Skip to main content
Committee HearingSenate

Senate Jt Leg Audit — 2026-10-29

October 29, 2026 · Jt Leg Audit · 34,603 words · 10 speakers · 137 segments

Senator Senatorsenator

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. . . Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

All right. All right, everyone. Let's see. Test, test, test. Yeah. Test, test, test. Test, test, test. I pushed. Let's see. Test, test, test. It's okay. Let's see. Hello.

Senator Senatorsenator

Black. Just black.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

You want coffee?

Chair Herbedianchair

Do you want coffee?

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Thank you.

Chair Herbedianchair

Okay. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Okay. We're going to get started here. Hi, everyone. Welcome to our Joint Legislative Audit Committee Oversight Hearing. It is a pleasure to be here in Castaic and Santa Clarita, where the subject matter of this audit hearing is very close and personal to those of you in the room and to the community, and it's a pleasure to be here. Thank you to Senator Schiavo for having us in our district, Senator Valadaris for having us in your district, and thank you all for being here. My name is John Harbidi, and I chair the Joint Legislative Audit Committee for the State of California, and today we're going to go over an audit that, as I said, is very close and personal to this community. For the record, the audit is entitled Los Angeles County Department of Public Health. Its actions in response to conditions near the Chiquita landfill have been incomplete. Again, it's appropriate that we are here and talking about this because I know how important it is for everyone here. I know how important it is to your representatives here before you. and I want to applaud Assemblymember Schiavo for requesting this audit and really pushing for this. I want to thank and applaud Senator Valadares for, as a member of this committee, voting in favor of it and getting us to this point. And we are here with the State Auditor, Grant Parks, and his team, who did a fantastic job on the audit. And I do want to get into the substance of it, but before we do that, But I do also want to acknowledge Assemblymember Mark Gonzalez, who is here with us. And I just want to thank my colleagues for being here and all their attention. And I actually am not too far from you. I not only chair this committee, but I represent the 41st district, which includes communities of Altadena, Pasadena, Sandimus, Upland, Rancho Cucamonga, and parts of the high desert. And we as you know just went through our own public health crisis in the Eden Fire And while I can say that I know everything that you going through I don I can say that my community and I have a lot of empathy for what you going through because we, again, have gone through similar struggles and are fighting for the future of our community through the public health crises that we are dealing with as well. And I know Assemblymember Gonzalez has been going through similar experiences as well. And it all is related. And it's all related because our communities have a bond of that struggle and those crises and trying to get more help from government agencies, including the Department of Public Health. So it's really an honor to be with you. And you know that you have members here who care deeply about you and what you're going through. With that, I just want to allow for, you know, some opening statements from my colleagues and talk about what we're going to talk about. But I do want to say that as we discuss the audit report, you will notice that the Department of Public Health is not here. And we want to explore ways in which the Department of Public Health can and should improve their services to this community as it relates to the landfill, but also how it can increase its communication and delivery of services to you. I think it's unfortunate and disappointing that the department is not here. And that goes without saying. I wish that they were here, especially when the audit actually noted that the communication between the public health department and the community has not been perfect. It can be improved. And that's one of the concerns of the auditor that we will hear from today. That said, again, I want to thank Senator Schiave, my colleague, for bringing this audit to us. And I'm going to hand it over to her for opening statements and then Senator Valadez and then Senator Gonzalez. But before I do, just a few housekeeping items to ensure that we hear from everyone. I want to ask that the panels keep their presentations to the time allocated. We only have two panels today, so I don't think that's going to be too hard. I will ask that after each panel, members will have questions to the dais for the presenters and the panelists. And then we're going to reserve public comment at the end. So I know a lot of people probably have public comment. That will come after the two panels. And so we thank you for your patience, but there's going to be a lot of good information being shared in the two panels, and then you'll have your opportunity for public comment. With that, I'm going to hand it over to Senator Schiava for an opening statement.

Senator/Assemblymember Pilar Schiavosenator

Thank you so much, Mr. Chair, and I want to thank you for your support and leadership. You've been incredibly supportive as we have been trying to figure out all the ways, all the levers that we can pull in Sacramento to try to protect our community and really get results from government at a time when it's when you need government to show up is in emergencies like this, in disasters like this. I'm grateful to the staff, the auditors for their hard work in this report and my colleagues for being here today as well and especially grateful to everyone in the community who's here. YOU KNOW, I REQUESTED THIS AUDIT TODAY BECAUSE FOR YEARS NOW, FAMILIES HAVE BEEN BEGGING FOR HELP. THIS HAS BEEN DESCRIBED, THEY'VE BEEN DESCRIBING DEBILITATING SYMPTOMS. I JUST TALKED WITH SOMEONE THIS EVENING WHO TALKED told me they lost their wife to cancer, they have cancer, and both of their dogs died. And this, unfortunately, is not a rare story that you hear in this community. Too often, people can see too many of their neighbors who have cancer are suffering from all kinds of symptoms, headaches, dizziness, nausea, tremors, bloody noses that are uncontrollable that kids wake up in a puddle of blood in the middle of night. This is a horrible, horrible situation, and we are not getting the kind of response that we need from L.A. County Department of Public Health. The auditor's findings in auditor speak are scathing. It is, you know, a clear failure of leadership that our community is not getting the support that they need, and it is the leadership that needs to fix that or get out of the way for someone else to do it. Thank you. We have done everything that we can imagine to try to get them to act. I started convening monthly meetings with Department of Public Health and all of the agencies responding. And I was just going over my notes last night of those meetings that I've been convening for two years, monthly meetings last year and then every other month this year. And so often I'll go through all the agencies and have notes on what they're reporting out, all the things that they're doing, and then LACDPH, no notes, nothing. This has happened month after month and for year after year at this point. We have held press conferences and town halls. I slept at Jennifer Elkin's house and experienced symptoms myself just in the 12 hours that I was there inside almost all of that time. I had burning face, burning eyes, burning throat. In the morning, I blew my nose and it started to bleed. And I could not remember the last time that I had a bloody nose. And then to continue to try to build pressure for the Department of Public Health to act, I slept outside camping with Jane Williams, who's going to testify today, at another neighbor's home, camping outside. and had many of those symptoms again, and also my ears have not stopped ringing for a year and a half now. So now I have tinnitus. So, you know, this is very serious, and people are getting sick. I have been to funerals in our community, and it is unacceptable that our L.A. County Department of Public Health not only is not showing up, is not doing what is in their name, public health, Protecting public health is literally their number one job, and they're not doing it here in our community, but also that they're not showing up today. They're not showing up. It's, again, complete disregard for our community. And their excuse is, well, there's a lawsuit, and so we can't talk about it until this lawsuit is resolved. Anyone have an idea of when that lawsuit is going to be resolved? Years. Years. so they don have to be accountable to our community for years because there a lawsuit Are you kidding me This is ridiculous Yeah So this is, you know, this is something that we have tried literally everything that we can think to try. I've been working with people in the community to try to figure out all THE WAYS IN WHICH WE CAN GET THE RESPONSE THAT WE NEED. AND HAVE RESORTED TO DOING STATE BILLS THAT REQUIRE A HEALTH STUDY TO HAPPEN BECAUSE THEY REFUSE TO DO ONE. THAT'S ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT THINGS IN AB28, THE LANDFILL SAFETY ACT, REQUIRES A HEALTH STUDY. I DID BILLS ON TRANSPARENCY SO EVERYBODY CAN HAVE THE INFORMATION ABOUT THE TEMPERATURE AND AIR MONITORING DATA. I did bills on making sure that, you know, if anyone got relief dollars, you're not taxed on those. By the way, you should not be getting taxed on those. And if you did, you can do something to amend that and get in touch with my office, and we'll help you with that. But we have been doing a patchwork of bills at the state level to make up for the inaction at the local level. And it's inexcusable. It's why I asked for the audit and why I'm very happy to have this conversation here today, TO HEAR BOTH FROM THE AUDITORS, FROM COMMUNITY MEMBERS, AND FROM ALL OF YOU. SO WE WILL HEAR FROM THE AUDITORS JUST ABOUT HOW THE HEARING'S GOING TO WORK. WE'LL HEAR FROM THE AUDITORS. WE'LL HEAR FROM COMMUNITY MEMBERS WHO ARE GOING TO COME UP AND SPEAK. AND THEN THERE WILL BE A TIME FOR PUBLIC COMMENT AT THE END FOR EVERYONE TO ALSO TALK ABOUT IF YOU'VE HAD ANY EXPERIENCES WITH LA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH, WHAT THEY HAVE BEEN, ANY, YOU KNOW, HEALTH ISSUES THAT YOU'RE EXPERIENCING IN THE COMMUNITY, if you're comfortable sharing those, but we really want to hear from people and make sure that your voice is on the record on this issue today to help be part of the change that we need to see happen and continuing to build pressure on the L.A. County Department of Public Health to show up, to do their job, and to protect public health here in our community. So with that, I look forward to this conversation.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you, Senator Schiavo. Senator Valdez.

Senator Senatorsenator

Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you for making the time to come up to our community to chair this important audit hearing and for being really a phenomenal chair. For those of you who don't know, the Joint Audit Committee is composed of both senators and assembly members, and we request for some of the most vital audits that are important not only to the state but to our community. So I would like to thank the assembly member for requesting this audit and that we hold this hearing here in our community as well, AS WELL AS ASSEMBLY MEMBER GONZALES FOR MAKING IT OUT AND DREGING THAT LA TRAFFIC. WE GENUINELY APPRECIATE IT. AND THEN, OF COURSE, TO SCVI FOR HOSTING US IN THIS WONDERFUL ROOM AND BEING A GREAT COMMUNITY PARTNER THROUGHOUT THE CASTAG VALVERDE AREA. AND GENUELY BECAUSE SCVI CARES ABOUT OUR KIDS AND THE FAMILIES IMPACTED BY THIS ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER. AND THEN LASTLY, I ALSO WANT TO THANK THE ASSEMBLY SERVICES FOR COMING OUT AND MAKING SURE THAT WE NOT ONLY HAVE A PHENOMENAL HEARING, BUT THAT THIS IS RECORDED. YOU CAN FIND THIS ONLINE. IT IS A PART OF OUR HEARING ONLINE AT THE SENATE WEBSITE AS WELL AS THE ASSEMBLY WEBSITE. AND I WANT TO THANK STATE AUDITOR GRANT PARKS AND YOUR ENTIRE TEAM FOR THEIR WORK AND TO EVERYONE WHO HAS JOINED US THIS EVENING. Most importantly I want to thank the residents of Valverde of Castaic and all of our surrounding communities For years families living near Chiquita Canyon landfill have endured conditions that no family should have to live with Persistent odors headaches nausea concerns about the air that their children breathe, and the uncertainty of not knowing whether their homes are safe. As a mother, I cannot imagine the anguish of wondering whether the home that you've worked so hard to provide for your children is hurting them, could be making them sick. And as your senator, I believe that you deserve answers, accountability, and meaningful relief. You deserve more than another government meeting. You deserve results. And I've worked on legislation to strengthen protections for our community affected by landfills, improved oversight, and addressed the gaps in our laws that have become apparent through this crisis. And again, I want to acknowledge Assemblywoman Pilar Siavo, who requested this audit, and who has worked very diligently to bring attention to what's going on here. We may not agree on every issue, but protecting the health and safety of our constituents is never, should never, and will never be partisan. And I believe that everyone involved... I believe that everyone involved, local, state, federal officials, has a responsibility to work together towards solutions. Because our families living here don't care what agency has jurisdiction or which elected official gets the credit. They want to know that their families are safe. They want to know what's being done to address the conditions at the landfill. and they want to know what happens next. This audit gives us an important opportunity to answer some of those questions. It identifies serious shortcomings by the county department of public health response, including inadequate health monitoring, inconsistent communication, and significant delays in recommending relocation assistance. Those findings deserve careful examination, and they deserve accountability. But the audit also found that the county's solid waste enforcement program acted with reasonable speed and took appropriate steps to address the conditions at the landfill. Both findings do matter. And I believe that we have an obligation to examine this report its entirety, recognizing what was done correctly, identifying where government fell short, and determining what has to change. And we also have to recognize that accountability extends beyond one department or one level of government. There are important questions about the landfill's operators' responsibilities, coordination among regulatory agencies, and whether our existing laws provide the tools necessary to respond to an environmental emergency of this magnitude. and there are families who continue to need help today. Some are concerned about their health but cannot afford to leave their homes. I know this. Others are struggling with financial uncertainty and the fear that their most valuable investment, their home, may have lost its value. Those challenges cannot be solved by one audit alone. They require cooperation. they require resources and sustained commitment to making this community whole Because ultimately our responsibility isn to assign political blame here It about accountability correcting what went wrong and making sure the people of our community are not forgotten. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you, Senator. Senator Gonzales.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Thank you, Assemblymember Harabedian, for putting today's audit together. I know you've been in this role for a couple of years now, as I have as well, in terms of being in the legislature. But since day one, you've been a strong champion, obviously, your community, going through many similar devastations as mine. But at the end of the day, I appreciate your leadership on having this meeting here today. I know we have to get things started, but I just want to thank Assemblymember Shaivo for her work and the senator, of course. Assembly member Shivo is in my caucus and brings this up at least to our caucus members every week, but for a reason. And I want to thank her for that because we are very similar. We might be what's considered almost, I think it took me longer to get here than it does to Sacramento when I play. But the reality is my Boyle Heights people are here as well. My Eastside people are here. And I want to thank them for coming here today because, you know, I represent the 5th Forest District in the state and the 54th Assembly District. 70% of my district speaks another language other than English, and 85% of my district are renters. I've worked with Jane over a number of years when Exide was first shut down. Exide, as some of you might know, was 33 years with the temporary permit that caused the most severe lead poisoning in our district that we are still dealing with today in my time as district director. Jane and I and many of our community folks to my right over here, Alma and so many others, have worked together to make sure we didn't shut it down. and these environmental injustices, and we come from the school of, you know, justice delayed is justice denied, and that's what we are seeing here in this community as well. Boyle Heights, if some of you don't know, is surrounded by fire freeways. It's been landlocked by a lot of environmental injustices, including our air pollution, and so many things have happened in our area, and some of you might know the recent lineage fire that we are dealing with as well, and a lot of that debris came to this area, to these landfills and this side of town, So it's really important for us to have this discussion because government should be the problem solver, not the problem. And that's why we are here today to go through that. And with many of you in this help and many of you on this dais, we're able to pass AB 817, which is holding those corporations accountable and making sure they have a contingency plan if they destroy our communities, in addition to making sure that if we do sue as a small business, as a resident, that when we sue these companies that we don't get taxed on it from our compensation as a result of that. So we were able to pass that bill, and the governor did sign that. And that was something that took a lot of work to get there, but many people understood what was needed in our backyard, and we're not going to stop there. So thank you all for taking time out of your day. Many of you had to leave work early, find babysitters for your pets or for your children. I don't have kids myself, but I do appreciate many of you who do on this panel and how hard it is to have to maneuver that. It's a Thursday night, and there's a lot of stuff going on out there, so I really just wanted to be here in solidarity and support and to listen. And thank you again to my colleagues for putting this afternoon together.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you, Assemblymember. Thank you again for being here and those words. We're going to start with our first panel, and it is the overview of the audit report by the state auditors. So Mr. Parks, if you could come up with your team. We have Grant Parks here who is the California State Auditor. Very nice to have you here in the district. And Bob Harris, the audit principal, and Daniela Jacobs, the senior auditor. Mr. Parks, you know how this works. The floor is yours, and I will give you, because of the nature of this hearing and where we are, as much time as you need. So please take your time to go over the findings, and to the extent that anyone else needs to jump in, feel free. So take it away.

Grant Parksother

Thank you very much, Chairman Herbedian. Thank you for having me here this evening. Also, Assemblymember Schiavo, thank you for the audit request. And members, it's a pleasure to be with you. In September, we released our audit report in response to Assemblymember Schiavo's audit request concerning the Los Angeles Department of Public Health and its response to the conditions at the Chiquita Canyon landfill, including its health effects on nearby residents. I'd like to briefly touch on some of the events at the landfill leading up to the audit request and then list some of the key audit objectives along with our main observations during the audit. And after my remarks, I'll be turning it over to my colleague, Bob Harris, who was the audit principal on the assignment, along with Daniela Jacobs, who led the audit team, who will walk the panel through our audit findings in more detail. By way of background, and as you can see, and I'm sure many in the audience today are aware, the Chiquita Canyon landfill is located very close to where we are tonight, located in northern Los Angeles County in the Santa Clarita Valley, surrounded by the communities of Halsey Canyon, Castaic, Valverde, where several thousand people make their homes. And the conditions at the Chiquita Canyon landfill have persisted over several years. And so I think some brief background remarks on its history and LADPH's actions may be helpful to this evening's discussion. In 2017, L.A. County issued a conditional use permit to Chiquita Canyon for the continued operation of the landfill and included various conditions, including the Chiquita operate an air quality monitoring program and provide several regular reports to various county agencies so they can more effectively monitor landfill operations. And upon issuing this permit, L.A. County also created the Chiquita Canyon Landfill Community Advisory Committee, or CAC, which is composed of individuals who live in the Santa Clarita Valley and serves as an advisory body to the Board of Supervisors, among others, on matters related to the landfill. In early 2022, the landfill became the site of a high-temperature underground chemical reaction, and this reaction has caused an increase in both odorous landfill gas emissions and hazardous waste, known as lechate, and both Cal Recycle and Chiquita Canyon believe that this chemical reaction will continue for several years and that the reaction may also be growing. Residents of these communities near the landfill have complained about increased odors over the last three years since 2023 and in connection with these odors have reported experiencing negative health effects such as headaches, eye, nose and throat irritation including nosebleeds, tremors, nausea and fatigue. LADPH began monitoring air quality and health symptoms in July 2023 when they also issued a public health notice to Chiquita Canyon notifying them that the reaction was impacting the health of its residents and was creating a public nuisance, requiring the landfill to take specific actions. And the next month, LADPH also issued a letter to Chiquita Canyon with various recommendations for mitigating the health impacts, including expanded and enhanced air monitoring actions The following year in 2024 LADPH released the results of a health risk evaluation conducted by a contractor it hired and held a community meeting to discuss the evaluation results And LADPH also began an online survey to better understand the health impacts of the community. In December of that year in 2024, LA County filed a lawsuit against Chiquita seeking abatement of the nuisance and funding to subsidize the relocation and home hardening efforts of the community. The following year. I'm sorry. I'm sorry, Mr. Parks.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

If I can, as you're talking about this, just for clarification, because I know within LACDPH there are kind of two wings, basically, right? There's an enforcement wing and there's a health wing, right? And so when you're talking about the actions here, because I know most of them have to do with enforcement and not with health, if you can just, for shorthand, would you mind saying enforcement or health so that we're clear on that, who's doing what?

Grant Parksother

It's all health. Is that okay?

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

That's fine, and thank you for the request. Thank you.

