Skip to main content
Committee HearingSenate

Senate Law and Public Safety — October 15, 2026

October 15, 2026 · 18,434 words · 34 speakers · 196 segments

Senator Henrylegislator

Here.

Ms. Hollandwitness

Senator McKnight. SENATOR McKNIGHT: Here.

Ms. Hollandwitness

And, Senator Greenstein.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Here.

Ms. Hollandwitness

You have a quorum.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. We are going to get to our bills very shortly. But, what we are going to do is just start the longer hearing -- the one about isolated confinement. I have an opening statement, but I think I’ll wait until after this person testifies-- OK, we’re going to start today with James Ford, President of the New Jersey FOP. And, then, if we can, we’ll get back to the voting on the two bills. But, we’re going to do it because Mr. Ford has to leave for another meeting. Thank you.

Jamesfordwitness

Good morning. Thank you very much. I appreciate the opportunity to speak this morning. Thank you for including us in the conversation. I did email to Tom ahead of time our position on the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act. We do not oppose the act in totality; we just have some amendments, some changes that we would like to see done to it. So, I’ll speak to those now.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

And, by the way, before you do, I was just going to say this is good because, although the bill exists at the moment, the purpose of this hearing is to hear suggested amendments. So--

Mr. Fordwitness

Sure--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

--definitely go with that.

Mr. Fordwitness

Yes, sure. So, we have three bullet points. The letter I submitted goes into great detail, and I won’t take too much of your time this morning with the detail. The full letter-- Like I said, that is -- was sent in for the record. My name is Jim Ford; I am President of the New Jersey State Fraternal Order of Police. Thank you. The-- Number 1, the proposed modification of out-of-cell requirements regarding this act. The NJ FOP respectfully recommends amending the applicable out-of-cell scheduling requirements to establish a minimum of one hour per day for five days per week, in changing what is currently two hours for seven days a week. Under our proposal, the scheduled out-of-cell opportunities would continue to accommodate essential activities, including exercise; opportunity to go to the library; access legal materials; all those type of things. It would still afford for that. It would also afford for additional considerations should the administration of the facility deem it was warranted or necessary. We encourage the Legislature to establish the framework that recognizes differences between punitive disciplinary detention, administrative separation, and protective custody -- those are three different things, and we encourage the Legislature to establish a framework that recognizes those differences; that establishes the safeguards necessary for not only the inmates, but for the officers themselves. And, any of those modifications should be done in conjunction with evaluating the constitutional standards of medical mental health requirements and other protections governing the conditions of the confinement. That’s point Number 1. Point Number 2: Restoration of maximum disciplinary detention sanctions. We recommend restoring the maximum permissible disciplinary detention sanction to 30-60 days for a single violation, and 60 days for multiple violations. These proposed periods wouldn’t represent maximum allowable sanctions; rather, mandatory or automatic penalties associated with the confinement. Those charged with disciplinary violations are afforded established hearing procedures already, opportunities to present their cases to administrative appeal rights, and pursuant to applicable regulations and institutional policies. So, like I said, it just affords a little bit more flexibility to the institution. We submit that the disciplinary framework must protect the rights of the incarcerated individuals while also recognizing the rights of correctional employees to work in an environment where serious violence and repeated misconduct are addressed effectively. My colleague behind me is going to provide information on some of the numbers of the increases in assaults on correctional officers, and that is one of our underlying concerns. The NJ FOP also requests a careful legislative review of the restrictions governing disciplinary isolation for individuals classified with designated vulnerable populations. We are asking for -- point Number 3 -- to reconsider restrictions involving vulnerable populations. We understand that there are enhanced protections for individuals that are affected by age, medical condition, mental health status, or personal circumstances -- that they may place them at increased risk of harm in restrictive housing. Nevertheless, we believe that the framework warrants examination to determine whether it provides correctional administrators with sufficient flexibility to address serious acts of violence committed by individuals with those classifications. And, so, a balanced statutory approach would protect vulnerable incarcerated individuals while also protecting the correctional staff. So, in conclusion, we believe that protecting the rights and dignity of incarcerated individuals and protecting the safety of correctional officers are not competing objectives. Both are essential responsibilities of a fair, effective, and professionally managed correctional system. Our members are not asking the Legislature to ban correctional reform; we’re asking for reforms that recognize the realities of their profession; provide appropriate operational flexibility; and preserve the ability to respond effectively to serious threats and violent misconduct. We respectfully request that the State -- the Senate Law and Public Safety Committee -- consider these proposed amendments and engage with the NJ FOP in developing amendments to the legislation that balance humane correctional practices with the fundamental obligation to maintain safe and secure institutions. Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. Did you want to testify?

Unidentified Speaker

No.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK. Thank you very much.

Mr. Fordwitness

Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Any questions? (no response) I don’t have any yet, so we’re the only two in here, so.

Mr. Fordwitness

(laughter) Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you very much. Good luck on your meeting.

Mr. Fordwitness

Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK, we’re going to go back to the bills.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

We are going to start the larger hearing about isolated confinement. And, we have a couple of panels. So, panel 1 is Ronald Pierce, Deputy Ombudsperson, New Jersey Office of Correction Ombudsperson. Oh yes, you know what-- Have a seat, but I am going to make my statement here. Just-- It’s very brief. Good morning, Committee members. I am here today to help us open a critical discussion on the implementation of the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, and -- it’s sticking together -- and my newly introduced legislative draft, S4595. Many times, we would do this type of a hearing first, then develop the legislation, but it can be done either way. So, we do have that as a starting place, and then any amendments, changes, whatever we decide to do we can do to that draft. When we passed the historic ICRA baseline legislation back in 2019, our collective goal was clear. Regarding-- It seems to be out of order. They gave it to me out of order. I had it-- The pages are out of order.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

The pages are out of order, I think. Just give me a moment, please. OK, so, we were talking about, back in 2019, our collective goal was clear: To establish humane statutory boundaries on solitary confinement and protect vulnerable populations from prolonged isolation. However, we must confront a stark reality regarding how this law is operating on the ground. Frontline correctional officers represented by PBA Local 105 are facing new issues with assaults. Documented assaults on guards doubled from 200 in 2021, to 424 in 2022, with a high concentration of hazardous splashing incidents. That is when the inmate throws bodily fluids on the officer. This escalation has left over 10% of our active correction members on extended medical leave. At the same time, formal reports from the Office of the Corrections Ombudsperson, and civil rights groups like the ACLU New Jersey, indicate that the New Jersey Department of Corrections is failing to consistently grant inmates their mandated four hours of daily out- of-cell time, frequently operating alternative restrictive housing units, which is really solitary confinement by another name. It seems that the current implementation framework may not be serving both our frontline staff and the individuals in State custody. My ultimate goal for this hearing is to engage constructively with all stakeholders from law enforcement -- labor leaders to civil rights advocates -- to determine exactly how we can refine the current framework. We must find a balanced path forward that strictly mandates compliance and tracking; protects human dignity; and ensures that the people keeping our facilities secure can return home safely to their families. I also want to add that, within the last couple of years, we did one bill that specifically dealt with the idea of the inmates splashing the guards, and it was-- It increased sentences. I was a sponsor of the bill, but I had some concerns about whether it would do the job. But, from what I understand, it is definitely not hurting and it’s actually helping -- a little. It’s not doing the complete job, but it is helping. So, that bill was finally signed into law. What we’re trying to do here is to figure out what methods might be out there -- creative methods -- to try to deal with this. Just as an example, I heard-- I’ve heard that they have improved splash guards on the cells. So, if they try to splash an officer, it’s harder to do it. Food entry areas have been changed. We were able to get money in the budget to allow the prisons to make some of these -- what I consider creative changes. And, maybe there are lots of different ways to accomplish what we’re trying to accomplish. So, we’ll definitely look at all of that and listen to all of you and go from there. OK, thank you. And, so, we have our first person, Ronald Pierce, from the Ombudsman’s Office. And, you can begin.

Ronaldpiercewitness

Good morning, and thank you--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

And, identify yourself for the record.

Mr. Piercewitness

Good morning; my name is Ronald Pierce. I am the Deputy Ombudsman for the Correctional Ombudsman’s Office. I am an independent, neutral oversight body of the New Jersey Department of Corrections. First, my-- The Ombudsman, Terry Schuster, would like to extend his apologies for not being able to attend. He got married this past weekend, and is on his honeymoon. But, he did leave me a couple of sentences he wanted me to instill. First, he says that there is not enough well-vetted independent findings for law -- for law to consider potentially changing the landmark piece of legislation. With the cooperation of DOC, our office would be able to provide much more objective data next year that will assist lawmakers as they grapple with this important topic. It looks like the number of staff assaults has come down notably this year, with no changes in the law. And, so, part of that has to do with some of the things that have been changed by the DOC, which have been working. For instance, there have been a lot of K2 going into the facilities through paper by mail. And, so, the DOC was able to find the funding, and adjust the way that people receive mail. Now, it goes to an independent vendor who copies it and sends it in, so the K2 is not getting in as much. And, we believe that K2 -- and other drugs of that nature -- create assaultive behavior patterns. Another thing is -- and, you just took some of the words out of my mouth -- were the splash guards. They are very important, and they were a major contributor to assaults on the officers. And, nobody should be assaulted; nobody should be -- have bodily fluids thrown on them. And, we honestly are glad that the DOC and the Legislature found money to start providing these splash guards. They can help, the way things are done, and so they’re-- And, there are a number of other things that the DOC have implemented that are starting to show results. But, without giving them time, then we’re actually trying to throw the baby out with the bathwater. So, we want to monitor and-- We want to monitor the practices that have been implemented, such as the splash guards, the K2. And, there was one other topic I wanted to make sure I brought up. Oh, and the mail. So, we would like to be able to work with the DOC. Part of what happened-- Our reports-- We had the report of all the data that, for the 2023-2024, in order to look at the rise in violence. But, the DOC, when we asked for the 2025 data for the disciplinary process, we were told that their data is not reliable, so there was no real need for them to provide it. And, so, whatever data they’re using to give us their reasons for saying that it’s unnecessary, we would like to work with them and get some data so we can work with them. It is our mandate to work with the Department of Corrections to provide the Legislature and the Governor vetted, neutral oversight, and to give -- monitor and participate in legislative policy developments affecting the correctional facilities. This is part of our mandate in law -- that’s our statute that provides us. So, we want time in order to look better at this topic. And, as you say, this here is to discuss changes. There are some things in this bill-- And, since we’re not on the bill, I wasn’t going to discuss them, but if you would like me to then I can.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

I would like you to.

