Skip to main content
Committee HearingUnicameral

Judiciary Committee - Room 1525

September 21, 2026 · Judiciary · 10,340 words · 1 speakers · 22 segments

Good afternoon everyone. It is 1:00, so we'll go ahead and get started. Welcome to the judiciary Committee and Senator carolyn bosn from lincoln. I represent district 25, which is southeast lincoln, lancaster county, and I serve as the chair of the Committee. We're holding a legislative resolution hearing today on LR 403. For those who are joining us for the first time, interim study resolutions are introduced by senators who believe that the Legislature should investigate certain topics that may be the subject of future legislation. The judiciary Committee is here today to receive information about these topics. We will not be using our usual procedure of asking for proponents and opponents. As this is an interim study, we're going to have an introducers opening statements followed by invited testimony testifiers, and we will finish with the closing statement by the introducer. If you wish us to give one. If you are planning to testify today, please fill out one of the green testifier sheets on the table at the back of the room. Print clearly and fill it out completely, listing every organization you represent. When it is your turn to come to testify, please come forward. Give the testifier sheet to the page or the Committee clerk. Speak clearly into the microphone, telling us and spelling your first and last name to ensure we get an accurate record. We use a three minute light system for all testifiers. The light will be green when your testimony begins. When the light turns yellow, you have one minute remaining and the red light indicates you need to wrap up your final thoughts and stop. Questions from the Committee may follow. If you have handouts, please bring up ten copies. We will not accept thumb drives, cds, dvds, oversize documents, books, lists of signatures, and similar silence. Or turn off your cell phones. Verbal outbursts and applause are not permitted. Let's see if you have a position statement or excuse me if you wish to submit a position comment. There are testifier. Excuse me. There are position pages at the back of the room. They will not be included on a Committee statement. I'm not sure if this is relevant because we don't do a Committee statement. I'm just reading. Okay, we'll cover that bridge if we get to it, but I'll have the Committee members with us today introduce themselves, starting with Senator hallstrom. Bob hallstrom, legislative district one representing otoe johnson, nemaha richardson and pawnee counties. Welcome rick holdcroft district 36, west and south sarpy county. Terrell mckinney district 11, north omaha. And our introducer today is Senator, Senator rountree and you are district. Three three. Okay, sorry. All right. Also assisting the Committee today. To my left is our legal counsel, tim young. And to my far right is our Committee clerk for the day, becky bartunek. Is that how you pronounce it? All right. Acting as the page for today's hearing is joel henson.

Jason Witmerother

And with that, we will begin our hearing on LR 403. Senator rountree. Thank you. Good afternoon. Chair and members of the judiciary Committee. My name is victor rountree. Victorrountree, and I represent district three, which is made up of bellevue and papillion. Today I'm here to introduce LR 403, which deals with the shackling of youth involved in the justice system. Last interim, I spoke with youth advocates across the state about their experiences with the juvenile justice system. These children go through dramatic and traumatic, life changing events and can be left with deep trauma through their experiences. This session I brought LB 996, which sought to ensure that when restraints are used on a juvenile, they are used for good reason. The Committee has heard from multiple youth advocates about how their lives have been changed by having restraints used on them. We have heard of youth who have no history of violence or flight risk still being restrained for simple purposes such as medical visits. Today we will hear from testifiers who have lived experiences and from industry professionals who can help us understand how to make these changes practical. With safety at the forefront of any potential legislation. Safety for the incarcerated or detained. Youth. Safety for any drivers transporting them. And finally, safety for community members. I appreciate your time for this important issue today. There are testifiers behind me who can speak to more specific aspects of when and why shackling is used in our current practices. With that, I would be happy to answer any questions that would not be better deferred to our testifiers behind. Thank you so much. All right. Are there any questions from the Committee? I'll get started just so that I know. Are you planning to close at the end? If we have, a lot of questions will come to us as the hearing goes on. And from our conversation, it sounds like what you're really hoping for is a good roundtable discussion on this. Are you going to be open for questions at the end then? I will be open for questions at the end. Thank you. Perfect. Thank you. All right. So we'll just start with testifiers then. And sen rountree will come back up at the end. I'm just going to go straight down the list that was provided to me from Senator rountree with a ride care representative as our first testifier. Is there someone here from ride care? Okay, we'll go next to jason witmer from the aclu. Good afternoon. Good afternoon, chair, bosnian and judiciary Committee. My name is jason witmer. Jasonwitmer. And I'm here on behalf of the aclu of Nebraska to provide some input into LR 403, the routine and standard shackling of children is harmful and inconsistent with the rehabilitative purposes and goals of our juvenile legal system.