Grant Parksother

The comments that I'm talking about in the majority of our audit report focuses on health. So the activities that I'm mentioning here pertain to health, not the enforcement program. LADPH began monitoring air quality and health symptoms in 2023, and they issued a notice to Chiquita Canyon for them to take various actions. But by May 2025, they issued a directive to the landfill to provide additional funding for home hardening. And by 2026, LADPH ended its online community survey. These events in no way reflect whether or not LADPH conducted their work adequately. It's simply a reflection of the events that have taken place during the time period, which is a request in the audit to figure out what exactly the department did. And as Assemblymember Schiavo noted, LADPH plays two key roles here, which is worthwhile touching on. There is the county health officer role, where the head of LADPH has a responsibility to make sure that that department is investigating and diagnosing health problems and taking actions to protect the health and safety of residents. And secondly, LADPH has an enforcement program where they work in coordination with the state's Cal Recycle Department to make sure that the landfill is following state landfill rules. And so our audit touched on both activities. Our audit criticism in our report focuses primarily, actually entirely on the public health aspect of LADPH, not the enforcement program. To touch briefly on the audit request and why we were asked to do the audit, Assemblymember Schiavo wanted to know various information, including identifying what the department did to notify residents of potential negative health impacts from the landfill, evaluate what steps the department took to document symptoms and to act to protect the public, and also to compare the department's response to the landfill to other events, such as the gas leak at Aliso Canyon, and if significant differences exist in those responses to determine the reasons why. So I'll talk now about some of the audit results. A key takeaway from our audit, ultimately at its core, is that the community's concerns and criticisms of LADPH were well-founded. And in our view, the Department's efforts with respect to the landfill have been incomplete and differ from the other hazardous events that we reviewed during the audit. And our findings fall into three broad categories. The first that LADPH missed opportunities to better protect community health Number two LADPH demonstrated limited communication and community engagement And three we noted inconsistencies in how LADPH responded to the Chiquita Canyon event when compared to the department's responses to other health emergencies. And we also made various recommendations to LADPH. I'll touch briefly on each of these three areas in more detail. With respect to missed opportunities to better protect the public health, the department could not always provide evidence that it consistently monitored air quality throughout its response efforts, and this included not commenting publicly when detected levels of harmful chemicals exceeded protective thresholds. This prevented the community from understanding the impacts of these exceedances to their health. For example, in late 2023 and in early 2024, the landfill frequently reported exceedances of hydrogen sulfide levels in the air, yet we found no evidence of LADPH explaining the health risks to the public or alternatively reassuring residents that they shouldn't be concerned. And the LADPH analyst we spoke with who was tasked with monitoring air quality data reported from the landfill was actually unaware of the particularly high gas levels that we inquired about during our audit. And while the department did conduct an online survey regarding community health symptoms, the usefulness of LADPH's survey was in question, limited primarily because of the poor design and communication. With respect to communication, the department didn't accurately tell the community how long the survey would be available and what it would be used for. And in terms of flawed design of the survey, it was constructed in such a manner where LADPH has no information on how many people actually completed the survey. Or in other words, how many unique individuals completed it, therefore preventing a real understanding of how widespread the public health impacts were. I.e. whether it was a few people reporting often or whether it was a great number of people reporting less frequently. We also found limited communication and community engagement from LADPH. We saw lengthy gaps in time where the department did not share new or valuable information to residents, including not providing any substantive written updates for most of 2025, despite residents asking questions about chemical levels in the air and whether those levels exceeded safety thresholds. In addition, the department's approach to community engagement offered few opportunities for two-way dialogue with concerned community members. For example, we noted that LADPH's participation on CAC meetings was often 10 minutes or less, where LADPH didn't always have an opportunity to respond to questions posed from the community. And in our view, LADPH really could have engaged in question and answer sessions on its own with the public as part of its efforts to communicate effectively, especially given the limited public engagement in the CAC meetings. However, the department decided not to do so. And further in my view, LADPH's decision not to attend this evening's meeting to answer the community's questions and concerns along with the defensiveness and the department's response to our audit where we criticize its communication strategy, in my view, further reinforces our conclusion that LADPH appears uninterested in further community engagement regarding the landfill despite public concern. The third issue that I briefly touch on from our audit findings is inconsistency when responding to other health hazard events We compared the department response to four other health emergencies and found inconsistencies such as differing approaches to formally assessing health-related needs, differing communication strategies to keep the public informed, inconsistent partnerships with other county agencies to provide mental health support to impacted residents and communities. And we also found that it took the department two years to issue a directive to the landfill operator regarding relocation assistance for residents near the landfill as compared to its response to a similar event in Aliso Canyon where the department issued that directive within one month. The underlying cause for our findings appears to be that there has been change in turnover in leadership at LADPH between earlier public health emergency events such as at Aliso Canyon compared to the more recent event at Chiquita Canyon. And LADPH we found lacked policies and procedures that would promote and better ensure consistency in how it plans for and responds to health emergencies, such as how it determines the frequency and depth of the community engagement required and the data and the health assessments it shares to protect and to reassure the public. As far as recommendations, we made various recommendations to the County Board of Supervisors at improving LADPH's communication strategies and the data it shares with the public. We made those recommendations to the board because we knew that LADPH, based on our discussions with them during the audit, would be uninterested in considering or implementing our recommendations. Unfortunately, the department responded to our report on behalf of the Board of Supervisors to indicate that the board would similarly not be taking action on those same recommendations. Ultimately, this means that the board and LADPH have indicated that they will implement, I think, one recommendation from our report related to actually establishing policies and procedures to guide its response to health hazard events, but it does not plan to implement some of our other audit recommendations, including engagement with the community, such as by developing a communications plan with input from the community or by providing updated health assessments, even if only to reassure the public based on the air quality data it receives from the landfill. And so with that, I'll turn things over to Bob and Danielle to walk the panel through our report

Senator Senatorsenator

in more detail along with our findings and recommendations. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you, Mr. Parks. I will note before Mr. Harris goes, that's the first time in two years that we've been working together that you got a round of applause. So well done. Well done. All right, Mr. Harris.

Senator Senatorsenator

Thank you, Mr. Chair. members of the committee my name is Bob Harris I'm with the California State Auditor's Office as a principal auditor so along with Miss Jacobs we're going to walk through the findings that the state auditor just summarized in a greater level of detail kind of unpack how we reached the conclusions we reached I'll be covering the first two areas the missed opportunities to protect public health and the limited communication and community engagement and then Miss Jacobs will cover the the second half so in the area of missed opportunities to protect public health we want to focus on two key areas of our findings the first is the department's communication about air quality in the communities surrounding the landfill and the second will be the department's efforts to document through a health survey and other efforts that it made the health conditions of the people who live in the area surrounding the landfill so related to air quality and air quality communication it's helpful probably to take a step back for a moment and cover some background information about how LADPH and others have been assessing the air quality in the communities around the landfill. One of the key metrics that they've been using is this concept of a reference exposure level, or a REL. So a REL is a standard set by the state, actually. It's set by the State Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment. And a REL is a health protective threshold. So it's an indicator when levels of chemicals in the air might be reaching concerning thresholds. To have a REL, you basically have three different parts. You have the chemical that you're talking about, so hydrogen sulfide or benzene or any other chemical that OEHA has set a standard for. So you have the chemical. You have the duration of exposure, so how long you've been exposed to that chemical. There are RELs for an hour-long exposure. There's RELs for 24 hours' worth of exposure. And then you have the dosage, the actual amount of the chemical you've been exposed to. So there are parts per billion, parts per million measurements. and when you put all that together a specific chemical for a specific amount of time and in the specific amount you have a rel it's important to note that individuals can experience health symptoms even when levels of chemicals in the air don't reach that rel and that's in fact what members of this these communities have been experiencing even though sometimes chemicals have not reached the rel folks have still experienced very significant symptoms What the REL indicates is when the risk starts being coming elevated for what we call an adverse health effect. Now, I know it's a little confusing, but we have to distinguish between health symptoms and adverse health effects. Adverse health effects are health effects that are toxicological and possibly irreversible. So the REL tells you when you hit that threshold for that chemical for that amount of time at that level of exposure, that the risk is starting to increase that someone will experience one of those adverse health effects from that exposure. It doesn't guarantee they will, but it says the risks are starting to increase. And they're set at, as I said before, health protective thresholds, meaning they're set to be sensitive for populations that might be more susceptible to feeling those health effects or experiencing those health effects. So they are definitely at a protective threshold. Just because chemicals exceed the REL doesn't guarantee adverse health effects, fact the department informed us throughout the audit exceedances which is what we call when the chemicals go above the rel require interpretation and that depending on different circumstances and exceedance may or may not be cause for greater concern or not as much concern so they do need to be interpreted as the state auditor indicated in his opening comments the landfill publishes air quality data on a regular basis they provide reports to LADPH on a quarterly and a monthly basis monitoring the levels of certain chemicals in the communities surrounding the landfill and throughout 2023 early 2024 and sporadically continuing after that the landfill has reported exceedances of certain chemicals in particular hydrogen sulfide many exceedances in fact in 2023 and 2024 and so what we expected was that ladph would provide the community with information about how to understand what to do with that exceedance data so this exceedance data is public it's provided to LADPH but it's also posted publicly and so we expected the department would do that interpretation it would provide the community with advice or guidance about how to understand this information and its implications for their health we expected that because it would have been consistent with how the department had acted in the past in 2022 before complaints about the landfill odors started increasing LADPH had actually commented on a certain exceedance information and advised the public that they didn see any reason to be overly concerned about that data from 2022 So we expected they would continue to offer public guidance as the landfill event increased in severity We also expected it because they told the community that they would do so. In their communications with the community, when they first began their response activities, they said that they would be looking at the health data and the air quality data and that they would be reviewing it to determine if they needed to provide health guidance and also again because they told us these do require interpretation if there is an exceedance how concerned should I be if I'm a community member how what steps should I take to protect myself unfortunately when we asked LADPH if they had provided any of that guidance or provided any comments to the community about this exceedance information they were not able to point to any information that they had provided the community specifically about these exceedances so So despite the fact that they said they were going to, despite the fact that the exceedances require interpretation for people to understand, they had not directly commented on those exceedances at all. Further complicating things with this area is that when we asked them to show us proof that they had been reviewing the air quality data consistently, they were able to provide that proof for less than half of the air quality reports that the landfill had been providing. So we looked at all of the quarterly and monthly reports the landfill had provided about the air quality in the community and ledph had documentation evidence that it had reviewed less than half of those so that's concerning because it showed that the department didn't necessarily have a rigorous process for reviewing that and documenting the results of its review so we can turn now to the second area we covered in this uh missed opportunities for protecting public health which is the department's efforts to document the health symptoms that members of the community were experiencing. We're going to talk mostly about the health survey they conducted, but by way of background, before the department conducted the health survey, they had for about the first year and a half of its response starting in mid-2023, they had a hotline, a public health nurse hotline, an email address that members of the community could call in or email their symptoms to, and the department was logging those in a spreadsheet. So that's about the first year, year and a few months, what they were doing to collect health symptom information. But in late 2024 the department decided to transition to an online survey. They told us they did that to standardize the type of information that they were collecting, that they wanted to kind of have a standardized format for what people could report so that they could measure it differently than they had been. The department's rollout of that survey though was marked by some inconsistent messaging to the community, which we think could and probably did cause confusion in the community about what exactly this survey effort was going to entail. There were essentially two different places where the department was publicizing this survey. One was on the actual website where you could go take the survey, and the other was through door-to-door flyers that they were handing out. They did make an effort to go door-to-door to advertise the survey, and at most of those locations, though, they didn't actually make contact with a real person. Over 90% of the homes that they visited, locations they visited, they just left written information about the survey. So on the website, the survey was positioned or advertised as a month-long daily survey. So it was going to be something that starting when the survey opened, it was going to happen for a month's time, and people could log on daily to take the survey for that month period. The written materials that the department distributed though said something different They said that it was a retrospective survey essentially It was a survey of resident experiences over the past month So there was already some mixed messaging from the department about exactly what were the goals of the survey and what were people expected to do if they were to log on and take that survey. The most significant change, though, and sort of flaw in communication from the department came when they decided that they were going to extend the survey period. So kind of regardless of which one you read at the outset, the survey was initially advertised by the department as sort of a limited-term effort, right? Either a thing that was going to happen for a month or a thing that would happen for a brief period of time about the last month. And the community does seem to have understood that that was a limited-duration effort. And we'll look at the rate of responses here in a moment, and I think you'll see that that's the message that got through to the community, was that this was a limited term effort. But the department in late 2024 decided that it would actually extend the survey effort, but it made no proactive announcement about that. They updated their website, so if you happened to go to the website, you would have seen passively, basically communication, that the survey remained open. But unlike when they initially rolled it out and went door to door to announce the survey, the department didn't proactively notify individuals that the survey would actually continue, and it did continue on for over a year after that. I'll go now to the survey rates of response, and this is what I was mentioning just a moment ago. The message that the survey was going to go on in late 2024 came through loud and clear, as we can see from the rate of survey responses, and as the state auditor mentioned before, because of limitations in the design of the survey, we don't know how many unique individuals this is this is just the number of times somebody responded to the survey but you can see the steep drop-off after the department did not announce that it was going to continue conducting the survey there was clearly a drop in awareness or a drop in participation eventually when the department closed the survey in 20 26 they acknowledged that the community had been confused about this and that they didn't necessarily know that the survey was still open but part of the thing that's important to understand about this picture is the public health nurse hotline had essentially been transitioned out of existence by this point so this was the department's main and only tool for collecting information about the community's health conditions and as you can see it wasn't collecting very much information at all and it relied passively on people to voluntarily go to the website and report their symptom information as opposed to going out and proactively collecting that information. I'm going to go ahead and turn now to the second major area of our review and that is the limited communication and community engagement from the department. And we'll start with communication. So we spoke earlier about communication about air quality data but for this area of our review we kind of zoomed out to any communication at all, general communication with the community about the landfill event. And the story we found there is one of declining frequency, both in the written communication the department was issuing, but also the verbal communication they were having with the community. So with respect to written communication, in the initial months of the department's response, they were issuing flyers or handouts for the community about air purification or about things that they should know about the department response to the landfill event But we pretty quickly run into two pockets of significant breaks in written communication from the department the first is this march 2024 that a nine period where there was no substantive written communication from the department to the community about what was going on and then the second more significant is a 12-month period starting in february of 2025 so essentially all of 2025 basically the department was not issuing any substantive written communication to the community about steps they could take to protect themselves, about the condition of the error, about the steps the department was taking to coordinate with other agencies. None of this was being communicated to the community in writing. Similarly, there was an early sense that the department was communicating verbally frequently at CAC meetings. If you look at the CAC meetings from 2023 2024 the department was regularly showing up and sharing substantive information they showed up and did that at almost all of them from that 2023 2024 period but when you turn into 2025 and the second or the first half of 2026 the story is much different they show up and share substantive information at less than half of those meetings so we saw their participation in the cac meetings drop off significantly which meant the verbal updates that they could be providing the community had dropped off at that point it's not as though there wasn't things there weren't things for the department to be communicating about so we considered whether there were things they could have been sharing with the community in addition to the air quality updates they could have been providing there was also the opportunity to just provide basic information about things like RELs so that the community could better understand these concepts there were steps the department was taking as I said to coordinate with other agencies or to consult on whether there are possible cancer clusters. Those are all things that they could have been providing the community with information about but we found that they weren't doing so. So a lot of room for improvement in here and missed opportunities to better communicate with folks. Turning to community engagement, so community engagement involves communication of course but it also involves listening to the community's concerns and responding to them. That's sort of the differentiator here between communication and engagement so what we would have expected to see was the was the department having a two-way dialogue with the community and listening to and responding to their concerns so at a at a basic level we did see the department engaged in engagement activities so the ones on the screen are engagement activities that kind of cover the basic expectations so CAC meetings for example these are meetings for the community they are the communities meetings and ledph was at least in the early part of its response um showing up and being present at community meetings that's a that's a best practice that we identified on our audit and that's something that they were doing at least again in the initial months of their response but each of the activities on the slide right now also come with shortcomings. So the CAC meetings again are inherently limited when it comes to LADPH's ability to engage with the community. They are not LADPH's meetings, they're the community's meetings and they're given a certain amount of time to share their information alongside many other agencies and entities. Their average speaking time at these meetings is less than 10 minutes for meetings that can go on for multiple hours. So while they're admirable in one sense that they're there at those meetings and sharing information it's it's also not a complete engagement with the community they don't get a chance for example to respond to community questions at those meetings so going down the line The public health nurse hotline, we mentioned that earlier. One of the limitations there, again, it did allow them to collect information from the community, but only a total of 65 unique individuals ever called that hotline or sent email and emailed in information. So they were open to receiving information, but they reached only a very limited portion of the population by doing this step. The door-to-door survey I mentioned earlier, over 90% of the doors that they went to go visit, that they didn't actually interact with a person. They just left written information. And then there were several one-time activities, the town hall event they held to discuss the health risk evaluation results, meetings with school district officials. And those were probably, you know, good examples of the ability to actually have interaction with the community. But they were isolated events, and they all occurred in the first year of the response. And this response has been going on for three years now. So we expected that the department would take additional steps to overcome those shortcomings then but they didn't so this is the extent of their engagement activities they could have for example held more town hall meetings or even made the written communication that they were having more targeted to residents concerns we also reviewed related to engagement how the department responded to community concerns and it was a bit of a mixed bag In some cases they did seem to hear the community's concerns. For example, when the department was collecting information on the public health nurse hotline, they initially didn't really share any of what was being reported to them with the community until the community asked them to do so. By the time we reached the health survey, they proactively started putting the results of the health survey up on their website. So they did seem to get the community's concern about wanting to know what what is being reported to you could you share that with us there are other things though where we noticed they either didn't or didn't didn't respond to the community's concerns or didn't respond effectively a key example here is the effort to collect health related information from the community the community has long expressed a desire for LADPH to do more than it's done to go out into the community to meet in person with with individuals and collect health information from them essentially do something besides the passive collection activities that the department has engaged in and although the department initially did respond albeit not affirmatively not that they agreed to do so but they did initially respond to the community's concerns the community's concerns persisted and we didn't see LADPH's dialogue with the community persisting. We saw them no longer responding to the community's concerns for a more in-depth health study. They could have done so to continue to explain the reasons why they didn't want to. They could have ended up changing their minds and in response to community feedback, going out and doing more. But we didn't see them even continuing that dialogue, which is an important part of community engagement. So when it comes to communication and engagement, there are plenty of missed opportunities and examples in the audit report of how LED pH could have done a better job serving the communities around the landfill I'm gonna hand it over now to miss Jacobs she's gonna cover inconsistencies between health events and also the recommendations we made we were gonna do

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

thank you mr. Harris we're gonna do questions after but mr. Gonzalez you had a question just

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

super quick one yeah you may or may not know what was the radius of the outreach that they did

Senator Senatorsenator

I don't.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

It's not on you.

Senator Senatorsenator

I just don't know.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Yeah, no.

Senator Senatorsenator

I going to give a very broad answer It was to the general communities of Castaic and Valverde and the communities immediately surrounding the landfill

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

And who did they hire to do the door-to-door, or who did the door-to-door?

Senator Senatorsenator

I don't know that.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Okay.

Senator Senatorsenator

And then?

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

They used the staff.