Mr. Piercewitness

OK, some-- Wow, that’s really tiny. Can I have my colleague, Luis Torres, come up? I think he has better eyesight than me.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Sure; yes. Join the club. (laughter)

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Would you like to borrow this?

Mr. Piercewitness

So, there are several areas that are of concern or questionable to us that we would like further discussion on. And, you know- - So, go ahead tell them who you are.

Luisa. Torres - Rodriguezwitness

Good morning. My name is Luis Angel Torres-Rodriguez, and I am the Administrative Analyst at the Office of the Corrections Ombudsperson. One of the first comments is, “Excluding anyone in a cell- -”

Mr. Piercewitness

Read this--

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

Read this one?

Mr. Piercewitness

Read that, so they know what you’re talking about.

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

OK, so this is on Page 2, Section 33: “Isolated confinement means confinement of an inmate in a correctional facility, pursuant to disciplinary, administrative--

Mr. Piercewitness

No, just the red highlights--

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

--protective, investigative, medical, and other classifications in a cell. Or, similarly, confined holding or living space alone or with other inmates. Excluding anyone in a cell with a cellmate from a-- From the definition, it’s contrary to the research showing being one, another person can be as bad or worse when other stimulants or human contact is limited.”

Mr. Piercewitness

Yes, that part talks to about changing isolated confinement and -- the definition of isolated confinement to solitary confinement where solitary means only one person. And, the issue with that is almost all of our isolated confinement -- all of our RHUs, they’re not-- The DOC does not consider that isolated confinement. But, all of those are usually doubled up. So, they’re-- Isolated confinement is just as dangerous, if not more, when there’s two or more people in a housing space for extended periods of time. Next.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. Is that--

Mr. Piercewitness

No, there’s, there’s--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

More?

Mr. Piercewitness

--about six of them. Maybe five?

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

There’s five.

Mr. Piercewitness

Five or six.

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

The history of a psychiatric hospitalization, and the question is, why? Based on medical examination or mental health evaluations conducted by medical staff, or judicial determination. Is there training in these fields to determine sexual preferences? Where is this Judicial determination made, and what is the criteria?

Mr. Piercewitness

Again, that is concerning the changes made from somebody identifying as gay, lesbian, or LB -- LGBTQ and other vulnerable populations, trying to make it where there has to be some kind of medical or judicial testimony that says that this person is LGBTQ or this person is another member of a vulnerable population. We think, first of all, that becomes cumbersome for the courts and everything else, but it’s also an issue of, how do you determine that? Rather than somebody’s own sexual preference or own issues with how they see themselves. And, so, that’s a concern we have we would like to discuss further down the road.

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

On Page 3, Line 40: “As evidence based by recent threats or conduct. Are these observations; changes; guilty findings; definitions of recent; in this context? What about repeated assaults on other IPs?

Mr. Piercewitness

Excuse me. This here goes to the part of the legislation that talks about repeated offenders being able to be housed in isolated confinement for longer periods of time. And, it goes to the heart of how do you determine that? Is it guilty findings? Is it the legislative finding? Is it the Judicial Branch? Who determines what these findings are? And, how-- And, for what length of time? If somebody committed, say, a splashing in 1990, and then in 2026, right, he pushed past a guard -- which would be an assault, no doubt about it; it would be an assault -- for whatever reason, he pushed past a guard. Those two would make it multiple offenses, but very different offenses, and at very elongated periods of time. So, that would have to be a lot more clearer so we can understand.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Can I ask you--

Mr. Piercewitness

Sure-- SENATOR GREENSTEIN --this is all comments on the bill itself?

Mr. Piercewitness

On the bill itself.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

About how much more of that -- about how much more of that do you have?

Mr. Piercewitness

I don’t know that there’s more--

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

Just one more.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Just one more? Because I-- And, can you also send over the comments on the bill to us--

Mr. Piercewitness

Most certainly--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

--so as we’re looking at the bill--

Mr. Piercewitness

I will send it; I will send it--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

--we would have those.

Mr. Pierecewitness

--through the Chair to everyone.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Yes, thank you.

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

This is on Page 3, Line 43. “Was previously, on two or more prior occasions, classified as being under closed custody status, or placed in isolated confinement. In any time period in the last year, this is too broad.”

Mr. Piercewitness

Again, I think I jumped the gun and answered that or talked about that one before, on the last topic. (laughter) But, we also would like data that shows how many of these assaults have went to the prosecutor, because we do have that law now. But, how many have the prosecutors taken up so far?

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Possibly -- Possibly--

Mr. Piercewitness

The data-- The data would help us to better understand, and help the Legislature in their -- not only in their findings, but the way they would draft this bill -- or amend this bill, because it is drafted.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

We may get some testimony on this statistic.

Mr. Piercewitness

OK.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Is there anything else? You basically have finished--

Mr. Piercewitness

I’m able to answer any questions if people have any.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Well, do you have any questions? (no response) Any questions? (no response) I don’t either, at this point. Thank you very much; really appreciate it.

Mr. Torres-rodriguezwitness

Thank you, Senator, for having us.

Mr. Piercewitness

Thanks.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thanks for your testimony. OK, panel two is William Sullivan, President, PBA Local 105; and Jason Cook, Vice President of PBA Local 105. Morning.

Williamsullivanwitness

Good morning.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

How are you?

Mr. Sullivanwitness

Good morning. My name is William Sullivan; I am President of PBA Local 105. I represent approximately 4,500 correctional police and parole officers. Chairwoman, members of the Committee, thank you for this opportunity on the discussion on this bill. I spent more than two decades working inside New Jersey correctional facilities, and I want to provide some history and perspective on the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act. This legislation dates back many years, including efforts led by Senator Ray Lesniak. Governor Christie vetoed an earlier version in 2016. And, the legislation was ultimately signed into law by Governor Murphy in 2019. I testified against the legislation early on, because I feared it would lead to increased assaults on our officers. I also worked with Senator Declan O’Scanlon to address the concerns through legislation intended to protect employees who were assaulted. Unfortunately, those protections have not worked, and we have had -- as we had hoped. I want to acknowledge that ICRA has done some good. It has helped expand mental health services, programming, and protections for inmates who genuinely need them. We had individuals spending years in restrictive housing, whose mental health was deteriorating. Those issues needed to be addressed, and they have. But, after more than 20 years in corrections, I can tell you the inmate population and behaviors have changed. We need to adapt our laws to today’s correctional environment. Before ICRA, we experienced assaults, but nowhere near the frequency we have today -- especially bodily fluid assaults. Previously, inmates who feared for their safety because of gambling debts, drug debts, or threats could seek protective custody. While protective custody remains legally available, the restrictions on housing options have created operational challenges. We now encounter inmates who deliberately assault officers because they believe doing so will get them removed from general population. Think about that -- an inmate afraid of another inmate assaults a correctional officer to escape the situation. And, the consequences extend far beyond-- When a serious assault occurs, the facility has -- and the affected units need to be secured; you have to lock down the whole area, all the units, when you’re dealing with that specific situation. That means inmates who are following the rules lose access to programs, recreation, education, and rehabilitation. A small population of repetitively violent inmates disrupting the rehabilitation of the overwhelming majority who are doing the right thing. These individuals are trying to serve their sentences, complete programs, and prepare to return to society. They should not continually suffer because the lack of tools to manage those who repeatedly choose violence. S4595 gives us a better way to address the problem. We need to separate repetitive violent inmates when necessary, and provide appropriate treatment, establish meaningful consequences, and allow them a way to earn their way back into general population through positive behavior. We must remember that prison is the final level to custody for individual sentence and incarceration. When someone continues to assault officers, the other inmates -- we cannot send them somewhere else. We have a responsibility to maintain order, protect everyone inside those walls. The original intentions of ICRA were good; we’re not asking to undo those protections. We’re asking to correct the unintended consequences. These amendments can help deter staff assaults; preserve mental health resources; and protect the rehabilitation opportunities of inmates who are trying to improve themselves. After more than two decades in this profession, I believe we can protect vulnerable inmates while holding repetitive violent individuals accountable. We do not need to choose between rehabilitation and security -- we need both. With that, I can either answer questions or let my colleague testify.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you; thank you very much. Any questions? (no response) I don’t have any at this time. But, thank you for the testimony. And, gentlemen-- Go ahead.