Jason Witmerother

LR 403 relates to Senator roundtree's LB 996 from last session limiting, prohibited, limiting and prohibiting routine shackling and transporting children. The standard use of shackles and restraints in transport is inconsistent with other areas of Nebraska. Law relating to imposing restraints onto children. Nebraska's juvenile court permits restraints on children based on individualized findings involving physical harm, recent danger, recent dangerous behaviors, and substantial flight risk with no less restrictive alternative will work. And if restraints are ordered, courts are required to make a written findings. Nebraska's room. Room confinement law uses a similar structure before restrictions that isolate children can be imposed. Less restrictive alternatives must be exhausted, and there must be immediate and substantial risk of harm. Confinement must end when the risk resolves and documentation is required. However, Nebraska's juvenile detention standard permits the use of mechanical restraints using a slightly different standard by exempting, quote, routine use during transport, transport transfer, unquote, from ordinary approval and reporting requirements. With regard to shackling children during transportation, we are urging this Committee to adopt a similar standard of using restraint only in incidents. Instances of individuals, findings of safety concerns and substantial flight risk. Such a standard would require custodians or caregivers caretakers to use a less restrictive response when it can reasonably address that risk. Allow staff to respond immediately to a genuine emergency without waiting for prior approval, while requiring continued restraint to be recessed. Reassessed once the immediate danger is under control and again to end restraint when circumstances change and restraint is no longer necessary, and to require brief documentation explaining the restraint use and for how long. LB 996 Committee hearing it was asked whether waiting for an emergency can sometimes mean acting too late. We should not prejudge youth, and should instead use the approach that we already use in other parts of our juvenile system. The emplacement of restraints to be based on individualized and clearly expressed risk ending restraint when no longer is necessary, and documentation. We thank Senator rountree for his leadership and his work for providing opportunities for accountability and protections for our our most vulnerable populations. Thank you. Questions from the Committee. Just a couple of things. Do you know what the current policy is as it relates to shackling of juveniles from an hhs perspective versus from a probation perspective? The separation of the two? Yeah. What their current policy is. No, I would have to find out. But I believe we have somebody here with that. I did provide all the statues of what I presented. Sure. That wasn't one of them. Is it your understanding that they are shackling every juvenile in all cases currently. Transporting the. The department has. It's basically a de facto thing, just automatically that I. My understanding, I guess what we heard from the transportation in the last bill. Correct.

Jason Witmerother

And they was discussing like, we don't have the, the, the infrastructures in our vehicles except for a bolt in a, in a thing. And we have elderly people and etcetera, and no cage and, and all these elements that could eliminate the use of shackling. And so our concern is the de facto is to shackle when we transport, no matter what the cause, which is why you heard it from youth who were going for medical and being shackled as if they was dangerous, with no cost and individual risk assessment, could eliminate that. Also, by putting in what we said, the concern was, well, we can't get to a judge, we can't get to this. It might be in the middle of the night. Well, it should still not be de facto, but a person could decide in that moment, like, for instance, the youth tries to run. At the moment, they don't have to say, well, see, this law made me have to call somebody instead of dealing with the situation. Sure. So I guess my question is, are you operating from the from the is the information that your opinion is based on, based on the fact that you believe juveniles are de facto being shackled all of the time when transported? Or yes. I will say yes. Okay. I guess I could go look that up, but that's, that's also all the, all the input we've been getting. And what I've been looking at is they're consistently being shackled upon transportation. And is the input that you've been getting. Essentially, the hearing that we had on LB 996, I was there. I mean, I remember the hearing in the juveniles that came in, or is there something else that you're basing that opinion on? Well, one of the things is, so the two former ones that I gave was in the court, which we know they don't always shackled when they're in the courtroom because they do the process. And then in comparison to the juvenile room confinement. So that's something different. But the similar structure that we think should be looked at. And then the third form that I gave you is the, the one that one second is the juvenile detention center, where they have it exempt, that the exemption is all transportation is shackling for and it's for detention centers. And so everybody else follows suits that I've seen from our input. So yes. And I can go look that up. But if we put consistent standards, we can stop the process of people just falling into line with this is just best practice in how do you control kids? You shackle them. Okay, so if I were to tell you that in conversations in preparation for today's hearing, I spoke with someone from dhhs and their.