Senator Senatorsenator

I'm sorry?

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Oh, who got a flyer at their house?

Senator Senatorsenator

Okay.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Sorry.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

I apologize, Mr. Arbidi.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

And last question. And I do have to get back. I'm going to leave in a bit, but I wanted to ask these questions. Lastly, in what languages was this conducted as well? Survey of language, right?

Senator Senatorsenator

Was it just English?

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

They had a Spanish translation of the survey as well. Not AAPI languages?

Senator Senatorsenator

Not to my knowledge, but they, it didn't require it based

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

on the threshold of languages for that community based

Senator Senatorsenator

on their procedures for language access

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

and who was using different languages. So they did review. And of that, was it just door knocking with a flyer or was it text messaging or was it like Instagram or any social media?

Senator Senatorsenator

We didn't see social media outreach or text messaging.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

So that was also missing from the overall audit.

Senator Senatorsenator

Okay, understood.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

I will let Ms. Jacobs go, but what time do you – because I want to make sure you can get your questions in.

Senator Senatorsenator

That was in about the next 30 minutes.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Okay, so I may just have you go first then when she's done.

Senator Senatorsenator

No, I apologize.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Okay, no, no, no, no.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you for those. WOULD YOU LIKE TO GO AND THEN WE'LL GO TO QUESTIONS. THANK YOU.

Senator Senatorsenator

THANK YOU, SORRY. THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR AND MEMBERS. MY NAME IS DANIELA JACOBS. I'M A SENIOR AUDITOR WITH THE CALIFORNIA STATE AUDITOR'S OFFICE. AND THE NEXT AREA OF OUR REVIEW THAT I'LL COVER HERE IS THE INCONSISTENT ACTION LADPH TOOK WHEN WE COMPARED THEIR ACTIONS IN RESPONSE TO THE CONDITIONS NEAR THE CHAQUITA CANYON LANDFILL AND OTHER HEALTH HAZARD EVENTS THAT HAVE OCCURRED IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY OVER THE PAST DECADE OR SO. SO WE REVIEWED FIVE EVENTS IN TOTAL INCLUDING THE RESPONSE TO THE CHAQUITA CANYON LANDFILL AND WE ASKED THE DEPARTMENT HOW IT ENSURES THAT IT CONDUCT A ROBUST AND CONSISTENT RESPONSE WHEN IT HAS HEALTH HAZARD EVENTS TO RESPOND TO. AND THE COUNTY HEALTH OFFICER TOLD US THAT THEY ALWAYS TAKE ACTION IN THESE FOUR MAIN AREAS, SURVEILLANCE AND MONITORING ACTIVITIES, MITIGATION STRATEGIES, COMMUNICATION AND RESOURCE COORDINATION. HOWEVER, OUR REVIEW FOUND THAT THERE WERE INCONSISTENCIES IN EACH OF THESE AREAS WHEN YOU LOOKED AT THEIR DIFFERENT RESPONSES. SO IN THE AREA OF SURVEILLANCE AND MONITORING, WE FOUND THAT THEY CONDUCTED MORE FORMALIZED ASSESSMENTS OF RESIDENTS' NEEDS AND HEALTH IMPLICATIONS FOR OTHER HEALTH HAZARD EVENTS THAN THEY DID WHEN RESPONDING TO CONDITIONS AT THE LANDFILL. SIMILARLY, AS WE'VE COVERED, THERE WAS MORE CONSISTENT COMMUNICATION IN OTHER EVENTS and more robust communication, especially in response to events such as Aliso Canyon and the 2025 wildfires. And then in the area of resource coordination, we found a notable example where the department did not coordinate with the county agency responsible for mental health, where it did do so in response to another event where it invited the county department of mental health to join it in an event it was participating in to make sure that residents were connected WITH MENTAL HEALTH RESOURCES. WE DIDN'T SEE ANY SIMILAR ACTION TAKING PLACE IN RESPONSE TO CONDITIONS AT CHIQUITA CANYON DESPITE MENTAL HEALTH SYMPTOMS BEING ONE OF THE TOP CONCERNS THAT WAS REPORTED TO THE DEPARTMENT. BUT ONE OF THE MOST DARK EXAMPLES THAT WE SEE IS IN THIS AREA OF MITIGATION STRATEGY AND ACTIVITIES TO PREVENT OR REDUCE HARM. AND THIS INCONSISTENCY IS BETWEEN THE ELISO CANYON GAS LEAK RESPONSE AND THE CHIQUITA So conditions persisting after Aliso Canyon and Chiquita Canyon were strikingly similar In both cases LADPH said that the conditions didn represent any immediate danger There weren health effects expected to continue long term and they were expected to stop once the odor exposure stopped. Similarly, a lot of the symptoms experienced were similar. Headaches, dizziness, nausea, irritation, and nosebleeds. So in both cases, we see similar underlying conditions, but in Aliso Canyon, it took the department only 22 days to direct the responsible party to offer relocation assistance to individuals affected by the hazard event, whereas it took them nearly two years, that's the 657 days at the bottom of the slide, to direct the Chiquita Canyon landfill to take similar action. And then you can also see at the bottom of the slide here that it took the county longer TO ENGAGE IN COURT ACTION ON RELOCATION IN THE CHEQUITA CANYON EVENT. SO AS A RESULT OF THE FINDINGS THAT WE'VE DISCUSSED TODAY, WE RECOMMENDED THAT THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS DIRECT LADPH TO CONSISTENTLY SHARE ITS ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH RISKS RELATED TO AIR QUALITY, TO PROACTIVELY COLLECT UPDATED HEALTH INFORMATION FROM RESIDENTS AND TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT THAT TOOK INPUT FROM THE COMMUNITY into consideration. We also recommended that the department itself should create policies and procedures to define how it responds to health hazard events to increase its consistency moving forward and that it should monitor its responses to those events by reviewing past ones for how it could improve. We did reach out to the department in advance of this hearing to understand if it had taken action and it said it had begun to create these policies as these were some of the only recommendations that it stated it would implement and we'd be happy to answer any questions thank

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

you incredibly thorough yeah absolutely round of applause incredibly thorough by all three of you thank you and we appreciate the level of detail that you just went into I'm I know Senator Gonzales has a as a time line here so I'm gonna allow him to go first are you sure okay no no

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

No, please. And if you do have more questions before you leave, let me know.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Senator, please.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Again, thank you all for your phenomenal work on this audit. I have five areas of questioning. There are not very many questions other than the five, though, so bear with me for a second. The first is around really understanding the audit. MR. PARKS, YOUR REPORT IDENTIFIED SIGNIFICANT SHORTCOMINGS IN THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH'S RESPONSE, BUT IT DID ALSO CONCLUDE THAT THE COUNTY'S SOLID WASTE ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM ACTED WITH REASONABLE SPEED AND TOOK APPROPRIATE CORRECTION, CORRECTIVE ACTION. COULD YOU EXPLAIN THE DISTINCTION? WHERE DID THE COUNTY FULFILL ITS RESPONSIBILITIES AND THEN WHERE DID IT FALL SHORT? And were the shortcomings primarily failures to exercise existing authority, failures of internal processes, or gaps in state law?

Senator Senatorsenator

Thank you for the question. Part of our work during the audit was to examine how the enforcement branch of LADPH was conducting oversight of the Chiquita Canyon landfill, I think up to two years before the event actually happened. AND SO WE WERE LOOKING AT INSPECTION ACTIVITIES, WE WERE LOOKING TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT THE REPORTS WERE BEING DONE ON TIME WHETHER OR NOT THERE WERE FINDINGS WHETHER OR NOT THE LANDFILL OPERATOR WAS COOPERATIVE WITH THOSE INSPECTIONS AND THEN ONCE PROBLEMS WERE IDENTIFIED were being done on time whether or not there were findings whether or not the landfill operator was cooperative with those inspections And then once problems were identified we were trying to evaluate how quickly was the enforcement program taking steps to ensure that the landfill operator was taking action to mitigate the effects of the subsurface chemical reaction. But to answer your question more specifically, I think I'll turn it over to Bob Harris. So to the part of the question, so LADPH has these two functions, and they really do operate very independently of one another. So staff don't cross over. These are very different individuals with very different processes in place for how they do what they do. So there is a significant procedural distinction. There's also a distinction of authority. So the enforcement program, it's a regulatory responsibility that they hold at the designation of CalRecycle. So there's a lot more law, criteria, regulations or whatever that they can hold the landfill or similar operators accountable to. That doesn't mean that the public health arm doesn't have what it needs in terms of authority. It just means that there's a lot of specificity to the regulations around regulating a landfill that don't necessarily exist for the broad scale responding to any possible health hazard, right? You asked, I believe, if there's sort of breakdowns in process or procedure. Yeah, I was curious to understand if it's established they have the authority in both departments of the oversight here. Were there internal failures of procedures, or were there any gaps in state law that we should be addressing from a legislative perspective? In reverse, no. We didn't identify any gaps in state law. There are no legislative recommendations in the reports. Nothing we feel like state law lacks or gaps in the criteria there. With respect to the internal processes and where those shortcomings are, as ms jacobs noted noted they don't have policies and procedures um they or they didn't at the time we conducted the audit we still understand that they're still working on those so when it comes to health hazard response they had no playbook so to speak you know they had no no uh set of instructions or a standard operating procedure for how to respond and that can lead to inconsistency that can lead to gaps in responses. We found that the predominant thing that we could identify that was affecting how they responded happened to be the expertise and the judgment of whoever happened to be running the department at the time that particular event happened, which is not where you want to be. You want to be in a position of having standard operating procedures. Not that they can't change or evolve or grow and improve, but you want to be in a position of having those SOPs. So do you find it strange that we just came out of COVID, you know, two and a half, three years ago, where there was immense communication, everything regarding public health, from vaccine access to you name it, right, to masks to you name it. Isn't it a little bizarre that no procedure exists? We would have wanted them to have a procedure. Yeah. So to look at the 657-day delay here, that was probably one of the most troubling revelations in the audit for me is that it took 657 days to direct relocation assistance compared with 22 days at Aliso Canyon. So what specifically should have triggered an earlier recommendation for relocation? Or what could have? If the department had standard operating procedures that defined what conditions should ask it to issue its directives, that would have provided the department with a framework for when it should take specific actions. WE COULDN'T IDENTIFY A CLEAR REASON WHY THE DEPARTMENT HADN'T ACTED SOONER IN THIS CASE, ESPECIALLY WITH SO MANY OF THE UNDERLYING CONDITIONS LOOKING IDENTICAL FROM THE RECORDS OF THE INDIVIDUALS WHO RESPONDED TO THE ELISO CANYON EVENT. SO WE, WHEN WE ASKED THEM, WHY DIDN'T YOU DO SO SOONER, THE DEPARTMENT OFFICIALS WHO ARE IN CHARGE NOW HAD A SENSE THAT ELISO CANYON WAS MORE DANGEROUS OR POTENTIALLY HAD BIGGER IMPLICATIONS, BUT THE RECORD SHOWS THAT THE CONDITIONS AND THE HEALTH ASSESSMENTS OF THE OFFICIALS AT THE TIME HAD SIMILAR ASSESSMENTS TO WHAT IS HAPPENING NOW CURRENTLY. SO THERE WAS NO GUIDING FORCE TO STANDARDIZE BETWEEN THOSE TWO RESPONSES. I THINK I WOULD ALSO ADD, TOO, THAT WE MENTIONED THIS IN THE REPORT, IS THAT LEADERSHIP AT THE DEPARTMENT CHANGES OVER TIME. And so ultimately you have these health officials and people in leadership positions who are making in their view professional judgments and people can reach different professional judgments perhaps. But I think the point that we raised in the audit is you know you don't want professional judgments to be so far apart. There needs to be some element of standardization where perhaps each health emergency isn't precisely the same but how you go about planning for it, what factors you consider as the inputs TO HOW YOU'RE GOING TO RESPOND, WHAT KIND OF DATA YOU'RE GOING TO SHARE WITH THE PUBLIC, THE THOUGHT PROCESS, THE PLANNING NEEDS TO CONSIDER THE SAME KIND OF INPUTS, AND THAT WAS THE GENESIS AND THE IMPUT BEHIND OUR RECOMMENDATION TO THE DEPARTMENT. A LITTLE BIT MORE AROUND THE HEALTH MONITORING, THE OBVIOUSLY WE SAW THROUGH THE CHARTS AND THROUGH YOUR COMMENTS THAT YOU MENTIONED THAT THE COUNTY NO LONGER HAD RELIABLE CURRENT information about the health symptoms that the residents were experiencing. Was there any, is there any even, you know, I know there hasn't been a response, but is there any indication of why this sudden drop off of monitoring, of collecting data, of engagement and communication in 2024? I mean, did it have anything to do with the lawsuit? I'm just trying to understand why there was, it felt like a lot of engagement to minimal. Right. Right, so I will deal with the collection of health information first. So the department told us that the health information it was collecting through the survey that it conducted was supplementary information. So it wasn't the only thing it was doing to monitor health conditions. But the things that it told us it was doing in addition weren't things that could actually tell you what the community's health conditions were. So they mentioned things like monitoring the number of notices of violation issued by the Air Quality Management District. Well, those notices of violation tell you that someone didn't like the way the air smelled, but they don't tell you what health symptoms they're experiencing. So they're an indicator that the air stinks, but they're not an indicator of what I might be feeling health-wise. So we didn't find the other things that the department said it was looking at to be sufficient really for its argument that like well we have a good handle on this because we reviewing all these other pieces of data with respect to engagement the only thing I say is the department position was that it felt like it was sufficiently engaging with the community we obviously don't agree with that we think that they could have been doing more but as to why it dropped off in the later period I will note that it did their attendance at CAC meetings does seem to tick up again come 2026, but we were, you know, had to cut it off at some point because we were about to release the audit report. But they didn't provide an answer with respect to engagement other than we feel like we've done a good job, essentially. Okay. In terms of legislative fixes identified, are there any specific changes to state law that would have enabled a faster or more effective response? So the Landfill Safety Act that Assemblywoman Schiavo sponsored is probably a really good step in that direction. It puts in place, as she mentioned in her opening comments, a lot of requirements that had they been around for this event would have changed how responsible departments would have had to respond. than that, no, we don't have any other legislative recommendations in the report. So to dig into that a little bit, though, because I did support the Assemblywoman's bill, but that is essentially just monitoring of gases and what is that? So what am I missing in terms of an addition? Because you just said earlier that it's not simply the monitoring of emissions or odors, but understanding the health impacts. So I'm just trying to connect the two. I won't speak for the Assemblywoman, but it does include also a component in the bill about health studies. Okay, okay. Thank you. This is your fault. So my last area is really about accountability implementation. Which of your recommendations do you think is the most urgent for protecting the residents of our community today? I think it's all about health ultimately and so our recommendation that the department really needs to put up on its website its own public assessments about what are the health impacts when you have these exceedances. Don't leave the community in the dark. It's kind of a fundamental question of a public health officer. Protect the public. Let them know what's going on. And so being more transparent by sharing with the community either you should be concerned or you shouldn't be concerned. I think that's job one. I think job two is there's a real responsibility for the public health officer to engage in continual monitoring and survey of health symptoms in the community and do so in a way where you're able to track individuals to understand how widespread the problem is. And I guess my third, if I had to pick only three, the third one is, you know, you think of emergency response agencies after a wildfire disaster or another emergency event, they always engage in after action reports where they look at what went wrong, what needs to improve, what can we do better. That was a recommendation we made to the department. Position yourself to get better. Clearly what happened here at Chiquita Canyon wasn't the greatest example of how it should be done. Let's learn from this and let's figure out how we better serve the community the next time something happens. I just make one what happening because it still existing And then lastly you know I just want to thank you all for taking so much time to understand this audit I'm sure that we're going to have lots of follow-up, but all of your recommendations to clarify, all of the recommendations in the audit right now can be done predominantly administratively at the county level. They don't have to be, there doesn't need to be a state intervention. If there was a desire to do it, they could do it on their own without state intervention. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you, Senator. Senator Rocheva.

Pilar Schiavoother

Thank you, again, for all of your thorough work and explanation tonight so our community can really understand what has gone into the many months that you put into these conversations. I imagine sometimes frustrating conversations with LA County Department of Public Health. And you know, I mean, I just think it's truly unbelievable, some of this stuff. The fact that they were not communicative during March to November of 2024, I have the the summary of the South Coast AQMD reported complaints and NOVs, that is the worst time. That's the worst time in the last four years. They were having, during that time, there were 2,200 complaints a month for multiple months during that time, 1,500, 1,400, 2,500, again in September, 1,500 in October. And November came down, and December, when we have the Santa Susanna winds, which is also when they happened to do their health study, and they said, oh, the air's not so bad. It's not so bad. It's like background. So, you know, for them to not communicate with the community during that time, it doesn't make any sense to me. And if you'll indulge me for a minute, I have a visual aid for what the time that it took and what we are experiencing. It took two billboards, or what are these called? Poster boards. Thank you. Thank you. Two poster boards to get Chiquita Canyon complaints on the board. AND AS YOU CAN SEE, CHIKITA CANYON IS THE REDDISH-ORANGE. THOSE ARE AIR COMPLAINTS. ON THE LEFT, NOTICE IS A VIOLATION. ON THE RIGHT, WHICH MEANS THAT BASICALLY A BUNCH OF THESE WERE CONFIRMED AND THEY ISSUE A VIOLATION BECAUSE SO MANY PEOPLE GOT THEIR COMPLAINTS CONFIRMED. SO THAT'S CHIKITA CANYON. AND THEN THE OTHER COLORS ARE TWO OF THE OTHER ONES THAT YOU COMPLAINED, YOU COMPARED IT TO. So Aliso Canyon is in the blue, the smallest bar on the right, and Dominguez Channel is in the green in the middle. So we comparing 38 complaints to 4 or 2 in the other instances And then on the far left on my left on your right there a line with some numbers That's the days that it took LACDPH to act. As you can see, the other two instances way at the bottom, eight days, 22 days. As you heard, it took two years for us here for them to take any action. 657 days. And no one's been evacuated, have you? Has anyone been evacuated yet? No.

Senator Senatorsenator

No.

Pilar Schiavoother

No state of emergency. So this is mind-boggling that they would not be communicating with people in the height of this, right? Should they give you any understanding or explanation of why they just didn't communicate at all during that time? Other than the fact that they felt like they were doing a sufficient job already, no. If doing nothing is sufficient, then I guess they would be right. So you know, what is incredibly frustrating to me is that this is what they do. I, you know, before getting elected to the state assembly, I, for 13 years, was a nurse advocate. I worked with nurses. I fought for healthcare. I fought for community and public health. And I have said this directly to the leadership of LACDPH, that it is so frustrating that I fought for my career to bolster public health, to support public health departments like theirs, and they have deserted our community in the time when they need them. And I can't, can you, I hear what you're saying today, and I still don't hear a sufficient answer on why they have not acted sooner, why they haven't acted more decisively, why they haven't communicated with our community, why they haven't done a real health survey where they actually know who they talked to and how many people it was. How do you not know how many people you communicated with in a health survey? This is crazy. I mean, did you hear anything?