Jasoncookwitness

Chair and members of the Committee, good morning. My name is Jason Cook, and I am a Correctional Police Officer with the New Jersey Department of Corrections, assigned to New Jersey State Prison in Trenton. I am also a longtime union rep, and was recently elected to serve as Vice President of New Jersey PBA Local 105, representing the men and women who work every day inside New Jersey’s correctional facilities. Before joining the Department of Corrections, I proudly served our country for five years in the United States Marine Corps, including service in Operation Iraqi Freedom. After completing my military service, I continued my career in public service, and joined the NJ DOC in January of 2012. I have spent years working inside New Jersey State Prison -- one of the most challenging correctional environments in this state. I know what violence inside looks like. I have personally been assaulted, and, as a union rep, I responded to and assisted hundreds of correctional officers who have been assaulted. My recent election as a Vice President of Local 105 has given me an even greater responsibility to speak for those officers. But, today, I am not here simply as a union officer. I am here as someone who has lived this. I want you to understand something that the stats cannot fully describe. I want you to understand what it actually feels like to be one of those statistics. I had an inmate throw bodily fluids on me. Think about what that means for a moment. Someone intentionally throws urine, feces, spit, blood, or another bodily substance onto your body and uniform. Your natural reaction is to immediately get it off you; you want to wash yourself; you want to take your contaminated uniform off; you want to get into clean clothes. But, you’re a correctional police officer; you cannot simply walk away. You still have a unit to secure; you still have inmates to supervise; you still have responsibilities to your fellow officers. The incident has to be brought under control before you can take care of yourself. You eventually -- when the situation is secure -- you can clean yourself and change into a clean uniform. And, then comes the part that people outside these walls rarely understand: You go back to work. Sometimes you go back to that same unit that same day. If not, you may be back there the next day. And the inmate who just assaulted you is still there. You walk onto that unit, and that inmate -- or other inmates around him -- may kick the cell door, laugh at you, mock you over what just happened. They know what they did; you know what they did; your coworkers know what they did; and, too often, it feels like nothing meaningful happens. When an inmate is classified as part of a vulnerable population under the current ICRA framework, the options available to manage that inmate can be severely limited. That is demoralizing. I served five years with the United States Marines; I served our country in a combat zone. I then chose another career in public service protecting people of New Jersey inside a State prison. Yet, there are days when correctional officers can have bodily fluids thrown on them, clean themselves up, change their uniform, and then be expected to stand in front of the same person who assaulted them as that inmate laughs about it. And, then, we come back tomorrow and do it again -- day after day, shift after shift. That is what correctional police officers do. But, accepting the dangers inherent in this profession does not mean we should accept a system that allows repetitive violence without meaningful consequences. That is why I support Senate Bill 4595. This legislation recognizes something correctional officers have been saying for years -- there’s a difference between an inmate who genuinely needs protection because of serious mental health or other vulnerabilities, and an inmate who repeatedly engages in violent behavior and presents a continuing danger to officers and other inmates. S4595 creates a category for repetitively violent inmates -- it requires evidence of a substantial risk of serious harm based upon recent threats or conduct; requires that less restrictive intervention be insufficient; and requires a history of prior closed custody classification or isolated confinement placements. That is not indiscriminate punishment -- that is recognizing repetitive dangerous behavior. The legislation also specifically recognizes the risk of serious harm to a correctional police officer or other employees when determining whether restrictive placement is necessary. For the people who actually work inside these prisons, the language matters. We need consequences that inmates understand. We need a system where an inmate knows that repeatedly assaulting an officer will affect where and under what conditions that inmate is housed. We need a system where positive behavior provides a path back. If your behavior demonstrates that you cannot safely remain in the general population, you should be separated from that population, and your behavior should determine when you are ready to earn your way back. That is accountability. It also restores something that has been disappearing from our profession -- dignity. No officer should have to accept being covered in another person’s bodily fluids as simply another day at work. No officer should have to stand there the following day while the person who assaulted him kicks the door, laughs, because he believes there will be no meaningful consequence. No officer should begin a shift wondering whether today’s assault will be the one that sends him to the hospital or ends his career. And, yet, despite all of this, we keep showing up; we put the uniform back on; we walk through the gates; we take our posts. We protect our fellow officers; the civilian employees working inside these facilities; and, yes, we protect the incarcerated population as well. We do our jobs. We are simply asking the State of New Jersey to give us the tools necessary to do those jobs safely. Forty-five ninety-five does not eliminate protections for vulnerable inmates. The legislation continues to require medical and mental health oversight; provides inmates opportunities to contest confinement; requires periodic review; guarantees access to necessities and medical care; and requires facilities to provide appropriate opportunities for recreation, education, treatment, and social interaction. What these amendments do is recognize that these protections cannot become a shield for repetitive violence. Mental illness deserves treatment; vulnerable inmates deserve protection. But, a correctional police officer also deserves protection. And, someone who repeatedly chooses to assault officers should not be able to manipulate a law intended to protect genuine, vulnerable people in order to avoid meaningful consequences for violent behavior. These amendments can help restore accountability. They can help create a deterrent; they can help restore dignity to the men and women who work inside our prisons; and, ultimately, they can help ICRA better serve the people it was originally intended to protect. I have served my country; I have served the State of New Jersey for more than 14 years. I have been assaulted, and I have stood beside hundreds of fellow officers after they were assaulted, as well. And, now, as Vice President of PBA Local 105, I have been entrusted by my fellow officers with the responsibility of carrying their voices beyond the prison walls. So, today, I am asking you to hear those voices. Listen to the men and women who actually work behind those walls. Please give us the tools to protect ourselves; protect one another; protect the inmates in our custody; and maintain safe and orderly correctional facilities. Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you both very much. I actually just wanted to ask a couple of things. First of all, thank you for helping to develop this legislation. I think it’s extremely important that we do what we can to make changes so that officers are not assaulted. How do you feel this bill will go beyond that one that we did a year or two ago, that had to do with the splashing and increasing sentences for people who did it? Do you feel this will compliment it? Do you think it goes way beyond it? What are your thoughts on it?

Mr. Sullivanwitness

Thank you for that question. So, my thoughts on that process are, like you said, we’re talking about 10% of our inmate population -- it’s around 400 inmates in our restrictive housing units. These are the ones who just can’t get -- get in sync with what the general population does. So, the amendments to this legislation will help us deal better with the individuals who are repetitively assaulting us, so that the general population -- the other 11,500 inmates in our custody -- can continue to do the right things to continue to improve. And, this helps us address the 10% that constantly create the shutdowns; the lockdowns; the violent assaults. So, we just feel that these minor adjustments are just going to help to assist to curb some of that behavior and deter that behavior.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK. I know earlier -- I believe the earlier speaker, the Ombudsman’s office talked about statistics. Do you know some of the statistics? I know you do, some of the statistics on this--

Mr. Sullivanwitness

I might have-- So, I have gotten some official statistics, but I have collected statistics over the years. So, my math might not be the most accurate, but it’s pretty spot on. So, don’t hold me to the exact number. But, for instance, pre-ICRA, we had 416 staff assaults in 2018. Up to 2025, we have 1,204. So, we’ve had a 700% increase in staff assaults -- mainly bodily fluid assaults -- since the enactment of ICRA. I will attribute the years of COVID -- 2020, ’21, ’22 -- those numbers didn’t spike as fast, I’m assuming because of the way the prisons were operating. But, the hard data you really want to look at is from ’23 to ’25. I know the testimony earlier said that we need more time to collect data; we have seven years of data, and we need to adjust these things so that we can swing the pendulum back the other way to help with the assaults.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Do you have any other -- what I would call creative ideas, like splash guards, and whatever? Any other things that you think would reduce these assaults?

Mr. Sullivanwitness

There’s always different things. And, I thank you guys for the legislative process; there’s approximately $1.5 million spent on what are called “security food ports.” What these are is, there’s a sliding door behind a glass that lifts up. You put the food tray or items in the tray, you shut it, you move the sliding door, and that prevents splashing. But, what happened then was they figured out the cracks in the doors, underneath the doors, and other areas to splash you. So, the Department has limited some of the items they’re allowed to have in those areas, but they’ve also began the process of spending money to outfit all the cracks of the doors and everything with metal or other brush-like material. It’s always you fix something and then it’s adapted to, and people figure out how to get around it. So, we do thank you for the money for the security food ports. We have seen a 90% reduction -- not 90% like 700, 90% of that -- 90%, so around 650%. Like I said, my math’s not the best, but we have seen a reduction since the food ports have been installed. The other things they talked about, the mail scanning and all that stuff, is working pretty good. Like I said, everything we need to do costs a lot of money. If you asked me the solution to fix some of these problems, I’d say you’d have to have a couple billion dollars and build a state-of-art correction facility.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

What would that have-- What would a state-of-the-art facility have?

Mr. Sullivanwitness

So, newer correctional facilities, there’s less hands-on. It’s more of an officer working a control booth; opening and closing doors. So, there’s no one-on-one interaction. You’ve got to realize most of our facilities, New Jersey State Prison was built in the early -- I believe some of you did tour that facility -- Rahway in east Jersey, 1896. And, our newest prison was built in 1995. So, you would imagine that when you’re walking up and down the tiers of these facilities, you have a key and you’ve got to open every single door. So, you’re interacting with every single person. Sometimes that agitates people, and they get angry and do things. So, a newer state-of-the- art facility would be less hands on, and less opportunities to be assaulted. But, like I said, that is a very pricey item. So, we have to keep chipping away with these smaller things. And, I do appreciate you guys always coming through to help us fund those items.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Let me ask you, do you feel that the prisons are doing enough with mental health treatment for these people? Because, I’m sure a lot of the people who are splashing probably are-- Well, they’re either very angry or mentally ill.

Mr. Sullivanwitness

So, part of the bill, we did ask to add the -- I believe it’s the LPN title -- to help give more resources, because we don’t have enough clinicians available to help those people. So, we did add some stuff to help with the mental health when we drafted this bill. But, you have to realize-- I’ll put it this way: There’s some people who are acting vulnerable, or acting out, taking up resources, because they’re kind of playing a game, if I’m going to put it in a more -- so we can-- I’m just looking for the word. So, there’s people who are acting out and not actually needing the resources, and they’re taking resources away from the people that actually need it. So, like I said, some of the things in this legislation will help curb some of the people who are, in layman’s terms, faking it or using it to manipulate to get out of different areas, or be put in different areas, of the institution.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. Do you have any questions? Comments? Anyone? (no response) Thank you very--

Mr. Sullivanwitness

Thank you very much; I appreciate it.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you very much; thank you. The next panel is Reverend J. Amos, I think, Caley, New Jersey Prison Watch; Antonne Henshaw, New Jersey Prison Watch; and Brittany Bowers, New Jersey Prison Watch. And, if you could come up and then share a microphone, or whatever. As many of you as could fit up there. That would be good. Thank you.

Reverendj. Amoscaleywitness

So, first of all, thank you--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you--

Reverend Caleywitness

--Madam Chair, and to the members of this Committee. This is a matter of great urgency, and we really appreciate your interest.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Oh, yes, folks, when you speak could you start with your name, and the--

Reverend Caleywitness

Yes; I’m sorry--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

--name of the group. Thank you.