Jason Witmerother

The information I was provided, which I have not also verified, is that the initial transport from court to a, you know, custodial setting for juveniles is shackled. And then after that, it's on a case by case basis. That would be news to, you. Know, I read their testimony. They they said yes, initially, they shackle everybody because they don't have an assessment. And we disagree with that because that's a presumption that every child is is dangerous. And then they're, they're subject to shackling, which is dramatic. So just about every child, if not everyone. And so that's something that should be addressed because that's the de facto factor. Okay. That's the part where it's. Just you're lumping the initial transport from court to the facility in with every transport that may happen thereafter. So my recollection of her testimony was that the initial court to the to whatever placement they're moving to is shackled. And we can agree or disagree on whether shackles should be used on that. But I'm now focusing on transportation from the facility to, in your example, the dentist's office, which I believe you probably recall, the individual who testified about their experience. Yes, at the dentist. And if my understanding is correct, that hhs position is that's a case by case basis on that particular form of transport, whether or not that youth has to be shackled, that they look at certain factors. Actually, yes, I do, I do I do believe I read that however I get through saying I'm lumping it in, but that's the concern is also lumped into being shackled is them kids being, being shackled and, and transported before they're assessed. And you don't have to do a full assessment if it's intermediate things, somebody can determine right then and there, unless they're well, actually, unless there's an immediate concern, they can contact whoever, their supervisor, whoever's approved to do this assessment and come up with genuine conditions of whether why is this shackling needed? Is the kid a potential threat immediately? Is the is the child trying to run off? Has somebody said this or are we just concerned because this kid is in trouble and now this is what we do, as we shall call them, just in case? Well, I mean, as you acknowledged in your own testimony, there's there's a portion of this that comes back to the safety of the juvenile being transported. Right. And so that has to also play into it. Even if, you know, juvenile a has no run history, there's a suicidality factor that also has to come into play. That's a safety issue, right? You would agree. We wouldn't just impose a traumatic thing onto them because there may be a safety issue. We need to figure out if there's a safety issue or we're already doing something that adds to that safety issue, which is shackling. Okay.

Jason Witmerother

So my question is there's factors in addition to just being a flight risk or having a made a bad choice. Yeah. Are you saying like the potential of harm to themselves or others is already reflecting and not just the partsch? I think that's enough. My question is if I, if I can. Yes, I testified to that. I part of that would be, yes, substantial risk of flight. That's shown potential of not just a potential, but we see that there might be a risk to their self or others in that moment or something to prove that could be in that moment. That is. I didn't say that wasn't one of the conditions. What I'm saying is if we just ease so the kids in trouble, we're just wrapping this up into we need the risk are all there, but we we want to see the risk. And we want to see documentation of why. Why. This is because with documentation, a person will be more conscious about what they're doing and then the length of time. Because again, shackling regardless is going to cause trauma. But it's different if some kids are getting shackled for 20 minutes and we're ignoring the kid that's getting shackled for six hours to drive across the state, which I've personally been part of. And they didn't shackle me. And I was all the, the, the threats and the person talked to me because as a human being, you can get through kids, even if you're not going to change your whole life in a moment and you can go from one area to another just talking and listening to them. De escalation is a real thing. It's it's really disappointing to some of us that we move into a thing where the, what we're doing to the kids is secondary to full grown adults constantly saying, oh, I'm scared of this and I'm scared of that. Well, why are you in this practice? That's, that's my concern. And I've worked in a hospital diversion house. So I'm not speaking from somebody who was not constantly subjected to people going through mental health crisis and who were full grown adults. And so that that's, that's part of the, you know, that's part additionally, beyond aclu and the civil rights and civil liberties and the protect youth in traumatic events, but we constantly seem like we're just falling into this area of, we need these tools because of the potential of what this individual, in this case, children may or may not do. However, if we're documenting, they're going to show what they, we, we, we see that kids saying he's going to hurt himself. And if we put him in the back of the vehicle, we're afraid of what will happen. And we did our due diligence and then we made that decision. And then maybe we had a conversation.