Senator Senatorsenator

It's a lot of air complaints to review, so I'll give them that. It's a lot of work. But did you hear anything that kind of explains this or you found any sufficient answers on this? I WOULD SAY WE DIDN'T GET A CLEAR ANSWER FROM THE DEPARTMENT ABOUT WHY THEIR ACTION WAS AT THE LEVEL THAT WE SAW IT AT. AND WHY DID YOU CHOOSE IN A COUPLE OF YOUR COMPARISONS ALISO AND DOMINGAS CHANNEL AS THE COMPARISONS? I DO HAVE TO STATE THAT DOMINGAS CHANNEL WAS NOT ONE OF THE COMPARATIVE EVENTS THAT WE CHOSE. TWO OF THEM WERE IN THE AUDIT REQUEST THAT YOU SUBMITTED, INCLUDING THE ALISO CANYON RESPONSE AND THE RESPONSE TO THE 2025 EATON AND PALISADES wildfires. The other two events that we looked at were the city of Paramount, hexavalent chromium. emissions as well as City Terrace, which was another landfill that had potential concerns about health effects due to emissions from that closed landfill. Okay.

Pilar Schiavoother

You know, this is, so the Attorney General just, I was at a press conference with him on Tuesday. He and the Department of Toxic Substance Control both are suing, so the state of California, different agencies are suing Chiquita Canyon for mismanagement of toxic leachate, the garbage liquid that has all the toxins in it, right? And suing for mismanagement of it, spills, illegally disposing of it, they're carting it to other communities too. And so I know my colleague, Mr. Gonzalez, was talking about how the lineage trash was brought up to, I think, Sunshine Canyon, which is also in my district right down the road. And so, you know, issues in other parts of the community become issues for other parts of the community as it's exported. This leachate, millions and millions of gallons of leachate are now being trucked, illegally trucked down to, I think, Supervisor Hahn's district to a place where they should not have been treated and then were dumped in the LA River and then flowed out to the ocean where it's everybody's problem if you go to the ocean. So this is becoming a regional issue. And what has been frustrating about County Department of Public Health is that all of these different agencies, I mean, AQMD is killing themselves over here documenting all of this, right? People know the investigators by their first names because they come to their homes regularly and verify all the complaints that you all have a full-time job of reporting. And if I ask in the meetings that I would convene with all of these agencies that are responding and they're all reporting everything they're doing and, you know, trying to figure out the kind of maximum of their authority to act and take action. Department of Public Health most months didn't report anything out. And when they told me, when they came the beginning of this year and said that they were going to close the survey, they said, Dr. Davis said basically that they had enough information now that it was clear that the landfills making the community sick. And so they had what they need. AND OBVIOUSLY MY NEXT QUESTION WAS, GREAT, WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO NOW? AND YOU KNOW, HIS ANSWER, WHICH WAS THE SAME ANSWER IN THE LETTER THAT THEY SUBMITTED TODAY, AND HIS ANSWER REGULARLY WHENEVER I ASK WHAT THEY'RE DOING, IS TO POINT EVERYWHERE ELSE. WELL, IT'S A MULTI-AGENCY RESPONSE. WELL, THERE'S A BUNCH OF AGENCIES. WE ALL HAVE A ROLE TO PLAY. AND I LOST MY MIND FOR A SECOND, AND I SAID, NO, YOU ARE THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH PUBLIC HEALTH IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY WHAT ARE YOU DOING ON PUBLIC HEALTH health Public health is your responsibility What are you doing on public health The rest of the conversation didn go very well but at the end of the day it was there was no

Senator Senatorsenator

answer. There's no answer. And we have, you know, schools like this one, like the schools down the street who have to check air monitors before they decide if they're going to send

Pilar Schiavoother

KIDS OUT TO GO TO RECESS OR TO GO TO LUNCH. AND I'VE ASKED PUBLIC HEALTH, CAN YOU COME MEET WITH THEM? CAN YOU HAVE A TOWN HALL WITH OUR COMMUNITY TO TALK WITH PARENTS AND SCHOOL STAFF SO THAT THEY KNOW WHAT ARE YOU READING IN THIS AIR MONITOR DATA? HOW MANY PARTS PER BILLION AND PARTS PER MILLION IS DANGEROUS? I MEAN, THIS IS, YOU HAVE TO BE A SCIENTIST TO UNDERSTAND THE DATA THAT YOU'RE PRESENTED. They are supposed to be our interpreter, and it seems like that's an important thing that they could have been doing this whole time. Is that correct?

Senator Senatorsenator

That is correct, and that's essentially our first recommendation, is that you need to be sharing with the public whether or not they should be concerned based on what's in the air that they breathe every day. I mean, they should be, and one of the limitations that I think I understand that they have is that for them to send out text messages, it has to be kind of emergency, right? There's a fire, something like very, very urgent, and it's a whole negotiation with another agency to be able to figure it out. But if they have to, this is a 20-year-plus problem that we have. This is not going away anytime soon. There is no silver bullet. They are covering it and sucking out the gases and trying to burn them off and doing all of these things. that hopefully make it better, and it seems like from the construction when they peeled it back this summer, it's definitely making it better, but it's not fixing it, and it's not solving it. So you cannot sit on your hands as an agency responsible for public health for 20 years and not have a plan. They have no plan. There's no plan that I've heard about. Did you hear about a plan? No plan.

Pilar Schiavoother

Okay. Okay. Yes, go ahead.

Senator Senatorsenator

There's a community plan specifically for the event of a slope failure that they've been working on in conjunction with the landfill, but I wouldn't say a broader, different plan. And that's something they just asked the landfill to come up with a plan in the last six months. And a slope failure means that the landfill slides down the hill into the community because it has liquefied so much. That is what this means. That's what they're planning for. And they don't have a plan to say what we should do, though.

Pilar Schiavoother

Do we shelter in place? Do you think that would be safe? Anyone? No. How are we going to evacuate people? So this is, you know, at the end of the day, it's clear from my interactions with leadership because the last thing I'll say is that you raised the issue Mr. Harris about how with the air monitoring sometimes people can have symptoms or what was the distinction you made it was symptoms and health effects and symptoms adverse health effects below the REL and I tell you I didn know a whole lot about landfills before I got elected and unfortunately I know a lot about landfills now And one of the things that I have learned is that the science has not caught up with our landfills And what that means is they are only monitoring certain chemicals, right? Hydrogen sulfide being one of them. BENZENE, A CANCER CAUSING CHEMICAL, BEING ANOTHER ONE THAT WE'RE VERY CONCERNED ABOUT. BUT THERE'S A COCKTAIL OF CHEMICALS, RIGHT? IT'S BURNING PLASTIC. THINK ABOUT EVERYTHING THAT GOES INTO TRASH. THAT IS WHAT'S BURNING OVER HERE IN OUR LANDFILL. AND SO THERE IS NO SCIENCE THAT SAYS, OH, THIS COCKTAIL OF CHEMICALS THAT YOU'RE BREATHING, THIS AMOUNT OF AIR IS DANGEROUS. WE'RE OPERATING WITHOUT THE SCIENCE THAT WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO EXPLAIN WHAT PEOPLE ARE ARE EXPERIENCING. AND WHAT THE DIRECTOR FOR RARE HAS SAID TO ME IN MULTIPLE MEETINGS I'VE HAD WITH HER NOW IS THAT WHEN THE SCIENCE IS NOT THERE, THE COMMUNITY HAS TO BE THE SCIENCE. THOSE ARE HER WORDS. BUT STILL THEY ARE NOT ACTING ON THE COMMUNITY AS THE SCIENCE. I DON'T SEE THAT. I DON'T SEE THAT IN THIS REACTION OVER HERE WHERE IT IT TAKES 657 DAYS TO ISSUE A NOTICE AND STILL NO ACTION HAPPENS WITH IT. I DON'T SEE IT FROM JUST WAITING FOR A LAWSUIT THAT'S GOING TO BE TAKING YEARS. AND SO IT IS, AND IT'S NOT LIKE THEY DON'T KNOW. LIKE YOU SAID, THEY'VE BEEN SHOWING UP. THEY COME TO THESE MONTHLY MEETINGS THAT ARE THREE HOURS LONG WITH PUBLIC COMMENT AT EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM WHERE PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT ALL OF THEIR HEALTH SYMPTOMS. For years they've been doing this. It's not like they don't know what's going on. I've definitely been telling them what's going on in our meetings. We've been having press conferences. I've been camping out here to get attention to it. Like anything to get them to act, sending letters to the board of supervisors, asking them to get them to act, right? Our whole LA delegation sent a letter with specific requests on public health, about studies, about informing the community, holding town halls, all of these things. And so the only conclusion you can come to, I feel like, at the end of the day, is that it is a failure of leadership because there's no other explanation. Because we keep showing them what's happening and how terrible it is, and they keep not showing up. They keep pointing the other way. They keep explaining it away. They keep gaslighting our community. There's lots of reasons you have nosebleeds, didn't you know? So, you know, this, for me, this, I'm so grateful for it because it validates what everybody here has been feeling and experiencing and just feeling like you're banging your head against a wall with County Department of Public Health and getting no action and no protection for our community. And that is why I am at the point where either they implement these, they do real health surveys on a regular basis, they implement your recommendations, and if they are not going to do that, they need to be removed and replaced by the Board of Supervisors. And the Board of Supervisors needs to tell Department of Public Health, and there are many good, caring people at Department of Public Health who I know are sick to their stomachs over what they see and hear from our community And their hands are tied because of the leadership And so, and you guys know them. And we need the Board of Supervisors to demand that LA County Department of Public Health implement these solutions, do a real health study, be present for our community, communicate with them, and make sure that they are showing up and helping our community in a real way that supports them. And I am ready to fight for money at the state level. I will partner with them. I don't care what it is as long as it is going to help our community. I am down. I am down for all of the things that it takes to help our community in a real way. So, you know, that's where I've ended up with your audit and knowing, you know, what we have all experienced is we need either action, a change of leadership. And if neither of those things will happen and the board will not act, which so far they're refusing to do, then the state has to come in and act. We can't wait. We cannot wait any longer. Thank you. Thank you for all of your work. Thank you so much.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you, Assemblymember. Thank you. Thank you. And I want to thank Assemblymember Gonzalez for being here, and I just want to thank the three of you, Mr. Parks, Mr. Harris, Ms. Jacobs. Thank you very much. And you guys can go back to your seats and appreciate everything we just discussed. At this time, typically the auditee would come and testify because Department of Public Health isn't here. We will not have that. They have submitted a letter. It is on the website. It is part of the record. Supervisor Barger has submitted a letter. It is also on the website and part of the record. But now we will go to our next panel, Perspectives on the Audit. So I'm going to ask for the panel members to join us here at the table. Jane Williams, Executive Director for California Communities Against Toxics.

Senator Senatorsenator

Jennifer Elkins, former president of the Val Verde Civic Association. Stephen Howes is here, and he will be testifying. Jose Bobadilla and Darcy Stinson. So as you guys are taking your seats, I think that Jane Williams is going to go first. Okay. So, Ms. Williams, whenever you are ready, the floor is yours. And thank you for being here. Thank you for all of you for being here and taking the time to lend us your voice and tell us about your experience. It's very important, and it will help all of us hopefully get you guys relief in a proper way. So with that, Ms. Williams, thank you, and you can begin whenever you're ready.

Pilar Schiavoother

Thank you so much. Well, first of all, I'm Jane Williams. I am the executive director of California Communities Against Toxics. I also chair the Sierra Club's national clean air team. And I'm extremely sorry to be here today. And the irony is that I have worked for 20 years with Mr. Gonzalez in East L.A. on the Exide catastrophe, which is the largest and most expensive environmental cleanup in this country's history, Second only to the Hanford Nuclear Reservation. I've been working in Ms. Schiavo's district now. This February will be five years on this landfill. And I had the unfortunate circumstance of getting to work in Mr. Harabane's district on the Altadena fire.

Senator Senatorsenator

Okay.

Pilar Schiavoother

And so I also work on disasters and fires in other states because I have this national position with the Sierra Club. And so I have a very unique perspective on this problem. And I share many of Assemblymember Schiavo's observations about the Department of Public Health.

Senator Senatorsenator

Okay.

Pilar Schiavoother

Now, because of the lineage chemical disaster and fire, I had to do quite a bit of research on why is this happening? Because right now, Chiquita Canyon is the longest ongoing chemical disaster in the country's history. And that was not me that had that observation. That was a senior member of the EPA team that's working on the landfill fire. And usually a chemical disaster is short-lived. Believe it or not, it's short-lived. You have something that happens, something explodes and blows up, and then you sort of have this resolution period, okay? That's not happening here. And in fact, I was telling your staff member, Colton, in the car here, I have worked on a number of different things in my career now since it's more than three decades old, And this Chiquita Canyon landfill fire, you say, is my black eye on my career. Absolute, utter failure.

Senator Senatorsenator

Okay?

Pilar Schiavoother

Because when I started working on it, I thought, okay, we have this apparatus in the state that's going to respond. And that did not occur. So that response did not happen. It's very similar to the lineage fire where you thought a response was going to happen and it didn't happen. And so what's interesting is that if you have a dam that's going to break, so just in the other district over, you had the St. Francis Dam, right? A very famous dam that broke and killed hundreds of people. So in the state of California, we have all of these authorities over evacuations now. So if you have a tanker truck full of chemicals that goes over on the freeway, you have like four different people that can declare an evacuation. A dam is going to break, you've got four different people, all the way from your cabinet level to somebody on the ground to somebody in the middle. We don't have that in this situation, and we don't have that at Lineage, and we don't have that in things like the Garden Grove chemical disaster. We only have one person that can issue an evacuation order, and that is the local public health officer. And so I am, I feel very terrible disagreeing with the audit committee because they did such an amazing job, but one of the things that I want from the next governor, I want new evacuation numbers, because the evacuation numbers that we have now, which are the RELs, do not protect women and children. They do not. They'll protect a 42-year-old guy on a ladder in great physical shape. They do not protect a two-year-old toddler. They do not protect a pregnant woman. And so I've asked Dr. Chris Thayer, who's head of our Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to issue new evacuation numbers. And so if you're doing air monitoring and you exceed those numbers, you should be issuing evacuations. And that's a hard number. That's not where you've got discretion. It's like, no, you need to evacuate at these numbers. That is something that we may need the legislature to weigh in on The second thing is why is it only for chemical disasters like Lineage like Garden Grove like Chiquita, that the only person that has evacuation authority is a local public health officer? Now, just to be very blunt because I'm known for that and because I'm too old now not to be, okay? Why is there only one person in the state that has the authority to issue an evacuation order? And just think about it selfishly as an elected official, right? Like, would you want that pressure put on you when there's a lot that can happen when you issue evacuation? I am sure that you have seen how pissed off people were in Garden Grove. They just held a big town hall meeting, 600 people showed up. These people here would like to be evacuated. pissed off because they were. So, but here's what I say about what happened in Garden Grove. No one is sick. Okay? Yes, their businesses were, you know, they have interruption of business. They had to move out of their houses for five days. But they are not going to be facing a lifelong public health crisis like the people here in Chiquita and quite frankly the people in Lineage. So Lineage is now the state's largest chemical disaster. 20,000 have sought public health care, okay, someone's going to get that tab. And this is why I think that I disagree with the audit committee, and I think that the legislature does hold a role here, okay, because in 2021, we had nine chemical disasters in the state of California. This year, we're at 24, and we're not done yet. So, when you look at what is happening across California, and I just want to tell you I got a call from Yana Garcia who's Cali PA secretary because she knows I'm an expert in these kinds of situations. Like, what's happening? It's just aging infrastructure, isn't it, Jane? I'm like, if only it was that simple. No, it is not. It's a series of three things that are happening. Lineage was only built in 2018. It's not aging infrastructure. The warehouses that burned down in Ontario and in Modesto, huge disasters. Brand new. Relatively brand new. Garden Grove, why can't you keep a water pump running? Darcy, why can't you keep? It's like a pump that you have in your swamp cooler. Okay, I live on a horse ranch. I've got to keep a bunch of pumps running. I have extra ones on hand in case something breaks. Their pump broke, and so they had a chemical disaster. That has to do with heat and human error. So what we know about these disasters is that there's three major causes. Aging infrastructure, do we have that? Yes. Human error, do we have that? Yes. And NATEG events, natural disasters, earthquakes, flooding, heat, etc. But here's what we know. These disasters are increasing in size, duration, and impact. And Pilar will tell you, this is not the only landfill fire we have in California. So we are now actively managing three landfill fires in California, Elsa Bronte, Chiquita, and Avenal, which I want to shout out to my colleagues here that went to Avenal yesterday for a public meeting. Okay? A delegation of folks from Chiquita went there. Okay? So I'm on the board of Green Action for Environmental Health and Justice, and they're responding to that landfill fire. And let me tell you what's going to happen in Avenal. If the state and the feds can get in front of it Avenal is going to look like Chiquita it going to look like Val Verde in three years and you have a small town there and you going to have to evacuate the whole town So enough said on this, but there is a role for the legislature to play. Chiquita is an absolute and utter failure by the state. It is a failure by the Department of Public Health. And my own personal view is that when I look at the comportment of the leadership of the Department of Public Health, it is negligent. It is completely negligent, not just at Chiquita. At Altadena, at the Palisades, and at Laneige. And I'm really sorry that Mark left because we have known each other now for way too long, and now he has the double disaster of Exide and Laneige. So thank you for the opportunity to give testimony. Thank you.

Senator Senatorsenator

Ms. Williams, I do know that you have a hard deadline, so are you going to?

Pilar Schiavoother

There's no way.

Senator Senatorsenator

Okay.

Pilar Schiavoother

In fact, I'm supposed to be accepting an award in East L.A., so I do not have to leave.

Senator Senatorsenator

Well, thank you.

Pilar Schiavoother

I just said that there's no way.

Senator Senatorsenator

I appreciate that. Okay. Well, then we will wait for the questions then. Okay. We will now thank you for that. I'm going to go to Ms. Elkins. Thank you, Jane, for being here with us tonight. I know this means a lot to all of us. And I just wanted to add that Avenal is now accepting trash that would have been going to Chiquita Canyon. They're taking our trash. So we're putting one burden onto another community that's already burdened.