Reverend Caleywitness

My name is Reverend J. Amos Caley, a pastor at the Reform Church of Highland Park, and an organizer with New Jersey Prison Justice Watch. We have worked really closely with the many sponsors of the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, and we began with Senator Lesniak in 2015 -- all the way up until its passage seven years ago. In the years since, we have been really carefully monitoring the continued use of isolation through direct correspondence and connection to loved ones of incarcerated people. Additionally, in my role as one of the appointed members of the Advisory Board to the Corrections Ombudsperson, I have paid close attention to the facility inspections and special reports coming from that office. All of the evidence points in one direction -- all of the evidence points in one direction: The Isolated Confinement Restriction Act has yet to be fully implemented in both the letter and the spirit of the law. There are understandable reasons for this. The DOC was charged with promulgating regulations for implementing ICRA during the first year of the pandemic, which hit our state prisons -- here, I’ll point to that in a second -- which hit our state prisons harder than any other correctional system in the country. Moreover, Commissioner Koons has spoken at length about the structural and staffing changes that make the housing requirements of ICRA difficult to consistently satisfy. But, third -- and, this is very important -- there is an interpretive dilemma at play, where isolated confinement is defined by the Department differently than what the statute mandates. Isolation is intended to be defined by the conditions of confinement anywhere, over time, rather than a housing classification, as the Department currently considers it. So, these are understandable reasons, but they are not meant to be excuses. This is not a “gotcha” moment; it really is a call to creativity and collaboration. And, this call is an urgent one. We know that S4595 is a bill that’s been introduced, and it seeks to loosen the restrictions of the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, and allow more people to be isolated for longer durations of time. And, this would be a huge step backwards. Not because-- Not just because ICRA has not been fully implemented, but because the law was designed to make prisons safer. Assaults on staff are on the rise, but they are happening in units and wings where isolated confinement is already being practiced. I want to point -- this represents the closed custody units. This is where staff assaults are taking place; they are primary on closed custody units. So, the idea that isolation is a solution for assaults is erroneous. The data corroborates what psychologists, criminal justice researchers, and the United Nations have already documented: Treating people inhumanely contributes to violent and aggressive behavior. So, the answer is not to isolate more; the answer is -- the answer to institutional safety is to create alternatives to isolation. What you just heard is absolutely true from the PBA Local. It is absolutely true that when people assault other people, they do need to be removed and given special treatment. And, what that does not mean is throwing them into isolation for longer periods of time. It means mental health resources, and it means restorative justice interventions between staff and residents; the expansion of clinical services. These actually-- These implementations, these interventions, have been tried in other states and in our own in small ways. I have introduced into the written testimony a report that we developed that chronicles the problems with treating violent behavior with further isolation and further punishment. And, within this report, there are case studies of other states that have been successful in implementing violence intervention, harm reduction, mental health supporting strategies that have led to reductions in other states by up to 74% in violent activity. So, just, in conclusion, officer safety and humane treatment are not competing priorities. They are mutually reinforcing responsibilities. If we want safer prisons, we need to make the prisons more functional, not increase the practices that further erode that safety -- which isolation is documented to do. I am happy to answer any questions.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Is anyone else speaking?

Reverend Caleywitness

Yes, sorry. We can do questions after--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Why don’t we have all of you speak, and then we’ll do the questions.

Reverend Caleywitness

Sure.

Brittany Bowerswitness

My name is Brittany Bowers. I am currently a learning disabilities teacher consultant at Pemberton Township High School. I have over a decade of experience in education, including work in Trenton and Newark, with an emphasis on trauma-informed practices. I am also a former employee of the New Jersey Department of Corrections.

Unidentified Speaker

We got you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

You’re doing great.

Unidentified Speaker

We’re here.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

You really are.

Ms. Bowerswitness

This is opening kind of a wound from the past, so.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

That’s OK; take your time.

Ms. Bowerswitness

From February 2021 through November 2021, I worked for the New Jersey Department of Corrections, within the Office of Educational Services. Alongside a school psychologist, I was hired to implement trauma-informed practices within the learning center. Our primary objectives were to support institutional safety; increase educational engagement; and promote rehabilitation through individualized behavioral support. As we identified areas for growth, we noted that approximately 40% of our adult student population was housed in the Restricted Housing Unit -- also known as RHU. While educational services remained available to these individuals, our goal was to increase their participation in the learning center. As such, recognizing a need for additional behavioral support, we expanded our trauma-informed interventions to help those individuals -- help these individuals develop the self-regulation skills necessary for successful reintegration into the general population, as well as society as a whole. I personally facilitated individual interventions, as did the school psychologist through separate sessions. Our approach emphasized accountability through reflection rather than punishment alone. Following behavioral incidents, we conducted structured debriefings to guide the individuals to identify triggers, reflect on their reactions, and develop safer alternatives. Regular check-ins reinforced emotional regulation, problem solving, and goal-setting skills. These sessions also provided opportunities to assess mental health concerns and practice strategies for managing future conflicts. Educational staff received additional trauma-informed professional development through Rutgers University. Our interventions were grounded in the understanding that repeated exposure to trauma can heighten an individual’s stress response, interfering with thoughtful decision-making. By helping individuals recognize these responses, we sought to strengthen self-regulation and encourage more constructive behavioral choices. The outcomes we observed were encouraging. Overall, approximately 17 adult students were housed in RHU at the beginning of work in April of 2021. Between April and June 2021, nine individuals housed in RHU successfully re-integrated into the general population following approximately 65 to 90 days of positive behavior. By August, the number of adult students had decreased to five total. Most importantly, along individuals participating in our educational services, we observed no incidents of splashing or physical violence against correctional officers, educational staff, or peers during this participation. While these observations do not establish causation, they demonstrate the potential value of consistent trauma-informed interventions within correctional settings. As the Legislature considers revisions to the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, I hope the Department will revisit strategies that integrate behavioral accountability, rehabilitation, and institutional safety. My experience demonstrated that these objectives need not be mutually exclusive. Thank you for your time and consideration. I welcome any questions from the Committee.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. Is anybody else-- Are you going to testify? Why don’t you go ahead. Thank you.

Antonnehenshawwitness

Antonne Henshaw. Thank you for this opportunity to share. I am a young person who served a 30-year-to-life sentence here in the State of New Jersey. I was in the Department of Corrections from a very early age, and my first time ever being in solitary confinement was torture. I had no prior criminal record, and I went through what I went through. Anybody being assaulted is absolutely wrong. I have never assaulted an officer; I’ve never splashed an officer. And, in my job in the facility, I often had to defend other peers who have done this. It’s (indiscernible), it’s absolutely terrible. But, what I began to learn was to try to understand what the behavior was trying to accomplish. And, that is missing. Come home, 2018. I meet Mr. -- Reverend Amos Caley, and I begin to talk about being in isolated confinement on and off over my 30-year sentence. But, no disciplinary infraction. How can one be in isolated confinement without violating a rule? So, the way isolated confinement and how it was packaged earlier is very, very self-serving. What they didn’t say was, “What about the people that they’re putting in these places under investigative detention?” And, then they cite extenuating circumstances to keep you there longer. My longest stint was 18 months with no charge. I had four disciplinary infractions over a 30-year period that didn’t result in any isolated confinement sanctions. What also wasn’t mentioned was, they have management control units for people that they can’t control in general population settings, or RHUs. They didn’t share that. It’s in Trenton State Prison -- still there. Where they control exactly the things that they talked about on a continuous basis. They also have what they call “chronic violator status,” in the New Jersey administrative code. But, what they don’t say -- and, even my colleagues here -- they don’t talk about the public health threat that this torture creates. And, I’m going to share with you guys my scar tissue that hasn’t gone away. And, I’ve been home eight years, and I still struggle with this. What happens is, your humanity gets stripped away from you. You start losing sense of who you are, and do you have value as a form of punishment. We do not have to degrade in order to punish. We don’t have to dehumanize in order to punish. But, yet, we do. I now pay taxes to support that. I am now a constituent with the right to vote to support that. But, what nobody says was, “How are you going to come home and survive that?” I never knew what happened to me until I came home and saw that isolated confinement cell, and I broke down. I’m on Princeton University’s campus, and I cried. And, Amos and the rest of them were trying to console me, and I never knew what I survived until I saw it, because I was in it. And, Amos couldn’t help me, because he didn’t understand what my body was responding to. We bring this home with us. And, this not only makes the officers unsafe, it makes the community unsafe. Isolated confinement, as currently running in New Jersey’s Department of Corrections, is one of the biggest public health threats to people being released. And, me knowing that something was off and something -- I couldn’t figure it out on my own -- I sought treatment. And, one of my diagnoses was survivor’s guilt. I felt guilty for surviving something that was meant to kill me. My family couldn’t understand it; my children couldn’t understand it. People in my community were like, “Why doesn’t he talk?” “Why does he do this and that?” “Why does he just walk around like that?” These are the ills that isolation produce, that we have to consider if we’re going to do anything about increasing the time of the torture again. We have to own all the consequences that come with it. And, I’m here as a servant to be able to help; to be able to share. I’m not saying that they should not be held accountable -- that is not what I’m saying. I am not saying what the DOC said was wrong; I am not saying that. What I’m saying is, all sides need to be at this table to be able to understand how to remedy this. I now work in Pennsylvania -- I can go in any Pennsylvania institution to help their population. But, I’m banned from coming in the very system that bore this pain and this scar tissue. Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. Very moving testimony. I just want to ask the three of you, do you have any-- If one of the goals of this bill is to reduce the assaults on the officers -- the splashing; other things -- do you have any creative ways to do that? Or, what are some of your thoughts on how to do that?

Reverend Caleywitness

Well, so, we do not oppose all of the efforts that this bill -- that this bill is trying to do. We oppose any strategy to curbing officer assaults with further disciplinary sanctions. We do believe that people need mental health services; we believe that the letter of the law needs to be investigated and implemented. I do believe that the first testimony from the FOP suggested that an investigation be held in, really, investigating how long people are actually being held in these cells at any given time, to-- The Office of the Corrections Ombudsperson has consistently -- and, I’ve seen inside of these prisons as well -- the lack of creative use of space. In Bayside Prison, which is one of the more state-of-the-art prisons, it has a huge cafeteria, a mess hall, that’s filled with file folding boxes -- just filled, every square inch. And, everybody has to eat their meals in their cells. So, you cannot tell me that the efforts are fully exhausted to try to reduce the amount of time that people are in their cells. There is so much more that can be done to actually implement the law, and only then will we know, has the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act yielded the results that we want? So far, it has not, but that is not because it’s been implemented; it’s because it has not been implemented.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Got it.

