact purpose? Because we, I mean, I don't know that it was set up to be, you know, some kind of fund that would grow and then be used to support disasters. That's not my recollection of what it was doing. Ms. Ewell, amen.

Jana Lockwitness

Madam Chair, I think my understanding is that it, the statute says, like, like the fund continues to exist and that it can be used for eligible future disasters. So I think that was envisioned, and I think it was left in statute like that in case there was another big disaster and the General Assembly wanted to put another big transfer of money into it, then the infrastructure here would be in place to basically do a similar thing for the next big disaster. and since it's still sitting in statute and I think probably a little more money has come back to them than they thought they will be able to help a little bit assuming Aspen Acres and the flooding will be I think eligible disasters under what was in the bill Thanks Madam Chair and I think we're getting towards maybe the answers to my questions but I would like the department to address sort of what they plan to do with this money for Aspen Acres as well as for the floods and how that compares with what they did for the Marshall Fire.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

And if we're going to run legislation, we might as well fix or modify the purpose of this bill. If there's any restrictions on it that would keep them from being able to do the things that Pagosa Springs needed, for example, that would be helpful to know as well. Okay. Moving up. Rep. Garcia. Thank you. How much would it be if it was in complaint with the 16.5%? Ms. Yule.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair. Rep. Garcia, it would be a very low balance. I think actually, and there's a minimum of $200,000, and it's because there are some years they haven't made any expenditure out of the fund, so then they would have a maximum of a $200,000 balance, and there were a couple years where the expenditures were basically zero.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. All right. R7. R7.

Jana Lockwitness

This is for the Rural Economic Development Initiative, or READY grant program. This is a grant program that's been around for quite a while. It was, for a long time, $780,000 a year from the general fund. We reduced it to $500,000 for budget balancing purposes for the current fiscal year. This program provides grants for rural communities to develop plans and projects that create jobs, drive capital investment, and diversify their economies. There are some examples of recent projects listed there. A reduction of $115,000 would probably result in two fewer projects awarded a year. The projects are usually between, I think, $50,000 and $150,000. dollars. The exact number they asked for, I have a feeling they were possibly trying to hit some sort of target for So obviously this request was put in before the results of the ballot initiative, so, you know, but this is, you know, their grant balancing option that they put forth prior to the new news about the economic outlook. Are there any questions about this one?

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Rep Taggart. Thank you, Madam Chair and Ms. Yule. I don't think it's going to surprise you coming from the rural part of Colorado. This is not one I'd like to see. Rural Colorado is suffering right now and take another $115,000, which isn't a lot of money, but it is two grants. I'd rather than find it someplace else than here. Rep. Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. You have some detail in your brief here about what these projects include, but I think maybe a little more detailed list of the projects they've funded over the last couple years and what communities those have gone to and whatnot. That might help us understand a little bit more about the impact that these cuts might have. Okay. I mean, I'll just say I hear you, and I just wonder if I feel like these little, a little money here and a little money there and here a grant, there a grant, everywhere a grant, isn't actually solving a problem. And so what is the struggle and what is the amount of money that's needed to address the struggle and how can we get that to the people that need it? It would be a better way to go just writ large all throughout this budget. And I get why this happens, but it just doesn't seem very efficient. I mean, we've already just spent $115,000 talking about it. You know what I mean? So I don't know. I'd like us to try to figure out a way to actually have a bigger impact with the money that we spend. But that's a conversation maybe for another day.

Jana Lockwitness

Ms. Yule. Would you like this on their presentation hearing agenda to hear more about?

Representative Garciaassemblymember

OR I COULD JUST HAVE THEM ATTACH THE GRANT AWARD DETAIL TO THE WRITTEN ONLY RESPONSES, WHICHEVER YOU. SURE. AS LONG AS THEY'RE GOING TO TELL US HOW MANY JOBS THEY'RE ACTUALLY CREATING AND WHAT KIND OF CAPITAL INVESTMENT THEY'VE ACTUALLY DRIVEN AND HOW THEY'VE DIVERSIFIED THE ECONOMIES IN ANY GRANTS THAT THEY'VE GIVEN OUT. THAT'S WHAT IT SAYS THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO BE DOING. SO I MEAN, I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY JOBS A COMMUNITY ARTS CENTER WOULD ACTUALLY CREATE AND HOW THAT WOULD DIVERSIFY THE ECONOMY. I MEAN, YOU KNOW, I'D LIKE TO TRY AND PROTECT WORLD COLORADO AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE ALSO, BUT, YOU KNOW, I AGREE WITH SENATOR MOBLEY. WE HAVE ALL THESE LITTLE SMALL GRANT PROGRAM HERE, LITTLE SMALL GRANT PROGRAM HERE. THERE'S A BUNCH OVER IN O-EDIT. I MEAN, THEY'RE ALL OVER THE PLACE. AND WHAT ARE THEY ACTUALLY ACCOMPLISHING? AND ARE THEY ACTUALLY CREATING JOBS, DRIVING CAPITAL INVESTMENT, AND DIVERSIFYING THE ECONOMIES? OR ARE WE JUST MAKING COMMUNITIES FEEL GOOD ABOUT THEMSELVES? I mean, we might be better off putting the money into infrastructure improvements to their highways that go right down Main Street. I don't know. Same. Because there's that grant program, too. Yeah. Okay. R8.