Jennifer Elkinsother

Good evening. My name is Jennifer Elkins. I'm a Valverde resident, and I'm also the current president of the Valverde Civic Association. My home is around 1,500 feet from the reaction site at Chiquita Canyon Landfill. We have been dealing with this disaster in our community now for four years and have seen no end in sight, no real solutions, and no real relief for the residents. Over a dozen of my neighbors have been diagnosed with cancer in the last two years. You can walk down the street and point out more neighbors who have had cancer than those who do not. My family, including my children, have suffered from severe nosebleeds, hives, skin irritation, respiratory issues, irritated eyes, headaches, and other health impacts. We've also had several pets die prematurely on our property in the last few years. I emailed the public health nurse almost daily for an entire year. That's what this is. These are my emails. The only response I received was that the symptoms would be logged. advice, no questions, no action was taken other than the logging of our symptoms. There is no policy or procedure, no standard practice. I don't know if public health didn't know how to respond or just didn't want to, but we got absolutely nothing from their department. And I'd like to read you just a couple of the emails I sent so you can kind of have a sense of how that went. This was dated September 25th of 2023. I said, we left the town for a few days and had zero symptoms. It's the best we've felt in months. Came back home last night and guess what? Symptoms have returned this morning. Burning eyes and throat, congested sinuses, headache, nausea, fatigue. What more needs to be done for public health? Step in and actually do something. The county and the schools keep telling us the air is safe. It just smells bad, but we are breathing toxic gases, and our symptoms and health issues tell me the air is not safe to breathe. The response I got was, thank you for the report. I'm adding it to the additional reports we have received in your previous reports and forwarding them to the leadership team in public health. And this was our response that we would get after every email. Public health claimed to do a door health survey and I can tell you that nobody ever came to my door to talk to me about a health survey There was never a flyer left at my door, and honestly, I've asked all of my neighbors, and I can't find a single person who can recall someone from public health coming to their door. The health survey itself was a joke. I found out about the survey from the town council meetings. The questions were based primarily on odors and asked questions about health symptoms when smelling odors. There was never an option to report health symptoms when odors were not present. Each question had a drop-down menu with options, and there was nowhere to input something that wasn't listed in that drop-down menu. There was also a lot of confusion about when to fill out the health survey. Some thought it was a one-time survey. Others said, I'm not filling that out every time I smell an odor. That's multiple times a day. I already report to AQMD. It was very confusing and very unclear when we were supposed to fill out the survey, how often and for how long. Many residents weren't even aware the survey existed. What we did receive at our door were flyers from the landfill with what they called myths versus facts, where they proceeded to gaslight us once again. I will go ahead and read you one example of that. under myth. They said the reaction is causing long-term health impacts, including cancer. Next to it, the column says facts. Both Chiquita and LA County commissioned independent toxicologists to evaluate air quality in the communities around the landfill and assess potential health risks. The studies by these experts found no expected short or long-term health impacts from the landfill. Yet we have dozens of people with cancer. The recent work on the western toe of the landfill began before the community was ever notified, before the cool room was open, and before there was any plan in place to protect the community. Just recently we had a benzene exceedance in the middle of the night, and the only notification residents received was an email at 2 AM. There was no emergency protocol, no emergency response. It wasn't even investigated until residents woke up in the morning and reported the exceedance to government agencies. In any other emergency, like a fire, there would be a text message alert. Alarms would go off, sheriffs would be knocking on doors, there would be a shelter in place order. None of that happened. And then, just like any time we have an exceedance here, we were told that the exceedance was a false reading due to faulty equipment. I'm not buying it. We have sat at meeting after meeting, month after month, year after year. Our questions don't get answered. Public health is pointing fingers, blaming other agencies. We get the notorious, we'll get back to you next month, which they rarely do, or it's just crickets. It's like talking to a brick wall. We keep our windows and doors closed at all times. My children cannot play outside, and I've had to make the heartbreaking decision to relocate them to schools further away to protect their health. They had to leave their friends and community and start all over to get away from the toxic landfill air. I now commute about three hours each day to drive them to and from school. We sign our kids up for sports and activities clear across town just so they can have a chance to play outside. Too many of our neighbors have had to move away and are now struggling financially, paying double or triple the mortgage and property taxes they used to. Many others have no choice but to stay in their homes and suffer through the persistent air quality issues and health impacts. We have been asked countless times, why don't you just move? Why did you buy a home next to a landfill? But nobody asked the landfill to move. Nobody asked the county, why did you allow the landfill to be built next to homes? Founded in 1924, and the landfill began operating in 1972. Nobody asked the county why they approved hundreds of new homes to be built in close proximity to this environmental disaster either. I have had neighbors who have had to leave their home in the middle of the night and sleep in a Walmart parking lot because toxic landfill gases were invading their home. Public health, it is your job to protect us. Protect our health. Our health is not being protected. Public health has three core functions. Assessment, collecting, analyzing, and monitoring population health data, health status, and community hazards. Policy development, using scientific data and community partnerships to create laws, plans, and policies that promote health. And assurance, making sure essential health services, regulations, and a skilled workforce are available and equitable for everyone. Health has the ability to give the recommendation to relocate residents to protect the health of the community. They didn't do that. Instead, they took some air samples during Santa Ana winds and spent hundreds of thousands of dollars for Dr. Love to tell us that there are no health risks while dozens of neighbors dealt with cancer and miscarriages and heart problems and respiratory issues. Many with symptoms so severe that they couldn't function normally. They allegedly went door to door to hand out some flyers and told residents they could take an online survey. They did enough to say that they did something, but they didn't do enough. LA County Department of Public Health, you have failed this community, and you didn't even have the courage to show up tonight to face us.

Senator Senatorsenator

Thank you, Ms. Elkins. Mr. House.

Stephen Houseother

My name is Stephen House. I'm here on behalf of my wife, Brandy. She very regrettably came down with a fever and got sick yesterday, and I had to do everything I could to get her to stay in bed and not come tonight because she desperately wanted to be here. So I'm going to do my best to read the statement that she wrote down for me to read. One second, pull it up here. So it says, Hello, my name is Brandy House. Thank you for having me here today and listening to what I have to say. We moved to Val Verde in 1998. I was excited to be a first-time homeowner in a little town surrounded by hills and away from city lights. We had just had our first child, and it looked like an amazing place to grow up. We were told about the landfill, but we were assured it was closing. Now, this is in 1998. We soon found out that was not actually the case. I was concerned, but I believe the agencies in place would keep us safe and would never put us in harm's way. Wow, was I naive. Through the years, things got worse. At first, we smelled it a couple times a week, and it was really bad every once in a while. As the years went by, though, things progressively got worse. We now smelled the landfill daily, and we were all afraid something bad was going to happen if Chiquita Canyon landfill was allowed to stay open much longer. So in 2017, when the conditional use permit was up, we were sure that the landfill would honor the contract and the community would close. We were heartbroken and betrayed to learn that the county had signed a new conditional use permit that would allow Chiquita to be open for an additional 30 years. A period of time mind you that Chiquita Canyon Landfill was never designed for originally Then in 2022 we began having all sorts of symptoms We were fatigued all the time, terrible brain fog, headaches, burning sinuses, sore and hoarse throats. We had nausea so bad at times that it would make us vomit. My youngest son began to have nosebleeds two to three times a week. At first, it wasn't connected until the neighbors began talking. They, too, were having the same symptoms, and their kids were also having nosebleeds. I began getting very anemic, and I was having to go in for iron transmutions every six months. Then, in February 24, I was diagnosed with an aggressive stage 3 breast cancer. After being tested and cleared only a year and a half earlier, I was shocked. originally I didn't think it had anything to do with the landfill until I realized that 10 other neighbors of mine also had cancer. Sadly, that number has grown to, from what I understand, 13. Going through cancer meant chemotherapy, radiation, and added autoimmune disease of type 1 diabetes. This means years of medication that I still currently need to take. These are, she asked me to bring them, some of her, these are cancer treatment drugs there. And then these are all the other stuff she's got. She has to have a Dexcom. She has to carry around insulin shots. She's got other ones. She has to have a nebulizer. These are all things that she has to take on a regular basis. And what it does, the cancer treatment, it suppresses the white blood cells. I'm doing a tangent. It suppresses the white blood cells. And so that's why she gets sick a lot more often, because her body can't fight off an infection that a normal healthy person would. So these are some of the medications she's on and will be on for the rest of her life, unfortunately. Later, through a health study, we learned that women in our community were 57% more likely to have a miscarriage. This felt like a punch in the gut. I myself have experienced five miscarriages, one being a set of twins. Sorry. Two of these miscarriages happened at 18 weeks, nearly halfway through my pregnancies. I was told that it was just a fluke the first time with my son, Azariah, and that there was no reason it would happen again. But it did. and I gave birth again to my silent little Jacob at 18 weeks. Despite all of these difficulties, Valverde had been home to us for over 27 years. We had raised four children there. We loved our community and the close relationships we had built there. Our home in Valverde fed our needs too. It was near town, not too far from my husband's work, and because of when we bought, it was very affordable. This was important as it allowed me to be at home with our kids, which was very helpful since we have two children with special needs. It made it possible to get them the therapy they need. Our home was the perfect price and the perfect place. But with Chiquita Canyon Landfill so close and no resolution in sight to keep us safe, we just did not feel safe there anymore. I felt as if we stayed, one of us might even lose our lives. Through a ton of prayer and faith we decided to put our home up for sale Honestly we were not sure it would even sell We put right in our listing which we not required to do that was less than a mile from the landfill, and we lowered our asking price three times below comparable homes selling in our area. It took quite a while, but to our surprise, despite being very upfront with all the potential buyers, our home did actually sell. This decision to move has cost us dearly. We now pay over twice what we did for our Valverde home. And at 50 years old, we were just four years from being able to take our property tax base with us, where we were able to keep the same tax amount with us. Now, financially, things are so tight for us, not just because of new home expenses, We are farther from town. We're further from my husband's work. The commute has doubled. We are struggling not just financially, but we also miss all of our friendships and our community we built in Valverde. These people are like family, and we have a hard time being able to spend time with them. Was it worth it, though? I would say yes. We are no longer suffering with all the symptoms that we did in Valverde. My son has not had one bloody nose since we moved in January of this year. Not one. My daughter, who lost the majority of her sense of smell, can not actually smell normally again. We thought maybe it was COVID or something. A couple of months after we moved, she's like, oh, my gosh, I can smell again. We didn't even think that was really a symptom of the landfill issues. We took our special pet chickens, you know, the ones that aren't laying anymore with us, and all of a sudden they started laying eggs again. Overall, our life has gotten much better since we have moved. With all of that said, so many of my friends and neighbors are still living in the shadow of the Shakita Canyon landfill, and they are unable to leave. We are asking you to hear them and help them. This is a toxic problem that is not going away. They need your help, and they need you to step up. And I just want to add on my own comment here is that one of the things, we were one of the closest homes to the landfill. and we can definitely stay say that getting out of the area and going to a different place has improved our health dramatically for my entire family so anytime that they're saying with studies like the doctor love studies or a Pelley County Public Health or stating that you know all you know it's okay it's not that bad that is not true if you get these people out of the community of Verde they will get better doesn't mean that all their symptoms are going to go away that is not permanent I don't know that's for some doctor to say but I will say from my experience if you leave the area if you get these people out of the area their symptoms and their health will improve and it needs to be done and I really would hope that the LA County Public Health would listen to the community step up and make that make that determination and make it happen Thank you.

Senator Senatorsenator

And thank you to your wife, who we hope she feels better and probably is watching from home. So thank you to Brandy as well. Mr. Bobadilla.

Jose Bobadillaother

Buenas noches, Presidenta y miembros. Mi nombre es Jose Bobadilla. I been a resident of Valverde since 1982 I bought my house in 1994 where I lived very close to the boatyard in 2002 I started my business with my business. I had a restaurant and I was the cook. I started to experience health symptoms in 2016, and there were some bumps that have been worse with the time. My symptoms were when I started the disaster of the Chiquito Caño in 2023. I have a lot of other problems in my health, pain, anxiety, stress,

Senator Senatorsenator

Formigueos, intensivimientos, niveles muy altos de azúcar, en la sangre dificultad para respirar, problemas cardiológicos. Mis manos comienzan a temblar tanto que ya no puedo usar los cuchillos para trabajar. to cut the food with care. My health problem made me lose my business because I couldn't work. I hope to see my restaurant. Good night.

Senator Senatorsenator

Thank you. I'm going to translate his speech into English so that you can hear the rest of it.

Senator Senatorsenator

Good evening, chair and members. My name is Jose Bobadilla. I have been a resident of Valverde since 1982. I bought my house in 1994, where I live very close to the landfill. I started my business in 2002. I owned a restaurant and I was the cook. I started experiencing health symptoms in 2016. Tremors that have gotten worse. My symptoms worsened when the disaster at the Chiquita Canyon landfill started in 2023. I developed many other health symptoms as well. Headaches, nausea, dizziness, stress, tingling and numbness, very high blood pressure, difficulty breathing, and cardiovascular issues. My hands started to shake so much that I can no longer use a knife to carefully cut food. My health problems caused me to lose my business because I could no longer cook or operate my restaurant. Then I lost my home, a home I worked so hard to buy, a home I thought I would retire in, a home where I now lost everything I paid into it. Now I am living with my family and depending on them because I am so sick, I have become disabled and can no longer support myself. Where was public health when we needed them? Why are they not studying our health impacts? Why didn't they demand that residents be temporarily relocated to protect our health and well-being? That is their job. The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health has failed this community. We deserve better. Nobody should have to suffer the way that I am suffering, the way our community is suffering.

Senator Senatorsenator

Thank you, Mr. Bobadier. Thank you very much. Mr. Stinson.

Assemblymember Thankassemblymember

Oh, my gosh. This sickens my heart. So many people are suffering that I didn't know with so many of the same concerns. The same health problems. We've asked departments of every government agency public agencies. Citizens of Cass State has gone to Sacramento to advocate for our community citizens. I'm sorry I need to start off saying I'm Darcy Stinson. I'm here for myself but I also sit on the Cass State Area Town Council as a board member because people need their voices to be heard and we as a community has been has have been pretty much told to shut up and so the community needs people to stand up and I know that this hearing is about LA County Public Health but I'm gonna say LA County Public Health answers to the Board of supervisors and as much as this board is asking for the board of supervisors recommendations the board of supervisors does not have any care for the community of castake they have shown this and proved this multiple times and so I as much as I love this hearing and I love what this board did or the the The auditor's office did. Somewhere I read in here that you're requesting the board of supervisors to make decisions. We have been asking the board of supervisors to make decisions, ask for a state of emergency, ask so many different things to help so many of the citizens go through the struggles that they are going through. And it's crickets. It's, no, we don't need a state of emergency. We're not going to. However state of emergencies get declared for all the other, this might be wrong saying this, wealthier communities. Our communities are not a very wealthy community. But other communities get it. I have some personal things but I have a house in Valverde I lived I don know if you can tell like I sad but I am angry I am so mad at it. I feel like it's taking over me right now. And I just, just want to scream. The houses were my next door neighbor. they weren't just neighbors, they were family. I made the decision to move out probably about a year and a half to two years ago. I got cancer. Cancer came back. Going through struggles in my life sucked. And I'm here in my house thinking, oh my God, I'm going to make my daughter have cancer because I'm choosing to live here. So we had to dig down to our finances, and luckily we had them to get another place. And so we have now two homes. I still have my Val Verde home. Still paying mortgage on my home that's useless. My taxes, everything. The health department knows this. I have text messages from them. One of the text messages I'd like to read, back in 2023 to the health department and to a lady named Christina, I think De La Rosa. And as, like Jen said, and other people, this is kind of the response. So I said, this is at this is at 1.32 a.m. I woke up right now. My wife's nose is bleeding all over the bed and has severe sore throat. My throat hurts as well currently, and we have insanely strong odors, and who knows what else. Our entire house smells like the dump right now. It is super strong. The next morning at 10, just want to let you know today, the landfill was issued another notice of violation. Was still counting. And this was at 5 p.m. Just want to let you know, the landfill got their 40th notice of violation. I never thought we'd have this many notices of violation. I mean, AQMD, the Terrence Mann kept saying, oh, well, if you get a couple, actions will happen. Well, nothing's happened. They're not paying any other fines, so who cared? Back when they could have fixed it, they chose not to. Anyways, the response from LA County Health is, good morning. Regarding your complaint, there's a lot going on behind the scenes, which I had yet to see what was going on. um we uh i will note that your complaint is in our database which i know doesn't feel helpful but it is a data point for us so that's what la county health cared about our health is it's just a data point we are not data but to la county public health i guess that's what we are I'm going to say some of the things. The health survey that supposedly went around door to door I have a I ex I kind I ex I like to know my awareness and my surroundings So I have security cameras everywhere. So when they said they came door to door, I said, what date? I will sit all day looking at my cameras because nobody came to my house. I didn't get to refuse anybody. At my house, I had 900 feet away from the landfill. I know it's not up there, but on the map that you guys, or that the board did, that bottom, you know, you have the landfill at the bottom. That bottom square, the bottom right corner is my house, Stephen's house. Jen's house is just a tiny bit more up. But that's where we are. I mean, we're closer to the landfill than anyone. But they didn't come to my house. I asked all my neighbors, all of them. None of them came. And the only thing I can think of then is they didn't come to our house because they know what the answer is. We're all getting poisoned, and they don't want to hear us say it. But I'm going to say it. We are getting poisoned. And everyone was. And so I, the other thing, the CAC meeting, I was the president of that board for over a year before the 2017 expansion. So I know how it runs. How it runs now, so back then the community came in, the community came, voiced their concerns, and we listened. And the board was responsive. And the supervisor's office with Michael Antonovich and Ros and Wayman, I feel like they actually involved themselves and they cared somewhat. During this time, Valverde does not have a representative on the board, which on the other committee we had two. People such as myself, when I lived in Valverde, requested to be on the board, was denied. The houses requested to be on the board, denied. Other residents here that sit on the Cass State Town Council, denied. Why? They're in Val Verde. The county won't give a reasoning why, but we are not heard. And so that's why I feel like the Board of Supervisors, I don't think if you guys make a recommendation, it needs to be something more than that because I don't think they are going to care. And I don't know if anyone's really saying that, but I really, as much as I hate to say this because you guys have taken your time and so much effort, but I just don't see them actually caring because there's something else that's going on that none of us are aware. Our governor's office said that they'll look at a state of emergency, but it has to be signed by the Board of Supervisors. She's the controller. So their office made it pretty clear when we were up in Sacramento that they'll assign a state of emergency, but it has to be signed by the Board of Supervisors first. They denied, and Stephanie English said, We will never sign a state of emergency. Why is there a difference for us versus other issues? I know I probably past my time but I just also wanted to say I had two dogs in Val Verde They both died of cancer Something great Not great That's a very bad choice of words. When I would walk out of my house, this is one of the big things that helped me move. When I walked out of my house, I could look at the houses directly from the street of my house and see seven homes. Five of the seven homes had cancer. When I expressed this to LA County Public Health and Dr. Love and did their health studies, I was on the board at COC. Their response was, well, that's normal for a cancer cluster because of the percentage. But they tied our cancer cluster, not just Val Verde in our small area, but like in a gigantic area that's not affected by the landfill. And so of course it's not going to be just like Mr. Gonzalez talked about the battery excite. What if they did a health study and I'm not familiar with that. Did they do it about, you know, communities in towns away and use that data for the battery excite? I don't know. But my guess is they probably took the surrounding area like it should be done and that's the health study. County hasn't done that for us. The timeframe for the survey, you know, at the CAC meetings, it's half the time the meetings are a joke. Sorry, but I thought it was a one and done deal for the survey and I'm tied into the community. So either I'm a complete idiot and didn't know or most people thought it was a one and done. LA County didn't say. Something that's in this report says that public health don't have a lot of time to speak at the CAC meetings. That's a, I don't know where they got that information because that's also false. They're given approximately 10 minutes, that's kind of a guideline. If they go longer, they can. AQMD does, EPA does, Todd Sachs does, so, and nobody, you know, Bob doesn't shut them up. They keep going. And the people that are limited are the community members to like three minutes and then they're done. But LA County could, has been asked questions or LA County Public Health, sorry, LA County Public Health is asked questions and they don't respond. I've been told by LA County Public Health nurses that their hands are tied. They feel sorry for us. A lot of the lower end people at LA County Public Health, they actually care. So not all of LA County Public Health is bad. But the superior leaders of LA County, we're told that it doesn't go beyond that. That they don't know why, but they're just here to take our information. I thank you for this. I think there's a lot of flaws in it. You know, LA County Mental Health, a community member involved already opened up a mental health, not a mental health, it was an unsanctioned mental health group, like anger management group. ...or stuff, you know, as in the military, you know, people that are veterans have anger management problems, I guess. Well, somebody in our community opened up a group where we could go, and there we found, I found out, like, I used, so my hand's pretty good right now. I would say, I tremor a little bit. Before, my hand was like this. I would drop cups. The VA had checked me for Parkinson's, and they were like, no, you don't have Parkinson's. We don't know what's wrong with you. We have no idea. Nerve conduction tests from up here to down here. Stuff. I explained all this to public health. They knew everything. But it was just, thank you. That's it. And so at this group, I found out so many other people. Like Jose, I'm finding out now. I'm sorry. I'm going to go start crying again. And I just really don't like doing that. I thank you for your time. I've probably spoken way too long. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you to each of you. The strength, what we just heard, I know it's hard to do this, and it's more meaningful than you guys know. I mean, I do think that as hard as it is for you to get up here and tell us your stories, it is so important for us to hear it. And so I thank you. I know that your representatives thank you. I know Senator Rochiavo thanks you. I know the Senator Valadez thanks you. But I do think that it is clear from hearing your stories, the stories of the community. I was here with Senator Rochiavo almost two years ago now. I don't know the exact date. Many of you were there as well. And it's startling to know that from then until now, there's still just little action and little help. And I do think that you guys should know that you're going to get help, and that's why we're here. And you have folks that are going to ensure that, and I think that you may seem powerless. What you're doing now is really, really important, and it's going to get you help. So that's why we're here. That's why I allowed you to take as much time as you want. And it's really impactful. So with that, I'm going to open this up for questions. I unfortunately have to go home to my kids. but this was something that is important to me it's important to your representatives I know it's important for you but I feel very privileged and honored to be here tonight to hear this and we will help and we as a collective with every level of government hopefully kind of rowing in the same direction but I want to make sure that each of you and anyone watching knows that you're not alone you're obviously not alone and as much as you feel like over time you've been alone, you're not. Okay? So I'm going to allow the committee members, Senator Varadaris, to go first and then Senator Schiavo. But I appreciate every one of you and thank you for the testimony. And again, thank you, Mr. Chair.