Mr. Henshawwitness

I train credible messengers here in the State of New Jersey, up and down the state. We also train certified peer specialists. That needs to be adopted from the Pennsylvania system that they have. They also have certified peer recovery specialists among the populations, and training them to do these things. There needs to be credible messengers inside the institutions that are trained by formerly incarcerated people, and Department of Corrections, and professional staff, to develop these things to be able to remediate this collectively, from all sides. I don’t know what it’s like to be a correction officer, but I’ve trained correction officers in the state of Pennsylvania; what it’s like to come home. And, they need to help us understand what it’s like to be a correction officer. And, I think, in that, we can come up with solutions in the certified peer recovery specialists and the certified peer specialists training, and the credible messenging model, to fuse something together to create outcomes that we can measure and we can design -- co-design -- together. REVERAND CALEY: So, specifically to your question, we just think that the bill is not informed, and it’s not -- it will not purport to do what it’s setting out to do. We do believe that efforts do need to be made; we do not want to brush this under the rug. We don’t think that we have it all figured out. But, we welcome the opportunity to sit with you, Chairwoman, in order to think about what could a meaningful piece of legislation that would protect officers and also ensure the institutional safety, and not throw people away for as long as just is deemed to be necessary by one side of the people that we’re trying to protect.

Mr. Henshawwitness

And, I think one key thing that we need to be focused on: We’re only talking about 10%. We’re not talking about the 90%. We only have to focus our efforts on 10% of the population that is causing this harm. And, what is our harm reduction strategy in order to do this? And, I think we can come up with something for 10% of our population.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK--

Ms. Bowerswitness

Just to add, we did have adult students who previously were known to splash officers that we worked with--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Can you speak up?

Ms. Bowerswitness

We did have students, adult students, who previously were known to splash officers, prior to us coming into RHU, especially during COVID time. And, so, we did come in and began talking with them, and saying -- sort of similar to what the previous officer mentioned -- what it would be like if that were to happen to them. Who would want to go home covered in body fluids? That is not an appropriate solution; that is not how you’re going to show maturity and that you’re ready to integrate back into society. And, so, we would have those conversations with the adults that we were speaking to in RHU to help kind of bring that awareness of what you were saying, connecting both sides to kind of this compromise. So, I think it would be really important to have these follow-up conversations with these individuals to kind of reiterate the importance of the behavior.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK, thank you. Any questions? (no response) Any questions? (no response) Thank you very much. We’re actually going to toggle back to the bills. There’s only one more bill, and we’re going to do it now. And, then, we’ll continue with this hearing.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Now, we’ll go back to the hearing. The next group is, I guess, Garden State Equality and other groups. Lauren Albrecht, Senior Director of Advocacy and Organizing, Garden State Equality; and Jim Sullivan, ACLU of New Jersey. Hello; how are you doing?

Laurenalbrechtwitness

Good morning, Senator. SENTOR GREENSTEIN: Morning. Or, afternoon, or night. (laughter)

Jimsullivanwitness

Good morning, Chair Greenstein--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Morning--

Mr. Sullivanwitness

--and members of the Committee. My name is Jim Sullivan; I am the Deputy Policy Director for the American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey. The ACLU of New Jersey worked with a broad coalition of advocates, faith leaders, formerly incarcerated people, families, clinicians, and legislatures to pass the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, and we have monitored its implementation since. Our central message is that ICRA has produced real change -- that the evidence behind it has strengthened since 2019, and that its promise is not yet fully met. For roughly a decade, the ACLU New Jersey worked with a bipartisan mix of legislators and state stakeholders to pass ICRA. Advocates and legislators began pressing for limits on solitary confinement in the early 2010s, as clinical research and national attention converged on the practice. The Legislature passed an isolated confinement bill in 2016 that was later vetoed; however, the effort resumed in the following sessions with revised language, additional language, and direct testimony from people who lived in the isolation, and from clinicians who served them. This was not a hastily passed law. Rather, it reflects years of engagement with legislators of both parties; input from a range of stakeholders; and legislation that was supported by a wide range of advocates and constituents. ICRA, signed by Governor Murphy in 2019, reflects a negotiated balance. The statute preserves the Department’s authority to separate people who pose a serious threat, and it keeps emergency exceptions. It limits duration; bars use on people for whom isolation is most dangerous; and requires transparency. It also rests on a body of research that has grown more consistent since the statute passed, and I would like to summarize some of that right now. First, as it pertains to psychological harm, clinical and survey research has documented harm from prolonged isolation for decades. Dr. Craig Haney’s evaluations of people held in long-term isolation found high rates of anxiety; confused thinking; depression; and hallucinations. Secondly, the research on self-harm, mortality, and life after release is still relevant and even more consistent to this day. A New York City jail study found that people who spent time in solitary confinement were far more likely to harm themselves than others -- even after accounting for other risk factors. Research on people released from prison associates a history of solitary confinement with higher PTSD symptoms, and higher mortality after release -- including from suicide, homicide, and overdose. These findings bear directly on public safety, because nearly everyone held in isolation returns to their community. Lastly, pertaining to the discussion here today, safety inside facilities. The research offers little support for the view that solitary confinement makes facilities safer. The study of supermax prisons found no reduction in the institutional violence attributable to supermax placement, and research on supermax confinement has associated it with worse outcomes after release -- including violence recidivism. States that reduce restrictive housing -- including Colorado, North Dakota, and others -- reported stable or improved safety outcomes, along with reduced use of force and fewer assaults on staff in several jurisdictions. The findings are not uniform across settings, and Department leadership and correction officers are right that violence is a serious problem that policy must address. However, the research supports the claim that long isolation is a poor tool for reducing it. Lastly, I would like to talk about the work that remains. As I said, the ACLU of New Jersey has been working on this bill and monitoring it since it was passed. And, we asked the community to focus its oversight on the following steps. Each is administrable, and none requires re-opening the statute. First, close the definitional gap. Require the Department to support, by unit and by month, every person held in a cell 20 or more hours a day -- whatever the unit’s name -- and to reconcile those numbers with its ICRA census. Second, standardize out-of-cell locks. Require electronic, audible records of out-of-cell time and programming for each person in restrictive housing, available to the Ombudsperson and in aggregate to the public. Next, build alternatives to restrictive housing for non-assaultive violations. Fund graduated sanctions, behavioral health units, and step-down programs of the kind used in other states. And, report their outcomes. Next, extend independent oversight to county jails. Give the Ombudsperson or a comparable body authority to inspect county facilities, and require every county to follow ICRA reports on a common template, with consequences for a failure to file. Also, we need to publish disaggregated data. Report placements and duration by race, age, disability, and gender identity; and report the protected categories in the statute, so the Legislature can verify that those protections hold. Invest in staffing and deescalation. Fund officer recruitment and training, so that out-of-cell time and programming can operate safely. And, track assaults on staff alongside isolation use, so that the effect of each can be seen. Lastly, we recommend that they hold -- we hold regular oversight hearings. An annual review of the quarterly reports with the Department of the Ombudsperson, counties, correctional staff, and people with direct experience to the table will help keep implementation visible. In closing, I want to thank you for inviting the ACLU New Jersey to take part in this discussion. And, as part of that discussion, I am going to follow up with every member of the Committee with the research that I cited here today--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you--

Mr. Sullivanwitness

--in addition to summary -- because I summarized it. And, I would also like to respectfully ask that the proponents of the bill today do the same. It’s-- We want to engage in a discussion-- I find it difficult to engage in discussion when we’re just saying numbers. So, I would just respectfully request that we all can get the full statistics, full data sets, and make sure we’re all operating from the same numbers and the same math and all that type of stuff.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

I would--

Mr. Sullivanwitness

Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

I would like to sit down with you, let’s say, and talk about some of this. So--

Mr. Sullivanwitness

Absolutely; we will absolutely follow up. Like I said, I’ll follow up with all the research and the statistics cited today, and am happy to--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you--

Mr. Sullivanwitness

--meet with any of you further.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you.