Jana Lockwitness

R8. This is basically like a budget balancing request, and it's similar to one we had last year but less confusing. It is also a revolving loan fund IT WAS CREATED BY SENATE BILL 22 which transferred million into this revolving loan fund This one is administered directly by DOLA within the department which is different from the one last year for the mobile home parks. That was a little more confusing because it was administered by outside parties. So for this one, basically what has happened is that the fund, because it was spent down slowly, accrued a lot of interest. Some of that interest they already re-granted back out, but they're still expecting more to come in in the future, and there's also a little bit of money coming back from some types of loans that were made. They make several different types of loans from this fund, and only some of them have like payments, repayments certain coming back in, some of them don't. So just based on all the cash flows that they're looking at, they have offered up 2.3 million dollars for budget balancing next year and then basically they would say put in statute for the next four years after that 1.8 million dollars from this fund to the general fund and the loan the fund will continue revolving in the future they make new loans as they're able if the general assembly does not take this option for budget balancing they estimate based on the types of work this fund does they estimate that 380 more affordable housing units could be created or preserved with this money it's 9.6 million total over what they're proposing so it's 9.6 million basically that we could use for budget balancing or let it continue in the revolving loan fund okay

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Questions? Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

After that, there's some of the common policy items, as you can see, on 10 and 11. And then on the bottom of page 11, we have the explanation of their statewide decision item related to severance tax funding. So what they are proposing this year is for DOLA, a $10 million transfer from the Decarbonization Tax Credits Administration Fund back to DOLA's local government severance tax fund. If this is not approved, they estimate that their fund will be over encumbered by $5.9 million during quarter two of next year. As you'll remember from back in June, the fiscal year 26 severance tax collections came in worse than we thought, and this fund has been used for a lot of budget balancing measures. Specifically, HB 26-1405 did a $19.4 million transfer on July 1st, and there's a $27.3 million transfer that will happen on June 30th. So that's $46.7 million from that fund that was used for balancing. because of the way the projections changed between March and June, you had to do a June interim supplemental to basically do a general fund swap of 4.4 million to help keep them out of the negative, closing the fiscal year. I had written in here on the bottom of page 11 that they ended the fiscal year over-encumbered with 14.7 million. Once I revisited that with the department, they realized they had a mistake on their end in some of their spreadsheets. So the 14.7 million is wrong. They said they actually ended fiscal year 26 pretty close to zero, which was the goal of the general fund swap we did, was to keep them way out of the red So they did end it and that pretty close to zero but the what their estimate that they be 5 million dollars over encumbered again next year does is still accurate based on the numbers as they

Representative Garciaassemblymember

are right now so question yes senator by over encumbered do they mean that they contracted it out already or that they just grant did a grant miss you um thank Thank you, Madam Chair.

Jana Lockwitness

Senator Kirkmeyer, it's contracted out, but they would only hit, it's not an actual cash deficit unless everyone who they contracted out to, you know, called it in at the exact same time. So they did just specify for me, they're over-obligated, but it's not necessarily a cash deficit. and they I think are expecting to have to talk more about these projections during the hearing if you would like me to just

Representative Garciaassemblymember

sure and when they talk about them I'd like to know how much money they have in their loan program that they do out of their severance of mineral dollars because they have a loan program that they have money that comes back into and why can't they just go use that thank you Madam Chair and Ms. Ewell you may have said You may have said this already, but I don't have a good enough understanding of what the local government severance tax fund does. I assume it funds local governments for something. That's about all I got. So I could use a little bit more information for that. So thank you. So I'll just add, or I have a question about what you said about the $14.7 million was wrong. Was that like a typo, or that was just a bad estimate? So we gave them a supplemental in June, and was that based on the 14.7 wrong number?

Jana Lockwitness

Madam Chair, so the 14.7 wrong number was in some data tables submitted with their request for this, and so it was some typo in their spreadsheet from them that flowed through wrong. for just the fiscal year 26 ending balance. So what we did in June was correct, and it did have the intended goal of basically bringing them to zero at the close of the fiscal year. Because I saw this, and I was like, 14.7 million in the red.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

I thought we fixed this, and so once we looked at it some more, they realized there was an error.

Jana Lockwitness

And to rep Brown, I'll have them talk more about this, But overall, this fund, it gets 70% pooled into a grant program that they refer to as the Energy and Mineral Impact Fund money, and it gets combined and pooled up with federal mineral lease money for, like, infrastructure grants to local governments, like drinking water and sewer stuff are a big use of it. And then 30% of it is distributed to local governments based on a formula. So we did the digital trunk radio system out of these funds. But we want to know everything, not just their energy impact grant funds, because I think they use the funds for other little programs here and there, little special things that they like to do. So, and then there is the loan program within that as well. That's water and sewer projects typically. That's been in effect for a very long time. So we'd like to know.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

But on the, may I ask a question? Yes, of course. Thank you. Before we get going. So they want to transfer from the decarbonization tax credit administration fund. Didn't we put money into that?