Grant Parksother

I know Halloween is coming up for your kiddos this week, So have a blessed weekend and it was thank you very much Each and every one of you thank you for your story and know that everyone on this dais knows that while you well this is very hard I'm sharing your story in front of California is not easy and we know that your voice and your story doesn't just represent your voice in your story there are so many others that you're representing and thank you for

Senator/Assemblymember Pilar Schiavosenator

THAT. I'M GOING TO, OH, I HAVE THE GAVEL NOW. I'M A COMMITTEE MEMBER ON THE JLAC COMMITTEE, SO THE CHAIRMAN HAS HANDED THE GAVEL OVER. I'LL ASK SOME QUESTIONS AND THEN I'LL LET THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER FINISH WITH HER QUESTIONS. SO MY FIRST QUESTIONS ARE FOR JANE. YOU HAVE obviously vast experience with these types of environmental disasters. Can you tell me, are there any other similar disasters in which their local public health department has stepped in effectively and what they've done differently than what LA is doing? is a poster child of that where we had the state's worst childhood cancer cluster and the public health department in the county of Kern in the mid-80s refused to do anything and so the state public health department stepped in. Okay. And that is why I have a long and illustrious history with the Department of Toxic Substance control because they came in and investigated and cleaned up toxic sites all throughout the community. Secondly, I would point to the Garden Grove response where the Department of Public Health was the CUPA. The CUPA is the Certified Unified Program Agency. They were one and the same. So the fire department came in and said, okay, we've got to do like a quick evacuation, but then they worked together within an incident command to say, wait a minute, we have a tank in the middle that is reacting. we have two tanks next to it, if all three tanks go, we're going to have a mass casualty event, and they did an evacuation. And that was exactly what should have happened. So it's very interesting to talk to the first responders. When you respond to chemical disasters, you get to know each other because most of the people are the same people that you're seeing over and over again, right? And I think there were some people that felt that the response to the Garden Grove disaster was was overly cautious, right? But when you look at what I just saw in Toledo, it was not overly cautious because you have a 10-mile-long plume and you have tens of thousands of people affected. And the same thing with lineage, where they should have evacuated and they didn't, and now you have 20,000 people that have sought health care. A certain percentage of those are going to end up with permanent disabilities. So as state legislators, and I know that Assemblymember Schiavo was on the health committee. So I don't know what committee is using it. I'm the vice chair in health as well. Right. So you might be interested to know that the Casmelio toxic waste dump, which is over in Santa Barbara County, where they had brought in all this liquid toxic waste, and they were actually spraying it in the air, and the whole town of Casmelio was sick. The doctors took out a full-page ad in, like, in the Santa Barbara newspaper. Okay. So, what the town of Kasmelia did is they closed their schools and they had school in the state legislature They took the kids with desks okay to make the point right and they closed this is the Casmelia toxic waste dump they closed the toxic waste dump they had a huge you know, cleanup, US EPA was involved, Department of Toxic Sub, the state came in, right, and did this, but it took this very dramatic action of literally this town holding school in the of the legislature for a number of days, by the way. Okay? So I have been part of some of these actions in the past. So as a policy maker, right, we definitely see the good, the bad, and the ugly. This is the ugly. Lineage is the ugly. Garden Grove is the good. The Santa Susana Field Lab and the Sandy Fire, I hate to say it, it was the good because they brought in the Department The Department of Energy strike team, they put nuclear monitors all around the lab and then they used the new CAL FIRE planes that are linked to the supercomputer in San Diego. They flew the planes in there, they could see, oh yeah, the fire's going to go across a nuclear lab. They basically carpet bombed the northern boundary with flame retardant, then they brought in drones and they could see the fire was there. They're like, they carpet bombed that with water and they saved the Sandy Fire from going over the Santa Susana field lab. This was a huge incident command that happened just this past May. So do we have modern technology? Do we have structures and incident command? Do we have policy that allows this to occur? I am here to tell you as the first advisory committee member on our California Accidental Release Program and the person who has sued the federal government on the risk management federal prevention plans my entire career that we have an infrastructure that should work and it does work at times. So the question here, and I just applaud the audit committee, because they're trying to get to the point is why is it failed here? Why is it failing? Well, and I look at two components, right? I look at the public health component, which is for me obviously the most pressing. We have people that are sick. We have people that are dying. Pets are dying. And so I think I'm trying to understand, you know, if there has been a public response to any public health department response in any similar community. We would love to have further conversations about that. But the other component is the cleanup component, right? And whether it's the Army Corps of Engineers at the federal level, whether it is technology in California, it's my understanding there is an energy company in northern California that removes waste from landfills, takes it to their facility, burns it at 4,000 degrees, all within a safe, secure location where there's zero emissions and even can destroy toxic waste. Has any of that technology been used in any similar disasters that you're aware of in the past? Yes, that's a conversation for a little bit longer. Okay. A little bit longer conversation. No, a little bit longer conversation, but let me just say, okay, that we, at this point, a number of the folks in this community just recently did our own public hearing on the remedial action work plan because the state refused to hold a public hearing. And I am very critical of the state's actions on a number of these toxic sites that I work on, not just this one, because part of our national structure under our Comprehensive Environmental Response and Liability Act is that whatever remedies you are doing, like the one that you just talked about. The remedy needs to have a scale towards permanency. And one of the things that happening at Chiquita is that you just going from one crisis to another It this Band it this Band it this Band it this Band And it like no Very interesting how the national contingency plan came about. It was insisted upon by General Stafford, who was the Republican chair at the time of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee. Because when CIRCLA was first passed, EPA jumped into all these toxic sites and says, you know what, we're just going to burn everything. And people did not like that, because now you've got a toxic site in your yard, in your community, and now you've got incinerators being dropped in, and then all that stuff going in the air. And these were incinerators that were mobile. And so they actually passed what are called the SARA Title III amendments to CERCLA, Superfund Reauthorization Act. And it insisted that local communities be involved in decisions on the remedy selection. Okay, local communities are supposed to have a say in remedy selection and those remedies are to tip the scale towards permanency, not towards short-term remedies. And right now, our governor and our state on a number of these sites that we have, either chemical disasters or long-term problems like this one, are doing these short-term remedies. And many times it's been extremely difficult to get information. Like, I am an information nerd on landfills. Everybody knows this. And I still do not have the waivers from South Coast on this landfill. We have requested from South Coast all the waivers that they've granted to the landfills in their regions. And we are probably going to have to sue that agency to get those waivers. So there's fundamental problems of transparency

Senator Senatorsenator

and of our state's compliance with federal law with the National Contingency Plan. So I hope that, I'm not sure that gets exactly to your, is there something better we can do here? Absolutely. I could lay it out for you like bing, bing, bing. This is what we need to do. At Lineage, this is what we need to do. At Exite, this is what we've done and this is what we're doing. And so you have to start asking yourself, why programmatically is this structure that was put together in the mid-'80s by Republican leadership in our Congress not being followed today in our state? That is a fundamental question that I look forward to talking with the relevant committees on as we move forward in the next legislative session and with a governor who, by the way, comes from East L.A.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Assemblywoman. Thank you all so much. I know it's incredibly painful to talk about this over and over and over and over, but as our chair mentioned it really is impactful your stories are why we have passed legislation in Sacramento and continue to make progress at the state level and continue to make it impossible to ignore us here locally so I want to be if we can be super quick I do have a few questions or things I want to point out but I also want to make sure we get to public comment as quickly as possible because I know it's getting later Jane, if you can just very briefly, and if you don't have it in front of you, I do, on the CASPER study, but I think it's important to point out that because Department of Public Health would not do a real health study to assess people's health in a way that you could analyze and draw conclusions from, The community, you led a community effort to do a CASPER study. in that, you know, to fill that void, basically, and do the work of Department of Public Health. Can you talk about what you found?

Senator Senatorsenator

I have it here if you want a cheat sheet. Oh, no, I know what I found. I just don't want to be the only woman on the board that starts to cry, okay? Because so far, Gina and I are doing pretty good, okay? So, I'm like, okay, because...

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

That's why we got tissues on the table, lady. It is not pretty. It is not pretty. Okay.

Senator Senatorsenator

First of all, let me thank you very much. I might need a little bit of emotional support here. First of all, I want to point out that I don't know if the audit committee asked the Department of Public Health this, but to my knowledge, the last CASPER study that the Department of Public Health did was the Aliso Canyon study. Okay?

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Right. Okay. Okay, because we had just did one.

Senator Senatorsenator

So I led the CASPER study here at Chiquita, and then I initiated the one at Lineage. So we have one done at Lineage too.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Can you explain, sorry, first? So let me tell you what a CASPER study is.

Senator Senatorsenator

Explain what a CASPER is, yeah. Okay. And it's very ironic that I'm the person doing CASPER studies now in LA County because one of my colleagues who was a very prominent environmental justice advocate who just died in January down in Wilmington. Jesse Marquez, the executive director of Coalition for a Safe Environment, created, pulled all these health surveys that had been done for like 20 years. He and this other person, Jill Johnson, who now works at UC Irvine, okay, they pulled together all these studies back 20 years ago, and they created this Casper protocol for Wilmington, where we have four refineries and giant tanks of stuff, whatever. And then the CDC actually adopted it as a quick way to get a view of what is happening during a disaster. And so this CASPER protocol now is a protocol that is endorsed by the Center for Disease Control, and we have used it. We've used it in Maui. We've used it at some of the disasters in, like, Katrina. We've used it at some of the other disasters that I have responded to, okay? And it is designed to be done in like three days by volunteers. Okay? It's quick. It is quick. And there's a number of templates that you can use. We created our own templates specifically for Chiquita because it was a landfill. And there's not usually disasters at landfills. I know you guys might think that's crazy, but we don't usually have chemical disasters at landfills. So we did that study with some of the community members here as volunteers over really, about two months, right? And of course the findings are what you would expect to see, but also what you would not see. And here's why. First of all, yes, you see higher cancer incidence. Yes, you see people with inhaler use much more, or new inhaler use, okay? You see people with bloody noses all right you see people with tinnitus which is very unique usually at chemical disasters we do not see tinnitus we see that okay here but the thing that you usually do not see at a Casper survey are miscarriages and the reason for that is because women don't want to talk about it it is a taboo subject especially in the Latino community but But even among more well white women they do not share even with their closest friends if they had a miscarriage or not It is a societal taboo And so it was shocking to me because I did a number of the surveys myself I interviewed people and it was shocking how many miscarriages there are. And now when I talk to the community, not only are there elevated miscarriages, but you do not have children being born in this community anymore. And this is a very fascinating, I've never seen this before, it is a fascinating, so sociological impact because most of the families that have children of childbearing age have asked those children to leave their households. And we saw that in the CASTR survey that I live in a multi-generational household. My 25-year-old son lives with me with his partner, right? And so you see this. This is multi-generational households now, usually two generations if not three. And so you will see babies in households and we don't see that. In the communities that are closest to the landfill, you're not seeing that anymore. The other striking thing that we saw in the CASPER survey was social cohesion erosion. And I hate to say it, but this panel is the perfect example of that. You make these very strong social ties in a functioning community and it is those strong social ties that we have in East L.A. for my colleagues that are here, right, that allow you to be resilient in the face of societal shocks, whether that is an economic downturn, a pandemic, a flood, a landfill fire. And what happens during these situations like this is you get a diaspora. It's happening in lineage right now. People have left the community and they will not come back. So the other striking thing about the CASPER survey that is just heartbreaking is that people who used to get together walk their dogs, take their kids to the park, have potlucks. They don't do that anymore because you cannot be outside. And so that further erodes social cohesion. It further erodes it. And the fascinating thing that I read just two weeks ago was the 10-year study on Aliso Canyon. Okay? So it's not the public health study. It was a 10-year retrospective done by UCLA. And the striking thing was that these people who were evacuated, who actually were evacuated twice, okay, and a CASPER survey was done, and it was a huge thing, and it was a mess, but they feel invisible now. They feel invisible. And this is a fairly wealthy, much more upper-middle class. You would not think that social cohesion has been eroded. It has. And we see also in what is called the Maui study, which is now the longest longitudinal study post-disaster that we've ever done, which is three years from Lahaina, we see this sense of invisibility, which is that your people don't see your suffering and your people don't care. And to me, that is one of the biggest problems that we have. And when you see the Maui study, what you see is especially striking is young people no longer hope. They no longer believe they're going to have families, they're going to own homes, they're going to have kids and a career. And so these social psychological problems that you have after a disaster or during a disaster in this case have long-term public health impacts that are beyond whose nose is bleeding, who has tinnitus, or who is using inhalers. It is a long social shock to the communities that are enduring them And now unfortunately we are going to be enduring them more and more and more because we got our landfills on fire we have flooding we got things like lineage happening now. We have 24 chemical disasters. We had nine five years ago. So, both of you being on the public health department, the specialty services of mental health for these communities is going to become more and more and more needy and apparent as we see how these communities are impacted over time. At lineage right now, what we see at the three month mark after a major disaster is rise in suicide rates. These things have a horrible toll. I hope that is responsive to your question.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Yes, I mean, thank you. It's, the impact is profound and the ripple effects are hard, are really hard to quantify in a lot of ways because of you see this community of people who love each other and like family and being broken up because of this disaster. I just wanted to highlight a couple numbers out of that health study, and I know it took Department of Public Health a couple months with my encouragement. Have you talked to Jane about this study? Have you talked, have you looked at the results of this study? And I guess after a couple months, they finally called you.

Senator Senatorsenator

But let's be clear why they called me. I'm sure you would like to believe it was because you asked them to. But what they really needed was the study for their lawsuit.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

They wanted your data. They wanted the data.

Senator Senatorsenator

Yeah. Okay. The data that they should be getting. Okay. At the end of the day, it's very important to understand that we did the study and I made a personal guarantee to everybody that their data would never be shared. Okay? The surveys that we did all went back to the original people. So everyone who did a survey has their survey and they are welcome to do whatever they want with it. They can put it up on a billboard. They can give it to the Department of Public Health. They can, you know, give it to their attorneys. they can do whatever. And I was very clear with the Department of Public Health when they called me twice, and by the way, Waste Connection called me four times wanting the survey, okay, that if they wanted the survey, all they had to do was call a couple community leaders and say, hey, I would like to have the surveys. Put it in the paper. People would send you their surveys, right? But here's the real thing, is that because they lost their preliminary injunction because they had not done a health study. YES, RIGHT. I MEAN, ULTIMATE, LA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH IS A LIABILITY ON THIS ISSUE, TRULY, BECAUSE I DON'T THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE REALIZE, BUT THE LAWSUIT THAT THE COUNTY HAS DONE, ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS THAT THEY WERE SEEKING WAS A PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION, WHICH IS LIKE THE FAST INTERVENTION, RIGHT, WHERE THE court makes a quicker decision on action. And we were really hoping that that would come quickly. It's been a couple years. And it did not come quickly. And there was a lot of back and forth. And also the landfill, of course, is in the mix, mucking it up. But essentially it seems like if you look at the decision, it was not clear to the court who had been impacted by the landfill And that LACDPH job to go figure that out So that action that we could have the $20 million they're suing for to help relocate people did not happen. There was no quick judgment on that because they did not do their job. It's just failure after Failure after failure. I just want to point out that we asked them to do a CASPER survey at Lineage. And they told us, me specifically, we do not have the personnel or the money to do that. And two weeks later, they did a health survey door-to-door of hundreds of people.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Yeah. Okay.