Ms. Albrechtwitness

Good morning-- Good afternoon-- Good morning, Chairwoman, and Senate Law Committee. Thanks for having us today. I am Lauren Albrecht, and I serve as Garden State Equality’s Senior Director of Advocacy and Organizing. I am happy to be here today because I love my job, and I love doing this. And, I’m excited to engage in this dialogue with all of us. We represent hundreds of thousands of LGBTQ and allied New Jerseyans -- including, in a very, very small overall percentage, transgender inmates. I am here today to share with you our concerns regarding any rollback of 2019’s Isolated Confinement Restriction Act. In 2019, when Governor Murphy signed this bill, it was hailed as groundbreaking, and a progressive step towards ensuring that people in the care of our prison system -- in the care of our prison system did not leave a facility worse off than when they got there, because that defeats the hope of rehabilitation. We do take very seriously the safety of public servants who voluntarily sign on as correction staff. Anecdotally as well, as a nonprofit organization, we certainly understand funding challenges; staffing shortages; limited resources; complex regulations; and exhausting, tireless work. My testimony here, and our opposition to rolling back ICRA, should not be interpreted in any way as a dismissal or downplaying of the severity and responsibility of the work undertaken by our prison staff, or the conditions in which they are often working. But, it would also be difficult for me to consider the experience of our prison staff in these facilities without taking into consideration the accounts we receive from transgender inmates in New Jersey facilities. This week, I received a report from a recently incarcerated trans woman -- who I will call MB, for the sake of her privacy. MB was incarcerated in Southwood State Prison in Bridgeton from 2023 to 2026 -- so, after the 2019 passage of this law. As a trans woman, MB was incarcerated in this male-only facility, and was also undergoing hormone replacement therapy. Which, anecdotally, as well, is an interesting fact when I think about a quote that I read from the New Jersey Monitor on September 4 in 2026 -- just last month, which is attributed to the Corrections Officer’s Union, which, as supporting evidence to roll back the 2019 law in terms of hours of isolated confinement, says, “All you have to do is say you’re LGBQT and you’re vulnerable. All you have to do is say you have a psych history, and they make you vulnerable. The main thing is changing it so that somebody can’t just self-identify as vulnerable to get out of sanctions for this bad behavior.” I couldn’t agree more, and I have a lot of concerns and questions about what’s being done to help the folks who are self-identifying as mentally ill in this vulnerable place. That begs a larger question about the un-implemented parts of the law requiring mental health exams. So, on its face alone, I would just say that the supposition that there’s some significant population of cisgender men pretending to be transgender women to skirt the rules is flawed at best. In this case, MB was, as I said, undergoing hormone replacement therapy under the care of a doctor. MB also reports, in addition to her solitary confinement, she was often housed with cisgender men who physically and verbally assaulted her. A point I’d also like to raise here on this topic is that, too often, instead of addressing these real dangers at their point of impact, or instances between incarcerated persons and holding the actual perpetrators accountable, facilities respond by isolating the person who is more vulnerable. We also recognize that placing transgender people in solitary confinement -- under the pretext of protecting them or protecting prison staff -- does only serve to deprive them of meaningful human contact; educational opportunities; rehabilitation; recreation; and essential services. Protection for any party should not result in a loss of humanity for anyone in 2026 in the United States. So, I think that what I hoped to hear today is a solid reason why, instead of approaching the incarceration of transgender people -- again, a very, very small group, in a way that both honors the letter and intent of the law and ensures the safety of both inmates and prison staff, the reflexive response would be to roll back the guardrails on the allowable hours a person can spend in solitary confinement. Our prison facilities are entrusted with the care -- entrusted with the care and safety of all residents, at what may arguably be the lowest points in their lives. And, I cannot fathom a single way that anyone has done any favors by rolling back protections that are not yet fully implemented. Two years ago -- because this has been brought up a lot -- the splashing offense law -- two years ago, we also opposed that law. Ourselves and the preeminent voices on HIV science in this state -- Hyacinth and others; national organizations -- we opposed that law on the basis that it was based on outdated science. And, we still oppose a large part of what was codified into law on that. However, now there are splash guards; however, now there is testing; however, there now is enhanced penalties. I would also just like to note here that the CDC maintains that any -- there is negligible or no data support that a chronic transmissible illness has ever been transmitted from a splashing offense. I think that’s really-- Like, we’ve talked about splashing a lot here; data is important; facts are important. I understand that it’s disgusting to be covered in spit. It’s revolting; nobody should ever have to do that. But, when we talk about -- when we talk about the impacts of that and how we mitigate it, it again -- it again should never come at the cost of the humanity of another. I and many of my colleagues who work closely with our transgender populations hesitate to believe that the only way to create more safety for prison staff is this. Rather than a study to revisit any unimplemented portions of the law; rather than more structured out-of-cell time; rather than diversionary mental health environments; rather than more carefully crafted and culturally competent -- culturally competent mental health exams. And, no data suggests -- no data exists to suggest that upping allowable isolation hours creates more safety for prison staff, so then what? We roll back a law not yet fully realized, and then see that this wasn’t the problem or the solution to begin with? Study after study tells us that increased solitary confinement ups the temperature rather than cooling it. We are also asking the State of New Jersey to provide its officers with the tools needed to do their jobs without compromising the dignity, safety, security, or possible potential future rehabilitation of anyone. And, as echoed by our colleagues at New Jersey Prison Watch, we also commit ourselves to 100% of our resources to helping bring meaningful change to this discussion. This is, again, not a gotcha; like they said. This is not a gotcha; this is teachable; this is adaptable; and this is a place that we see the ability from New Jersey to continue leading this discussion. So, for these reasons, I urge our Legislature to continue hearing the concerns of all impacted stakeholders, and exhaust every other reasonable solution besides more solitary confinement hours on vulnerable populations. On the bill itself -- which I do have points for, but I didn’t bring today, because the bill is not on the agenda -- I am happy to share them in an email to the Committee. I am happy to have a meeting at any time. And, thank you; thanks for your time.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you, both. Any questions or comments? (no response) Thank you both very much; appreciate it. OK, now we’re going to hear from some academics. Dr. Matthew Sheridan, Program of Criminal Justice for Rutgers University, and Michael Isaacson, Direction of Communications, Justice 4 Demi. OK, thank you very much. One of you can begin. M A T T H E W J. S H E R I D A N, Ed.D.: Good morning-- Or, good afternoon, I suppose, by now. Sorry, I am-- I will apologize -- start with an apology. I have just returned from several weeks out of state--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Can you identify yourself?

Dr. Sheridanwitness

I am terribly sorry. I am Matthew J. Sheridan, and I have an unusual history; so, let’s start there.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK.

Dr. Sheridanwitness

I have spent 11 years in the New Jersey Department of Corrections serving a life sentence. I-- I’m exhausted; forgive me. After that, I served for 33 years with the Departments of Corrections, Human Services, and Law and Public Safety, where I retired from. I have spent over 35 years working with universities -- and, especially Rutgers -- in the State of New Jersey, where I currently still teach. So, I have a little bit of experience with this. And, as I said, I’m apologizing to you because I’m not as prepared as I would like to have been. I had a death in my family, so I’ve been dealing with that--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Sorry--

Dr. Sheridanwitness

--for the last three weeks. However, much of what I wanted to say to you about the harm to people caused by solitary confinement has already been addressed by others. So, I would like to skip past that, if I may. Let’s approach this from a municipal worker perspective. The history of corrections in this country -- and in New Jersey, since the Trenton State Prison is the oldest operating prison in the country at this time -- has 225 years of failed reform movements. Solitary confinement has 225 years also of that, of experience with it as a failure. We know what it does. New York actually did something really interesting -- it was an unethical experiment, but they did nevertheless do affirm what happened in Pennsylvania. But, we maintained solitary confinement -- not for redemption as it was originally intended, but as simply a control mechanism causing extraordinary harm. Harm to individuals who are in solitary; harm to those when they come out; staff; guards; other prisoners; and, when they come home, there’s, as one person so eloquently said, to our population out here. We are at threat with all of this. So, excuse me for a moment (indiscernible) glasses on, and seeing where we go next. In addition, we also changed solitary confinement over the years. We went from simply solitary confinement to introducing such really unique little things like the hole, and sensory deprivation. And, we know what that does. Alright, so, why should we even bother with this? We’re not going to get rid of solitary confinement anytime soon. It’s just impossible. There’s going to be a need for it until we institute something else that’s much more comprehensive. I would like to suggest, as one person mentioned earlier -- and, I think it was only one mention of it -- that we must start to use evidence-based practices. Evidence-based practices are always about 75 years old, but the significance of them is that there is research behind them to tell us that they work. A hundred percent? No, but better than anything else that we’ve ever used. Some specifically -- some of those would include therapeutic diversion units; staff deescalation; cognitive behavioral rehabilitative programming; and policy limits and independent review, such as we get from the Ombudsman’s Office. So, I will leave my notes with you as well, because my notes at the bottom include the fact sheets. But, you’ve already heard some of this already. I mean, my feeling is-- I mean, if I were-- I don’t support the bill as it is, unless we were to abolish solitary confinement. Which we cannot do, unless we put other things in place, such as the evidence-based practices. And, until we do that, we continue to place everyone -- everyone, without exception -- at risk. That means somebody comes home, places me at risk, my family at risk, you at risk. So, solitary confinement is wasteful and ineffective. If it worked-- How does it contribute to recidivism? I mean, we know that people fail afterwards. We should remember who our population is. Seventy percent of our prisoner population is functionally illiterate. Try serving in New Jersey in that state. Majority of our people suffer from multiple learning disabilities. The majority suffer from mental illness. No doubt that our recidivism rates -- I mean, I hate that word, quite frankly, because it doesn’t describe everyone -- but people cannot survive. Ladies and gentleman, I will offer myself in any way I can in the future to help. I have no problem making myself available. I’m not a young man anymore, but that means I have more time. So, thank you--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you--

Dr. Sheridanwitness

--so much for today--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you.

Dr. Sheridanwitness

I hope that you will seriously take this topic under consideration and understand the threat to everyone. Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. Sir.

Michaelisaacsonwitness

Thank you, Madam Chair and senators, for allowing me to speak today. My name is Michael Isaacson; I am the Director of Communications at Justice 4 Demi, an LGBTQ prison justice organization. In my work, I maintain contact with over a dozen members of the LGBT community incarcerated by the New Jersey Department of Corrections. Through their letters, phone calls, and electronic messages, as we witness the persistent use of isolated confinement by the Department of Corrections, it is used for punishing conduct violations; for retaliating against grievance filings; for preventing means of self-harm; for abrogating the responsibility to keep people safe in general population; and for accommodating staffing shortages. Within the Department of Corrections, isolated confinement goes by many names, including restorative housing unit; pre- hearing disciplinary housing; protective custody; constant watch; and others. Vulnerable populations, as defined by the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, including people who are LGBTQ, disabled, or elderly continue to be held in isolated confinement despite the law explicitly prohibiting it. The law defines isolated confinement as being kept alone in a cell for upwards of 20 consecutive hours, but, in my experience, this can extend to days, weeks, even months without any out-of-cell time. Isolated confinement is dehumanizing and dangerous, and recognized by the United Nations as a form of torture. The conditions in the units for isolated confinement are atrocious. People are held without access to clean water; without properly functioning heating or air conditioning; without access to showers or hygiene products; with broken toilets leaking sewage; and with roaches and other vermin scurrying about the floor. Due to the relative lack of supervision, I have known at least two women who were left passed out on the floor in a state of diabetic ketoacidosis for hours without receiving medical attention while being held in isolated confinement. All of this occurs in violation of existing law, and particularly the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, which the proposed legislation being discussed today seeks to revise. As it currently stands, the law provides no penalty for violating the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, nor means of enforcing it. The Office of the Corrections Ombudsperson, the agency tasked with overseeing the Department of Corrections, currently possesses no means of bringing the Department in line with the law beyond chastising its leadership and writing reports, which are ignored. The present proposed legislation, in many ways, represents a state backwards, easing restriction on isolated confinement on the pretext of its statistics being blamed in a law that has never been followed throughout its existence. If we are to revise the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, it should be in the form of providing penalties for the Department of Corrections, its leadership, and its staff for violating it. It should be in the form of easily giving the Office of the Corrections Ombudsperson the power to litigate, or to recommend litigation to the Office of the Attorney General. Thank you again for allowing me to testify today. I hope all stakeholders can come together to pass legislation that protects the safety and well-being of incarcerated people and corrections staff alike. Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you. Any questions? (no response) Thank you very much.