Jana Lockwitness

Ms. Ewell. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer to be totally honest with you I cannot explain the decarbonization tax credits administration fund very well I know You had a really weird chart with it I remember But my takeaway is that basically there money that goes into that fund and then if it's above what they need, it goes to the general fund anyway. So I don't believe there would be a material difference between taking it from that fund to DOLA or just amending the general fund, the transfer from DOLA to the general fund that we already put in statute by $10 million,

Representative Garciaassemblymember

you would get the same outcome as far as I understand it. But I know that I think this flow of funds is more material to the DNR component perhaps,

Jana Lockwitness

and that Ms. Shen is probably going to be talking about it more in depth. But one of us will be able to explain it by figure setting, hopefully.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

I do think a couple of years ago, we put money into the decarbonization tax credit fund. Like we had to help bail them out or something. I don't know. That was a Hanson bill. I don't know that anybody can explain it. I'm not even sure Hanson could explain it. I don't remember him explaining it very well on the Senate floor at any rate. But so, yeah, I guess we need to know the history too. Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

Ms. Ewell. Thank you, Madam Chair. Or should I, I can have DOLA attempt to explain a bit of the history. Maybe we just get rid of the decarbonization tax credits. Well, I believe that fund is expiring after this year anyway, but it's there and there was also a bill that amended it last year.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

And yeah, I'm not totally. Maybe that was our bill. Maybe it was last year we did that. I don't know. I know we put money in it. Okay. Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

That brings us to R1 on page 13. Okay, so basically this is like a bundled request related to three bills from 2024 that all created programs related to housing affordability through land use reform. And those were Senate Bill 24-174, Sustainable Affordable Housing Assistance, HB 1152, Accessory Dwelling Units, and HB 1313, Housing and Transit Oriented Communities. So all three of these bills were funded by one-time transfers into the programs. Of those, only Senate Bill 174, the fiscal note did estimate a need for ongoing costs. The other two...

Representative Garciaassemblymember

It has the word sustainable in its name. But I was on that bill with Senzinger, and it was never supposed to be general fund money. Just saying. Sorry.

Jana Lockwitness

So, yeah, for, you know, 174, it was funded with a $15 million transfer from the, it was a combination of severance. It was like $10 million severance. Yeah, and $5 million federal mineral. So, I should make a note of that, that perhaps there was an argument that the ongoing costs should be paid out of there.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

But as we know. Where did they stop the program?

Jana Lockwitness

It wasn't supposed to be a grant program going on forever. Yeah, so on page 14, the summary, in my understanding of 174, is that some of the components don't have a statutory end date. So the two bullets there on the top of page 14 talk about how the bill requires local governments to conduct, publish, and submit housing needs assessments and housing action plans, every six years in perpetuity, and housing assistance plans, progress reports every three years, and comprehensive plan elements every five years. So they're basically saying because of all those staggered deadlines that are ongoing that they still need, it's a little over $600,000 a year ongoing basically for staff in DLG to keep reviewing these elements. and then the department is required to do a statewide housing needs assessment every six years and maintain guidance documents, provide technical assistance, assistance with the data they need to do these reports and provide ongoing courtesy and compliance reviews. The fiscal note did identify, so there was like a big grant component cost but also the ongoing technical assistance aspect. So the fiscal note identified $586,000 in six FTE starting in 2627 that might be needed based on the ongoing aspects. So what they're asking for is pretty much in alignment with that, other than you could debate whether it should be the general fund or the energy mineral impact funds again. but then on top of that is they're asking for $1.2 million through a transfer into this continuously appropriated cash fund and they state that the funds are for grants not yet awarded and staff to award new grants, manage existing grants and provide technical assistance I do have a question of why if they're out of money already they don't not award new grants they could not award new grants potentially and let's see, and the grant related aspect of this bill is expected to be over by December 2030 so basically there's 1.2 million dollars related to the grants and that has an end date and that was supposed to be one time funding and then there's what they've identified as ongoing statutory requirements that they're asking for over $600,000 a year for in perpetuity so that's part one PART OF...

Representative Garciaassemblymember

REP TAGGERT.

Michelle Curryother

THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. MS. EWLE, I GUESS WHAT PUZZLES ME ON THIS $600,000 IS WE'VE GOT A GRANT FUND THAT IS COMING DOWN IN TERMS OF ITS TOTAL BALANCE AND HAS GONE, IF I'M READING THIS directly in 3031, but what's remaining static through this whole period of time is $600,000 for administration. As the fund comes down, it shouldn't require as much administration, and so we've got to fix cost against a variable fund. It doesn't make a great deal of sense to me.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Ms. Yule.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair. Rep Tagger, they're tying the $600,000 to the staff to do these two bullet points, which is like the rolling review on page 14, like the rolling review of these deadlines of local governments having to submit planning documents to them every six years, every three years, every five years, and then there's a report the department does every six years. So they're basically saying that aspect is not related to the grant program that was one time and being drawn down. It related to having to have like basically land use planners on the staff in perpetuity to do those aspects Well so the 600 approximately in the 6 FTE are to for the statewide housing needs assessment that's supposed to be done every six years, because it shouldn't be tied to the local government. I mean, that's the part that stops, because the grants stop. It wasn't supposed to be more than 15 million either.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Ms. Yule.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer, I think DOLA is interpreting it as, even though the grants end, that the local governments have to keep doing these documents. Yes, but we don't have to come that. I'm sure they can speak to it at the hearing. I assume they would need to just, yeah, so they can talk about how they are interpreting the statute. I need to make sure I'm here. It's the Tuesday after Thanksgiving. Okay, great. Because that's not what the legislation was supposed to be doing. We had a lot of discussion about it with the governor's office. I understand they might need something to continue doing the statewide housing needs assessment that has to be done every six years, but they just put one out, so they don't have to do another one for another six years.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

We're on accessory dwelling units.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yes.