Senator Senatorsenator

So you have to ask yourself why, when they clearly did have the personnel and the people, why don't they want to do a CASPER survey here, and why don't they want to do one lineage? And by the way, why didn't they do it at Altadena? Okay, and here's why. Because CASPER surveys are a specific protocol that makes the results of the survey statistically able to be spread over large distances. okay it's a statistical sample all right and it's clear to me now they don't want to do them I don't know why they don't but they don't so that's that is a question like if I had informed if I had had informed the audit more I would have asked the auditors to say why why do you have these disasters that keep happening you just look at what we have endured in the last three years in LA County with Two fires, landfill fires, chemical disasters, oil spills, right? Why isn't the county doing castor surveys anymore? And this is a region-wide issue that we have to have protocols for and rules of the game. There has to be rules of the game, and there are none. They're not willing to implement them according from their response to the audit, and neither is the county Department of Public Health. And so I think to your point, Jane, the state has to step in in this instance. And just to know, a CASPER survey costs nothing to do. Right, you can get volunteers. You can train volunteers to do it. We do them for free. We do them for free.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

I know we want to get to public comment. I'm just going to make comments. I was going to ask all of you questions, but I won't. I'll just kind of make a quick comment, and then we can get to public comment. But, you know, on the CASPER study, so we know there's been mention of the Dr. Love health survey, WHERE THEY CAME IN AND TESTED THE AIR DURING THE SANTA ANA WINDS. AND, YOU KNOW, AND THEY USE THAT CONSTANTLY AS, WELL, THE AIR IS JUST LIKE BACKGROUND IN L.A. COUNTY. I HAVE BEEN ASKING L.A. COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH, DR. DAVIS AND DR. QUICK AND DIRECTOR FOR AIR TO PLEASE COME AND HAVE COFFEE WITH ME IN JENNIFER'S BACKYARD AND TELL ME AFTER A HALF HOUR IF THIS FEELS LIKE THE REST OF L.A. COUNTY AIR, BECAUSE I'LL TELL YOU WHAT, IN MY PATIO, I DON'T GET BURNING EYES AND BURNING SKIN AND A BLOODY NOSE AND HEADACHE AND TINITIS AND ALL OF THESE THINGS, RIGHT? THAT DIDN'T HAPPEN IN MY PATIO. AND THE CASPER STUDY SHOWED, FOR EXAMPLE, HYPERTENSION, THREE AND A HALF TIMES THE LA COUNTY AVERAGE. HEART DISEASE, 10.7 times higher than the California average. Cancer was 24.6 times higher than, let me see, the county average. But miscarriages 57 times higher than L.A. County normal. AND THAT IS HEARTBREAKING. AND SO, YOU KNOW, LA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH CAME UP TO THE HEALTH COMMITTEE. THEY PRESENTED ON ALL THE THINGS THEY HAD DONE ON THE FIRE. THEY HAD THIS BEAUTIFUL POWERPOINT PAGES AND PAGES OF THINGS THAT THEY HAD DONE. IT'S IN COLOR NORMALLY, BUT WE SAVED ON PRINTING. BUT PAGES AND PAGES, AND I STARTED CRYING IN THAT COMMITTEE HEARING BECAUSE YOU COULD barely fill one page for what they've done for our community. Barely one page. And I know there's frustrations around their response to the fires, too. And for us, it's like a thimble, you know? So that's one thing. Steve, you mentioned moving away and that some of it has, the symptoms have gotten better, right? And that's what DPH, I think, has been saying, right? Well, if you just go away, go somewhere else, it's going to go away. So it's not chronic. It's not permanent, right? But how is it not permanent when people live here 24-7 and you can't just leave all the time? You sleep here. You live here. Your kids go to school here. Some people work from home. This is a 20-year issue, 24-7. We have to treat it as a chronic issue, and there has to be new science around that. And then, Darcy, you talked about your tremors. A lot of people have tremors in this community. I've met so many people. I'd be in rooms like this and ask people to hold up their hands, and people hold up their hands shaking, right? IT'S UNFORTUNATELY VERY COMMON. AND ONE OF MY OTHER FRUSTRATIONS IS THAT I'VE ASKED DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH MANY TIMES IN THE MEETINGS THAT I'VE HAD WITH THEM TO INFORM LOCAL HEALTH PROVIDERS. CAN YOU JUST LET THEM KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON? BECAUSE EVERYBODY HERE IS GOING TO THE DOCTOR, GOING DOWN A RABBIT HOLE, TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IS, WHY DO I HAVE THESE RASHES? WHY DO I, YOU KNOW, HAVE A HARD TIME BREATHING? WHY DO I HAVE TREMORS? WHY DO ALL THESE THINGS, RIGHT? You're getting tested up the wazoo to figure out what's going on with you, and you move away, and lo and behold, it gets better. Not gone, but better. And so it's an unbelievable waste of resources that is happening where everyone is spinning their wheels trying to figure out what's happening with their body. And Department of Public Health has refused, refused. And they do this all the time. THEY WILL DO THIS, I MEAN, OBVIOUSLY COVID, THEY WERE SENDING OUT ALL KINDS OF NOTIFICATIONS TO HEALTH PROVIDERS, RIGHT? MEASLES RIGHT NOW, THEY'RE DOING NOTIFICATIONS TO HEALTH PROVIDERS. AND THEY REFUSED TO DO IT. INSTEAD, THEY DID A WEBINAR TO GENERALLY ON TOXICS, AND WE HAD TO WE HAD TO WE HAD TO THEY HAD A COUPLE SLIDES ON CHIQUITA SPECIFICALLY BUT IT WAS LIKE A VOLUNTARY WEBINAR. WE DON'T KNOW HOW MANY DOCTORS, WHO, FROM WHERE, IF ANY OF YOUR DOCTORS WERE THERE. DID ANYONE HEAR ABOUT THIS FROM THEIR DOCTOR? NO. YOU DIDN'T. OKAY. SO IT'S JUST LIKE ACTION AFTER ACTION AFTER ACTION, OPPORTUNITY AFTER OPPORTUNITY FOR THEM TO STEP UP AND DO SOMETHING. THEY CONTINUE TO FAIL TO DO IT. AND YOU KNOW, LIKE THE CHAIR SAID, WE ARE GOING TO FIGHT FOR THIS COMMUNITY UNTIL REAL ACTION HAPPENS. AND IF THE LA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH IS NOT GOING TO DO IT AND THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS IS NOT GOING TO DO THEIR JOB AND DO IT AS WELL, THEN THE STATE IS GOING TO HAVE TO COME IN AND THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE TO DO IT. THANK YOU ASSEMBLY THE WOMAN. WE'RE NOW GOING TO MOVE TO THE PUBLIC COMMENT PORTION OF THE HEARING. SO IF THERE, DO WE HAVE A MICROPHONE THAT WE'RE GOING TO UTILIZE? OKAY. SO IF would like to comment please so perfect there's a microphone right behind you in the center please line up in an orderly fashion and we're gonna ask that in order that we get through everyone's comments that you state your name your community and you'll have one minute I'll be flexible I just don't want I want everyone to go for 10 minutes each. Okay.

Pilar Schiavoother

I'm from the East LA Bojites Coalition, and I stand here today on the shoulders of my sister in struggle, Dolores Huerta. I think something very important is that the county did not activate the incident command system. I also think you need to understand the history of the department and when it was split, and how the previous director, this would have never happened. There's a division in that department. A woman two years ago threw herself off one of the buildings and committed suicide and wrote a letter and taped it to her car because of all the dysfunctionalism in that department. Because I'm cutting time, I think you have to look at that suicide note, and I'd like to further talk to you about what I think is wrong with the county. The county has failed us, and when you have asked the Department of Public Health to do something and they haven't done it, that is an intent. Therefore, it is criminal. Not only did I ask for them to be fired for rare, and I think they need criminal charges, and I did contact the Attorney General's Office and the Environmental Crimes Division also within the DA's office. This is criminal negligence. But you've already done your job asking them to do what they're doing. And yes, it's the health department, the fire department, and the sheriff's department can also issue an evacuation. So these are important things, and you have power, but I think that there is a disconnect, and unfortunately the auditors aren't on the ground. So just like we all were in COVID, and you would have to go up and do your nose, and you had someone push something in, because you are not evacuated, it is the incident command system that would then get that information. The other important thing is that they're privatizing health care, and they've also changed the county employees. The county employees are now being subcontracted in the health department And within that division that a problem because there no historical information And that is very key on why it so dysfunctional and why people are scared to speak up because they're scared of losing their jobs. The people that I've talked to that work in the department cannot stand Ferrer or Montu, Mr. Davis. And prior to COVID, the doctors and universities were actually going to come out publicly against Ferrer because she's not a medical doctor, but that COVID hit and it didn't happen. And I also want to share some of your comments when you talked about how COVID, we got all this information. No, it wasn't. That information, and you're still not getting the information because healthcare has been privatized. So we have these images where they sent out, and unfortunately the state failed. They funded private medical mobile units. I spoke to Ferrer, and she told me, we can't use this information under HIPAA. So under HIPAA, because it's privatized, we're not going to trigger that incident command system if it's not the county health department that documents it. And they're not documented. I knew what was happening, and so I wanted to call for a town hall at East LA College who offered their auditorium, and I was going to set up the incident command system there to force them to trigger the evacuation. They didn't do it. You have the power to do that. I would have funded the legislation to fund the incident command system so that we have people on the...

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

If you could wrap up your comments.

Pilar Schiavoother

That's where I would spend money, to expand the incident command system so that you can actually document your health problems so that you do trigger an evacuation. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you.

Senator Senatorsenator

Again, state your name, your community, and try and stick it. That was a long minute. It was a great minute. All right. My name is Richard Jumanek, and I'm a resident of Castaic by the Live Oak School on Rangewood Road. I've been in Southern California for 38 years, and of that time, 32 years has been in Valverde and Castaic. And one of the things I want to especially do here is thank you for doing this legislative, this audit, And, you know, because I think we finally have people that we can believe are telling the truth, okay, and especially you, Chiquita Schiavo, about all that you've done for this. But my take on this is, and something that came up a couple of months ago was all the development around the Chiquita Canyon landfill. And they are talking about thousands of homes, tens of thousands of residents, thousands of jobs as far as the construction jobs and everything there. It's an economic driver that is, there's no way that the county is going to give up that economic activity because of what's happening with this Chiquita Canyon landfill. There is no way. If you're asking the question of why didn't the Department of Health do this, there's your answer. Because they're afraid of losing this economic driver in the County of Los Angeles that they absolutely have to have. And there is nothing that the County is going to do to make any possible thing that can block that stuff. Okay? AND THE WHOLE ISSUE HERE IS THEY DON'T WANT TO BRING UP ANY KIND OF PUBLIC HEALTH ISSUES BECAUSE IT MAY AFFECT THAT WHOLE DEVELOPMENT OF THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF HOMES LITERALLY public health issues because it may affect that whole development of thousands and thousands of homes Literally Over 8 homes in the shadow of the dump And the county is not going to back away from that because of the financial reasons. They don't care about the couple of thousand people here and the physical issues that we're having. We can be sacrificial lambs as long as they get their money because that's what drives this county. So I mean something I think that really needs to be looked at is when you talk about why the Department of Public Health hasn't done anything, it's because they can't jeopardize that project. And there's thousands and thousands of homes and millions and hundreds of millions of dollars at risk here and they just can't do that. And, you know, I mean, I think that this needs to be turned into the federal government for a toxic waste site. Because we know now, after four years of dealing with this dump and the personnel there, they cannot handle what's going on. It needs to be turned into a Superfund site. It needs to be taken away from those people. And somebody with enough authority, maybe you can get in touch with Lee Zeldin at the Environmental Protection Agency and say, hey, you know what? We need an intervention here from the federal government and throw those people out of there. Thank you. Good evening. Thank you for having me here. We need changes at the Department of Public Health, and we need them immediately. I'm sorry, sir, what was your name? My name is Joe Gonzalez. I'm from the Boyle Heights area. Thank you, Joe. Okay, by the lineage fire there. Okay, we need change, and we need it immediately. What's going on right now is we're having – it's the same as if they would have put a gun to my head and shot me in the head because they're letting this stuff go on and on and on. These are criminal acts that they're doing now. In the block where I live at, there's only 19 homes. Thirteen people that we know of have cancer or have died of cancer, and they refuse to call it a cancer cluster. This is just going on and on and on. They say, oh, no, we can't do that. You know, we can't do that because of HIPAA. just like they're saying they can't be here because of a lawsuit. We don't have a lawsuit against them. It's so far that I know at lineage, but they're not there either. So it's just smoke. The DPH is blowing up our backsides. I, in a fenced yard, have had five dogs die of doggy cancer. the extreme health costs not only of my life but of the the financial aspect of it this year so far i go to kaiser in hollywood it's costed me almost two thousand dollars in parking alone just in parking i've gone through radiation chemo you know once a week uh every two weeks every three weeks, it just keeps on going on and on and on. And I didn't plan for this on my retirement, man. It has eaten my retirement up, man. I mean, the cost of this stuff is just crazy. It's crazy. You know, medicine, doctors, special studies they have to do and stuff like that. It's ridiculous, man. I don't understand how the county allows this stuff to go on. Like I said, if you don't consider a cancer cluster, you're not doing nothing to it. So the Department of Public Health having an enforcement division and a public health division is ridiculous, because that's the right hand and the left hand on the same body. They should be in contact with each other. There is no excuse for them not to be in contact and working in conjunction with each other. Our house is not a long learning curve where they should learn that either. That should have been the first thing that comes out right up the top. The state has to stop allowing growth polluters into communities where people live at. And that's really, you know, I'm keeping short of that. Thank you, Joe. Hi, my name is Abigail DeSessa, 27-year resident of Val Verde, and I represent Val Verde on the Casteic Area Town Council. However, I'm speaking not for the council today. As a public figure, people know who I am and know how to reach me. I got a call in late fall of 2023 from public health at 9 p.m. at night from a private number. And I was told by my name, this is Abigail, right? Yes. And I do know who the person was. I recognize the voice. You're going to have to figure this out on your own. Everything I send up to my superiors, I get told laughingly. Ha, ha, ha. We're not going to do anything with that. All the recommendations that this person recommended for us was laughed at. Finally, this person was told, if we look for something and find something, we're required to report it. If we don't look for something, we won't find something. Therefore, we don't have to report something. 9 p.m., my home landline, private number, a public health worker, a voice I recognized. Mental health. I am that person who started the group, ran it like an AA meeting at a local church. I was being made to feel like I was crazy, and I didn't feel like I was alone. So I got permission to do that and started inviting the community once a month, and that is how Darcy recognized that I had really bad shaking and I kept dropping my phone. And we all started to connect all of our same symptoms. So the reason I did that was because at one of those CAC meetings, which by the way are not community anything, it is literally not community anything. The community is shut down and shut up. We may watch. I got into a verbal argument with Stephanie English. You know how that can be. And Stephanie English, Supervisor Barger, Senior Field Deputy. And I brought up the fact that our mental health was really screwed. And she goes, you know what, that's a good idea, Abigail. I'll look into it. So I had to do it myself. Well, I'd like to let you know that last month dealing with my adult son that lives in my house who's gone back to college, when I got into a little bit of an argument with him over, you should be taking more classes, his response to me is, what does it superlative matter? I'm going to die of cancer anyway because I live here. Thank you. Thank you, Abigail. Thank you, Abigail. My name is Cher Arabalo. I also sit on the Castelliac Area Town Council, I'm here speaking tonight for myself and my friends in the community. They say a picture is worth a thousand words So I went and blew this up today at CVS because two years ago almost to this date we had a town hall meeting And this is Dr Nicole Quick And you can see she's just looking at her phone. We all want to see that. Somebody else in here took the same picture, funny or not. So for hours, looking at her phone. And this was our representative at the time. This was the person that we had on the CAC board at the meetings. and that was the person that we were directing all of our calls to and our inquisitions to. And that was who we were supposed to talk to. And she was there for our community, but the whole time she was on her phone. When Jennifer's 11-year-old daughter was basically crying and saying, what are you going to do to protect me, she was looking at her phone. When a community member said, I just found out I was diagnosed with cancer again, she was looking at her phone. When people stood up there and said, my dog just passed away, She still looked at her phone. She didn't care about the community and that that's the perfect representation Of our interaction with public health So thank you for being here and thank you for listening and thank you for hearing us. Thank you, sir Good evening. My name is Carol parallel I WANT TO TELL TO ALL THE RESIDENTS OF THE STATE AND CHAQUITA CANYON, WE UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU GUYS ARE GOING THROUGH AND UNFORTUNATELY THE PUBLIC HEALTH DEPARTMENT HAS FAILED EVERYONE. I'M A 37-YEAR RESIDENT OF BOYO HIGH, SEASTALE. I LIVE 1.5 MILES FROM THE LINEGE FIRE. IT'S VERY DISAPPOINTING TO HEAR EVERYTHING THAT'S BEEN GOING ON AND IT'S BEEN ALLOWED. AND I SECOND YOUR MOTION, WHAT YOU'RE SAYING, THAT THEY NEED TO BE FIRED AND LET GO. we need to have someone representing us in the public health department that is an actual doctor that has seen patients. My story is my mom in her 70s, three weeks after the lineage fire, had a double ammonia, septic, E. coli. My mom was on her deathbed, spent a week in the hospital, and they're saying there's nothing in there. There's nothing in the water. There's nothing. There is something. shouldn't take all these people to sit here to say there's something going on. They need to do a better job to represent the public because our tax money goes towards it and we need to have better representatives, not just from Kaseya to East LA, all the surrounding areas that they're responsible for. Thank you very much. I believe kids deserve a childhood, don't you? My name is Gwen Stinson, and I'm 13 years old. I lived in Valverde for 13 years of my life, and then the landfill was never my concern until I was 10. When I was outside with my parents, I asked, Is that smell what the landfill is? Knowing that they always complained about it. Unfortunately, their response was yes. After that, I barely went outside and enjoyed my day. I had a trampoline and bike, but none of them were getting used ever since that conversation. I also missed many school days due to headaches, which not only caused harm to me, but caused harm to my education. Along with this, I woke up with blood in my bed from leaving my window open and laying the toxic air in my room. Bloody nose. Since I've moved, this hasn't happened. I MISS MY VALVERDE HOME AND MY OLD NEIGHBORS BUT DUE TO HOW BAD THE LANDFILL IS WE HAD TO MOVE WE HAVE THESE MEETINGS BUT NOTHING IS CHANGING WE DESERVE A CHANGE THANK YOU how bad the landfill was we had to move We have these meetings but nothing is changing We deserve a change Thank you Thank you John Picoretto I live in Hillcrest and thank you for creating this forum Just a follow-up on what you said about doctors and the communication from the health department, zero. Between three specialists, the ER at Henry Mayo, they're clueless about the landfill. like they don't even know that exists in the problems that we've been having so they really need to step that up because doctors need to be understanding what they're dealing with rather than just try this try that my concern though is with listening to the audit and all the failures from the health department obviously the governor is pointing the finger back to the to them as far as the responsibility and who has the authority I don't know was our supervisor invited to this tonight? I mean she's nowhere to ever be found so you don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure out there's some cahoots or coercion going on of why this whole thing is being delayed and pooh-poohed and pushed to the side. I mean the community has spoken for all these years that is shocking. I mean you know picture says a thousand words that that does and And for them to ignore this, it's criminal. I really believe that they should be investigated and held accountable and start putting these people behind bars because that's the only way you're going to stop this from involving. Thank you. My name is Janet Trotter. I've lived in the North Bluff track for 37 years. North Bluff track is just right across the street here. I'm not in Val Verde, but I get a plume of this nasty old smell all the time. And they ask me, Janet, what does it smell like? You can't describe what it smells like. It is the most putrid thing in the world. I give you kudos for what you do. You've got balls of steel. I love you. My own grandchild, my firstborn grandchild, never made it, and I think it had to do with that dump. My neighborhood where I live, I have watched five of my very close that have been there 37 years. Well, they're not there anymore, so they're gone. But I'm here for you tonight, Mark. And I'm fighting for them because I've watched a few of my neighbors had their complete face peeled down to their chin from cancer, one of stomach cancer. The other guy, they didn't know if it was stomach cancer or throat cancer or brain cancer that got him. There's about 13 to 14 of them. I know the people in my community because I worked on the advisory committee for the community, and the word gets around on what's going on. Right now it looks about maybe 13 people have had cancer. Half of them are not with us anymore. And I'd like to see a change to that because I've got a lot of neighbors that had their daughters, their wives, miscarriage. My daughter is one of them. Sadly to say, that was my first grandbaby. My other daughter just had two babies, and it's so sad to see that her sister can't have children. So it's very hard for me to sit and listen to some of these people's stories. and we have to sit here and go to these meetings week after week, month after month, and year after year, when something needs to be done here and we're forgotten. It Val Verde It in Castaic I thought it was the water It not the water This was during COVID right before COVID really even hit that I was watching my friends die and I wanted to know what the hell was going on in North Bluff. A friend that my husband's cousin, we were camping, and his buddy, he's a big wig, got a nice Bentley, lives in Santa Barbara, and he goes, Janet, I'd really like a test of your water. And I always thought it was in the water. Mark worked for Department of Water and Power. They cut all his hair off. He was in over 22 hours of surgery, and some of my other neighbors the same thing. Their spots were on the different parts of their skull. But it's really sad to see your close neighbors, after so many years, have to go through this and watch their kids running down the street, crying their eyes out. It's really hard to see, and then for these people not to do anything, I was there that night. That lady took the picture because I took the same picture. One was on her phone and the man behind her, I was in the front row. I pulled him and I'm like, get her off her phone. Get her off her phone now. And then the other one was asleep and I got that on my phone at home. So the next meeting maybe you'll see that picture. I got the other gal snoring away up there. Thank you. Buenas noches. Mi nombre es María Morales. Good evening. My name is Maria Morales. Can you hear me? My name is Maria Morales. I live in City Terrace, which is on the east side of LA, and I've lived there for 50 years. I'm here to share that as you have been suffering here, in less than a month, in our community, we had the lineage fire, but we also had 25,000 gallons of oil that were spilled and contaminated the river and the LA River and went into the ocean. And to this day, the oil spill happened in May and since May, there's been no communication about what we should do, how we should prepare. My husband's arms got full of rashes in an unexplained way. There was no information either about the oil spill or about the lineage fire. Here. My cancer will come back. I am in remission. And that's why I come to support you. And I'm going to tell you the surprise of the lady or the lady who has talked very well and is fighting for you and your community. I am a cancer survivor. I had stomach cancer, lymphoma, and I'm afraid that everything that's happened, my cancer, the cancer may come back. I'm really grateful to you for all of the advocacy work that you're doing to raise awareness about this. We came to support this issue and more awareness, and she also spoke earlier about how she has anxiety at night, and I failed to translate that. She's concerned about her mental health. She can't sleep. I also want to say something about God. For me, the exterior house is our planet. If we don't take care of our planet, from those environmental disasters and chemicals that are happening, the Earth is already giving grits. Grits. That's why those disasters that we have ambient, those disasters, those disasters, those disasters, those disasters, those things that are happening in the Earth, because we are affixing those people who only come to fill the money in the bags and they don't care about our health and our suffering around. I want to speak about how the earth is our home and what's happening inside of our home is that these companies are making our homes sick. They're everything from the floods, the chemical disasters, these types of issues happening in the canyons. These are all things that are devastating our community and making our homes sick. They're making all of us sick while they become rich. If you could wrap up your comment. . . and that's why we need to be in God's graces and fight for our community specifically removing Ferrer and removing Montu Davis from their roles because they're doing nothing to help us and they need to leave. Thank you. Thank you. I just want to say something. Thank you. So her concern about the similar refrigeration warehouses that surround the community that are just a disaster waiting to happen, that we need to fight together to protect our communities in more substantial ways so that they don't kill us all. Thank you. Hello, my name is Timothy Trotter, and I'm a 38-year resident of Castaic. Just off subject, Senator Valveras, I totally, totally appreciate what you said about a company in Northern California that is willing to clean up the dump. I asked that question at CAC meetings I asked the dump I asked the barger office There also a fellow here in Santa Clarita who 14 says his company can clean the dump up I'd have to agree at this point it needs to be a super fund. But that's what we all really, really want since we're here tonight to tear up the Department of Public Health. I think a lot of agencies need to be tore up, and I think this is a great place to start. I agree 100% with the survey that the state audit did on them. I think they need to cut their heads at the top. I don't think they should even be asked to keep their job. They don't follow standard operational procedure. I don't even know where to go. Everything that everybody has testified tonight is absolutely true. I'll tell you my story real quick. I've been a brain doctor. I've been a lung doctor. I've been a heart doctor, I've been a skin doctor, I've been a thalumagist, and they all say, oh, there's nothing to matter with you. Ask them, have you heard of benzene? No. So this is what eventually when L.A. County Board or Health Department gets shut down, or not shut down, but new management, they need to do what was suggested is let other doctors in the community know what's going on. We just don't want surveys saying, oh, yeah, this happened here and this happened here. That's not going to do anything for us. We want real solutions for our health and also solutions for shutting down the catastrophe at the Domba. Thank you. Thank you. Buenas noches. Mi nombre es Sandra Quintero. Vengo de Boyajas. Y tengo casi 40 años viviendo ahí. In first place, I would like to ask, please, if you could remove these two people who are encarging, occupying two sillas where they don't do their work in the Department of Health and if they could ask the person Jonathan Filden, who was the director of that department, and that he knows how to perform his profession, to work with the health of all the people here in this life, I would like to help them to help us with the good of us, and that those people are removed from that place that they do not work, and that the work they should do. TAMBIEN. OH, PERDON. OKAY, MY NAME IS SANDALUZ QUINTERO. I COME FROM BOYLE HEIGHTS. I'VE LIVED THERE FOR 40 YEARS. I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE TWO INDIVIDUALS THAT ARE CURRENTLY LEADING THE DEPARTMENT. THEY SHOULD BE REMOVED. I ASK YOU, PLEASE, TO LOOK AT THE PREVIOUS DIRECTOR WHO DID KNOW HOW TO EXERCISE HIS JOB, JONATHAN FIELDING, HE'S OVER AT UCLA. I THINK I RECOMMEND I PLEAD WITH YOU TO PLEASE out to him because he didn't know how to run that department. Thank you. I thank you ladies. I think the way you've expressed yourself, you really want to represent the community, so I want to thank you for doing that. You're doing a good job. That's what I, to all of you. Thank you. A todos. Como ustedes saben han visto estas personas que est encargadas en la salud p en el Departamento de Salud no han hecho nada As you know you have seen these people who are encarged in the public health care department they have no done anything nothing of their work that they should develop right Neither of them, nor of those who are encadered in this department. Nobody wants to take charge, nobody wants to say that there is venom, that everything is fine, right? And we all know that nothing is fine, everything is fine. If I could have you wrap up your comments. Just one more. That everyone knows that the individuals that are working in the Department of Public Health aren't doing anything. That's true. We know it. We all know it. We know that we're being poisoned and they're not doing anything. . . and that's what they want to do. Here there's no crime, but we have you who have the power. And together we have to continue to go forward and win as it should be done by divine justice and the world. Right? Thank you. Thank you. There is a criminal hand here. We know it. There's a divine justice and we know what needs to be done. So thank you. We hope you move forward. Yeah, these are all criminal acts. Thank you. Hi.