Dr. Sheridanwitness

Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

I believe our last-- I believe our last group is Michelle Callari, NJOPD -- I’m not sure what it stands for - - opposed. Donna (sic) Stackhouse, New Jersey Institute for Social Justice -- I don’t see if you’re for it or against it on there. Sean Washington -- opposed. And-- Can you read that name? MR. LITTLE (Majority Aide): I think it’s LaShawn

Senator Greensteinlegislator

LaShawn (indiscernible) -- really?

Mr. Littlewitness

Or just say Jersey -- Justice for Jersey.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

I can’t read the name, but it says Justice for Jersey. L a S H A W N F I T C H: I’m sorry, LaShawn Fitch.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Oh, LaShawn Fitch; OK. And, that person is in favor. Oh, no need to testify, I think.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

I’m sorry, I can’t hear you.

Mr. Fitchwitness

I’m sorry, it’s a testify; I’m testifying--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Oh, you want to testify--

Mr. Fitchwitness

--in support of protecting (indiscernible)

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK, if you can come up, you can wait, and we’ll get you right after, OK. And, we also are asking at this stage if people can just not do a very long speech; just keep it to about three minutes. If you have anything more you want to give us, put it in writing and send it in, OK. And, I believe this is our last group am I -- yes.

Michellecallariwitness

Good afternoon--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

And, identify yourself.

Ms. Collariwitness

My name is Michelle Callari; I am an Assistant Public Defender with the New Jersey Office of the Public Defender.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK.

Ms. Callariwitness

Good afternoon, Madam Chairwoman, and members of the Committee. I oversee our statewide youth defense practice in two trial regions. I know you’ve heard from others today about the well-documented harms of isolated confinement, but I am here to speak specifically about what those harms mean for emerging adults our office represents, and why any changes to the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act must account for their unique developmental needs. The Office of the Public Defender recognizes the importance of maintaining safe environments for individuals in custody, and the staff responsible for their care. But, safety cannot come at the expense of a person’s healthy development or long-term well-being. Expanding the circumstances in which isolated confinement may be used raises serious concerns -- particularly when we consider the developmental vulnerabilities of emerging adults. Turning 18 does not mean a person has reached full developmental maturity. Brain science confirms that the brain continues to develop into the mid 20’s -- particularly in areas responsible for impulse control, emotional regulation, decision-making, and weighing consequences - - underscoring the importance of rehabilitation over punitive approaches during this critical development period. Emerging adults are still developing the skills necessary to regulate emotions, control impulses, assess risk, and make decisions under stress. These are not abstract developmental concepts -- they directly affect how emerging adults respond to conflict, frustration, and the highly stressful environments of incarceration. Many of the emerging adults we represent have also experienced significant trauma, mental health challenges, or developmental disabilities. Those circumstances must be considered when determining how to respond to behavior in a custodial setting. Isolation does not teach emerging adults how to regulate emotions, resolve conflict, take accountability, or respond appropriately to frustration. Instead, it can intensify the very challenges that contribute to behavioral incidences in the first place. Removing an emerging adult from meaningful human interaction risks escalating the stress and dysregulation, rather than addressing the underlying causes of the behavior. We must also recognize that incarceration can be particularly damaging to this population, because it occurs during a critical period when they are still developing the skills, relationships, and sense of identity that will shape the rest of their lives. Incarceration does not simply remove a person from the community. It can interrupt education; derail employment opportunities; sever connections with family and other sources of support; and deprive young people of the everyday experiences through which they learn independence, responsibility, and sound decision-making. At a time when emerging adults are still learning to regulate their emotions, manage conflict, and navigate difficult situations, incarceration can expose them to additional trauma -- intensifying existing mental health challenges and reinforcing feelings of hopelessness and disconnection. These harms are especially concerning because the very skills that emerging adults need to successfully return to their communities are the skills that incarceration can undermine. Isolated confinement compounds these consequences by stripping away human interaction and opportunities to learn from others, leaving emerging adults with fewer tools to manage stress, conflict, and make safer choices. Rather than preparing young people for successful reintegration, these practices risk deepening the challenges that brought them into the justice system and increase the likelihood they will remain entangled in it. Incarceration should serve a clear purpose; maintain safety while providing individuals with structure, support, and services they need. When emerging adults return to the community, we should want that person to be better equipped to manage conflict, regulate emotions, make safe decisions, and contribute positively to the community than when they entered the facility. Isolated confinement moves us further away from that goal. Rather than helping emerging adults develop the skills they need to succeed, it risks deepening trauma, worsening mental health, and reinforcing behaviors that can contribute to involvement in the justice system. We must and can protect the safety of facility staff and other incarcerated individuals without relying on practices that undermine continued development. Emerging adults must be held accountable for their actions, but accountability must be paired with opportunities to learn, grow, and change. A response that intensifies distress without addressing its underlying cause does little to prepare a person for a safer and more successful future. The question before us is not simply how we respond when a person presents a safety concern, it’s whether our response makes the person, the facility, and ultimately, our communities safer in the long run. Thank you for the opportunity to share the perspective of the New Jersey Office of the Public Defender, and the emerging adults we represent.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you; thanks. Who is next?

Dameonm. Stackhousewitness

Good afternoon. My name is Dameon Stackhouse; I am a Justice Fellow with the New Jersey Institute of Social Justice. Good afternoon Chairwoman Greenstein--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Good afternoon--

Mr. Stackhousewitness

--and the Committee. I -- I’m going to make it brief, because I know we don’t have a lot of time. But, I’m a licensed social worker, and I came before you today to speak from my professional lens and my experiences with formerly incarcerated individuals, that is able to speak to the firsthand knowledge of what isolation can do and will do to individuals. And, when you’re in those cells, not able to take a shower; use the phone to let your family members know where you are and what’s going on; to have meaningful rec.; to be able to go to the law library and actually look at what happened that put you in this situation that is still being investigated. Because one hour will not do it. You’re either going to make a choice between whether or not you can take a shower or you’re going to call a family member. So, to look at the amendments that are about to happen, or you’re proposing, we’re looking at time; we’re looking at mental health professionals; and we’re looking at the vulnerable populations precisely. To move from 20 hours to 22 hours is taking away the opportunity for individuals to gain their thoughts, and their ability to communicate with individuals that they love. Regardless of what happened, to take away an opportunity to have a mental health professional come once a day to once a week -- you don’t know what’s going to happen in that one week; it’s someone that is already suffering from a mental health illness and is deteriorating. And, to protect our vulnerable populations, to change it from one year for an individual who is 21 years old-- And, we just heard, the brain is not fully developed for a lot of individuals, especially that have experienced trauma as a child, all of the (indiscernible) and the things that we discuss in our field of study. Adding more social workers to clinical -- I love that part, because you’re adding a pool of mental health professionals that will be able to be in the room. And, to go on the tiers and talk to individuals to find out what’s going on so that they can go back into general population and come back into society whole, and at least understand what they need to do to stay that way. So, I just want to leave you with safety and humane treatment must go together. Solitary confinement can deepen psychological distress, and may push people that are already at risk of psychosis. No one person should be left to detain -- or, in detention to deteriorate without meaningful human contact. Timely clinical care, safeguards, and mental health services. We can address both of these, but we can’t address the behavior if we don’t address the trauma and the disabilities, the undiagnosed illnesses. And, the New Jersey Institute is willing to do -- just like everyone else -- continue to work to figure out how do we make sure that individuals and staff are taken care of. Thank you.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you very much; thank you both. Appreciate it. Is there a Sean Washington here?

Seanwashingtonwitness

Yes, ma’am.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

OK, why don’t you come up, and also LaShawn Fitch, was it? Why don’t you both come up. And, you’re the last two. We can start with Sean.

Mr. Washingtonwitness

Yes, ma’am, thank you. Thank you, distinguished members. Senator Greenstein, I’ve seen your name on a lot of bills while I was incarcerated. Thank you. My name is Sean Washington. I am a 2020 exoneree. I spent 25 years in prison, from 1995 to 2020, for crimes I didn’t commit. The majority of time at Trenton State Prison, New Jersey. I was in -- I was in ASEG one time; I’m going to share a little brief story with y’all. I got-- I came back from ASEG, I was a little upset; a little emotional. There was a commotion. Officers went to quell the emotion -- they put handcuffs on me, and also punched me in the face after they handcuffed me. I did six months in ASEG behind that. My first couple months, I was steaming mad. I was mad at this world. Then, I finally calmed down. I was in ASEG one time in 23 and a half years in prison, because I see that wasn’t the place to be. I went in there for something I didn’t do, but I understand that they need ASEG because you have some people in there who just don’t want to follow the rules. So, I learned to follow the rules; I became a paralegal; I studied; and I got out. And, also, what helped me in prison was the education. When I first got there in 1996, they had a lot of education programs from ’96 to 2000, and then they start chopping them away. I think they opened up South Woods and a lot of the shops, jobs, and stuff, started going down to South Woods. But, isolation is not good for no one. It causes mental illness. And, people need to interact with other people to sustain and maintain their mental stability in prison. So, (indiscernible), isolation, it may be necessary for some people, but it’s not good for everybody. It’s not a one-size-fits-all. And, I would like to note -- suggest, or just to share with y’all; I know you might not be able to do it -- but if you ever can, take a tour of seven wing ASEG inside Trenton State Prison. Go look at them cells.

Mr. Fitchwitness

Go do it.

Mr. Washingtonwitness

That’s not -- that’s not good for human beings. If they had animals in there, PETA would be protesting and filing lawsuits against New Jersey State Prison for the way those cells look. So, I understand people do what they want to do; it’s about law and safety, and people want to keep people safe. But, ASEG is not good for everyone. So, thank you. That’s all I have to say.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Just one question for you. Do you have any ideas what you think could be done to stop people from attacking these officers as they do by spits -- splashing things on them?