Jana Lockwitness

The next aspect is the accessory dwelling unit bill. This was funded with a one-time transfer of $5 million from the general fund to the accessory dwelling unit, fee reduction and encouragement grant program fund, which is not continuously appropriated. There was also an $8 million transfer to Oedit, but that is not material to this request. So because that fund is subject to annual appropriation, it has been in the long bill. I did so to date we've already appropriated over $5 million in the long bill but they had indicated especially in 25-26 the cash appropriation was much higher than they needed and nobody caught it and they hadn't spent all that money before figure setting last year I did question the spend down of this program and they showed me a plan that totaled $5 million through fiscal year 28-29 I guess I didn't at the time think to question them about the following two years but I was certainly surprised to see a request for more money for this program especially because there had been questions from this committee about taking back some of the money during budget balancing the last two years anyway so they are saying that they need 1.8 million dollars more which would come from the transfer and the request and go into that cash fund and that would allow them to spend through fiscal year 3031, and this program does have statutory end dates. They state that the costs for this program are, they're statutorily required to provide guidance and technical assistance, a toolkit and educational materials, compliance review, grant making, grant management, and assistance to grantees. I'm on the top of page 15 now. They do say that the grant program aspect is hard to predict because they basically are, it's like a promise to pay back the fees for like ADU that local governments are charging for ADU. So they don't have a great way of estimating how many people are going to, you know, engage with the program and file the paperwork for doing an ADU that their local government then has to waive and get paid back for So they said that made it hard to predict And then also there are jurisdictions that weren required to do this but they can voluntarily opt in to being a certified ADU supportive jurisdiction. And they can opt in at any time, and there's no deadline by which they have to opt in. And so it's really, Dole is saying, between all of that and And for all three of these programs in general, just the amount of technical assistance the local governments need to understand the programs and participate in them has been, I think, much higher than expected. And technical assistance counts as, like, administrative time. So that is what they're saying about this one. I did also have a note in here, and this is something I noticed when this bill was in appropriations two years ago, that it started as $10 million for the program, and that was cut in half without, like, any other changes. So I had always wondered if they might say, actually, we needed more money. So anyway, that's what I have for that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay, so I have a couple of questions about that. First of all, I'd love to understand, well, how many units got built with this fee reduction money? How much went to actually local governments to not charge the fees versus how much money got spent on advising and whatnot-ing? And then you said there was $8 million that wasn't impacted by this. And if we could just understand what is that paying for? I thought that we had some loans or some other program that was going to help people who were low income build an ADU. And I'd just love to understand, did this program cause us to build more ADUs or not?

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Senator Kirkmeyer. And we'd like to know who got the money, the $5 million. And we'd like to know how much is actually left of the $8 million that's over in OEdit. Not only what have they done with it, but how much is left. Because it was supposed to be one time. And so I don't care if it started out at $10 million. It got cut to five, and that was one time. So learn how to manage, and when you've spent all the money, it's gone. And the change in law was supposed to actually have the bigger impact on whether people built ADUs or not. Well, people were already building ADUs. So, our entities, local governments were already building ADUs and already had programs for them. Rep Taggart.

Michelle Curryother

Not all of them.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Rep Taggart.

Michelle Curryother

All the big ones. Thank you, Madam Chair.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Ms. Ewell again.

Michelle Curryother

I'm not understanding the math here that the department's giving us, because it was initially a one-time transfer of $5 million. They've already allocated $5.1 million, which would have put them in the negative. And they're saying they have $435,000 less left, excuse me. And they need $1.8 million. The math is... Not math. It's not. Not mapping. No, it's not. I'm just trying to figure this thing out. IF I COULD HAVE THIS, THAT I GET 5 MILLION, BUT I COULD SPEND 5.1 MILLION, AND I CAN GET AN INDITIONAL 435, OR I HAVE AN ADDITIONAL 435 I WOULD LIKE TO SIGN UP FOR THIS IMMEDIATELY MS HUMEL SENATOR AMAVILLE REP TAGGR THAT IS BECAUSE THE 5 MILLION IS BECAUSE I would like to sign up for this immediately Senator Amovale Rep Tiger that is because the million is because that is what we appropriated but they didn spend it

Jana Lockwitness

So between what was appropriated in the bill and then the first two long bills, it summed to more than $5.1 million. And I noticed in the second year I was like, and it's, I think, I suspect, because initially the bill started as a continuously appropriated cash fund, and that switched at the end. So I think they weren't probably proactive about, like, worrying about the cash fund appropriation. And the long bill, it sort of just was on autopilot with the fiscal note instead of their actual spending plan. So that's how the appropriation ended up already exceeding $5 million. But, yeah, so basically they're saying starting next year they'll have $435,000 left, and they think they need to spend another $1.8 million basically over the next four years. So overall what they're asking is a $4.4 million transfer from the general fund, and it would go, so this is on page 13, at the bottom of page 13. So the top row on that table is the appropriated part they're asking for of the $600,000 for $174 that we already talked about. The next three rows are the components of the transfer. So basically they want a one-time transfer totaling to $4.4 million from the general fund. $1.2 million would go into the fund for $174. $1.8 million would go into this ADU grant program fund, and we would have to appropriate that back out in the long bill every year. And then they want $1.36 million to go to the House Bill 1313 cash fund, which is continuously appropriated. And they have also, with this request, identified an offsetting transfer of $3.8 million. in the Infrastructure and Strong Communities cash fund that we could transfer to the general fund to offset it, or transfer to the general fund anyway, obviously, because that fund is expiring. And that one is because this program, this other program in Division of Local Government, there was a grantee that had money awarded, and then their projects stalled, and there were some federal issues. So that's how $3.8 million just recently became available in that fund. and that program repeals in December, so no matter what, that money is going to...