Pilar Schiavoother

My name is Elizabeth Jeffords. I'm a community member here in Hasley Hills, Cal State. Five, six years, seven years. I don't know how many years it's been now. I moved in in January of 2020. And it's been nothing but a nightmare since, unfortunately. We have a great community. there's nothing that I can say that hasn't already been said a thousand times over again. But we're here today. Thank you, Ms. Filar Shavo. You're the only person I'm getting out of bed for. So I'm here. I'm here for you because you've been here for us. And you've literally saved my life over and over again. And everyone else here has said that. But we're here today to talk about the failure of the health department in Los Angeles County. I was not born and raised in California. I was not fortunate enough for that. But the reason why I moved to California was because under what I could see outside of the state was that California is the leader in everything, healthcare and sunny, shiny, running outside, and smiles all day long and environmental justice, number one, right? Protecting their people, number one priority. We set the tone for everywhere else in the country. And to be here in this position and to be bedridden for four years while paying property taxes for 20 years in Los Angeles County, I am disgusted and I'm embarrassed to even tell people that I'm a part of Los Angeles County, that I live in this state because no one in my family, my ancestors even, can believe that I've stayed here this long and put up with this Month after month year after year we go to these meetings and Dr Quick barely looks up from her phone engages I waited in line over an hour to speak with her and she literally turned her back on me and said no Where do we go for answers? I'm paying thousands of dollars. I've lost my entire retirement, my life savings, going to the hospital, checking for all these tests. seeing what's wrong, what's happening. And every month they tell us it's acute. There's nothing to worry about. When we could have just been told up front that this is the situation, we're not going to do anything about it, it's out of our hands, but at least we would know to get the hell out of here. because four years ago, I was a completely different person. And four years ago, even then, I couldn't imagine myself in the state that I am right now. And so there's something to be said about not just letting the hospital, the medical staff around our community being told what's going on. It's a completely different thing to withhold that information. from the public because as full as this room was today, we had to make this happen. There was no LA County Health mass door knocking, emails, text blasts, nothing for any of those things that we found in the audit. Any of the surveys, any of the reach out, by the way, I did not get anything on my door, that's for sure. But instead, I'm the one emailing, like an idiot. Every single day for two years, the county health nurse, my symptoms, crying every single day. Do you know, we're talking about 1,500 days of my life spent crying in tears, trying to find answers to get out of this situation. when we have a health department who is supposed to be dedicated to solving those problems for us and to letting us know when we're in danger, when our lives are in danger. I had no problem taking my tax money every year. But when I reach out, no one's there. No answers. Even today, we're going into the new year. It's going to be my fifth new year in bed. physically unable to go anywhere or the want to celebrate anything because there's no part of this last five years that makes me want to celebrate or have joy or have hope we sit there every month and listen to the gaslighting and the we'll get back to you we'll circle back next month and the lying with the monitors being faulty. There's no way. Because what we have here is evil. And we've allowed this landfill to dictate our lives and the lives of our constituents and the lives of our neighbors. And that's not fair. None of this is our problem. None of this is because of us. We did everything everything we were supposed to do. So the least we can do is, I just want to make sure when you can sit up there and the chair says, we're gonna do something, we're gonna fix this, when? Because I would like to see that done before I die. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

I've been really leaning it with time, so if you can try and keep it. Thank you.

Jennifer Elkinsother

Hi. Good evening now. My name is McKitzley Herrera, and I'm a resident of Monterey Park. Where my childhood home is is along the plume path from the Lineage Warehouse Fire. I just first and foremost want to say thank you to everyone who has shared their experience and their story, because I feel like I'm getting a glimpse into the future of what the next few years is really going to look like for us without real accountability and real change from our Department of Public Health. I am truly just in shock, but truly I think at the essence of this shock is just disgusted that they are continuing to get away with this with no action, no true accountability. And my question to all of you is, what does real accountability look like? The question of when? When is, like, enough time, enough time? Because the fact that this is, we're only a few months in, but this is years. This is years of people's lives. Like, new generations aren't even being born. And so the question of miscarriages has me now thinking, okay, one, my reproductive rights are already getting, you know, targeted. As a young woman, I'm in my 20s. But also, it's now having me think, okay, do I need to start thinking about what does this mean for my future? My future as a woman, if I want to become a mom, what does this mean for my family? I've already been evacuated from my childhood home, the one safe space that I had. And now having to get adjusted to a whole new community. I live by a high school. My community before was very quiet. It is very, very different when you look at the reality of what people are living. I'm very grateful I have the opportunity to live somewhere else, but my home is contaminated from toxic air. I smelled that for days until my mother and I chose to evacuate our home. We returned because we both have had, we returned assuming.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

If I can have you wrap up your comments.

Jennifer Elkinsother

Absolutely. We assumed that our home was safe, but because of the fact that we have underlying health issues, it is not safe. We've gotten sick. I have suffered from full body rashes, and because of the lack of responsibility that public health felt, the hospitals that I went to, and I quote, said that if this was really a problem, if this was really serious, we would know about it. So you're probably just having an allergic reaction, but I've never had a reaction like that from my body. My body is now scarred as a result of the fact that I have severe sensitivity now. So I just want to know what real accountability looks like, and I would hope and pray that you all have the courage to also ask these questions and also remove these people from their jobs The fact that they are still continuing to get paid time and time again is beyond deplorable and truly disgusting Thank you for your time Thank you Thank you.

Stephen Houseother

My name is Alma, and I'm Miquetzli's mom. I'm very grateful that my daughter has also begun to find her voice in this, and it's devastating as a mother to see your kids suffer the way she's been suffering, and it's been devastating and traumatizing to have to keep telling our story over and over. And I'm learning that there's trauma by actually telling your trauma. And I want to just stand in support of all of you of having to do that for the last four years because we've been doing it for the last four months, and it is unbelievable. We started Protect LA Now because we were not protected. And plan is the acronym. There was no plan. There was a plan to cover things up. There was a plan to lie. There was a plan to keep people from the truth. And there was a plan to just make people believe that in Spanish we say no pasa nada, nothing's happening here, nothing to see here. AND THERE IS A LOT TO BE SEEN, THERE'S A LOT TO BE HEARD. AND THERE'S A DOCUMENT THAT I WANT YOU TO NOTE AND I WANT IT TO BE ON THE RECORD BECAUSE WE DID A LOT OF RESEARCH INCLUDING ON WHAT HAPPENED AND WE'RE LEARNING ABOUT WHAT'S HAPPENED HERE AND THE COMPARISON OF WHAT THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, SPECIFICALLY PUBLIC HEALTH DEPARTMENT, AND HOW THEY RESPONDED TO OTHER DISASTERS AND WHAT THEY DID ACROSS SEVEN AREAS AND WHAT THEY DID NOT DO TO ISSUE ANY INFORMATION, ANY GUIDANCE, ANYTHING IN THE BOIL HEIGHTS AND EAST L.A. PLUME PATH COMMUNITIES AND THE SAN GABRIEL VALLEY BECAUSE IN OUR SITUATION IT CUTS ACROSS THE COUNTY AND MULTIPLE CITIES. SO IT'S NOT JUST ONE CITY, IT'S VARIOUS CITIES. AND THEY'VE BEEN NONRESPONSIVE. AND I THINK THAT THIS IS CRIMINAL. THERE'S BEEN A CRIMINAL WARRANT ISSUED. For us, it's really important that the state come in and do what you have to do. Issue receivership, take over. If they haven't done anything for this community in the last four years, what can we expect? When we've been poisoned, when we're sick, when we feel like we're burning from the inside, and then when we documented everything and shared our concerns with the county public health officer WITH THE LETTER DATED JULY 6TH. WE WERE RESPONDED WITH A LETTER THREE DAYS LATER THAT SAID, GO AND TALK TO THE POLLUTER WHO MADE ALL OF THIS HAPPEN.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

IF I COULD HAVE YOU RUB UP YOUR COMMENTS.

Stephen Houseother

WE WILL NOT HAVE A RESPONSE FOR YOU. YOU NEED TO GO AND ASK LINEAGE SO I GOING TO SHARE THAT LETTER AS A MATTER OF PUBLIC RECORD FOR YOU BECAUSE THAT IS A PUBLIC IT BASICALLY THEM SAYING WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR PUBLIC HEALTH THIS CORPORATION IS. AND SO IF THAT'S THE CASE, LET THE COUNTY'S RESPONSIBILITY, QUOTE, UNQUOTE, BE THE STATE'S RESPONSIBILITY. TAKE IT OVER, HAVE IT IN RECEIVERSHIP, AND FIRE ALL OF THESE PEOPLE WHO HAVE ENDANGERED ALL OF OUR LIVES. THANK YOU.

Jose Bobadillaother

Good evening. My name is Bernard Arbello. I'm a retired police commander. I came to this community. Love the community. It's great people, great area, and the dump makes it terrible. I really wanted more than all, more than anything, to thank Pilar Chiavo. So I honestly don't know if any of you would be here without her. She listened to us when no one else would. And as a police officer, the one place I want to be safe is at home for myself and my family. We're not safe at home. You know, as a police officer, if we do something wrong, there's malfeasance or oppression under color of authority, and we hold accountable. These people are doing the same thing. What they're doing is malfeasance and oppression under public authority. And there is no consequences. They get the dump gets notice of violations, thousands of notices of violations and not one fine. Nothing happens. It's, and I generally think they want us to just stop going to the meetings so they can stop being there, but we still keep going to meetings and we're not going to stop. But more than anything, Thank you, Ms. Shella. Thank you so much. Thank you. So. Can I just say something to the community real quick? Ten seconds. Ten seconds. Next Tuesday is election day. Please go vote.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Excuse me, sir. Unfortunately, this is a state hearing.

Jose Bobadillaother

Please go vote. Thank you.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

Thank you, sir. Okay? Thank you. So we're going to bring it back to the committee, and if the assembly would like to offer any closing remarks. I just want to say you should cut legislation. So ma'am, we're in a state hearing. Thank you. We can talk after, too. Just I want to wrap it up.

Senator/Assemblymember Pilar Schiavosenator

I know it's been a long night. There's been a lot of tears shed and a lot of frustration for good reason. And... And we should not have to fight this hard. We shouldn't have to fight this hard. It's so frustrating. It is so frustrating that it takes this much and this many years and this many stories and tears and suffering that our community is going through to get just basic action to happen by the Department of Public Health that is responsible for public health. It's unbelievable. It's unforgivable. AND IT JUST HAS TO CHANGE NOW. IT HAS TO CHANGE NOW. AND AS I HAVE SAID BEFORE, IF IT DOES NOT CHANGE, IF THEY DON'T CHANGE, THE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS HAS TO CHANGE IT. IF THEY DON'T CHANGE IT, THE STATE HAS TO CHANGE IT. WE CANNOT KEEP WAITING AND CROSSING OUR FINGERS AND BEGGING AND PLEADING FOR THEM TO SHOW UP AND DO THEIR JOB AND PROTECT OUR COMMUNITY. WE NEED ACTION AND WE NEED IT NOW. AND SO THAT'S WHAT I WILL CONTINUE EVERY DAY TO FIGHT FOR WITH YOU, AND WE ARE GOING TO MAKE SURE THAT CHANGE COMES TO THIS COMMUNITY. THANK YOU, EVERYONE, FOR ALL YOU DO.

Chair, Joint Legislative Audit Committee John Harabedianassemblymember

THANK YOU, AGAIN, ASSEMBLYWOMAN. I WILL HAVE NOTHING TO ADD, BECAUSE THOSE WERE PHENOMENAL CLOSING REMARKS. THANK YOU FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE. THANK YOU TO THE AUDITOR. AND WITH THAT, THIS HEARING IS ADJOURNED. Thank you. Thank you. .

Source: Senate Jt Leg Audit — 2026-10-29 · October 29, 2026 · Gavelin.ai