Jason Witmerother

And that's the reassessment is as we was going upon a conversation and part of dealing with this youth, we decided at this time, we have a good rapport. We're going to take off the shackles, we're going to have a communication about that, and we're going to proceed on. In your mind, is this a decision that's made on a court level, or is this a decision that's made on a provider level? I think an appropriate places in the courtroom should be the court level. If you can contact somebody. But otherwise, like supervisors, your your leadership level, or if it has to be because there are some there are circumstances where it might have to be that the person that's currently available. And then, as I said in the thing, immediate situations does not detract from a person using discretion in that moment. You know, like I can't take an, I can't take 20 minutes to try to get ahold of somebody because something is happening now. The kid is, you know. Actively. Actively making a threat, running off. Yes, etc. Any questions? Senator hallstrom? Mr. Whitmer, just I've looked at the states that have passed legislation, and it seems to me at first blush that probably the vast majority of states do have restrictions on the ability to shackle in courtroom proceedings, and that you have to have, as Nebraska law does, a a court hearing and a finding by the judge before they'll be shackled. And it seems like there's plenty of justifiable reasons that have led states to come to that conclusion. Psychological issues. You're in public, you're seen in shackles, the presumption of innocence, things of that nature, the ability to take notes, to communicate with your counsel and so forth. What's the is there a gap? And particularly what I'm interested in is the psychological impact. I can see when you're shackled in public, you know, you feel disgraced, whatever. When you're being transported in a in a private vehicle. If there have been any studies or data that show that there's a gap in the psychological impact of juveniles and the difference between being publicly displayed in shackles and versus being transported privately in a in an automobile. Well, what so I'm going to relate this. So when you put a juvenile in solitary confinement in any sort of confinement, room confinement, isolation, there's a ton of. And this is this is separate from a public shaming. There's a ton of research that shows the psychological harm and etc. That is being done to that child that we often miss because we're thinking, oh, it's just I'm putting them in a room and this is the same thing. Do you equate solitary confinement to. I clay isolation. Transported in a automobile with other individuals? Yeah, I would say that, yeah. I'm I'm in a vehicle with an officer or a transporter. I'm shackled in there.

Carrie Rumbaughother

There is a person there that hopefully they talk to me like a human being. But I know one thing I'm already being, I'm already treated like I'm not one because I'm instantly I'm. As soon as I get in there, there's no grace for me. There's no saving. So I'm just. That's why people end up down the same road is they're still treated like, this is the road you're on. This is who we treat you as. It would be helpful. It would be helpful. From my review, I think california was the only state that at first glance that I saw that had a reference outside of the courtroom proceeding for transportation. And I think the sheriff or the corrections officer could make a finding in the sheriff or the corrections officer could make a finding in advance as to whether or not shackling should be imposed. If you've got any information regarding what other states are doing in the transportation mode, that would be helpful to me at least. Okay, yes, I could put that, but I will say that I did. Somebody spoke to me and I believe they have some information on other states. So if that comes, I will still visit with you to see if you want something from me. And I know you have went to another state, I believe. Did you not say, well, it's not a question for you? Sorry, but. It's a discussion. Yeah. Okay. Totally different than a hearing. And I have looked at several of those. So but I'd rather come with clear information because I'm a person that needs information in front of me and not the memory box. I'd appreciate that. Or I start ranting. But again, thank you for the questions. And, and we do this because we are the best practices are for the person that's being subject to safety and security and all that can come right along with that and still respect that. And that's why we always push on these elements. So. Great seeing no other questions. Thank you for being here. Thank you. Next testifier I have listed is carrie rumbaugh. Good afternoon and welcome to. All right. Good afternoon, chair and members of the judiciary Committee. And thank you to Senator rountree for the invitation to the administrative office for testimony today. My name is carrie rumbaugh, karirumbaugh. I'm employed by the Nebraska supreme court's administrative office of the courts and probation as the deputy administrator overseeing juvenile probation services division. I am here before you today to provide testimony regarding legislative resolution 403, the administrative office of the courts and probation is dedicated to our work with youth and families in the juvenile justice system. Our focus is providing supervision and skill building, which allows youth to remain in their communities and build rehabilitative skills which allow for successful release from probation, ultimately impacting recidivism.