Representative Garciaassemblymember

This December?

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah. Like now.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

So that's going to revert.

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah, so that money is available. The $3.8 million is, like, available no matter what.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yeah, to balance the budget. It's going to the...

Jana Lockwitness

They're proposing sending it to the general fund, and they are proposing thinking of it as an offset to this request.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

You can think of it however you want.

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Senator Kirkmeyer.

Jana Lockwitness

I'm sorry, were you finished?

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Where was the, what was the Infrastructure and Strong Communities Cash Fund tied to? Which bill?

Jana Lockwitness

Which program?

Barbara Kirkmeyerother

Ms. Yule.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Kirkmeyer, it was a bill and program with that same name from, I think, 2022, and I cannot explain what that one did. But it's over. Yeah, that was like a one-time ARPA swap-funded program. All of these were basically supposed to be one time. That's what they said when we were in local government. Okay.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Next up, 1313.

Jana Lockwitness

Yes, so 1313 was funded with a one-time transfer of $35 million from the General Fund to the continuously appropriated Transit-Oriented Communities Infrastructure Fund. That bill basically established criteria for communities to designate transit centers and neighborhood centers. DOLE has to approve those designations. And then there's a grant program to assist the local governments with planning, community engagement, and infrastructure projects that benefit affordable housing, transit centers, and neighborhood centers. They are expecting the final grants to be awarded in this fiscal year, but the projects won't be completed until 2030 when all the, this one does have, I think, repealing deadlines. And so basically they are asking for $1.4 million more to, and this one would be to basically subsidize the program starting in fiscal year 29, 30, and 31, because they expect to run out of administrative funding during fiscal year 29. So there would be two years of unfunded technical assistance and overhead costs. And this one, they did have a 6% statutory funding cap just based on the $35 million transfer in. They do know that they have 3.7 FTE for this program, and that is lower than 5.7 estimated in the fiscal note. But again, they have not been able to stretch the funding as far as they thought.

Rep Brown. I mean, I really don't understand why. Maybe they can tell us a little bit more about why their administrative funding ran out so quickly. I also, maybe you can help me, Ms. Ewell, understand why, like this, we're talking about 27-28 budget. They're talking about money that we would then apply to future years. They want us to put this money into a fund, into this existing fund, and then kind of earmark it for future years for their administrative costs that they weren't able to maintain or that they underestimated? I mean, which is it? Did they overspend? I mean, what happened here?

Jana Lockwitness

Ms. Jewell. Thank you, Madam Chair. Rep. Brown, yeah, I think for all three of these, I think they're basically saying, like, they were really focused on meeting all the statutory deadlines. And that doing that caused them to, and meeting the statutory deadlines and prioritizing giving out grant money, but then, yeah, that caused them to basically run through the money faster than they had planned. The reason we're talking about fiscal years going out through 2031 is because they want, you know, for two of the three, it's going to go into a continuously appropriated cash fund. But then, as you note, like, they would have to correctly meter that through fiscal year 31.

That seems like a tough sell, right? like you're asking, they're asking for money for the next four years in a fund that we don't, I mean I don really like continuously appropriated things anyway I guess I would ask they going to have a pretty hard they going to need to come in with some pretty strong explanations let's put it that way. So I would ask them to really flesh this out a little bit more.

Rick Taggartother

Rep. Garcia. Thank you, Madam Chair. I guess I'm not as skeptical as you all are, because as I see it, in order to invest in these transit-oriented community infrastructures, it is actually long-term. And so the way that I'm reading this is because of the way that our grant structure works as it being a reimbursable grant project, they will be awarded the grant in 26-27. But the funds can, like the grant project can go through 2030, and they will get reimbursed throughout that time to get the fully, like the money that they are saying that their project will cost. So it's not necessarily, I don't see this as like, let's just see what happens in 20 to 29, and let's see what happens in 29 and 30, but it's more of we need to make sure that there is money in place for the reimbursements that the grants were awarded to do.

You can do that by not over-encumbering in the first place. If they know they only have $5 million to spend, you only have $5 million to spend for the next four years, through the course of the whole project. So you don't think, oh, I'm going to reward $5 million knowing that the money is going to affect how the money comes in and the reverse is going to be in. But, oh, it's going to maybe be $6.8 million. You don't do that. They over encumber. That's the problem. And they want to continue to over encumber. And they want to spend more than the $15 million that they got from this grant program. That's it. That's one time. Yes, it's up for interpretation.

