November 10, 2026 · Judiciary Committee · 10,813 words · 14 speakers · 83 segments
The meeting of the Senate Judiciary Committee will come to order. The time is now 945. Will the clerk please call the roll?
Chair Gaviron, here. Senator Reynolds, here. Ranking Member Hicks-Hutson,
Senator Blessing, here. Senator Katrona,
Senator Timken, here. Senator Smith, here.
All right, we do not have a quorum, so
we will be moving on to testimony until we do have a quorum present. We do have a quorum present, so we'll proceed as a full committee. Members, a copy of the minutes from the June 10th meeting of the committee are on your iPads. The question is, shall the minutes be agreed to? Without objection, the minutes are agreed to. Before we get started today, I wanted to mention to everyone we have a hard stop today at 11 o'clock, So we're going to try and get through all the testimony on these bills. There will be a timer running, and we'd ask if you can keep your testimony to five minutes. That would be really helpful in making sure we get through everyone. All right. The first order of business is to call House Bill 565 for its first hearing. We'll now hear sponsor testimony from Representatives Jerrolds and Odioso.
Good morning. This is my first time testifying before this August body, and it's quite a privilege to do so. Chair Gaviron, Vice Chair Reynolds, Ranking Member Hicks-Hudson, and members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, thank you for the opportunity to provide sponsored testimony on House Bill 565, the Grand Jury Privacy and Protection Act, designed to safeguard the identities of Ohioans serving on grand juries. In 2024, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled in its decision states, Ex-Rail Cogan v. Jefferson County Clerk of Courts, holding that the names of grand jurors are public records subject to disclosure. Current Ohio public records law does not exempt disclosure. If a document is a public record and is not exempt from definition of public record, the public office generally must permit its inspection or copying. If enacted, HB 565 will be the 53rd public record exception. House Bill 565 amends Ohio Revised Code 1449.43 to protect the state's substantial legislative interest in maintaining the anonymity of grand jurors and grand jury forepersons by exempting their identities and personal addresses from public records. That's what the bill does right there. The recent Ohio Supreme Court ruling raises serious questions by undermining the longstanding foundational principle of grand jury secrecy. When a grand jury is impaneled, jurors must take an oath. That includes the requirement to keep all proceedings secret unless required to disclose. This means that grand jurors are expected to maintain confidentiality regarding the deliberations and findings of the grand jury, which is crucial for the integrity of the process. Confidentiality, including the jurors' identities, allows jurors to deliberate candidly and independently, free of intimidation, pressure or harassment or retaliation by individuals under investigation or their associates. This protection is especially critical given the sheer volume and seriousness of cases grand jurors handle The U Fifth Amendment in the Ohio Constitution Article I Bill of Rights Section 10 time trial for crimes, underscores the critical importance of grand juries preserving liberty and fairness in our criminal justice system. Ohio Criminal Rule 6 governs the procedures related to grand juries, including their composition, summoning, and the rights of defendants in criminal proceedings. HB 565 is limited to the scope of public records requests and does not impinge on the Ohio court's inherent powers to investigate grand jury operations. According to a 2022 Court News Ohio report, grand jury service varies statewide, with jurors serving schedules that may range from one day a week over to two months to every weekday for two weeks. During that time, jurors may hear as many as 15 cases in a single day. This workload further underscores the need to shield jurors from public exposure and potential retaliation. There is a daily need for a large number of grand jurors in Ohio, and we need to preserve this pool as being willing to serve. Grand jury secrecy has endured as a fundamental principle in the American justice system, with roots tracing back centuries to medieval England and even earlier justice systems. The Grand Jury Privacy and Protection Act, House Bill 565, before you today, preserves this living, critical, legal foundation by applying it to modern public records law. Last thing, House Bill 565 received unanimous support in the Ohio House, passing out of the Ohio Judiciary Committee with 13 yes votes, zero no votes, before passing the Ohio House floor with 96 yes votes and zero no votes. Chair Gaviron, Vice Chair Reynolds, Ranking Member Hicks, Hudson, and members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, I now turn over this moment to my joint sponsor, Rep. Gerrolds. Thank you.
Thank you, Representative Odioso. Proud to have you as a joint sponsor. To Chair Gaviron, Vice Chair Reynolds, Ranking Member Hitz-Hudson and members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, thank you for the opportunity to provide sponsored testimony on House Bill 565, the Grand Jury Privacy and Protection Act, legislation designed to safeguard the identities of Ohioans who serve on grand juries. I will begin with a simple question. If we ask everyday Ohioans to step into one of the most serious responsibilities in our judicial system or justice system, should we also ask them to risk their personal safety and privacy while doing it? Across Ohio, grand juries meet every single day. The large counties, small counties alike, grand juries here case after case, often dozens over the course of a single term. Statewide, thousands of Ohioans serve on grand juries each year. They review violent offenses, organized crime, corruption in cases involving deeply personal harm. They are not public officials. They do not seek attention or recognition. they serve because the system depends on them and because we ask them to answer the call. And for generations as my colleague has mentioned we have asked them to serve with the understanding that their identities would be protected That understanding was fundamentally altered in the Supreme Court 2024 decision in a state v. Colgan v. Jefferson County clerk of courts, which held that the names of grand jurors are subject to disclosure under Ohio's public records law. Whatever the legal reasoning behind that decision, the real world implications and consequences are unmistakable. Ordinary citizens are now exposed to the public identification simply for fulfilling their civic duty. In today's Ohio, a name is not simply just a name. A name can be searchable. A name can be linked to an address, shared online, stripped of context, and amplified in ways none of us can fully control. We all have watched how quickly misinformation spread and how easily individuals involved in criminal proceedings can become targets. Ohio courts and law enforcement have documented an increase in threats and harassment connected to serious felony cases in recent years. That reality can't be ignored when we consider the safety of the people we rely on to serve. Grand juries, secrecy exists for a reason. It protects independency. It allows jurors to deliberate freely and honestly without pressure from defendants, associates or the public. It ensures decisions are based on evidence and law, not fear or intimidation. With when jurors begin to worry about being identified, targeted or retaliated against, the integrity of the process itself is compromised. House Bill 565, as my colleague mentioned, is a narrow, responsible and grounded common sense legislation. It amends 149.43 at Ohio Revised Code to exempt the names of grand jurors and signatures of grand juror forepersons from public disclosure under Ohio's public records law. It does not interfere with the authority of the courts. It does not weaken oversight or accountability. What it does is restore a long-standing protection that aligns our public records framework with modern realities. The bill protects the identifications of grand jurors, affirms the principle of grand jury secrecy so Ohioans can serve without fear of retaliation, coercion, or public exposure, and preserve the independence of the judicial process while maintaining the proper balance between transparency and the constitutional rights and safety of the people we serve. If we want Ohio to continue answering the call to serve, we must meet our obligation to protect them while they do. House Bill 565 does exactly that. It strengthens our justice system by not shielding power, but safeguarding the people who make it function. Chair Gaviron, Vice Chair Reynolds, Ranking Member Hitz-Hudson, and members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify on House Bill 565. And with that, we are happy to answer any questions you may have at this time.
Thank you very much for bringing this bill. I appreciate that. And first question goes to Senator Ken Smith.
Thanks very much, Madam Chair. Thank you, Reps, for this legislation. So I think I understand the reason to redact names of the grand jurors and their home addresses. But I guess my question is the redaction of the signature of the grand jury chairman is proof that the grand jury brought the charge and not the prosecutor And so I while I see the The concern for the bill I wondering if that provision of the legislation could be problematic.
This page shows part of the transcript. The full transcript is available on request.