Carrie Rumbaughother

This work is essential as juvenile probation is targeted to work with high risk youth. Data from the second quarter of 2026 indicate that 77% of youth placed on probation were at very high, high or moderate risk of recidivism. Therefore, as community safety is a core priority of juvenile probation, there are times when youth are transported securely. Secure transport includes a youth being handcuffed or shackled. Over the past fiscal year, 6351 transports occurred for youth on probation and 226 were secure. Transports, 3.56%. Currently, midwest special services inc. Is the sole provider that probation utilizes for secure transport. A number of other providers are utilized for non-secure transportation. Secure transportation is used for youth in the juvenile justice system at various system points. The first point is juvenile intake, which occurs when law enforcement takes a youth into custody and requests a probation officer assess the youth for placement at detention. The probation officer uses a detention risk assessment instrument to determine if detention is necessary, and per state statute, the probation officer is to authorize detention for youth if they are a community safety risk. There is a record of failure to appear for court or for the protection of the juvenile due to a record of fleeing law enforcement, absconding placements or home committing violent felonies, multiple property crimes, or threatening to harm others. Law enforcement is to comply with the decision of the probation officer if youth are authorized to be detained, law enforcement would follow their own internal policies regarding restraints for youth. The second system point is court ordered detention. If this occurs, secure transportation is arranged by probation due to a judicial determination of community safety, and youth are shackled during the transportation. There are incidents where a court determines non-secure transportation can be utilized or changes or ordered to the restriction due to special circumstances. Therefore, it is essential that judicial discretion continues to be available for these specific reasons. Third, a probation officer has the authority under Nebraska revised statute 43286.01, section four, to take a juvenile into temporary custody without a warrant. If the juvenile would attempt to leave the jurisdiction or will place lives or property at damage, the probation officer may call upon law enforcement officers for assistance, including transportation. Finally, when a youth has committed to the department of health and human services office of juvenile services for placement at the youth rehabilitation and treatment centers, state statute requires og to provide transportation for detention to the rtc facility, and therefore og s internal policies would apply regarding restraints. Would you like me to stop? No. Carry on. Overall, when a youth is placed in a secure facility such as detention in the wire, there are standards that these facilities must comply with. Detention centers in Nebraska must comply with the juvenile jail standards created by the Nebraska crime commission.

Carrie Rumbaughother

The current Nebraska jail standards have not been updated or amended since august 8th of 1993. Secure facilities may transfer to youth outside of their facilities for emergency medical reasons. These facilities have internal policies regarding use of restraints and shackles during these emergency transports. In closing, the administrative office of the courts and probation takes shackling youth in the justice system very seriously and supports ensuring that secure transportation in the use of shackles is targeted for incidents when community safety is at significant risk. While studying this issue, it is important to note that if every decision to shackle requires a court order, this could have a significant impact on court docket, including all parties involved in the case. Thank you, Senator roundtree, for setting this essential topic as unnecessary utilization of shackling can result in significant impact to youth who are being transported. Thank you for your time and I'm happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Senator mckinney. Thank you. August 8th, 1993 is the day my sister was born. Oh. Yeah. No, she's younger than me. I guess my question I got I have two one. You think so? It's been what, 33 years essentially since the changes have happened. Do you think it's fair to maybe look at the jail standards and see what in that time period it's good and bad and what can we adjust? I would say yes to that. I think they do need to. Be updated and look at, you know, current research, state research, as well as national research in regards to jail standards. Okay. And I was wondering, because I'm looking at the standards and I think this is point seven use of restraints. And it talks about the need for reports. Anytime a youth is restrained, where can we find those reports? Are those unavailable for like a Senator just to kind of see what the reports are saying. So I don't work for the crime commission, so I'm not sure of where those reports are. So that that wouldn't be something I'd have access to in probation. Okay. Thank you. Any other. Senator rountree, do you have questions? I do, but I was also okay. All right. Carrie, thanks for being here. And for, you know, your explanation here. If I'm looking at page one, the bottom part of that second paragraph, it appears as though your from a probation standpoint, transports that are secure are very low, less than 5% correct. Were you here for the hearing that Senator rountree had on LB 996? I was not. Okay. We did hear from a number of individuals, and admittedly, they may not have been probation. This number surprises me, and I would assume a lot of my colleagues who are up here only because we heard from so many youth who described instances where they had been transported and were transported securely.

This page shows part of the transcript. The full transcript is available on request.

Source: Judiciary Committee - Room 1525 · September 21, 2026 · Gavelin.ai