Michelle Curryother

I THINK WHERE I'M PUZZLED ON THIS IS I DO UNDERSTAND AND RESPECT THAT THE GRANT MAY BE SPENT BY THE COMMUNITIES OVER A THREE OR FOUR-YEAR PERIOD, PERIOD, BUT THE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE THAT GOES INTO HELPING THEM DEVELOP THE GRANT IS OVER BY 26-27. I MEAN, WHERE THEY NEED THE HELP IS UP FRONT OF THE GRANT, NOT AFTER THE GRANT IS GIFTED, SO TO SPEAK. SO I COME BACK AGAIN TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS THAT THEY SHOULD BE DONE BECAUSE THEY'RE ALREADY SAYING FINAL GRANTS ARE EXPECTED TO BE AWARDED. SO I WOULD UNDERSTAND SOME COSTS IN 26-27, BUT WHAT TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE ARE YOU GOING TO GIVE THREE YEARS OUT FROM NOW? THAT JUST DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. So I have a question, too, which is about the lawsuit around, I think it's just 1313, but it might be all three of them. I'm not sure. And I'd like to understand what the status of that is. And, you know, like if these communities are not going to do it because they don't have to, I think it would be worth understanding that, too. AND I'M ASSUMING THAT A COMMUNITY THAT DOESN'T WANT TO DO IT AND IS IN THE LAWSUIT IS NOT GETTING ANY GRANTS, BUT I DON'T ACTUALLY KNOW THAT EITHER. SO I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE FORMAT WOULD BE FOR TALKING ABOUT THAT. BUT, YES, YOU ALL. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR I BELIEVE THE LAWSUIT DOES ONLY APPLY TO THIS ONE AND JUST THAT YEAH THE GOVERNMENTS AND THAT LIKE ARE NOT Thank you Madam Chair I believe the lawsuit does only apply to this one and just that yeah the governments and that are not going to be designated as meeting the requirements and receiving technical assistance

Jana Lockwitness

I'll have the department speak to the ongoing costs. I think they are saying even though the grants are awarded completely in this year, they still have to administer the grants and make sure the things get built through 2030. But also I believe that in that time frame, I think the jurisdictions who are trying to meet these requirements, I don't know if DOLA has to monitor that they stay in compliance or what, so they can speak more to that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

I had all the similar surprises and concerns, I think, that have been expressed here, that these all seemed very clearly like one-time programs and one-time costs when they were discussed in appropriations two years ago.

Jana Lockwitness

At the bottom of page 15, there are some other relevant points that I do sympathize with the department on some of this. They do admit that they underestimated indirect costs, common policies, and other fringe costs in the fiscal notes. They state that for $174,000, some of the consulting assistance to set some of the components up quickly cost more than they expected, and that overall for a lot of the consulting for housing-related planning work across the state, that that cost more than they thought because there's not that big of a pool of consultants that can do these kinds of studies, so they feel like the prices were higher than they expected. They also note that initially a lot of these programs were first proposed in one bill, Senate Bill 23-213 concerning land use, and then it was kind of deconstructed into these three different bills, but the bills have kind of overlapping concepts and requirements and deadlines and staffing needs, And so I think it's understandable that they had a tough time bucketing out the exact costs for these programs over a five-year time frame. But on the flip side, I think for their hearing, I'm still also not fully grasping why the spending plan wasn't done to assume that you're not getting another dime.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Yeah. Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

So hopefully they can speak to that.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay.

Jana Lockwitness

Okay, thank you. I have a couple more quick sections.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay, okay.

Jana Lockwitness

On page 17, budget reduction options. So as you know, this budget was prepared before the outcome of the ballot initiatives, and so there are a lot of budget cuts proposed throughout all these departments. For DOLA, there are only a couple things proposed. And this committee, I believe we took a lot of budget balancing actions in DOLA the last couple years. So for this year, basically, the only thing they proposed was the $115,000 cut to the READY program and then the transfers from that revolving loan fund. So on page 18, the table shows their requests. I only showed the first year transfer from their R8 proposal. So they proposed $2.4 million in general fund relief. As we just talked about in R1 they asking for some general fund money that depending how you think about that other 3 million dollar transfer is partially offset or not Anyway so even with the new budget situation I still think there's a few things we should look at in DOLA regardless on the bottom of page 18. One the first one is the targeted crime reduction grant program which we've talked about before. So this program was created in 2017, and first it was only for South Aurora and Colorado Springs. It was expanded and modified. It was expanded to Grand Junction and Trinidad. There was more funding when it was expanded for a couple years, but then it went back to being just $3 million, so that $3 million is split between four communities when it used to be two, and then last year during budget balancing this committee, we cut the appropriation from $3 million to $2.7 million because we gave, like most of DOLIS grant programs, a haircut last year. This program does spend, it has always spent all the money appropriated to it. There's a lot of different nonprofits and community organizations who apply for this money, and they never have any reversions in this program. This program is scheduled to sunset next September, and it had a sunset review. the Sunset Review did recommend continuing it as most Sunset Reviews do. They did identify several recommendations to improve the program, and there was some other interesting information in the Sunset Reviews, which is that for these communities, crime is only going down in Aurora. It went up a little bit in Colorado Springs and Trinidad and Grand Junction. It was unchanged, and that's violent crime. and violent crime statewide is down based on the data they're using. Even if crime was down in all these communities, there's no way to prove definitively that it's because of the grant program. This grant program, over the course of all the bills that tinkered with it, there has been more of an effort made to collect data. So they do collect a lot of data about where the money's going, who it's going to, and they attempt to collect outcomes. And there's a lot of testimonials and a lot of people who will tell you how great the grant program is. However, you know, there's never going to be able to be definitive proof that the grant program is the cause of lust crime. There's only, like, anecdotes, which are good to have for context. The other thing about this grant program is that it's a pretty high administrative cost and effort for the amount of money being given away because it goes through this mostly, DOLA mostly gives us all out to be managed, but for the community foundations that are involved, they have an admin cap of 8%, but then there's this reference in statute to third-party grant administrators, and I believe they're the ones who took on the additional data collection requirements, and they're allowed, their cap is up to 15%. So there's actually like a pretty high administrative cost.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Are they trying to make these loans?