Mr. Washingtonwitness

I’m just recently hearing about this splashing thing. It happened a couple times before when I was in there, but they-- When I was there, in 23 and a half years -- it was an isolated incident. And, usually, if you splash someone, they get splashed -- they did something to that man or woman. They’re not going to splash for no reason. When I was in there, this one officer kept harassing me, harassing me, harassing me; I was this close to catching another case. They mess with us in there for no reason because they have that power. But, people need help. They need mental illness. I took a class in there, a psychology class, with a Dr. Jordan, and I started to understand the psychology; I started reading psychology. I understand how the brain works. For one thing I’ve learned, it’s like we have to unlearn everything you was taught as a child. If you were a criminal, you grew up in the criminal element in those rough neighborhoods, those inner cities, you have to learn everything that you once learned and re-educate yourself. So, education is the main thing. Maybe a person needs to sit down for 30 days to calm down, but years? Isolation is a form of psychological damage. When I was in there -- real fast -- there was some men that were in there that did, like, umpteen years at MCU because of their revolutionary behavior, allegedly, and they ended up getting paid a lot of money because they come to find it was unconstitutional. But, people need help; speak to them. But, if they’re throwing stuff on officers, them officers have to be doing something to them -- allegedly, I don’t know. But, it was isolated when I was in there. They harass you. And, also, the prison has so many people in there. So, they need (indiscernible) to lock people up, because everybody can’t fit at population. So, they’re just charging a person with something just to put them in (indiscernible) to get them out of the way. And, that’s less work they have to do when you’re (indiscernible). But, people need mental illness, they need to talk to them to try to calm them down. The class is education -- that’s the biggest thing for me, education. Thank you all very much.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you.

Mr. Fitchwitness

Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. My name is LaShawn Fitch, on behalf of Justice for Jersey, Incorporated. Before I go in-- First of all, to extend anything further with solitary confinement is just -- I’m (indiscernible) put it into words, and let me tell you why -- let me give you context. I’m a recipient of Phil Murphy’s executive clemency. I was just released December 4, 2025. I was one of the best paralegals in the State of New Jersey. I was in Trenton State, New Jersey State Prison. And made legal association. I know Dana DiFilippo well -- we did many stories together. I was one of the watchdogs; that got me sent from Trenton to South Wood on retaliation. But, let me give you context. I’m a paralegal. I go on lockup (indiscernible); RHU; whatever they would like to call it. Because in 2020-- I know y’all wondering what I got here. What I got here is the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act, which was signed by former Governor Murphy in 2019. Let me tell you how it got into New Jersey State Prison. How it got in there -- because major seers, I know you know these names -- Jeffrey Crothers, these brothers who were at the top -- yes, let’s talk about them. So, when we go into RHU, when someone catch an institutional infraction, they must see what’s called “court line.” Court line is what you call a makeshift judge, and they go and they tell you what your sanctions are, and they tell you how much time you’re about to spend in RHU. Now, when they did the RHU -- restorative housing unit -- I told Dana DiFilippo, it was still solitary confinement in spite of the name. So, when we talk about the splashings, and we talk about the bodily fluids, I was there for all of it. Let’s talk about-- Let’s say you caught an infraction, right. Let’s say-- Because it’s prison within a prison, which makes no sense anyway. You catch an infraction, you’re supposed to get proper bedding; you’re supposed to get running water; you’re supposed to get the basic necessities. That is the constitutional, right? If you do not give the person the basic necessities, what is it now? Cruel and unusual punishment -- we do know this; we all know this. So, when you have a mental health prisoner -- because in Trenton, they’re supposed to differentiate; they’re supposed to have the NCU for the guys in here, the mental-- They’re all crammed in. And, they don’t know how to deal with them. And, the only way the officers know how to deal with them is to assault. I can be mental health walking around Trenton -- that’s how nonexistent they are. I walked these units -- 10 units, in seven wing. NCU. These hearings are shams. These officers are coming complaining. Why? Because you left that man a week with no running water. You left that man in there a week with no toothpaste; no bedding. How you think you’re going to act? And, then when they call me, because I had to not only be the paralegal, I had to be the psychologist and the therapist. So, they call me not only when the fire started, but to put the fire out. “Fitch, can you come talk to him? This is Major Craig Sears.” The other major, we don’t want to talk-- He’s gone now. They’ll call us, “Fitch, we need help over here.” Why? “Because this person is not compliant.” Why is he not complaint -- what happened? “Well, I’ve been in lockup for 30 days; I had nothing.” Where is his property? We’ll find his property in another closet down the hall. No wonder why they start. And they’ll start fires. You know why they start fires? Because that’s to get someone’s attention. Because no-- They neglect these units. If you went back on seven wing and seen the infestation, the rats was this big back then. The rats looked like puppies. Roaches; centipedes. When Crothers came, the administrator there, I was there. I was the wing representative; I was the one putting the lawsuits in. I was the one causing all the stir with Dana DiFilippo, telling her everything that was happening inside, because I lived it. No one is going to tell me what I lived. So, of course, everything was about the office. And, then, 2023, they did make revisions to the Isolated Confinement Restriction Act. They started a level system. Let me tell you what the level system did. The level system, it created a conflict because, 1., what the level system said is that the officer tells you when you get on the phone, and when you get to have these privileges. But, when you go see the sanction officer, it’s the sanction officer the one who gives you the sanction to tell you that when your phone privileges are done how long you get to spend in a cell. So, now you have the DHO -- who are the detention hearing officer -- at odds with the officer in the unit. When did this person get to use the phone? And, now, if it’s an officer’s discretion, what if I don’t like it? How do you think you’re going to use that phone? I was there for it; I just left. It was 17 years -- 36 years old, I was 17 years old. Paralegal right now. I’m out here trying to make a change. I know what’s happening -- I walked those rooms; B block. The NCU hammers -- which are a sham. I’ve been there, and I’m here to basically say, on behalf of the impacted, on behalf of those who are still dealing with this, when they started the Isolated Confinement Restrictive Act was a sham from the door. Because all it did was take ASEG and turn it into RHU -- same thing. It’s the same exact thing; nothing changed. Oh, you are in that cell 23 hours, make no mistake about it. When they said the program -- they just take you out to change, put you in a cage from here to here, and say, “Go play cards.” That’s (indiscernible) What is that doing to the brain? What is that doing to the mind? A lot of y’all saying that I was 17 and 36 -- what do you think isolated confinement did to me? I was just one of the strong-minded individuals that rose above it, but that’s not the masses, that is the less than 1%. Same percentage I had of getting that executive clemency. Everybody is not-- I get it. Right now, we are in a shortage of officers. There’s a lot going on with that, too, with the overtime; there’s a lot. So, there’s a lot of crying in DOC right now because they want more money because they’re tired, and they’ve got to spend it -- we get it. But, at the same time, that does not give you the opportunity, the authority, to violate one’s constitutional rights. That is cruel and unusual punishment. Some people may feel that, “Oh, if you did the crime, do the time.” But, if you’re convicted of a crime, you’re not stripped of your constitutional rights; you’re stripped of your freedom. The punishment was my sentence. I shouldn’t go to jail to get further punishment. That’s not how it goes. But, I understand you have rules and regulations that one must follow -- I understand that. But, you have to look at both sides of the coin. When you look Terry Schuster, the Ombudsman, he did his reports. I got them all right here. He went 2023, 2024 -- he did Northern. That was a freezing ice popsicle. What about the brother that lost his life there in Northern, not too long ago? Troy-- Darrel Foye, I know him personally. I had to call his family. Yeah, Big D died.

Mr. Washingtonwitness

Wow.

Mr. Fitchwitness

What happens to his family? Who is going to explain that to his family? You got a bunkie who was mentally ill, went -- I don’t want to use the word psycho -- on him, killed him in his cell. Because that person wasn’t supposed to be in a cell with him. This is happening all the time. I’m going in there to see brothers with mental health; they’re getting jumped on by the COs, because they don’t know how to deal with mental health. On the streets, they don’t know how to deal with the mental health crisis going on, so what do you think is going to happen in the prison? Where is the oversight committee? Because they’ve been vacant for years. So, there’s-- Outside of the Ombudsman, please unstrap the Ombudsman’s Office. They have to wait for SI; the SID is with the DOC. Let’s stop this. SID is a one-sided thing, and they grip the DOC. They are not going to give the Ombudsman’s Office the authority and the power to go in and investigate, because you know why? Their report is going to be redacted by the time you get it.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Mr. Fitch, can I ask you to just wrap it up?

Mr. Fitchwitness

I’m sorry; I’m sorry.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thanks.

Mr. Fitchwitness

I’m sorry.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

I’m glad you were able to get a lot of this out--

Mr. Fitchwitness

Yes--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

--because we’re hearing all different viewpoints, so that’s good.

Mr. Fitchwitness

I just believe that there should be no amendments to the Isolation Confinement Restriction Act, because what it does (indiscernible). There’s no rehabilitation to it, at all, but just take away--

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Do you like the bill that exists now, that was signed in 2019?

Mr. Fitchwitness

I-- If DOC was not circumventing the process, it would have definitely alleviated some things. But, what happened was they- - I think it was (indiscernible) who was acting at the time, that they got this level system, because they kept crying that they were getting splashed, they were getting splashed, they were getting assaulted. And, this is when they came up with the zero tolerance. Remember they came up with the Z, the zero tolerance? But, that also gave them the right to attack as well. Knowing that they’re protected by this. So, I like the bill as it was. I think that legislators, policymakers, need to go inside the prisons and talk to the administrators themselves -- not the underlings; not the majors; not the sergeants that are being told what to say before y’all get there. Because, if you notice, every time they do a tier, what they tell the inmates: “Shut up. Don’t you say nothing.” Why do you think they say that? They don’t want you to know what’s going on. But, now that we out here, that’s going to change.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

Thank you; thank you very much.

Mr. Fitchwitness

All right.

Senator Greensteinlegislator

And, unless we have any questions here, thank you all.

Source: Senate Law and Public Safety — October 15, 2026 · October 15, 2026 · Gavelin.ai