Jana Lockwitness

No, I don't think so.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Well, I like this, the way you described it goes out.

Jana Lockwitness

Instead of just going, it goes out, you did this. I don't know, what does that mean?

Representative Garciaassemblymember

But I think you just explained it.

Jana Lockwitness

Yeah, it's like basically DOLA had to find administrators administrators in each of these communities, and then the administrators, like, run the grant program and work with the grantees on the ground. So...

Representative Garciaassemblymember

You know, we have all that data in reports and stuff that I can provide to you.

Jana Lockwitness

So anyway, I think I'm expecting that someone in the General Assembly will run the sunset bill to continue it. We could let it sunset and save $2.7 million. Or to play devil's advocate, if we are going to continue it, Maybe it's worth restoring the full amount or more if we're going to spend such a high administrative cost on it. So that's just something to keep in mind.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Rep Sirota has her hand up. Rep Sirota.

Jessica Greenwitness

Thank you. I was just wondering if, I don't know, Ms. Ewell, if you had a chance to look at the Sunset View. But if there was anything in there, because it says they make a bunch of recommendations for improvement, do the recommendations actually address the high admin costs and how to do this better, or that's still left unaddressed?

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Ms. Yule.

Jana Lockwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Sirota, I did read it. It doesn't really say that the admin cost is high and we should cut it back. The recommendations were more related to some of the definitions, I think. There might be some recommendation related to, I think there's not really a good definition of what a third-party grant administrator is, but they also focused on, they recommended, I think it was in Trinidad, they couldn't find as many organizations to participate as they wanted. They also recommended putting, there is a connected loan program that has just been kind of revolving money too, and they recommended putting more effort into the loan program and marketing them together more. And I think they also, the Sunset Review recommends doing it for another five years to try to collect more data. but yeah so that's yeah but it didn't really talk about being able to cut administrative costs and it did also note that this amount of money being split four ways doesn't go very far but it didn't go so far as to say you know more money but also I think and there's always a question of why is it just these four programs the General Assembly picked these four cities, but we can't, like adding more communities is sort of out of the question without more money for sure because it's already being split four ways.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Okay. Yeah, Boulder didn't get any money. But this year Boulder would get half the money. The Joint Budget Committee only cleaned it up. The Joint Budget Committee only cleaned it up mechanically. The Joint Budget Committee never picked any of the communities. Not even in the beginning? No, or later. Those were added across the street. Okay. All right. Well, let's move on unless people want to talk about this some more. And then... If we know if we are related to 267, we must probably learn your name. The next item, yeah, on the middle of page 19. This one is the Firefighter Heart and Circulatory Malfunction Benefits Program So this is I going to be honest a program we don talk about very much and I can explain it very well But basically it gives out helps cities give out money to firefighters to like ensure them against heart and circulatory health issues And a couple, it's, can you explain, I can't explain it. A couple years ago, it was expanded from full-time firefighters to volunteer and part-time firefighters. And so because they expanded the number of eligible people being covered, they assumed it's going to cost a lot more. But how the bill was structured is that they put mandatory increasing appropriations in statute, which is what's on that table, through the next five years. And then on July 1, 2028, there's a $2.5 million transfer from the general fund to the program, or to the cash fund for this program. And there were also components that affect public safety, because Mr. Brackey was looking at this. And the JBC last year sponsored a bill to take the required appropriations out of statute. And it wasn't to say that we shouldn't fund this program, but we, especially on the dola side, Like, there's been no data ever provided that the amounts put into the fiscal note, which are what they're, or into statute, like, are panning out to be the actual cost of the program. Like, I don't think we know. I don't think we know if it's going to keep going up that much in perpetuity. Because as you can see, first it went up $300,000, then $200,000. The jump from $500,000 to $650,000 is what we took out. So actually the bill is supposed to take out all the future increases, but it was amended. and so we ended up only taking out the required appropriation for this year. So the enacted version still allows these increasing appropriations. So in DOLA's budget, they have a $500,000 general fund increase, which is a third of their general fund increase for the whole year, for their whole budget, just because of the annualization of 24-12-19. So I think my recommendation on the previous page says, for their hearing, I would like to see if they can bring us any data data on like what are the actual costs of the program and do we think we need these increasing appropriations but regardless dola could without the increasing appropriations in statute dola could still ask for the amount of money they need for this program every year which i think would be preferable because then we'd really know what's going on with the program also statute has always provided that if the appropriation is not sufficient then participation becomes optional for the employers. So I think that we should ask DOLA for more information, and I would suggest running basically the same bill we ran last year to try to take, because it's not common to put required increasing appropriations in statute anyway. We typically expect that it comes through the budget process. So I think we should run the bill again this year, and ask DOLA for more background information at their hearing, if that's okay. So I just want to be clear, though, what we're doing is helping municipalities and whoever else hires firefighters to cover their insurance because normally regular old health insurance doesn't cover heart and circulatory malfunction. Like I find that a little bit hard to believe. Don't other kinds of occupations, I mean, is this the only place? DO YOU HAVE TO BE A FIREFIGHTER TO HAVE A HEART AND CIRCULATORY MALFUNCTION? AND WHY WOULDN THAT BE COVERED BY INSURANCE I DON know I just have questions about that Yeah Maybe you don remember this bill but I remember it pretty well It was called what? The Hugh McKean bill. Yeah. Okay. Okay. I don't know who else in the house would not have this, but the mallet got both of them on the planet. And it was not good. So anyway, I think there should be more than that, because there are certain municipalities with fire districts and then fire boats, and then there are firefighters and then there are fire districts that can collect the response to them. And maybe it's the volunteer firefighter districts that should be getting the funding. Because they're the ones that might actually need it. Because they're not getting health insurance provided because they're not employees. Okay. Thank you, Madam Chair. Yeah, so if it's okay with you, I'll ask Dole what information they can bring us about this for the hearing. Okay, and then the last one is also a bill we did last year that we might have to do again. The Public Defender and Prosecutor Behavioral Health Support Grant Program. So this one is, this Foley is a pass-through for DOLA, so DOLA doesn't really take ownership in this program, but $500,000 to DOLA that by statute gets split 50-50 to the Office of the State Public Defender and Colorado District Attorney's Council. Office of the State Public Defender has always spent all their money. CDAC, however, had trouble getting the money spent, and it was piling up. On page 20, in the version in front of you, I kind of totally botched putting these numbers on paper, and I mixed some of them up. So they just submitted an RFI saying that through the close of fiscal year 26, they had only spent $393,000 out of a million dollars that they got over four years. as of October they had spent and then I switched these two numbers on accident rough day they had spent $415,000 and they still had $585,000 available so they're still sitting on a lot of money even though they didn't even get a new appropriation in this year because of the balancing bill we did and also last year in their RFI response they had said they had already spent $550,000 which doesn't match up with what they said this year so they are actually sitting on more money than I thought, and had we known that, we could have just made the bill effective for two years, but now if we don't want them to pile up even more money, we would have to run another bill, and that's because of the way it works in statute is because we can't change the appropriation and not harm the public defender's office unless we run a bill again. Okay, I'm just going to say the same thing I said last year when we were looking at this. I believe the employees in these two departments have health insurance, and I don't understand why they can't use their health insurance to get the services that they need. And the state, if the state isn't covering adequate mental health benefits, they should be. And that's a different problem. And also, no offense, but this shouldn't be in DOLA, because it should be in the BHA. And so I think those are all things we should be looking at. And this kind of thing same with the one that in the Department of Ag like it just it just crazy we should stop doing it and i mean crazy in the nicest possible way rep brown thank you madam chair uh i think i'm sure that they may have provided this information to us last year but um why uh I was going to ask a question. Why don't you go ahead? Thank you. I guess the question is if what you're saying, Madam Chair, is the case where they should already have this coverage, why is it inadequate for them to come with this request? That's what I wanted. Thank you. Okay. Yes, I believe they've probably provided that every year, and they'll give the same answer, but I can have them provide it again. That's so fun for us. Not sure if we can get it through DOLA or if I'll have to just provide it through, like, Department of Law, because it's, like, CDAC, and DOLA is really not involved hardly at all, but we'll get you this information one way or another. I mean, does DOLA have an FTE associated with administrations? Not sure. They do not. It literally, when the bill was initially drafted, it wasn't in DOLA. And then it ended up in DOLA. But they don't have an FTE. They literally just hand the money out. So it also makes it kind of difficult because there's a bit of a gap. Like I have to try to contact CDAC every time I have a question about this. So it just wandered over to DOLA on its own. Okay. Okay, so I think I don't have anything to call attention to on the footnotes. They had an RFI about this program, which is where these answers come from. There was also an RFI submitted through HICPUF about the reappropriated funds and the voucher programs going between HICPUF and DOLA. and to be honest, the response I think left a lot to be desired and I think me and Mr. Kurtz and Mr. Dermody have to work through what was submitted because initially what they responded with was that the amount of Medicaid billable housing voucher and tenancy support services things is much lower than we anticipated. So I think we'll have to bring you information about what's going on with that, probably through the HICPF aspect, because I cannot explain that either. Okay. So that is it. All right. Thank you. That was great. Okay. Anything else?

Michelle Curryother

Madam Chair, Craig Harper, JBC staff. Just a reminder for you all and anyone who happens to be listening, you won't meet again as the Joint Budget Committee until next Thursday the 19th. We'll start up at nine o'clock that morning with the briefing on CDOT and both Thursday and Friday next week are pretty full but folks should expect to schedule change on Friday to effectively eliminate the lunch hour and move up the education presentation to try and get you all out of here earlier next Friday as well.

Representative Garciaassemblymember

Thank you for that. And I just want to offer my appreciation to the analysts that rearranged their schedules today and presented on very little notice with very little preparation, showed a lot of flexibility, and I appreciate it. So thank you. Okay, I want to echo that, and thank you to everybody for being flexible. And it's 2.30. Okay. The joint budget committee will stand in recess until 9 o'clock on Thursday the 19th. So when the actual departments come, like, do we, so if we put all these notes and stuff, like, do we pull them out of the drawer when the departments come through? They also, when the departments come, the packet that they give us is a presentation to the department as well as written questions to all of our questions that we've asked. Could we respond to the questions? Yeah, they're responses, yeah. To all the questions? You thought we could try and remember? Yeah, they were like, ask the department to do this and then they go and write something. And, Director Hartford? Yes. Is it at all possible to request when they give us the printouts of the slides that they're not like in full blue color? I'm just thinking it's also nice to write notes on those. It doesn't change the amount of . Oh, I see what you mean. Well, yeah, because it will be in the end instead of in the middle. Well, we can revisit it. Everybody who was sitting here thought that that was okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you.

Source: Joint Budget Committee [Nov 13, 2026] · November 13, 2026 · Gavelin.ai